Hello all! To preface, I want to begin by saying that I am in no way trying to make Tsukushi seem like he is less talented than he is. He's written this fantastic story, after all, that sits as my 8th favorite manga (and 2nd favorite anime) of all time.
However, something that I don't see people talking about often - or even at all - is that Tsukushi is a novice writer, and it shows in a lot of places throughout his story. This is his first manga, only having tackled two one-shots previously and with zero experience even as an assistant to an established mangaka as many other manga authors do.
In this analysis, I'd like to dive into what I think is a bit of a valley that he's written himself into because of this inexperience...and how I think he could get himself out of it.
Throughout the story, there are a few times when it feels as though his scenes lack a particular direction. I'll give a couple of examples. First, in the first few chapters: we open with a scene of Riko talking about the star compass, then shift quickly into a bit of exposition about the world, then cut again to the scene of Riko at her Auntie's house.
Each of these scenes has its purpose as part of the story, but when tied together, there is no real flow. I find this lack of flow to be a serious detriment because it doesn't give the audience proper time to digest the information presented. I don't think I would've remembered Riko's dialogue about the star compass at all, in fact, if I hadn't watched the anime first - which positions this scene as a cold open after the abyss has already been explained, and after Reg has already been introduced.
It's also somewhat jarring to see Riko, then narration as exposition, then Riko again in a completely different place...without any sense of how they got there. I actually think that Tsukushi's fantastic worldbuilding is lost in this first volume almost in its entirety. Unlike in the anime, we never see how Riko gets from one place to another. She doesn't even carry Reg out of the abyss in the manga...they just teleport from the abyss to the orphanage, with no context.
For a story about the exploration of the unknown, I actually find that there is an incredible lack of exploration in the first few volumes of the manga, up until the fourth layer. And it makes sense: the fourth layer is where Tsukushi was essentially instructed by his editors to add Nanachi, and by adding Nanachi, he was forced to spend a lot of time in a single place - truly exploring that place.
This is where I think Made in Abyss shines in the fourth, fifth, and sixth layers. Clearly, he's taken his editor's advice to heart. Heading into the fifth - and then, especially the sixth - layer, Tsukushi draws many more panels of the landscape and of the characters walking through that landscape than he ever did before. It's fantastic. I praise him for this. I really feel like I'm exploring something.
This is taken to the extreme in the sixth layer, which I really appreciate. We get to explore pretty much every nook and cranny of Iruburu and the area surrounding it; it gives a great sense of scale and wonder.
However, this is where we come back to Tsukushi's inexperience with another problem: character writing. Now, it's hard to say if Tsukushi was planning on introducing anything resembling Nanachi at all before his editors told him to do so, but even if he didn't, an experienced writer should be able to work around changes in their story to provide a cohesive experience.
As many people have noted, however, this is a problem when it comes to Iruburu...because of Nanachi, and how she's sidelined for much of the arc. Now, it's worth mentioning that much of what I'm about to say is just speculation, and I don't particularly mind what the arc does with Nanachi, anyway.
But I think that by sidelining Nanachi - and reintroducing Mitty - Tsukushi has dug himself into a bit of a hole. There are a couple of problems I see here:
Nanachi now needs to come back into the spotlight, and fast. If she's going to continue traveling with the rest of our main cast, she needs to truly be a main cast member.
Because the only thing Nanachi did in the Iruburu arc was form a relationship with Belaf, that relationship is now required to be held in higher regard. It does look like Tsukushi is doing alright here, given that Belaf has already been brought up once past the anime. But it needs to be brought up more...which is a challenge when Belaf is dead.
Perhaps most importantly, the reintroduction of Mitty retroactively makes Mitty's story incomplete.
That last point is what I want to focus on. A writer generally separates their story into three acts:
The buildup, in which the characters commit to their goal and are motivated to begin their journey.
The midsection, in which the journey takes place, usually culminating in a smaller climactic event before the climax itself.
The climax, where the character faces their most difficult struggle - the one the story has built up to - and pushes through their lowest point.
However, an experienced and skilled writer won't just do this for the overarching story...but for every character arc and narrative arc placed within it. Prior to the Iruburu arc, Mitty had a nice, concise three-act story:
The buildup occurs as we are shown what has become of Mitty; she's introduced as a girl who was turned into a hollow, and so we are given investment and motivation to solve this problem and free Mitty from her suffering.
The midsection occurs as we are shown Mitty's backstory, explaining her journey and culminating in Bondrewd's experimentation.
The climax occurs, in which we face our most difficult struggle in order to finally kill Mitty and bring an end to her suffering.
It's a fantastic and concise arc. I love it. And I think the majority of people would agree that this - essentially the final episode of season 1 - is the best part of season 1.
But now, Tsukushi has reintroduced Mitty. Mitty's story is no longer over. And I sincerely hope that Tsukushi knew what he was getting himself into, because the reintroduction of Mitty in the Iruburu arc - even though she dies (again) in the arc - makes it so that that entire arc that we got before is only the first act. We haven't yet solved our problem; we've merely been introduced to the journey that Mitty's soul is on. It's going to leave a bad taste in my mouth if the last we ever see of Mitty is a random bit tacked on after her arc has already ended.
And that leaves us with where we are now. We have a new arc, exploring new places, and deepening the mystery to levels that it's never been before. I'm excited to see what Nanachi's (and Mitty's) contribution to the team will be in this and coming arcs, and I'll be very disappointed if Tsukushi's inexperience comes back to bite him in this arc as well.
It seems to me as though he's falling into a trap I've seen in many manga as of late: introducing too many things for his own good, and then being unable to handle them all concisely and impactfully. If anybody's ever read them, for reference, examples of other manga that I think have this problem are My Hero Academia, Witch Hat Atelier, and Children of the Whales. I really, really hope that he's able to balance all these plot threads. He's done a good job so far, but all the arcs we've had have been fairly linear, with only a tiny diversion from that path in the Iruburu arc.
What do you all think? Do you agree? Do you disagree, and think that the problems I mentioned aren't problems? I'm curious to know your thoughts, and excited to see what the next chapter has in store in the next few days. Judging from the structure of previous arcs, we're about ready to start getting into some crazy shit either this upcoming chapter or the next.
Thanks for reading!