r/LotRLore • u/Daugtherofeve • Apr 29 '21
r/LotRLore • u/jes732 • Sep 07 '24
Is the Source Material For Numenor Problematic For RIngs of Power?
r/LotRLore • u/Afalstein • Jun 12 '26
6 Ideas Tolkien Abandoned in Lord of the Rings
r/LotRLore • u/Daugtherofeve • May 13 '21
Lord of the Rings- Movies: Least-best to the Best
r/LotRLore • u/jes732 • Sep 06 '24
If Sauron Had Repented or Never Turned Evil
r/LotRLore • u/jes732 • Sep 19 '24
Why the Misty Mountains War is My Favorite Conflict
r/LotRLore • u/NoAlien • Jul 04 '22
How are Orcs born?
I saw news that the new LotR show will include female Orcs, and I have a question about this: Aren't Orcs born from these weird gestation sacks we saw in the Two Towers? It may be a movie thing, or it is specific to Uruk-hai so if someone could clarify that for me, I'd appreciate it.
r/LotRLore • u/jointheclockwork • Nov 26 '21
Sauron, Gandalf, Saruman, and the Maiar
So, as I understand it, Gandalf was/is stronger than Saruman. Sauron is much stronger than Gandalf (Gandalf specifically feared facing him) even without the ring. They're all Maiar with Sauron and Saruman both being servants of Aule. Obviously, just because you're the same class of being does not mean you're of equal power levels but why was Sauron so powerful even without the ring AND spreading the rest of his power so thin? Is there a cannon reason or is it just one of those things?
r/LotRLore • u/12BlueCookies • Mar 21 '24
Where did the tomatoes come from?
Okay, so we all know the horrifying scene of Denethor devouring his precious cherry tomatoes. Today I was looking up the origin of tomatoes and I found out that they originate from somewhere around southern/central America and possibly Mexico. This lead me to wonder, how the f did they get cherry tomatoes in Gondor? looking at a map it would stand to reason that they would come from a region somewhere south if Gondor, but south gondor is discribed as a region similar to the mediteratian area, and south of that is Harad which is discribed as being similar to northern regions of Africa. below that Tolkien says the region further expands in a similar fashion as the African continent. as LotR is set in a kinda mideval setting you have to assume that trading is done in a fashion similar to early colonial expeditions and such and may not yet reach all the way around the world (at least for the kingdoms of men). and even if they did, they would reach regions with similar climates as found in asia which is NOT south america. knowing this i therefore must conclude that we as people have all been unjustly punished with the awful sight of Denethor destroying his cherry tomatoes as the tomatoes had no reason to be there (or exist at all) to begin with. Am i right or am i missing a piece of the puzzle? unfortunately there is very little tomato lore to be found so i hope maybe someone on this sub can enlighten me with a possible in universe tomato origin so i may find that the trauma this scene has caused me was not without reason and i can move on with my life.
Edit: same goes for potatoes, also from south america. smeagol was frickin right, WHAT EVEN ARE TATERS PRECIOUS?!!!
r/LotRLore • u/Daugtherofeve • Aug 05 '21
Narnia and Middle Earth-The Union of the Two Authors
r/LotRLore • u/Count_Erfit • May 04 '21
What language does Gandalf spellcast in?
Specifically in the mine of moria when he’s leading the company down the staircase and stuff happens
r/LotRLore • u/Daugtherofeve • Mar 26 '21
Fantasy Geek-Lord of the Rings: What is your Precious??
r/LotRLore • u/Daugtherofeve • Apr 27 '21
Lord of the Rings-Tolkien Quotes and a Pandemic??
r/LotRLore • u/jes732 • Sep 01 '24
What if Arnor Never Fell During the Third Age?
r/LotRLore • u/jes732 • Aug 25 '24
Would an Alliance Between Sauron, Smaug, and the Balrog Have Worked?
r/LotRLore • u/jes732 • Aug 26 '24
Do Tolkien’s Values Have a Place in 21'st Century Pop Culture?
r/LotRLore • u/[deleted] • May 15 '17
Dwarf Tobacco
While sitting having an afternoon bowl I started to wonder, what type of tobacco blend a dwarf would smoke? I'm assuming a strong robust blend with peppery notes, but what do you think?