r/MAME • • May 09 '22

Community Question Help (Question in comments)

Post image
0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

11

u/star_jump May 09 '22

Serious question: what part of that notice is unclear? How could it be improved to make it clearer?

-3

u/Amazing-Insect442 May 09 '22

Is it wrong to ask what OP should do for next steps?

Obviously sees it’s a non-working rom. So is the next step to find one from a different source, run programs like clmamepro (spelling?), or finding the correct version of MAME for the version of the rom that he has? Checking that OP has A chd to go w/certain Roms, but oh yeah gotta make sure it’s in the correct sub folder?

Some of that stuff I know have to be done but I still don’t know how to do them, & I’ve been tinkering with some emulation stuff for a year in what spare time I have (& can’t invest time in tutorials that have tips that are out of date).

The steps for troubleshooting ARE listed out there in the internet but when starting out it’s impossible to know (without experience) which rabbit holes are useful & which are obsolete.

7

u/star_jump May 09 '22

But in this case, it doesn't matter what roms or CHDs OP manages to find. Even if OP successfully obtains the right files, emulation for that game is incomplete, and therefore will not run. Like OP, you're more focused on the popup than the message behind it which indicates that the game doesn't work.

1

u/Megapsychotron May 12 '22

It's a Sega Chihiro game, it definitely won't run regardless

0

u/Amazing-Insect442 May 09 '22

Ok, thanks. What helps people like (I suspect) OP & myself is not hearing “look it obviously says it doesn’t work,” but rather hearing “here is WHY it doesn’t work- there is no discrepancy between versions, file types, etc, because ‘emulation for that is incomplete’.”

A message that says “this game is missing required rom or chd” will send them to forums like this to find out what is missing. The comments OP is getting are “it doesn’t work,” which are… not what MAME is telling OP. Y’all know what is up with that, but I think OP was asking “I’m new to this, what is MAME asking me to find?“

5

u/star_jump May 09 '22

Current modern versions of MAME do just that. OP is using a version of MAME that is over 12 years old at this point. Granted, there are few alternatives available for Android, but this still isn't the approach that we recommend on the sub.

2

u/Amazing-Insect442 May 09 '22

Ah ok. Thanks for the clarification!

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '22

There are also two stickied FAQs at this top of this sub that explain everything you're confused about. They show up even when browsing Reddit on a mobile device, so nothing was stopping OP from reading them before posting.

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '22

Is it that much effort to Google "what is a MAME ROM", "MAME CHD", "MAME ROM help", or "The selected game is missing one or more required ROM or CHD images"?

0

u/Amazing-Insect442 May 10 '22

Less a question of effort & more a question of time spent following “leads” on info that is either obsolete or solving a problem that isn’t tied to the question at hand. Tinkering with RetroPie a year or two about drove me mad, trying to follow a bunch of coding & romset matching, etc, & …anyway. Doesn’t matter. I felt that I understood where OP was coming from with asking the question “what do I do here.”

For people trying to get into the hobby, your response feels gatekeeper-ish. Obviously new people use Google. And YouTube. And check the forums. And Reddit. And wikis. And sometimes we don’t know exactly which questions to ask.

Apologies if asking these questions is an issue.

-2

u/user___-rekt May 09 '22

was way too focused on the popup, also i kind of thought that it needed bios because it was near gfx, sorry man

6

u/WoodstockArcades May 09 '22

Well it says right there that the game is NON WORKING.

0

u/user___-rekt May 09 '22

thanks for pointing it out man, still my first experience emulating mame

2

u/ICEknigh7 May 10 '22

That's not even MAME.

1

u/[deleted] May 10 '22

He did say "emulating mame"...

7

u/ericvhunter May 09 '22

IT SAYS RIGHT THERE WHATS WRONG. Most likely its a game that has a CHD attached to the ROM. It's missing it.

4

u/justindarc May 09 '22

Even if this game was in a working status, it looks like you’re running on a mobile device. The system requirements for this game are going to be immense. A very high-end PC will be required.

1

u/Big-Worth-3165 Mar 18 '24

Cxbx reloaded is your friend

-2

u/user___-rekt May 09 '22

So i'm trying to get WMNT2 (Export) in MAME4Droid, and i came upon this screen, how do you get rid of this screen and get my game running?

6

u/MameHaze Long-term MAME Contributor May 09 '22

you don't

the red text says that it's not working

it doesn't work

-2

u/user___-rekt May 09 '22

thanks man

3

u/mamefan May 09 '22 edited May 09 '22

You're missing rom or chd files. Your MAME version is very old. You're probably using roms that are newer than your MAME version. https://www.reddit.com/r/MAME/comments/enz17s/rmame_roms_my_game_wont_play_faq_please_read/

Still, it does look like it's not working even if you did have the files.

1

u/user___-rekt May 09 '22

i see, thanks man