r/Malwarebytes • u/ByteEat3r • Jan 27 '18
FIXED - Malwarebytes 3 - High Mem Usage / Web Protection Issues
Hi everyone --
So sorry about the issues you've been having with high memory usage.
These issues should now be resolved. You may need to reboot your machine; in some cases, a second reboot may be needed.
Additionally, here's an official update from our CEO Marcin:
https://forums.malwarebytes.com/topic/220112-important-web-blocking-ram-usage/
Thanks so much for your patience.
MB @ Malwarebytes
3
u/peanutdronetree Jan 27 '18
Thank you Malwarebytes! It appears to be working for me. Malwarebytes version: 3.3.1.2183 Component package version: 1.0.262 Update package version: 1.0.3803
3
u/NotSwitchedOn Jan 27 '18
This didn't work for me, however restarting the mbam service seems to have done it.
3
u/ByteEat3r Jan 27 '18
Here's a quick command for other folks that aren't sure how to restart the service.
Hit the following key combination from your desktop.
Windows Key + R
Run the following command into the prompt that appears.
powershell.exe -command "restart-service MBAMService -force"
1
u/NotSwitchedOn Jan 27 '18
Thanks v muchly for your work, my guess is that the service restart forced the app to pick up the latest (which it should have but for whatever reason hadn't)
Regardless, am happy it's working within parameters again.
1
2
u/icyone Jan 27 '18
So the app says there are no updates available, and the powershell command does nothing either. Where can I download the update and apply it manually? What a joke.
1
u/ByteEat3r Jan 27 '18
Sorry that it didn't fix the issue. Would you please try rebooting your machine?
1
u/thr0wawayforquestion Jan 27 '18 edited Jan 27 '18
E: clicked the update button on the right side of the main screen, instead of in settings. Alternatively right click tray icon and check for updates. For some reason it's not an application update.
2
u/rweedn Jan 27 '18
I've just installed 3.3.1,2183 and it still has the same issue?
2
u/ByteEat3r Jan 27 '18
Can you try updating Malwarebytes through the application?
On the left side, click 'Settings', then select the 'Application' tab and click 'Install Application Updates'. You may need to temporarily disable web protection if that doesn't work.
Here's a doc with some screenshots:
https://support.malwarebytes.com/docs/DOC-1125
Thank you!
4
u/rweedn Jan 27 '18
Web protection is turned of and it says no available updates. I'll try again after a restart
1
u/thr0wawayforquestion Jan 27 '18 edited Jan 27 '18
E: clicked the update button on the right side of the main screen, instead of in settings. Alternatively right click tray icon and check for updates. For some reason it's not an application update.
1
u/mixmatch1122 Jan 28 '18 edited Jan 28 '18
I have the same issue as the guy above.
My version is 3.3.1.2183, restarted my laptop 3 times now and still it leaks?
Thinking of doing a clean reinstall.
edit: I did a clean install and it worked.
44
u/mkleczynski Jan 27 '18
CEO of Malwarebytes here. Deeply apologetic and heartbroken about today's issue. I'm on reddit if you need help fixing issue or just to vent.
22
u/TheDrunkMexican Jan 27 '18
You should be roasting your QA team right now. With as wide spread as this thing was, and how it was crashing systems, there is no way this could not have come out in QA. I'm thankful I opted to pass on your enterprise platform (mostly due to the absurd cost), had my organization had to deal with this, heads would have rolled.
10
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
We have pushed 20,000 updates routinely like this. This was a bad push into prod. I will be documenting shortly and it will be on our blog and forum.
4
Jan 28 '18
It still spikes my CPU to 100% periodically.
Here I am, still with windows defender because of this bullshit.
4
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
An uninstall and reinstall fixes this problem 100%.
3
Jan 28 '18
That is what I've already done.
I uninstalled it because of the RAM and CPU usage.
Then I downloaded the installer from your site, and installed it.
Once it was installed, it said it was up to date.
Before you tell me to restart it again, I already had to because of the CPU usage.
That did nothing.
3
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
I'm wondering if something stuck around during the uninstall. Can you try this: https://forums.malwarebytes.com/topic/196955-malwarebytes-support-tools/?tab=comments#comment-1116748
Happy to flip you over a free lifetime key for all the trouble you've had. PM me if interested.
2
Jan 29 '18
Before we go trying to make sure nothing's left over, I'm going to confirm it's actually still causing the issue.
This morning I woke up to higher than normal CPU temperatures and usage.
After closing Malwarebytes, it stopped.
I haven't opened it any more today.
Since you've offered a free lifetime key, I've gone back to confirm it wasn't just a one off bug.
It would appear that after waiting a day, it has stopped.
It's still higher than with just Windows Defender running, but not like it was this morning. I'm sure that's to be expected.
I may have jumped the gun a bit earlier, but I was just tired of computer problems.
You don't have to give me a free lifetime key, unless you just want to for some reason.
3
u/TheDrunkMexican Jan 28 '18
I can understand the stress you went through yesterday, but your defense of "we've done it 20,000 times before and it worked just fine" is absolutely not owning up to "yeah, we botched the QA process".
Further below this one, you counter someone with "uninstall and reinstall fixes it 100% of the time". Are you really prepared to tell enterprise customers to use that solution? With 25k client endpoints on my network, there is no way it would go back on after an uninstall due to this incident.
3
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
Completely appreciate your feedback. Realize that I'm on reddit and trying to answer as many questions as I can. I will be careful to be less informal, lesson learned.
There are no excuses for what happened. What worked 20,000 times clearly broke once, and that's one too many times. We are gutting our entire QA process and putting in safeguards so this, and any other doomsday scenario we can think of, will never happen again.
Our enterprise customers are not being told to uninstall / reinstall. We have a few ways of getting them up and running, many which can be done from the centralized console.
Please feel free to message me directly with more feedback or if you need any help.
5
u/ramtek_us Jan 29 '18
We are one of the corporate clients. Problems with Malwarebytes have been nonexistent up until now. I am willing to cut them some slack up until the point it becomes clear that it is a habitual problem. One mistake doesn't do that. I spent my Saturday with my team fixing the error on workstations. Yes that is incredibly annoying and lifespan I will never get back. Still, I have spent far more time over the years fixing unintended mistakes from Microsoft or issues with annoying problems with Symantec products on individual machines. Context people. IMO The worst thing about this problem was that the fix wasn't scriptable because it broke access to the machines and that the testing clearly doesn't test enough scenarios. If there are lessons to be learned fix that. Aside from that kudos for taking the hits from the numerous trolls on here.
1
u/konnerbllb Feb 04 '18
Have you thought about pushing program updates like this in small batches? Or allowing users to automatically forgo program updates for X amount of days like Windows 10 allows? I would love the have this option.
11
u/RabbitPoopRaisins Jan 27 '18
Can you call my boss and tell him this wasn't my fault?
10
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
I am very happy to discuss over the phone; please send me a message if it's a serious request.
6
5
u/fallwinterspring Jan 27 '18
Even the fix was obnoxious. I ran the powershell script and rebooted 3 times and it didn't work as per your instructions.
I had to open services.msc myself and toggle the the Malwarebytes service in there to fix it.
Complaining aside, I do like your product. Keep it up guys.
4
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
Thanks for the kind words. This problem sucked for our users; we will make it right. I will document so everyone understand what, why, and why never again.
1
u/misterred Feb 01 '18
Where's that document? I am still blocked from my LAN after updates and there is no application-level update available to me. How and when should I just expect this to fix itself? Thanks.
1
u/mkleczynski Feb 01 '18
Shoot me a message with your email; will get on the phone today.
1
u/misterred Feb 01 '18
I found the pinned instructions for clean reinstall, which I had to do. It seems to have gone well despite another moment's panic when I was not prompted, as doc said that I would, to back up my license. But after reinstall/reboot, things now seem to be operating normally. Thanks very much.
1
5
u/noirthesable Jan 28 '18
Like, no need for venting from my end (probably would’ve if it took longer, but the response was quite quick). Thanks for stepping in and getting involved in the community.
3
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
Thanks for the kind words. I am deeply disappointed but we are working hard to resolve these issues for our users.
2
3
u/GimmeCat Jan 27 '18
Thanks for getting on it quickly. It would be nice to hear a more technical explanation of what went wrong, beyond the brief statement given earlier on the forum.
I have a quick question if you're not too swamped at the moment. I QA'd for you guys several years ago via uTest, squashed some bugs, and have been using the tester's Premium key ever since. Are you guys cool with that? I figure it would've been disabled if not, but I'm also kinda scared to ever uninstall in case the key doesn't work anymore.
Good luck with the aftermath of today's issues. I don't envy you the cleanup and angry customers, but I think MB has a solid enough reputation that it'll survive it.
3
3
u/technicalanarchy Jan 27 '18
I gotta say 1st off thank you to Malwarebytes, it is invaluable. It has kept me several of my customers out of trouble for years.
That said today's issue had me freaking out. It was the worst memory leak I have seen since one in Windows 98 (can't remember what it was though). While it was going on it was scary af.
Thank you for fixing it so quickly.
3
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
Thank you for the kind words. We are working hard to get in touch with our customers and make sure they understand the steps we're taking to ensure it never happens again. More soon.
2
u/technicalanarchy Jan 28 '18
Thank you for the reply.
I know Malwarebytes works hard and does a great job, please don't go to far overboard "Ensuring this never happens again" that phrase always scares me.
I'm sure everyone on the Malwarebytes team, especially those that were working today learned a lifetime of lessons in 3 or 4 hours.
And don't fire the person who did it, (unless they did it intentionally) cause I'm sure they will never, ever do anything like it again.
1
u/mkleczynski Jan 29 '18
This was an honest mistake and a perform storm between the person on watch and the systems we have in place. We're doing a full review and will chaos monkey the hell out of this thing. I can't promise no issues ever again, but we certainly learned 40 lessons this weekend.
1
u/ramtek_us Jan 29 '18
Machines with more ram weathered the bad push better. Machines with marginal amounts of ram (say 8GB) were crippled. The main issue was that we had to touch every single machine individually. Right clicking the tray icon didn't function on some machines (though every block displayed) so we ended up logging on with safemode with networking support, running mbam.exe from the run line, updating the definitions from there and then rebooting. This took the team 5 hours to complete with all of our client workstations. It was very labor intensive but at least it happened on a weekend. I think some mechanism to whitelist our individual management servers would be advisable. If we could have pushed updates centrally we probably wouldn't have even noticed the problem.
1
u/M_Renegade_M Jan 31 '18
1
u/mkleczynski Jan 31 '18
It's been a long couple of days, but I can't say that I didn't at least crack a smile on this one.
0
u/banished98ti Jan 27 '18
Utterly shameful. This program has completely gone to shit since 3.0.
Ive removed it and will be demanding a refund.
8
u/mkleczynski Jan 28 '18
I'm sorry to hear you feel that way. Message me and will refund immediately.
0
u/Hi_Voltg3 Jan 28 '18
I'm just glad the fix was timely. I uninstalled and waited for further word on the issue. As for venting, I ran Antorus today on my Shaman I'm trying to gear and didn't get a single piece of gear 😡
19
u/Exicuton Jan 27 '18
This is gonna hurt big time on the MalwareBytes reputation. Ouch. Quality control is priceless in this business.
9
u/Sacred_twerp Jan 27 '18
Considering - they responded pretty well I think. Bricked our four computers in the network for a bit, but they admitted the problem nearly right away and pushed out a fix quickly.
I feel sorry for them, they are catching absolute hell for it. But we won't leave them over this. (We buy the premium deal)
If google was as responsive and helpful when they screw up - it would be a whole different world.
Hang in there, MWB code peeeps. This too will more or less pass...
4
u/hesonline Jan 28 '18
Shit happens, even to the best of us. Your reputation stays the same with me. I respect the company and the product. Good job patching this fairly quickly last night.
3
u/RousingRabble Jan 28 '18
Anyway to do this remotely when MBAM is stopping all network traffic? Have about 200 machines in 10 locations.
2
u/egas_tt Jan 28 '18
Any luck with removing this remotely? We are in the same boat.
1
u/RousingRabble Jan 28 '18
Unfortunately not. We have to go to each machine.
1
u/egas_tt Jan 28 '18
Dang it! I just got in to work and about the brief the team.
Thanks for the feedback.
3
2
2
u/HalfManHalfHunk Jan 28 '18
I was glad to see I wasn't the only one experiencing this problem, thought something was horribly wrong with my PC at first, but I'm even more glad with how fast you guys responded to and fixed the issue.
3
u/MajaSoda Jan 28 '18
This bug bricked my computer and caused corrupted graphics drivers. I had to spend two hours trying to fix this mess it caused. Im guessing im just gonna hear "I sowwy". Can't believe I paid for this shit.
1
u/walwalka Jan 28 '18
Enterprise console wouldn't update the machines policy in my organization today. Had to uninstall from all the endpoints.
1
u/egas_tt Jan 28 '18
We have just under 800 MWB clients that connect to our management console where the side effect of this faulty update has taken the NIC offline.
According to the forum post from Malwarebytes, the solution when this happens is to reinstall the client.
Does anyone else have this issue? If yes, how are you proceeding? I am dreading going in to the office today to assist our floor guys to manually remove the clients on 800 computers.
There is small window of connectivity when the affected machine rebooted and the malwarebytes service hasn't started as yet. So I was thinking about a computer Group Policy with startup batch file to remove the client but I can't guarantee that the machine will try to download the new policy before MWB kicks in.
1
u/misterred Jan 28 '18
I've been unable to determine whether this broken update is what's caused me suddenly to be unable to access my LAN without first disabling "Web Protection" (specifically I cannot access router settings on https: // 192.168.1.1 even with that IP asserted in Exceptions), or not. (I get the useless impertinent MWB Block page.)
1
u/RabbitPoopRaisins Jan 28 '18
Yes this is it. We had around 300 machines start blocking LAN traffic yesterday due to this update.
1
u/ScoobyGreg Jan 29 '18
I updated malwarebytes and restarted my computer and thankfully everything is fixed and back to normal. Question: should I still install mb_clean and run it or am I in the clear now?
1
10
u/rweedn Jan 27 '18
Well at least they fixed it as soon as they could and admitted there was an issue