This is a long read. I'm sharing it because I've reached a point where I know I need to separate, but I don't know how. I'm asking for advice from those who've been through it.
-------------
I read something on this subreddit that shook me.
It was a comment written to someone who was struggling in their marriage, but it felt like a stranger had been watching my life.
That’s one of the strange things about this space. You read the words of someone you’ve never met, describing a person you’ve never known, and somehow recognize the life you’ve been living.
I’m paraphrasing, but the message was this:
You cannot be the parent your children need while your marriage requires you to make yourself smaller. You spend your days walking on eggshells, giving in to demands to avoid conflict, keeping the house to your partner’s standards instead of playing with your children. You live with a nervous system that cannot rest, and your body pays for it. Your children get what is left of you.
I haven’t stopped thinking about it.
My partner is going through one of those periods where they’re happy, so we’re supposed to be happy.
Except I can’t meet them there anymore.
I think something in me has given up.
There wasn’t one particular argument that brought me here. What was said to me last time wasn’t the worst thing I’ve heard. It was one more thing in a long series of things, and I knew there would be no apology.
One habit they’ve developed is repeating things I’ve said back to me in the voice of an angry, abusive bully. Not the words I used. Not the tone I held. But that is the person they seem to hear when I speak.
I remember hearing it and feeling something sink in my stomach.
Is this how they see me?
Is this who they describe to their family and friends?
Have they made me into this person so they can remain the one who has done nothing wrong?
Mistakes have begun to multiply. Something I know happened once becomes something I’ve done several times. I find myself trying to memorize entire conversations because I know I may have to defend what was said.
I have started keeping a record in my head of things that happened in my own life.
Imagine that. Having to remember what happened to you so someone else can’t convince you it happened another way.
There was a death in my family. I didn’t get a hug. I wasn’t asked how I was doing.
I suffered an injury. Rather than ask what had caused it, my partner told me what was wrong with me. A week passed before they asked about the injury itself.
There was a moment when they acknowledged they had been mean to me. They said they hadn’t meant to be.
There was no apology.
And I thought, what would an apology change at this point?
I used to want them to understand how much they had hurt me. I used to believe that if I could find the right words, the right example, the right way to explain what had happened, something would change.
But I don’t know if I want an apology anymore.
I think I would be frightened if they gave me one.
Because I would have to decide whether to believe them again.
I’ve started thinking about all the ways I’ve changed to live in this house.
The last time I cleaned the house, I was running late to see a family member. I wanted to finish everything before leaving because I didn’t want to come home to another cold reception. I didn’t want to give my partner another reason to think I was useless.
I finished, brushed my teeth, and stepped outside.
My partner was vacuuming the rooms I had cleaned, wearing a scowl because I’d missed a small bit of dog hair.
I remember standing there and thinking, what’s the point?
They think I’m useless. They think I’m inept. They don’t seem to like me. Why am I spending my time trying to prove otherwise?
So I stopped following the chore list.
I didn’t stop contributing. I took over things I knew they disliked doing. Animal care. Moving furniture for the morning furniture reset routine (don’t ask). Things I could point to if I was accused of doing nothing.
That has kept the peace.
Think about that.
I’ve reached a point where I choose chores based on which ones might keep me out of trouble.
Not because I want to do them. Not because the house needs them.
Because I want to come home without having to defend myself.
I think that’s one of the things people don’t understand about living this way. You begin to make decisions that make no sense outside the relationship.
You stop doing things you enjoy because you can’t bear what might happen when you return. You begin to measure the cost of an hour spent with family, a book club, a moment of rest.
You start thinking about the expression on someone’s face before you’ve seen it.
You learn to tell what kind of day you’re going to have from the way a door closes, the sound of a voice, the silence when you enter a room.
You find yourself relieved when they’re in a good mood.
And then you feel guilty because you can’t be happy with them.
You know that the warmth might be gone by morning, and you have no idea what you might do between now and then to make it disappear.
I think about how much of my life has become an effort to avoid someone’s displeasure.
And I wonder where I went.
Becoming a parent was supposed to be one of the great joys of my life.
And it is.
I love my girl. I love feeding her. Holding her. Watching her discover things. I love the little expressions she makes when she recognizes me. I love the weight of her against my chest. There are moments when she’s asleep on me and the rest of the world seems to disappear.
I feel like myself in those moments.
But I’ve started questioning myself as a parent too.
I’ve been made to feel that I help with our girl when it’s convenient for me. That what I contribute isn’t enough. That the nights I spend caring for her, the work I do, the things I provide, the hours I give, somehow don’t count.
And I’ve made mistakes.
Of course I have.
I’ve been exhausted. I’ve been in pain. I’ve slept through a feeding when I was supposed to be there for her. My partner had to take over, and I felt terrible.
I don’t want to be excused from that. I don’t want to make mistakes that could put my girl at risk. I want to be held accountable when I get something wrong.
But there’s a difference between making a mistake and being made to feel like the mistake is who you are.
There was an accusation that I’d fallen asleep holding our girl several times. I could account for one incident. I couldn’t reconcile that with the number I was being given.
And once again, I was trying to prove something about myself.
Trying to prove that I wasn’t careless.
That I wasn’t useless.
That I loved my own child.
I never imagined parenthood would involve defending whether I was a good enough parent to someone who could see how much I loved my girl.
And the worst part is that I started believing some of it.
I started wondering if I was the problem.
If I was a bad parent.
If I was the sort of person who couldn’t do anything right.
I can spend a day doing things for my family and one mistake can leave me feeling that I’ve done nothing at all.
But there’s one day I keep coming back to. I’ve been trying to bury it for months.
Earlier this year, some of my partner’s friends were coming over to meet our baby girl.
The guests weren’t coming for another twelve hours.
I went to my morning book club for one hour.
That was my mistake.
When I returned, my partner had begun cleaning every room at once. Furniture had been moved everywhere. The house was in pieces. They were furious, and I was made to feel like the worst person in the world for leaving.
We finished everything within two hours.
There were ten hours left before the guests arrived.
Ten hours.
But because my partner had done so much work during the hour I was gone, I knew I couldn’t sit down. I couldn’t be idle. I had to find something to do, something that would justify my presence in the house.
I asked what else needed to be done.
I was told I should know.
So I kept looking around the house.
Looking for something out of place.
Something to clean.
Something to move.
Something that would stop them from being angry with me.
I remember the feeling of walking from room to room and finding nothing left to do.
It should have been a relief.
Instead, I was frightened.
Three hours before the guests arrived, I started having a panic attack.
I went into the washroom. I was crying and hyperventilating, gripping the counter, falling to my knees. I kept saying I didn’t know what to do. I didn’t know what else I was supposed to do.
I couldn’t catch my breath.
And in the middle of all of this, I noticed we were out of paper towels.
I remember crying and repeating that I was going to get paper towels.
Over and over.
I’m going to get paper towels.
I’m going to get paper towels.
I think I needed something to do. Something that would make me useful. Something that would justify leaving the house. Something that would make the feeling stop.
I made my way to the front door.
My chest was tight. I was wheezing. I was crying so hard I could hardly breathe.
I looked up.
My partner was standing there holding our baby girl.
They were looking at me.
No expression. No concern I could see. No question.
Nothing.
I had never seen them look at me like that.
I remember thinking, is this who they are?
Is this the person I’ve spent my life with?
And then I felt ashamed.
I’m pathetic, aren’t I?
I was standing at my own front door, crying and struggling to breathe, and all I could think about was how pathetic I must have looked to them.
Then another thought came.
What if I die right now?
Not because I wanted to.
Because for a moment, I thought something was happening to my body that I couldn’t stop.
And there was my girl.
In my partner’s arms.
Looking at the world with no understanding of what was happening in front of her.
I managed to get outside and find some air.
When the guests arrived, I was the best host imaginable.
Of course I was.
I’m the extrovert. I entertained everyone. I made conversation. I made people laugh. I made sure everyone was comfortable.
I became the person people expect me to be.
The person I used to enjoy being.
Nobody would have known what had happened a few hours before.
Nobody would have known that I’d been on my knees in the washroom, struggling to breathe because I couldn’t figure out how to avoid another confrontation.
My partner was happy.
At one point during the evening, they gave me a kiss.
I remember how that felt.
Like a dog.
Like a pet that had behaved itself.
A prop. Something that had performed its function and made its owner look good.
I’d been frightened of this person for most of the day. I’d cried in front of them. I’d felt like I was dying.
Now I was being rewarded for putting on a good show.
I think that kiss hurt more than some of the things they’ve said to me.
Because I wanted to feel loved.
And for a moment, all I felt was owned.
The next day, my partner was overjoyed with how the evening had gone.
What happened to me never came up.
They never asked me about the panic attack.
They never asked what had made me cry like that.
There was no apology.
It was as though none of it had happened.
Except it had.
And I can’t forget their face at the door.
I think about my girl.
She was a baby. She couldn’t have understood what was happening to me.
But what if she had been two?
What if she had been eight? Thirteen? Seventeen?
What would she have thought if she’d seen a parent on their knees, crying because they didn’t know what else they could do to make someone happy?
Would she have been frightened?
Would she have tried to comfort me?
Would she have learned to look away?
Or would I have learned, by then, to bury everything so deep that she’d never know I was suffering?
I don’t know which possibility frightens me more.
Does my girl deserve this version of me?
How would she ever know the person I was before this?
I was strong. I was courageous. I had a life that belonged to me. I had a sense of myself that didn’t depend on whether someone woke up in a good mood.
I was someone who made people laugh because I wanted to make them laugh.
Someone who loved books and music and conversations that lasted into the night.
Someone who could make a mistake without feeling that it was evidence of some terrible defect in their character.
Someone who could walk through their own front door without being afraid.
I miss that person.
And I think there’s something worse than missing who you used to be.
It’s knowing that person is somewhere inside you, but you’ve spent so long trying to keep the peace that you no longer know how to let them out.
I think about the kind of love I want my girl to find one day.
I want her to be loved by someone who is kind to her when they’re angry.
Someone who can admit when they’ve hurt her.
Someone who doesn’t make her afraid to speak.
I want her to know that she deserves tenderness without having to earn it.
That her mistakes don’t make her unlovable.
That she doesn’t have to spend her life making herself small so someone else can feel big.
And I don’t know how I’m supposed to teach her those things if I spend my life accepting the opposite.
What would I tell her if she came to me one day and described a marriage like mine?
Would I tell her to stay?
Would I tell her to be patient?
To find the right words?
To clean the house one more time?
To apologize for something she hadn’t done?
To make herself smaller?
Or would I open the door for her?
I keep coming back to that question.
Because I know what I would want for her.
And I don’t know why I’ve spent so many years believing I deserve less.
Therapy has been refused. My insecurities, the things I trusted my partner enough to confess, have been thrown back at me. I believe our friends and their family have been given a version of me I wouldn’t recognize.
I wake up wondering whether my partner hates me.
When they’re in a good mood, I feel like a failure because I can’t return their affection.
I’m expected to feel romantic toward someone I’ve spent the day being afraid of upsetting.
I go without touch or affection until I begin to feel ugly.
Then, when they’ve had drinks and want intimacy, I find myself wondering whether someone has to be drunk to want me.
And I’m ashamed of that thought too.
I’m ashamed of how much I’ve wanted to be loved by someone I no longer feel safe being vulnerable with.
I’m ashamed of how many times I’ve tried to convince them that I was worth being kind to.
I don’t remember when love became something I had to make a case for.
I’m tired.
I’m tired of memorizing conversations so I can prove what happened.
I’m tired of explaining what’s hurt me and having to comfort my partner when their tears become the focus of the conversation.
I’m tired of defending myself, proving a point, and watching the goalposts move. I’m tired of the whatabouts.
I’m tired of being asked what I contribute when I’ve spent so much of my life trying to contribute enough.
I’m tired of my family telling me they can’t remember the last time I was happy.
I’m tired of being unable to explain to people how sad I am. How helpless I feel. How much of myself I’ve lost.
I’m tired of feeling like a failure.
I’m tired of the stress I feel when I walk toward my own front door.
I’m tired of feeling ashamed because I can’t find a way to make someone understand what this has done to me.
And I’m tired of being tired.
I used to think the next apology might change something.
That if I found the right words, explained the hurt in a way they could understand, they might stop doing these things.
But even if they apologized for everything tomorrow, I don’t think I would believe anything was going to change.
And that’s what has broken me.
Not the arguments. Not the insults. Not the coldness.
It’s the realization that I could spend the rest of my life trying to persuade someone to treat me with care, and I might die without succeeding.
I don’t want that life.
I don’t want to grow old in a house where I’m afraid of making a mistake.
I don’t want my girl to grow up believing that love means enduring whatever someone does to you, as long as they tell you they love you afterward.
I don’t want her to remember a parent who was frightened of being themselves.
I want her to know that I was more than this.
And I want to have the chance to show her.
Which brings me to the reason I’m writing this.
I need to separate. I just don’t know how to do it without losing more of myself, or putting my relationship with my girl at risk.
I’ve spent so long managing my partner’s reactions that the thought of telling them our marriage is over fills me with dread.
I can imagine the conversation before it happens.
The tears. The accusations. The sudden recollection of every mistake I’ve made. The question of why I’m doing this to our family. The possibility that I’ll be told I’ve misunderstood everything, that things weren’t as bad as I remember, that I’m giving up without trying.
And I know myself.
I’ll start explaining.
I’ll defend the things I’ve said. I’ll bring up examples. I’ll try to prove that I’ve been hurt. I’ll feel terrible when they cry. I’ll find myself trying to comfort the person I’m trying to leave.
And by the end of it, the conversation will no longer be about separating.
It will be another argument about whether my feelings are justified.
I’ve spent years having that argument.
I can’t do it anymore.
But I can’t pack a bag and disappear. We have a child. We have a home. We have a life that has to be divided without making our girl carry the weight of it.
I don’t want revenge. I don’t want to punish my partner. I don’t want to turn our child against them. I want our girl to have a loving relationship with both of us.
I don’t even want to convince the people around us that my partner is a bad person.
I just want to leave.
And I’m frightened of what leaving might cost.
I’m frightened of losing time with my girl. Of having my parenting questioned. Of having every mistake I’ve made brought forward as proof that I shouldn’t be trusted with her.
I’m frightened of the story that might be told about me.
I know some friends may choose sides. I know people who have known me for years may never understand why I left.
Part of me wants to sit everyone down and tell them everything. Show them the conversations. Explain what happened. Make them see that I wasn’t the person they might have been told I was.
But I know where that road leads.
More explaining. More defending. More time spent trying to control how other people see me.
I don’t want to build the next chapter of my life around the same thing that has consumed this one.
I may have to let my partner remain the good person in everyone else’s story.
That’s a hard thing to accept when you’ve spent years trying to prove you’re not the bad one.
But I need to separate in a way that protects my relationship with my girl, protects my peace, and gives both of us a chance to build a life outside this marriage.
I don’t know what that looks like.
Do I speak to a lawyer before I say anything? Do I work out where I’ll live and what our parenting arrangements could look like? How do I have a conversation about ending a marriage when I can’t get through a conversation about hurt feelings without it becoming something else?
How do you make it clear that you’re not asking for permission to leave, without turning the separation into a war?
And how do you stop yourself from feeling responsible for the other person’s pain when you’ve spent so many years believing that keeping them happy was your job?
I suppose that’s what I’m asking those of you who have been here.
Not whether I should leave. I think I know the answer to that.
I want to know how you did it.
How you held your ground when the tears came. How you protected your relationship with your children. How you stopped defending yourself to someone who had spent years making you feel that everything was your fault.
How you accepted that you might never receive the apology, the understanding, or the acknowledgment you spent so long waiting for.
And how you learned to live without being frightened of what was waiting for you at home.
I keep thinking about that comment to the parent.
About making yourself smaller.
About spending your life keeping someone else comfortable while your child gets what’s left of you.
And I keep seeing myself at that front door.
My partner holding our girl.
Me struggling to breathe.
That face.
I wish I could go back to that moment.
Not to change what happened. Not to find a way to make my partner understand how frightened I was.
I wish I could go back and put my arms around the person standing there.
Tell them they weren’t pathetic.
Tell them that being afraid didn’t make them weak.
Tell them that they didn’t need to earn the right to breathe in their own home.
And then I’d tell them to look at their girl.
Not because they should feel guilty for what she might have seen.
But because there’s a whole life ahead of her, and she deserves to know the person they were before they learned to be afraid.
I don’t want to spend the rest of my life remembering that moment as the day I understood everything and did nothing.
I felt like a dog that night.
I still do sometimes.
But even a dog will run if it can get the door open.