r/MHOLVote • • Oct 05 '20

CLOSED LM119 - Titles Reform Humble Address - Division

2 Upvotes

Titles Reform Humble Address


The Rt Hon. The Lord Houston has moved:

That a humble address be presented to Her Majesty, that she will be graciously pleased to give directions in such a manner

1)- The usage of “British Empire” in the Most Excellent Order titles shall hereby cease, with all previous rewards with said name remaining in full.

2) “The Most Excellent Order of the British Empire” is hereby replaced with “The Most Distinguished Order of British Excellence”, with its constituent titles being amended as follows.

a) “Dame Grand Cross of the Order of the British Empire” is replaced with “Dame Grand Cross of the Order of British Excellence.”

b) “Knight Grand Cross of the Order of the British Empire” is replaced with “Knight Grand Cross of the Order of British Excellence.”

c) “Dame Commander of the Order of the British Empire” is replaced with “Dame Commander of the Order of British Excellence.”

d) “Knight Commander of the Order of the British Empire” is replaced with “Knight Commander of the Order of British Excellence.”

e) “Commander of the Order of the British Empire” is replaced with “Commander of the Order of British Excellence.”

f) “Officer of the Order of the British Empire” is replaced with “Officer of the Order of British Excellence.”

g) “Member of the Order of the British Empire” is replaced with “Member of the Order of British Excellence”


This humble address was moved by The Rt. Hon Lord of Houston PC KBE MS, on behalf of Solidarity.

Opening Speech

My Lords,

I bring back this humble address in light of recent events sweeping the world. Ever increasingly since we last debated this item, people have become aware of the issues around systemic racism, and a global movement has continued to develop in recent times with ambitious and laudable goals of creating a more just and equal society. It is in that spirit that I felt the need to resubmit this motion.

As I said in the last debate. This isn’t about debating the merits of the British empire. It’s about recognizing the fact that some people may have negative views of it. Whatever stance you take, it makes common sense that we should do all we can to make one of our highest rewards as open to public adoration as possible.

And again, this isn’t about erasing history. Awards aren’t museums. They aren’t history books. Nobody learns more about British history by getting a reward. I’m more than happy to teach about the history of the British Empire, but putting it on a reward isn’t a teaching moment, it’s promotional.

Finally, last time around there were some objections to the specific name change. Let me be clear, I made this pick at the urging of a report I read on this very subject from the Public Administration Committee.

https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200304/cmselect/cmpubadm/212/21209.htm

The new name keeps continuity with the abbreviation, and minimizes disruption during the transition.

I urge this place to think hard about the message we want to send.


This division ends 7 October 2020 at 10pm BST.

Please vote Content, Not Content, or Present.


r/MHOLVote • • Jan 31 '16

ABUSE OF ALERT VOTE IN THE LORD SPEAKER ELECTION

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/MHOLVote • • May 02 '21

CLOSED B1169 - Broadcasting Standards Exemption Bill - Division

1 Upvotes

Amendments 1 through 5, in the name of the Viscount Strabane, are agreed to. The question is that the Bill do now pass.

Division! Clear the bar.


Broadcasting Standards Exemption Bill

A

Bill

To

Create a register of networks that show content in conflict with rules of watershed and to require relevant warnings within the broadcast that content being played would be otherwise in violation of watershed rules Section 1: Interpretations

(1) For the purposes of this Act—

“OFCOM” is The Office of Communications

a “network” is a television distribution web of any number of channels under a single operator

“children” is anyone under the age of 18

“watershed” refers to the rules and regulations specific to certain time periods laid out in section 1 of the OFCOM broadcasting code

“Mandatory daytime protection” is a PIN protection system in place pre-2100 and post-0530 which cannot be removed by the user

Section 2: Eligibility

A television channel shall be eligible to register itself exempt from watershed if it is deemed that its programming and target market is not one aimed at children.

Section 3: Register

(1) A public register shall be established by OFCOM whereby a television channel can register itself as exempt from watershed.

(2) All applications to register a television channel exempt from watershed shall be public and the verdict on the assessment shall be public as well.

(3) OFCOM is obligated to assess thoroughly and fairly a television channel's eligibility as defined in Section 1 within a reasonable timeframe.

Section 4: Requirements for television service providers

(1) OFCOM must require a television service provider to establish the following standards for television channels with exemption from watershed-

(a) notification of the channel as exempt to viewers before they view the television channel;

(b) clear separation between watershed and watershed exempt television channels;

(c) where deemed possible by OFCOM, a PIN protection placed between 0530 and 2100 which:

(i) includes application to future devices certified by television service providers;

(ii) includes future software updates on devices certified by television service providers; and

(iii) is on by default, but may be turned off by the user.

(2) With respect to violations of requirements within this section, OFCOM may investigate violations and levy a fine to any person who is found to contravened such standards.

Section 5: Exemption

(1) A television channel shall be exempt from rules directly applied by watershed only if they are on the register, and all other broadcasting standards that would apply regardless of watershed will still be in force.

(2) A television channel that is accepted onto the register for exemption shall only practice its exemption 2 weeks after the public verdict is given and the network should give warning of their upcoming content within these 2 weeks.

(3) A television channel shall not practice at any time its exemption until it incorporates into its broadcast-

(a) Mandatory daytime protection

(b) A warning within the broadcast where relevant that it is playing content that breaches watershed rules if they were applied to a non-exempt television channel.

(4) This section shall take precedence over 1.24 of the broadcasting code meaning that while OFCOM should update their code as soon as possible, this register is still required until then.

Section 6: Short title, commencement and extent

(1) This Act may be cited as the Broadcasting Standards Exemption Act 2021.
(2) This Act comes into force on the passing of this Act.
(3) This Act extends to the whole United Kingdom.
(4) Her Majesty may by Order in Council extend the provisions of this Act, with such modifications as appear to Her Majesty in Council to be appropriate, to any of the Channel Islands or to the Isle of Man.


This bill was written by IcoMHoC MP on behalf of Coalition!


Mr Deputy Speaker, I bring this bill to parliament today to legislate protections for consumers and to create a more streamlined and sure system by which networks can remain competitive. In current broadcasting standards there is an avenue through which channels can broadcast material that would usually be restricted by watershed however it is present only as a part of OFCOM broadcasting code and while it uses many of the same protections I bring forth such as the mandatory daytime pin it is also unrestricted to any timeframe. With this bill comes a register to ensure that consumers are certain about what type of content they can expect and it also brings with it a requirement to include in one’s broadcasts warnings of the content so that a consumer can monitor what will be included for where one needs to make more nuanced decisions on what is suitable.

And with these strong enhancements to the rights of consumers also comes a strong enhancement to competition within media, by guaranteeing exemptions from watershed rules networks that want to try and provide a competing product to that of streaming services can now provide entertainment throughout the day in a less restrictive way. With this bill we should hopefully see more confidence in the viability of live television as a competing medium where consumers can get entertainment with more choice and networks can make more competitive moves in the content they produce and air.


This division ends 4 May 2021 at 10pm BST.

Vote Content, Not Content, or Present.


r/MHOLVote • • Apr 20 '21

CLOSED B1169 - Broadcasting Standards Exemption Bill - Amendment Division

1 Upvotes

The question is that the amendments be agreed to.

Division! Clear the bar.


Broadcasting Standards Exemption Bill

A

Bill

To

Create a register of networks that show content in conflict with rules of watershed and to require relevant warnings within the broadcast that content being played would be otherwise in violation of watershed rules Section 1: Interpretations

(1) For the purposes of this Act—

“OFCOM” is The Office of Communications

a “network” is a television distribution web of any number of channels under a single operator

“children” is anyone under the age of 18

“watershed” refers to the rules and regulations specific to certain time periods laid out in section 1 of the OFCOM broadcasting code

“Mandatory daytime protection” is a PIN protection system in place pre-2100 and post-0530 which cannot be removed by the user

Section 2: Eligibility

(1) A network shall be eligible to register itself exempt from watershed if it meets the following criteria -

(a) The network is not available free to air through either satellite or any other means, and

(b) It is deemed that its advertisement and image is not one aimed at children.

Section 3: Register (1) A public register shall be established by OFCOM whereby a network can register itself as exempt from watershed.

(2) All applications to register a network exempt from watershed shall be public and the verdict on the assessment shall be public as well.

(3) OFCOM is obligated to assess thoroughly and fairly a network's eligibility as defined in Section 1 within a reasonable timeframe.

Section 4: Exemption

(1) A network shall be exempt from rules directly applied by watershed only if they are on the register, and all other broadcasting standards that would apply regardless of watershed will still be in force.

(2) A network that is accepted onto the register for exemption shall only practice its exemption 2 weeks after the public verdict is given and the network should give warning of their upcoming content within these 2 weeks.

(3) A network shall not practice at any time its exemption until it incorporates into its broadcast-

(a) Mandatory daytime protection

(b) A warning within the broadcast where relevant that it is playing content that breaches watershed rules if they were applied to a non-exempt network.

(4) This section shall take precedence over 1.24 of the broadcasting code meaning that while OFCOM should update their code as soon as possible, this register is still required until then. Section 5: Short title, commencement and extent (1) This Act may be cited as the Broadcasting Standards Exemption Act 2021 (2) This Act comes into force on the passing of this Act (3) This Act extends to England & Wales.


This bill was written by IcoMHoC MP on behalf of Coalition!


Mr Deputy Speaker, I bring this bill to parliament today to legislate protections for consumers and to create a more streamlined and sure system by which networks can remain competitive. In current broadcasting standards there is an avenue through which channels can broadcast material that would usually be restricted by watershed however it is present only as a part of OFCOM broadcasting code and while it uses many of the same protections I bring forth such as the mandatory daytime pin it is also unrestricted to any timeframe. With this bill comes a register to ensure that consumers are certain about what type of content they can expect and it also brings with it a requirement to include in one’s broadcasts warnings of the content so that a consumer can monitor what will be included for where one needs to make more nuanced decisions on what is suitable.

And with these strong enhancements to the rights of consumers also comes a strong enhancement to competition within media, by guaranteeing exemptions from watershed rules networks that want to try and provide a competing product to that of streaming services can now provide entertainment throughout the day in a less restrictive way. With this bill we should hopefully see more confidence in the viability of live television as a competing medium where consumers can get entertainment with more choice and networks can make more competitive moves in the content they produce and air.


Amendment 1

Replace section 2 with the following:

Section 2: Eligibility

A television channel shall be eligible to register itself exempt from watershed if it is deemed that its programming and target market is not one aimed at children.

Note: allows for the registration of free-to-air channels which meet the requirements.

Amendment 2

In section 5 replace "England & Wales" with "the whole United Kingdom".

Note: minor adjustment as broadcasting regulation is not devolved.

Amendment 3

Insert a new section 4 to read as follows, renumbering successive sections:

Section 4: Requirements for television service providers

(1) OFCOM must require a television service provider to establish the following standards for television channels with exemption from watershed-

(a) notification of the channel as exempt to viewers before they view the television channel;

(b) clear separation between watershed and watershed exempt television channels;

(c) where deemed possible by OFCOM, a PIN protection placed between 0530 and 2100 which:

(i) includes application to future devices certified by television service providers;

(ii) includes future software updates on devices certified by television service providers; and

(iii) is on by default, but may be turned off by the user.

(2) With respect to violations of requirements within this section, OFCOM may investigate violations and levy a fine to any person who is found to contravened such standards.

Note: creates a set of standards to help inform people who might want to avoid a channel with the watershed restrictions removed, parents being one group for example.

Amendment 4

Insert a new subsection 4 in section 5 to read:

(4) Her Majesty may by Order in Council extend the provisions of this Act, with such modifications as appear to Her Majesty in Council to be appropriate, to any of the Channel Islands or to the Isle of Man.

Note: allows for customary extension of broadcasting law to the Channel Islands or the Isle of Man subject to their approval.

Amendment 5

Omit the definition of "network" in section 1 and replace each instance of "network" in the rest of the bill with "television channel".

Note: allows for channels to be individually registered rather than by entire networks at a time.

Amendments 1 through 5 are moved in the name of the Viscount Strabane.


This division ends 22 April 2021 at 10pm BST.

Please vote as below:

Amendment 1: Content/Not Content/Present
Amendment 2: Content/Not Content/Present
Amendment 3: Content/Not Content/Present
Amendment 4: Content/Not Content/Present
Amendment 5: Content/Not Content/Present


r/MHOLVote • • Apr 28 '21

OPEN LB217 - Consent of the Crown Bill - Final Division

1 Upvotes

All amendments failed.


Consent of the Crown Bill


A

BILL

TO

conclusively abolish the principle of Crown consent within the legislative process.

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s Most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

Section 1 - Abolition of Queen’s consent

(1) No bill within either House of Parliament shall require the consent of Her Majesty, through signification or otherwise, prior to receiving Royal Assent.

(2) The prerogative power to refuse to grant the consent of Her Majesty for a bill which would affect—

(a) the royal prerogative;
(b) hereditary revenues;
(c) the Duchy of Lancaster;
(d) the Duchy of Cornwall; and
(e) the personal property and interests of Her Majesty;

shall be conclusively abolished.

(3) Standing orders in either House of Parliament shall be prohibited from requiring the consent of Her Majesty in the course of considering bills.

Section 2 - Abolition of Prince’s consent

(1) No bill within either House of Parliament shall require the consent of the Prince of Wales, through signification or otherwise, prior to receiving Royal Assent.

(2) The prerogative power to refuse to grant the consent of the Prince of Wales for a bill which would affect His Royal Highness in his capacity as—

(a) the Prince and Steward of Scotland;
(b) the Duke of Cornwall;
(c) the Prince of Wales and Earl of Chester; and
(d) the proprietor of personal property and interests in right of any royal title;

shall be conclusively abolished.

(3) Standing orders in either House of Parliament shall be prohibited from requiring the consent of the Prince of Wales in the course of considering bills.

Section 3 - Savings

This Act shall not affect any standing orders or the progression of any Bill in the Parliamentary term in which this Act comes into force.

Section 4 - Extent, Commencement and Short Title

(1) This Act shall extend to the whole United Kingdom.

(2) This Act shall come into force one day after receiving Royal Assent.

(3) This Act shall be cited as the Consent of the Crown Act 2021.


This Bill was written by the Rt Hon. Viscount Strabane CT MLA, Attorney General for England, on behalf of the 28th Government.


My Lords,

As a preface, I would advise peers to read about the practice of Crown consent here as it is often confused with Royal Assent. This bill aims to abolish Crown consent only.

Crown consent essentially says that if a proposed bill impacts a prerogative power of the executive or the financial interests of either the Queen or Prince of Wales, the Government may advise either figure to block the progression of the bill in Parliament. This is important because it is relevant to all sorts of issues, be it corporate taxation or matters of peace and war. This power has been used to block legislation from the opposition and backbenchers in the past, so it is hardly an unused anachronism.

The Government views the present state of affairs as a double-standard because no parallel mechanism exists for powers granted to the executive by virtue of statute. The executive has never had an effective veto over bills which would impact the making of SIs from statutory provisions for example, yet prerogative powers are treated differently.

This is not a monarchist vs anti-monarchist issue as some would probably have it, but rather a bill which intends to broadly strengthen the independence of Parliament from the executive.


Lords may vote either Content, Not Content or Present only.

This division shall end at 10 pm on 30th April 2021.


r/MHOLVote • • Dec 13 '18

CLOSED LM071 - Motion to treat corrections to named Secretaries in the same manner as SPaG Amendments - DIVISION

1 Upvotes

Motion to treat corrections to named Secretaries of State in the same manner as Spelling, Puntuation and Grammar Amendments


This House recognises that:

  • Legislation should not name a specific Secretary of State, instead referring to "the Secretary of State" in general, as to avoid confusion when the role is renamed, or otherwise re-organised.

  • Amending legislation to no longer name a specific Secretary of State does not impact the interpretation of legislation, in the same manner that Spelling, Punctuation & Grammar Corrections does not change interpretations.

  • This House does not vote upon Spelling and Grammar amendments, since they do not impact the interpretation of legislation.

This House therefore resolves:

  • That amendments to legislation such as to no longer name Secretaries of State be treated in the same manner as Spelling, Punctuation, and Grammar amendments, and thus be eligible to be labelled Amendment A00, and also thus be accepted without a division, unless the author objects.


This motion was written by His Grace The Duke of Lancashire.

This division shall end on the 15th, with results on the 16th.


r/MHOLVote • • Feb 08 '22

CLOSED B1316 - Investor-State Dispute Settlement Mechanism (Authorisation) Bill - Final Division

1 Upvotes

Amendment 1 passed.


B1316 - Investor-State Dispute Settlement Mechanism (Authorisation) Bill


A

BILL

TO

Prohibit the invocation of investor-state dispute settlement mechanisms by corporations without the consent of Her Majesty.

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s Most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

Section 1 - Definitions.

(1) In this Act,

a) “investor-state dispute settlement mechanism” refers to a mechanism within an agreement signed by the United Kingdom allowing a suit to be brought against a country party to that agreement for actions taken by it that infringe upon the profit of an investor,

b) “corporation” refers to any person that is not a natural person.

Section 2 - Prohibitions.

(1) No corporation shall invoke an investor-state dispute settlement mechanism without the prior authorization of the Government.

(2) Her Majesty may, by proclamation, designate a Minister to provide authorizations under this Act.

Section 3 - Contravention.

(1) Every one who contravenes a provision in section 2 is liable to:

a) be fined not less than ten times the revenue derived from the offence, if a corporation, or

b) be fined not less than one million pounds, imprisoned for no less than ten years, or both, if a natural person.

(2) For the purposes of (1), the amount of revenue that the violator stood to gain had their invocation of the investor-state dispute settlement mechanism been successful is deemed to be the revenue derived from the offence.

(3) Where a corporation is convicted of an offence under (1), Her Majesty may initiate proceedings against any person employed by that corporation who:

a) was aware of the conduct so offending,

b) was in a position to prevent said conduct, and

c) did not attempt to prevent said conduct

as if they personally committed the offence.

Section 4 - Extent, commencement and short title.

(1) This Act may be cited as the Investor-State Dispute Settlement Mechanism (Authorization) Act 2021.

(2) The provisions of this Act extend to the United Kingdom.

(3) This act will come into effect 2 years after receiving Royal Assent. This Act comes into force on Royal Assent.

(4) No proceedings may be initiated against any person under this Act for acts that took place prior to its enactment.


This bill was written by AceSevenFive on behalf of the 29th Government.


Opening Speech:

Madam Speaker,

Investor-state dispute settlement mechanisms are inherently an infringement on the rights of nations to regulate their own affairs. Investors should not be allowed to sue states for passing legislation that harms their profits. This legislation supplements recent bills to prohibit the United Kingdom from enacting new ISDS mechanisms by prohibiting businesses from invoking existing ones. I hope that all members of this chamber can back the death knell of ISDS. Thank you, Madam Speaker.


Lords may vote either Content, Not Content or Present only.

Division will end on 10th February at 10pm BST


r/MHOLVote • • Jan 21 '22

CLOSED LM145 - Afghanistan Support Motion - Final Division

1 Upvotes

Afghanistan Support Motion


This House notes that:

(1) The decision by President Biden and NATO to pull out of Afghanistan, allowing the Taliban to takeover the country, has resulted in a deep humanitarian crisis.

(2) It is estimated that more than 20 million Afghans are on the brink of famine and that by the middle of 2022, 97% of the population could be below the “universal poverty” line.

(3) The World Food Programme has launched their biggest ever appeal and operation to seek to help the country.

(4) Domestically, controls on Afghan citizens coming to the UK were dropped which has meant a large number of people with very little to no assets could come to the UK to flee the Taliban.

(5) Local authorities will be dealing with large numbers of new people requiring support because of a decision that was made at Westminster.

This House calls upon the Government to:

(1) Substantially increase funding to UN programmes and NGOs to get support to the people of Afghanistan directly whilst avoiding giving money to the Taliban.

(2) Ensure that the upcoming budget provides funding to local authorities and other departments and agencies which require it to support Afghan refugees and migrants which have come to the UK since the Taliban takeover.

(3) That the Government supports programmes in Afghanistan which reinforce and expand upon the education of women and girl within the Country.


This motion was proposed by The Right Honourable Sir Tommy2Boys KCT KG KT KCB KBE KCVO MSP. the Duke of Aberdeen, on behalf of Coalition!


My Lords,

It’s a pleasure to present my first motion in a long time to this place and it’s on an issue dear to my heart. The people of Afghanistan deserved better. To simply turn our back on them and walk away is a stain on the west’s collective conscience. But we are where we are, and we must do what we can for them now.

The humanitarian situation within Afghanistan is bleak. I’ve done quite a bit of research when it comes to Yemen, long believed to be the worst humanitarian situation in the world. The very thought anything could be worse than what we see in Yemen scares me, but it’s where we are heading.

We need to get help to these people and fast. That involves getting money to NGOs and UN agencies quickly so they can get food and medicine into the country. We do not need to give money to the Taliban to help ease the crisis there, and with UN agencies currently having the ability to work in the country unimpeded this is especially true. The government should use the upcoming budget to get money to groups that can help.

Closer to home, we again can and should do more to help those who have come to the UK. C! welcome the loosening of controls on people from Afghanistan coming to the UK, but we must recognise that this puts immense pressure on local authorities especially. People who come will have little to no assets, and it’s vital we give them the best attempt to get on in their new life.

Finally this motion calls upon the government to support the education of women and girls within the country. Now we on these benches are not naive. We know who the Taliban are, but we have a moral duty to try. To try and ensure the gains made in girls education since the fall of the Taliban 20 years ago are not completely abandoned.

I hope this House will find itself able to back this motion and I commend it to the House today.


Lords may Vote Content, Not Content, or Present

Vote on this motion will end on the 23rd January at 10pm GMT


r/MHOLVote • • Jul 01 '18

CLOSED B594.2 - Free Speech in Universities Bill 2018 - FINAL DIVISION

1 Upvotes

B594 Free Speech in Universities Bill 2018

A B I L L TO

make provisions for the complete protection of free speech and the flow of ideas in universities.

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s most Excellent Majesty, by and with the consent of the Lords Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:-

1. Freedom of expression in higher education

  • (1) A qualifying institution must have regard to the desirability of:

    • (a) ensuring the freedom of expression of its students, and

    • (b) ensuring that a student's position in the institution is not adversely affected by an exercise of the student's freedom of expression.

  • (2) A student's freedom of expression includes the freedom (within the law) to:

    • (a) hold and express opinion,

    • (b) question established ideas, principles, and conventional wisdom, and

    • (c) present controversial or unpopular points of view.

  • (3) But a student's freedom of expression does not include the freedom to disrupt or hinder the operation of the institution or the carrying out of the institution's functions.

2. Reasonable restriction of expression

  • (1) A qualifying institution must not impose restrictions on the freedom of expression of its students unless the restrictions:

    • (a) are reasonable,

    • (b) are justified without reference to the content of the speech, and

    • (c) are imposed only so far as necessary to serve a significant governmental interest.

  • (2) A restriction of the type mentioned in subsection (1) is not reasonable if the restriction, however framed or worded, would have the effect of:

    • (a) preventing the exercise of a student's freedom of expression in a particular place or area (other than in a place or area in which a student would not normally be permitted or to which student access is restricted in the interests of health and safety); or

    • (b) broadly restricts the means by which the freedom of expression may be exercised.

  • (3) For the purposes of subsection (1)(c), "a significant governmental interest" has the meaning given in regulations made by the Secretary of State.

  • (4) Regulations under subsection (3):

    • (a) are made by statutory instrument, and

    • (b) are subject to annulment in pursuance of a resolution of either House of Parliament.

3. Offences

4. Qualifying institutions

In this Act, "qualifying institution" has the meaning given in section 11 of the Higher Education Act 2004.

5. Responsible Speech

Section 3: 6. Commencement, short title, and Extent

  1. This Act commences comes into force immediately after Royal assent.

  2. This Act should be referred to may be cited as the Free Speech in Universities Act 2018.

  3. This Act extends to the whole of the United Kingdom England and Wales.


This bill was written by the Right Honourable /u/Toastinrussian MP. PC on behaf of the Government; and recognises the work of Colorado Senate Bill 17-062, particularly Senator Tim Neville, and Representatives: Jeff Bridges, and Stephen Humphrey


This division shall end on 4 July 2018.

Division! Clear the bar.


r/MHOLVote • • Aug 30 '20

OPEN LB189 - Modern Slavery (Bridging Visa) Bill - Final Division

1 Upvotes

Only A03 passes and is applied accordingly.

Amendment Reading here


Modern Slavery (Bridging Visa) Bill


A

BILL

TO

establish a temporary right to remain in the United Kingdom should an individual become a victim of modern slavery.

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s Most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

Section 1 - Bridging visa established

(1) The Secretary of State shall make provision for a visa (referred to in this Act as a “bridging visa”) established under this Act.

(2) The bridging visa grants the holder leave to remain in the United Kingdom for a period of no less than six months for the purpose of seeking alternative employment.

(3) A person who possesses a bridging visa must be able to, subject to other enactments,—

(a) apply for other visas;
(b) re-apply for the visa held prior to applying for the bridging visa; and
(c) have recourse to public funds.

(4) There shall be no annual cap on the number of bridging visas.

Section 2 - Eligibility for the grant of a bridging visa

(1) The Secretary of State shall grant a bridging visa to a person who fulfills the following conditions.

(2) Condition 1 is that the person is a victim of a trafficking-related offence.

(3) Condition 2 is that the person has applied for the visa and an authorised officer has accepted the application, by form or in-person.

(4) Condition 3 is that the person reports the person who committed the offences in question to the appropriate authorities.

(5) In this section, a trafficking-related offence is—

(a) an offence under section 59A of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 (Trafficking people for sexual exploitation)
(b) an offence under section 4 of the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc) Act 2004 (Trafficking people for labour and other exploitation)
(c) an offence under section 3 of the Migrant Workers Act 2015 (Assisting an unlawful employment).

Section 3 - Compensation to be granted to visa-holders

(1) For the avoidance of doubt, any person granted a bridging visa shall be immediately eligible for compensation under section 6 of the Immigration Act 2015.

(2) The Secretary of State may, by regulations, amend section 6 of the Immigration Act 2015 to up-rate the amount of compensation due.

(3) Regulations made under this section are subject to the negative procedure.

Section 4 - Defence on grounds of slavery or exploitation

A person who is eligible for a bridging visa is not guilty of an offence where—

(a) an act which constitutes an offence is the result of compulsion related to the circumstances of slavery or exploitation; and

(b) a reasonable person in the same situation would do that act.

Section 4 - Defence on grounds of slavery or exploitation
(1) A person who is a victim of a trafficking-related offence is not guilty of an offence where—

(a) an act which constitutes an offence is the result of compulsion related to the circumstances of slavery or exploitation;
(b) a reasonable person in the same situation and with the same characteristics would do that act; and
(c) if over the age of 18, the person had no reasonable alternative to doing that act.

(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to the following offences—

(a) murder;
(b) treason;
(c) kidnapping;
(d) an offence under the Sexual Offences Act 2003, the Sexual Offences (Scotland) Act 2009, or the Sexual Offences (Northern Ireland) Order 2008;
(e) an offence under section 4 of the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc) Act 2004 (Trafficking people for labour and other exploitation);
(f) an offence against the person;
(g) an offence under the Terrorism Act 2000, the Anti-terrorism, Crime and Security Act 2001, or the Terrorism Act 2006; and
(h) any other offence designated by the Secretary of State by regulations.

(3) The Secretary of State may by regulations amend subsection (2), subject to the affirmative procedure.

Section 5 - Extent, Commencement and Short Title

(1) This Act shall extend to England and Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland.

(2) This Act shall come into force one day after receiving Royal Assent.

(3) This Act shall be cited as the Modern Slavery (Bridging Visa) Act 2020.

This Bill was written by the Rt Hon. Lord Greencastle on behalf of the Social Democratic and Labour Party.

List of relevant Acts:

Section 59A of the Sexual Offences Act 2003

Section 4 of the Asylum and Immigration (Treatment of Claimants, etc) Act 2004

The Migrant Workers Act 2015

The Immigration Act 2015


Please vote Content/Not Content/Present only.

This division shall end on Tuesday 1st September at 10PM BST.


r/MHOLVote • • May 30 '21

OPEN B1170 - Bank Holidays Bill - Results

1 Upvotes

B1170 - Bank Holidays Bill

Content: 15

Not content: 10

Present: 1

The contents have it! The amended bill is returned to the Other Place.


r/MHOLVote • • Jun 15 '21

CLOSED B1198 - Grammar Schools (Repeal) Bill - Amendment Division

1 Upvotes

B1198 - Grammar Schools (Repeal) Bill - Amendment Division

A

BILL

TO

Repeal the Grammar Schools (Reform) Act 2020 and ban the establishment of any new grammar schools.

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s Most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

Section 1: Definitions

For the purposes of this Act—

”grammar school” means a school designated under the School Standards and Framework Act 1998 section 104.
“Secretary of State” means the Secretary of State of Education or otherwise appropriate Secretary.

Section 2: Repeals

(1) The Grammar Schools (Reform) Act 2020 is hereby repealed in its entirety and all changes to other acts caused by it shall be reversed.

(2) The Secretary of State shall no longer have the power to designate new grammar schools.

(3) The Grammar School Commission shall be disbanded.

Section 3: Closing of current grammar schools

(1) By 2023, all current grammar schools shall begin to accept students through the same method as non-selective schools.

(a) During this process schools may choose to only become non-selective for each new grade starting the school instead of making all grades non-selective simultaneously.

Section 3: Commencement, Extent, and Short Title

(1) The Act may be cited as the “Grammar Schools (Repeal) Act 2021”

(2) This Act shall extend to England and Wales

(3) This act shall commence immediately upon receiving royal assent.

This bill was written by The Right Honourable u/Rohanite272 OBE on behalf of the Social Democratic Party


Amendment 1

Section 3: Commencement, Extent and Short Title

In (3), change to “This act shall commence 2 (two) years after receiving Royal Assent”

Explanatory note:

This will ensure that the Grammar Schools Commission, established by an Act of Parliament in a previous term, will be able to transition to the changes proposed by this law and ensure that this is not simply partisan virtue signalling by the incumbent Government in the House of Commons.

The Amendment was moved by the Right Honourable Earl of Bournemouth


This reading shall end at 2200hrs BST on 17/07/2021.

Vote Content, Not Content, or Present on the proposed amendment.


r/MHOLVote • • Jul 13 '20

CLOSED B981.2 - Direct Democracy Bill - Final Division

1 Upvotes

A02 and A03 passed, A01 failed.


A

BILL

TO Give the British People a say in their own affairs

BE IT ENACTED by The Queen's most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and in accordance with the provisions of the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, and by the authority of the same, as follows:

Section 1. Provisions

  1. If a petition nationally signed for national issues or locally signed for local issues by over 15% of the electorate is brought before parliament, a devolved assembly or a local council, a legally binding referendum on the matter must be called within 12 months of signature level reaching, unless the matter has been put to binding referendum under this Act within the last 15 years, as determined by the Electoral Commission

  2. For a petition to be deemed valid, the signatures must have been gathered within a 9-month timescale and specify an enacting authority.

  3. A National Referendum shall be defined as: A referendum affecting: The entire population of the United Kingdom or a Referendum affecting the Citizens of 6 (Six) or more Regions.

4) The regions are as follows: Wales, London, the South East, the North West, the West Midlands, Yorkshire & the Humber, East of England, the South West, the East Midlands, the North East, Scotland, and Northern Ireland.

5) No elector may sign a local petition in Wales, Scotland, or Northern Ireland under this Act.

6) One side of the issue must attain at least 50% of the vote and at least 33% turnout to be enacted.

7) All of the referenda scheduled within the same 12-month timeslot must take place on the same day, to reduce the cost to taxpayers.

8) If an issue is deemed of extreme importance by the Electoral Commission, Clause 3 shall not apply and the referenda may be held at an earlier date.

9) Referendum results are binding. They must be acted upon and respected by the relevant Government Department, Regional Assembly or Local Authority.

10) If a referendum petition is received which the relevant body believes to be non-serious, they may refer it to the electoral commission for judgement. If the electoral commission also agrees it to be non-serious they may discard it. If the petition is rejected, the leading petitioner shall have full rights to appeal before the commission

Section 1A: Compatibility with Devolution

(1) The devolved legislatures are the Scottish Parliament, Welsh Parliament, and Northern Ireland Assembly

(2) Nothing in this Act allows for the submission of petitions to, or the holding of referenda by, any devolved legislature under the provisions of this Act.

(3) Where a national petition is submitted to a Government Department, the Government Department must determine if that matter is reserved to the Parliament of the United Kingdom in relation to the powers of each devolved legislature.

(4) If the Government Department determines the matter is reserved to the Parliament of the United Kingdom in relation to one or more devolved legislature, persons living in the relevant devolved region shall be permitted to vote - under the same electorate rules as the rest of the United Kingdom - in the referendum.

Section 2: Conditions for Seriousness

Where a public authority or court is making a determination on the seriousness of a petition they have regard to all relevant factors in particular they must give consideration to—

(a) The enactability of the petition, if the petition is possible to be enacted.

(b) The legality of the petition, if the petition would if enacted be unlawful and if the enacting authority has the legitimate authority to enact it.

(c) Where the petition specifies an action that would be unlawful under an international law instrument or treaty to which the United Kingdom is a contracting state, to meet the enactability and legality tests the petition must be formed to call for renegotiation and/or withdrawal from the instrument or treaty in a lawful manner.

Section 3: Prohibited Questions

(1) No petition may be accepted where it’s enactment would infringe upon the rights of an individual under the Human Rights Act 1998.

(2) No petition may compel the amendment of schedule 1 of the Human Rights Act 1998.

(3) No petition may compel a Unitary Declaration of Independence.

(4) If a petition is submitted in contravention of this section, the electoral commission must refuse the petition.

(5) Individuals who feel their rights under the Human Rights Act 1998 are at risk because of a petition may file a motion in court to cancel the referendum.

(6) The court may make a preliminary decision to postpone to a future or unspecified date or suspend any binding duty to enact the result of a referendum where the applicant has presented a substantive case.

Section 4: Question determination

(1) In determining a question for a referendum held under this act, the electoral commission is to aim to select a question that will advantage neither side and that is impartial.

(2) The electoral commission may determine the question itself or it may choose seek agreement between official campaigns on a question.

Section 5: Extent, Commencement and Short Title

  1. This Act shall apply to England and Wales the entire United Kingdom .

  2. This Act shall come into force upon Royal Assent

  3. This Act may be cited as the Direct Democracy Act 2020

This bill was written by the Rt. Hon Sir Friedmanite19 OM KCMG KBE CT MVO PC MP, on behalf of the LPUK and is co-sponsored by the Labour Party and The Democratic Reformist Front


Division ends Wednesday 15th July 2020 at 10pm BST.

Vote Content, Not Content, or Present only.


r/MHOLVote • • Aug 29 '23

CLOSED B1588 - Energy Bill - Amendment Division

2 Upvotes

B1588 - Energy Bill - Amendment Division


A

B I L L

T O

consolidate and reorganise the energy network in Great Britain, to establish Great British Energy as a state-owned energy company, to provide for the governance of Great British Energy, to repeal the National Energy Strategy Act 2017, to establish a Green British Generation subdivision, to provide for targets of reduction in fossil fuel usage; and for connected purposes.

Due to its length, this bill can be found here.


This Bill was written by the Rt. Hon. Sir /u/Frost_Walker2017**, Duke of the Suffolk Coasts, and the Rt. Hon. Sir** /u/LightningMinion MP MSP MLA KT CBE OM PC, Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change, of the Labour Party on behalf of His Majesty’s 33rd Government.


Opening Speech:

Deputy Speaker,

I’m proud to present to the House of Commons the first piece of legislation I have written for Westminster, with this bill implementing the government’s promise to create a new publicly-owned operator of the energy industry named Great British Energy, or GB Energy for short. I shall now briefly give a summary of the provisions of this bill and explain why the establishment of GB Energy is important.

Currently, as per the National Energy Strategy Act 2017, the energy industry is run by publicly-owned regional energy bodies. GB Energy is going to acquire these bodies to become a national operator of the energy industry (ie the generation and supply of electricity, and the supply of natural gas or alternative heating fuels) owned and funded by His Majesty’s Government. GB Energy will be split into 3 divisions: Great British Energy Generation (which shall be concerned with generating electricity and with producing heating fuels), Great British Energy Transmission (which shall be concerned with the transmission of electricity and heating fuels across the country, as well as their storage, their import, and their export), and Great British Energy Distribution (which shall be concerned with the distribution of electricity and heating fuels to houses and businesses). To clarify, transmission deals with transporting the energy across the country but not to buildings: the transport of it into buildings is the distribution.

Great British Energy Generation shall have 2 subdivisions: Green British Energy (which shall deal with the generation of electricity from renewables and the production of renewable heating fuels), and Great British Nuclear (which shall deal with the generation of electricity from nuclear). The generation of electricity from fossil fuels and the production of natural gas will be a responsibility for Great British Energy Generation rather than its 2 subdivisions.

The divisions and subdivisions of GB Energy will be led by a director appointed by the Energy Secretary. The board of GB Energy will be formed of these directors, a chair appointed by the Energy Secretary, 2 other members appointed by the Energy Secretary, and 3 members elected by the staff of the corporation via the Single Transferable Vote system.

GB Energy will be required to draft an Energy Decarbonisation Plan setting out how it plans to end the use of fossil fuels for the generation of electricity by 2035, and the supply of natural gas by a target the Energy Secretary can determine.

Over the past year, households across the UK have been threatened by rising energy bills. I think it’s important that bills are kept affordable, which is why this bill contains provisions regulating the maximum price GB Energy can charge for energy. Specifically, GB Energy will have a statutory duty to consider the desirability of keeping its customers out of fuel poverty as well as the impact of the price of energy on low-income customers, and the rate of inflation. GB Energy also has no profit incentive due to being a government-owned corporation and having no shareholders to satisfy, and in fact this bill bans GB Energy from turning a profit, ensuring any profit the corporation makes is reinvested into lower bills or into the activities of the corporation. These provisions will all help ensure that GB Energy keeps bills low.

Last winter there were predictions that there may have to be blackouts due to the cold weather. While this government’s planned investments in green energy will hopefully avoid blackouts having to be held, this bill includes provisions for the emergency case where GB Energy may not be able to meet demand for energy. In such a case, it may enable or construct new fossil fuel generators, or it may petition the government to order a blackout for no longer than 2 weeks, with the Commons being able to resolve against such an order. The blackout order can be renewed for further periods with the consent of the Commons if needed.

During the debate on the Energy Sustainability Office Bill, the government said that bill would be redundant due to the provisions of this bill. I can now elaborate that the provisions on the Energy Decarbonisation Plan in Part 2 Chapter 2 and the reporting requirements in section 11 make it redundant. Section 11, in particular, requires GB Energy to make a report on its progress to decarbonising its activities and to promoting sustainability and to meeting climate goals at least once each year. Section 11 also requires GB Energy to publish an assessment each year of whether it received sufficient funding from the government that year, with section 9 explicitly requiring the government to fund the corporation properly. This will ensure that GB Energy receives sufficient funding.

Deputy Speaker, the establishment of GB Energy will serve 2 main purposes: by consolidating energy generation into one corporation with a legal mandate to decarbonise, this government will ensure that the energy industry is decarbonised in line with the UK’s climate targets. By having the energy industry in public rather than private hands, we ensure that GB Energy doesn’t need to turn obscene profits or reward shareholders, ensuring that bills can be kept low at affordable levels to prevent fuel poverty.

I commend this bill to the House.


Amendment 1 (A01):

Amend Section 11(2) to read:

(2) GB Energy must from 1st January 2026, publish a report in conducting sustainability monitoring in its affairs, which should include, but not be limited to —

(a) Measurement of greenhouse gas emissions associated with energy generation and consumption, and efforts in promoting sustainable energy generation;
(b) Tracking and reporting of energy usage, efficiency, and waste management;
(c) Assessment of water usage, land use, and ecosystem impacts;
(d) Evaluation of social and economic impacts on local communities; and
(e) progress towards goals set by the Secretary of State.

No less than once a year.

EN: Expanding the monitoring and reporting provisions to be more considerate in including environmental and social impact assessment.

This Amendment is moved in the name of the Baron of Inverness, u/Hobnob88


Lords may vote either Content, Not Content or Present to the Amendments.

This Division ends on the 31st of August at 10PM BST.



r/MHOLVote • • Jul 17 '19

CLOSED B833 - Counter-Terrorist and Security Bill - 3rd Reading Division

2 Upvotes

B833 - Counter-Terrorist and Security Bill


 

A Bill to make provision in relation to terrorism; to make provision for the retention of travel documents of individuals suspected of intending to travel abroad for the purpose of committing terrorism-related activities and to make provision for the issue of a temporary exclusion order.

 

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Spiritual and Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

 

PART 1

POWER TO RETAIN TRAVEL DOCUMENTS

 

1 Retention of passport and travel documents

(1) If a senior officer, qualified officer or police constable has reasonable suspicion that a person leaving the United Kingdom intends to engage in terrorism-related activity outside the United Kingdom, they have the power to—

(a) search for travel documents relating to that person and to take possession of any that the constable or officer finds;

(b) inspect any travel document relating to that person; and

(c) require that person to hand over all travel documents in his or her possession to the constable or officer and to retain them.

(2) In this section, the Secretary of State will have reasonable suspicion where—

(a) he reasonably believes that the person is leaving to engage in terrorism; and

(b) the retention of their passport and other travel documents is necessary.

(3) In the case travel documents are lawfully seized by a customs or immigration official, they must seek permission from a senior officer, qualified officer or police constable to retain the documents, they may retain the documents until a police constable or officer gives them such direction.

(4) Where a police constable authorises the retention of documents, they may continue to be retained—

(a) while the Secretary of State considers whether to revoke that person’s passport;

(b) while consideration is given to charging that person with an offence; or

(c) while consideration is given to making that person subject to any order or measure to be made or imposed by a court, or by the Secretary of State, for purposes connected with protecting members of the public from a risk of terrorism.

(5) However, travel documents may not be seized under this section for a period longer than 14 days unless the court grants an extension—

(a)the court may only grant an extension if the person concerned has been acting to mislead officers and there are exceptional circumstances justifying the further use of power.

 

PART 2

TEMPORARY RESTRICTIONS ON TRAVEL TO THE UNITED KINGDOM

 

2 Temporary exclusion order

(1) A “temporary exclusion order” is an order which prohibits an individual (the “excluded individual”) from returning to the United Kingdom unless the return is in accordance with a permit to return issued by the Secretary of State.

(2) The Secretary of State may issue a temporary exclusion order to any individual where—

(a) he has reasonable suspicion that the individual is, or has been, engaged in terrorism-related activity outside the United Kingdom;

(b) he is satisfied that the order is conductive to the public good or for purposes connected with protecting members of the public from a risk of terrorism;

(c) the excluded individual is outside the United Kingdom;

(d) the excluded individual has a right to abode in the United Kingdom; and

(e) a court has given appropriate permission to the Secretary of State under section 3.

(3) During the period that a temporary exclusion order is in force, the Secretary of State must keep under review whether condition (2)(b) is met.

(4) The Secretary of State shall lay a report before parliament annually.

(5) The report required under subsection (4) must set out—

(a) the number of applications made to the court; and,

(b) the number of applications granted by the court.

(6) The report under subsection (4) must be carried out by the Independent Reviewer of Terrorism Legislation.

(7) In this section “conducive to the public good” means that on advice of the Crown Prosecution Service there is a reasonable doubt over the ability for a successful prosecution in the UK.

 

3 Temporary exclusion order: Permission of a court

(1) This section applies if the Secretary of State makes an application to the court for permission to issue a temporary exclusion order to the excluded individual.

(2) The function of the court shall be to determine whether the relevant decisions of the Secretary of State are obviously flawed.

(3) The court must not give permission if the subject matter in section 2(2) is not met. In any other case, the court must give permission.

(4) Only the Secretary of State may appeal against a determination of the court under this section.

(5) If the Secretary of State makes an application under subsection (1), they must attempt to notify the excluded person.

(6) The notification must contain—

(a) sufficient information about the allegations against them to give effective instruction to a special advocate; and

(b) instructions to enable the person to apply for a live link direction.

(7) The court may consider the application in the absence of the individual, without the individual being notified and without the individual making any representations to the court only if an attempt at notification under (6) has been made in the previous 10 days.

(8) In the Crime and Disorder Act 1998 after section 57F insert—

“57G The use of live links in proceedings regarding temporary exclusion orders

(1) This section applies where the permission of a court for a Temporary Exclusion Order is sought against a person or where an appeal for a permit to return.

(2) If a court is considering an application for a Temporary Exclusion Order or an appeal, the court may give a live link direction under this section in relation to that hearing.

(3) A live link direction under this section is a direction allowing the person subject to the Temporary Exclusion Order, to attend proceeding of the court through a live link from the place approved by the court.

(4) The court may rescind such a direction if it appears to the court to be in the interests of justice to do so (but this does not affect the court's power to give a further live link direction in relation to the offender).

(5) The offender may give oral evidence while attending a hearing through a live link.”

(9) In this section “the relevant decisions” means the decisions that subsection 1(2) is met.

 

4 Temporary exclusion order: Suspension of the right to return during court proceedings

(1) Whilst the court considers the Secretary of State’s application for an order, the Secretary of State may make an interim detention order, in respect to the concerned individual, to—

(a) refuse entry or leave to enter the United Kingdom;

(b) cancel their leave to enter; and

(c) have them detained at the British Embassy or border checkpoint at which they are present.

(2) After section 4(2)(d) of the Immigration Act 1971 (administration of control), insert—

“(f) the exercise by immigration officers of their obligation to fulfil orders under section 4 subsection (1) of the Counter-Terrorist and Security Act 2019.”

 

5 Temporary exclusion order: Supplementary provisions

(1) A temporary exclusion order comes into force on the day the order is issued and is in force for a period of two years.

(2) The Secretary of State may revoke a temporary exclusion order at any time and must give notice of revocation to the excluded individual.

(3) The issue of a temporary exclusion order does not prevent a further order from being issued to the excluded individual including where an order has expired of the two-year duration.

(4) The Secretary of State may only issue one further order excluding the individual from the United Kingdom if the Secretary of State can display reasonable grounds for doing so.

(5) In this section, the Secretary of State will have reasonable grounds when—

(a) he suspects that the individual is still, or has been, engaged in terrorism outside the United Kingdom at the time in which the previous order was in effect or at a time after the order has ceased to have effect;

(b) he is satisfied that the order is conductive to the public good or for purposes connected with protecting members of the public from a risk of terrorism; and

(c) the excluded individual is outside the United Kingdom;

 

6 Permit to return

(1) A “permit to return” is a permit granting the excluded individual permission to lawfully return to the United Kingdom.

(2) A permit to return must state—

(a) the time or period of time the excluded individual is permitted to return to the United Kingdom;

(b) the manner in which the excluded individual is permitted to return to the United Kingdom; and

(c) the place the excluded individual is permitted to return to the United Kingdom.

(3) For the provision of this section, the Secretary of State may specify—

(a) a route;

(b) a method of transport;

(c) an airline, shipping line or other passenger carrier; or

(d) a flight, sailing or other transport service.

(4) The Secretary of State may not issue a permit to return unless in accordance with this section.

 

7 Permit to return: Application of excluded individual

(1) If the excluded individual applies to the Secretary of State for a permit to return, the Secretary of State must issue a permit within a reasonable period.

(2) The Secretary of State will require the individual to attend an interview with a police constable or qualified officer.

(3) The Secretary of State may refuse to issue a permit to return if—

(a) the excluded individual fails to attend the interview under subsection (2); or

(b) the Secretary of State still suspects that the individual is, or has been, engaged in terrorism-related activity outside the United Kingdom.

(4) An application is not valid if it is not made in accordance with the procedure specified by the Secretary of State.

(5) The Secretary of State must issue a permit to return if satisfied the individual is to be deported to the United Kingdom.

 

8 Permit to return: Appeal

(1) A person may appeal the Secretary of State’s refusal of a permit to return to the court.

(2) The person may appeal the decision for up to two months after the Secretary of State’s refusal.

(3) If the court finds that the Secretary of State has erred in fact or law, the court may issue a permit to return.

 

9 Obligations after return to the United Kingdom

(1) The Secretary of State may impose any or all of the permitted obligations on an excluded individual who—

(a) is subject to a temporary exclusion order; and

(b) has returned to the United Kingdom.

(2) The “permitted obligations” are—

(a) any obligation that may be imposed on an excluded individual under the provisions of Schedule 1 to the Terrorism Prevention and Investigation Measures Act 2011—

(i) paragraph 10 (reporting to police station); or

(ii) paragraph 12 (monitoring movements and communications).

(b) an obligation to attend any deradicalisation programme for any period approved by the Secretary of State; and

(c) an obligation to notify the police of—

(i) the excluded individual’s place or places of residence; and

(ii) any change in the excluded individual’s place or places of residence.

(3) A notice under this section comes into force immediately and will remain so for one year after the expiry of the order.

 

10 Offences

(1) An excluded individual subject to a temporary exclusion order commits an offence if, without reasonable excuse, returns to the United Kingdom in contravention of the restriction on return specified in the order.

(2) An excluded individual subject to an obligation or obligations under section 7 commits an offence if, without reasonable excuse, does not comply with the obligation or obligations.

(3) An individual guilty of an offence under this section is liable—

(a) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 4 years or to a fine, or both;

(b) on summary conviction in England and Wales, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or to a fine, or to both;

(c) on summary conviction in Northern Ireland, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or to a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum, or to both; and

(d) on summary conviction in Scotland, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or to a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum, or to both.

 

11 Review of temporary exclusion order

(1) This section shall only apply where an excluded individual who is subject to a temporary exclusion order is in the United Kingdom.

(2) An excluded individual may apply to the court to judicially review any of the following decisions by the Secretary of State—

(a) a decision to issue the temporary exclusion order;

(b) a decision that any of the conditions of subsection 2(2) were met in relation to the issue of the temporary exclusion order; and

(c) a decision to impose any of the obligations on the excluded individual in relation to section 7.

(3) On a review under this section, the court must apply the principles applicable on an application for judicial review.

(4) On a review of a decision within subsection (2)(a) and (2)(b), the court has the power to quash the temporary exclusion order or to give direction to the Secretary of State for the revocation of the temporary exclusion order.

(5) On a review of a decision within subsection (2)(c), the court has the power to—

(a) power to quash the obligation;

(b) if that is the only obligation imposed on the excluded individual, power to quash the notice; and

(c) power to give direction to the Secretary of State for the variation or revocation of the notice.

 

12 Interpretation

“Terrorism-related activity” means anything comprising of an action taken for the purpose of terrorism, with the meaning of the Terrorism Act 2000.

“Court” means—

(a) in the case of proceedings relating to an individual whose principal place of residence is in Scotland, the Outer House of the Court of Session;

(b) in the case of proceedings relating to an individual whose principal place of residence is in Northern Ireland, the High Court in Northern Ireland; or

(c) in any other case, the High Court in England and Wales;

A “senior police officer” is a police officer of at least the rank of superintendent.

“Qualified officer” means an immigration officer or customs official who is designated by the Secretary of State to prevent those suspected of terror from travelling abroad.

“Travel document” means anything that is or appears to be—

(a) a passport; or

(b) a ticket or other document that permits a person to make a journey by any means from a place within Great Britain to a place outside Great Britain, or from a place within Northern Ireland to a place outside the United Kingdom.

A “deradicalisation programme” is any measure or action intended to cause an individual with an extreme and violent religious or political ideology to adopt more moderate views.

A “deradicalisation programme” is any measure or action intended to cause an individual with an extreme and violent views to adopt more moderate views.

 

13 Extent, short title and commencement

(1) This Act extends to the whole of the United Kingdom.

(2) This Act comes into force on the day of royal assent.

(3) This Act may be cited as the Counter-Terrorist and Security Bill 2019.

 

This Bill was submitted by the Secretary of State for the Home Department, the Right Honourable /u/cthulhuiscool2 CB OBE MVO MP, the Secretary of State for Defence, the Right Honourable /u/Friedmanite19 CBE MBE MP, the Secretary of State for Justice, the Right Honourable /u/LeChevalierMal-Fait OBE MP, and the Minister of State for Security, the Right Honourable /u/DexterAamo MP, with help of the expertise of the Right Honourable Baron Grantham KP KCB PC QC on behalf of the 21st Government.


This Reading ends on the 20th with results being posted the day after.


r/MHOLVote • • Nov 01 '22

CLOSED B1419 - Regency Act 1937 (Amendment) Bill - Final Division

2 Upvotes

Regency Act 1937 (Amendment) Bill


A

BILL

TO

Amend who can become a Counsellor of State under the Regency Act 1937, and connected purposes

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen's most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

Section 1: Amendments to the Regency Act 1937

(1) Insert after 6(2A) of the Regency Act 1937—

“(2B)(a) Parliament may determine via a motion as stated in Annex 1 of this Act that a Counsellor of State should be removed from their role and replaced by someone who is considered a working member of the royal family.
(b) A person is considered a working member of the royal family if the Secretary of State and the Crown agree that a person carries out functions on behalf of the Crown or the Government.”

(2) At the end of the Regency Act 1937, insert the following Annex—

(1) The motion required under Section 6(2B)(a) is as follows—
“That this House has resolved that [PERSON A] should not be eligible to be a Counsellor of State under Section 6 of the Regency Act 1937 due to [REASON A], and that [PERSON B] should be appointed a Counsellor of State due to [REASON B]”
(2) For the purposes of the Motion in this Annex—
(a) [PERSON A] is the current Counsellor(s) of State who the mover of the Motion wishes to see removed as a Counsellor of State, (b) [REASON A] is the reason or reasons why PERSON A should be removed as a Counsellor of State, (c) [PERSON B] is a person not currently a Counsellor of State who the mover of the Motion wishes to see appointed as a Counsellor of State, and (d) [REASON B] is the reason or reasons why PERSON B should be appointed a Counsellor of State in place of PERSON A.
(3) Multiple persons can be removed as a Counsellor of State and appointed with an equal number of new Counsellors of State.

Section 2: Extent, Commencement and Short Title

(1) This Act shall extend to the whole of the United Kingdom.

(2) This Act shall come into force immediately upon Royal Assent.

(3) This Act shall be known as the Regency Act 1937 (Amendment) Act 2022.


This Bill was written by The Right Honourable Sir /u/t2boys KCT KG KT KCB KBE KCVO, the Duke of Aberdeen on behalf of the Liberal Democrats


Opening Speech

Deputy Speaker,

This bill is rather simple. Parliament is who currently dictates who are Counsellors of State. Parliament should change it so that non-working royals are excluded. Parliament can, in future and I hope the very near one, use this amended Regency Act to remove Andrew and Harry from the line and replace them with Edward and Anne. It is the best way to ensure the powers vested in royalty can be carried out if Charles is out of the country or requires a stand in for other reasons as our late great sovereign Queen Elizabeth the Second did. For that reason, I urge parliament to back this bill.


This vote shall end on the 3rd November at 10pm GMT.


r/MHOLVote • • Feb 07 '22

CLOSED B1313 - Academies (Legalisation) Repeal Bill - Final Division

2 Upvotes

A01, A02 and A03 passed and are applied. A04 failed. Full results on the spreadsheet.


A

Bill

To

Reinstate The Schedule 11 Repeal Act and repeal the Academies (Legalisation) Act 2019

Section 1: Definitions

(1) In this Act, unless specified otherwise;

(2) “Academy” or derivatives will have the same meaning as granted by Section 1A of the Academies Act 2010

(3) "Local Authority" or derivatives refers to the local authority in which the academy is located.

Section 2: Repeals

(1) The Academies (Legalisation) Act 2019 is repealed in its entirety.

Section 3: Reinstatements

(2) The Schedule 11 Repeal Act 2015 is reinstated in its entirety

Section 4: Reversion to Local Authority Control

(1) All academies shall hereby seek to revert to local authority control, where the Authority have presented an adequate implementation plan to the Secretary of State for Education.

(2) Where an academy trust feels necessary, they may make an application to the local authority or to Her Majesty's Government for appropriate remuneration for their work.

(3) Academy trusts should seek to have completed the process within a year five years of this act's passage

Section 5: Government Support

(1) The relevant Government Minister shall make available any support necessary to assist with the reversion to local authority control.

(2) The relevant Government Minister shall ensure that these schools are appropriately inspected by OFSTED on an annual basis for at least five years following the reversion, and report back directly to the relevant Government Minister with details for each schools standards and the effect of reversion on the national educational standards trend.

(3) The relevant Government Minister shall endeavour to provide reverted Academies with the relevant provisions to raise their standard of teaching if it is deemed inadequate.

Section 6: Commencement, Full Extent, and Title.

(3) This Act may be cited as the Academies (Legalisation) Repeal Act

(4) This Act shall come into force upon Royal Assent

(5) This Act shall extent to England


Link to repealed legislation: https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOLVote/comments/hax6nm/b955a_academies_legalisation_bill_final_division/?sort=old

Link to Reinstated legislation: https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOC/wiki/acts/2015-c44

This Bill was written by /u/KarlYonedaStan KCB KCMG KT PC MP, Prime Minister, on behalf of the 29th Government.


Vote on the amended bill in its entirety by 9th February 2022 at 10pm GMT.


r/MHOLVote • • Feb 07 '22

CLOSED B1293.2 - Gambling Act (Amendments) Bill - Final Division

2 Upvotes

A

Bill

To

Reform the Gambling Act 2005 to remove obligations to consult the gambling interests when developing regulation, allow for demand to be considered in licensing, and enumerate consideration for vulnerable groups

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen's most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

Section 1: Removal of Commission Obligations to the Private Sector

(1) The Gambling Act 2005 is amended as follows:

(2) In Section 23 —

(a) Omit subsection 5(e)

(3) In Section 24 —

(a) Omit subsection 10(c) and 10 (e)
(b) Omit subsection 11(c)

(4) In Section 25 —

(a) Omit subsection 4(e)

(5) In Section 59 —

(a) Omit subsection 3(b)

(6) In Section 76 —

(a) Omit subsection 2

(7): In Section 22

Omit (b)

Section 2: Consideration of demand

(8) The Gambling Act 2005 is amended as follows:

(9) In Section 72 strike “not” and

(10) insert (c) “the expected impact of proposed facilities on vulnerable groups”

Section 3: Procedures of application

(11) The Gambling Act 2005 is amended as follows:

(12) In Section 73 —

(a) After subsection 2(c) insert (d) “the licensed activities impact on vulnerable groups”
(b) Omit subsection 5

Link to amended legislation: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2005/19/2014-05-28

This bill was written by the Right Honourable Sir KarlYonedaStan KCMG KCT MP, Prime Minister, on behalf of the 29th Government

Opening Speech:

Deputy Speaker,

This is another step in the Governments work to properly regulate gambling and update our gambling legislation to the increasingly corporatised, digitalised, and uneven casino landscape.

Section 1 of this Amending Bill removes a litany of requirements for the Gaming Commission to consult, consider, or defer to private sector operators when crafting regulation. While the Commission certainly may, should it find pertinent, do so, to require it simply opens up opportunities for important regulation to be delayed or altogether be disrupted by the lobbying of vested interests.

Section 1 omits Section 22(b) of the Gambling Act, which states the Commission has a positive obligation to permit gambling so long as it does not violate the license objectives, Section 23 5(e) requiring consultation with ownership prior to new licensing regulations, Section 24 10(c) 10(e) and 11(c) requiring consultation with ownership prior to revisions to the Code of Practice, Section 25 4(e) requiring consultation in guidance towards local authorities, Section 59 3(b) requiring consultation for the Secretary of State to create an offence of inviting, causing, or permitting a child to use Category D gaming machine, and Section 76 2 in procedures for General Conditions (for licensing).

Section 2 allows for the Gambling Commission to consider demand when licensing, which it was prohibited from doing previously, and enumerating consideration for vulnerable group’s impact in relation to demand. The Commission should be able to consider whether gambling is already oversaturated, or where a new gambling business would meet actual demand - the market is not easily deferred to in this case given the fact that gambling demand is inelastic, given its addictiveness.

Finally, Section 3 adds experts on gamblings’ impact on vulnerable groups as a possible avenue for more information gathering when evaluating applications. It also removes the ability for the Commission to disregard irregularities or deficiencies in a regulation.


No amendments were submitted so the bill proceeds directly to a final division.

Vote on the bill in its entirety by 10pm GMT on 9th February 2022.


r/MHOLVote • • Feb 06 '17

CLOSED B393 - Succession to the Crown (Royal Marriages) Bill - Final DIVISION

2 Upvotes

Succession to the Crown (Royal Marriages) Bill

A bill to make provision about Royal Marriages; and for connected purposes.

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen's most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Spiritual and Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen's most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:—

Part I: Definitions

Section 1: Definitions
  1. In this act, “Marriage” refers to either non-State marriage or a Civil Partnership under the terms of the Civil Partnership Act 2004 and The Separation of Marriage and State Act 2016

Part II: Consent of Sovereign required to certain Royal Marriages

Section 1: Changes
  1. There shall be no undue restrictions on the ability of Members of the Royal Family, or those in the line of succession, to get married.

1. The Royal Marriages Act 1772 shall stay repealed.

Section 2: Amendments to the Succession to the Crown Act 2013
  1. Section 3 Parts (1), (2), (3), (5) and (6) of the Succession to the Crown Act 2013 are repealed.

Part II: Commencement and short title

  1. This bill shall come into effect immediately after receiving Royal Assent.

  2. This bill may be cited as the Succession to the Crown (Royal Marriages) Act 2016. This bill may be cited as the Succession to the Crown (Royal Marriages) Act 2017.

  3. This bill shall extend to the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.


This bill was written and submitted by /u/demon4372 and sponsored by /u/DF44, /u/thechattyshow, /u/Yoshi2010, /u/ArthurDent24.

This division will end at 02:00 GMT on 9 February 2017.

Division! Clear the bar.


r/MHOLVote • • Nov 25 '17

CLOSED B531 - Energy Privatisation Bill - Final Division

2 Upvotes

Energy Privatisation Bill

A Bill To repeal the National Energy Strategy Bill National Energy Strategy Act 2017 in its entirety, to relinquish crown ownership of British Energy Transmission, British Energy Distribution, and British Energy and ensure that the government does not have any stakes in an energy company beyond 700 days of enactment.

Section 1 : Definitions

  1. The Competitions and Markets Authority will be referred to as the CMA.

  2. “Capacity” means the nameplate capacity of an energy facility.

  3. An “energy facility” means a collection of energy producing units in close enough proximity to make collective operation and sharing of resources including labour viable.

  4. The “Secretary of State” means the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change

  5. The “Regulator” means The Office of Gas and Electricity Markets.

Section 2 : Privatisation British Energy Distribution and British Energy

  1. The National Energy Strategy Bill 2016 National Energy Strategy Act 2017 is hereby repealed.

  2. British Energy Transmission, British Energy Distribution and British Energy shall both be fully relinquished from crown ownership.

  3. The companies shall be sold via an auction or number of auctions, as determined by the Secretary of State, occurring no later than 700 days after enactment.

  4. The Secretary of State shall be responsible for holding each auction and each facility shall be auctioned individually.

  5. With assistance from relevant bodies, the Secretary of State shall be responsible for the evaluation of assets, liabilities and facilities prior to any auction.

  6. No bidder can own more than 20% of the capacity in a region and no more than 40% of one type of generation in a region. The distinction between regions shall be at the discretion of The Secretary of State.

  7. No bidder can own more than 10% of the capacity overall and no more than 20% of one type of generation. The distinction between sources of generation shall be at the discretion of The Secretary of State.

  8. No company can purchase more than 20% of any one company. All bidders are required to have their employees own 10% of their total business. All bidders are required to have their employees own at least 51% of their total business. (4) Each facility shall be auctioned individually.

Section 3: British Energy Transmission

  1. British Energy Transmission shall be relinquished from crown ownership

  2. Regional companies shall be established, defined and decided on by The Secretary of State. The formation of these companies shall be the responsibility of The Secretary of State.

  3. All Assets and Liabilities of British Energy Transmission shall be transferred to the relevant regional Transmission company. The transfer shall be the responsibility of the Secretary of State.

  4. An initial public offering shall be conducted by each regional company with the exact number of shares, date, and full nature of sale being determined by the Secretary of State.

  5. Distributors must continue to cover all consumers within their area.

Section 4: Competition And Market Authority

  1. The CMA shall design the auction type. The CMA must design the auction to maximise competition and final price whilst considering other relevant factors.

  2. The final design shall be presented to the Secretary of State and approved before any auction may take place.

  3. The CMA shall enforce the same limits outlined above in section 2 for the auction indefinitely in order to protect competition.

Section 5: Regulator

  1. For the purpose of clarification, The regulator shall be reestablished under The Department of Energy and Climate Change for the purpose of protecting the interests of consumers and the promotion of competition with all duties and powers granted before The National Energy Strategy Bill 2016 National Energy Strategy Act 2017.

Section 6: Enactment, Extent and Short Title.

  1. This bill shall extend to the whole of the United Kingdom.

  2. This bill shall take effect immediately upon receiving royal assent.

  3. This bill may be cited as the Energy Privatisation Act 2017.


This bill was submitted by /u/friedmanite19, The Chief Secretary To The Treasury and /u/cthulhuiscool2 on behalf of the government, and is sponsored by the Classical Liberals


This Division will end on 30 November

Division! Clear the Bar!


r/MHOLVote • • May 14 '22

CLOSED LB237 - Employment and Trade Union Rights (Dismissal and Re-engagement) Bill - Final Division

2 Upvotes

Amendment 1 passed (Content: 33, Not: 3, Present: 6) and has been applied.

Employment and Trade Union Rights (Dismissal and Re-engagement) Bill - Final Division

A

Bill

To

Streamline and simplify safeguards for workers against dismissal and re-engagement on inferior terms and conditions; and for connected purposes.

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows:-

1 - Definitions

(1) The practice of ‘Fire and Rehire’ is defined as;

(a) Dismissal of one or more employees in the case of said employee or employees not accepting a change in the terms of employment, where the employer shortly after hires the employee or employees on new inferior terms of employment.

(2) Inferior contract terms are defined as;

(a) Terms of an employment contract inferior in pay, benefits, right, working time, or in other significant ways deemed inferior to terms of the previous employment contract.

(3) Employee representative is defined as;

(a) A member or employee, multiple or a combination of, a relevant trade union tasked with representing employees in co-determination proceedings.
(b) An employee or multiple of the company in the process of co-determination, elected by employees to represent.

2 - Co-determination procedure

(1) The practice of Fire and Rehire shall be forbidden.

(a) An employer may not re-hire an employee on inferior contract terms within 60 days of the end of their contract.

(2) Where an employer is in the process of dismissing or amending contract terms of 20 or more employees at once —

(a) A co-determination procedure shall take place between the employer and the relevant trade union.
(b) The aim of this procedure shall be to avoid dismissals or to reach mutual terms for the amending of the employment contracts.
(c) The employer must notify the relevant trade union at least 5 days before the beginning of the co-determination procedures.
(d) If no relevant trade union exists, the employees undergoing the co-determination procedure have the right to elect their member or members for the purpose of representation in the co-determination procedure.
(e) In the case where terms cannot be reached, the employer is prohibited from dismissing workers for the purpose of changing the terms of employment and must continue with the original contract.

(3) Contents of the co-determination procedures

(a) The employer to which section 2 applies has the duty of disclosing relevant financial information to the employee representative.
(b) That employer has the duty of disclosing the number of workers affected by the procedures and the basis of their selection.
(c) That employer has the duty to avoid lay-offs and contract changes if possible, and the duty to minimise the effects of the contract changes on employees.
(d) The employee representative has the right to submit changes to the employer’s plan.
(e) The employee representative is obliged not to release or publicly discuss information, such as financial records, considered confidential.
(f) If an agreement cannot be reached between the parties, or the employer is thought to be in breach of this act, the employee representative has the right to appeal the proceedings to the employment tribunal.

(4) Duration of the co-determination procedures

(a) The co-determination procedures shall last for a minimum of 7 days.
(b) The co-determination procedures shall last for a maximum of 30 days.
(c) The co-determination procedures end by agreement between the parties, or by breaching the maximum duration.

3 - Penalties

(1) An employer is found to be in violation of this bill if they do not undertake the processes as set out in chapter 2 (co-determination procedure), section 2, subsections a, b, c, d, and e of this bill.

(2) If found to be in violation of the sections listed above, the employer can be fined up to £30,000 per employee, and fees incurred through the courts and the recovery of the fine claimed from them.

(2) If found to be in violation of the sections listed above, the employer can be fined up to the value of the previous salary of each employee, and fees incurred through the courts and the recovery of the fine claimed from them.

(3) The fine shall be paid to the employees affected by co-determination procedures, excluding the fees incurred through the courts and the recovery of the fine, which shall be paid to the relevant parties.

4 - Short title, commencement and extent

(1) Employment and Trade Union Rights (Dismissal and Re-engagement) Act 2022

(2) This Act will come into effect 2 months after Royal Assent.

(3) This Act shall extend to England, Wales, and Scotland.

This bill was co-written by Rt Hon. Lord Stamford ModelVa MVO in combination with other members of Solidarity. It is submitted on behalf of the 34th Official Opposition.


Opening speech - ModelVa

My Lords,

The reality of running a business is that at times it is necessary to dismiss employees. Fire and rehire however refers to the shameful practice where employers dismiss employees, for the purpose of hiring them immediately back on a worse contract. The purpose of this bill is to bring both sides to the negotiating table, to reach a mutually beneficial end.

In contrast to unilateral actions of the employer, the Official Opposition proposes here a co-determination procedure take place. This way when temporary or permanent dismissal is a business requirement, the employees get their fair say.

Co-determination procedures are by no means radical, nor do they restrict the employers rights to conduct dismissals when deemed necessary by both sides.

My Lords, I urge all the members of this house to join in strengthening worker rights in the UK.

I commend this Bill now to this Honourable House.


Lords may vote Content, Not Content, or Present in the comments below. Votes will be open until the 16th of May at 10 pm BST.


r/MHOLVote • • Apr 26 '22

CLOSED LM151 - Nigeria Security Assistance Motion - Division

2 Upvotes

LM151 - Nigeria Security Assistance Motion - Division


This House recognises that:

(1) In the statement in the other place the Minister for State said “The Government will not …seek to help them [blacklisted states] address the development and security needs”.

(2) There are ongoing Islamic State Affiliates operations in Nigeria.

(3) The United Kingdom has a long history of working with the Nigerian Armed Forces to improve capabilities against violent extremisum.

(4) Development is an important tool in addressing violent extremism because it addresses the root cause of why people might be willing to fight for violent extremist groups - poverty.

(5) Britain and Nigeria share a long history and despite small disagreements in some areas have more to gain by working together

This House urges the government to:

(6) End the policy of ceasing security cooperation with Nigeria.

(7) End the policy of ceasing some development aid in Nigeria.


This Motion was written by The Marquess Gordon (u/LeChevalierMal-Fait) OBE KCMG PC, as Private Members motion


My Lords,

I am certain we all remember with horror reading about the Chibok schoolgirls kidnapping, ‘Islamic State’ and similar violent extremists horrify us the world over.

The truth is we live in a very unequal world, because of globalisation something has happened which has never happened before and that is that those in grinding poverty know there are people elsewhere living very good lives. As a result some feel very alienated as a result.

Different forms of violent extremism offer supposed explanations why this is the case. This is a danger to the states where live and we in the West who would face terrorist attacks. The only long term sustainable solution to alienation is development. Because only through development can we address the circumstances in which people decide to sign up to this barbaric death cult.

Nigeria has been a success so far a combination of security assistance and development assistance giving people who may become ISIS recruits a better life and reduced feelings of alienation. We should not allow a small disagreement to cause all of this progress improving security in Nigeria to be lost.

I urge your Lordships to be content.


Lords may vote either Content, Not Content or Present to the Motion.

This Division ends on the 28th of April at 10PM BST.



r/MHOLVote • • Apr 15 '22

CLOSED BILLB1335 - Telecommunications Infrastructure Nationalisation Bill - Amendment Division

3 Upvotes

B1335 - Telecommunications Infrastructure Nationalisation Bill - Second Reading

A

BILL

TO

Increase access to high speed broadband, increase competition and ensure accessibility in telecommunications by nationalising Openreach Limited and the VMED O2 UK Limited fibre optic cable network operating within the United Kingdom

BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords Temporal, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same as follows:--

1 Definitions

In this Act—

(1) “Openreach Limited” means the private company limited by shares with company number 10690039.

(2) “BT” means the private company limited by shares with company number 02216369.

(2) “Openreach” means—

(a) Openreach Limited; and
(b) The assets of BT necessary for carrying on the operation of the telecommunications network, including—
(i) Fibre optic cables;
(ii) The copper network inclusive of the asymmetric digital subscriber line (ASDL) and telephone networks; and
(iii) The associated cabinets, exchanges, and components of the network necessary for its operation.

(3) “Virgin Media” means the private company limited by shares with company number 02591237.

(4) “VMED O2 UK fibre-optic cable network” means the physical fixed line infrastructure of Virgin Media, including associated cabinets, exchanges and other necessary components for operation.

2 The National Telecommunications Network

(1) There shall be a body corporate to be known as the National Telecommunications Network.

(2) The membership of the National Telecommunications Network shall comprise of—

(a) A chairman appointed by the Secretary of State;
(b) A member appointed by the Scottish Ministers;
(c) A member appointed by the Welsh Ministers;
(d) A member appointed by the Northern Ireland Executive; and
(e) Other members as the Secretary of State may from time to time appoint.

(3) Before a member is appointed under subsection (2), the Secretary of State must be consulted by—

(a) The Scottish Ministers, in exercise of paragraph (b);
(b) The Welsh Ministers, in exercise of paragraph (c); or
(c) The Northern Ireland Executive, in exercise of paragraph (d).

(4) An appointment made by the Secretary of State under subsection (2)(a) or (2)(e) may be terminated by the Secretary of State.

(5) An appointment made by the Scottish Ministers, Welsh Ministers, or Northern Ireland Executive may be terminated by the Scottish Ministers, Welsh Ministers, or Northern Ireland Executive, as the case may be.

(6) The Schedule (which makes further provision as to the National Telecommunications Network) has effect.

3 Secretary of State empowered to make purchase

(1) The Secretary of State may by order—

(a) Acquire Openreach and the VMED O2 UK fibre-optic cable network; and
(b) Provide appropriate compensation to Openreach Limited and Virgin Media for the acquisition.

(2) If the Secretary of State makes an Order under subsection (1), they must carry out the functions in both paragraph (a) and paragraph (b).

(3) The Secretary of State must make an order under subsection (1) within three months after the day this Act comes into force.

4 Short title, commencement, and extent

(1) This Act may be cited as the Telecommunications Infrastructure Nationalisation Act 2022.

(2) This Act comes into force six months after it receives Royal Assent.

(3) This Act extends to the United Kingdom.

SCHEDULE

1 Employees of the National Telecommunications Network

(1) The employees of the National Telecommunications Network who are not members shall be appointed to and hold their employments on such terms and conditions, including terms and conditions as to remuneration, as the National Telecommunications Network may determine.

(2) If the National Telecommunications Network so determine in the case of any of the employees of the National Telecommunications Network who are not executive members, the National Telecommunications Network shall—

(a) pay to or in respect of those employees such pensions, allowances or gratuities, or
(b) provide and maintain for them such pension schemes (whether contributory or not),as the National Telecommunications Network may determine.

2 Finances of the National Telecommunications Network

(1) It is the duty of the National Telecommunications Network to keep proper accounts and proper records in relation to the accounts.

(2) The Secretary of State may, with the consent of the Treasury, make grants to the National Telecommunications Network, which shall be paid out of money provided by Parliament.

(3) Any excess of the National Telecommunications Network’s revenues for any financial year over the sums required by them for that year for meeting their obligations and carrying out their functions shall be payable into the Consolidated Fund.

3 Secretary of State’s authority to make directions

The Secretary of State may make such directions, determinations, or objectives as relates to the operation of the National Telecommunications Network that are necessary or expedient for its internal structure, operation, and provision of services.

4 Provision of services

(1) The Secretary of State may by order determine whether the National Telecommunications Network will—

(a) Provide wholesale services to such other telecommunications providers that the National Telecommunications Network determines; or
(b) Provide services to end users.

(2) The Secretary of State must make a determination under this paragraph before the National Telecommunications Network commences operation.

This Bill was written by Mr. Model-Kyosanto, as a Private Members Bill. Portions of this bill are inspired by the Office of Communications Act 2002.


Deputy Speaker,

The nationalisation of a telecommunication network, such as what is occurring in this Bill is something I have always sought to achieve. It is something that should be a nationalised monopoly, and should have never been privatised. We have seen many nations seek to re-nationalise their fixed line telecommunications infrastructure, Australia being the primary example of such with their ‘national broadband network’, which opened up the opportunity for widespread access to fast internet, and gave many people access to the internet for the first time.

Beyond the simple argument that some things should be controlled by the Government and operated for the public benefit, which I am sure many don’t need convincing of, there are many other aspects of this Bill which may be appealing to more conservative aspects of society, much in a similar way the Australian scheme found itself receiving bipartisan support and continued investment even after the Labor Government was removed from office.

Firstly, this would allow us to charge fees for use, and would give operators the ability to only pay to access smaller sections of the network so they can offer more direct competition and cater especially to certain demographics. This would also generate further revenue for the government through fees, as well as reducing the current emissions created through doubling up on high energy use infrastructure. This would also increase private competition, as more companies would be able to access the overall network.

Secondly, this also allows the Government to achieve the goal of Fibre to the Premises (FTTP) at every premises in the United Kingdom, allowing for 1000mbps internet speeds beyond the current capacity offered by Fibre to the Cabinet/Node (FTTC/N) which caps out at 80-100mbps.

A national fibre network that is leased out is also a plan that can work when done functionally, as experienced in Australia through the NBN when done correctly, and it would also allow us to use this fibre for mobile service, delivering better speeds in regional and rural areas, if we deliver fibre to every home, we would not have to rely on the current system that Mobile Network Operators use to supply spectrum to their towers which can be through private fibre, or microwave dish technology which is used in rural and regional areas.

It is clear that Universal Service Obligations are a failure, and that we should not simply maintain the status quo of private monopolies which are unable to properly maintain their networks because of profit incentives. This Bill is one which not only creates positive change and investment, but allows the private market to flourish with competition, with equal access to a nationwide network, consumers will have greater choice, as well as faster speeds as we move into an era of work from home and online schooling as opportunities, which should be available to all British people no matter where they live, at an affordable price.

I urge all to support.


Amendment One:

Amend Section 3(2) to read:

If the Secretary of State chooses to make an Order under Subsection (1), they are empowered to carry out the functions under that section.”

This Amendment was moved by [The Baron Shitterton](reddit.com/u/thechattyshow)


Amendment Two

Amend Section 2(1) to read:

There shall be an Advisory Board to be known as the National Telecommunications Network.

EN: Makes the NTN a body to advise the Government instead of a corporation.

This Amendment was moved by [The Baron of Colwyn Bay](reddit.com/u/model-willem


Amendment Three

Amend Section 2(6) to read:

The Schedule (which makes further provision as to the National Telecommunications Network), upon written consent of the Secretary of State and the devolved First Ministers, has effect.

EN: Gives further clarity as to informing the devolved assemblies.

This Amendment was moved by [The Earl of De La Warr](reddit.com/u/scubaguy194


Amendment Four

Omit Section 3. Renumber Accordingly.

This Amendment was moved by [Lord Sigur of Appledore](reddit.com/u/tartar-buildup


Amendment Five

Delete contents of Section 2(5), and insert:

An appointment made by Scottish Ministers, Welsh Ministers, or Northern Ireland Executive may be terminated by those Ministers respectively, with approval from the Secretary of State.

This Amendment was moved by [The Lord Sigur of Appledore](reddit.com/u/tartar-buildup


Amendment Six

Strike Section 2(2)(a-e), amend Section 2(2) to read:

The membership of the National Telecommunications Network shall comprise of no more than ten individuals selected by the Secretary of State.

Strike Section 2(3) and section 2(5). Amend Section 2(4) to read:

An appointment made by the Secretary of State under Section 2 may be terminated by the Secretary of State.

EN: We don’t need devolved section because this shouldn’t apply to the devolved assemblies.

This Amendment was moved by [The Lord Sydenham](reddit.com/u/Sea_Polemic


Amendment Seven

Amend Section 3(2) to read:

The Secretary of State may be empowered to make such an order as indicated by subsection (1) three months or sooner from the day after this Act comes into force as detailed in Section 4(2).

EN: Links everything together, allows provisions for the Secretary of State to order the change sooner, and clarifies the commencement.

This Amendment was moved by [The Earl of St. Ives](reddit.com/u/Sephronar


Amendment Eight

Amend Section 4(3) to read:

The provisions of this Act shall not come into force in the United Kingdom, until all devolved administrations have passed a legislative consent motion.

EN: We should not be forcing our devolved assemblies to implement this law, created by Westminster at huge expense to the taxpayer, without first consenting to do so.

This Amendment was moved by [The Earl of St. Ives](reddit.com/u/Sephronar)


Amendment Nine

Amend Section 4 of Schedule 1 to read:

(1) The Secretary of State must ensure that the National Telecommunications Network, as a wholesale provider of telecommunications infrastructure access will —
(a) Allow for access by such other telecommunications providers that the National Telecommunications Network determines; and
(b) Ensures that all previous telecommunications providers have access to the extent of the network that the telecommunications providers had prior to the Bills implementation.”

EN: Prevents the Secretary of State of shutting out free market access to the telecommunications network.

This Amendment was moved by [The Lord of Melbourne](reddit.com/u/model-kyosanto


Lords may vote Content, Not Content, or Present on the amendments. Given the large number of amendments, I ask Lords to be extra diligent in their demarcations.

Voting on these amendments will be open until the 17th of April, at 10 pm BST


r/MHOLVote • • Jun 23 '18

CLOSED LM068 - LGBTIAQ+ Pride Month Motion

3 Upvotes

LGBTIAQ+ Pride Month Motion

This house recognises that:

  1. There has been a great pace of change of acceptance of the LGBTIAQ+ community.

  2. LGBTIAQ+ rights are human rights.

  3. There is still work to do with regards to LGBTIAQ+ rights and the fight for equality and the end of the stigma that the LGBTIAQ+ community face is not over.

  4. Pride Month raises awareness of discrimination and highlights the issues affecting the LGBTIAQ+ community.

  5. We should commend both the Irish people for voting in their millions to recognise equal marriage and the Supreme Court in the US for its decision to abolish any ban on same-sex marriage across all 50 states.

  6. Progress for the LGBTIAQ+ community comes after decades of campaigning from civic society and congratulates them on their successes.

  7. It is illegal to be gay in 75 countries and is punishable by death in 10 and believes that this highlights the need to ensure that the campaign for LGBTIAQ+ equality continues.

This house urges this house to:

  1. Support LGBTIAQ+ positive legislation to expand the rights of LGBTIAQ+ people.

  2. Condemn foreign powers when they act to curtail the rights of LGBTIAQ+ people.

  3. Speak out against abuse of the LGBTIAQ+ community.

  4. Recognise June as LGBTIAQ+ Pride Month.

This house urges the Minister for Equalities to:

  1. Publish their plans for LGBTIAQ+ inclusive legislation.


Submitted by The Right Honourable Countess /u/waasup008 of Brighton CVO DBE CT PC on behalf of the Labour Party.

This vote shall end on the 26th June 2018


r/MHOLVote • • Jan 06 '16

CLOSED LB018 - A03

3 Upvotes

LB018 - A03

Remove Part III Section 9 in its entirety.

—/u/Ctrlaltlama, 1st Lord Mansfield