r/Mahouka • • May 17 '24

Discussion I’ve been irritated by the reactions of Mahouka

0 Upvotes

Okay,where do I start they off,yeah people on social media and mainstream media saying the anime is trash and that saying bad stuff about it without watching it is triggering me and offending me a lot which adds to the fact that in order for the anime to be continued,the dvd,the bluerays needs to be bought and with these reactions,I’m starting to get worried and the Japanese audience is getting older also and meaning they have work and have less and less time to have time for their hobbies and the generalization of the anime hate is just driving me crazy. These people are toxic,dumb and they base their arguments on opinions rather than logic and the reviewers,react channels and entertainers made it even worse,like Gigguk who is just straight up misunderstanding the anime. He thinks this anime is like all of the op main character trash isekai stuff,it’s not,it’s much more complicated than that and these people are not understanding it even when being explained and when spoil them with how the Shibas got together,they would go on a tantrum saying rude/bad things to the author and trashing the anime without properly understanding the situation.

What a lot of people don’t know is this anime is a manipulation/power oriented anime and people are getting it wrongly that it frustrates me everytime the general reviewers trashing it like this. Like they think it’s an nsfw anime where people enjoy it for dirty stuff.With everything violent happening around on social media and the world and people getting dumber,it’s driving me crazy that people are also just toxic and shetting on the anime where I want to relax and enjoy it more. Soo much depends on money and bluerays dvd sales for the anime to continue,when people are like this,it worries me that they would stop doing the anime,like often times it hits me that the anime would be demon slayer level successful if people were smarter and more understanding and more productive. These days I’m just meditating and reading books just to avoid these social media bullshet and I don’t even respond to the comments of clueless toxic comments on YouTube anymore cause I know it would just hit my mental health.


r/Mahouka • • Sep 04 '23

Why I Dislike Tatsuya x Miyuki Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I would like to preface this by saying that I am currently on vol. 26 so please no spoilers. Although this is probably an annoying topic that is often brought up, I wish to provide a different and new perspective to this (sorry in advance if its not new but I couldn't find much on the subreddit about this). The problems I have with this ship is not that it's incest or that I hate Miyuki. Honestly, I would say that I like her rather than dislike her (albeit I was forced to read pages of author simping and stating how beautiful she is every chance he gets) even though she can be a bit overbearing at times.

The main problem is that I feel like Tatsuya is forced into the relationship. Even though he is now accepted into the Yotsuba family, he is still being controlled in a way by Maya and the Yotsubas. Although he uses the clan's influence and powers for himself, he won't be able to be truly be free until Miya's mental interference magic (IM) is removed. While being stripped of his strong emotions, he is basically a magic machine in which he is forced to only love one person for his entire life. As such, I feel like Tatsuya is one of the most tragic characters in the series (then theres maya...). As much as I really enjoyed reading vol. 16 with all the plot twists and suspense, I was also disappointed with the fact that Tatsuya still accepted all the sht that's been thrown at him. Maya knew that he wouldn't be able to retaliate since Tatsuya would never do anything to bring suffering to Miyuki which makes him a slave to Miyuki and by extension the Yotsuba clan.

Thus, I felt like most of their interactions after the engagement feel very forced. It's a given that Miyuki is elated upon hearing the news that she is now allowed to marry and have a sexual relationship with her brother/cousin, but on the other hand, Tatsuya is visibly perturbed and confused upon hearing the news. Miyuki doesn't have a problem since she has been deeply in love with him since the Reminiscence Arc, but Tatsuya doesn't feel the same way and even expresses the fact that he can only see her as a sister. Even though he feels very uncomfortable with Miyuki's advances (i.e. bathtub scene/sleeping together), he would never reject her due to his love for Miyuki being hardwired into his brain.

Thus, they are not in an equal relationship (probably will never be unless Tatsuya can regain his emotions). For me, it feels like a parent/child or servant/master relationship where Tatsuya follows Miyuki's whims. Even though people will say that Miyuki would also follow Tatsuya's every wish, and while I also agree with this fact, I do not think their love is the same. Due to not having strong emotions like greed or strong jealousy, Tatsuya will be content with anything as long as Miyuki is happy/safe. Therefore, he wouldn't feel intense sadness or anger if Miyuki was with someone else. but I cannot say the same if the roles were reversed though.

I find it really depressing that he's indirectly forced down this path, and I just want him to be free at the end of the series where he can live by his own rules.

Finally, another problem (albeit small compared to the main one) is that this pairing is predictable. This is just a personal complaint since I enjoy stories where the ending/plot isn't easily predicted, and romances where end game girl is established from the start is beginning to get stale for me. This is one of the reasons why the incest part doesn't bother me since I appreciate the author for having the guts to do something different. From the start, Tatsuya x Miyuki was pretty much confirmed which makes it less interesting for me at least.

That's why I like Tatsuya with Lina since they are similar in a sense that both were forced to become weapons. Though, Lina is now trying to find her own path which being shackled by her past. Even Tatsuya states that he understands her pain, and that he feels a certain kinship with her. As such, I feel like they can form a relationship where they can be equal if he wasn't bound by Miya's mental IM. Plus, she's a lot more expressive, and I find their dynamic charming. Even though this ship might be very unlikely, I still have hope.

Mayumi wouldn't be bad either since I enjoyed their dynamic, but after vol. 23 yea.... and Honaka would be like whatever, but I wouldn't hate it. MAYA would be pretty nice for obvious reasons, but very, very unlikely (though a man can dream)

Sorry for the long rant (?)! I have more to say but wasn't sure how much I'm allowed to write. Hopefully Magian Company will begin to expand more on this topic. Though, I would love to hear what everyone else thinks about this!


r/Mahouka • • Aug 26 '22

does miyuki become a better character?

0 Upvotes

I watched S1 ages ago and found out now that there is S2 but miyuki is still the same which is being obsessed with her brother. I'm fine being spoiled on this but does she ever get out of that stupid trope? If not then she is by far the worst character in the show


r/Mahouka • • Oct 16 '24

AI-Generated I asked ChatGPT to create a spell using Mahouka's magic system. Let me know of your thoughts. Spoiler tag just incase. Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Prompt: create a magic spell using this [mahouka's] magic system

Spell Name: "Voltaic Resonance Burst"

  • System: Acceleration System

  • Subsystems: Oscillation-Type (from the Acceleration System) + Release-Type (from the Release System)

Spell Concept:

"Voltaic Resonance Burst" is a spell that combines precise vibration control with energy release. The caster uses Oscillation-Type Magic to induce high-frequency vibrations within a target, creating resonant frequencies at the molecular level. This weakens the target's structural integrity, priming it for the secondary effect. Once the target reaches a critical resonant state, the mage uses Release-Type Magic to unleash stored electrical energy, causing the target to shatter violently in a burst of electrical discharge.

Detailed Breakdown:

  1. Step 1: Oscillation Induction (Oscillation-Type Magic)

    • The mage casts an initial Oscillation-Type Magic spell that induces high-frequency vibrations into a specific object or material, matching its natural resonant frequency. This resonance causes internal stress and weakens the molecular bonds within the object.

    • Effect: The target begins to vibrate subtly, with the internal structure becoming increasingly unstable.

  2. Step 2: Resonance Amplification (Oscillation-Type Magic)

    • As the vibrations intensify, the mage amplifies the resonance further, pushing the object to the brink of structural collapse. At this stage, the vibrations have caused internal fractures or weaknesses in the material.

    • Effect: The object is now vulnerable, with its internal cohesion severely compromised.

  3. Step 3: Electrical Discharge (Release-Type Magic)

    • The mage quickly switches to Release-Type Magic, channeling stored electrical energy (either from the environment or previously stored energy within the CAD) into the resonating target.

    • The electrical energy violently interacts with the weakened structure, causing the object to explode in a burst of high-energy plasma and electrical arcs.

    • Effect: The target shatters in a high-energy explosion, with electrical discharge leaping across the surroundings, potentially stunning or damaging nearby entities.

Practical Use:

  • Combat: This spell is highly effective against both physical structures and heavily armored targets, as the resonance weakens even the toughest materials before the final explosive discharge. The electrical arcs add an extra layer of offense, potentially disrupting electronics or paralyzing foes.

  • Utility: The resonant frequency can be fine-tuned to work on specific materials, making this spell adaptable to various situations, such as demolishing walls, breaking through magical barriers, or disabling machinery.

  • Drawback: The spell requires precise control over both the frequency of vibrations and the amount of electrical energy released. If overdone, the caster could cause collateral damage or risk the explosion backfiring. It also consumes a significant amount of Psions, especially during the final energy release phase.

Spell Summary:

  • Name: Voltaic Resonance Burst

  • System: Acceleration System (Oscillation-Type) + Release System (Release-Type)

  • Effect: Induces resonant frequencies to destabilize the target, followed by an explosive electrical discharge that shatters the weakened object.

  • Applications: Combat (armor/shield breaking, stun effect), utility (demolition, disabling machinery).

This spell illustrates the blend of the Oscillation-Type and Release-Type magic principles, taking advantage of physics-based effects to create a powerful and visually dramatic effect in battle.

Would this type of spell be possible considering the laws of physics? What would be the limitations for this spell?


r/Mahouka • • Mar 16 '21

Tatsuya dating life

1 Upvotes

This might sound like a vent, but im just so mad. I know it was pretty obvious since ep1 he and his sister would be together ect ect. But it makes me so sad and mad that he didnt end up with the president. Why? Well Jumonji (the big guy) suggest her as a bride, her father suggests it, she has feelings for him. Like there is so much hinting going on, but at the end its just one big middle finger. I get that tatsuya and his sister have plot armor, but why did they do so much hinting at tatsuya x saegusa to end up doing nothing at all?


r/Mahouka • • Apr 05 '20

(Miyuki x Tatuysu) or (Tatuysu x Mayumi)

0 Upvotes

Can those who want Miyuki and Tatuysu in a romantic relationship explain why they ship them ? Especially since they are brother and sister(at least cousins) which makes there relationship incestual which, in my opinion makes the relationship disgusting and in moral. I want to know,dose the fact that they are related bother you and if it doesn’t why not ?

I personally ship Tatuysu and Mayumi together and if not Mayumi I would want Linda to be with Tatuysu but, I definitely don’t want Tatuysu x Miyuki. In My book a perfect ending would be Tatuysu x Mayumi and Miyuki x Ichijou Misaki.


r/Mahouka • • Aug 02 '20

Is Tatsuya actually going to end up with Miyuki? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I know this has definitely been said a million times, and the story definitely hints at it, but do people thing the end is going to be actual siblings getting married. I don’t know about anyone else but it’s the only consistently off putting thing I find with the series


r/Mahouka • • 14d ago

Media Where to Yotsuba succession arc movie (piracy)

3 Upvotes

I really want to watch the movies but the movie is not available in my region, so can anyone share where can I watch it


r/Mahouka • • Feb 24 '25

Discussion fundimental misunderstanding fans have SPOILERS DUH Spoiler

0 Upvotes

so the fundimental misunderstanding is that Miyuki and Tatsuya are more akin to cousins genetically because of the modification done on Miyuki making tatsuya more akin to Maya's son.

this is false since since maya and miya were IDENTICAL TWIN SISTERS they would be IDENTICAL so even if tatsuya was Maya's actual son(he obviously isn't ) genetically he and Miyuki would no matter what be genetically siblings.

if maya turned out to be his mother that would make them half siblings unless it turned out Tatsurou was still his father

so in the end no matter what, socially and biologically they are brother and sister


r/Mahouka • • Mar 25 '24

Tatsuya's and Miyuki's Mother is a Wh**e! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I saw the Movie reminiscence arc the first time today and I really started hating their mother, the whole yotsuba clan, their aunt and many more. Even if Tatsuya does not meet the defenition of magic they use, he's still family, her son and is still able to do incredible things with his abilities and I'd still consider them magic, but the worst thing is operating him so he fits in and stealing nearly any emotion he had and then still continue with hating him, she really is one of the worst anime mothers I know! I need to talk about it! (I know it's not reality, don't need to tell me!) Any opinions about it!?


r/Mahouka • • Apr 11 '24

What the fuck is wrong with this bitch? At least that what I thought in this scene

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Mahouka • • Jun 11 '25

Discussion The degradation of female characters. Spoiler

17 Upvotes

I find it hard to digest the way Mayumi and Honoka have been degraded in the novel....

The former being hated by her surroundings (since volume 23 of the first part of the novel) and the latter practically being discarded from the main plot and made to look like an "easy girl" out of spite (I still can't believe that Honoka could end up married to Takuma).

The same goes for Angelina, who has become a figurehead. Almost at the level of a silly mascot.

Sato created an amazing magic system, but failed to complement it with a story that had good character development. So much so that not even the main couple has had a significant breakthrough in their relationship.


r/Mahouka • • Jun 04 '24

Discussion Who does tatsuya end up with Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I mean he can't end up with her own sister


r/Mahouka • • Jan 16 '22

What would Miyuki's reaction have been if Tatsuya had told her he was gay?

3 Upvotes

r/Mahouka • • Feb 07 '22

I don't like the covers.

2 Upvotes

That's it.

While both the writing and the tone are rather mature, the covers look childish. Coupled with the colours' choices, also somewhat girly.

I don't think they look that good on my shelves, especially compared to series like, Overlord, though the comparison is unfair with the hard covers. But even compared to Slime, on Youjo Senki, it's not as good.

That's the end of my little rant. I own 18 volumes and I fully intend to complete the series anyway.


r/Mahouka • • Sep 23 '20

Am I the only one who doesn't like Miyuki ?

5 Upvotes

So,
I know that Mahouka isn't a great show, it's just one average action anime with op main character, but the fact that there have to be those irritating female characters is just outrageous.
Am I the only one skipping almost every scene with Miyuki after 3 or 4 first episodes ?

Edit: a lot of fan boys came here, to straighten things up, I'm only skipping those shitty-ass incest scenes, I'm watching the series for action and plot, not for some ice-witch incest porn scenes


r/Mahouka • • Jun 22 '24

Question Is it true the series “goes to shit” after vol 16?

0 Upvotes

I’m planning to start reading this as it seems right up my alley but i don’t want to get invested in a series for it to just turn out to drop the ball in the middle…


r/Mahouka • • Jun 28 '24

Discussion Sizes

4 Upvotes

Hello there fellow Mahouka fans!
I came here to you all with one specific but weird at same time question. . .

How would you rank all breasts sizes? From biggest to smallest, cup sizes etc.
Just. . . breasts sizes thread xD


r/Mahouka • • Nov 04 '20

Why is this series still being published? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I remember years ago around 2012 or 2014 in Japan there was a ban on works that had incest and, if I'm not mistaken, this culminated in the cancellation or sudden change of some manga and books as well. I didn't follow it very well I just heard that it was a law or something. I spent a few years without watching anime and I just found out that this series has a new season and continues to be published, that surprised me. I read posts on this subreddit and after reading some spoilers I was even more perplexed because the author clearly could have made the two characters unrelated and the whole genetic modification thing seems just an excuse to make their incest acceptable. Not only are the characters in an incestuous relationship but their engagement is based on fraudulent documents.

Does anyone have an idea why this series was not canceled years ago? I am not a fan, however considering everything I just listed I was astonished.

Note: I created this account to ask just this question and it's something I've been thinking about for a few weeks.

I found the news that I was told the year was 2014. The article says that there was an amendment in force in Tokyo. I don't know if it's still applies.

Three years ago, Tokyo tightened an ordinance stopping children buying publications that "significantly stimulate sexual feeling". "2011 amendment expanded the rules to cover pictures or text that "glorifies" incest."

When writing characters in an incestuous relationship that is omitted through fraud, wouldn't it be considered to glorify incest? The author created mechanisms to make illegal marriage possible, right?

I'm not here to judge the characters themselves, I was just curious to know the possible reason why this work could continue.


r/Mahouka • • Jan 08 '22

Anyone know of a Ichijou Masaki/Shiba Miyuki fanfic?

0 Upvotes

I really love masaki and miyuki as a couple. If anyone knows a fanfic with that pairing, I’d greatly appreciate the recommendation.


r/Mahouka • • Dec 23 '20

If Naruto was in the Mahouka Universe, which girl would be best suited to be his Love Interest?

0 Upvotes

Naruto would still have the same personality from the main canon series and I won't be including Miyuki ( have nothing against her just don't want to ).

144 votes, Dec 30 '20
21 Angelina Kudou Shields
34 Erika Chiba
39 Honoka Mitsui
18 Mizuki Shibata
5 Shizuku Kitayama
27 Mayumi Saegusa

r/Mahouka • • Jul 10 '22

Hmm will tatsuya ever actually realize how much of a badass he is , or just be a dense MC

0 Upvotes

r/Mahouka • • May 20 '22

I’ve given up on mahouka LN

2 Upvotes

It’s too confusing and the mtl make me hate my life so I’m done maybe in 5 year ig I’ll pick it back up hopefully a decent translation will be available


r/Mahouka • • Oct 26 '23

Anyone else get pissed off after the author of the original LN (not company) basically just made strategic class magic out of his ass and had tatsuya give it to the guy that hates him most?

0 Upvotes