Now, hopefully before you flame and downvote me into oblivion, you will understand that I am not saying EVE is the best MMO. I understand that objectively it definitely has problems and can be rough around the edges, and that subjectively it is not everyone’s cup of tea.
However, I am saying that some of the philosophy and systems behind EVE are the best of any MMO, and makes it one of the few ‘true’ MMOs currently on the market, imho.
Stick with me, some of my thoughts on the matter are a bit hard to put into words, but I am going to do my best to convey what I mean. There is definitely a wall of text incoming, but I will try to summarize it via a tl;dr at the end.
To start off with, I am going to argue that EVE Online is one of the only true MASSIVELY multiplayer games, thanks to its single-shard universe.
In other MMOs, the player base is split into separate shards and servers based on their real-world geographical location. These separate shards might have a maximum population of a couple thousand at most, but often far below that.
In my opinion, there is nothing massively multiplayer about that. Most of the time, these MMOs feel even less ‘multiplayer’ than an arcade lobby shooter.
EVE Online, on the other hand, has a single shard that the entire playerbase plays on. Tens of thousands of players are usually on at the same time, inhabiting the same world, and can all interact with each other.
There is no fancy phasing or server meshing. If I hear a battle is happening in a specific location, I can fly to that location and witness it.
This single-shard universe has a variety of benefits. The first is the most obvious: it can lead to the huge battles that make headlines. I can’t think of anything more massively multiplayer than thousands of players literally grouping up into huge fleets, working together towards the singular goal of winning a battle.
However, the single-shard universe has plenty of secondary and tertiary benefits as well, some of which aren’t as obvious at first glance. Even if you prefer playing solo or in small groups, this single-shard universe will have an effect on you.
It allows you to play with people from all over the world. EVE Online is the only game where I, as an American located on the east coast, have been able to play with an English, German, Swedish, Russian, and Australian person, all at the same time. As corny as it may sound, this can lead to a lot of real-life growth. While this was only a group of six, I will argue that there are very few things more massively multiplayer than this.
It adds a feeling of life and activity to the world. When I visit NYC, I am not necessarily going to interact with everybody I pass on the street. However, just those people being there makes the city feel alive. The same is true in EVE Online. One of my favorite activities when I first started playing the game was simply parking outside of a popular station (basically the counterpart to a major city in other MMOs) and people-watching. I enjoyed seeing all of the different types of ships docking and undocking, going about their days. I would invent backstories for them, and imagine what they were up to. That lumbering freighter could be loaded with cargo vital to the current war effort, and was currently heading to the deepest fringes of lawless outer space. That flaming miner could be returning with a full load of precious ore after just barely surviving a gank. That cruiser bristling with missile launchers could be returning after handily soloing EVE’s counterpart to a dungeon. While I am not directly interacting with any of these people, their mere existence is improving my experience. This might technically be possible in other MMOs. I’ve had similar experiences watching people in Ironforge in WoW. With that said, the scale of EVE propels the experience to new heights.
It allows for routine and familiarity. If I tend to stay in the same area of the world long enough, I will become familiar with my neighbors. Even if I never say a word to them, I will get to know them over time. Simply by existing in the same space as them, I will learn their general routines, play styles, dispositions, etc. I will notice when they are gone, and wonder what happened to them. This shared experience is what makes a game massively multiplayer. In many other MMOs, there is back-end phasing trickery going on, where it might phase in and out other players, and I might never see the same person twice. That prevents this sort of familiarity.
Directly tying into the single-shard universe is the entirely player-run market. Even if I am a solo player, I am going to be interacting with others by simply using the market. When I buy anything on the market, whether that be a ship, a weapon, or even a single piece of ammo, it is guaranteed that another player has had a hand in making that, and it is likely that it has actually been the work of multiple different players.
Firstly, it requires a miner to go out and gather the raw materials.
Those raw materials are then likely to be sold on the market to another player.
That second player will then process those raw materials into refined materials.
That second player might then use those refined materials themselves, or might sell them on the market to a third player.
This third player will then use those refined materials to craft something.
That third player can then list that crafted item on the market for me to buy. Obviously, a single player might do all of those things themselves to limit overhead, but the outcome is the same, I am interacting with other players simply by existing in the world.
The entire market is interconnected, interdependent, and quite volatile. Even disparate groups of players can all have an impact on the market, and are therefore indirectly affecting each other.
If there is a war going on between player alliances, and a certain type of ‘doctrine’ ship is being destroyed and consumed much more than normal, the demand and price of that ship might increase, causing ripples across the universe as other players start mass-producing that ship type, or switching to other cheaper ships for their own use.
If one group decides to go on a crusade against miners, and starts destroying mining ships en masse, it will have an actual impact on the amount of resources available, and the price of everything on the market is going to skyrocket in turn.
A single player may decide to liquidate their assets, and dump thousands of items onto the market. This could tank the cost of that item.
A single player might see a need for resources to be transported to some backwater system. They could single-handedly seed that system with items, becoming both a much-needed resource, as well as something of a baron to the people who inhabit that system.
The very market these items are being bought and sold at could be located in a station that was built by other players. Dozens of players could have worked together, directly or indirectly, to mine the resources and build the station that you are now docked at. The one you see as safe harbor, where your items are stored, where you use the market, where you repair your ship. In fact, one of the largest trade-hubs in the game for years was a station that was a cooperative between the largest alliances in the game - some of them mortal enemies, boasting a combined membership in the tens of thousands of players - that shared the tax income with each other.
Even if I never say a word to another player, their existence is having an impact on me, and my existence is having an impact on them. I can think of few things that are more massively multiplayer than that.
I could go on, but think I am going to leave it there for now.
TL;DR - EVE Online is one of the only true massively multiplayer games, because of its:
Single shard universe, that allows a massive amount of players to group together, that allows players from all over the world to play together, and that allows players from all over the world to have an impact on each other, even if that is only in the form of ‘background noise’.
Player-run economy, which combines with the single-shard universe and ensures players are interacting and having an impact on each other, even if they never share a word.
Discussion Questions: Do you agree or disagree with this sentiment? Do you think other popular MMOs would be better or worse if they tried to implement some of these systems? What are some quintessential ‘gold standard’ systems other MMOs incorporate?
Edit - also, just to be clear, I haven't played EVE in about 10 years at this point, so I'll admit some of this is probably rose-tinted glasses. While I am sure EVE has been updated and changed in that time, the core systems I am talking about remain the same. I have also put hundreds or thousands of hours into various other MMOs in that time, including WoW, GW2, New World, ESO, etc. While EVE was my 'first love' in terms of MMOs, I wouldn't necessarily qualify myself as an EVE player anymore.
Edit 2 - Your boos mean nothing, I've seen what makes you cheer.