r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Apr 26 '24

Discussion Am I the only one who’s okay with no magical boys?

6 Upvotes

I hear a lot of magical girl fans say they want magical boys but in my opinion that kinda misses the point. magical girls are supposed to be hyper feminine super hero’s

Are there some hyper feminine males? Of course but let’s be real girls and women are far more likely to embrace said aesthetic

What do you guys think?


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Sep 08 '25

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ What do you think of trans magical girls? Do you think there is a chance we'll see more of them in the future?

26 Upvotes

I know magical girl anime doesn't seem to shy away from showcasing sexual minorities, different form of gender expressions and sometimes offer commentary on expectations related to it (ie: Revolutionary Girl Utena). We even have magical boys and magical girls who turn into buff guys (Magical Girl Ore) However when it comes to transgender people there isn't much to see. The only example I can think of is Kiyoharu Suirenji from Magical Girl Site. Aside from her the closest thing we get is a guy turning into a magical girl: LaPucelle from Magical Girl Raising Project. I think this is a topic worth explore it, while I don't mind it, if magical trans girls only appear in darker shows (I like watching dark magical girl anime)I kind of wish there was more of it.


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Nov 22 '25

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ RWBY is not shounen/shonen ....its a magical girl cartoon

2 Upvotes

A common complaint I see from certain groups in the RWDE community is that Ruby is a bad protagonist and that Jaune would be better as the main character because Ruby doesn’t behave like a normal shonen protagonist, and that Jaune does, and that it would be more interesting to watch a show about Jaune getting better then of Ruby, who is already great at what she does.

There is a reason that Ruby is not like a shonen protagonist; it’s because she isn’t one, she’s a magical girl protagonist.

RWBY is a magical girl show, and trying to view it or dissect the show and point out its flaws while viewing it under a shonen lens will definitely lead to a lot of complaints that ultimately just show a lack of understanding of what the show is trying to be.

RWBY isn’t trying to tell a story of Ruby becoming the Greatest™ in her world; Ruby’s not trying to become the Best Hero, or the next Hokage, or the Pirate King. She’s not focused on gaining strength and power and becoming better and better. She wants to be a Huntress because she likes helping people, she wants to help protect everyone and anyone on Remnant because she’s a kind person. She literally called Purity Incarnate, and her Pure soul and personality is something continuously brought up. Magical Girl protagonists are known for being idealistic, and believing in hope and purity and the goodness in the world, which are all traits Ruby has. She’s idealistic to a fault, and even when she’s having the world’s cruelty beaten into her, she refuses to bend and accept that is how things should be  (Ruby v Roman/Neo is a great fight just for showcasing this aspect of Ruby’s personality).

“If anyone ever tells me it’s a mistake to have hope, well then, I’ll just tell them they’re wrong. And I’ll keep telling them till they believe. No matter how many times it takes.” – Madoka Kaname

“We've all lost something, and I've seen what loss can do to people. But if we gave up every time we lost, then we'd never be able to move forward.” – Ruby Rose

RWBY is a story about Ruby and her friends protecting their world from the forces of evil, and vile monsters, and doing so with the power of their friendship and love for others, along with kicking a lot of monster ass (and if you’re going to argue that RWBY having fight scenes makes it shonen and that magical girl shows don’t have any fight/action sequences..... actually watch a magical girl show)


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Apr 12 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ If Netflix made a Live Action Sailor Moon series who would you cast? Here’s my bad attempt lol

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Sep 10 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ i've seen a lot of person saying that madoka magika ruin magical girl gender because it cause a lot of new dark series to appears but i never seing any of them

1 Upvotes

first sorry if it's not really the place to ask this question but i dont know where to ask else and i'm sorry if it's not clear too i don't really speak english and i did'nt watch the new madoka magika movie so dont spoil me

so like i said in the title for the number of time i hears this is surprising but honestly i can only think of like two show that could be call "dark"

first their is "magical girl site" and this one well it's the very definition of edginess and horrible stuff for horrible stuff but still create a big meme thats his unffortualy mostly used for mysogine joke that already was bad but became really dark when you know from where it's from

second it a little bit of a stretch because it's a ecchi comedy about bdsm magical girl it is "gushing over magical girl" i've seen people call it dark but for me it's fall in the same category of "Dxd high school" why are they sexualising 15 years old girl or even younger, seriously why ?

honestly it's not much so what are the other show that are like that because honestly i'm curious of why i see this take so often but other than these two i can think about any show that are dark


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Oct 10 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰General | Misc꒱⊹ Can they reset the timeline?

0 Upvotes

Can irl magical girls reset the timeline


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • May 31 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ Anyone else find lore episodes of magical girl shows boring?

Post image
0 Upvotes

A pattern I’ve noticed about myself is how I find episodes where the girls are just doing whatever and having fun to be so much more entertaining than the ones dedicated to the storyline.

The only exceptions I can think about for me is the first season of sailor moon, winx club and Lolirock (for Lolirock, the lore episodes were much better)


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Nov 21 '25

✨ ⁞ ⊹꒰Fluff | Meme꒱⊹ Magical Girls Club: "There's a boy in the club!"

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Sep 05 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ Is it just me, or the Madoka Magica outfits is... questionable..

0 Upvotes

For a long time I've loved the story of madoka magica, I've liked the anime for a long time but I dont think I can really ignore much anymore...?

I'm not gonna say that the original TV series was entirely sexualized, but I did question Mami in some scenes where I feel like it subtly focuses on her chest and legs.

I tried not to question it too much, but as the story progressed on and with more magical girls being created I saw more girls in magia exerda... and noticed a lot of characters who are 13... to 16 etc were dressed in underwear or have their chest almost showing? There was this one 13 year olds outfit that I really am confused where the symbolism in a lot of these outfit is?

I seen a lot of people saying it doesn't harm anyone or they are just fictional characters and I feel that it excuses the people who make these characters or how others see children.

Regardless if it's fiction these people draw and potray characters as children and put presumably fan service on these characters I believe that says more about the people doing this than anything.

Like even the target audience is older teens to older men... im just quite confused as to why we are targeting these children into these outfits to these older boys??? That feels really weird.


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Mar 27 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ Am I the only one who is concerned for/doesn’t like love blast girls?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Oct 13 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ WHAT WAS THE LORE OF GLITTER FORCE!?!?!

0 Upvotes

im planning to do a dnd campain about glitter force, but i didnt watch glitter force and now i can't watch it since it left netfiex so sploilers are fine (NO I WILL NOT GET CRUNCHIROLL SINCE IDK IF GLITTER FORCE IS ON CRUNCHY ROLL)

DO WHATCHA WILL


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Sep 24 '26

✨ ⁞ ⊹꒰OC Art | Story꒱⊹ Drawn an magical girl with the powerlifter physique... Opinions?.. (Artwork and character design by me)

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Apr 16 '25

Birthday Happy Birthday to the young sweets scientist, Cure Custard!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Jul 14 '25

✨ ⁞ ⊹꒰Blog | Talk꒱⊹ ꉂ(˵˃ ᗜ ˂˵) who wants to be besties!!

0 Upvotes

HALLLOOOO!! im yuyu/vivi/moe-chan and i love the magical girl genre!! (as a matter of fact i am one my self :3) im 4teen and wish to become a vtuber one day(my togo saying is trow bricks at the ped*philes)!! i was just wondering if there's any other magical girl fans my age here!! honestly i juust want someone to fangirl over cute animes and mangas!! one of personal faves is magical Girl Raising Project!! oh and madoka magica!! :3


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Jun 15 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ New webtoon chapter out

Post image
2 Upvotes

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/marigold/list?title_no=1037293

Lemme know what you think yo 🙏
Getting closer to a full transformation 👀


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Sep 11 '25

✨ ⁞ ⊹꒰OC Art | Story꒱⊹ My Idea For A PreCure Series

Post image
0 Upvotes

The name is "Princess" PreCure since the main gang is all males & their magical forms are them in dresses.

(Also Baldy is pronounced Blade {IDK how to say it since his name is Bucket in Spanish}.)

Basically Baldy accidentally finds his magical helper who's a clown named Squeakers. I rather not explain much but I'll try to work on the rest later.


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Apr 29 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ Apologizing for Yesterday's Actions

12 Upvotes

I would like to apologize for my previous post from yesterday, the one about me wanting to write magical girls despite me not being Japanese.

Someone on the other magical girl subreddit said that "American magical girls aren't real magical girls" or something along those lines, claiming that "Americans need to be original and create original stories". And that hurt me, since I'm American that loved magical girls and liked making magical girl-inspired stories. Looking back, all those replies I made to them sounded like I had a victim mentality, even if that wasn't what I intended. And I cannot look back at those replies without feeling the need to vomit, because why did I word my comments like THAT. I sounded so privileged that it makes me feel embarrassed.

And what did I do when I saw those comments? MAKE AN ENTIRE POST ABOUT ME WORRYING THAT I WAS "COLONIZING MAGICAL GIRLS" 💀. I acted emotionally, not logically. I genuinely thought that making the aforementioned post was something I needed to do to help get those worries out of my head, but as it turns out, IT WASN'T, and it sunk my reputation badly, and it made people upset and frustrated.

I didn't think my previous post would upset that many people, but it did, and I'm sorry. I would also like to apologize for sounding manipulative and sounding like I have a victim mentality. I was hoping to get some sort of feedback, but I didn't go about it in a good way, and it made people believe that I was genuinely being manipulative and having a victim complex (And none of those people knew who I was, so they had a right to believe that I was being manipulative or having a victim complex, even if I wasn't). While my intentions were good, the way I acted wasn't. I genuinely thought I was being "humble" by not wanting to piss off other people, but that completely backfired and I ended up hurting others in the end.

While I do not expect people to forgive me for my actions, I do wish for people to understand where I'm coming from, and take me accountable. I might distance myself from the magical girl fandom and avoid watching magical girl media in general after all of this, because I feel like I cannot trust myself around those without getting myself into further trouble and possibly even causing harm to others. Additionally, I'll probably just get flashbacks to that controversy, and not be able to enjoy magical girls the way I used to.

It was not cool for me to act the way I did, and it disappoints me greatly that I let myself act that way, which was what my 2026 NEW YEAR'S RESOLUTIONS told me NOT to do. I messed up, badly, and I cannot let myself get away with this. And just so you know, I'm almost 18, so it feels extra shitty for me to let myself act so impulsively and do something that I'd regret severely at MY BIG AGE, I'm practically an adult, so why am I acting so impulsively like a kid? Once again, I am sorry for what I've done. And I apologize for how I treated all of you.

NOTE: This is a repost of a post I attempted to make yesterday, but it got deleted for being too recent. I feel like I cannot move on without making a public post that holds me accountable. I'm not the best at writing apologies (or writing at all tbh), so I tried to make sure my post here didn't sound like self victimizing.


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • May 17 '25

Discussion On whether Madoka is for girls or not. (A suggestion on why Madoka's extra material and merchandise is...like that.)

2 Upvotes

The entire discussion on whether Madoka is a show aimed for girls or not due to some of its extra material and merchandise being fanservicey irks me; not only due to the fact that it ignores that women can be perverts too (Ume Aoki has made some... interesting comments towards some female characters), but because there's a huge factor that I feel everyone in the discussion seems to miss: Anime Otakus.

Anime Otakus are the ones buying the merchandise of the series. They're the ones going to cons and making fan material. They can be any gender, and most of them are adults (er, they have money at least). The relationship between certain anime and their fans are extremely important, so anime sometimes services those fans. It's not too uncommon for this to happen.

Madoka got a burst of popularity and has a sect of Otaku fans (The show was also made by some Otaku as well) so... the extra material services those fans. Not to mention, the entire first half of Rebellion is fanservice as well- just not perverted.

It doesn't matter if its for guys or girls, it matters if it's for Otaku. If its for Otaku, then its going to have fanservice, whether it is characters in skimpy outfits or doing something that the fanbase wants them to do, and most extra merchandise is for Otaku.

I mean, I'm not into this type of this thing either but even I noticed it when I used to like Madoka. In fact, the early 2000s and 2010s was massive on otaku culture and fanservice.

Anyways, the PSP game was the best thing to come out of the franchise.


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Oct 08 '25

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ Is Lyrical Nanoha Mahou Shojo for boys? NSFW

0 Upvotes

So I've been watching Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha over the past couple days. I'm 8 episodes in and I'm about to show it to my best friend and bf. I do like the show, a lot. It feels like if someone said "Hey, let's do that Cardcaptor shit but give it some...stakier...stakes". And it's an element of the show I like a lot. It moves quickly and it feels like we're always doing something to move the plot forwards. I was absolutely floored when I found out the first season is only 13 episodes, I thought it'd be 24 which was why the pacing was throwing me like "damn we're just go go going"! I think Nanoha reminds me so much of Sakura cause she's so sweet and caring but firm and set in her convictions. But I'm no fool and I was aware going in that the show is a spinoff of one of those fucky eroge visual novels. That alone gives me my answer to my posted question though the transformation sequence and the hot springs episode were enough to cement it for me. Though if nothing else, it feels like the fanservice is mercifully brief and for that I'm thankful. But I'm curious what y'all think about it being more a "boys" show than one for young girls.


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Mar 22 '26

🎀 ⁞ ⊹꒰Discussion꒱⊹ [Rant] Was Nabu the best character of Winx Club? I have my dobuts:

0 Upvotes

Introduction

One of the most popular, beloved characters in Winx Club is Nabu, Aisha's first love interest and the only heroic character who permanently died. So many fans consider him the best love interest, the best character (or at least one of the best), his relationship with Aisha is considered the best romance in the show, and many believe that Rainbow killing Nabu was a huge mistake. In a nutshell, Nabu is for Winx Club what Uncle Iroh is for Avatar: The Last Airbender.

Nonetheless, I dislike Nabu. Not only I consider him the worst written character in the entire WinxVerse (even Braffilius is less terribly-written than Nabu, and I'm not taking my words back), I genuinely believe Nabu was the worst thing that happened to Winx Club as a franchise. Yes, Nabu's creation and existence did more damage to the franchise and the fandom than:

  • 4Kids involvement in the IP.

  • The shitty CGI used for seasons 5 and 6.

  • The Butterflix dance in season 7.

  • The hideous artsyle used for season 8.

  • The Netflix live-action.

  • The ugly slop reboot.

Before explaining why I dislike Nabu, and why I consider his existence to have left a negative impact in the series, it's important to remember some details about him.

Who was Nabu?

Nabu was Aisha's first love interest. Aisha made her debut in the second season of Winx Club. Since she was single during the entire season, a boyfriend was created for the following season. Keep in mind season 3 had 26 episodes.

Aisha and Nabu's romance was set up to be an arranged marriage (remember this for later). The arranged marriage suplot began at the end of season 3 episode 9, when Aisha, in tears because her life was ruined (her words, not mine), told the Winx that her parents announced she will marry a man named Nabu due to the traditions of Andros.

Nabu was present in the following chapters:

  • Ep 11: This was his physical debut, with him spying on the Winx for some reason.

  • Ep 12: His first speaking role happens here, and he shows interest on Aisha, whom he spies with a telescope. Remember this for later.

  • Ep 18: Here happens his proper introduction. After getting caught by Aisha, who was annoyed over the marriage and the fact that one mysterious guy was stalking her (and the Winx, but showing special interest on her), Nabu presents himself as Ophir (which is a fake identity).

  • Ep 21: Nabu (pretending to be Ophir) is caught again, and here's when Aisha and he start knowing each other.

  • Ep 22: Nabu (pretending to be Ophir) tells more about his backstory.

  • Ep 23: Nabu reveals his actual identity and confesses his feelings.

  • Ep 26: Nabu helps Flora, Aisha, and Helia find the Specialists. Also, Aisha and Nabu kiss for the first time

So, in a season of 26 episodes, he has only appeared in 7 episodes (counting episodes 11 and 12) or 5 (not counting those two episodes). His only important appereances are in the last third of the season, and even then he's not present in all episodes of that last third.

After season 3, he appeared in Secret of the Lost Kingdom... but only as a cameo near the end of the film, and he lacks spoken dialogues.

Most of his screentime comes from Magical Adventure (which takes place after SOTLK and before season 4, but the Winx use Believix because Rainbow prioritized selling dolls over plot coherence) and season 4. The first episode Nabu appeared in that season was episode 4; since then, the writers showed us how perfect their Aisha and Nabu were as a couple, and how Nabu himself was the ultimate fantasy boyfriend... until, in season 4 episode 24, Nabu dies after sacrificing his own life to save the Earth Fairies.

Why I dislike Nabu?

Many remember Nabu as a well-written character... except that's not true. In fact, he's even a bigger Mary Sue than Bloom (NOTE: When I say Bloom is a Mary Sue, I'm referring to Bloom since season 4; she wasn't a Mary Sue in seasons 1-3).
Here's why:

  • For starters, his backstory is completely irrelevant for him; you could remove it, and he would even improve as a character because of it. This is bad because a backstory's purpose is to explain why X character has certain personality traits, beliefs, fears, motivations, and so on... something Nabu's backstory fails miserably.

    • His backstory is more or less the same one as Aisha (being raised in a rich family, with very controlling parents who make all the choices for them, and barely had pals at all; Aisha's friend being a girl who taught her freedom and how to dance... but who was forced to leave her; Nabu only had the company of some guards who taught him martial arts). However, for some reason, Nabu has none of Aisha's character flaws; in fact, he's devoid of character flaws. What we have, instead, is a guy overloaded with positive traits (wise, patient, supporting, social, friendly).

      • Whereas Aisha's backstory resulted in a coherent and plausible development of virtues (rebelliousness, dancing as a hobby, valuing freedom) and flaws (she's impulsive, she's afraid of being alone, has difficulty trusting others, and given her social skills are a bit lacking, she developed an "I can take care of myself" attitude even whe she does need help) that make Aisha a well-written character, Nabu has no character flaws, and thus, no opportunities for conflicts nor character growth. While developing the exact same flaws is boring, he should have developed at least one of these flaws.

    • How could Nabu be so mature and wise if he was 18 years old and his childhood was so restrictive? He gave Riven a perfect romantic advice, when his only relationship was his current one, and was an arranged marriage. And how can be so competent when his parents decided everything for him?

  • Nabu's pressence leads to other characters acting completely out of character, which is a common Mary Sue trait.

    • He won the hearts of Aisha and Riven pretty fast. Riven is the lone wolf who hates teammwork, and Aisha is distrustful of others; how can these two characters become attached to Nabu so easily?

    • Aisha was completely out of character whe she was dating Nabu; this is something I'll explain later.

    • Moreover, when Nabu died, everyone cried dramatically, despite not having a very deep relationship because he was only there some months (compared to the rest of the main characters). For example, Roxy, who never had any important interaction on-screen with him, cried as if she had lost her father.

  • Aisha and Nabu's love story, despite being overrated by the fandom, is actually one of the worst couples in the show:

    • When it comes to the arranged marriage... the fact that both characters agree with it becomes detrimental for both in terms of characterization and internal logic:

      • Nabu wanted not to obey his parents at 24/7 and, instead, desired making his own choices. This could have been interesting, because it would have given Nabu something to angst about, and would have shown he's just as flawed as any other human... but in the end, he accepted to marry Aisha. Which renders the entire deal useless, because he ends up allowing his parents chose his job and his home.

      • Also, Aisha accepting to marry Nabu, despite many episodes earlier saying she didn't want to, is out of character. She's rebellious and wants to make her own choices; why would she accept her parents taking away the freedom to choose her own guy? The only plausible way of making Aisha's choice not be OOC would have been because of Andros' sake (she cares for her kingdom), but that's not what happens.

    • While they were dating, neither of them seem to become a better versions of themselves... but how can they do that if their relationship is perfect, and if Nabu himself is flawless? If anything, this love story only brought up the worst of Aisha:

      • Before meeting "Ophir", Aisha literally wanted to ban all men from her life, including her father, because she was angry over her arranged marriage..

      • In season 4, she ignored her mission to protect Roxy (the very reason why the Winx were on Earth) in order to have dates with Nabu.

      • In general, she acts more like a childish fangirl, to the point of speaking in flowery language ("Oh my Nabu"), rather than Nabu's adult fiance.

      • After Nabu died, she desired revenge (understandable), but joined Nebula and broke her friendship with the Winx (not understandable at all; thanks God Aisha apologized and the six Winx became friends again).

  • Nabu brings nothing new to the table, he sometimes feel redundant:

    • He's a wizard, but unlike other wizards, who at least have character-specific gimmicks (such as Valtor's marks, Duman's shapeshifting, etc.), most of his magical stuff is done, or could have been done by other characters.

      • Can he fly? The Winx and the Trix can fly too.

      • Can he duplicate himself? Darcy can too.

      • Is he a martial artist wizard, making him a magic knight? Aisha has used her Morphix to create weapons and melee with them; she's the closest Winx to the magic knight archetype.

      • Besides, the Specialists have a peaceful guy who is also the grandson of Saladin the wizard: Helia. Why create a new male character to be a wizard when Helia's magical potential could have been explored and fleshed out?

      • Could he repair a car in season 4 episode 5? Tecna could have done it, since she's the Fairy of Technology.

  • The fact that Nabu stalked Aisha, and when he was caught, lied about his identity. He said he wanted to meet the woman whom he was going to marry... but why isn't he being honest? Why doesn't tell her from the get go that he's her fiance? After all, they ended up talking about it and, coincidentially, they had almost everything in common. What annoys me the most is the reaction of the fandom, and the double standards:

    • Some fans aren't willing to forgive Sky because he cucked Bloom and Diaspro at the same time. Which is understandable, because cheaters are scum.

    • Some fans dislike Riven because his relationship with Musa is toxic, and say Riven is too rude and sexist for her. Which is understandable, even though Musa is just as toxic as Riven in the relationship.

    • The fandom's reaction over Nabu stalking Aisha? crickets.

    • This one is more personal for me, because it's about Nex (Aisha's love interest in seasons 6-8), and it exposes how hypocrital many Winxers can be. Because most Winxers (and more specifically, Aisha/Nabu shippers) hate Nex, the same untrue, bad-faith arguments (Nex is a misogynistic 2.0) are used to promote an agenda about Nabu being the boyfriend Aisha deserved, about how Rainbow shouldn't have killed him, and about how Aisha shouldn't date Nex because, according to them, he treats her like crap. Now, whether you like Nex or not (especially how and when he's introduced) is up to you, but the "Nex is a misogynistic Riven 2.0." narrative, despite being false, always pops out during fact-twisting conversations, so I want to adress this:

      • In season 7 episode 8, Aisha and Flora got very stubborn about wanting their respective Fairy Animals to get along. Because of their stubborness, Nex said "Just like a girl, insists things go their way whether it makes sense or not" and insulted Aisha's Fairy Animal. Yes, his comment was sexist (he needed to say "just like a girl"), but it annoys me how people says Nex is a misogynistic monster who secretly wants to murder Aisha just because he made one sexist comment, yet they wanted Aisha to marry with a guy who stalked her, made her feel uncomfortable, and lied to her fucking face. Besides, for the people who complained about Nex's sexist comment: The Winx also made a lot of sexist comments towards men in season 7, yet none of you are saying the Winx are misandrists who hate all men. Double standards, anyone?

In a nutshell, Nabu is a poorly-written character because his backstory is irrelevant to his characterization, his mere existence makes other characters act out of character, he stalked and lied Aisha (yet none of those things are portrayed negatively by the narrative), his romance with her is rushed and incoherent, and he's a redundant character.

Why has Nabu become popular within the fandom?

Judging by the fandom's current views on him, it seems Nabu has always been a very popular character, and Rainbow killed him because:

  • They didn't want him to be more popular than Sky.

  • They're idiots.

  • They were malicious monsters who desired traumatizing children.

  • They wanted to troll the fandom.

Except Nabu wasn't actually a popular character. This makes sense because he was the most recent main character to have been presented; of course he couldn't surpass more recurring characters such as Sky.

Nabu became a popular character after his death. But why his death made Winxers turn him into a sacred cow?
Two words: Emotional manipulation.

Nabu is a perfect character, a perfect boyfriend, and his romance with Aisha was perfect.

Nevertheless, this perfection doesn't make sense once you start thinking. But the target audience of Winx Club were children, they just need to feel joy when watching cartoons. Thus, Nabu being written as a wish fullfillment character, and making Aisha's love story with him so unrealistically flawless, was made with one purpose: to make Nabu's death more shocking and more heartbreaking. After all, when two characters die permanently in a story, would you cry for the asshole, villainous one; or for the virtuous, angelic one?

But why was Nabu chosen by the writers to die? Why killing him instead of, say, Sky or Riven?

Because he was the safest character for the writers to kill off:

  • Sky? He's Bloom's boyfriend, not to mention he's Iginio's favourite Specialist. His death is a huge no-no.

  • Brandon? He's Sky's best friend, and the boyfriend of Stella (the second most popular Winx). Killing him is also a no-no.

  • Riven? He's the bad boy love interest, the writers need him if they want to write Musa/Riven relationship drama.

  • What about Timmy and Helia? While not as popular as the other three, they were fleshed-out enough, and had enough screentime, it would be a waste killing either of them.

  • But Nabu? He was the most recent boyfriend, and the most underdeveloped one to boot. He was, by a far margin, the safest character to kill.

Was Nabu actually supposed to be a recurring character?

Why was Nabu killed?

Before his death, he wasn't a popular character, and Aisha/Nabu weren't the most popular couple, as I said before. Maybe Rainbow killed Nabu in order to boost his popularity, or maybe they wanted to boost Aisha's popularity instead.

I wouldn't even be surprised if Rainbow had always created Nabu so he could be killed off easily.

After all, Nabu has never been designed to be a recurring character.

I mean, his lack of character flaws, his backstory being so irrelevant and contradictory to his current personality, his relationship with Aisha was so perfect, and the fact we all know they were going to marry each other might have been hints. Hints pointing out that Nabu wasn't going to be a recurring character.

Do you remember Nabu's debut? He made his debut in season 3, which had 26 episodes; and only appeared in 7 episodes (counting episodes 11 and 12) or 5 (not counting those two episodes). His only important appereances are in the last third of the season, and even then he's not present in all episodes of that last third. Also, his only appereance in Secret of the Lost Kingdom was near the end of the film as a cameo, and he lacked spoken dialogues.

This is because season 3 was originally going to be the last season of Winx Club, and Secret of the Lost Kingdom was originally written to be the finale; yes, they changed their minds in the middle of the development of SOTLK, but Rainbow originally planned to stop after season 3 and SOTLK.

This explains why Nabu appears so late in the show, why he's so perfect, and why Aisha/Nabu is so rushed. Aisha didn't have a boyfriend in season 2, so Rainbow felt they needed to give her one in season 3... except that was the last season (at first), so they couldn't develop the boyfriend properly. The solution? Make the boyfriend unrealistically flawless, without even trying to write a coherent backstory for him, and pair him with Aisha so, by the end of the show, we could all know their romance would work. Thus, Nabu was born.

But Winx Club continued after SOTLK. What could Rainbow do afterwards? Aisha/Nabu were such a flawless couple, and Nabu was devoid of flaws. This would result in plots with no conflicts, and stories need conflicts to be interesting. Their relationship would have become too boring. The writers could have given Nabu flaws retroactively... but it would have been out of character, since he wasn't designed to have flaws. Love triangles and relationship dramas would be cheap and contrived, not to mention they already introduced a Stella/Brandon/Mitzi love triangle in season 4. So, the writers chose to highlight Nabu's virtues and remember us how perfect Aisha/Nabu were for each other, and then kill him.

Copium and hypocrisy:

Nabu's death broke the fandom. In order to convince themselves that Nabu shouldn't have died, they took this piece of dialogue, and sticked with it:

Aisha: Will you take care of him [Nabu]?

Morgana: Until he wakes up again, you have my word.

The copium has two variants:

  1. "Nabu isn't dead, he's in a coma. Morgana said so!"

  2. "Nabu was originally in a coma, as Morgana said, and his death is the result of season 5 retconning Morgana's statement."

The thing is, Nabu was dead all along. He died in season 4 episode 24, and Morgana had never said he was in a coma. The previous episode, as well as episode 24's first minutes, foreshadowed this was going to happen. Additionally, after Nabu died, everyone referred to him in past tense ("Nabu was your friend", "Nabu wouldn't have wanted that"), which wouldn't make too much sense if he was actually in a coma. And, on top of this, Morgana said that Nabu gave his life for the Earth Fairies (season 4 episode 26).

Why wasn't Morgana more explicit, and said, "Nabu died"? Because Winx Club is a show for children... but let's try to find in-universe reasons why Morgana told Aisha that she [Morgana] has accepted to take care of Nabu until he woke up again?

  • Aisha asking Morgana "Will you take care of Nabu?" could have meant "Will you take care of Nabu's corpse?".

  • Morgana saying "Until he wakes up again, you have my word" was just a rethorical answer. Nabu couldn't wake up again because he died. And since Nabu couldn't wake up again, Morgana was going to take care of him.

But I'm not done yet.

A promotional image of Winx Club's season 5's DVDs in Serbia showed early titles for the second half of the season. And the early title for episode 15 was "Nabu's Return."

Some people are using this as "evidence" of Nabu's confirmed death being a retcon... but I digress, due to the following reasons:

  1. These are Serbian DVDs. Winx Club's home country is Italy.

  2. Do you remember the "Bloom, Fairy of Wind" mistake caused by Mattel's dolls? "Nabu's Return" might have been a similar mistake.

  3. Even if the name wasn't a mistake, it might have been a placeholder name for whatever reason, it could have been a red herring (suggesting that Nabu's return might have been possible... only to confirm that Nabu is dead and buried, and can't go back), it could have been anything.

And speaking of Nabu's return:

Before the reboot was made, many Winxers wished Nabu got revived so he could marry Aisha, and they could have their happily ever after ending... while complaining about Valtor's resurrection, and complaining about Bloom bringing Daphne back.
There's a lot to unpack here, so be patient:

  • I despise the idea of Nabu being resurrected just to appease fans who could never let him go. Bringing Nabu back to death would undermine his sacrifice, would make Aisha's grief pointless, would throw stakes and consequences out of the window (what's dangerous about fighting evil wizards when death is just a slap in the wrist?), would send a bad message to the show's target audience (yeah, let's make kids never face an uncomfortable aspect of life that everyone has to deal with), and would be bad writing.

  • However, just like how I hate the idea of Nabu coming back, I would hate the idea of Valtor, Daphne, and Musa's mom being resurrected... Oh shit, Valtor and Daphne were revived. But I want to talk about this:

    • Yes, I do agree Valtor being revived for season 8, and his demise being retconned to boot, was garbage.

    • Yes, I do agree Musa being unable to revive her deceased mother with the Sirenix wish, but Bloom getting to bring Daphne back, was garbage and hypocrital.

    • Yes, I do agree Daphne's death being retconned in order to allow Bloom to give her a corporeal body again, is garbage, hypocrital, and an insult to Daphne's tragic sacrifice.

    • And because of that, complaining about these three cases, while asking the writers to revive Nabu, is extremely hypocrital.

  • Some Winxers called out how, when Nabu died, Bloom didn't use her healing powers to save him. Yes, I do agree this is bad writing, since Bloom has been shown using the power of Believix to heal people (and even before Believix existed, Bloom could heal people as early as season 2)... but doesn't use it when it's needed the most. Nevertheless, I want to bring this up, since nobody has mentioned it: If Bloom not saving Nabu with Believix is bad writing and unfair, then the Winx (Aisha included) not using Fairy Dust to save Nabu's life is bad writing and unfair too. After earning Enchantix, the Winx could use Fairy Dust, which can counter any dark spell, miniaturize the Winx (except Bloom in season 3 and SOTLK, because her Enchantix was incomplete), and heal people. Moreover, the Winx can also use Fairy Dust when transformed in Believix fairies... but only used it once, and it was for miniaturization. Why none of the Winx, not even Aisha, used Fairy Dust to heal Nabu before it was too late?

    • Here's the answer: Because Fairy Dust was one hell of a story breaker power, as it had no limitations and no counterparts (it can dispell all dark/negative emotion-fueled spells, but a counterpart that can dispel all light/positive emotion-fueled spells doesn't exist) Deus ex machina is the best way to describe Fairy Dust. So, the writers "forgetting" Fairy Dust's existence except when miniaturization is needed, is just the way Rainbow admits they fucked up when designing such OP ability.

The end

That's the end of my rant. I just wanted to get these thoughts off my chest, since I was tired of reading the same stuff about Nabu.

A lot of Winxers will crucify me after reading this rant


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Jan 20 '24

Discussion anyone else think precure is overhyped?

0 Upvotes

so, i recently rewatched heartcatch precure for the first time in a few years and i'm honestly not sure what the hype is about. don't get me wrong i used to love it when i was a kid but as an adult i think it suffers from the same problems the 90s sailor moon anime did.

you can pretty much sum up a sailor moon/precure episode like this: a bunch of middle school girls are shown acting like morons and then we cut to the minute long transformation and underwhelming battle, repeat 50 times

what do you guys think?


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Jan 19 '24

Discussion I apologize for thinking Sailor Moon was more "girly" than Tokyo Mew Mew

1 Upvotes

I think I mainly just felt this for many reasons, but one of them is because of a reason that might sound shocking. There were some people on forums years ago that felt Sailor Moon was "too girly" (I'm not even sure if they gave it a chance), yet watched/read Tokyo Mew Mew and liked it. One of them even said she was a tomboy and ignored Sailor Moon due to thinking it was "girly", but watched/read Tokyo Mew Mew because of the animal powers


r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Jul 19 '23

Fluff | Meme Blue Reflection Meme. Ao Hoshizaki gives you this look, five minutes into Netflix and chill. While laying on the bed. Blue Reflection Sun Meme. Magical Girl Reflector. Anime, Game, School Uniform. Waifu.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MagicalGirlsCommunity • • Jun 26 '24

Fanworks Gushing over Wicked Magical Girls

4 Upvotes