r/MMORPG • • Apr 18 '18

Misinformation, read comments BDO just released its "Gamekiller" Patch which destroys all balance, makes the gap between new players and old players MASSIVE and they increase the shop prices on everything

0 Upvotes

So basically today the new "Gearscore" patch went life, which basically gives a lot of buffs and more stats to people with good gear and fucks over new players or anyone with weaker gear.

Good geared players are now basically twice as strong while weak geared players actually lost stats.

If you have gotten oneshot before, now a single player with good gear can take up on 30-40 medium to weak geared players. This effectively kills the entire low Tier siege scene as a single player can now join Low tier sieges and continues to solo 3-4 guilds. You think Archeage pay2win and powercreep was insane? BDO is basically like activating GM mode now.

They also drastically increased the prices on all the outfits to milk their playerbase one final time before everyone without the absolute best gear quits.


r/MMORPG • • Nov 12 '20

Misleading World of Warcraft will now cost Aus players $AUD20/month. No reason why. Just because. Nothing extra. Just pay more.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/MMORPG • • May 14 '25

Meme People trying to convince you these AoC skins look good

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/MMORPG • • Nov 15 '25

Discussion Why do people love GW2 so much?

0 Upvotes

I’ve tried to get into this game time and time again. I have yet to talk to a single person besides them hopping into a quest really quick. I’m level 30 now, when does it become a multiplayer game? The word MMO is thrown around too much. I want groups and killing mobs together.


r/MMORPG • • Apr 18 '24

Question FFXIV gets praised for essentially redoing the same thing every expansion. Why?

5 Upvotes

I've played WoW and FF14 since the start of each MMO. I'll never understand the praise FF14 gets for essentially being stuck in a Warlords of Draenor loop with each expansion. It honestly feels like to me a fancier version of the WoD expansion in WoW. Dungeons that don't matter, everyone lives in their housing spaces and the open world of the game is pretty dead. Why? Is this something the developers are working on? Everything I've seen from the new expansion is just cosmetic so far besides the new classes.

I finished the Hydaelin arc in Endwalker then quit after beating the first savage and doing some ultimate raids. Looking at the WoW expansion vs the new FFXIV expansion just seems like FFXIV is so behind and just doing the same thing and hoping it works. I liked it before when it held my interest for a bit because I could swap off MMOs during each downtime but maybe I should try GW2 for a secondary mmo?


r/MMORPG • • Dec 21 '25 Popcorn Bravo

Opinion My Review: Ashes of Creation

29 Upvotes

Hi all - lots of strong opinions and feelings being shared around Ashes of Creation. I wanted to avoid repeating the same negatives that have come so far, though several are valid, in order to provide a more positive perspective from someone who’s had a very happy and enjoyable first 100 hours. I hope this helps people who are on the fence or feel they’ve seen only one side of the discussion. I want to be clear that the game DOES need work; I don’t intend to mislead or anything - I just want to offer a different view from my gaming experience so far. I hope it helps those on the fence.

This is my Steam review:

People calling this a scam are really off the mark here from what I can tell in my first 100 hours, but I do appreciate the optics that leads them to that conclusion. I want to be clear that the game DOES need work, which has been largely documented by many others, but it also has many positives, and I want to highlight them:

  1. Excellent spell/casting animations

  2. Interesting and engaging class design

  3. Functioning node systems with inter-node trading, caravan pvp events, and zone development

  4. A robust and varied crafting system; simple systems, but full of items, materials and interconnectivity, which provide relevant, competitive gear.

  5. A range of enemies, each with mechanics, casts and telegraphs to engage with.

  6. A range of new events, quests, bosses and dungeons that pop up alongside zone development.

  7. A variety of mounts, boats, tools, weapon types.

  8. Varied and interesting biomes, each with unique and valuable materials/enemies that create a need for inter-zone trading (no global auction house)

  9. (Particularly subjective) A slow, gentle pace of levelling designed to make the journey the game, not the end.

Since this Early Access Alpha, I've witnessed the Intrepid team do the following:

  1. Land hotfix after hotfix live on servers

  2. Respond immediately and swiftly to any big bugs/exploits that appear

  3. Actively shut down and restart servers in response to performance issues

  4. Open a new US server due to population demand

  5. Experiment and change drop rates as well as mob spawn rates and density

It has been a genuinely pleasant experience playing AoC. No, it's not finished, nor is it perfect, but it has all the things it needs to succeed. People are rightly impatient after a long wait, but this game is being actively developed and managed. I do not sense a scam based on the work on the devs since release; I think this can really go somewhere.


r/MMORPG • • Jul 07 '19

FFXIV:Shadowbringers score 9.5 on metacritic user reviews

0 Upvotes

FFXIV is what's killing the mmo genre. It's currently the highest rated mmo but at the same time it's the least innovative and most horrible in it's mmo aspects.

  • Generic anime-themed story ✓

  • Bad pvp the game ✓

  • Slow and repetitive combat from 1 - 80 ✓

  • Bad to non existent open world content ✓

  • Repetitive and boring leveling process ✓

  • Shallow and meaningless gear progression ✓

  • Staying in the city afk waiting for reset while showing your costume ✓

  • Constant E-RP'ing in public which is utterly disgusting ✓

This is the mmo that's killing the genre with it's mediocrity. And without its final fantasy name, this game would have been thrown in the forgotten mmo bin a long time ago.


r/MMORPG • • 15d ago

Discussion Anyone actually hyped for Evercold after watching the fan festivals?

12 Upvotes

I have 7k hours in FF14 and for the first time, after watching every fan fest, i'm like "meh". Endgame loop, even if there are some changes, is still pretty much the same as before. Cutting raids in half is something nobody asked for. What most people wanted is a new endgame loop, but once again it will just be "Farm Tomestones > Get Gear". Nothing about potential new game modes or endgame activities. I know Yoshi P saved the game more than a decade ago, but it feels like its time that someone with new ideas and the balls to try something new to take over.


r/MMORPG • • Dec 22 '25

image Ashes of Creation, Everyone

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/MMORPG • • Jun 09 '26

News Summary of future of Guild Wars franchise livestream

Post image
0 Upvotes
  1. ⁠Does annual updates = expansions?": Yes, the goal is to return to annual expansions, "updates" was a miswording/is just their internal terminology for expansions. (Annual expansions are their "sweet spot" after iterating through different content cadences.)

  2. ⁠Are you concerned that taking an 18-month break will affect player retention?: No, they're happy to be able to "modernize" content (+ it has been a longtime player request). They also think it's a good opportunity to bring in new and returning players, hence the recent changes to how things are bundled. Mentions it "isn't just bugfixing"; talks a lot about Zhaitan fight, brief HoT & PoF namedrops. Also says there isn't no new content at all (new Orr map + WvW borderlands). Colin is an Asura Engi main. Guardian who?

  3. ⁠Why not do expansions and modernization in parallel?: Business concerns, internal team size, time, trying to do both at once would result in both being very underwhelming. Some past expansions have done a bit of modernizing (e.g. Wizard's Vault), but the new effort is supposed to target all of the game rather than just the latest expansion.

  4. ⁠Can ArenaNet deliver on developing GW2, GW3 simultaneously?: Mentions they've been internally preparing for years to do simultaneous development (+ partnering with 2weeks), and have been doing it for some time. ArenaNet is split in "three mini-studios" (one for GW2, a very small one for GW1, presumably one for GW3). FTEs dedicated to GW2 are dedicated only to GW2, no borrowing of resources. GW2 and GW3 have very different tools, tech stacks.

  5. ⁠Will the Hall of Monuments give rewards for previously-achieved achievements, or will it require replaying?: More news to come later, goal is to do both. First two releases will be core game only (second will be overworld + story content), expansions will be afterward, goal is to have a 1.5-2 month spacing, some new achievements & Wizard's Vault objectives; rewards for both GW2 & GW3. GW2's HoM is the "next iteration" of the HoM.

  6. ⁠Will GW1 Reforged be connected to the new Hall of Monuments?: At the moment, no, only GW2. GW1 Reforged devs are focused on the mobile port + new content. (They "will review" bringing back the GWAMM title.)

  7. ⁠Can GW2 support PBR without affecting performance?: It's difficult, but say they've learned from the various changes they've made over the years (e.g. DX11, new shaders, VoE lighting changes). Big challenge is getting assets developed outside PBR pipeline to work with assets made inside the PBR pipeline. Performance optimizations for GW2 are a separate and parallel effort in ANet. This year has seen new monitoring & diagnostics deployed for tracking server latency. They've been adding more granularity to shader options so people can "opt out" of new changes.

  8. ⁠What went wrong with Desert Borderlands, and how will the new one be different?: WuvWuh is hard to develop for due to having lots of different kinds of players (roamers, coordinated & uncoordinated groups, zergers, etc.). Desert Borderlands was too big (hard to find fights), too vertical, hard to navigate, bad objectives. Desert Borderlands was designed with what's best for gliding first (rather than what's best for WuvWuh), couldn't be redone once it launched. Want to release a greybox map for new map & do live betas for player feedback, comparison to PvP Rush.

  9. ⁠How will ANet ensure older GW2 maps & metas remain populated during the transition?: They expect new & returning players to come to GW2 (incl. players from GW3). Tangent to mention that GW2 has been "doing pretty well" even before GW3 announcement, GW2 has since seen a ~40% increase in daily active users since the GW3 announcement, Saturday was single best day for new player acquisition since 2022 Steam launch, VoE was a record for returning players (gone for a year or more) and this record was doubled this past Saturday. GW2 megaserver system was designed to keep content being/feeling populated. GW2 is an expansive game, but may be overwhelming for a new player + requires knowledge not in GW2/on the wiki (e.g. event timers); they would like to put more information in the game itself (at some point).

  10. ⁠Is mobile a long-time focus, or an experiment?: Mobile was the right choice for GW1 Reforged. GW1 Reforged was able to happen because of the unexpected success of GW1 anniversary, GW1 Reforged has been bigger than expected (hence mobile port).

  11. ⁠GW2 on console or mobile?: No to both, ANet has explored console in the past (2009, 2014, 2021) but concluded it couldn't/wouldn't happen. Console & crossplay would require compromises to the game/significant changes to the feel of the game given the GW2 tech stack. GW3 being designed to be played on console is part of what makes it "different".

  12. ⁠Why 3 different games across 3 different parts of the timeline?: ANet games start from addressing player concerns/problems, MMOs have been stagnant so they thought it was "time to solve a different problem". GW1, GW2, GW3 are very different types of games ("MMO experiences") and can appeal to different kinds of people (with overlap). GW1, GW2 were MMOs for people who hates MMOs, GW3 is following that lineage. HoM is the unique ecosystem that connects the Guild Wars games, drove GW2 players to play GW1. Mentions regret of not investing more in GW1 Reforged earlier, HoM will be "much more expansive" to connect GW2 & GW3. Intent is for Guild Wars players to be able to enjoy all 3 games. Being in different points in time allows GW2 to tell stories that can't be told in GW3, and vice versa. Taimi will likely not be in GW3, sorry to all Taimi fans. GW2 has many story threads left open. GW2 is magitech, has sci-fi elements, unique aesthetics with the Charr & Asura, was a big jump from GW1; GW3 is meant to be very different, grounded high fantasy, "almost no technology", the GW3->GW1 technological jump is much smaller than GW1->GW2. GW1 & GW2 set up stories & mysteries for GW3.

  13. ⁠"How will GW2 look like 5 years from now"?: Final question. They hope that GW2 can keep feeling like people's homes. Want to close story threads in GW2 + set up new stories, similar to what they're already doing now. Next expansion development likely starts next year, but news will only come after the launch of GW3. They've been quiet for the past little while on GW2 news due to waiting for the GW3 announcement, but there'll be more communication going forward. Colin confirms that GW4 will be a Roller Beetle racing game (100% real).


r/MMORPG • • Apr 15 '24

Discussion Throne and Liberty is completely broken. There are massive amount of dupes and stat altering cheaters/hackers on the Korean servers.

7 Upvotes

Ive been playing on the Korean servers as I was excited for the game and once I saw all the problems I regret playing it altogether.

The game is full of speed hackers and even people altering their character stats to the point where they are killing world bosses, which require huge numbers of players in a single hit. This is because the client is the one doing most of the work and the server is not checking for people who are hacking. People are cheating using the client side. I was also getting killed by people in a single hit as well when I was far higher level and in powerful tank gear. They are also clipping and moving though walls as well.

Its going to be far worse in the west because There will be no need for identification like the Koreans Require. This will mean that the game will be flooded with bots that kill everything in one hit and doesn't matter if they get banned, just like in runescape they will get replaced immediately after getting banned.

We all hate the phrase P2W, but this game is actually cheat to win (C2W).

Even if it wasn't P2W, it would still be 100% pure dogshit. Avoid this game. Throne and liberty is a giant turd that disguises itself as a beautiful world. NCsoft is trying to release this trash in the west to make up for its failure in Korea.


r/MMORPG • • Oct 03 '23

Opinion Servers moving from "small-island communities" to "mega-servers" has been detrimental to the genre

9 Upvotes

When you have cross-server, cross-platform, and can sit in town to do most activities...is the game even still an MMO? There isn't a world to actually interact with. Toxicity and lack of real social interaction has increased since Servers no longer matter.

In a small island community everyone knows everyone. People have a reputation, and any actions (whether good or bad) will be remembered and associated with them. Having a reputation is a great reason to not be toxic to someone, but when you never see these people again, there are no consequences for being toxic.

Then there's the other side, positive interactions. These get stifled out because there's little reason to get to know people you will likely never see again. It does make sense, if you are on a trip and land in a huge city, talking and getting to know a stranger doesn't really make a lot of sense. Now on the other hand, if you go to a small island to visit, most people will probably be very interested in you since they know everyone, and they don't know you.

The conveniences of modern gaming has actually pushed MMOs away from what made them MMOs in the first place. Next-gen MMOs need to see a shift back towards these smaller communities, so players can feel that "immersive world" many of us specifically like this genre for.

EDIT: It's quite interesting to see such a strong divide between preferring small or mega servers. Perhaps the MMO genre needs to branch into 2 sub-genres: One for small servers that focus on worlds to be a part of, and another for megaservers with lots of instanced content that is easy to get into.

EDIT2: LMAO unlucky I posted this the same day NW is having server issues hahaha!


r/MMORPG • • Jun 14 '24

Discussion Didn't expect to say it, but New World is starting to grow on me.

2 Upvotes

I have played some hours recently after finally battling my own free will, and im actually enjoying it. I bought it in 2022, played some and put it down. I have played a little over the span of time since then and it just didn't feel good playing it. Now that im finally getting down and dirty with the game, in terms of actually spending the time to see if I actually enjoy it, I love a lot of aspects of New World.

I enjoy the combat, mainly because I have been playing games like ESO (combat I don't dislike but simple and not as immersive) and games like WoW or LOTRO where the combat is more click to attack, etc. In New World it is like a 3rd person shooter with a shotgun, rifle or bow. It's a lot more immersive with a sword or any other weapon because you can get more close and personal, not to the mention the world itself is overloaded with materials you can mine, chop down, and harvest overall. Animals are plentiful and easy and fun to hunt. The grind is enjoyable so far for me. Their is an actual challenge as well. Many areas, even by the starting zone can be challenging if you happen to wander in them.

Anyways, the point of this post is to say, give New World, or any other game a chance, I thought I disliked it, I thought the graphics were kind of shabby over the time after release, but I spend some time in it and my performance has gone up, my entertainment has also risen. I am really happy with it right now.

New World isn't perfect, not by any means. It's world is enthralling, immersive but it's lacking on some features.

It could of utilized a more immersive player housing system, it could have been one of the only MMO's to give the players an ability to build their house from scratch, out in the wild with plots, etc. It could of utilized more survival dynamics, that would of been more interesting in terms of the challenge and creativity.

A first person mode would have been amazing to see, pretty easy to implement wouldn't be? Maybe im missing something, maybe the devs said something, but it's included in a ton of MMO's already, like ESO for example. It does as a lot more immersion.

(Also I do know New World is kind of stepping away from the MMO title, either way I still consider it an MMO)


r/MMORPG • • Apr 11 '18

FFXIV is very bad.

0 Upvotes

I was a tank 70 since 2013 beta but gave the account to my friend because i thought i wouldnt return the game then Went back for nostalgia and level again a SAM to 62 currently doing SB main story quest, holy shit im so fucking burned of go here and there and kill 4 mobs that i dont know how i last so long, dropped the game already this time forever, so much boredom and agony of playing this shit.

Yes it has good graphics, music and pve boss battles, but thats all this game has , the open world and social part is really bad, i barely talk to anyone until SB, seriously they have to stop doing that stupid quest system and change it or kill it forever, this thing is the worst, what a shit of boredom, stop the quests already give the char at max level to enter the fun directly( if any) or create a new system but for love of god stop with that horrible quest system all the time going here and there draining your time for nothing and felling on rails, ffxiv is really a shit mmo, regret being restarted, only good thing is pve... and its feel allmost on rails too!! , doesnt have the freedom of wildstar pve bosses for example, even pve in ffxiv is on rails, fails the mechanic? You die, in wildstar for example there are differents ways of do a mechanics, dont feel on rails like ffxiv in pve, sorry my english, ffxiv is so bad.


r/MMORPG • • Feb 12 '22

News Lost 1.1 million concurrent players on Steam right now. Keeps breaking records WOW.

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/MMORPG • • Aug 20 '24

image My EAGLE ARCHER cant be stopped !!! I just hit 99 in crafting !!! Runescape 3 !!!

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/MMORPG • • Mar 11 '20

I feel like a fool for subbing to WOW classic

10 Upvotes

for 6 months I had subbed to WOW classic, but after that I stopped the game. Now I feel like a fool for subbing to WOW as I could have easily played a better quality version on PServers for free. I feel like a big fool because I subbed to a game that came 15 years ago and it's not even relevant in today's world.

Compared to modern day MMOs WOW feels very inferior in every element, only thing that was good was leveling and progressing till 60 and the fixed loot without ilevel. In all other systems it feel very dated.

Glad I didn't pay for more and realized this, made me feel like a real fool who fell for the hype.

This sub had previously warned me about the same, but I didn't realize it until now.


r/MMORPG • • Aug 18 '24

Discussion Ashes of Creation defenders read this.

3 Upvotes

I made similar comment on utube and I'm gonna post it here too. I believe people who are supporting Ashes of Creation monetization are actually causing a long term damage for future MMO games. People who are white knighting AoC monetization their go to argument is "nobody is forcing you to buy" or "I'm doing this to support the development of the game." While that reasoning is fine, it will encourage future MMO development to do what Star Citizen and AoC are doing.

  1. Kickstart an ambitious MMO.

  2. Keep people hyped by uploading shiny updates about the game development on utube page.

  3. Sell overpriced FOMO cosmetics and Alpha Keys.
    Usual MMO development time is probably around 6 years but if you are making money selling Alpha keys what's the point of finishing the game? Just milk it stay in Alpha for 10+ years and keep selling keys.. Star Citizen did it and is now 13 years old, AoC is 7 years old. Many AoC defenders haven't realize it yet but they are ruining the future of MMO's.. They are creating the new meta of MMO development.
    I don't know what is the 1st game that made big bucks selling loot boxes, but when other companies realized someone made bank selling it, everybody starts selling loot boxes.. I imagine it would be the same for MMO once they discover MMO fans are willing to pay hundreds of dollars for Alpha keys. For now the large gaming companies haven't noticed it yet but when they realize that MMO players are willing to pay lots of money to test a game that may or may not be ever released it will become the norm.. So keep ignorantly defending this type of monetization, if were unlucky maybe not only MMO but even single player games will sell Alpha keys too.. I bet GTA 7 would make billions before release if they sell alpha keys.. People who are supporting this type of monetization reminds me of Dustin feeding the Demogorgon, he didn't know he was raising a monster. (sorry for the grammar, not native English speaker)


r/MMORPG • • Jun 21 '21

Discussion Anyone else thinks that Aion Classic won't be successful at all?

2 Upvotes

Game was super grindy, RnG heavy and didn't have much content. Abyss PvP was basically who has the bigger zerg. Normal PvP was also just getting a group and farming single players that are leveling. So overall, PvP in Aion has nothing to do with skill. 12 years ago this was probably fun and newish but i doubt that anyone would play the game if it would come out today.


r/MMORPG • • 17d ago

Discussion NCSoft is actually winning against bots

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/MMORPG • • Nov 25 '24

Discussion You should play Oldschool Runescape -- Here's Why.

9 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I spent the last few weeks editing a rather large video essay covering my experience in OSRS over the past year. You can watch it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NuaCg6XhWr0

Any and all support/constructive criticism would be greatly appreciated!


I summarized a few of my most important points below:

After quitting World of Warcraft, I bounced between multiple different MMOs -- Guild Wars 2, FF14, ESO, and eventually BDO which sparked my intrigue over the sandbox elements (that were somewhat spoiled by the MTX).

After that, my friends and I decided to, almost as a joke, starting a Group Ironman in OSRS, and the following year-long experience somewhat changed my perspective on MMOs in general.


Elements of an MMORPG that, to me, create for the best game.

  1. Longterm progression that isn't consistently devalued by new content releases. Powercreep and powergrowth is totally fine, however, it shouldn't be the only backbone of the game -- soft resets every 6-odd months work for an ARPG, but they do not fit the longterm engagement demanded by an MMORPG.

  2. Binary interactions form the blueprint to all game design, and too often modern MMOs shy away from contextualizing these kinds of interactions with deeper systems. What is awesome about OSRS is that it seems to operate in an entirely different language to most contemporary MMORPGs -- the way items interact, the way systems intersect, the way all forms of progression (power and not) lead to an overwhelming feeling of persistent growth -- each element here is crucial to making a world that isn't just a large arena for combat.

  3. Itemization and general character progression is crucial. I came up with 3 facets that make for exceptional progression: Rewards ought be proportional to the time investment they demand. Time investment is at the center of most of the rewards in the game. Rewards should almost never exist in a vacuum. So many MMOs tend to half-ass one (or all) of these crucial elements.

  4. Systems and Functions > Fidelity and Gaudiness -- One of the most evocative elements of OSRS is how every single system seemingly intersects with another. This intersection tends to provides value and depth without overwhelming system bloat. It's much easier to understand the overlapping processes/systems when they all operate in a similar 1-0 binary.


General Takeaways:

Something my video highlights is the language of game design. And, on top of that, discusses how a game must, in some ways, demand respect from its players to be given that respect back.

This is most often seen within OSRS's questing system, that not only teaches you the simple binary systems of the game (and how they expand out in complex ways), but also demands enough attention and respect from you to actually create a meaningful journey out of whatever you're doing.

Even through all the questing helpers available today, the experience of some of the final, most difficult quests is utterly unrivaled by any other MMORPG currently popular on the market.


There is a lot more to write, but I figured that just this brief overview may spark some interesting conversation:

  1. What do y'all think of OSRS? Are you turned off by the graphics? Or is the slower nature of the early game something that wards you away?

  2. Have you played it? What do you appreciate about the game?

  3. What do you think modern MMOs could learn from titles like OSRS which, unlike just about every popular MMO, are actually GROWING in playercount?


Thanks for reading/watching!


r/MMORPG • • Mar 13 '22

Discussion Unpopular Opinion: I honestly prefer playing MMORPG from late 00's then crap they release these days!

0 Upvotes

Trow hate if you want, I've been on a quest to find same joy in playing modern mmorpg like i had when i used to play these old ones, it seems non if the new games gives me such satisfaction and i realized many old ones are way better. I don't know what's up with the new ones but they simply makes me boring and can't handle playing them more then few days, they miss that "something" that i can only find when playing old MMORPG. Don't know what it is.


r/MMORPG • • Jan 03 '22

Discussion Let's have a positive discussion - what features in the next WoW expansion would bring you back to the game?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/MMORPG • • Mar 01 '24

Discussion Hot Take: EVE Online is the quintessential ‘gold standard’ of MMOs, and is the best example of what an MMO is and what an MMO should be.

16 Upvotes

Now, hopefully before you flame and downvote me into oblivion, you will understand that I am not saying EVE is the best MMO. I understand that objectively it definitely has problems and can be rough around the edges, and that subjectively it is not everyone’s cup of tea.

However, I am saying that some of the philosophy and systems behind EVE are the best of any MMO, and makes it one of the few ‘true’ MMOs currently on the market, imho.

Stick with me, some of my thoughts on the matter are a bit hard to put into words, but I am going to do my best to convey what I mean. There is definitely a wall of text incoming, but I will try to summarize it via a tl;dr at the end.


To start off with, I am going to argue that EVE Online is one of the only true MASSIVELY multiplayer games, thanks to its single-shard universe.

In other MMOs, the player base is split into separate shards and servers based on their real-world geographical location. These separate shards might have a maximum population of a couple thousand at most, but often far below that.

In my opinion, there is nothing massively multiplayer about that. Most of the time, these MMOs feel even less ‘multiplayer’ than an arcade lobby shooter.

EVE Online, on the other hand, has a single shard that the entire playerbase plays on. Tens of thousands of players are usually on at the same time, inhabiting the same world, and can all interact with each other.

There is no fancy phasing or server meshing. If I hear a battle is happening in a specific location, I can fly to that location and witness it.

This single-shard universe has a variety of benefits. The first is the most obvious: it can lead to the huge battles that make headlines. I can’t think of anything more massively multiplayer than thousands of players literally grouping up into huge fleets, working together towards the singular goal of winning a battle.

However, the single-shard universe has plenty of secondary and tertiary benefits as well, some of which aren’t as obvious at first glance. Even if you prefer playing solo or in small groups, this single-shard universe will have an effect on you.

  • It allows you to play with people from all over the world. EVE Online is the only game where I, as an American located on the east coast, have been able to play with an English, German, Swedish, Russian, and Australian person, all at the same time. As corny as it may sound, this can lead to a lot of real-life growth. While this was only a group of six, I will argue that there are very few things more massively multiplayer than this.

  • It adds a feeling of life and activity to the world. When I visit NYC, I am not necessarily going to interact with everybody I pass on the street. However, just those people being there makes the city feel alive. The same is true in EVE Online. One of my favorite activities when I first started playing the game was simply parking outside of a popular station (basically the counterpart to a major city in other MMOs) and people-watching. I enjoyed seeing all of the different types of ships docking and undocking, going about their days. I would invent backstories for them, and imagine what they were up to. That lumbering freighter could be loaded with cargo vital to the current war effort, and was currently heading to the deepest fringes of lawless outer space. That flaming miner could be returning with a full load of precious ore after just barely surviving a gank. That cruiser bristling with missile launchers could be returning after handily soloing EVE’s counterpart to a dungeon. While I am not directly interacting with any of these people, their mere existence is improving my experience. This might technically be possible in other MMOs. I’ve had similar experiences watching people in Ironforge in WoW. With that said, the scale of EVE propels the experience to new heights.

  • It allows for routine and familiarity. If I tend to stay in the same area of the world long enough, I will become familiar with my neighbors. Even if I never say a word to them, I will get to know them over time. Simply by existing in the same space as them, I will learn their general routines, play styles, dispositions, etc. I will notice when they are gone, and wonder what happened to them. This shared experience is what makes a game massively multiplayer. In many other MMOs, there is back-end phasing trickery going on, where it might phase in and out other players, and I might never see the same person twice. That prevents this sort of familiarity.


Directly tying into the single-shard universe is the entirely player-run market. Even if I am a solo player, I am going to be interacting with others by simply using the market. When I buy anything on the market, whether that be a ship, a weapon, or even a single piece of ammo, it is guaranteed that another player has had a hand in making that, and it is likely that it has actually been the work of multiple different players.

  • Firstly, it requires a miner to go out and gather the raw materials.

  • Those raw materials are then likely to be sold on the market to another player.

  • That second player will then process those raw materials into refined materials.

  • That second player might then use those refined materials themselves, or might sell them on the market to a third player.

  • This third player will then use those refined materials to craft something.

  • That third player can then list that crafted item on the market for me to buy. Obviously, a single player might do all of those things themselves to limit overhead, but the outcome is the same, I am interacting with other players simply by existing in the world.

The entire market is interconnected, interdependent, and quite volatile. Even disparate groups of players can all have an impact on the market, and are therefore indirectly affecting each other.

  • If there is a war going on between player alliances, and a certain type of ‘doctrine’ ship is being destroyed and consumed much more than normal, the demand and price of that ship might increase, causing ripples across the universe as other players start mass-producing that ship type, or switching to other cheaper ships for their own use.

  • If one group decides to go on a crusade against miners, and starts destroying mining ships en masse, it will have an actual impact on the amount of resources available, and the price of everything on the market is going to skyrocket in turn.

  • A single player may decide to liquidate their assets, and dump thousands of items onto the market. This could tank the cost of that item.

  • A single player might see a need for resources to be transported to some backwater system. They could single-handedly seed that system with items, becoming both a much-needed resource, as well as something of a baron to the people who inhabit that system.

  • The very market these items are being bought and sold at could be located in a station that was built by other players. Dozens of players could have worked together, directly or indirectly, to mine the resources and build the station that you are now docked at. The one you see as safe harbor, where your items are stored, where you use the market, where you repair your ship. In fact, one of the largest trade-hubs in the game for years was a station that was a cooperative between the largest alliances in the game - some of them mortal enemies, boasting a combined membership in the tens of thousands of players - that shared the tax income with each other.
    Even if I never say a word to another player, their existence is having an impact on me, and my existence is having an impact on them. I can think of few things that are more massively multiplayer than that.

I could go on, but think I am going to leave it there for now.

TL;DR - EVE Online is one of the only true massively multiplayer games, because of its:

  • Single shard universe, that allows a massive amount of players to group together, that allows players from all over the world to play together, and that allows players from all over the world to have an impact on each other, even if that is only in the form of ‘background noise’.

  • Player-run economy, which combines with the single-shard universe and ensures players are interacting and having an impact on each other, even if they never share a word.

Discussion Questions: Do you agree or disagree with this sentiment? Do you think other popular MMOs would be better or worse if they tried to implement some of these systems? What are some quintessential ‘gold standard’ systems other MMOs incorporate?

Edit - also, just to be clear, I haven't played EVE in about 10 years at this point, so I'll admit some of this is probably rose-tinted glasses. While I am sure EVE has been updated and changed in that time, the core systems I am talking about remain the same. I have also put hundreds or thousands of hours into various other MMOs in that time, including WoW, GW2, New World, ESO, etc. While EVE was my 'first love' in terms of MMOs, I wouldn't necessarily qualify myself as an EVE player anymore.

Edit 2 - Your boos mean nothing, I've seen what makes you cheer.