A
BILL
TO
Provide for a referendum on the structure of the Parliament and the structure within which the House Of Lords shall take if any.
BE IT ENACTED by the Queen’s Most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Lords, and Commons, in this present Parliament assembled, and by the authority of the same, as follows –
Part 1 - Abolition of the Lords Option
1 - Commencement of Part 1
The commencement of this part is contingent on a positive vote in the referendum provided by under section 12.
2 - Abolition of the Lords
(1) This section commences upon the next dissolution of parliament.
(2) The House of Lords shall cease to form part of Parliament.
(3) The following enactments are repealed—
(a) the House of Lords Reform Act 2014;
(b) the House of Lords Act 1999; and
(c) the House of Lords Precedence Act 1539.
(4) Omit section 1 subsection 4 of the Life Peerages Act 1958.
(5) In section 1 subsection 2 of the Life Peerages Act 1958 omit subparagraph (b).
3 - Consequential changes to Parliament
(1) The House of Commons is now to be known as the Parliament.
(2) Parliament (the former House of Commons) shall continue to be elected with representatives from throughout the United Kingdom.
(3) The Parliament continues to exercise the authority of the Sovereign Parliament of the United Kingdom.
(4) Her Majesty may by Order in Council make arrangements for the exercise of ceremonial functions by the Sovereign in Parliament (including Royal Assent, the Opening of Parliament and other ceremonial functions); and an Order in Council under this subsection—
(a) may amend an Act of Parliament, and
(b) may not be made unless a draft has been laid before and approved by resolution by Parliament.
4 - The UK Scrutiny Committee
(1) Each of the devolved parliaments/assemblies shall according to their own rules of procedure elect members to serve as the Scrutiny Committee of the Parliament.
(2) The Scrutiny Committee shall comprise—
(a) 2 Members nominated by the Northern Irish Assembly;
(b) 3 Members nominated by the Senedd;
(c) 5 Members nominated by the Scottish Parliament;
(d) 25 Members nominated by English MPs according to the rules of Parliament.
(3) The Scrutiny Committee shall perform a revising and scrutiny role as set out in section 6.
5 - Scrutiny Committee Membership
No individual may be a member of the Scrutiny Committee and Parliament.
6 - Powers Of The UK Scrutiny Committee
(1) The scrutiny committee may—
(a) amend bills;
(b) reject bills;
(c) hold committee hearings on bills involving relevant stakeholders;
(d) hold committee hearings on subjects deemed relevant by the committee;
(e) compel attendance and testimony at hearings under (c).
(2) In the Parliament Act 1911 substitute for each instance of the phrase “House of Lords” the “scrutiny committee”
Part 2 - House of Lords Restructuring Option
7 - Commencement of Part 2
The commencement of this part is contingent on a positive vote in the referendum provided by under section 12.
8 - A Restructured House Of Lords
(1) After the commencement of this section the House of Lords shall consist of—
(2) Ministers may by regulations make arrangements for the constituencies for the election of members; and—
(a) each member shall be elected for a single term of 15 years;
(b) elections shall be held at intervals of 5 years with 7 seats each cycle;
(c) the regulations may specify which seats go up for election at each cycle.
(3) The leave to sit for a peer with a life peerage granted before the commencement of this part is void.
9 - House Of Lords Appointment Commission
(1) There shall be a House of Lords Appointments Commission.
(2) In making appointments the Appointments Commission shall aim to ensure that the appointed members of the House of Lords—
(a) are independent of government (including local, regional and national government),
(b) are able to contribute knowledge and experience of a wide range of commercial, professional, cultural and social matters.
(3) The members of the Appointments Commission shall be appointed by Letters Patent, on the recommendation of the Prime Minister made with the consent of the leader of each political party with more than 2 MPs.
(4) The Prime Minister may nominate candidates to the commission—
(a) when a member resigns;
(b) when a member is barred;
(c) when a members term expires.
(5) Appointments are for a term of 15 years unless a member is replacing a barred or retiring member in which case the term is until that appointment would end.
(6) Appointed members may resign.
(7) Appointed members may be barred if they have been convicted of an offence and sentenced to one year in prison.
10 - Initial appointments
(1) The first 20 appointments are to be made by the Prime minister consulting party leaders of parties with more than 5 seats in the commons, however, they shall come in 3 batches.
(2) The first batch will consist of 7 members appointed for 1/3 of the usual term.
(3) The second batch will consist of 7 members appointed for 2/3 of the usual term.
(4) The third batch will consist of 6 members appointed for the usual term.
11 - Franchise at General elections
Sitting Lords who have not been renominated may vote in the general election after the commencement of this part, only.
Part 3 - Commencement Referendum and General Provisions
12 - Commencement Referendum
(1) On the appointed day the referendum shall be held.
(2) The question on the ballot paper unless amended is—
Which of the following arrangements do you want for Parliament?
(You can only choose one)
(a)The abolition of the House of Lords; or
(b)The restructuring of the House of Lords.
(3) In Wales, the Question shall also be put in the following form—
Pa un o’r newidiadau canlynol yr ydych yn ei ddeisyf ar gyfer Senedd y Deyrnas Gyfunol?
(Dim ond un gallwch ddewis)
(a) Diddymu Tœ’r Arglwyddi; neu
(b) Ailstrwythuro Tœ’r Arglwyddi.
(4) Ministers by regulations may specify the appointed day.
(5) The referendum shall have two official campaigns arguing for each option.
(6) A vote in favour of option a) shall commence part 1 of this Act.
(7) A vote in favour of option b) shall commence part 2 of this Act.
13 - Franchise
(1) A person who would be entitled to vote in a general election held on the day of the referendum is entitled to vote in the referendum.
(2) Members of the House of Lords who may not vote due to membership in that body in general elections may vote in the referendum.
(3) No other person is entitled to vote in the referendum.
14 - Extent, commencement, and short title
(1) This Act shall extend across all nations of the United Kingdom.
(2) This Act shall come into force after receiving Royal Assent.
(3) This Act may be cited as the House of Lords Act.
This Bill was written by The Baron Blaenavon (u/LeChevalierMal-Fait) OBE KCMG PC as a Private Member
Links & Meta
House of Lords Reform Act 2014
House of Lords Act 1999
House of Lords Precedence Act 1539
Life Peerages Act 1958
This bill borrows from Lord Lisvane’s Act of Union Bill 2018.
Opening Speech;
My lords,
The 1999 act was intended as merely a transitional arrangement now some 21 years later it begs getting back to. The system created in 1999 while sensible for a transition lacks legitimacy and has to my view transformed the lords slowly since the life peerages act of 1958 from a chamber for feudal notables and their descendants to be rewarded with a voice in government for a chamber where political notables are rewarded with a voice in government. We have swapped I fear an ancient form of client patron relations for a more modern one, whether it is Salami, Blair or Cameron most prime ministers resort to packing the lords as political expediency to assist their agendas and as reward for loyal apparatchiks.
While in the past I have opposed what I believed to be ill conceived attempts at lords reform, this bill I hope addresses concerns which some members may have around maintaining technocratic oversight and hopefully putting the type of good work that is done in this chamber on a proper footing.
The bill functions through two options, one being total abolition and the functions of the lords being taken up by a federal esque scrutiny committee with members being nominated by devolved parliaments and English MPs. And the second where lord reform is pursued that sees a cap on peers and terms of appointment to maintain that cap, its rolling system of initial appointments would mean that each prime minister would upon winning a term have the power to nominate a minority of lord to the appointments commission.
These nominated lords would be vetted for knowledge, etc but would make up a minority of the chamber with just over 50% coming from elections ensuring a balance in the chamber.
What a victory for option two would do, would be to legitimise the lords in its current role as advisors, scrutinisers but due to its lack of complete electoral legitimacy and the length of its terms it would not be able to realistically challenge the legitimacy of the parliament act 1911 as the other place would retain a greater democratic mandate.
But to do so I feel it is necessary to provide a realistic alternative being abolition, the status quo I opened by noting was intended as merely temporary and without clear legitimacy simply besting it in a referendum would not secure the legitimacy of the reformed house.
I therefore beg your lordships to be content with moving this chamber forwards perhaps a little later than Margret Beckett intended in 1999 but no the less we shall move with purpose and to better secure the legitimacy of governance in this land.
Please submit amendments in the comments below before 10 pm on 15th December 2020