r/Malwarebytes • • Mar 01 '18

How Good Programs Go Bad -- the Fall of Malwarebytes

What does most malware do? It tells you you are in sudden danger when you are not, in order to scare you into buying something.

That by itself doesn't mean a program is malware. It takes more. Like the following:

(1) When you install Malwarebytes Free, it defaults to the 14 day Premium Trial.

(2) When the trial runs out, a warning appears that is intended to scare users into buying the Premium version -- a warning that implies the user is in imminent danger.

(3) If users downgrade to the Free version, the checkbox (to switch back to the Premium Trial and its scareware message) gets re-checked EVERY TIME they do a full upgrade.

(4) Full upgrades seem to be more and more frequent...

Now this last one might be a necessity of battling modern malware. But when you combine all four you get something that looks a lot like a virus. At the very least, it's disappointing.

"HOW CAN FREE STUFF BE DISAPPOINTING?" Because we're spoiled by good free stuff. But MBAM also makes $, yeah? (They must -- I've advised many virus-prone clients to pay for MBAM.)

And it's good to get paid. Especially if you deserve it because you made a light, fast, effective, safe cleaner and made it available for free.

But beware the road that so many have taken. AVG --> Crapware Bloatfest. Avast --> Turdpile Scumbladder. There's more but I'm lazy. Oh yeah -- Norton. Yes I invoke Norton, the Nazis of fake security. Decade after decade, trusting grandpas gently shell out $50-$100 per year for one of the worst AV programs in history, just because, once upon a time, Norton was clever enough to bribe HP and Dell to infect countless generations of PC's with "Free 90 day trials" which expired with, you guessed it, scary warnings. (Another Norton coup: they convinced journalists that Norton is the go-to authority on malware. Interviews with Norton "experts" usually feature some kind of "war room" -- a big darkened high-tech workspace full of busy technicians toiling under giant screens that show the global progression of "the threat". Jesus.)

PS - How long till Adwcleaner starts having nag screens about the pro version?

9 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

5

u/veritablechicken Mar 02 '18

Inb4KasperskyBoughtThisAccount

3

u/Shiznoz222 Mar 02 '18

Lol. Riiight...

7

u/banished98ti Mar 02 '18

Absolutely agreed.

Ive used this product for years and it has gone to utter shit.

I am a paying customer and this thing has become annoying beyond belief. It constantly turns off the real time protection and the massive mem leakage a few weeks ago was the last straw for me.

As soon as these companies start making products for the masses and add superficial GUIs everything goes to shit.

BRING BACK THE OLD MALWAREBYTES.

4

u/SticknMyDicknAChickn Mar 02 '18 edited Mar 02 '18

/u/banished98ti

Malwarebytes 3 is currently running perfectly on millions and millions and millions and millions and millions and millions and millions of computers. The most common issues experienced are not always caused by Malwarebytes but by the other programs people have installed on the computers alongside Malwarebytes. Who knew?

 

Just like anyone else with an issue beyond their comprehension (elitist paying customers such as yourself included), you can get free help. The directions are laid out here and should be simple enough for just about anyone to follow. (Feel free to DM me and I will be happy to assist you.) https://forums.malwarebytes.com/topic/190532-having-problems-using-malwarebytes-please-follow-these-steps/

 

Of course, you are more than welcome to "BRING BACK THE OLD MALWAREBYTES" - You can download v. 2.2.1 (and stick it where it belongs) here - https://downloads.malwarebytes.com/file/mbam_2x

4

u/banished98ti Mar 03 '18

Does the old version contain all the updates I need to safely run it?

4

u/SticknMyDicknAChickn Mar 03 '18 edited Mar 03 '18

You seem to be under the misguided notion that there exists a cybersecurity program that will 100% protect your device while you navigate the internet with reckless abandon much like a modern-day Yukon Cornelius. Wahooo!

 

Your request was "to BRING BACK THE OLD MALWAREBYTES" (aka Malwarebytes Anti-Malware) and I have supplied the link as requested. Version 2.2.1 has reached EoL and is no longer being actively supported but as far as I am aware is still receiving malware definition updates.

 

Your computer cannot actively infect itself with malware. That is entirely dependant upon how you behave online. As has been stated here and elsewhere ad nauseam, you are the first line of defense. If you choose to knowing (or unknowingly) behave in an irresponsible manner, there is no software on the planet that will save you or your device from yourself.

 

Rather than waste your time (and mine) with a senseless rant against Malwarebytes 3, you would be better served by availing yourself of the free assistance to anyone who has an issue with the software. I personally know of countless people who are running version 3 with ZERO problems whatsoever. I provided a link to knowledgeable support staff who are eager to help you. No one wants you to have a poor experience with the new Malwarebytes.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '18

Someone is dense. His question is "Is it as useful as the current version of Malwarebytes"

Your answer in relation to that was "No, malware bytes has never been an end all approach" While true...does not answer his question.

You're the one wasting his time here motherfucker.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/pelosi-isa-dumb-cunt Mar 03 '18

Lol. You've now become the "Shit For Brains" poster child.

 

Your argument is untenable and you are clearly not receptive to any logical form of assistance. Like I suggested above in item #5 (https://www.reddit.com/r/Malwarebytes/comments/817yx2/how_good_programs_go_bad_the_fall_of_malwarebytes/dv1dam3/) you should immediately box your computer up and rush it back to the place you bought it.

 

When the salesperson inquires as to why you are returning your computer please explain that you are TOO STUPID to own such a sophisticated piece of hardware. Ask if they have any used buttplugs you can suck on.

1

u/VanApe May 13 '22

Yeah, wow. You know something's gone to shit when asses like you come out of the woodworks.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/VanApe May 13 '22

Lmfao, that all you got dude? Sure is better than having your head in your ass. How's it smell limpdick?

Keep preaching it! You're tarnishing the credibility here with every comment you make!

1

u/VanApe May 13 '22 edited May 13 '22

Oh wow, this pelosi thing is your alt? I'm guessing you're banned here?

Niiiice. Ban evasion.

Edit: Yep. Same posting style. Same interests. Seems like one of many with how short your comment history is. Don't got much of a life, do ya dude?

2

u/Arizona-Willie Mar 02 '18

It's a virus that turns off real-time protection not the program period shows you got a problem somewhere.

2

u/Atari_7200 Mar 18 '18
  1. Must be new, didn't do that, it was an install question.

  2. Lmao, pretty much every free AV does this. Never mind it's not even a scare popup, it literally tells you the trial expires and you should buy premium if you want it to continue to actively protect your PC

  3. What? Also you can't renew the trial.

  4. What? The last full upgrade was months ago, probably longer. Discounting the one a few days ago obviously.

  5. not really a point you listed, but the implication is that malwarebytes is rogue. It isn't. Not even in the fucking slightest lol. It does what it says it does, and more. Mbam's active components have never been freeware. But their manual scanner has been, and still is.

2

u/TIGERESTEP Apr 17 '18

THANK YOU , I LIKE THE WAY THAT YOU TALK or TYPE lol . YOU seem to be an intelligent person, & im sure we would both agree "THE WORLD SURE COULD USE MORE OF THEM" THANKS for Being you...

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '18

You realize it was for EMPHASIZATION? right?...Right?

1

u/SuspiciousDude13 Aug 20 '22

4 years later. Malwarebytes is a laggy piece of shit that takes half my ram while running in the background. It keeps putting me on free trial and then screaming at me when it's over to upgrade to paid version. Every time I turn it on it begs me for a subcription and asks me for my email (likely to receive spam about upgrading to paid version). It's still slightly less obnoxious than CCleaner, but awful nonetheless. The only thing keeping me from switching over is that most alternatives are even worse. It seems like scummy advertising is the go-to way of designing stuff nowadays.

1

u/billdietrich1 Mar 02 '18

I'm more concerned that Malwarebytes apparently does not report keyloggers. I wonder what else they've chosen not to report. Coinminers ? Also I think they should report all installed remote-access software (such as Teamviewer) as PUPs. Inform the user, and let them decide if it's a problem or was installed deliberately.

3

u/BleedingTeal Mar 02 '18

Yea... Not to be rude but it’s very apparent that you’re not well versed in the topic you’re attempting to venture. What you’re suggesting would be anti trust and would guarantee that Malwarebytes will be sued and they will lose by the publishers of such applications. Just because you don’t want them doesn’t mean that they qualify as PUPs under Malwarebytes terms. To block applications that allow remote access such as TeamViewer would also bring Microsoft into question since they’ve had a native remote access application embedded within Windows for decades. Additionally, just because a given application or application type could open a system to compromise doesn’t mean it should be blocked. Because every application has security weak points, of which an operating system is just a specific type of application. So fundamentally the basis of your entire argument is deeply flawed and will never occur from any security publisher, Malwarebytes or otherwise. I’d advise you to let go of that pipe dream, and if you’re not able to then perhaps it’s best to remove thyself from the internet entirely as your expectations are grossly unrealistic.

1

u/billdietrich1 Mar 02 '18 edited Mar 02 '18

Really ? Reporting (not blocking) something as "potentially unwanted", saying "user should know about this", would be an "anti trust" violation ? I think you're not well versed in the topic you're attempting to venture. Trying looking up the definition of anti-trust, which usually involves market power and unfair competition and potential monopoly.

Nothing wrong with "bringing Microsoft into question". If that MS remote access server is activated, tell the user, maybe they would choose to deactivate it. I would. As with anything reported to user as PUP, user always can say "yeah, I installed that, I know about it, ignore". Or maybe they'll say "wow ! who put that there ? problem !".

2

u/BleedingTeal Mar 02 '18

Yes it would, because Malwarebytes isn't a passive security application. So to do what you're suggesting would require changing the fundamental way the application works which is to be proactive and aggressive against bad agents, such as PUP publishers.

And you are looking at the linguistic definition, not the legal definition which is what I am referring to and is what matters in this case. https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/antitrust-laws

3

u/billdietrich1 Mar 02 '18

Well, I use Malwarebytes only in passive mode, doing a scan every couple of weeks. But in real-time mode, isn't it "proactive and aggressive" against new viruses and such trying to come in ? I don't think what I'm asking for requires any fundamental change at all, to either passive or real-time mode.

I see nothing in the link you gave that would apply to Malwarebytes or prevent it from reporting things as PUPs. Where in the following do you see that it would be wrong to notify the user about a keylogger, for example ?

startquote

The Sherman Act outlaws "every contract, combination, or conspiracy in restraint of trade," and any "monopolization, attempted monopolization, or conspiracy or combination to monopolize." Long ago, the Supreme Court decided that the Sherman Act does not prohibit every restraint of trade, only those that are unreasonable. For instance, in some sense, an agreement between two individuals to form a partnership restrains trade, but may not do so unreasonably, and thus may be lawful under the antitrust laws. On the other hand, certain acts are considered so harmful to competition that they are almost always illegal. These include plain arrangements among competing individuals or businesses to fix prices, divide markets, or rig bids. These acts are "per se" violations of the Sherman Act; in other words, no defense or justification is allowed.

endquote

There's no conspiracy between competitors or fixing of prices or rigging of bids. It's not illegal to say "hey, look at this thing on your computer, are you sure it should be there ?"

1

u/SticknMyDicknAChickn Mar 04 '18

The Sherman Anti-Trust Act? Really? Dude. Lol. Don't get too close to the edge, you'll fall off.

3

u/billdietrich1 Mar 04 '18

Dude, Lol, I'm the guy saying Anti-Trust doesn't apply. Talk to /u/BleedingTeal

1

u/kodenkan Apr 15 '18

Bill, actually Teal is correct. One of the reasons Microsoft paid such high antitrust fines years ago was because of their economic favoritism: they would allow only select companies (their partners) to be integrated into the O/S. Remember Netscape, early Google apps, et al? It's because Microsoft controlled the portal (Windows) that reached these other programs. Shutting off access (warning someone) had too much sway over the vendor's survival. Microsoft and other companies would squeeze companies until they broke and then buy them pennies on the dollar.

As to the PUP, he's right there, too. Every O/S installs Msoft Remote Access but disables it. So if the software did what you suggest, it would flag everyone's Microsoft O/S as a PUP when in fact it needs to be invoked manually. Same with TeamViewer.

Hope that clears things up. BTW I hate the nag screens too. I understand the companies need to survive, but ads are so prevalent now they're jading people and becoming less effective at drawing attention. Just like banner ads, then interstitial, now dialog boxes. We're all becoming expert at avoiding annoying marketing-speak on the page.

Luck!

3

u/billdietrich1 Apr 15 '18

Sorry, that didn't clear up anything IMO.

  • Malwarebytes reporting something to the user is not some kind of anti-trust violation, because Malwarebytes Corp is independent (not part of a trust) and not promoting it's own competing product and arguably doesn't have immense market power (it's just one of N malware scanners).

  • Malwarebytes reporting something to the user is not the same as Malwarebytes disabling something. I don't advocate MWB disabling keyloggers automatically or quarantining them automatically.

  • If MS Remote Access is installed but disabled, I don't know if MWB should flag it as PUP, that's a judgement call. But certainly reporting it as PUP would not be same as "flagging Microsoft's OS as a PUP". It would be flagging a specific service or app.

  • I have heard nothing from you or him that supports "to do what you're suggesting would require changing the fundamental way the application works".

2

u/kodenkan Apr 15 '18

Well, I tried. Sorry it wasn't clear. I've been sr mgt in tech firms most of my former career, and what you're asking for is impractical. It's obvious Teal has been in the tech game a long time, too.

Anyway, good luck to you.

3

u/billdietrich1 Apr 15 '18 edited Apr 15 '18

Yeah, you've failed at communicating. Please tell me why a Malwarebytes scan of files on disk can't detect and report a keylogger file. Why doing so would require some complete redesign of the MWB app.

[PS: appeal to authority ("I've been sr mgt in tech firms most of my former career ... It's obvious Teal has been in the tech game a long time, too.") is not a good form of conversation. I could mention that I was a computer programmer for 20+ years, have BS and MS in Computer Science. But all of that is irrelevant.]

1

u/BleedingTeal Aug 02 '18 edited Aug 02 '18

I'm not certain but a simple explanation as to why it wouldn't find a key logger is because it's not looking for key loggers. But I'm sure you already thought of that.

Additionally, your entire argument against my point also proved it. The problem with your argument involving the Sherman Act doesn't allow a security company like Malwarebytes or any other to blanket block a type of application, much like Microsoft can't blanket block a 3rd party web browser from being installed. While you may find MS Remote Access to be a PUP, the security industry does not. Nor would Microsoft make an application to run on it's own operating system that meets the legal definition of a PUP thus allowing Malwarebytes or any other security application to block it because it's anti-competitive and punitive.

Congrats on spending 20+ years as a programmer, and that you obtained a BS & MS on CS, but you've been bested by a guy in his mid 30's with a GED, no college degree, and less than a decade working in the industry. Check your information again, because you're flat out wrong in your interpretation of both the dynamics of how security applications work, and what they can legally do.

Good day, sir.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/kodenkan Apr 15 '18

No, your experience means a great deal, Bill. Just like I cited mine. But you were confined to programming. So you didn't have to learn about these issue. As a programmer, you probably don't understand marketing or legal and view it only through your myopic lens. I mentioned I was sr management because I had to know those things; it wasn't egotistical.

But for someone who asked a question, you sure are belligerent to those who tried to help you. Communication is two-way, Bill.

For instance, after two people have tried in good faith to explain something, and you've snapped at them both, I said good luck to you. FYI that means good bye and don't bother me again.

The obstinate and combative shouldn't ask questions he doesn't have the ken to understand.

Good luck to you!

3

u/billdietrich1 Apr 15 '18 edited Apr 15 '18

Yes, you're still failing. You can't give me a reason why MWB has to be completely redesigned to detect keyloggers and report them as PUP. I think you and Teal are completely wrong about this. And you offer no facts or reasoning to show otherwise.

And no, your experience/authority or mine matters not at all. Facts matter.

[PS: AVG can detect keyloggers: https://www.avg.com/en/signal/is-your-partner-spying-on-you-with-a-keylogger

So do at least some versions of Norton: https://www.cnet.com/forums/discussions/how-do-you-prevent-and-defeat-keyloggers/

So saying it's impossible for MWB to detect at least keyloggers' files on disk is wrong.]

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '18

You do realize that programs (like team-viewer) are often classed as trojans, and are one of the most common false-positives out there?

I don't think this is as serious as you describe, I'm not going to call you out on it until I can do some research to back that up though. It IS a good point, IF it's true.

1

u/BleedingTeal Jul 31 '18

You don't know my background so I'll give you the benefit of the doubt on this. However, if you knew my background, my current job title, and my previous job title & the company I worked for you may find me a bit more credibile. But this is not the right subreddit to get into all of that. 🙂

2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '18

If you're not going to elaborate I'm just going to have to assume you don't know anything on the subject. Have a good one mate.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '18 edited Aug 01 '18

I do not but did you sound like you know about what you're talking about; However even with credentials it is what you say that I would judge. That's why I didn't want to call you out. I'm genuinely curious, as this conflicts with what I know from working in IT.

It would be fantastic if you could provide some sources that I can educate myself with, even if it's over dm's

1

u/BleedingTeal Aug 02 '18

Sorry, life an such pulled my attention away from here. Plus, I forgot to respond in the midst of a very busy day yesterday.

Anyway, part of the problem with most AV's is they use definitions to determine if a given file is malicious. That works if naming schemes remain constant, which they did 20 years ago, but they really haven't since then. The trade off with traditional AV's is there's minimal behavioral based detections which matters in 2018 and beyond for a lot of reasons. Definition based dections is a very very small part of what Malwarebytes application does, however the majority of it's function is behavior based which allows the application to be smaller in size, lighter in system resource usage, and quicker to adapt to a changing threat landscape. So an application such as TeamView (which is a security risk but for other reasons) wouldn't be flagged as a Trojan or anything else with MB because it's not actively doing anything to attack the system.

But as far as the original comment I replied to, the reason Malwarebytes doesn't blanket flag such remote access applications like TV is because that's anticompetitive, which in the responses to my comment it's explained why that's all kinds of bad.

Unfortunately I don't have direct sources as my knowledge comes from being in the industry and absorbing information from a multitude of sources over many years. Including some very smart people at Malwarebytes, as well as my understanding of how business works and how some parts of the law applies to businesses such as Malwarebytes. I'm not trying to be deliberately vague or dismissive. It's just difficult to effectively answer the posed question based on how I've come to acquire the knowledge I have as again it's come from multiple places across several years. If you're curious I may be able to find one or two articles which discuss some of what I'm talking about however.

Edit: words. I'm tired and can't brain so good. =\

15

u/[deleted] Mar 01 '18 edited Mar 01 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/dgrrr Mar 24 '18

Hi pal! FYI the trial gets "restarted" because in menus for a major update / upgrade, the "try our Premium Trial" box gets re-checked. (It appears to be a default.) I have never seen it NOT checked during a major update (unless I uncheck it). THIS is why, when I return to a client computer months later, MBAM has become an expired trial or paid-for Pro. Because the reinstall does NOT retain the state of the checkbox. Also, I agree that deactivating the trial is simple for most. But not for the older clients I'm talking about. In those cases, the MBAM's choice to reset that checkbox is important. And kind of my whole point. BTW, I'd be FINE with a confirmation box that said, "On previous installations, you declined the trial. Are you sure you don't want realtime protection?" That would fix the biggest issue for me.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '18

You mean someone actually works as a field technician, and realizes how mbam's failings affect his clients?