There’s that one thing Louis Rossman keep missing over and over again.
We DO NOT have 500 Louises Rossmans in each town in the world.
I wanted to address these rants Louis having on his YouTube channel pretty much weekly. Because these rants bother me deeply on a personal level, and for some reason - there doesn’t seem anyone else to try to address it. So, with my far from perfect English - I’m going to try addressing it myself. In fact - I’m going to do it a second time, because the first time ended up being a piece of crap and I had to scrap it.
Louis, sorry to break it to you, but Apple (so as other manufacturers) did not actually wage war on you and all of the consumers. Like an ant has no quarrel with a boot - until recently you and businesses like you had no quarrel with Apple. Trust me - there is not a single employee at Apple wasting their precious time plotting their next move against you. They would never spend time on intentionally and deliberately making their devices less repairable. It is actually much more pragmatic and simple - they just never prioritize repairability. The needs of businesses like yours was never even on the list of their concerns. They just didn’t know you existed, Louis.
How do I know that? Well, I actually have no way of knowing that. I am not an employee at Apple, and I am not affiliated with Apple in any way, shape or form. I am not even an Apple fanboy - I personally own only two Apple devices (Apple TV and a very first generation iPad Pro) which I barely use. I own laptop from Microsoft, a smartphone from Google and a smartwatch from Samsung. Apple did not pay me for writing this. But this is where it gets very personal for me. I can prove it to you that I’m right. Let me explain.
But first - who do you appeal your rants to, exactly? Who is that soul-less ephemeral entity called Apple you are talking to? Is that Tim Cook? Is that Steve Jobs? When you say Apple did this and Apple did that, who exactly are you talking about? It’s employees, Louis. The company of that scale operates very differently from the way you operate your business. There is not a single mastermind behind all of this micro-managing every single decision in the entire company. It’s not even executives. It’s just regular employees. Employees who produce solutions to address business challenges. That’s all it is, Louis. There is your malevolent evil mastermind you are fighting with - employees who is trying to go by with their lives while fulfilling their employment responsibilities.
Here is why it is so personal for me. I am such an employee myself, and you are alienating and fighting with me. I am not an employee at Apple. My occupation is not even related to the hardware manufacturing - I am a software architect. But over my 10+ years career doing software development - I am constantly being presented with one particular business challenge over and over again. Same one Apple (and virtually any other business operating in a creative domain) being presented with. And I land on the same conclusions Apple did in their design thought process. And I am seeing pretty much all the industry leaders doing the same. And the industry itself is slowly transforming to accommodate for that common business challenge.
The challenge is - people. Employees, Louis. There’s never enough of them. Highly skilled and qualified employees, that is. Yeah, yeah - I know. Just pay ‘em enough and they’ll show up, right? Wrong! You operate very small tiny business, Louis. You had the luxury to handpick some of the best employees yourself. Ever though of trying to scale it? Exactly. Try to hire 500 or 2500 more employees and then try to keep up with the same quality service you are able to provide today. You have all means to scale - you are successful. You are choosing not to, and I’m thinking it is for this precise reason. Look at that half a million dollar typical Sillicon Valley compensation package for an average software engineer with 3-5 years of experience. Is that too low, Louis? Yet somehow - we can’t hire enough engineers. All the universities in the world combined can’t cover for that demand.
One way of solving that business challenge would be - invest in education. I can’t speak too much on that - I work with things, not people. Not my area of expertise. But I do know that companies like Apple, Google and such are investing in education programs, grants, they run campuses themselves. Maybe they can do more? Perhaps. I don’t know. I do know however that you are in fond of that approach - you trained some of your employees yourself. You are training outsiders too. You have that wiki project. Good for you, Louis. We need more people like you!
The other approach is - hire a few highly qualified employees that would develop the tools and services that would allow low skilled employees (which we have no shortage of) to perform the job previously only highly skilled employees were able to perform. This is what I am. This is what I do. Last 10 years of my career was solely devoted to developing such tools and services. And it is not in any way more selfish than the other approach - most of these tools, not being a core of the business, are ending up being open sourced. Where other players on the marked chime in and contribute, so it helps to solve for everyone. Great projects such as Apache, nGINX, Kubernetes and Linux itself. I myself have made lots of open source contributions and I did start and do maintain a couple of open source projects myself. These open source projects ending up helping the education as well. I can’t train people, I am bad at this - so I do what I do best.
In essence - it’s just yet another wave of that same industrial revolution and mass production. This is another reason I don’t believe education alone can solve the challenge. Besides that it can’t produce highly skilled employees fast enough in the big enough volumes - it also poorly capitalizable. People die and their expertise dies with them. And there’s only so much they can train during their life. Innovation, in the other hand - is permanent. Once invented - all the humanity to follow can benefit from it. This is how we advance as a civilization. Imagine if we still had to solder every single circuit board manually from scratch for every single iPhone in the world? There would be no iPhone, or it would cost $25k each (if not more).
I mean - we’ve been through this multiple times already, right? Steam engine, printing press, mass production factories and so on. And there was always luddites too, right? Don’t be one, I’m begging you. You are better than that - I know it.
There was an industrial revolution going on recently (maybe last 10-15 years) and it mostly went unnoticed by the common folk. Revolution happened in the industry of software engineering and system administration - my industry. Did you know we don’t troubleshoot severs anymore? We just throw them away. That’s right - the whole internet operates that way. First came virtual machines and then containers. They abstracted out hardware from the software to such a degree that no one cares about server health anymore. Something not working? Kill it. Kill it automatically. And automation will re-create a fresh healthy virtual machine server from scratch in minutes (or, in case of containers - in seconds). Does that sound familiar?
Yeah, Louis. This is why this is so personal for me. I was a part of this movement. I put my hands to create and adopt this. I’ve personally transitioned a few companies through that transformation. And it was the only way they could survive, stay in market and compete with other players. It was years ago - today it’s a common knowledge. I don’t know a single software engineering company who haven’t made that transition yet. And we still not having enough engineers, even though that transition allowed to dramatically lower the bar and put everyone in a much better position and allowed to keep innovating. So, the journey continues.
Now, let’s get to the point finally. Hardware manufacturers having all the same challenges as software developers. They need to provide consistent level of quality for repair services across the globe. And they don’t have a Louis Rossman Repair Group in every single town in the world. See the challenge? So they are trying to transform their offering accordingly to this harsh reality. They are trying to make it so component level repairs are obsolete. So then - repairs can be performed by much less skilled workers. Not because they hate you. Not because they want to hurt consumers. Not because they want to make more money (which they are, but that’s not the point). But because they can’t hire 20,000 Louises Rossmans across the globe. And the one the only Louis Rossman that they can hire - refuses to be hired (on their terms).
And consumers, mostly, agreed to these terms. They put it on the market and consumers kept buying. Consumers seemed to be happy with paying extra for “insurance” and just have their device completely replaced in case of issues instead of repairing it. And most consumers use cloud, so there is no data to backup.
Efficient behavior being rewarded, so it incentives similar behavior. Success in the software engineering inspired hardware manufacturers to follow. Hardware manufacturers inspired car manufacturers to follow. And eventually it crosses that line in the sand consumers are not ready for. I mean, replacing entire Tesla battery instead of just a charging port? Yeah, that one. Too much - and consumers are open about it. So the market will figure it out. It always have. I think that one case might have helped you to advance your cause significantly, capitalizing on the fact that most consumers are not ready to go there and militarizing their response back at the hardware manufacturers with the magic of extrapolation.
You, dear Louis, might have started something big here. You might have had just enough impact to turn this table around. It seems like consumers now starting to care about repairability. And manufacturers noticing that too. And where’s demand - there’s supply. So the manufacturers will adapt. We might see more repairable products in the future. And it is good. I’m happy with that. See - I am not trying to characterize neither you nor Apple in this rivalry. But you are. And in doing so - you are alienating me and millions of other employees around the world who had to do the same. So I am trying to point out - you are not, in fact, enemies with Apple. You are partners. It’s not ethical to shit on your partners, Louis. They produce devices you perform repairs on for living. Be respectful of your partners, Louis.
And, your partners might not want to share the schematics with you until you sign the non compete agreement with them, Louis. They have every right to protect their intellectual property. Why do you think you have the right to dictate them that they should spend additional extra money and resources on making sure schematics are available to you? Have you ever thought how would that impact potential new players on the market if they would be overburdened with such a requirement from the day one? Have you considered how would that impact security of devices for the consumers, if you forced them to open up schematics retro-actively on devices they designed before that requirement?
Oh yeah, security. I know - you think that’s a lame argument. But it’s not. Security through obscurity is a real thing. Low efficient, but real. Did you know that there is no impenetrable indestructible security mechanisms in the world? Every encryption, every locker, every security measure can be broken in principal. What matters is - how much time and effort it is going to take to break it with the current level of our civilization advancement? Look at the door locks from 15th-16th century. They are not very hard to break into by the modern standards. Enigma had something about 57 bits of security to it (similar to DES “modern” encryption algorithm), which with proper and not so expensive equipment can be broken today in less than a day. Even AES keys with less than 4096 bits are not considered “safe” anymore, even though they are still widely used and it still would take significant CPU power and time to break into. Security is never absolute, Louis. It is a constant race between the locking and breaking tools. In that race you take everything you can get - including low efficient measures such as security through obscurity.
If schematics were to be shared with public - they would have to be analyzed prior to that. Manufacturer will need to make sure nothing in the schematics points out to potential vulnerabilities or making any suggestions that may help to advance brute-force attacks. With your 1.69M subscribers YouTube channel - you are making it more and more worthwhile for them to invest into this, so - good for you. Consumers including myself should be thankful - it’s not like I’m trying to defend Apple. I’m not trying to say you are doing anything wrong neither. But - you make foolish arguments every now and then, either out of ignorance, cluelessness or maybe even intentionally to advance your cause - who knows.
Sometimes you make really awful allegations. And most subscribers on your channel - would not have enough knowledge to understand the flaws in your judgement. So in a way - you sometimes abuse viewer's cluelessness to advance your cause. You either doing in intentionally or not - but it definitely causes some damage to the manufacturers. Like that time you went on a rant about screen replacement disabling Face ID. This was so disingenuous.
First of all - they clearly did not try to prevent anyone from replacing the screen. They clearly didn’t want you to replace the chip. Second - they didn’t actually disable the entire device in case of the screen and/or chip replacement. So, if they were trying to do what you alleged they were trying to do - they did a very poor job there, don’t you think? But they disabled only the Face ID. Didn’t it ever occurred to you that that chip might have actually something to do with the Face ID, huh? What if this is actually a SoC component similar to the one in smartcards and keys such as Yubikey, designed so that some secret data such as certificates or keys can never be read from it? What if that module takes the Face ID data and makes an actual decision to unlock the device instead of the CPU and iOS? What if it communicates that decision back to iOS, so then iOS needs some way of knowing the message was actually sent by the authorized chip and not a pawn someone soldered instead programmed to always send unlocking messages as a way to break into my iPhone? I don’t know that, and you don’t know that either (at least you didn’t say you do, which makes me very suspicious that you actually don’t know what you are talking about on that particular matter). And the fact that Apple backed off from that as a result of your rants doesn’t prove anything. They might have decided not to use this chip and keep all the processing on the CPU, which might be making Face ID a bit slower but bearable. Or - they might have disabled chip authorization/certification mechanism altogether, so that the device is indeed will be less secure than it otherwise would be. Because this feature happens to be less of a priority for them than a PR damages - who knows what’s their risk assessment looks like. The point is - you make bunch of (sometimes wrong) assumptions on nothing and then use it to fuel your RTR movement. C’mon man - you are better than that. Don’t give them ammunition to fight you. We need you to win. Imagine if they can now orchestrate a break into someone's iPhone with a replaced screen later and then use it as a PR stunt against you? That wouldn’t help RTR now, would it?
And this is serious. As serious as someone getting raped in a parking lot - no kidding. A typical smartphone today would be having some password manager as well as some MFA authenticator app installed on it. Which basically makes it a single point of failure, a key to all the doors in my life. I came to that realization fairly recently and replaced my authenticator app with a hardware TOTP key - and I have a career in software architecture and security. Imagine regular people who’s not even in tech? Imagine they are having smart homes, smart locks etc? This is no joke man. Raping in the parking lot and in your own house unfortunately is very real. Manufacturers will obviously use it to fear monger you into anything, you’re right about that - and we should not let them make us replace entire car batteries instead of a charge ports because of that. But let’s also not downplay it like it’s some freaking joke. And let’s not give them ammunition.
Hope you learned something… (couldn’t resist haha).