Look, I get it.
Murktide regent is just a beater, and “a BeAtEr CoUlDn’T pOsSiBlY wArRaNt A bAn In LeGaCy”
But Why Should Blue get the biggest 2-3 mana Beater in the format, with evasion and which is difficulty to remove?
The combination of size, cost, evasion, and difficulty of removal on a blue threat is putting incredible pressure on the format, and has greatly constricted the metagame. It’s not a coincidence that all the new broken turbo Xerox decks warranting bans are 2 colors running Murktide Regent.
Let’s take a moment to walk through just how incredibly powerful the big blue dragon actually is for “just a beater”
Firstly, Murktide Regent is huge even by Legacy Standards
A fully loaded 8/8 Murktide Regent has more power than any threat traditionally run in Reanimator. It’s straight up bigger than Griselbrand, Atraxa, [[Chancellor of the Annex]], [[Iona, Shield of Emeria]], and even has more power than [[Inkwell Leviathan]].
The only larger creatures commonly run in Legacy are Emrakul, and Phyrexian Dreadnought, which both realistically require combos in order to effectively get into play.
That’s just a demonstrably different class of threat than the traditional 4/5 Tarmogoyf or 5/5 Gurmag Angler. Now in all fairness, it takes some effort to get an 8/8 Murktide Regent.
But even the “trivial” to accomplish 5/5 Murktide regent, and the common 6/6 version are huge, presenting a 3-4 turn clock and matching/outclassing traditional legacy Beatsticks like [[Gurmag Angler]] and [[Tarmogoyf]], while also adding evasion.
The Evasion of Murktide Regent is the Second Key Dimension of the Card
In the past, beatsticks and evasive creatures were two different classes of cards. Tarmogoyf, Gurmag Angler, and Batterskull all lacked evasion.
But Murktide Regent can fly, which is incredibly difficult to effectively block against in Today’s legacy. Even as a 5/5 Murktide regent is the biggest fair flyer running around in the format and can kill any typical fair non-murktide blocker. This problem is only further accentuated for non-blue decks, which often have to rely on more mana expensive cards to chump block, like Yorion and Endurance.
All of which is to say, a Murktide regent on the attack is often connecting for damage, and a lot of damage. There is no “mana dork or snapcaster mage blocking Gurmag Angler” here. Nor do you have “lots of time” to find an answer a-la flipped Delver. A 5/5 Murktide regent kills in 4 swings, a 6/6 can often get there in 3, and 7/7 or 8/8 regents can swing a game substantially with even a single hit. With very few ways for the opponent to slow down that clock.
As a result, opponents need to get a Murktide Regent off the board quickly, but
Murktide Regent third key aspect is that it’s hard to remove
The only consistent, widely played, answers to Murktide Regent in Legacy are:
Swords to Plowshares, Solitude, Pyroblast, Snuff Out, and… Murktide Regent. (And sometimes a 1-of Murderous Cut in Beans decks).
Popular Legacy answers like Lightning Bolt, Fatal Push, Abrupt Decay, and Prismatic Ending simply don’t work at all against the dragon, while answers like Dismember, Unholy Heat, Sheoldred’s Edict, and Flame of Arnor are painfully unreliable, able to answer only small or unaccompanied regents.
Murktide Regent demands specific answers.
And, just like evasive threats used to be a different category of threat than “beaters”, removal dodging threats used to be their own category (see Nimble Mongoose, and True Name Nemesis). Murktide Regent, however combines all of these roles into one big evasive hard to remove threat. It is the midrange multi-tool of threats.
And it does so for only 2 (ish) mana in Blue
Which is huge.
One of the biggest historical weakness of blue in Legacy, was that it lacked good top end threats. So decks splashed white for Stoneforge Mystic (and the accompanying Batterskull/Kaldra), or Black for Tomstalker then later Gurmag Angler, or green for Tarmogoyf, or had to concede size in exchange for better mana. Those different splashes lent themselves to varying playstyles, and forced real decisions in terms of what cards would be available, or how vulnerable the mana would be, for a given deck.
Furthemore, non-blue fair decks could turn to cards like [[Knight of the Reliquary]], and [[Endless One]], and “good-in-nic-fit.card” to go bigger than their blue adversaries.
But now, Murktide Regent blows all those old threats out of the water, and exists in a tier of its own. No other threat in legacy offers so much size, for so little deckbuilding investment, and has evasion, and is so hard to answer. The Blue Dragon facilitates delver and other turbo Xerox decks being trivially two color. Why play Grixis or RUG delver with worse mana when UR has a complete threat suite? Alternatively, throw 2-3 Murktide Regents in a UB shell, and you’ll have a complete mid-range creature package, leaving plenty of free space to throw in a reanimator package.
There’s no need to worry about splashing or making deckbuilding concessions to get access to evasive threats, hard to remove threats, and large threats. Just run some instants and sorceries in blue.
Now some people will comment that Murktide Regent is often played in only 2-3 copies to a deck, but the reality is that’s all that you need. You only really need 3 attacks from a regent over the course of a game to win, and 2-3 copies provides plenty of redundancy to accomplish that aim in a blue shell.
Others might point out that Murktide Regent is only the third most player creature in Legacy, and has only been in about 27% of Legacy decks so far in 2025 (according to MTGTop8), whereas Tamiyo sees far more play (in about 37%).
But 1: Tamiyo is herself potentially a problem.
2: Murktide Regent makes Tamiyo way more of a problem, by presenting a 1 turn clock when played in duplicates off of a Tamiyo ult. Since redundant copies can grow beyond 8/8. (It also comboed with Psychic Frog).
And 3: Murktide Regent doesn’t need to be in more than a quarter of all decks to be having an outsized impact on the metagame. If you want to play fair in Legacy, you need to have a solution to the dragon, and if you want to combo you need to be able to outrace it.
Fair threats often set the benchmark for format speed, and in Legacy today you need to do something before the dragon can kill you out of a tempo deck.
Some people also argue that banning Murktide Regent is pointless since alternatives exist like [[Cryptic Serpent]] and [[Ethereal Forager]], but those creatures lack evasion and are much smaller respectively.
The reality is that Murktide Regent is in a class of its own. This type of evasive hard to remove low cost super-beater is largely unprecedented in Legacy, and is incredibly toxic in blue. It has unduly trivialized deck construction for blue decks, and puts pressure on the format velocity. It seems like an incredibly reasonable format boundary to say that blue can’t have the best large beater in the format, let alone one that is also evasive.
Further, there’s strong reason to believe that banning Murktide Regent would do a lot of good for the format.
Firstly, it would relieve some of the pressure presented by the Turbo Xerox shell, by forcing more decisions about the associated creature package. Right now Ux Tempo decks can just run Murktide Regent as a Beater/Evasive-Threat/Hard-to-Remove-Threat blue wunder-kard. Alternatives like Cryptic Serpent, Gurmag Angler, Barrowgoyf, and Tarmogoyf can cover some of those bases, but not all of them.
Secondly, it would invite more diversity in blue shells. Second and third color splashes become a much more complex conversation when non-blue creature quality becomes a bigger deal.
Thirdly, it would provide a boon to ailing control and non-blue fair decks by weakening the top end of aggro/tempo blue decks.
I get that Murktide Regent is not necessarily "classically broken" by historical legacy standards, but it really does seem like the card just is a net negative for the overall format quality. If it's valid to remove cards like Sowing Mycospawn for housekeeping reasons, why not Murktide Regent?