r/MLBTheShow • • Sep 06 '24

First Look Season 3 is absolutely horrendous

15 Upvotes

Anyone else can’t stand the out of position cards? Just makes the game so unenjoyable for me


r/MLBTheShow • • Jan 31 '23

Meme I can’t be the only one, right?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • May 22 '24

Discussion Max elevation stadiums need to be removed from online play

5 Upvotes

If you are the away team at stadiums like shield Woods, Capital Lange, or any other max elevation stadium… There is zero chance you win that game. Stadiums like these reward the absolute worst of the worst swings. Tons of sub 90 mph runs every single game. for the love of God this mechanic.


r/MLBTheShow • • Aug 28 '21

Suggestion For SDS XP Cap is a horrible move by SDS.

1 Upvotes

Bosses literally aren’t accessible for 5 days. If i wanted to grind for it in a day I should be allowed to. If people are using exploits to get the xp, then either: A. Ban Them B. Make the methods they were using not give xp.

Just a colossal failure on SDS’ part. If people hit the daily xp cap, the incentive to play the game is decreased, and you’re losing player retention.

EDIT: you guys know it’s okay to criticize the game right? You don’t have to rush to SDS defense every time someone says something not positive about the game


r/MLBTheShow • • Feb 26 '24

Question Has there ever been a major game that has ever not had a trailer or literally any information less than three weeks until release?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been trying to think and I can’t think of one. This is absurd!


r/MLBTheShow • • May 16 '25

Meme Please SDS… Make it stop

Post image
2 Upvotes

I’m just sad this happens so frequently, and am trying to laugh through the pain


r/MLBTheShow • • May 26 '24

Discussion Ill get myself cooked for this opinion

1 Upvotes

But Captain Boosts have absolutely ruined this game, every damn game is just facing the same 9 switch hitters boosted to the gills over and over and over again

Everyone whined about no team diversity for years but now are fine just running the same players to make sure they get a boost


r/MLBTheShow • • Jul 31 '26

PSA People play in Coors because every aspect of SDS's XP, PXP, and program rewards paths incentives people to do so and punishes those who don't

0 Upvotes

No amount of raging, shaming, browbeating is going to change this.

Hitter XP, PXP, and the overwhelming majority of program progress in all programs, events, the Multiplayer program, etc. is based on accumulating XP hits, extra base hits, home runs, and runs. Coors helps you to do all of that faster.

Pitcher XP, PXP, and program progress is based on strikeouts, innings, wins, and saves. Coors does nothing to HURT any of those.

Particularly for average skill-players with limits on the time they can play, it's ENORMOUSLY beneficial to play in Coors to help parallel hitters and make progress in EVERYTHING - Seasons, MP program, any other programs, events, etc. Anyone with actual brain function plays their Mini-Season games in the smallest max altitude custom park possible for the same reason.

This would only change if pitcher XP/PXP was REDUCED by giving up runs, which I would say has zero chance of ever happening.

Remember the vast majority of DD players aren't destroying baseballs even on All-Star; you're vastly reducing your program/XP/PXP progress with a 2-1 score Event game or a 4-3 Ranked game in an average sea level MLB ballpark, instead of a 4-3 score Event game or an 8-7 Ranked game in Coors.

The main issue is SDS nerfed the altitude of all the fake minor league parks driving everyone to Coors.


r/MLBTheShow • • May 12 '26

Discussion How is it even possible for a development studio under SONY to be this incompetent?

0 Upvotes

This game launched almost 2 MONTHS AGO. And the game is currently UNPLAYABLE. like you literally cannot even load into a ranked game right now. Every single match disconnects, and bugs out your weekend classic rating. This is UTTERLY EMBARRASSING. We pay this company 70 dollars a year to play their game, and they could NOT CARE LESS about doing the bare minimum to make sure the game even functions properly.


r/MLBTheShow • • Feb 13 '24

Suggestion For SDS Tyler Skaggs, the final boss of my “Gone Too Soon” program, a program dedicated to players who died while they were actively playing baseball.

Post image
0 Upvotes

You would have to face him and the 2019 Angels down 4 with 20 outs to work with on Legend in the final showdown.


r/MLBTheShow • • Jun 11 '24

PSA Maybe unpopular opinion; But seasons are pretty awesome

72 Upvotes

I see a whole lot of complaints about the seasons and having to start the grind over of getting a new team, etc. but honestly, that’s the beauty of the entire thing. Not using the same 99 cards all year long, having to use different cards and discover some players you rake with that you never thought you would, core cards being available still and even the wildcard system is pretty dope

I’ve already got a 93 overall team in S2 and I’m using cards I never would have thought of before. Abraham Toro, Trey Mancini, Kyle Tucker, Eddie Murray, etc. Along with my parallel 5 David Peralta, P4 Derek Jeter core cards, and my P4 Kerry Wood wildcard makes for a interesting dynamic.

Keeps the game fresh and different and I don’t understand how guys don’t want to keep it feeling new. Just my opinion of course, but thought I’d share how much fun I’m having with the game this year

My record might not be the greatest (75-57) but this is the most fun I’ve ever had in DD with an MLB The Show game.


r/MLBTheShow • • Apr 20 '25

Appreciation Average Tyler Soderstrom hit

Post image
0 Upvotes

His no doubters seem to never land👀


r/MLBTheShow • • Apr 06 '24

Discussion Diamond Dynasty is the best it has ever been

186 Upvotes

The whining on this sub has reached new heights. Why aren’t we praising the changes that have made the mode more realistic? Last year was a joke with 99s all over the place that were free. I’m glad they fixed it to mirror actual baseball where owners with deep pockets have an advantage. The fact that teens, people who live in their mom’s basement, hourly employees, those without college educations and high paying jobs, etc could compete with those with strong finances was unrealistic, and frankly wrong.

Let’s also take some time to praise SDS for its excellent monetary policy in the stub economy. Adding Jelly Beans to packs in place of uniforms and equipment was great way of controlling stubflation. Those quick sells of uniforms and equipment were adding too many stubs into the economy. The reduction of XP earned per game was also a brilliant way to keep people from obtaining too many free packs and stubs. The fewer stubs in the economy, the more affordable the marketplace.

Downvote me all you want, but this version diamond dynasty is realistic and I’m all for it. Kudos to SDS for the improvements this year and I hope it becomes even harder to grind free cards as they roll out new seasons.


r/MLBTheShow • • Feb 15 '23

Question Does SDS still have a graphics department?

4 Upvotes

How are we about come out with the 3rd game on current generation hardware and it still looks EXACTLY the same as it did about 6 years ago, mid PS4 gen? Did they all get transferred to only making new card art? Did the graphics budget get slashed to afford the rights to more legends? Not a single graphical enhancement to be found in the current gen besides 4k resolution. Inexcusable.


r/MLBTheShow • • Apr 18 '26

Suggestion For SDS Can we please address how bad the “new and improved” defense is?

0 Upvotes

There’s 0 reason for this kind of scripted error to happen in a competitive setting, i had no actual input in my secondmans movements, all i did was load the I seemingly did everything right and was punished for it.


r/MLBTheShow • • Jun 22 '25

PSA TBH: The new Skenes isn’t as good as the original live series 💎

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I’ve used him in a few games and I don’t think he plays as well, anybody else have this experience?


r/MLBTheShow • • May 24 '23

Analysis HOT TAKE MLB THE SHOW 2023

42 Upvotes

This is the most pay to win version of mlb the show we ever had

Change my mind.


r/MLBTheShow • • Aug 03 '22

Question Why is the content not out yet?

0 Upvotes

It usually should have came out 5 min. ago


r/MLBTheShow • • Mar 25 '26

Suggestion For SDS What an Absolute Garbage Game

0 Upvotes

How is it possible you do server maintenance every single day and are constantly “working on improving the game” and it is still a nearly unplayable game?

Maybe next year work on making a game that uses the next gen (as in the ones that came out years ago already) consoles power and is actually finished and playable when you release it.

Constant disconnects, horrible game mechanics, etc. Just a terrible “effort”.


r/MLBTheShow • • Jul 23 '18

Was a Great Year Fellas

0 Upvotes

Keep up the grind, but like many, I can say I am officially done with this game.

I’ve played MLB The Show since the beginning and God is this year’s online version atrocious. I have a pretty damn good record online (for the “Git Gud” Comments lol) but this game is just not fun anymore TO ME. The more I play, the more I get frustrated or stressed. It doesn’t feel rewarding anymore. This year, the better players don’t always win.

Between the online cheese, people swinging at everything & still winning with a lucky homer-run, 99 runners, fielding, terrible hitting feedback system, The Gallo’s vs. The Legends, dancing PCI’s, lack of contact hitters, I can keep going and going but I don’t want to waste your time. You guys already know the struggle.

Was fun playing with you all. Possibly see you all next year.


r/MLBTheShow • • Sep 25 '20

Show Off Favorite card in the game

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow • • Aug 18 '24

PSA Moonshot Event Stadiums

1 Upvotes

Y’all may or may not agree with this but in the moonshot event, don’t be a dick and choose a stadium where the ball doesn’t fly. I understand if you don’t want to play at a max elevation stadium, I don’t like playing at them, but picking red rock stadium where the ball goes no where and a perfect is an out in center because the fence is 450 ft, that’s just lame. It’s the moonshot event. Pick a good park, let the ball fly. They’re common pitchers. Just hit bombs and have fun, it’s supposed to be about homeruns, not small ball.


r/MLBTheShow • • Apr 03 '24

Appreciation Apparently Unpopular Opinion

55 Upvotes

Just posting because of all the negative posts/comments I’m seeing.. I am actually having a great time playing this game F2P. Is there less offline grinding (at the moment)? Yes. Have they released 40k packs that you have to buy to get all players where they may have offered some of those players in programs others years? Yes. Were there bugs on launch and still exist? Yes (Xbox here, sorry switch users).

Despite the flaws, I am still really enjoying playing the game.. The gameplay is pretty great and seems overall to be improved even if pitching is brutal. I still enjoy the offline grind so far and earning/ripping packs. I’m withholding judgement on content for now since we’re 5-6 games into the season.. I play online (not very well) and it’s a ton of fun when you get a full 9 inning back and forth game or a slugfest BR/event game with your run on the line.

Even if a ton of the game was copy/paste, it’s still a value with all of the game modes + ways you can play (especially for game pass subs).

So is it perfect? No, but it’s still really fun.


r/MLBTheShow • • May 08 '25

Suggestion For SDS You should be able to make 2 different lineups: one vs lefties or righties.

0 Upvotes

Teams in real life have different lineups for a lefty starter or a righty starter, why can’t we do that in DD?