r/MTGLegacy • • Jun 19 '24

Miscellaneous Discussion Legacy doesn't need more bans on fair cards. You just need to go out and touch some grass.

0 Upvotes

Legacy has suffered cascading bans of fair cards at the whims of people crying on the internet for years now. Who even knows what the format would look like right now if left to develop naturally?

Outside of truely format warping cards like Astrolabe or Underworld Breech, bans in legacy should come slowly. Power creep has always existed and isn't going anywhere. When you ban today's most competitive strategy, you ban the best competition to tomorrow's most competitive strategy. Continuing these bans means decks don't just have to compete with cards a step or two above them, but several steps above them instead. How much better do decks play against scam right now without so many potent threats being banned? Most of the new banned cards are pretty great top decks against today's best deck.

As is, efficient blue shells are always going to incorporate efficient new threats more effectively at first than other decks in this format. However, with time and enough threats, other decks benifit from new printings. Banning new threats just leaves Delver with whatever hasn't been banned yet and leaves nothing on the table for everyone else. They litterally can't play all of the boogeyman threats of yesterday. Do you really think Delver would be slotting Dreadhord Arcanist or Wren and Six still? It seems far more likely that there just other decks that would play them that just do not exist now.

Decks come and go and come back again in this format and your favorite deck is no exception. Too many of you got into legacy post Innistrad block and have this idea that the format is static and don't even understand that Innistrad block and unbanning sol lands "rotated" the whole format. Change in legacy has alway existed. Legacy isn't a format balanced on your feelings. It doesn't matter how miserable you feel because of a deck or card you don't like. Your favorite powerful thing to do in legacy isn't more important than anyone else's favorite powerful thing to do in legacy. I promise someone else hates playing against the cards you like.

This game wasn't meant to be played 24/7 on your computer at home. If the new hot deck has an edge on your favorite deck and it is getting to you, innovate, switch decks, play another format a bit, or take a break and do something else. There is nothing wrong with Legacy and if you wait six months, there will be a new hot deck in the format.


r/MTGLegacy • • Mar 07 '18

Discussion Ban Gurmag Angler (shorter than both)

0 Upvotes

It's simple really. Grixis Delver was a deck for years, but wasn't one of THE decks until late 2015 when Gurmag Angler got popular. Sure, there was some nonsense with Treasure Cruise and Dig Through Time in the middle of the year there, but when the dust settled, we had a new format-defining deck in the form of Grixis Delver.

I distinctly remember early 2016 when all the RUG Delver players collectively realized they weren't playing the best tempo deck in the format. One such player once posted here on Reddit and it made perfect sense to me. He was in some tournament, sitting across from a Grixis opponent with his 4/5 Tarmogoyf and Wild Mongoose in play while his opponent has a 5/5 Angler and 1/2 DRS in play and he thinks to himself "Yup, that's the difference between these two decks"

Now I'm sure all the DRS haters are foaming at the mouth about how DRS is the problem there, but really, it comes down to the fact that neither of RUGs premier threats could attack into that board due to Giant Wall that is Gurmag Angler to begin with.

DRS isn't new to Legacy, DRS isn't killing off decks that don't already have 20,000 other problems being viable in the Legacy landscape.

Gurmag Angler IS and DOES though.

It pushes anything that doesn't fly and/or can't kill a 5/5 out of the format. It's immune to Abrupt Decay and Fatal Push, 2 of the premier removal options of the format.

It rewards Delver players for Wastelanding their opponents lands since Wastelands help to feed the fish.

It rewards Delver players for GETTING Wastelanded since Wastelands help to feed the fish.

It acts as a giant mana reserve for all cantrips, effectively allowing delver players to stock up on mana that they can then blow later to feed the fish.

It has no obvious weakness outside of StP due to Delve and how it works.

And people don't realize how damn broke this card is because it was released as a common in it's set.

Please ban the problem card and stop taking away the fun stuff.


r/MTGLegacy • • Aug 12 '26

Stream/VOD Bilbo is COMPLETELY BROKEN in Legacy! 5-0 Trophy with Azorius Artifacts

0 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/qGnzuwd4qPk?si=UI-TeU143KIp33N9
Got a 5-0 Trophy on the first try with Bilbo Azorius Artifacts. Was just a brew but the Halfling carried a lot of wins and broken plays.

Can't imagine how busted it is in good decks.

I daily stream on Twitch and upload videos to YouTube. Subscribe!


r/MTGLegacy • • Aug 07 '26

Miscellaneous Discussion God I LOVE legacy right now

0 Upvotes

When car was hyper dominant for like a few weeks it was miserable, but now I'm super enjoying it.

Yeah you get car'd but this is legacy combo exists, it's better then Oops. I'm loving Doomsday, tempo is the top deck.

We have 3 entirely playable tempo decks.

We have 4.5 combo decks. Of which most are completely different then each other.

We even have a playable aggro deck?

When the top 10 is

30% tempo

40% combo

10% aggro

10% whatever you call lands

10% hybrid combo (Dimir car)

And just outside of top ten we have a viable true control deck????

The difference between #1 (Dimir tempo) and #2 (doomsday) is only 4% and the difference between 2/3 is like 3%.

I haven't had this much fun in legacy before. I love this meta so much.

For the first time since... ever? (at least as long as I've been playing ).

I'm praying for no changes to legacy.


r/MTGLegacy • • Jan 02 '25

Event Results Unpopular Opinion: Nadu should have been banned too.

0 Upvotes

Two weeks in, the MTGTop8 meta shows Nadu decks as the best deck of Legacy and I don’t think it shows the same on MTGGoldfish because clicking too much actually skews that. There is a midrange combo deck dedicated to just Nadu, Cephalid Breaskfast warping to Nadu, and some decks splashing for Nadu. If MTGO didn’t involve all that clicking and the timer, I would think it would also show as the best deck as it would on MTGTop8.

This card needs to go it’s both degenerate both from a gameplay and power level perspective. Sensei’s Divining Top got the axe for not just being really powerful, but it also made games take way too long and Nadu is perfectly capable of making games take too long because the player playing against Nadu decks may just sit there watching their opponent play solitaire with Nadu with the small chance that they actually whiff, this seems to rarely happen though.

Nadu adds nothing good to the format in my opinion. You all asked for bans that would affect UB Reanimator and Mystic Forge, but I consider Nadu more of a problem than what the Mystic Forge deck was capable of, the Eternal Weekend where it was the best deck caused a freak out and I guess helped Vexing Bauble get banned. It was only the best deck of that event though, I think people with a double Null Rod sideboard can actually help contain the deck.

I feel like it’s going to be several months of Nadu combo degeneration before wizards does anything. While you people are so ok with it in the format it has shown it just does too much. It doesn’t need to put up the same results as UB Reanimator to deserve a ban like Frog and Grief did. I think it adds nothing of value to our beloved format, the fans of Cephalid Breakfast still had a great combo deck even before Nadu, but Nadu just makes it busted.


r/MTGLegacy • • Nov 05 '25

Six Bans For a Healthier Legacy – Eternal Durdles

Thumbnail
eternaldurdles.com
0 Upvotes

Cyrus Bales (Crucible of Words) shares what changes he thinks WotC should make on Nov. 10 to improve the health and gameplay of the format.


r/MTGLegacy • • Sep 26 '14

Fluff Jeskai is NOT a thing, please don't.

7 Upvotes

These new names are horrendous, don't fall victim to bad-name-bandwagoning.

Please.

Edit: "Shardless Sultai" on stream right now. Fuck you, SCG. Fuck you.


r/MTGLegacy • • Mar 17 '25

Article Legacy Needs Big Swing Bans

Thumbnail
eternaldurdles.com
0 Upvotes

r/MTGLegacy • • Nov 02 '25

Can we please finally ban Murktide Regent?

1 Upvotes

Look, I get it.

Murktide regent is just a beater, and “a BeAtEr CoUlDn’T pOsSiBlY wArRaNt A bAn In LeGaCy”

But Why Should Blue get the biggest 2-3 mana Beater in the format, with evasion and which is difficulty to remove?

The combination of size, cost, evasion, and difficulty of removal on a blue threat is putting incredible pressure on the format, and has greatly constricted the metagame. It’s not a coincidence that all the new broken turbo Xerox decks warranting bans are 2 colors running Murktide Regent.

Let’s take a moment to walk through just how incredibly powerful the big blue dragon actually is for “just a beater”

Firstly, Murktide Regent is huge even by Legacy Standards

A fully loaded 8/8 Murktide Regent has more power than any threat traditionally run in Reanimator. It’s straight up bigger than Griselbrand, Atraxa, [[Chancellor of the Annex]], [[Iona, Shield of Emeria]], and even has more power than [[Inkwell Leviathan]].

The only larger creatures commonly run in Legacy are Emrakul, and Phyrexian Dreadnought, which both realistically require combos in order to effectively get into play.

That’s just a demonstrably different class of threat than the traditional 4/5 Tarmogoyf or 5/5 Gurmag Angler. Now in all fairness, it takes some effort to get an 8/8 Murktide Regent.

But even the “trivial” to accomplish 5/5 Murktide regent, and the common 6/6 version are huge, presenting a 3-4 turn clock and matching/outclassing traditional legacy Beatsticks like [[Gurmag Angler]] and [[Tarmogoyf]], while also adding evasion.

The Evasion of Murktide Regent is the Second Key Dimension of the Card

In the past, beatsticks and evasive creatures were two different classes of cards. Tarmogoyf, Gurmag Angler, and Batterskull all lacked evasion.

But Murktide Regent can fly, which is incredibly difficult to effectively block against in Today’s legacy. Even as a 5/5 Murktide regent is the biggest fair flyer running around in the format and can kill any typical fair non-murktide blocker. This problem is only further accentuated for non-blue decks, which often have to rely on more mana expensive cards to chump block, like Yorion and Endurance.

All of which is to say, a Murktide regent on the attack is often connecting for damage, and a lot of damage. There is no “mana dork or snapcaster mage blocking Gurmag Angler” here. Nor do you have “lots of time” to find an answer a-la flipped Delver. A 5/5 Murktide regent kills in 4 swings, a 6/6 can often get there in 3, and 7/7 or 8/8 regents can swing a game substantially with even a single hit. With very few ways for the opponent to slow down that clock.

As a result, opponents need to get a Murktide Regent off the board quickly, but

Murktide Regent third key aspect is that it’s hard to remove

The only consistent, widely played, answers to Murktide Regent in Legacy are:

Swords to Plowshares, Solitude, Pyroblast, Snuff Out, and… Murktide Regent. (And sometimes a 1-of Murderous Cut in Beans decks).

Popular Legacy answers like Lightning Bolt, Fatal Push, Abrupt Decay, and Prismatic Ending simply don’t work at all against the dragon, while answers like Dismember, Unholy Heat, Sheoldred’s Edict, and Flame of Arnor are painfully unreliable, able to answer only small or unaccompanied regents.

Murktide Regent demands specific answers.

And, just like evasive threats used to be a different category of threat than “beaters”, removal dodging threats used to be their own category (see Nimble Mongoose, and True Name Nemesis). Murktide Regent, however combines all of these roles into one big evasive hard to remove threat. It is the midrange multi-tool of threats.

And it does so for only 2 (ish) mana in Blue

Which is huge.

One of the biggest historical weakness of blue in Legacy, was that it lacked good top end threats. So decks splashed white for Stoneforge Mystic (and the accompanying Batterskull/Kaldra), or Black for Tomstalker then later Gurmag Angler, or green for Tarmogoyf, or had to concede size in exchange for better mana. Those different splashes lent themselves to varying playstyles, and forced real decisions in terms of what cards would be available, or how vulnerable the mana would be, for a given deck.

Furthemore, non-blue fair decks could turn to cards like [[Knight of the Reliquary]], and [[Endless One]], and “good-in-nic-fit.card” to go bigger than their blue adversaries.

But now, Murktide Regent blows all those old threats out of the water, and exists in a tier of its own. No other threat in legacy offers so much size, for so little deckbuilding investment, and has evasion, and is so hard to answer. The Blue Dragon facilitates delver and other turbo Xerox decks being trivially two color. Why play Grixis or RUG delver with worse mana when UR has a complete threat suite? Alternatively, throw 2-3 Murktide Regents in a UB shell, and you’ll have a complete mid-range creature package, leaving plenty of free space to throw in a reanimator package.

There’s no need to worry about splashing or making deckbuilding concessions to get access to evasive threats, hard to remove threats, and large threats. Just run some instants and sorceries in blue.

Now some people will comment that Murktide Regent is often played in only 2-3 copies to a deck, but the reality is that’s all that you need. You only really need 3 attacks from a regent over the course of a game to win, and 2-3 copies provides plenty of redundancy to accomplish that aim in a blue shell.

Others might point out that Murktide Regent is only the third most player creature in Legacy, and has only been in about 27% of Legacy decks so far in 2025 (according to MTGTop8), whereas Tamiyo sees far more play (in about 37%).

But 1: Tamiyo is herself potentially a problem.

2: Murktide Regent makes Tamiyo way more of a problem, by presenting a 1 turn clock when played in duplicates off of a Tamiyo ult. Since redundant copies can grow beyond 8/8. (It also comboed with Psychic Frog).

And 3: Murktide Regent doesn’t need to be in more than a quarter of all decks to be having an outsized impact on the metagame. If you want to play fair in Legacy, you need to have a solution to the dragon, and if you want to combo you need to be able to outrace it.

Fair threats often set the benchmark for format speed, and in Legacy today you need to do something before the dragon can kill you out of a tempo deck.

Some people also argue that banning Murktide Regent is pointless since alternatives exist like [[Cryptic Serpent]] and [[Ethereal Forager]], but those creatures lack evasion and are much smaller respectively.

The reality is that Murktide Regent is in a class of its own. This type of evasive hard to remove low cost super-beater is largely unprecedented in Legacy, and is incredibly toxic in blue. It has unduly trivialized deck construction for blue decks, and puts pressure on the format velocity. It seems like an incredibly reasonable format boundary to say that blue can’t have the best large beater in the format, let alone one that is also evasive.

Further, there’s strong reason to believe that banning Murktide Regent would do a lot of good for the format.

Firstly, it would relieve some of the pressure presented by the Turbo Xerox shell, by forcing more decisions about the associated creature package. Right now Ux Tempo decks can just run Murktide Regent as a Beater/Evasive-Threat/Hard-to-Remove-Threat blue wunder-kard. Alternatives like Cryptic Serpent, Gurmag Angler, Barrowgoyf, and Tarmogoyf can cover some of those bases, but not all of them.

Secondly, it would invite more diversity in blue shells. Second and third color splashes become a much more complex conversation when non-blue creature quality becomes a bigger deal.

Thirdly, it would provide a boon to ailing control and non-blue fair decks by weakening the top end of aggro/tempo blue decks.

I get that Murktide Regent is not necessarily "classically broken" by historical legacy standards, but it really does seem like the card just is a net negative for the overall format quality. If it's valid to remove cards like Sowing Mycospawn for housekeeping reasons, why not Murktide Regent?


r/MTGLegacy • • Sep 29 '21

Miscellaneous Discussion Banning ONLY Ragavan will still leave us with a Delver-dominated format

0 Upvotes

Is anyone aside from the absolute hardcore Delver enthusiast really happy to spend another 10 years with Delver being the best thing to be doing in the format? (Note: here "Delver" refers to the "Delver Shell" which may or may not contain copies of the Delver card)

Wizards, please save us from the Delver menace. If the monke's gotta go, please ban Daze while you're at it. Also, unban Frantic Search and Survival of the Fittest. In Richard Garfield's (pbuh) holy name, amen.


r/MTGLegacy • • May 07 '20

MTGO Event A different showcase photo summary

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MTGLegacy • • Feb 16 '19

Are you all really OK with fake cards?

1 Upvotes

Some of the "proxies" being sold online are actually counterfeit cards. A so-called proxy foil Liliana of the Veil sold online looks exactly the same as the real thing but will cost you $10 instead of $245 (I could link to it, but I don't want to give them free advertising). Trust me when I say it's almost impossible to tell the difference, especially when cards are double or even triple (!) sleeved in a tournament.

WoTC's official position is here. Basically, proxies are OK outside tournament use as long as no one could ever mistake it for the real thing. In the rules for this forum, it says "any discussion promoting counterfeits is strictly forbidden".

So I was surprised recently in this forum, where I spoke out against fake Magic cards (here and here) and was massively downvoted for it.

Is that really the majority view here? Fakes are OK? Seriously? Not all legacy players are rich, and some cards represent a significant investment for some people. An investment that will blow away in the wind when the market is saturated with fakes.


r/MTGLegacy • • Oct 31 '24

Community Hot Take, Legacy decks survive power creep better than other formats.

2 Upvotes

I know this sounds wild, but almost all Legacy decks have a great shelf life, this is because most of the decks of the past either stay tiered or at least become fringe competitive, but it’s just so rare for new cards to completely rotate a deck out of a format. There is so many decks in Legacy that are over ten years old many stayed tiered and many became competitive fringe decks still capable of spiking events it’s just you’re going to be running a different composition of the deck. The card pool is just so big in Legacy that you can get most decks working from Legacy’s timeline working at least to some competitive deck degree.

For example Elves seemed like a entirely dead deck to a lot of people, but people found ways to adapt to the format either by adding the Nadu engine to it or that Eternal Weekend Top 32 that involved a Green enchantment that adjusted the stats of Green creatures so Bowmasters can’t just straight up run over the deck. If you really want an old deck to work and put enough time into it you can probably break it into Legacy, the entire 75 will likely end up as something you may not feel as nostalgic over, but it could at least be tournament playable. Show and Tell is a deck I checked on MTGTop8 since 2011, it always remained a tiered deck. It had its highs and lows, but never became like unplayable. That is a good example of a deck with a really good shelf life.


r/MTGLegacy • • Aug 27 '19

Deck/Matchup/Tactics Help Stoneblade subreddit

0 Upvotes

Amazingly it didn't already exist and now with stoneblade crossing over both Modern AND Legacy I figured we needed a place for resources! I'm by no means a Stoneblade expert myself but I love Stoneforge mystic and Stoneblade/Delverblade decks are my favorite archetypes to play! So here you guys go!

https://www.reddit.com/r/Stoneblade/


r/MTGLegacy • • Nov 05 '19

Miscellaneous Discussion I never really liked planeswalkers since they were first introduced. I have been saying that I hate them for around 3 years now. I also design cards when I have time. So enjoy some flexible custom card designs I made that hate on PWs, which could theoretically see play in legacy.

Thumbnail
imgur.com
5 Upvotes

r/MTGLegacy • • Apr 08 '23

Deck/Matchup/Tactics Help An Abbreviated Explanation For Every Deck In Legacy

7 Upvotes

Courtesy of AmmiO2's youtube channel, would highly recommend their stuff. This is meant to give you an overview of generally every archetype and is not supposed to go too deep into things, but I thought it would be helpful to some to maybe kick off some research or deckbuilding. Let me know if I have anything incorrect or it needs to be updated, I'll try doing my best. Thank you, enjoy :)

8-Cast = Blue artifact matters deck that plays numerous cheap artifacts for affinity-style effects.
Aluren = Blue/Black/Green creature-centric combo deck that revolves around the enchantment Aluren.
Ad Nauseam Tendrils + The EPIC Storm (aka ANT & TES) = Both decks are built around the concept of building up a storm count to then unleash Tendrils of Agony or Grapeshot. The only difference is that ANT is typically Black and TES is usually Red.

Attractions = Utilizing the weird Attraction mechanic from the Unfinity set.

Bomberman = White or White/Blue artifact deck that revolves around the synergy of Auriok Salvagers' and Lions Eye Diamond to create infinite mana.

Burn = Mono red deck that revolves around dealing damage to your opponent as quickly as possible with cheap spells like Lightning Bolt. Also the cheapest deck in Legacy.

Cephalid Breakfast = Combo deck built around milling out your whole deck with Cephalid Illusionist and then reanimating Thassa's Oracle.

Cloudpost = Big Mana ramp deck that uses the card Cloudpost to generate a ton of mana for expensive spells like Emrakul.

Death and Taxes = Primarily White deck that uses plenty of hatebears and mana denial like Thalia, Spirit of Labrynth and Rishadan Port while finding creatures to keep applying pressure.

Delver = Blue/Red deck that summons cheap and efficient creatures and clears them a path with counterspells and cantrips. It is the most popular deck in all of Legacy.

Depths = Revolves around the card Dark Depths to be able to create a flying, indestructible 20/20 as fast as possible oftentimes with cards like Vampire's Hexmage.

Doomsday = Blue/Black deck that revolves around the card Doomsday to mill your entire deck and win the Thassa's Oracle, while finding ways to protect this combo.

Eldrazi Stompy = Aggro deck that uses numerous lands similar to Cavern of Souls to summon a ton of Eldrazi.

Elves = Elves.

Enchantress = Green/White deck that uses cards like Enchantress's Presence and Sythis, Harvest's Hand to make every enchantment you play give you card advantage.

Goblins = Goblins.

Hogaak = Green/Black deck built around trying to summon Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis from the graveyard.

Infect = Green/Blue deck that tries to play cheap creatures with infect and pump them up to get their opponent to 10 poison counters. This can also be done by proliferating.

Lands = Basically built around cards that are synergistic with lands to overwhelm the opponent.

Maverick = Green/White midrange deck built around Knight of the Reliquary and Green Sun's Zenith.

Merfolk = Merfolk.

Mono Red Prison / Blood Moon = Mono red deck attempting to lock out the opponent from playing by using Blood Moon and other control spells.

Nic Fit = Uses Veteran Explorer and intentionally sacrifices it to find basic lands, because Legacy decks rarely have much if any basic lands, to create a disparity in mana.

Oops! All Spells = Graveyard centric glass cannon that looks to win as early as possible or not at all.

Painter = Uses the synergy of Painter's Servant and Grindstone to mill the entire deck of your opponent.

Reanimator = Black/White deck that attempts to put huge creatures in the graveyard and then summon them onto the battlefield for cheap.

Sneak & Show = Red/Blue/Black deck that attempts to cheat out huge creatures with the combo of Show and Tell and Sneak Attack.

UWx Control = Blue/White/(another color) Control deck dedicated to simply controlling the game with card advantage spells.

White Stompy/Aggro = Aggressive mono White deck attempting to quickly put out large value creatures.


r/MTGLegacy • • Jun 18 '25

Podcast What Will Get Banned Next? See the Predictions!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

Zac interviewed 33 legacy players. He asked: 1: who are you? 2: what would you change for the health of the format? 3: what do you think wotc will do?


r/MTGLegacy • • Feb 04 '21

Miscellaneous Discussion Should Wizards seize the opportunity and unban a lot of card for a test period?

2 Upvotes

Assumptions:

  • Covid makes paper play not an option right now and the near future.

  • Therefore Legacy only happens on MTGO currently.

Would’d that be a great opportunity to test different ban lists on MTGO?

(For a predefined, limited time)

What about we unban:

  • Deathrite Shaman

  • Wrenn and Six

  • Treasure Cruise

  • Dig Through Time

  • Gitaxian Probe (still too powerful?)

  • Sensei's Divining Top (still too powerful?)

  • Lurrus of the Dream-Den (should be fine with the rules change?)

  • Zirda, the Dawnwaker (should be fine with the rules change?)

  • Mana Drain (too expensive in paper?)

  • Survival of the Fittest (too expensive in paper?)

and see how the meta looks after 3 months.

How many broken cards can one fit into a 60 card deck?

Together with the already powerful 2019/2020 cards there would’d be enough room to play all the good cards?

Also what I’m thinking is:

Many cards compete for your own (or opponents) graveyard as a resource:

  • Deathrite Shaman

  • Wrenn and Six

  • Dreadhorde Arcanist

  • Treasure Cruise

  • Dig Through Time

  • Uro, Titan of Nature's Wrath

  • Mystic Sanctuary

  • Klothys, God of Destiny

  • Gurmag Angler

  • Hooting Mandrills

  • Lurrus of the Dream-Den

How many of these can one play in the same deck?

I suppose Deathrite Shaman would just be too strong as it keeps all of the above cards in check.

Would DHA and W6 even be good enough with DRS unbanned?

Would DRS into Oko be 90% of the meta?


r/MTGLegacy • • Nov 12 '23

FIRE Sucks

29 Upvotes

Legacy was a nuanced format. Now it’s just playing 6 free spells before turn 3 and whoever played the most cards for free wins.

Just a rant complaining about pushed design, that’s all. Come tell me I’m wrong or that you agree.


r/MTGLegacy • • Feb 21 '17

Fluff Thank goodness for Legacy...

1 Upvotes

Like a lot of people, i watched some of the GP this past weekend, which happened to be Modern. Today, i thought to myself, why i dont i join a Modern League, I havent played that format in a while, but i have decks, that could be fun... yeah right. Five un-interactive matches later, two of which i got salty yelled at for no reason, and I'm SOOO GLAD TO BE DONE WITH THAT LEAGUE. I was lucky to go 3-2 with my Scapeshift deck, but i still lost rating points overall, because Modern players are terrible.. and bitter people.

Lets see, i played against the new Jund Death's Shadow deck twice, because people are brainless stooges, the new Cheerios deck, a storm deck, and Tron. Let me tell you how fun those matches were with no Wastelands or Force of Wills.

If it wasnt for Legacy, i dont think i'd even play this game anymore, outside of my groups awesome Legacy style cube. Modern is an awful format. I suppose it could be fun, if you just accept it for what it is, a degenerate moron format where you simply hope your dumb deck draws a better top 10 then their dumb deck, but doing that over and over and over isnt exactly my idea of fun.

Ok, i'm done.

/rant

TL:DR - Modern is the worst. Legacy rules.


r/MTGLegacy • • Jun 09 '21

Miscellaneous Discussion Unban Survival and Top

0 Upvotes

I had a long brainstorming session last night, and after much ponderous consideration, I believe that I have delved through a not-insignificant portion of the format's secrets to arrive at an inevitable conclusion that is most certainly not preordained:

We must unite in calling for the immediate unbanning of Survival of the Fittest and Sensei's Divining Top.

Firstly, while I think Delver being the best or second-best deck in the format for 10 years straight is clearly ridiculous and suboptimal in a number of ways, AND while I think that the recent dominance of Delver (even prior to MH2) necessitates that something core to the Delver shell has to go, there is a chance that bringing back Survival and Top will shake up the meta enough to offset Delver dominance and please the chunk of folks that just want the Delver shell to continue with all of its toys until the end of time.

As has been discussed ad nauseum on this very board, Top was mostly banned due to its impact on tournament logistics. Survival was justly banned for dominating the format, but the Legacy of today is so completely alien to the format at that time that it hardly allows for legitimate comparisons about metagame health. Some crude brewing of what Survival decks would look like today invariably leads to decks that are at best on par with what the format as a whole already offers.

UNLEASHIFY the INNER POTENTIALISM of Legacy: Unban Survival and Top, now!

Disclaimer: This post is in no way influenced by my NM playset of Survivals currently sitting in my Premodern RecSur deck. Nothing to see here.


r/MTGLegacy • • Jun 24 '25

Miscellaneous Discussion Legacy: June 30th Banlist Theories

Thumbnail
mtg.cardsrealm.com
2 Upvotes

Greetings, Legacy community! Every three months, it's the same old story: a new banlist update gets closer, and the community starts speculating what could and what will probably leave the format. Of course, each of us wants to see a different meta, and we can't help but discuss which cards weren't banned last time but should have.

This time, we're going to do things a bit differently. Instead of discussing what we would like WotC to address and what they'll probably do, we'll discuss whether it's time to move past a few core concepts and slay some sacrificial lambs.


r/MTGLegacy • • Jul 01 '24

Reanimate is a pillar of the format. instead emergency ban Grief (and Troll)

0 Upvotes

We have major upcoming events in SCG Baltimore and Buffalo Chicken Dip Legacy. They shouldn’t be ruined by Rescaminator. If the scam archetype continues to suppress play on MTGO over the coming weeks, Wizards of the Coast should let louse an emergency ban.

 

As an old-school Reanimator player, I would hate to see the deck’s namesake card go. Not only is it powerful, but it’s also exciting and dynamic. Losing half your life to bring something back is a real cost, and the spell gets shut off by aggression. It feels well suited to Black’s identity of power at any price. If Wasteland and sundry Blue cards get the “pillar of the format” exception from bans, Reanimator should be awarded the same privilege.

 

The same immunity need not be granted to Grief. That card, along with Troll of Khazad-dum, allows for all Black decks to benefit from Reanimate at little opportunity cost. Now, those cards are typically played in Reanimator combo decks too, but alternatives exist, and the archetype would still be potent. Banning Grief (and Troll) would require a greater deckbuilding commitment in order to play Reanimate.

 

I include Troll in this discussion because I suspect Reanimate will continue to be slotted into Black midrange decks unless the Lord of the Rings card is also banned. It could be that the community would care less about a 6/5 with super menace as long as Grief is gone, but fair warning, for Reanimate to wane as a Black staple, Troll likely too has to go.


r/MTGLegacy • • Aug 26 '19

New Players New B&R

0 Upvotes

Well modern just keeps messing up, I’m officially joining you guys for the foreseeable future.