r/MagpieGames • • Apr 25 '22

A Mild Critique of the Avatar: Legends Playbook Art Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hi, sorry if this is against the rules, but I just wanted to give a little commentary on the Playbook Art of Avatar: Legends. I know it's an odd thing, but I haven't seen any commentary on it anywhere, and I think it might be an interesting discussion topic for art in PBtA, hopefully. Basically, I have a small bone to pick with the "playbook art" for each of the Avatar: Legends Playbooks.

This is not with the raw quality of the art. The artist did an incredible job, and is far better than anything I could dream of. They are really well-designed, and mesh perfectly in the Avatar style, particularly with Korra (which makes sense, since most people are likely to want to play older characters in the age range of Korra instead of the younger characters of the original series).

That said, my main issue with the art is that, really, they don't evoke the Playbooks that well. And to explain what I mean, I think it's important to look at Masks.

Each of the Playbook characters (especially in the core 10) in Masks is instantly recognizable, to the point where you could show me them and I'd tell you what Playbook they're for. The color choices, posing, and overall designs really tell you everything you need to know about that Playbook at just a glance.

By contrast...I just don't think the Avatar: Legends playbook characters are as identifiable. You could easily shuffle around which Playbook they all represent, without it feeling odd or out of place. While I know the Avatar universe is far more design-constrained than, say, superhero comics, I still think there were a few places where there might have been room to better identify each of them. Is it just me, or do others think the same?


r/MagpieGames • • Feb 06 '23

The Imp

2 Upvotes

A character I thought of.

Argent had two simple tasks in his contract: sending threats and messages, and policing her minions. He read that contract, for years. Plotting. Planning. Scheming. Looking for any loopholes that he could possibly find. And loopholes, he found. It said nothing about delivering a false threat. A false threat, that he delivered to someone way stronger than the Lady of Crows. This caused chaos and havoc, allowing him to quietly slip away and purchase the dive bar that the Lady of Crows formerly used as her base of operations at the University.

He's been around in the city for roughly, 10 years.

Argent's memories have been tainted by demonic magic, wiping out who he once was- thus. Losing his family. He does, consider Hannah Pritchett, a talented artist, Thaddeus Thatch, a professor. Hank Doge, a Hunter and Clayton Jensen, a former hunter moving in from the country, as family.

The Lady of Crows still holds a grudge against Argent, and plots from the shadows her revenge- and a way to get his immediate return to her services, as that's one of his troubles.

The sentimental item he keeps, hanging behind the bar, is an art piece from Hannah. The very first art piece she ever did when she decided to become an artist. And it is just. The worst thing to look at. It is not done by someone that was talented- not at the time. But he keeps it around. Since then she's moved up in talent. Very weird uptick in talent.

The ritual item binding him to this plane is the first mug of beer that he sold.


r/MagpieGames • • Mar 03 '22

root the rpg Lizard Cult Clarifications

10 Upvotes

Why is the Lizard Cult depicted as Arabs/Muslims? Given the past couple decades and particularly American treatment of both at home and abroad, as well as consistent bad faith understandings of things like jihad, it just seems like an unnecessary and unhelpful pigeonhole. I’m comfortably running games that navigate around these difficulties, but why did you take this approach?

First, it’s important to note that the Lizard Cult isn’t a metaphor for Islam. None of the practices or beliefs the Lizard Cult holds are drawn from Islamic or Arabic sources; the kind of martyrdom practiced by the Lizard Cult echoes Norse or Mesoamerican blood sacrifice, the Cult’s structure of increasingly smaller circles of the devout draws upon Zoroastrianism or even hierarchical forms of Buddhism, and the Cult’s proselytization and forced conversions echo some of the darkest aspects of the Christian Crusades and the Spanish Inquisition. Even further, those practices vary from clearing to clearing as they adapt to the Woodland and the denizens.

In other words, the Lizard Cult—like any other faction—is drawing upon a wide variety of sources to represent a fable-like religious organization, one that can be “good” or “bad” depending on how you choose to represent them in your campaign. Our goal with every faction, from the colonizing Marquisate to the acquisitive Riverfolk Company to the devout Lizard Cult, was to create a political organization with a unique perspective that could be an ally or antagonist, and the Lizard Cult’s internal structures and goals reflect that work.

So why do some of the five lizards presented in the Denizen Deck have names like Qasira Ri’jal and Ubade Mo’set?

The Lizard Cultist names do represent a different culture than the European-esque cultures of the Woodland, and as a result were inspired by Arabic, North African, and East Asian names (but are still mostly fantastical). Just as the otters (Norse-ish) and moles (Roman-esque) bring in influences from other “outsider” cultures, the lizards—often religious outsiders—imply a desert-like home, a place shaped by their own culture and traditions that we thought evoked these influences.

Representing those influences is deeply important—the Woodland evokes a medieval Western Europe that spans nearly 500 years, dozens of different cultures, and multiple empires, and we want to ensure that the Arabic and African peoples that are often erased in the service of a “Western Europe was white!” narrative appeared in the names of the five lizards that appeared in the deck. Europe was a cosmopolitan place, and we want the Woodland to reflect that diversity.

But Qasira Ri’jal and Ubade Mo’set aren’t the only lizards depicted in the text. The Sundew Bend clearing (Travelers & Outsiders, p238) depicts the Lizard Cult as a largely positive force in the clearing, albeit one with its own religious goals. Sundew Bend features two lizards—Opal Moonrider and Hibiscus Gray—whose names don’t evoke any non-European influence, standing alongside converts to the Lizard Cult—Silverpelt and Peeta Clawrunner—who aren’t lizards at all. In Root: The RPG, species does not equal culture…and culture is even further distinct from faction, a political orientation in the fable of the Woodland. No Woodland faction is an allegory for any specific real world culture, and no species is an allegory for any specific real world ethnicity or people.

Ultimately, how much or how little you represent all of these elements is up to you, and it’s always fine to adapt and modify what we’ve presented for your table! Maybe the otters in your world are less Norse than they are Spanish; maybe the bureaucracy of the moles is comical and charming instead of deeply oppressive. The Lizard Cult isn’t “extremist” by default, nor is it Islamic or Arabic—it’s instead a pastiche of ideas that you can use in your games to add a religious faction to your story in a productive way.

But even more importantly, no faction in Root: The RPG is a monolith. The Lizard Cult isn’t an indomitable, unified set of religious institutions; it’s people who are part of a religious community—those people disagree, hold different beliefs, emphasize different aspects of their shared ideology, and even modify that ideology to suit their new environment. There are clearly extremist members of the Lizard Cult, but in the same way that there are “extremist” revolutionaries in the Woodland Alliance or “extremist” Eyrie patriots.


r/MagpieGames • • Mar 06 '22

Chi blocking in Avatar RPG

1 Upvotes

I am having a bit of a problem adapting chi blocking as seen in the two series with the game.

In the series, Chiblocking seems to have 3 different effects.

First - it can disable a limb. This seems consistent with the Impaired status in the game.

Second - The accumulation of attacks can cause someone to become almost paralyzed in effect. This is consistent with the Stunned effect in the game.

Third - It can block bending without impairing a limb or paralyzing the target. This is shown in the first scene in the Last Airbender where Kitara loses her bending but her arms and legs work just fine. Thus, theoretically, she could have taken any of the basic moves without impairment such as moving in for punch or trying to get away. The game does not describe this effect as far as I can tell.

Is there a way that we can have all three of these effects in the game as it is written currently?

As a side note, I found it surprising that Chi blocking was not a defined weapons/martial technique when things like disarm or parry are and seem much more simple to master from a narrative perspective.

Chi blocking is pretty ingrained into both series and I also find it strange it was not specifically treated in some way in the rule book but left up to the players to try to piece things together.


r/MagpieGames • • Apr 29 '22

KS Question

2 Upvotes

So I missed the KS, will all the items be avail on Magpie at launch? Or am I limited to the CRB now? Thank you in advance.


r/MagpieGames • • Sep 13 '22

DEAR MAGPIE GAMES

0 Upvotes

I really love what you guys did with the avatar ttrpg ruleset and I think you guys really struck something there but I think I know what could be your next big hit hear me out. I Think the beloved and widely accredited Anime known as Jojo's Bizarre Adventure would make for and amazing tabletop roleplaying game so what makes a good ttrpg? Well I'm sure you guys know all of these things but we'll go with the basics and strip all the story stuff but I'll come back to it because jojo's does have an amazing story and some possible narrative gimmicks that could make for fun storytelling but back to things like characters setting npcs and mechanics If we look at the characters in JoJo and how someone might want to make a character it's clear that stand abilities would like be the focus of most sheets though there could also be different alternative types of fighters relying on things like Hammond being a vampire or maybe an alien. Jojo's is pretty versatile with it's characters leaving the door wide open for dms and players to make fun characters that are very memorable. The setting really doesn't matter in my opinion because as we see in the anime/manga crazy stuff can break out just about anywhere for really strange reasons perhaps there could be some tips for settings or a version of morioh or something Npcs have all sorts of flair and the dm can show a lot by how someone dresses how their stand looks or if they can even identify someone's stand lots of fun enemy ideas beyond stands there's vampires animals the paranormal and just straight up street thugs sometimes so again it's pretty open ended So many cool mechanics could be implemented like duel heat attacks which is when stand users combo their abilities we could also get different stats for our stand user so our stand user has a sheet and our second sheet is kinda like your own personal class. The coolest thing about this whole idea is the uniqueness of each and every possible character. In masks there were playbooks and you're sorta just not supposed to pick the same one as anyone else at your table in avatar ttrpg there's playbooks as well as bendings which is really cool and there's tons of styles for bending but at the end of the day a jjba tabletop would just be infinitely more open ended I'd love to hear back from someone who works there and has seen the manga/anime


r/MagpieGames • • Jun 29 '23

[Avatar legends] Question about let's role

2 Upvotes

Hi Guys, I wanted to know if you planned to make system used for avatar legends on Let's Role ?


r/MagpieGames • • Oct 03 '22

Watching curated games?

2 Upvotes

I’m new to DMing, and haven’t used this system before. I was hoping to watch some of the curated play games. Are they available to watch somewhere, even for a fee? Or are they only live and that’s it?


r/MagpieGames • • Mar 25 '23

[Avatar Legends] Prodigy's Playbook Question Extraordinary Skill

3 Upvotes

Hello Magpie Games,

i have another question!
When the prodigy teaches other people techniques, do he has to know the technique by himself technically or is it enough when the prodigy know the techniques theoretical?
"When you spend time teaching a fellow companion a technique available to their skills and training," is the quote in the textbook.
Thank you very much


r/MagpieGames • • Aug 23 '21

Signed up but didn't get my Avatar PDF

3 Upvotes

I signed up for the pdf preview for Avatar Legends but still haven't gotten the email. This happen to anyone else?


r/MagpieGames • • Sep 02 '22

Root RPG Combat

4 Upvotes

I understand its supposed to be fast and not like D&D with huge beast with lots of health but a max of 6 health and a damn bear only having 5 just doesnt add up to me. Additionally with just 3 players the bear no longer matters. Every enemy just seems to weak. Was there a reason for this design? The only threat seems to come from impossible to manage numbers like 10 soldiers


r/MagpieGames • • May 14 '22

Rules for armor in Root RPG

4 Upvotes

Hello!

Looks like I can’t find a chapter in the rulebook where armor is appropriately explained. As I understood from various chapter picks, PC can allocate received injuries/exhaustion to armor items and marks a wear on them appropriately. That’s it? Thank you!


r/MagpieGames • • Aug 19 '21

Avatar deck, how to use it

5 Upvotes

Hi people, did someone seen what the cards deck actually is, and which use it has at all? I cannot imagine it, or how to use it...


r/MagpieGames • • Jul 12 '21

Fatigue in the Avatar RPG

5 Upvotes

Perhaps someone could clarify for me, but looking at the quickstart guide just released, doesn't fatigue mean that your character is incredibly squishy? Like, REALLY squishy?

I'm new to Magpie so I'm unsure if this is used in other systems, but I feel that this 'all in one' HP, attack, and utility pool doesn't give the characters much to do before having to stop? When I imagined this game, I thought there'd be perhaps a health pool, and maybe a chi pool for bending/combat.

I've other concerns too, like the system being quite railroady by default, and not general enough to let DMs have fun expanding the universe, but fatigue seems like a deal breaker as to whether or not I invest.


r/MagpieGames • • Dec 20 '22

Chatgpt makes a new Playbook

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Asked Chatgpt to generate a character sheet for the Janus. Instead, it created a hero named Janus with a somewhat new playbook with their own moves.


r/MagpieGames • • Sep 17 '23

Abney Park

5 Upvotes

Abney Park is a steampunk band - been around for over 30 years. They had an RPG out, but admittedly the mechanics were a bit clunky for what the setting is about. The RPG was based on the fictional backstory of the band - and there's some books out with that story.

The reason I'm bringing this all up is because the lead singer / owner of the band, Robert Brown, is considering getting a new edition of the RPG out, starting fresh with it.. And honestly, I think that PbtA would be a good engine for it, and I think Magpie Games would probably be one of the best companies to be doing it.

So, just throwing this out there - perhaps Magpie Games could talk with Abney Park? Here's hoping this comes through!


r/MagpieGames • • Sep 14 '22

Not enjoying Avatars combat

7 Upvotes

I've played masks for about 2 years now so when Avatar came out and it was basically Masks 2 in terms of rules I was very hyped to play it.

My group and I have played 5 sessions now, the game is great, the narrative is flowing, it feels very PbtA. And then combat happens.

Combat seemingly grinds the narrative flow to a halt as it turns into a mini game of picking combat moves, figuring out who attacks/defends/observes, and several rounds of fighting. Not to mention that its near impossible to actually win a fight without having the other side retreat; fatigue drags out the combat to unnecessarily lengthy engagements.

Is it just me, or did Masks do fighting way better by keeping it in the same simplistic narrative style as the rest of the game? Do a thing, trigger a move, roll it, narrative changes. I feel moves like Directly Engage, Defend Someone, etc. directly impacted the narrative and changed the situation in interesting ways while not feeling like you're playing a completely different mini game. A battle would finish within 5-20 minutes depending on how hard of a fight the GM wanted it to be rather than hours for even the smallest of significant fights. A move would do more than mark some fatigue boxes (without heavy GM intervention to make something else happen as well as the fatigue). An enemies conditions and the party's conditions would be given more readily due to the lack of a fatigue metre getting in the way.

It just kind of feels like Avatar leant a little too hard in the non-narrative direction to appease to D&D fans for combat. I just wanted to confirm i wasn't alone in this thinking.


r/MagpieGames • • Jan 29 '23

PLEASE SOMEEONE AT MAGPIE

0 Upvotes

A jojo's ttrpg would kill and I've been saying this for years now I just want to make my own stand.


r/MagpieGames • • Nov 30 '21

What if Magpie Games made a Naruto TTRPG?

9 Upvotes

They already made a Avatar game and I absolutely loved the play test and cannot wait for the official release. But I believe if Magpie chooses to do so, they can make a Naruto RPG correctly. Especially with the success of Avatar. What do you guys think?


r/MagpieGames • • Aug 30 '21

For Those Waiting on Urban Shadows 2E...

24 Upvotes

They just announced an estimated timeline, including expected delays...

Despite our best efforts to get everything ready, a PDF release in September will be difficult to meet. We still have some final writing to do, and we’re still waiting on art for the final book. This means we’re looking at a more realistic timeline of early Winter for the PDF and printing in early next year. We may still have the book to print in 2021, but we’ll keep you posted as we move forward.

One quick note: COVID has had a dramatic effect on paper supplies and global shipping. We are working to make sure we have everything in order to avoid production delays, and we’ll let you know as soon as we know about any problems. We just want to make sure everyone is aware that this is an unprecedented time for game production, but we’re on top of it!

This is completely normal, not only for Magpie but for many Kickstarters I've backed. I think I even stated in another Reddit post, that I expected the PDF in late Fall and the hardcopy in January or February.

Still looking forward to this very much, and it's always preferable to wait for quality content.


r/MagpieGames • • Nov 12 '20

urban shadows Urban Shadows 2E AMA with Mark Diaz Truman

35 Upvotes

Hello!

Mark Diaz Truman (@trumonz) from Magpie Games here. I am the designer and author of several tabletop roleplaying games, including Cartel, Urban Shadows: 1st Edition, Root: The RPG, and Zombie World. I'm here to answer questions about game design, our upcoming project Urban Shadows: 2nd Edition (Kickstarting now!), or anything else that you want to ask!

I’m definitely excited to talk about the new edition of Urban Shadows! Our team is creating a new experience with Urban Shadows 2E while keeping the feel and heart of the first edition. With upgraded moves and playbooks, new playbooks, city hubs, and more, Urban Shadows 2E promises intense supernatural politics within the heart of an unrelenting metropolis.

The Kickstarter: https://bit.ly/us2e-ama

Magpie Games: https://www.magpiegames.com

UPDATE: Thank you so much for joining us for our AMA! We had a blast answering your questions!


r/MagpieGames • • May 29 '23

Root RPG distinction between armor, shields, and other equipment

5 Upvotes

Hello!

I have a couple of things that I'm confused about today, mostly concerning wear.

Here is the text that has caused confusion for me:

"Characters in a fight can absorb injury on their armor or shield, marking wear on the equipment to reduce the injury harm they suffer on a one-for-one basis."

Questions:

  1. Is absorbing injury limited to only shields and armor, or all equipment? i.e. could you absorb injury on your sword or axe?

  2. How does this interact with something like the Heavy Bludgeon tag? The tag allows a character to expend an exhaustion to ignore the enemy's armor, but does that mean it can still be absorbed on a shield?

  3. Can a character use Wreck Something on a piece of equipment that another character is holding? Wreck something seems stronger than cleaving, and cleaving is limited to defenses, so is there any reason a PC can't wreck a NPC's sword mid fight?

Thank you!


r/MagpieGames • • Mar 06 '25

urban shadows Urban Shadows Now Available

30 Upvotes

The city hungers? Will you feed it?

The highly anticipated second edition of Urban Shadows is now available for purchase on the Magpie Games webstore, DriveThruRPG, and in local game stores all over the world!

Urban Shadows is an urban fantasy tabletop roleplaying game in which vampires, faeries, hunters, wizards, and more all fight to carve out a piece of the slums and skyscrapers alike, trading the only currency that matters on the city’s dark streets—Debt.

This new edition of Urban Shadows contains:

  • 12 unique character playbooks, each tuned to put your characters at the center of an urban fantasy story driven by allegiances, debts, and status

  • 4 supernatural Circles—Mortalis, Night, Wild, and Power—whose nightly politics fill the city with dramatic twists and intriguing NPCs

  • Clearly-defined mechanics that push the fiction forward every time a player rolls the dice, advancing your group’s tale at every turn

  • Detailed advice for the Master of Ceremonies, the player running the game, including 2 city guides—Chicago and Santiago—packed with story hooks

  • All-new city mechanics for backroom deals and faction play that make the nightly politics of the city real for players and NPCs alike

In addition to the 300+ page core rulebook, you can find a variety of new Urban Shadows accessories, including a deluxe version of the core book, a MC screen, custom dice, journal packs, pins, and more. Don’t miss your chance to take urban fantasy back to the streets!

The choice is yours. The city awaits.


r/MagpieGames • • Jul 11 '23

MASK: A NEW GENERATION- Influence

6 Upvotes

Question about Influence and its relation to NPC's. The text says that by default adults have influence over the PC's, and since a fair number of villains could be assumed to be adults, I would think that would mean that villains have influence over the PC's. To a certain degree it makes sense that the villains would be able to mess with the ideas and ideals that the heroes are developing, but in regards to the +1 to rolls that characters are supposed to get when they possess influence over someone, how does that work with the villains? My understanding of the game platform was that the GM never really rolls for anything, and that everything the villains and other NPC's do is in response to the PC's.