r/LiveFromNewYork • • Jan 25 '23

Sketch did people in the 70's actually think this cornball shit was funny?

38 Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • Jan 18 '22

Discussion A hard truth I deal with regarding Colin Jost.

57 Upvotes

No matter how good Colin is at performing, it’s difficult to separate him from the fact he’s a Catholic. Catholicism is litteraly an abusive cult, that has both mentally and physically damaged people in the past and still currently.

Edit: Read https://reddit.com/r/LiveFromNewYork/comments/s66m69/a_hard_truth_i_deal_with_regarding_chloe_fineman/ this is the post I was making fun of

GIANT /S

Edit: sorry for yelling. Thanks for the awards from those of you who got the joke


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Jan 25 '26

Discussion Some of you need to change your perspective of what a sketch comedy show should be

0 Upvotes

I get we’re all over the Trump cold opens but we don’t need 20 posts every week about it.

Weekend Update consistently makes digs at Trump but most of you just disregard it and act like SNL is reading off r/conservative posts for an hour and a half.

The show has never been blatantly right or left or even centric. They make fun of ridiculous situations in our political climate.

Expecting them to address a shooting that happened hours before showtime is just unrealistic. This isnt Colbert, this isn’t Jon Stewart, this is just a sketch comedy show that has been rehearsing all weekend.

I guarantee most of the people complaining about SNL not being political enough are doing zero work within their local communities to help the situation. Stop holding a sketch comedy show to a higher standard than yourself.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Apr 07 '26

Discussion Is Padilla as funny as McKinnon?

0 Upvotes

To me, Padilla has become so funny, I am already busting up laughing as soon as I see her on screen, before the sketch even starts. The last time I felt that way about anyone on the show was in the McKinnon era. The rest of the cast on this season is great, I love all of them, but Padilla is like a stick of dynamite.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Oct 14 '24

Discussion Anyone else already tired of Carvey’s Biden?

392 Upvotes

I know we’re less than a month away from a very important presidential election, but Dana Carvey’s impression of Joe Biden is so one dimensional that it’s gotten stale already. Baldwin’s trump also lost its luster, but there’s much more to draw from. We get it, Biden is old and bumbling. Maybe we should let him serve the rest of his term without tarnishing a lifetime of service?


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Nov 02 '25

Discussion This over acting extra was ridiculous.

Post image
28 Upvotes

Let Keenan do his thing, ya goof!


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Oct 04 '26

Cold Open Am i supposed to know who Dakota Johnson dates?

0 Upvotes

I barely know who she is... she's a nepo baby and I think she did 50 shades of Grey, her dad might be the rock. Thats all I know, as she smugly makes jokes about the famous musicians she is supposedly known for dating.. what are we coming to yaull?


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Aug 25 '25

Cast News And Now They Are Just 2 Remaining

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • Sep 18 '24

Screenshot/Other What the?! How did Sarah Squirm time travel back to 1992 to play George's cousin Shelly??

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • 15d ago

Discussion Tonight's cold open was the perfect example of how SNL worked for 40 years and what's wrong with it now

0 Upvotes

This was a 10-till-1 sketch.

Cold opens used to be the little odd sketches that worked their way up to being fully thought out ideas with familiar characters.
Church Lady
Wayne's World
The Californians
The Cheerleaders
Schweddy Balls (radio show)
etc

When big cultural events like the election debates would come around these would be lampooned as well. No problem with politics in SNL. Politics were in episode 1.
An election cold open is an obvious certainty next week, as it should be.

Tonight the odd ball sketch "David S Pumpkins" returned to uproarious applause. The crowd was hyped and laughing away. There was loud energy.

Then the biggest record scratch interruption happened, and the show never recovered.

Same boring, worn out impression we've seen weekly, almost uninterrupted for years. Followed by the same jokes The Daily Show and every podcast has already talked about for 2 weeks.

"Pumpkins" has been the last thing to break out into the mainstream from SNL in a decade.
People that didn't regularly watch SNL would still repeat catchphrases from the show because characters would appear right after the local news and it would catch on. People would repeat it at work or ask coworkers or recognize something their kids had been repeating.

Tonight was a perfect example of SNL pre-Trump, and how it influenced pop culture.

Then we all got to see why it hasn't worked in years. It's just tired clips that will get clicks because every internet bot re-posts it.
SNL just looks late to the party.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • 15d ago

Discussion Ashley Padilla’s characters are becoming repetitive, predictable, and is a little tiring…

24 Upvotes

the screams, the awkwardness, the frustration… it was all really funny, but now I kinda expect it and it got a little annoying and tiring…

I’m hoping maybe they can switch things up with her because I’m sure there’s so much she can do!

Edit: I don’t mean to sound like a hater, I think she’s hilarious and one of the best cast members, I’m just saying they can use her in more ways because I’m sure she’s super talented and can do different roles! Sorry to offend you all!


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Apr 15 '25

Other Can people stop talking on here about this whole teeth thing

10 Upvotes

The joke was most definitely lazy but thats all that proves; it was a lazy joke. The actual discussion people are having but refuse to acknowledge is how ones gender/status/power affects where they draw the line on if something is "Body Shaming / mean spirited" or "Just a Joke".  Thats perfectly fine, discourse is great but we don't need it every 10 seconds on an SNL subreddit.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Aug 27 '25 Helpful

Discussion SNL preaches progressivism, but their casting philosophy is completely out of touch with both the modern comedy scene and the present political moment

2 Upvotes

I commented this on a post about Emil’s firing but thought it should be said here too:

SNL’s track record is completely abysmal as it relates to any POC representation other than black american (and even that has been questionable in the past). 150+ people have been on the show and only three have been middle eastern, two of which got the axe after one season. Only ONE has been east asian. The biggest demographic in the world, only 1/167 representation!! Also, zero south asian, ZERO native american cast members, ever! And they’ve had only FOUR latinos in 50 years (the second largest demographic in the US). And as delightful as all those cast members were, they were all white or white passing latinos.

Why is this? We know SNL casts to fill specific roles and archetypes, but while white cast members can fill multiple archetypes (the straight man, the weirdo, the nerdy guy, the chubby girl), POC cast members can only be cast as “token member of X race” which makes them more disposable (since sketch shows NEED specific roles like a straight man to be filled in order to function, but they don’t NEED someone of a specific race.) Look at how most of Marcello’s roles revolve around his ethnic identity, despite him being much more versatile in his standup.

We also know there’s an upper limit on casting for POC but not white people. For example, when Sasheer was cast she was up against several other solid contenders for her demographic, but the show was only looking for one black woman. Meanwhile that same year they’d cast five new white males. No indication this has changed—Marcello was cast the year after Melissa left indicating the “singular latino slot” is still a thing.

The worst part is, SNL will continue to pat themselves on the back as this pillar of progressivism and diversity in media. They hired one asian guy and we never heard the end of how revolutionary that was, yet seven years later we haven’t had another. And at a time where middle eastern and muslim issues are having a vital moment in US culture, they got rid of their one middle eastern voice.

It just sucks, because some of the funniest voices in comedy right now belong to demographics that I know SNL doesn’t want to touch. It’s not like they have to go out of their way to find someone to be their “DEI” hire. Literally walk into any major comedy club in the US and asian, muslim and latino comics are killing it. At a time when networks are seemingly bending over backwards to placate increasingly fundamentalist, xenophobic and islamaphobic audiences, it’s just super disappointing.

(PS: let’s not turn this into a Jane Wickline hate fest if it turns out she was asked back. She’s not the one who fired Emil or anyone else. We can have conversations about privilege and white cast members being held to different standards. But no need to get specifically hateful towards one cast member who ultimately seems like a nice person)

Edit: well this is a bit more contentious than I expected, but I’m glad to be starting good discussion. Thanks to those who are giving interesting feedback and critique to my argument. There are just three major arguments popping up that I find a bit ignorant and/or oversimplified. One, that TV and comedy aren’t political or aren’t meant to be political. Two, that wanting TV to reflect the demographics of the country it airs in is unrealistic or “woke” or anti-meritocratic. And three, that SNL has never presented itself as a leftist or progressive show. One argument that I do agree with—American demographics are more relevant than worldwide demographics when evaluating representation on an American show. That’s fair, though I still think Asians are underrepresented even by US demographic standards. Keep the comments coming!

Edit: ok I’m gonna mute this because I have things to get done today and it’s too hard for me not to get into arguments about something I feel so strongly about 😂 but hopefully some people found the perspectives shared in this thread thought provoking.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Jun 22 '26 Heartwarming

Discussion Most overrated host?

35 Upvotes

I respect anyone who has the balls to host snl but for me it’s probably Sydney Sweeney. I think her performance fell flat in many ways and her monologue did not age well. No hate, just an opinion and I’m curious what other hosts people think is/was overrated.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • May 11 '25

Discussion I'm not sold on Jane's supposed nepotism...

0 Upvotes

I keep seeing constant accusations of nepotism towards Jane on every post and the reasons are just not convincing and tenuous at best.

So her dad worked for Letterman in the 80s and In Living Color in the early 90s. Her mother was Lorne's assistant from 87-90. That's how the two met. Is that enough to skip ahead of the line? I don't think Lorne gives preferential treatment to the children of every single person he's worked with since the 70s.

Are you sure it's not because she was on a live sketch show on TikTok that the LA Times called TikTok's SNL? An article like that can very easily catch the eye of the casting department. Doesn't that seem more plausible?

The constant "Jane is a nepo baby" comments are incredibly tiring. Am I missing something?

Edit: A bunch of you are saying she's not funny, which is fine, but that's not what the discussion is about at all.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Dec 11 '22

Discussion Does anyone else feel it was rather unforgivable for SNL / Lorne to ask Elon & Trump to host the show?

601 Upvotes

both men are disgusting narcissists (and generally terrible humans) that were given platforms to appear more “likable” - it doesn’t feel like it’s been taken to task enough yet. Trump was already spewing racist rhetoric by the time he hosted in Nov ‘15. Lorne also produces The Tonight Show which had the infamous hair rubbing and was only 2 months before the election when it was beyond clear how reprehensible Trump was. Just a terrible look.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Jan 19 '25

Discussion The Chappelle episode

333 Upvotes

Okay I'm gonna preface this by saying I'm not a big Chappelle fan, he's funny but never been my favorite host. But anyway... Did anyone else notice that the women in the cast had barely any screen time? And (apart from Sarah's Nosferatu which was beautiful btw) they were always kinda just portraying the accessory to the men, the only one with actual lines was Ego during the evacuation sketch, and even then she wasn't really a big part of it. Idk, just something weird I noticed...

(Also ngl the monologue ran wayyy too long, I was bored and stopped paying attention halfway through. If you're gonna do stand-up for 20 mins, book a comedy club, the best part of SNL is the skits and there were barely any because of the monologue.)

Edit: uh oh I've upset Chappelle's brown nosers... I never even insulted the guy and here they come.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Oct 07 '24

Discussion Jane Wickline was awesome

104 Upvotes

I love musical comedy and "The Party" was a ton of fun.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Dec 15 '25

Discussion Jane’s ‘Greatest Threat to Humanity’ song was the best segment of the episode

174 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/cY7o35ovQEY?si=FEAGdiYKrDSYURmz

I’m not a Jane defender and have been critical of her sketch performances multiple times. But this was by far the episode highlight for me. Does anyone know if she writes these songs solo? The absurdist, wry, ironic humor in this one really hit.

I think whoever is casting her in the sketches is doing her a great disservice. Her wheelhouse is WU when she owns these songs 100%, plus her pre-records.

I thought she killed it.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Jun 05 '22

Discussion Do you think TikTok creator Caitlin Reilly would make a good addition to next years cast?

6 Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • Nov 21 '23

Discussion Can we please stop reposting the same joke?

25 Upvotes

It's not funny.


r/LiveFromNewYork • • Apr 01 '23

Cold Open Writers when they find at 5:30pm on Thursday that Trump was indicted, and they have to rewrite the cold open.

1 Upvotes

r/LiveFromNewYork • • Jan 26 '26

Discussion It's not SNL's responsibility to do more than what they are doing

46 Upvotes

I'll start with this: If you or if you believe people should get their political cues from SNL, then perhaps you should begin re-evaluating what SNL actually is.

Have they taken stances in the past? Yes, but when there was a major loss of life (9/11, Sandy Hook, Oct 7., etc). For those of us who don't take their political cues from SNL, we remember that it was widely panned for their odd response of the 2016 election and their subsequent odd homage to Obama ("To him with love" song) during the Christmas 2016 episode.

The purpose of SNL is to entertain, and it isn't their responsibility to educate or inspire their audience into protest or action. They are currently parody-ing the current administration, and quite frankly, if we require them to do more, than perhaps we shouldn't be asking "Why didn't they do this.." and ask "Why do we need them to.."


r/LiveFromNewYork • • May 03 '26

Discussion Ashley overused

2 Upvotes

Happy for Ashley getting more screen time. But that’s because there’s a lack of options without Heidi and Ego. I’m actually getting tired of it. Am I the only one? I
Thought she would be Heidi, Vanessa or Kristen that surprises me with every new characters they come up with, but it’s running stale.