r/MBAIndia • • 41m ago

Career Advice CAT 2027 vs Job: Need Genuine Advice

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, this is going to be a long post, so please bear with me.

I am a 2025 B. Tech graduate from a Tier 2 private engineering college, with a degree in CSE, currently working at a boutique consulting firm. I am facing the age-old question of whether to go for an MBA or continue in my current role and industry.

A bit of background: I started in my current role as an intern back in Dec '24, eventually converted that into a full-time offer, and have been here for ~1.5 years now. Consulting is the industry I want to be in long-term, so I find myself at a bit of a crossroads.

Now, in order to grow in this industry, an MBA is kind of a prerequisite. Roles leading to Partner tracks at MBBs simply do not exist without an MBA, along with the million other benefits that can be talked about. My current firm, however, is an exception to this. You can make Partner without an MBA, and, in fact, a vast majority of the current leadership does not have one. The focus is clearly on homegrown talent, which is why my second option is to continue here in my current role.

My biggest liability right now is an education loan for my undergrad, which I have been paying off and am ~60% through with. I should be able to close it out in the next 7–8 months, after which I can focus on saving aggressively for said MBA.

From a family and financial standpoint, an MBA is certainly not something I can comfortably afford with fees in the 20–30 lakh range, considering I also have two younger siblings in Classes 11 and 8, respectively. Going for CAT 2027 would mean starting my degree in 2028, around the same time that Sibling A starts their undergrad. I absolutely do not want to put my parents under undue financial pressure for a completely optional master's degree. I know that would just be too much for them. This was also my reasoning for taking an education loan for my undergrad in the first place.

I am also leaning towards not taking a second education loan for myself. The mental pressure is just way too much, and my current experience has made that very clear to me.

That leaves me with 1 (ONE) realistic option: FMS.

I fully understand what that entails, how cutthroat the competition is, and the immense amount of work I would need to put in to get through. If I do go for CAT 2027, here's the plan I've been able to come up with so far:

Clear up my current loan ASAP, which looks like it should happen around July–August 2027. Then focus aggressively on saving until May '28, by which point I should be able to save around ₹8–10L. In my head, that seems enough to cover the entire two-year course (fees + living costs, all included).

Which brings me to my profile:

GEM candidate with a 9/7/8 academic profile and 17 months of work experience in Consulting. Please do let me know how badly the 7 is going to hurt me.

As far as preparation goes, I understand that, given everything I've laid out above, I would need something upwards of a 99.5 percentile, and I am willing to put in the work. My plan is to start preparing in December and dedicate the next 12 months to it.

My current working hours range anywhere from 12–16 hours a day, sometimes 18 and occasionally even 20. My day starts at 10 AM and ends anywhere between 10 PM and 4 AM. This leaves me with only 1–2 hours on weekdays that I would have to squeeze in, BUT my weekends are completely free, and I plan to make the most of them. I am planning to enrol in a year-long, online, self-paced weekend batch.

At the time of application, my total work experience would be around 25 months, and by the time I eventually join, I would be joining with 35–36 months of work experience.

Since I do plan to re-enter Consulting post-MBA, do let me know where I stand with my profile, especially how badly the 7 will affect me and whether this kind of work experience can do some heavy lifting.

The other side of the coin: NOT going for an MBA and just grinding it out in my current role.

I do like my job, and I also want to stay in the industry long-term. I am on track for my first promotion in the current cycle. My reviews have been really good so far, and I am planning to keep the momentum going. The growth is rapid, and I've already had a taste of it.

Financially, it does pay off really well once you're past the Manager role and enter the Partner roles, and the compensation isn't bad at all even before that. If I do stay, I would probably stay for ~5–6 years, maybe apply for a US transfer on an L1 visa, or maybe not. That's four years into the future, though, and I'll cross that bridge when I get there.

Another big pro is not losing out on two years of continuous earning potential, which would be a huge help for me.

I am very open to whatever perspectives you guys might have on the whole situation I've just described. I know this is A LOT of information and a lot of scattered thoughts, but I've been in this predicament lately and could really use some direction.

I am also aware that I could be approaching things completely wrong here, so please feel free to point that out as well.

I would also love to connect with someone who's been through a similar experience, or even someone who's going through one right now. It would be great to get to know your approach to things.

Thanks for reading this holy yap!!! 🙏


r/MBAIndia • • 47m ago

Other MBA Exam Prep Free SNAP Mocks & Daily Practice

3 Upvotes

For anyone preparing for CAT/NMAT/SNAP, came across this initiative that might be useful!

There are free SNAP mock tests with opportunities to win cash prizes and free courses. There's also a WhatsApp channel sharing daily SNAP practice questions.

Mock tests: https://unstop.com/quiz/rookie-110--1785518

Daily questions: https://whatsapp.com/channel/0029VbHXwF9E50UkYx10970I


r/MBAIndia • • 2h ago

Career Advice MBA is the biggest debt trap degree in India, there is no other degree like it, it will make your life Hell, if not done from good clg

1 Upvotes

pay high fees only to Top college which have above 15 lpa placements otherwise don't do MBA OR go to low fees clg OR do something else, like govt job or courses

But don't pay big money to below 15 lpa clgs, Even in 5 years your salary will not be equal to the fees u paid i can give that in writing


r/MBAIndia • • 2h ago

CAT Preparation Is family business relevant as work experience for mba interview

1 Upvotes

I am a bsc science 2026 graduate student. My father is a lic insurance agent but he has his own office so if I work under him and give that as work experience would it be relevant and yes I am going to give all the salary receipt and join date and all the documents needed.

Can someone please tell me


r/MBAIndia • • 3h ago

Admissions IIM Calcutta MBAEx R2 Applications Closing soon!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/MBAIndia • • 3h ago

Admissions Advice SPJIMR Student – Looking to Connect with Coaching Institutes

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/MBAIndia • • 3h ago

Career Advice i feel apart from above 20 lpa pkg clg, Government jobs are much better than Tier 2 clg

3 Upvotes

there are so many jobs in it like SSC, State PCS, Banking, PSU, Regulatory Bodies, ISRO, DRDO, CSIR, and many more, people should try it and it's not even tough as CAT


r/MBAIndia • • 4h ago

Ask Anything SIIB PUNE | Honest AMA

Post image
3 Upvotes

Not sponsored. Ask me anything.


r/MBAIndia • • 4h ago

Ask Anything Anyone from Bengaluru joining IIM Kozhikode Executive MBA Program

1 Upvotes

Need to know people from Bengaluru who’re going to join the IIM Kozhikode Executive MBA program from 10th to 16th December.
Need to book stay and travel, so if anyone’s there we can discuss.


r/MBAIndia • • 5h ago

Other MBA Exam Prep Can I get into xlri HRM program?

1 Upvotes

Female

Non engineering

Obc

Profile 8/7/6.5 (I am from Calcutta University 🥲)

I have two hr internships .

How much percentile do i need to score in xat ?


r/MBAIndia • • 5h ago

Campus Life I Made It to a Tier-1 B-School. I Can't Afford Lunch.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/MBAIndia • • 5h ago

Career Advice Advice required for CAT-XAT

1 Upvotes

I i am currently in my 2nd sem end, and my 3rd sem starts next year. I have 8/8 in school, currently in an online non science course, no work experience, good at maths, helps in family (manufacturing) business, do vibe coding and building a market fin niche platform.

I know my current profile is much below the avg. But i need advice to know how can i convert IIM ABC or XLRI JSR with ease. I have ample amount of time to work on anything that works, as i would take CAT in 2028 and XAT in 2029 and my final sem would be in Sep 2028.

Also i want to know if self builded-managed platforms do carry an impact in future, if it starts getting revenue and real stats stuff.

Note: I know i nowhere match the competition, but i have the time which i can invest to match the pace up back to.

I want some honest advices.


r/MBAIndia • • 5h ago

Career Advice 2nd year HCM MBA student at GIM. Placed. (AMA)

1 Upvotes

Happy to help guys. Reach out for any queries.


r/MBAIndia • • 5h ago

Admissions Advice What is your education loan ROI at IIM BLACKI, Fms delhi, xlri J

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/MBAIndia • • 6h ago

Campus Life Gangs of IIMs

8 Upvotes

I have noticed a weird pattern about iim communities. We all know iim placements are fishy, all kind of favourism, politics, bias, etc.

At every placement season, there are candidates who feel cheated. and they resolve to post those malpractices to subs like these. Being an IIM student, Ik most posts are accurate. But then gangs of that particular iim will always come in defence in the comment section.

whats funny is that those defence gangs legit have nothing to say. So they resolve to using vague comments like "Half baked lies", "he's lying", etc etc. Bruh, why would u mock someone's pain just because you r placed already. That person also paid a hefty amount and that’s why he feels cheated by these fishy practises.

What do you think? why do these gangs of iims behave like that. (gangs of iims stay away from commenting on this post)


r/MBAIndia • • 8h ago

Profile Review PLEASE REVIEW MY FMS DELHI SOP

1 Upvotes

Whether on the volleyball court or while working on college projects, I have always enjoyed being part of a team. These experiences taught me the importance of listening to different viewpoints, supporting one another, and working towards a common goal. Being part of our university volleyball tournament, college projects, presentations, and quiz competitions helped me see how teamwork brings out the best in people and sparked my interest in understanding how teams work together. I want to pursue an MBA to build a strong foundation in business and management. FMS Delhi appeals to me because of its practical learning approach, strong industry connections, and high return on investment. After my MBA, I aim to begin my career in Human Resource Management and gradually grow into a leadership role.


r/MBAIndia • • 8h ago

Ask Anything ANYONE HERE WAITING FOR REFUND FOR FMS BHU (IM BHU) MBA, PLEASE CONNECT

1 Upvotes

ANYONE HERE WAITING FOR REFUND FOR FMS BHU (IM BHU) MBA, PLEASE CONNECT


r/MBAIndia • • 10h ago

Career Advice Looking for career advice/guidance

2 Upvotes

I'm working in an Australian big4 bank as an operations analyst (india)which mostly deals with customer queries, cards and dealing with everyday transactions.

I graduated last year with a myquals BBA degree (8.1CGPA) from Christ University and I see this career as a dead end.

Also I have scored 10CGPA in 10th and 88% in 12th CBSE.

I'm planning to do FRM this year and look for an internal switch in my own company or any other company. After 2 years down the lane, I'm planning on doing an MBA with this experience.

Is this a dumb plan? Does having experience in ops analyst help when I apply for jobs after getting an FRM.


r/MBAIndia • • 10h ago

Admissions Advice Symbiosis online mba

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Hey, if anyone looking for or planning to take admission in symbiosis for online mba. Please let me know can get you good offer. I am already a student and we have referral program you can can get some cash benefits on your admission. You dont need to pay me any money. You will take admission directly to the college but just through referral so you will get cash. And if you take admission directly you not gonna get anything. So if anyone is planning for taking admission in symbiosis please let me know once. Thank you


r/MBAIndia • • 13h ago

Career Advice Traditional 2 year MBA vs Executive MBA

6 Upvotes

I am confused about which MBA is better for me. I will have an experience of 3.5 years in the tech industry, if I apply for CAT 2027. I am confused about which MBA will be better for me. I need guidance.


r/MBAIndia • • 14h ago

Global MBA Chances of Getting into M7 / T15 MBA Programs in the US – Indian Applicant

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/MBAIndia • • 14h ago

Career Advice 27M should I go for an MBA?

3 Upvotes

Hi 27 M with 6YOE earning 18 LPA working in big4 consulting tech. Got an offer from Accenture for 25 lpa. Given the market and AIs advancements, should i take the offer or aim for MBA from ISB ?

Note: considering ISB because its only 1 year course.


r/MBAIndia • • 15h ago

Internships & Placements Would you consider the MBA a good thing if you get placed at Vedanta Ltd as a management trainee in Talwandi Sabo after spending 20 LPA?

3 Upvotes

r/MBAIndia • • 15h ago

Campus Life Welcome to the Circus Ft. MBA

7 Upvotes

Can’t even imagine a more ill-managed college than this one!

We took admission for an MBA, expecting at least a basic level of professionalism and organisation. Unfortunately, everything here is at its peak level of mismanagement.

The quality of teaching is so disappointing that I genuinely believe some of the faculty members shouldn’t be teaching beyond nursery, or at maximum, first standard. The principal seems to have absolutely no idea how to manage an institution, and the director is someone who is both hated and feared by almost everyone, except for one particular “masterpiece” of the college.

Now, coming to the campus situation. We were initially shown the same campus as the PGDM students during admission. After taking admission, we were suddenly told to move to another campus because the PGDM campus supposedly wasn’t ours. And guess what? The new campus isn’t even ours either. It’s actually meant for engineering students.

And by the way, calling it a campus is being extremely generous. It’s basically a renovated basement. You can still experience an unpleasant smell in the classrooms, there’s barely any proper ventilation, the AC doesn’t work, and apparently, we’re not welcome anywhere on the premises.

The facilities are equally impressive. They couldn’t even arrange something as basic as toilet paper in the washrooms. When students raised the concern, the response was that all the supplies would arrive after a week. So, apparently, until then, we’re expected to figure out how to manage after using the toilet. Because why should basic hygiene be a priority in an MBA institution?

And that’s not all. The men’s washroom doesn’t even have proper partitions between the urinals. So, apparently, privacy is another luxury students aren’t entitled to. We can happily invade each other’s personal space while taking a piss.

But here’s the best part: despite being shifted away from the PGDM campus, we’re still expected to appear for our examinations there because that’s the only campus for which they have permission from Bangalore University.

The level of administrative incompetence doesn’t end here. One of my friends hasn’t received their results for almost two months, while everyone else has already received theirs. Apparently, following up repeatedly for something as basic as an examination result is now part of the MBA curriculum.

And whenever students raise genuine concerns or ask for accountability, the standard response seems to be, “We are there for you, maa!” Well, if this is what being there for students looks like, I’d rather not imagine what happens when you’re not there.

Now, coming to the students. What’s equally surprising is how many of them seem completely unaware of what’s happening around them. Most of them appear to believe that everything is going perfectly fine, despite the endless issues. I’m genuinely waiting for some of them to enter the corporate world and experience how things actually function. Although, considering the college’s lack of placement support and the questionable level of preparation some students seem to have, even getting there might be a challenge. But hey, let’s stay optimistic!

From inconsistent communication and administrative delays to campus confusion, poor infrastructure, questionable faculty standards, and a complete lack of student support, this institution manages to disappoint at almost every level.

Honestly, the only thing consistently functioning here is the ability to create new problems before resolving the old ones.

An MBA is supposed to prepare you for the real corporate world. At this point, this college is giving us a live case study in how NOT to run an organisation.