568
u/Flyrpotacreepugmu Noxious Gearhulk Nov 13 '19
Watch them ban Gilded Goose and Hydroid Krasis and just leave all those alone...
204
1
u/neverstopgoinbigdick Nov 13 '19
I’ve heard so many idiots say this and more idiots keep repeating it
→ More replies (1)1
u/jojo558 Izzet Nov 14 '19
As an esper control player, I would be fine with that. Hydroid Krasis is the main card that I can't beat. But I understand that a meta dominated by oko and esper wouldn't be healthy so Oko probably has to go
→ More replies (5)1
u/send3squats2help Nov 17 '19
i would really like to play standard again.... is it too late to hope for teferi time raveler to be banned? 3feri, oko, and once would be enough for me... nissa is just annoying...
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (198)0
u/Harry_Smutter Nov 13 '19
Nahh. Krasis is fine. Just boot Oko and Nissa and the set will be fine. Those two cards are just too damn oppressive. Especially since they are almost always run in the same set. Gilded Goose won't get banned because that's a food staple card and it will make food decks basically nonexistent outside of something that has [[Cat Familiar]] and [[Witch's Oven]].
→ More replies (1)4
u/Ahayzo Nov 13 '19
Lol Nissa? Oppressive? Are you high?
Ban Oko and you fix all the things that are actually problematic. Not all the mistakes, because Veil and OUaT are still things, but everything that is actually a problem.
→ More replies (6)
52
u/jacobsredditusername Rakdos Nov 13 '19
“No changes in any formats”
35
u/appoplecticskeptic Nov 13 '19
In response I “stop playing any formats”.
→ More replies (1)10
1
71
u/Arkanim94 Timestream Nov 13 '19
Oko and veil are the one that will end up being banned, it's inevitable at this point.
15
u/justins_porn Nov 13 '19
Then I might actually start playing this game again...coming from a guy who has a full food deck. It's just no fun
13
2
→ More replies (2)1
u/SlapHappyDude Nov 13 '19
The fact both have gotten banned in other formats doesn't bode well for them
122
u/LargeNCharge86 Nov 13 '19
I'm gonna say Oko and veil.
62
u/ShapesAndStuff Vraska Scheming Gorgon Nov 13 '19
Saw people rooting for a Goose ban, which would be an interesting one imo.
If Wotc decides to double down on their obvious affinity for Oko I think we might see it.
Goose + Oko would be a game changer, but maybe too heavy a blow for Green? Not sure.I think while Veil is ridiculously good, I don't think it'd be as big of a problem if the crazy meta didn't make it a necessity in so many mainboards.
89
u/elHahn Nov 13 '19
Goose + Oko is just hysterics talking. We've yet to see anybody make a coherent argument, that goose would be oppressive without an stable food source.
137
u/ChiralWolf Nov 13 '19
Imagine people arguing that llanowar elves should be BANNED in standard because insert planeswalker in green is too strong. That's just insane to me.
52
u/BEEFTANK_Jr Nov 13 '19
It's not even Llanowar Elves. It's a one-time use Birds of Paradise. Without another food engine, the only future mana you get out of Goose is if you have empty mana going into your next turn anyway.
37
u/ChiralWolf Nov 13 '19
That's sort of my point. We've had amazing green cards like Nissa for awhile now at the same time as elves and there weren't issues. To think that the goose is somehow the problem when it is what it is while oko is still out there is ridiculous.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (5)9
u/Pigmy Nov 13 '19
That’s why I’m seeing a lot of jockeying for once upon a time to be banned as the cars that smooths out goose+oko and makes it an almost certainty
→ More replies (9)15
u/Ahayzo Nov 13 '19
Goose isn’t even oppressive with a stable food source. People calling for pretty much any ban besides Oko are just wrong, but anyone who even considers Goose is straight up delusional.
12
u/LoreWalkerRobo Nov 13 '19
straight up delusional.
Would you say that trying to get it banned is a... wild goose chase???
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (4)9
u/DonLindo Nov 13 '19
In an Oko-free food deck, the goose is your stable food source
25
u/elHahn Nov 13 '19
I mean - yeah.
But there's a difference between enabling a strategy and being oppressive.
33
u/dougdemaro Nov 13 '19
That's 2 mana a turn though being spent instead of adding +2 to a planeswalker. The goose isn't ramping if it's making food
12
u/BEEFTANK_Jr Nov 13 '19
Also, if you're at the point that you've got 2 spare mana going into your next turn to create a Food, you probably don't need a mana dork anymore anyway.
→ More replies (2)3
29
u/TheOnin Nov 13 '19
Goose without Oko is significantly worse. A birds of paradise that needs to recharge manually.
Veil just got banned in Pioneer, it's gonna continue oppressing blue/black strategies for as long as it's in rotation. An overpowered sideboard card is still overpowered.
→ More replies (3)4
u/Pigmy Nov 13 '19
Goose has uses from a generation perspective if you needed food, but most of those are kitchen table jank like troll king combo.
14
u/SputnikDX Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
CovertGoBlue who writes for SCG now and does YouTube shenanigans said that he'd be interested in a Paradise Druid ban alongside Oko. This was before Veil was Pioneer banned though. In fact Veil wasn't even mentioned.
But Veil is just too powerful of a card. It is sideboard exclusive but a few things:
The reason Noxious Grasp was mainboarded is because post-sideboard games were so difficult due to Veil of Summer.
It will continue Green's dominance if it remains unbanned since it makes two colors that can threaten it so much worse. White is generally bad at the moment and Red can't adequately deal with cards like Questing Beast and Nissa.
People downplaying the notion that Veil is a 1 mana Cryptic Command need to understand that, post sideboard, that really is exactly what it is. If you know your opponent is playing blue or black there's no reason not to bring in 4, and it stifles interaction so much since the punishment for playing into an opponents Veil is absurd, essentially two-for-oneing yourself for daring to try to deal with an immediate threat.
5
u/DilithiumFarmer Nov 13 '19
The fact that Veil already been banned in one format, might result it being banned in more formats. Veil is really overpowered and can completely shut a deck off
3
u/TheL0stK1ng Golgari Nov 13 '19
Goose and Oko would reduce Green's early ramp and protection. Leaving Nissa and the Hydras still allow for a late game recovery, and honestly paradise druid causes green to not lose much.
Losing OUaT cuts down on consistency, which isnt an issue if the deck is still busted. It just shaves off a couple of percentage points.
veil's removal would allow for counter play, which is always a good thing.
The more I think about it, the more I think Green is still a problem if only two cards are banned. Powerful late game isnt an issue if ramp and early game protection is bad. Early game ramp isnt bad if the late game payoff is weak. Consistency isnt bad of the overall power level is weaker than other colors. But the issue with green is that it is consistent. It does have powerful early game. And it does have good ramp into a powerful late game. So I would just ban Goose, OUaT, Oko, veil and hydra. Its extreme, but Greens overall power level in every aspect of the game is very high. It all needs to be decreased.
4
u/ShapesAndStuff Vraska Scheming Gorgon Nov 13 '19
Yep it's a tough call. Green is so versatile right now.
I'm mostly worried Wotc is gonna shy away from banning oko. We'll see soon enough..4
u/TheL0stK1ng Golgari Nov 13 '19
Understandable. Luckily, the data backs up the general consensus and they seem to understand their face of the expansion was just not properly vetted. If they dont ban oko, I think they'll have to ban a lot more cards to keep the community happy, and I can't see them banning more than 2 cards from any one color
7
u/Arkanim94 Timestream Nov 13 '19
Removing oko deprive green of their busted start and being able to dominate early, mid and late game with problematic planeswalker.
Veil is just a grave mistake that shouldn't have seen the light of the day in standard.
6
u/Forkrul Charm Jeskai Nov 13 '19
Veil is just a grave mistake that shouldn't have seen the light of the day in standard.
Veil shouldn't exist in any format. I'm willing to bet it will see bans in Modern/Legacy and be restricted in Vintage. If not this B&R, it will 100% be banned next one after any combo deck that can afford it splashes green for that anti-counterspell protection.
→ More replies (2)2
u/axw3555 Nov 13 '19
If they don’t ban Oko, I could easily see a copycat style “update” a few days later as people finally go “you know what, see you when he rotates”.
2
u/ShapesAndStuff Vraska Scheming Gorgon Nov 13 '19
What was the copycat update? Sorry, I'm not really up to date on anything outside of MTGA
5
u/Arkanim94 Timestream Nov 13 '19
During Aether revolt standard, it was wildly know that iff they didn't ban the copycat combo ([[felidar guardian]] + [[saheeli rai]] it would have dominated the next months of standard easily.
Come ban Monday, and copycat combo isn't banned, the Mtg community lost its shit because no one want to ear that splinter twin is too good for modern but A ok in standard.
Three days later, wizard posts this article.
You could heard the clown shoes from a mile.
→ More replies (2)4
u/axw3555 Nov 13 '19
A few years ago, they did the banned announcement and announced no changes. 3 or 4 days later, they put out an announcement banning Felidar Guardian (copy cat is the nickname for the Saheeli/Guardian infinite token combo that it was used in).
→ More replies (10)9
u/Pikathepokepimp Nov 13 '19
As someone who is still new to MTGA why veil? The hexproof and counter prevention? Do you think if it protected from different colors it would be an issue?
27
u/LargeNCharge86 Nov 13 '19
Personal opinion, I think it would be fine if it didn't draw a card. It's a one Mana counterspell that replaces itself, and it's already been banned in Pioneer format.
→ More replies (9)12
u/_dUoUb_ Nov 13 '19
The old card that is worse than veil on the hexproof aspect and didn't cantrips was played, idk why they made veil so fucking busted
→ More replies (1)15
u/ristoman Nov 13 '19
it protects your entire board and yourself, so it's super versatile. It fights counters, discard and spot removal. On top of that it also draws you a card, which is not a common thing for green. Green already has some pushed cards and veil invalidates all the main strategies used to fight green, and does so way too efficiently.
→ More replies (3)6
u/hGKmMH Nov 13 '19
Any time you can 2 for 1 you have generated a huge advantage. You only need to float one Mana, or have a charged goose on the board to do it. The current green decks are fast enough to win by turn 6. The only board wipes in standard either can't touch nissa lands, or will leave wolves up.
So you are punished for interacting. And if you wait long enough to wipe the board chances are you are dead. And even if you try to wipe the board there is a good chance shit will be left over.
→ More replies (4)5
u/soleyfir Nov 13 '19
It does too much for too little. If you're playing green, discard counters and unconditionnal removal are your worst ennemies and this card protects you against most of these effects while drawing you a card.
It's really the card draw that's the worst offender for a 1 mana card. It means it will never be a dead card against an opp playing blue/black because you can cycle it if need be and you will be able to 2 for 1 your opp for simply 1 mana, possibly wasting his turn at the same time. For a color that has so much ramp, dedicating one mana for a guaranteed 2 for 1 is nothing.
Had it been other colors it would have probably been much less of an issue indeed. Red removal is notoriously bad against green as it's dmg based and green tends to have big stuff/buffs. White removal is pretty neat but more expensive. These colors also don't have counters or discard effect, so it would cover less. And besides, red or white decks that want to control usually splash for blue and/or black to get the good tools.
So this card effectively counters the best answers to green and it does it with an upside for a cheap cost, guaranteeing that you'll trade it for both card and mana advantage. And with green having so many powerful cards on average right now, them being able to nullify with an upside the turn of a control player makes them all the more difficult to beat. Without Veil, blue/black based control would be a very good option to prey on green decks and stabilize the meta.
→ More replies (2)3
Nov 13 '19
Yes, I want Veil gone as well and I'm a green player. I just got my Murderous Rider bounced by Gruul Aggro lol.
Goose will be fine without Oko and Nissa has plenty answers and is abused by control with sweepers, greedy Nissa players can be punished easily.
A lot of people were bitching about OUAT needing to go, but I don't agree. Yes, it gives enormous consistency, but in terms of value added is a trade off in the 2 drop slot, because you have to cut sth (Assasin Trophies for instance). It's not impressive mid game when you have your engines running, so I would spare that card at least until next B&R to see how things settle.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Wargod042 Nov 13 '19
Doesn't OUAT let you cut a couple lands, actually? Don't remember the math.
4
Nov 13 '19
I think people play 24 lands with OUAT anyway - it's a waste to dig for the land when you can dig for Goose or Innkeeper
2
u/Deadbeathero Nov 13 '19
Yeah, if they go too hardcore on this ban green will be gutted for the rest of the season.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Quazifuji Nov 13 '19
I think they could ban Oko, Veil, and Once, and green decks would still be top tier. They might just have to share the tier with other colors.
I also think people are so unhappy with the meta right now that banning too much might be better than not banning enough. Kind of like when they banned 8 cards at once from Affinity and said normally they would be more cautious, but so many people were quitting over the deck's dominance they wanted to ban a ton to send a message (also even then Affinity survives those bans - admittedly most of those bans were just the artifact lands).
→ More replies (2)1
Nov 13 '19
I hope not veil, one of the only ways for me to deal with simic flash early for my late game deck.
1
15
u/jaasa Timmy Nov 13 '19
Probably longer than that since the bans won't be immediately applied to Arena, we're probably gonna have to wait another couple of days. :/
39
u/Zero-R Nov 13 '19
People seem to highly overvalue Nissa, yes she’s very strong but she’s 5 mana and has drawbacks.
Nissa and krasis were in standard before eldraine and were not oppressive.
I think the bans will be Oko, OUAT, and potentially Veil of Summer.
I don’t really get anyone who thinks oko won’t be banned. That card is absolutely too pushed and will not survive this banning.
5
u/TitaniumDragon Nov 14 '19
You have to remember that the people who cry about those cards are really bad at Magic.
Nissa and Hydroid Krasis aren't problematic.
Oko is just grossly undercosted. Once Upon a Time is in the same category.
2
u/beingmeltdown HOU Nov 13 '19
5 Mana on paper, sure. But let's not forget that she can often come out on turn 3, untap a land to create 2 more mana and shit out a 3/3. On turn 4 you have access to 12 mana. And shit out a 3/3 every turn.
18
u/Zero-R Nov 13 '19
And then when a wrath comes on turn 4 they lose at least 2 mana dorks and a land.
Allowing your lands to be destroyed easily is quite the drawback.
No one thought Nissa was a problem with llanowar elves in the format before rotation, other than OUAT adding to turn 3 consistency nothing has changed and no one thought she needed a ban then.
While I do agree she’s strong, I don’t think she needs to be banned when there are actually broken and severely pushed cards in the colour that enable more consistency and 1 card value engines.
→ More replies (3)1
u/SoFFacet Nov 14 '19
As someone who was on Nissa/Krasis from week 1 of Spark, I completely agree. It was a strong combo but it took weeks for the archetype to be recognized as a peer of Hero, Esper, Command, Friends, Red, etc.
What changed is that all of the rival decks rotated and Field was banned, meanwhile Simic received Oko Goose and OUAT.
53
u/nescorpius Nov 13 '19
After the last big tournaments with 69% of decks running oko and 70% decks running Once Uppon a Time, for sure both will be ban.
top 8 MCVI 100% G
other championchip top 8 over 80% G
Veil Of summer is a maybe cause pioneer
18
u/Forkrul Charm Jeskai Nov 13 '19
Veil Of summer is a maybe cause pioneer
I'm predicting Veil will see ban/restriction in ALL formats except Commander/Brawl.
→ More replies (3)7
u/SinibusUSG Nov 13 '19
Is Veil warping Vintage/Legacy? With how prevalent blue is there I could certainly see it being splashed in everything.
→ More replies (1)20
u/Forkrul Charm Jeskai Nov 13 '19
Any degenerate deck loves the card since it demands an immediate counter or the deck just wins. As an example Storm will cast this whenever it feels like and if it's not countered it's gg, is it is countered you still need another counter to stop their actual combo.
Printing Veil, OUaT and Oko into the same standard is a bigger design fuckup than printing saheeli cat combo into standard.
7
u/ToBeKing89 Nov 13 '19
I promise you as an avid legacy player veil is worse for storm than it is better. Not only does it stop tendrills, it also blocks all of their discard in turns 1 and 2 which they use to set up the combo.
16
u/PedonculeDeGzor StormCrow Nov 13 '19
I don't think OUAT needs a ban. It's played in every deck that runs green because it's a very good green card, but it's not the reason why these decks are played. I think banning something else along Oko would be a mistake.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Forkrul Charm Jeskai Nov 13 '19
It's played in every deck that runs green because it's a very good green card,
It's not just a very good green card, it's one of the best cards printed in years. I can only think of 2 better green cards printed in recent history: Oko, and Veil of Summer. Both of which are also highly likely to be banned. It needs to be banned for the same reason other cheap cantrips like Git Probe/Ponder/Preordain are banned in Modern; it makes the decks that can run it too consistent. If you're running a green deck with more than 0 creatures, you're just making a mistake if you don't run at least 2 copies of this card.
→ More replies (7)3
u/metalgamer Nov 13 '19
Won’t Once Upon a time go down once Okie is banned though?
8
u/Forkrul Charm Jeskai Nov 13 '19
Not if Selesnya/Golgari adventure or any other potential Green deck are around.
The only way OUaT play goes down is if there's a rise in non-green decks. Which isn't very likely unless a lot more than Oko gets banned.
2
u/AnonymousBoiFromTN Simic Nov 13 '19
Once Upon a time is actually fairly difficult to play with against most decks commonly used in standard. I hope they buff the Orhzov cards because currently its a sloooow control deck to play
1
u/TitaniumDragon Nov 14 '19
Veil of Summer is more of a problem in formats with combo decks, because it is a [[Silence]] that cantrips for such decks, basically allowing them to win without any possibility of interaction.
It's not nearly so powerful in standard as the only combo deck is kind of mediocre and is pretty slow.
→ More replies (1)
30
u/ciurra Nov 13 '19
Nah just oko
18
u/temptroll100 Nov 13 '19
I agree that Oko and only Oko should be banned in Standard.
Nissa is a powerful card, but the best Nissa draws are rare and she can usually be interacted with when she comes down. Ramping her out on turn 3 requires Goose, 1 other ramp creature, 3 lands, and Nissa herself making it a rare occurrence. Coming down as early as turn 3 still gives the opponent 2-3 turns to disrupt by killing one of the two ramp creatures, forcing a discard of Nissa, or countering Nissa. And most often Nissa doesn't come down until turn 4 or later. But even once Nissa hits the table she can be interacted with. The opponent can have an established board and access to enough mana by turn 3 or 4 to immediately pressure Nissa - sometimes enough to take her off the table immediately, other times enough to force the Nissa controller into sacrificing or trading their animated lands. And losing animated lands is a real risk when playing Nissa as you can easily get caught without enough mana to play a big x-spell, or replay Nissa after having her bounced back to your hand.
Once Upon a Time is a very good card, and while I may be wrong I personally don't think it's ban-worthy or even incredible in a Oko-less standard. You really only want to see it when you can cast it for free. After that it usually just slows you down and clogs up your hand. I think it's so good in standard right now because it greatly increases the consistency that you can cast a turn 2 Oko.
Veil of Summer is similar to Once Upon a Time in my mind in that I think without Oko it becomes weaker. Veil is seeing a lot of play because it's great in the food decks which will be weaker without Oko, it's great against the food decks which play blue and black spells requiring a target, and it's great at protecting from hate cards such as Noxious Grasp and Mystical Dispute which are so prevalent because of Oko.
Oko is too consistent, too difficult to interact with, and too impactful - all 3 of which result in him snowballing to victory too often. Turn 2 Oko requires only Goose, 2 land, and Oko himself. And turn 2 Oko really only allows a 1-2 turn window for the opponent to disrupt the Goose, Duress Oko, or Mystical Dispute Oko. Going up to 6 loyalty immediately makes him really difficult to kill the turn he comes down and then he starts producing a 3/3 every other turn or every turn if there's a Goose out. Most commonly he's going to make a food (to be consumed by Goose or Wicked Wolf) or he's going to make a food into a 3/3 to protect himself or pressure the opponent. But he's also flexible, occasionally invalidating an Inkeeper, Questing Beast, Lovestruck Beast, etc. And it's not uncommon that his -5 allows for an alpha strike.
→ More replies (3)4
u/aldart Lyra Dawnbringer Nov 13 '19
Agree, I think that is it - Veil is a sideboard card, you can play around it (e.g., board clears).
Oko is a turn 2 powerhouse that wins the game by itself.
10
u/Kardif Nov 13 '19
Veil of summer is the same level of power as pyroblast and hydroblast. It puts enormous pressure on the metagame, and makes it so that post board games against green decks are miserable if you're trying to kill or counter their stuff
There's a very good reason it got banned in pioneer, there's no way it's surviving standard
5
u/_blue_skies_ Nov 13 '19
You tell the story like the only purpose of green is that has to be countered, and it's not fair of you can't be sure that when you try to do it, green can have an answer. I think veil is a fair card, mostly sideboard, and is not defining the standard. You can have only four of them, while unsummon and counters are many more.
→ More replies (3)
6
16
u/NobleLiongames Nov 13 '19
All these filthy control players asking for a veil of summer ban it’s shameless
9
u/Chrona82 Nov 13 '19
Even though my favorite decks right now are Esper Board wipes and Kenrith Gates, I wouldnt ask for that. Its a fair card that gives green answers to counter-pile bullshit decks. Nothing pisses me off lile being countered 15 times in a game while the opponent still plays whatever they want.
Control should branch away from reliance on counterspells, so people salty over that card need to get creative.
4
u/NobleLiongames Nov 13 '19
I agree like I have a friend that is like in love with board wipes and I get like playfully salty about it but it’s fine but there’s nothing more annoying than playing against a deck with 10+ counter spells and the game takes long asf because no one wants to play anything into a counter spell. Like Esper control got a huge nerf in the meta for a reason and it’s probably the main reason of the invention of this card. Counter magic is a mechanic that stagnates both competitive and causal play.
5
2
u/wierddude88 Nov 13 '19
I feel like there is a lot of overlap between people who wanted T3feri banned and Veil banned. Those cards prey on Control but outside of that are just pretty good.
16
u/sweeko_Z Nov 13 '19
If veil is banned green creature decks just kinda auto lose to control right? I mean I know it's a good card but it only does something against u/b.
36
Nov 13 '19
That's kind of the point. Aggro loses to mid-range, mid-range loses to control, control loses to aggro and combo does it's thing in the corner.
Right now mid range beats everything. Control being able to beat mid-range is just working as intended
1
u/sweeko_Z Nov 13 '19
I see your point and I mostly agree but veil is literally the only tool green has to beat control.
Veil does nothing against sweepers which is still usually gg vs creature midrange. If they had to ban something besides oko I would vote nissa I guess.
13
u/Daethir Timmy Nov 13 '19
That's why you splash others color in your deck. Each color is supposed to have its strength ad weakness, when the same color can create a powerfull board and protect it something went wrong.
→ More replies (2)18
u/LotusCobra Nov 13 '19
green has managed to play against blue/black for 24 years without Veil of Summer i'm sure they'll find a way
→ More replies (8)6
u/X13thangelx Nov 13 '19
Banning nissa doesn't change anything though. The reason she seems oppressive is because you can get her out early. If playing her on curve she comes out turn 3/4 by tapping out and investing 1 or 2 mana dorks. After plussing her you have 2 green available and a 3/3 blocker and she's at 5 loyalty which is still killable the next turn. Plus it opens you up to land destruction that you normally wouldn't face otherwise, which can set you back as well.
Imo, she does what she is supposed to as a planeswalker. She comes down and presents something that has to be dealt with in the next few turns or she takes over the game.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Kardif Nov 13 '19
No, you have questing beast vs walkers, nullhide ferox vs discard, the ceratops vs counterspells and walkers, the great henge vs boardwipes. Wicked wolf + food lives through boardwipes. Domri makes things uncounterable as does rhythm of the wild while we're at it
5
6
u/Orangebeardo Nov 13 '19
Why on earth are OUAT and VoS in that list?
6
4
2
u/Pigmy Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
Hot take, oko stays and they ban once upon a time in standard. There was a ton of press (that I saw) calling out once upon a time as the card most played. An eerie amount of attention pointed to it.
Another point is that all the big card shops are hedging oko. Sell prices anywhere from $40-$60. Buy prices as low as $7.
4
u/foukas Nov 13 '19
Why not both? Goose into Oko will still be unbeatable, even if the Goose is less easy to find on turn 1. People will still maindeck Noxious Grasp and company as long as Oko is legal.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/bedwarri0r333 Nov 14 '19
Why are the bottom two cards OP?
1
u/Xmorpheus Nov 14 '19
Once upon a time is usually played turn 0 to get a goose. Veil of summer is cryptic command in green for 1 mana
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/KuhlThing Nov 14 '19
If Oko could be errata'd to make his elk ability a -1 rather than a +1, I think he'd be fine. Then they'd have to be a little judicious with those elk.
But that's changing a card's text, not updating it. I don't know if WotC have done such a drastic errata on a card before, particularly in Standard.
2
u/spudwinkle Nov 14 '19
This is what needs to happen, but that would be too logical. I also don't think Once Upon A Time deserves a ban, it isn't game breaking.
9
u/tiedyedvortex Nov 13 '19
My predictions:
Oko is getting banned. He's an engine in a card, and since he's in green he can hit the board on turn 2 and hit 10 loyalty by turn 5 or 6.
Once Upon a Time will not be banned. Is it good? Yes. But it makes good green decks into better green decks, and ultimately it's just a filtered card draw with a condition to play it for free. That's not meta-destroying.
Veil of Summer will not be banned. Yes, it's a really effective sideboard hate card, but so is Noxious Grasp and Devout Decree and those aren't on the table to be banned. Veil makes green a lot better, red and white a little better (since they are immune to it), and blue and black a little worse. That's not the end of the world, and Veil isn't the thing making green unstoppable these days.
Nissa...maybe, but I don't think so. With a Goose and a Paradise Druid, Nissa can hit the board on turn 3, at which point the mana advantage she generates is unreal. But, this power comes with risk; if your lands are creatures, they can be killed. I think that the proper answer to Nissa is burn and land destruction. But Oko kills burn dead by pumping out food and elks to soak up the spells, and by generating massive amounts of loyalty to keep himself un-burnable. I think that with Oko out of the meta, Nissa will be good, but I don't think she'll get banned.
4
u/Jigokuro_ Nov 13 '19
Nissa shouldn't be banned. She could come out t3 since release because before goose there was lanowar elves, but it never mattered until Oko was added to hold off the usual counters (like burn as you say.)
10
u/Arkanim94 Timestream Nov 13 '19
The problem is that veil is miles better than the other hate cards of the m20 cicle, comparing them is disingenuous.
The fact that it got banned in pioneer, where the removal is even better than in standard basically says in advance that veil will be one of the card that will be banned.
5
u/fendant Nov 14 '19
The fact that it got banned in pioneer, where the removal is even better than in standard basically says in advance that veil will be one of the card that will be banned.
I agree it blows the other color hosers out of the water, but Pioneer has to worry about Veil enabling a lot more brokenness than standard does. If Oko's gone and the strongest thing Veil protects is like Nissa or Questing Beast it's not nearly so scary.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)4
u/Wargod042 Nov 13 '19
Veil of Summer is on an entirely other level from Noxious Grasp and the other color hate. That's part of the problem. The cantrip makes it a million times better than the others. It's so head and shoulders above other hate cards that it prevents the meta from naturally shifting to deal with Green being dominant; if it didn't exist Green wouldn't be nearly as unstoppable because at the very least people could come prepared with the right removal and not get blown out by 1-mana Cryptic Command.
3
u/chef2dearh Nov 13 '19
They better not ruin my favourite green ramp deck and bam Nissa. Finale of Glory is useless without her.
2
u/electrobrains Ajani Valiant Protector Nov 13 '19
People are using it now as a finisher for UW control.
3
u/HashSlingingSlash3r Nov 14 '19
when blue is OP, nobody panics, because "it's all part of the plan." But when green is OP, everyone loses their minds!
4
u/foukas Nov 13 '19
I hope to see more than an Oko ban this time. I hate playing against Green decks 80% of the time.
26
u/Kisaragi-san BlackLotus Nov 13 '19
They should ban all colors because I hate playing against everything.
3
→ More replies (11)2
u/Ahayzo Nov 13 '19
Yea but if you ban Oko then you stop seeing Green anywhere near 80%. He’s the only thing that needs to be banned
2
u/foukas Nov 13 '19
I disagree. Green has so many playables that the food decks will just evolve into Elementals or ramp lists that were popular in the M20 pre-Eldraine event. The Golgari/Selesnya adventure decks which are already solid will continue to be good.
I can see a metagame share go to red and black aggro decks as well as Fires of Invention variants, but green will still be overepresented.
This is evident from the "most played cards" in the last 2 MCs. There was nothing but Green cards there and I doubt that Oko was the only card to blame for it.
5
2
2
u/Crocodales Nov 13 '19
I feel that Veil of Summer definitely needs a ban, I’ve mostly been playing Control this standard (More fool me) and I’ve found that card far more oppressive than Oko.
27
u/JESUS420_XXX_69 Nov 13 '19
Well thats the point of the card.
2
u/Crocodales Nov 13 '19
And the point of Oko is to turn your enemies into 3/3 Elks, what’s your point?
12
u/sick_stuff1 Nov 13 '19
veil saw zero play pre rotation and a ban on veil does nothing to help the 2 weakest color in standard right now.
→ More replies (5)3
Nov 13 '19
Actually, veil saw a decent amount of play when top decks were Vampires and Esper. Veil only faltered in play when relatively uninteractive combo decks came to dominate the meta such as Kethis combo and Golos FoD. I'd say a card that's good outside of being comboed to death t3-5 is still a pretty good card.
0
→ More replies (1)4
u/MouseOverMeta Nov 13 '19
VoS keeps 3feri a little more honest. If it's banned people will return to blaming it for the state of the meta I'm sure. I don't think it's worth the ban because without Oko what is VoS protecting that's unbearable or broken? Turn 4 nissa can't be countered or removed immediately by a black or blue source? I guess? I dunno. I think wizards has been two heavy handed trying to give green players more tools and the community is just unsure how to process overpowered green cards in numbers... That said I didn't play for like 15 years. I recall green being trash forever and always.
2
u/Celoth Nov 13 '19
Oko ban I can get behind. Maybe Veil. Nissa and Once upon a time? I don't see it. Especially Nissa. I literally don't see her played.
2
u/TairesBayl Nov 13 '19
I have been out of the loop for some weeks now. Why vale of summer?
→ More replies (1)4
u/Dakkon_B Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 14 '19
Well some of the only good answers to these green plainswalkers are straight black removal or counterspells. However Veil not only "counters" your spell it cantrips all for 1 green.
So its like getting cryptic commanded for 1 green. Its a completely blowout that you usually can't recover from cause now the card you NEEDED to answer is still there but now you are also down an answer. (and usually it cost you more mana to even try too so mana constraints become an issue too)
→ More replies (1)2
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/Trabant777 Sorin Nov 13 '19
I think if [[Veil of Summer]] gets banned it will only be for BO3.
→ More replies (2)1
1
Nov 13 '19
I passed this test. But I failed similar one where I must reveal that I own Derevi, Empyrial Tactician.
1
1
1
1
u/ArtisanJagon Nov 13 '19
I really like Arena, but I also don't want to go up against Oko every game nor do I want to build a deck specifically to combat Oko decks.
1
1
Nov 13 '19
Do people rage this hard when playing magic irl? Or is it just because it’s a digital form of the game that people complain so much?
1
1
u/kick_ass_knicks Nov 13 '19
OOTL, what happens in 5 days?
1
u/PM_ME_CUTE_FISHIES Nov 14 '19
The next banned and restricted announcement is scheduled for November 18th (5 days from now). People are expecting Oko to be banned, as WotC have said that he has been stronger than they expected.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
u/GenKan Nov 13 '19
Make it an instant and if it hits concede / if miss fetch random basic and I would 4x each deck I currently play
1
1
1
Nov 13 '19
Wait, I pulled a foil Anissa during prerelease. Not the promo. Is she good in standard? Haven't played in a bit...
1
u/NeonArchon Nov 13 '19
You're out of your midn if youthink theere are going to ban all those cards, Green/ Simic would be just unplayable
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/TitaniumDragon Nov 14 '19
They need to ban Oko and Once Upon a Time.
It's also worth considering banning Gilded Goose, Arboreal Grazer, and Edgewall Innkeeper.
If Veil of Summer was a problem, people wouldn't be running black or blue. Instead, they're the second and third most common colors.
1
Nov 14 '19
I understand wanting to ban Oko, Veil, and OUAT but why Nissa? She's a five double green five drop that operates how a five drop should imo. Heck, her drawback is that the lands I make into 3/3's can be killed or exiled screwing me on mana.
Sure, she can create a big Krasis on turn 6 but she's been doing that since WOTS dropped and hardly anyone has been complaining about that until now.
1
1
1
u/Pacify_ Nov 13 '19
No way Veil is banned
12
u/isackjohnson Nov 13 '19
It's already been banned in a format with a larger card pool, so there's definitely a "way" it gets banned. I know these formats are way different but the fact it was banned in Pioneer could mean it has maybe too strong of an effect.
0
0
u/Jermo48 Nov 13 '19
I still think Krasis is the enabler of all of this nonsense. These decks were running blue before Oko almost entirely for it. Maybe it's just the type of deck I play, but besides a super accelerated Nissa, Krasis is always the card I want them to have least. It could be a vanilla creature and they'd still play it just for its absurd, uncounterable, arguably broken refill (with some life stabilization), but it for sure doesn't need to also be a massive threat on its own.
It's really not that hard to run these decks out of gas unless Oko solos your strategy, but then they just refill while gaining life and playing a massive creature and everything you did so far was irrelevant.
3
u/chaosxshi Nov 13 '19
What about kill spells after they tap out for krasis?
Krasis is strong for sure, but it's a strong just where it should be and is mostly managable.
8
u/Jermo48 Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
So you killed their Krasis after it drew 4 cards. Is that supposed to be a good answer? Looks like a 5 for 1 to me.
I'm not sure why anyone still uses the "dies to removal" argument about things. So does Oko. Krasis is an x spell, so it's insanely flexible. It's a massive flying trampler that scales with all your ramp, so it's always a good threat. It's a massive threat that heals, so it can stabilize. It's refill that synergizes with all your ramp to make it so it's quite close to impossible to ever run you out of cards. It has exactly no true counters besides discard because it still draws and heals when countered or removed, unlike all the other problem cards.
It has also been a straight auto-include in basically ever UG deck since it was released and has been in most of the best decks (including, if Oko is banned, both of the best decks this format that were so oppressive that they needed a ban in the first place). Know what's even more broken than Oko? Killing their Oko, running them out of cards and then having them topdeck a single card that gives them an 8/8 flying trampler, gains them 4 life and draws them into another Oko as well as another Nissa or Krasis or Hydra or whatever else.
→ More replies (3)
0
u/tysonarts Nov 13 '19
Nyssa, Once and Viel I have no problems with, Nyssa is largely handled with a board wipe, and Viel is necessary with the hyper amounts of mill/counter/theft decks out there that are black/blue. Viel is a well time nope you cannot take my stuff on turn 4, or nope you cannot counter my spell, again for the nth time in a row, or yeah, I like to keep my hand, so not no discarding this turn
8
u/_dUoUb_ Nov 13 '19
Veil is a 2 for one for 1 Mana, and sometimes more than that, veil is just busted bcs it cantrips, just ban veil and oko and the format is good again
3
u/deadlockedwinter Nov 13 '19
No because then 3feri Control will come back and everyone will want that banned again...
7
u/dIoIIoIb Nov 13 '19
yes. oko and his green friends being busted doesn't change how bullshit 3feri is.
4
u/_dUoUb_ Nov 13 '19
People that want 3feri banned are the counter players, I never saw any midrange deck thinking 3feri is opressive, hell we have a midrange meta now and it's not veil that shut downs 3feri, 3feri shuts down veil...
What shut downs 3feri is cheap creature and oko, that makes a creature to atack 3feri
→ More replies (1)4
u/NoL_Chefo Nov 13 '19
Veil is a staple in Legacy sideboards, a format with goddamn Spell Pierce in it, and is banned in Pioneer, a format with all the absurd Modern cards + the ones that were banned from Modern but sure, it's a perfectly balanced "well-timed nope" in Standard, which has the weakest cards of all those formats.
Say goodbye to Veil in five days, baby.
4
u/electrobrains Ajani Valiant Protector Nov 13 '19
Pioneer, a format with all the absurd Modern cards + the ones that were banned from Modern
That's not what Pioneer is.
0
1
u/mobyte Nov 13 '19 edited Nov 13 '19
I prefer something along these lines:
"This card cannot be countered. This card pierces hexproof. Search target player's hand, library, sideboard, and personal collection for any cards with the above names. Rip up the cards. Spit on them. Set them on fire. They lose the game."
1
u/Ahayzo Nov 13 '19
Were Veil and OUaT mistakes that shouldn’t exist? Most certainly. Are any of the three non-Oko remotely close to banworthy without Oko in the format? Not at all.
Oko and no other changes is the only right call for Standard in 5 days.
1
Nov 13 '19
Lmao it’s just oko dude. There’s no reason to ban nissa and the other two are just absurd 😂
1
1
u/LightLevel Nov 14 '19
I hate how everyone just forgot Teferi is a mood killer. And my god after all the bans are said and done that cat deck might get me to quit the game!
Who has time for that!?
0
Nov 13 '19
Veil of summer? You what mate? This card is not op at all...the other 3 yes, but veil of summer gave green a chance against all the black decks...
→ More replies (4)
6
u/KrimzonK Nov 13 '19
Come on dude I open two Oko by chance. I don't even have them in my Simic deck.