926
u/Juntayuy Aug 14 '23
Imagine being Linus and shitting about an LTT proto type ending up at a thrift store. Then doing this shit
211
99
u/00DEADBEEF Aug 14 '23
What was the LTT prototype?
224
u/Juntayuy Aug 14 '23 edited Aug 14 '23
Backpack prototype donated to Value Village. Was discussed last WAN show
EDIT: LINK https://www.youtube.com/live/EwgZaSYuBLc?feature=share&t=3208
100
→ More replies (14)68
44
u/HighTechXtreme Aug 14 '23
A special version of the backpack. I think it was either a WAN show or Short Circuit version.
→ More replies (30)8
→ More replies (4)38
u/preparationh67 Aug 14 '23
Linus needs to admit he just isnt responsible enough to be on an unfiltered podcast. For every LTT controversy theres also Linus making it worse on the WAN show and he needs to actually grow up and accept his words have consequences that he cant just hand wave away whenever its more convenient to be an entertainer rather than a tech reviewer.
→ More replies (11)
269
u/-NiMa- Aug 14 '23
Biggest L in LTT hisotry
52
8
2
→ More replies (9)2
u/ImMeltingNow Aug 15 '23
I’m OOTL. What’s so bad about this? Can’t they just get back whatever they auctioned and give a sincere apology + serious adjustments + adequate compensation to the party that was screwed over?
→ More replies (1)
446
u/Simon_787 Aug 14 '23 edited Aug 14 '23
Honestly hearing this was a huge shock.
They didn't just misrepresent the product, but they gave away their prototype? Completely insane.
LMG needs to explain this and compensate Billet labs. Not to mention preventing shit like this from ever happening in the future.
I lost a lot of respect for LMG in that part of the video.
216
u/DoubleU159 Aug 14 '23
The worst part for me is that he acknowledges they put it on the wrong GPU and doubles down about it being a bad product. It couldn’t be more obvious that it was never given a fair shot.
I understand as much as anyone that people make mistakes and that it’s about how you rectify those mistakes that matters, but Linus just went “it would cost like $500 to make a follow up video”. That’s just straight up being a dick. It shouldn’t take a massive amount of drama for someone to own up.
73
u/Imaginary_Time7995 Aug 15 '23
Literally even if he’s right and the product does suck it’s insane to be going on about how serious you are taking testing when you won’t even test a single product correctly.
28
u/redpandaeater Aug 15 '23
He was basically saying even if it was good it would never be worth $800. That's a very valid point and it's fine to have that opinion outside of a review, but you can't just do it dirty to try reaching your foregone conclusion if you want to be seen as a journalist. I'll never buy a Porsche Taycan like Linus has because I think it's way too expensive for what you get, but if I had the chance to drive and review one I wouldn't put on bald tires to try driving it around a wet track.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (10)5
u/Fuzzy_Eye_8472 Aug 15 '23
I question the financial success of a 100 million dollar company if they're worried about spending $500.
→ More replies (1)39
u/ProfessorDerp22 Aug 14 '23
This is a huge reputational loss for LTT. A company that supposedly prides themselves on being transparent about sponsorships and pro-consumer just made a huge ethics violation. I can’t wait for the inevitable sad Linus apology video.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (8)2
u/banenanenanenanen666 Aug 15 '23
Compensating will do shit. They should get the prototype back and return it to billet labs.
69
u/Alucardhellss Aug 14 '23
You know what's funnier
Just in the last wan show linus was saying they had to speak to an employee about giving a prototype backpack to a charity shop
And now this comes out
→ More replies (6)7
u/Kaining Aug 15 '23
They also talked about toxic fans that always tell them they're the best while they are basicaly ignoring any constructive everybody on their massive fuck up. From employes wishing they did less video, to industry colleagues to fan on every social media platform.
The disconnect is real.
→ More replies (1)
1.4k
u/_Kristian_ Aug 14 '23
Tech tip: want some money? Illegally resell one of a kind engineer sample👍
468
u/pikapikabooboo Aug 14 '23
preferably selling it to a potential competitor of the prototype owner to raise the price even more 👍
→ More replies (14)4
u/Dr-Cheese Aug 15 '23
“Don’t buy this, it’s not worth anything”
Proceeds to sell it
→ More replies (1)182
u/Rivesleon Aug 14 '23
Massive screw up on LTT's part but we should keep our criticism grounded in facts so that the community outrage doesn't get branded as "based on fake facts."
The original video GN got footage from shows that it was a charity auction for BC Children's Hospital. Not what should have happened, but not auctioned for profit.
124
u/GhostRiders Aug 14 '23
They took a prototype from a small starter company to be reviewed, willfully and knowingly tested it on a device it wasn't built for, ignored the instructions that were sent to them and fitted it incorrectly and then ripped it to pieces.
When it was pointed out what they did was very unfair Linus doubled down and trashed them again and finished off by admitting that it wasn't worth spending a few hundreds dollars to test it correctly.
If this wasn't bad enough, when ask to send the prototype back they ignored the company and sold it to god knows who..
Whether it was sold for profit or charity is irrelevant..
→ More replies (46)62
u/lavaman_e89 Aug 14 '23
If this wasn't bad enough, when ask to send the prototype back they ignored the company and sold it to god knows who..
Even worse, LTT said they'd return it at least 2 times prior to selling it at the auction.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (59)214
u/sA1atji Aug 14 '23
in this case it is secondary where the money went.
They sold and engineer sample they got for a sneek peek review (which they completly botched by countless mistakes) and failed to send it back despite getting multiple requests from the company that sent it to them.
→ More replies (6)80
u/Rivesleon Aug 14 '23
I agree that it should not have happened as I originally stated, I just don't want Linus to be able to brush the criticism off as "fake outrage" when people accuse him of selling it off for profit as a diversionary tactic from the actual issue that you mentioned.
→ More replies (20)→ More replies (15)17
u/ashurbanipal420 Aug 14 '23
Don't forget completely fucking up using it on wrong gpu then blaming company even thought they said it probably won't work.
390
u/standarded7 Aug 14 '23
it's nice joking about it but this action for sure could break the company's reputation in terms of brand deals. it would need immediate damage control and it seems like ltt's not giving a f///.
109
u/dragonice81 Aug 14 '23
They need to release something today addressing it
114
u/etheran123 Aug 14 '23
I don’t know, I’m fine waiting until WAN show, but I hope Linus doesn’t just deflect every criticism in the video.
82
u/dragonice81 Aug 14 '23
Idk, the prototype thing is pretty damning. Either some MASSIVE miscommunication occurred or it was actually malicious. I think they release something today
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (20)14
8
u/StickiStickman Aug 15 '23
They did. It was horrendous.
Some highlights:
To Steve, I expressed my disappointment that he didn't go through proper journalistic practices in creating this piece.
AND the fact that while we haven't sent payment yet, we have already agreed to compensate Billet Labs for the cost of their prototype).
We've set KPIs for our writing/labs team around accuracy, and we are continually installing new checks and balances to ensure that things continue to get better. If you haven't seen the improvement, frankly I wonder if you're really looking for it...
We wanted no one to buy it (because it's an egregious waste of money no matter what temps it runs at) and we wanted Billet to make something marketable (so they can, y'know, eat).
With all of this in mind, it saddens me how quickly the pitchforks were raised over this. It also comes across a touch hypocritical when some basic due diligence could have helped clarify much of it.
It's been disheartening seeing how many people were willing to jump on us here.
→ More replies (1)20
→ More replies (22)4
u/ff2009 Aug 14 '23
You will need to wait until Friday, and Linus will just find excuses how everything is fine and he can do no wrong, and proceed to read chat messages about how right and how awesome he is.
→ More replies (1)7
u/Liquid_Hate_Train Aug 14 '23
I would hope they’re actually just taking the time to formulate a proper response, rather than just Linus spouting off the top of his head.
→ More replies (11)0
49
u/Ok_Pound_2164 Aug 14 '23
What's likely going to happen is Linus refunding the value of the prototype and more talk on WAN about how big the company is and stuff "just happens" and how they are supposed to be better.
And then it'll be forgotten.
21
u/I_divided_by_0- Aug 14 '23
more talk on WAN about how big the company is and stuff "just happens"
If this happens it will drive me crazy because he’s always going on about how LMG is “a small company”.
→ More replies (2)7
5
u/DynamicMangos Aug 14 '23
Sadly, yeah. They have 15 MILLION subscribers on youtube. Gamers Nexus doesn't even have 2 Million. I suspect it won't come down to who's right and will instead come down to who has the louder voice, which will be Linus...
9
u/delslow Aug 14 '23
You don't think Jay or HWU or some other folk are going to pick this up and amplify it. Yes, the techtube space is large, but every smaller maker is gonna throw in his 2c for the views (at least Steve had the decency to not monetize the video).
11
u/FourDimensionalTaco Aug 14 '23
If I were Billet Labs, I would not accept this. The potential IP theft cannot be undone. I'd sue.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (3)2
u/deepredsun Aug 15 '23
The damage to Linus' image is going to do more damage than that prototype, this was a mask off type moment, eye opening.
1.3k
u/nickbg321 Aug 14 '23
Wow, and all of this while you were crying about how Anker wouldn't take down your recommendation from their website. This is just pathetic.
→ More replies (21)612
u/CharacterAddition810 Aug 14 '23
LMG essentially sold the lone engineering sample from small company, while using it on the wrong GPU in their movie for the Gamers Nexus video where Steve tore LMG to pieces (totally worth the 45 minute watch).
231
u/Pandering_Panda7879 Aug 14 '23
Imagine doing this with a big company like Intel or Nvidia. LTT would have been sued to the ground and it wouldn't have been unlikely that they could have gone bankrupt over something like this. Unfortunately it's just a start up and there probably won't be any legal fallout.
→ More replies (13)94
u/Datkif Aug 15 '23
And this is partly why the CEO of framework is in the videos.
Can correct and prevent stupidity
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (41)44
u/ThinTheFuckingHerd Aug 14 '23
Steve tore LMG to pieces
No shit, brutha brought the receipts and it was fantabulous!
121
u/HauntedMike Aug 14 '23
This whole thing is the exact thing that could permanently hurt a company like LTT.
Spends hundreds of thousands of dollars on machinery to prove to the public they have some of the most accurate and reliable data possible.
Multiple tests have a mistake ranging from minor to critically wrong. Too many overworked employees making induvial mistakes that aren't relayed properly. What a mess this ought to be to regain that image.
→ More replies (7)55
u/I_Push_Buttonz Aug 14 '23
Spends hundreds of thousands of dollars on machinery to prove to the public they have some of the most accurate and reliable data possible.
I hope the irony isn't lost on them.
Invest hundreds of thousands, if not millions of dollars in this 'labs' venture.
Constantly showcase all the equipment and new hires you have for it and hype up how extensive and no holds barred your testing will be.
Turn around and deride this product without properly testing it.
Go on WAN show and defend not properly testing it with "I would have had to pay someone hundreds of dollars for the time they would spend doing that and I can't be bothered".
kek
→ More replies (1)19
u/erhue Aug 15 '23
Also
Sell prototype on loan from another company (and risk legal consequences) to make a couple hundred extra bucks
→ More replies (1)
107
u/LIETZIBOY Aug 14 '23
Can somebody fill me in?? I haven't watched the wan Show for some time.
115
u/abz_eng Aug 14 '23
main points
block designed for 3090 was tested on 4090 - they're different and might work on 4xxx conclusion based on testing against wrong use
best prototype the company had
LMG were loaned the block
LMG agreed to ship it back TWICE
LMG put it up for auction and sold it (they never owned it)
a competitor could have bought the block is a concern
→ More replies (15)23
u/Faranocks Aug 15 '23
One more thing, they also sent it with a GPU. They didn't get that GPU back either.
34
u/BTechUnited Aug 15 '23
The fact they sent it with a GPU and LTT STILL managed to use the wrong one is mind boggling.
239
u/Mungkelel Aug 14 '23
Gamers Nexus video, where steve ripped LMG in pieces (absolutely worth the 45 min watch), LMG basically sold the only engineering sample from small company, while using it on the wrong GPU in their video
150
Aug 14 '23
Yeah they used it incorrectly, based on that they recommended no one should buy it and then...
...they fucking sold it.
49
u/MarioDesigns Aug 14 '23
they fucking sold it
After saying that they would send it back lol
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (15)70
Aug 14 '23
And then Linus just made fun of them even more and said that even it they had tested it correctly and it worked incredibly he wouldn't recommend it
→ More replies (20)39
u/RentonZero Aug 14 '23
I find it funny how they could whip out any GPU in existence especially during the crypto boom taking up all the 3090's but they just didn't have the right GPU lying around for that one video
→ More replies (9)20
u/LIETZIBOY Aug 14 '23
I've just started watching it, wtf ltt. I'm considering unsubbing to my single most favourite yt channel. I've watched ltt since they were working out of linus' house. I also am a floatplane sub.
If ltt doesn't change their policy or offer a BIG apology, this would probably drive me and many other people to unsub.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (1)4
u/xnfd Aug 15 '23
The bizarre thing is how hard Linus doubled down on their mistake. To paraphrase what he said on WAN show, it was always going to be a bad product even if it worked great, so it doesn't matter if they used the wrong GPU. This meant the height would be mismatched and it would have poor contact with the GPU. It's like reviewing a CPU or GPU and leaving out the thermal paste because you ran out, and then doubling down when people call you out
25
48
u/quick20minadventure Aug 14 '23
Small company gave cooling block prototype.
LMG tested it on wrong GPU.
Linus knew it was on wrong GPU, completely invalidating the video but Linus wouldn't spend employee time worth 500 USD to fix the video.
Company asks for prototype back.
LMG says they'll give it back
Instead, they auctioned it off to someone at LTX.
→ More replies (10)7
u/dustofdeath Aug 14 '23
They also ignored the provided manual and info on design decisions.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)2
295
u/NoVeMoRe Aug 14 '23 edited Aug 14 '23
So not only did they basically lie about the prototype's performance by mounting it to a GPU it wasn't designed for and didn't properly fit. They even had Linus double down on it by basically giving it a "NEVER BUY SUCH A PRODUCT" scorn and shoutout on the Wan show, but then also stole said prototype and auctioned it off?
Like what the fuck?!
As much as i love LTT and respect what Linus has build.
If they do not properly address this royal chain of major fuck ups and make major fucking improvements to how things are run, communicated and how inventory and review samples are tracked and cared for, i don't see how anyone should ever again trust a LTT's review again.
50
u/DynamicMangos Aug 14 '23
I think it'll be tough for anyone who knows their shit to ever trust them again.
They acted downright malicious, keeping videos with wrong information online and refusing to re-test things in order to keep their bottom line rolling. I won't ever be able to take them seriously again when they criticize another company. They'd rather save $100 to $500 bucks (on a video that would likely make them thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars) then to report the truth.
23
u/MrNegativ1ty Aug 15 '23
I mean, LTT was already on thin ice with most serious “tech people” but this statement right here:
They’d rather save $100 to $500 bucks (on a video that would likely make them thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars) then to report the truth.
That’s pretty much the nail in the coffin. I honestly struggle to think of a WORSE statement that a reviewer could make. Why on earth would I go to an LTT review if I know I might be getting false info? It’s not like there’s a shortage of tech review channels on YT…
→ More replies (3)46
u/ianjm Aug 14 '23 edited Aug 15 '23
I just cancelled floatplane.
Vote with your wallet, folks.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (1)22
u/32BitWhore Aug 15 '23
I think it'll be tough for anyone who knows their shit to ever trust them again.
I'm so glad Steve put this video out. It takes balls to call out Goliath like that and he didn't pull any punches. I didn't think I could respect him and his content any more than I already did, but apparently I still didn't respect him enough. The entire GN team are an asset to the PC building/gaming/tech enthusiast community.
→ More replies (1)3
u/deepredsun Aug 15 '23
Taking shortcuts and a huge ego, that's what I got out of the video by Gamers Nexus.
Image definitely took a huge hit, and they haven't even had a "we're sorry" tone about it, fucking up is bad but happens, doubling down shows what your character is like.
3
Aug 15 '23
If you actually watched the video and cared to hear Linus's reasoning, you would understand why it doesn't matter about what GPU they tested it on. The point he made, and rightfully so, is that regardless of the cooling performance, its a bad buy.
→ More replies (4)2
→ More replies (9)2
Aug 15 '23
The damaged company has legal grounds to sue for libel and defamation. Like legit lawsuit they would win for a fuck ton of money.
511
u/SFuglsang Aug 14 '23
This feels like too much of a fuck up to be intentional. I hope there has been some misunderstanding.
64
u/edamane12345 Aug 14 '23
The review video was released on June 24th. The Charity auction was on July 29-30th. So by 24th or end of June, LTT was done with the testing. You are telling me they accidentally held the prototype for a whole month?
Not only that, Billet Labs requested the item back TWICE and LTT agreed. LTT acknowledged the possession not once but twice.
64
u/CakeBakeMaker Aug 14 '23
Given that they thought the 4090 on the shelf was a 3090 Ti, I absolutely believe they just threw the Billet Labs cooler in the warehouse for a month before going "hey let's poke around and find some stuff we can auction off for charity." The marketing people answering the emails probably have never set foot in the tech trenches.
Not that this is an excuse mind. Incompetence is just as harmful as malice.
20
u/SnazzyLabs Aug 14 '23
This is definitely what happened, but that doesn't excuse it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)37
u/emwungarand Aug 14 '23
If they have a warehouse full of mislabeled shit and don't know heads from tails, how the fuck is anyone supposed to take LT Labs seriously in the future? This is a colossal failure from top to bottom.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (2)13
u/chibicascade2 Aug 14 '23
You know how big companies work right? One guy in inventory put it on the wrong shelf and a different guy agrees to ship it back. A third guy goes to get it off the shelf to ship back and sees that its missing.
For a company as big as LMG, it's not surprising that a screw up like this happened, but they definitely need to put safeguards in place to make sure this doesn't happen. They also need to find out where the prototype went and try to get it returned.
→ More replies (8)410
u/No-Internal-4796 Aug 14 '23
doesn't matter if it was intentional or not - the damage is done - both to the owner and to LMG. If it was a fuckup, they need to revisit their processes, because they obviously suck, and if it wasn't, they are straight-up the corporate shitbags some of us had begun suspecting was the case...
80
Aug 14 '23 edited Jun 29 '25
fuck spez
→ More replies (32)101
u/BakuretsuGirl16 Aug 14 '23
The odds of it being intentional are basically 0
Negligence, carelessness, miscommunication, sure.
→ More replies (15)→ More replies (34)4
u/RayzTheRoof Aug 14 '23
The absolute LEAST they should do is fully pay for another prototype to be made, as well as pay them whatever the auction went for. I know the auction was for charity, but this should be done imo
21
10
u/TheDuke2031 Aug 14 '23
It's done though billet labs is most likelly finished,
Their prototype could be in china right now and being mass produced and theres nothing billet labs people could do to fix this issue.→ More replies (4)12
Aug 14 '23
There is no way this is intentional, but this fuck up is too big, they need to make serious reparations regardless of their intentions
→ More replies (3)5
u/Laicbeias Aug 15 '23
its not intentional. its just incompetence triggered by too much self imposed pressure. linus has too much perfectionist energy and that can reflect badly on internal processes
3
→ More replies (9)3
u/iVinc Aug 14 '23
Linus - Cmon guys do you actually think i would sell something like that to their competitor? After all those years i would think the trust i build up would be enough to give me benefit of the doubt.
199
u/borek87 Aug 14 '23
Imagine someone will sell it to a cooling company / competitor who will use the solutions / IP to make a clone.
Would be a shame to loose $100 mil valued company to a lawsuit...
→ More replies (22)5
83
u/MrHollywood Aug 14 '23
Remember Linus always says to listen to companys who tell you what they are and how they aren't your friend. LMG is included in that, even if it is gross negligence that led to this. The twofer of shitting on the product they were knowingly improperly using and then accidentally selling the one of kind of engineering sample is massive fuck up intentional or otherwise. One thing to be wrong, another to accept no responsibility, double down on it, then proceed to fuck up further by selling the sample.
→ More replies (1)44
139
u/CommercialBreadLoaf Aug 14 '23
Honestly I wish billet labs had a donation page, they literally got fucked so hard. Terrible review that was based on LTT being too lazy to get the intended card, then trashed publically, then had the one of a kind prototype sold to some unknown third party.
I hope linus responds to this crap accordingly
44
u/sortabanana Aug 14 '23
You can buy some of their fittings and pipes on their website! They sell some much more affordable products.
24
u/CommercialBreadLoaf Aug 14 '23
Who knows, I might need some 1/4 inch brass fittings in the future ;)
6
u/Vioret Aug 15 '23
They already settled it. Billet gave them a quoted price for the prototype and LMG agreed to pay it.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (4)3
u/n0tAgOat Aug 14 '23
It's not unknown. It was a silent auction so they have the winners name.
→ More replies (1)
18
u/tkajtoch Aug 14 '23
I can try to understand rushing content to grow the business but auctioning a single engineering sample this company had after confirming they’ll send it back is just outrageous. This can literally cost these guys the entire company and as a small business owner myself I can imagine how they must feel right now after trusting LMG in the first place. I’m truly sorry, guys. I unsubscribed from floatplane, I won’t support this behavior anymore.
→ More replies (1)
99
u/capptan Aug 14 '23
This feels like it was malicious, even the follow up of not giving a fuck was dirty to me.
→ More replies (14)14
10
u/MercuryHawk1417 Aug 14 '23
Coming as someone who went into a tech career after being introduced to it by LTT, this is immensely disappointing. To make blanket judgements about a future product from a prototype that they knowingly misused is just pure and unearned arrogance. Not even going to mention the blatant THEFT of a small startups property. Just…. sad. If there isn’t a major course correction from this, then I guess you really should never meet your idols.
→ More replies (1)
8
u/Twiizzzle Aug 14 '23
This is such a huge fuck up!
Get your shit together internally. That is completely ridiculous that this ahd to happen. Whether it was miscommunication, employees not paying attention, once LTT said they would send it back...YOU SEND IT! Plain and simple, plus I'm almost certain that it's illegal to resell it.
The facts that Linus refused to do the due diligence of properly testing the cooler baffles me. You wrote it off because you chose to do it wrong, and literally said "fuck it, put the video out". You said you been doing this for a long time...and it still shows that you don't know everything.
Be better for fucks sake.
8
43
u/RoakWall Aug 14 '23
Whoever did this must present their next video naked.
60
u/Daepilin Aug 14 '23
whoever is at fault should need to contact a lawyer because I hope there are lawsuits coming their way...
Potentially ruining a company is not a "haha, lets do an apology video" situation...
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (4)3
18
u/edamane12345 Aug 14 '23
Never watched the cooler review video till today. I turned it off after 20seconds into the video when Linus said someone who has NO experience in watercooling is going to install a niche prototype product.
Just... no. I get that it makes it interesting but for a niche product, where is the professionalism required???
→ More replies (1)
11
u/MHWGamer Aug 14 '23
I mean the point really isn't about the risk of a compititor or that Linus himself is the evil thief guy selling stuff he doesn't own. The main point is how shitty the intern communication is that something like this can even happen.. and worst of all that Linus is so high up sometimes that he doesn't even understand the effect it has on small companies. That's the evil part. Even if the two-guy-business product is bad/overpriced/ not recommended, comepletely "testing" it in a wrong way and then coming up with "I don't feel like sorry NOT spending a few hundret bucks in worktime" is utterly shameless. Imagine if a big corp did that to their first product reviews as they were small.. or even now, imagine how much they would cry if you did that while testing the screwdrivers or overpriced products from them. "Hey, the screwdriver can't be used as a hammer without breaking, my 5$ metal screwdriver can do it. Wouldn't recommend" Unrespectful, shameful, not worthy as someone who wants to be "the gold standard of pc hardware testing and reviews" I hope this time Linus takes the time to reflect and apologize
→ More replies (1)2
u/MrNegativ1ty Aug 15 '23
I mean the point really isn’t about the risk of a compititor or that Linus himself is the evil thief guy selling stuff he doesn’t own. The main point is how shitty the intern communication is that something like this can even happen.. and worst of all that Linus is so high up sometimes that he doesn’t even understand the effect it has on small companies.
Yep, that’s the main point that I think is getting lost. I seriously doubt any other company is using the Billet prototype to develop their own similar product. I also doubt it was done intentionally, it was almost certainly a mistake that they offered it at the auction. Of course neither of those things absolve LTT for selling off the prototype that they weren’t supposed to, that’s a pretty egregious screw up by them and almost certainly is going to have lasting ramifications on their business.
The real point Steve was getting at was that if communication at LMG can get so bad that egregious stuff like the Billet Labs “scandal” can happen then it’s no wonder that lesser stuff like incorrect benchmarking data and forgetting to peel off the shipping packaging on a mouse also fall through the cracks.
I seriously think that LMG need to think long and hard about their production schedule because it’s becoming more and more apparent that they’re being overwhelmed with the upload schedule. Something’s gotta give.
It’s just sad because a decade ago, LTT was pretty much the go to place for any tech reviews, like if I wanted to buy a GPU I would go to LTT back in the day to look at an in depth review. You wouldn’t really do that nowadays, you’d go to GN or HUB or other similar outlets.
18
17
u/bakuman47 Aug 14 '23
Honestly I started questioning LTT around the backpack warranty controversy. HE was the one who always told everyone how important a warranty was to the customer, but then with his own product labeled it as “trust me bro” mentality to the scale of producing distasteful t-shirts that even made Luke cringe. This supersedes that a whole other level. Not only making even Luke cringe this time, with how everything has fallen in terms of standards, but also shitting on a small company where LMG were at fault for testing incorrectly, and then not retesting since that takes a couple hundred out of the company, a couple HUNDRED, Linus you misplace GPUs worth hundreds of dollars, you drive a taycan, yet you can’t afford a couple hundred to fix some bit of misinformation. Not only that but then selling the company’s only prototype, that they need to both impress investors or other media, who CAN and WILL properly test it. I’m sorry but if this is not negligence, that’s corrupt as hell. You literally set a company back due to your own negligence in literally two ways. I know obviously they are going to give them the auction money, not due to them “doing the right thing” but because optics are against them. For my final thoughts, just insert the over used Dark Knight Quote.
→ More replies (2)
5
12
u/Broad_Stuff_943 Aug 15 '23
Never thought I’d see Linus punching down. He was a twat on the WAN show.
I feel sorry for Luke. He should leave LMG.
→ More replies (1)2
u/msbaustx Aug 15 '23
And it isn't the first time. I've seen Luke die a little so many times because of the shit coming from Linus on the Wan show. I feel bad for Luke and I hate seeing what Linus has become.
48
Aug 14 '23
I didn't actually see anything from billet labs proving they asked for it back. Not saying they didn't but proof would be nice.
55
u/DoubleU159 Aug 14 '23
Is it not just an industry standard to not sell other peoples prototypes?
→ More replies (13)9
4
u/DynamicMangos Aug 14 '23
In the video it's said that Billet Labs has told GN directly, and it's stated that LMG agreed to sending it back twice. The proof likely consist of some E-Mails, but there isn't any reason to publicly display those private E-Mails when there isn't any reasonable doubt.
Should LMG claim that they never got any E-Mail asking for the prototype back, THEN it would be necessary to provide evidence.
→ More replies (7)0
Aug 14 '23
[deleted]
27
u/fade_into_darkness Aug 14 '23
The proof is "in conversations with Billet Labs, Gamers Nexus learned...", so hearsay but I'm sure an email chain exists somewhere.
→ More replies (10)0
4
4
Aug 14 '23
this isn't funny its something that should result in legal action and end in lmg paying hundreds of thousands of dollars in damages
20
Aug 14 '23
Yep this was the last straw form me i’m out. Floatplane and YouTube sub gone. Vote with your sub / wallet as Linus would say.
→ More replies (4)
3
3
u/Jealous_Check_6789 Aug 14 '23
This will blow up in his face so much. Let's hear his nonpology already. :)
3
3
19
u/NullTie Aug 14 '23
Where’s the Gofundme for the lawsuit?
3
u/Vioret Aug 15 '23
There is nothing to sue. They already settled it. Billet gave them a quoted price for the prototype and LMG agreed to pay it.
12
u/Wirenfeldt Aug 14 '23
They will have a flood of lawyers chomping at the bit to tear LMG a new asshole as soon as this gains traction.. Between video evidence, what I'm assuming is email correspondence and ideally an auction final sale note, this seems like free money for someone willing to do the work..
→ More replies (2)6
u/Vioret Aug 15 '23
There is nothing to sue. They already settled it. Billet gave them a quoted price for the prototype and LMG agreed to pay it.
7
u/CaffeineHelix Aug 14 '23
I think.. I'm going to unsub. I know I don't matter, and I'll still try and watch the WAN show. But I don't think this should just be blown over. Especially due to how morally right LTT used to be. They should listen to Luke more.
→ More replies (1)
12
u/Alastor999 Aug 14 '23
Hanlon's Razor aside, that kinda felt like it was done out of spite after being called out for improperly testing the prototype...
40
u/quick20minadventure Aug 14 '23
I can already imagine Linus is gonna come to WAN show and say no contract, so we were not legally obliged to send it back. Luke's gonna die inside and I can see his defeated face in 4k already.
8
u/bob_707- Aug 15 '23
Luke would literally need to walk out, to save face. Had to stop watching wan show due to the constant hot takes
4
u/General_WCJ Aug 14 '23
Honestly, I wouldn't be surprised if LTT's Lawyers say to not say anything publicly, or maybe only allowing a quick press release saying that they are conducting a full investigation on the procedural failures that allowed this to happen and that it won't happen again
→ More replies (2)4
u/FourDimensionalTaco Aug 14 '23
If they did this out of spite, they are massively stupid. This is fertile grounds for a lawsuit.
6
Aug 15 '23 edited Aug 15 '23
They made how much from that trash video? Yet wouldn't spend a dime of it to correct their malpractice? Then legit stole the product? And profited from it?
With zero effort to correct anything. Only instead attempting to avoid blame.
Disgusting. Linus is trash. What a prick.
4
u/Firecrash Aug 14 '23
Not that I wish this to them BUT it's about time some big lawsuit kicks their butts to do better...
→ More replies (2)
4
4
Aug 14 '23
Who was the writer for the video where they fucked up installing it?
6
u/DynamicMangos Aug 14 '23
I think it doesn't even really matter. They noticed in the beginning of the installation process that they didn't have the right GPU. at that point they should've either went and gotten a fitting one, or stopped filming.
Linus was there on set, he could've made the call to end it and do it right, but he didn't
6
u/Character_Past5515 Aug 14 '23
I get why people WOULD be mad, but did Billet actually ask for it back, Gamer Nexus saying this doesn't make it true, I can't find any comment where they ask for it back. Also who says they didn't just gave it to them for the action?
9
u/bradtn Aug 14 '23
They emailed the they don't communicate with them via YouTube comments
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (8)4
u/Klopferator Aug 14 '23
It's literally said in the video (around the 33 minute mark): "In conversation with Billet Labs GN learned..." and then Steve proceeds to tell the exact dates when BL asked to get the prototype back.
→ More replies (6)
5
u/Durier_Ferrand Aug 14 '23
I hope that after thoroughly explaining what MerchMessages are, they'll have some time to address this tiny situation.
By the way, does anyone know where I could buy a good water bottle ?
→ More replies (2)
5
u/Fubister Aug 14 '23
Damage to Billet Labs could be catastrophic, this is a major f up on LTT part. Data and bench results mistakes were interesting to watch because I had no idea they made so many, but bad mouthing Billet Labs and their product, misusing it and then selling it... I'm lost for words.
2
2
Aug 14 '23
What I hate is hearing Linus needing to be frugal about something. It comes up a lot, like his company spending for a video is low, but they'll take expensive ass sponsors hardware in a heartbeat.
Why does LTT need to auction off anything? Seriously.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Ezren- Aug 14 '23
It was said elsewhere it was for charity, but not spending money to do reviews correctly by spending a little extra time is purely an excuse. It was either negligent or willfully accepting incorrect information in a review. There's no magical other option.
2
2
u/ILikeBeans86 Aug 14 '23
So all of the videos of them doing stuff wrong and jackleg aren't just for content. That's how they run their conpany
2
u/metallus97 Aug 14 '23
At LEAST it wasn’t sold for their profit but for the profit of… I think it was a children’s hospital… a good cause
2
2
u/itsthedave1 Aug 15 '23
Seriously major issue and their offer to pay compensation is really not a good enough solution.
Hate to say it, but there really should be a major consequence for this...
2
u/abhorredmind Aug 15 '23
I will never forget the way he behaved in the "Strange Parts" video, you can see what type of person this guy is.
→ More replies (4)
2
u/Yodzilla Aug 15 '23
Man I really need to buy some Gamers Nexus merch, they’ve had such a good attention to detail for years and those coasters look rad.
2
2
u/Chicken-Nuggiesss Aug 15 '23
I swear i've heard on WAN show about another product saying something like "well they haven't asked for it back..."
2
u/James_H_M Aug 15 '23
OK, I'm not gonna scrub all of the last two WAN shows but didn't Linus and Luke have a small discussion regarding the backpacks they saw around LTX about someone changing out the zipper and how original it looked, but also I think it was Linus pointed out he saw a prototype that was there and how it was unfortunate, as it was not to be out in the public space.
A person from LTT must of taken it home or given to someone else and it ended up getting out of the LTT control but Linus would have liked it have been returned to the company.
However, a prototype cooling block by another company is able to be sold.
I think it might of been around when they were talking about their buttons.
→ More replies (2)
2
u/NeutralTableFlip Aug 15 '23
Whoever the point of contact at LMG that Billet had to go through needs to be let go.
There’s just no way in any other job you can mess up this bad, potentially put your employer in a very bad legal situation and still expect to keep your job.
2
u/mattumanu Aug 15 '23
While trying to save 100, 200, 300, or even 500 dollars, he wound up wasting 10s of thousands of dollars. That's why you do your due diligence. That's why it's not a waste of money. My guess is Linus will never understand that.
Now for the big question: Is this Linus' "re-roll" moment?
2
u/mildlyfrostbitten Aug 15 '23
"it's not malicious were just sloppy and incompetent bro haha buy my limited edition larceny tech tips shirt"
[luke looking uncomfortable but continuing to enable this.gif]
2
2
u/MGNConflict Aug 15 '23
I've been a viewer since 2013/2014, I'm certainly not a superfan by any means but I have some of their merch and had a Floatplane subscription at the $10 tier.
I'd encourage anyone wanting to boycott LMG until this is over by not watching their videos and cancelling their Floatplane subs (for LTT only, it's unfair to bring other creators into this if you subscribe to them on Floatplane too). I've cancelled my Floatplane sub and won't be watching anything but WAN until this has been sorted.
Linus's response is a typical Linus response: dismissive and not understanding why the community is so mad about this.
There's two separate issues here:
The Billet Labs prototype being sold (yes Linus, holding an auction for it is still by its very definition, selling it) due to an unforgivable miscommunication internally.
The accuracy issues within videos, seemingly due to focus on getting videos out rather than their quality.
The Billet Labs prototype should never have been sold but connects to something I noticed during LTX, which is that LMG were seemingly auctioning off/giving away junk that they didn't want anymore. Take the original Whonnock server chassis, outside being a tiny piece of LMG history it has no real value and you could even argue that it's not even a substantial part of LMG history either.
In other words, it looks like they were going around their warehouse and picking stuff to auction/give away that hadn't been touched for a long time or that they simply didn't want to keep around.
Linus said that they've "compensated" Billet Labs for the loss but what if it ends up in a competitor's hands? Will LMG compensate Billet Labs for potential loss of income if the competitor uses parts of the design for their own products? u/Billet_Labs has created a post here and as far as I can see they aren't happy (at all) that their prototype was sold off but have accepted that it happened.
All this obviously ignores the fact that the original LTT review of the thing was flawed, something that Linus is trying to downplay. There certainly exists a niche group of people who would buy the block if it meant giving them an edge for overclocking.
Linus claims that he's trying to create a videos that contain things people can buy but this historically hasn't been what LTT has been about, recent videos that I can think of that violate this is the "How many USBs can you plug in at once?" video "Pool cooling", and "How we built the $100,000 Desk PC". LTT has historically been full of jank and it's what us fans like about the channel but it seems that with their growth they've been doing less jank which is a shame.
The accuracy issues with the videos has been known to Linus for a long time now and even with incentives, their team still often miss the ball when it comes to checking for information accuracy. Jay even pulled down a review (the 4060 if I recall?) due to accidentally containing inaccurate information, but LMG has never ever done this with a single video containing inaccurate metrics.
For this reason I haven't used LTT to help with my hardware purchasing decisions for a couple of years now, it's always been other channels as they're more reliable. This is something that Labs will not fix because it's an editorial problem rather than a data problem.
LMG is focusing far too much on video quantity rather than video quality, surely a fewer higher-quality videos would be better than more lower-quality ones?
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/MemesterJake Aug 15 '23
I have no idea what’s the controversy is on this, can someone give me like a tldr on this?
→ More replies (2)
2
2
Aug 15 '23
The cycle repeats itself. Every company that becomes too big corrupts itself (same as pure capitalism. At one point, it corrupts society).
This is the result. And more shit will happen once in a while.
LMG is a big corporation now. The Linus in the kitchen is gone.
2
2
u/Its_Phobos Aug 15 '23
Mr Trust-me-bro can not, in fact, be trusted? What a huge surprise. Common Linus L. Maybe he can find a way to use this to show off his house some more.
3
u/MassDefect36 Aug 14 '23
The Problem with Linus Tech Tips: Accuracy, Ethics, & Responsibility
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FGW3TPytTjc&ab_channel=GamersNexus
4
3
u/ZerotheWanderer Aug 14 '23
I'm glad Steve did the video that he did, it seems like it was long overdue, and I didn't follow LTX coverage, but that's absolutely insane that they fucked over billet labs like that, multiple times they said they would return the item and then they just auction it off. That's extremely fucked up. I can't wait to see the damage control that comes from this.
6
u/turtlelore2 Aug 14 '23
Everyone here is trashing Ltt way too hard right now. As far as I know, there's been no response yet and the video revealing this information is just a couple hours old.
It doesn't matter if gamers nexus has a flawless 5000 year record of zero mistakes, it's still totally possible they didn't get everything right.
I'm not saying Linus is a perfect God or anything. I'm saying give him a chance to respond. Way too many of you guys try to destroy Linus over literally anything. He could eat chicken nuggets with a spoon and you'll be calling for his immediate execution or something.
27
u/Xelikai_Gloom Aug 14 '23
Yeah, I'm not happy about it, but you gotta wait till a response is given before passing judgement. However, I'm only giving LMG a week, because I also recognize that no response IS a response.
→ More replies (4)16
u/haarschmuck Aug 14 '23
No response makes it ok.
They were sent something to test and the company said it's only compatible with a 3090 and they tested it with a 4090 and then said it was a shit product because it didn't work. Then in the WAN show Linus said that it's not worth the money to him to go and do the test correctly because nobody should ever buy it anyways.
THEN after the company emailing twice to get their prototype back and LTT agreeing, LTT sold it at an auction.
That's simply indefensible.
→ More replies (32)→ More replies (15)5
u/forbritisheyesonly1 Aug 14 '23
I like your tempered approach. People are so quick to condemn others nowadays, in every aspect of society. It's so tiresome. Give people the benefit of the doubt to respond and then see where you stand. I doubt half of the people that are quick to condemn LMG would be happy if they weren't given some grace or benefit of the doubt when they make mistakes, big ones in particular.
→ More replies (3)
3
Aug 15 '23
holy hell the brigading
why y’all like drama so much?? just let everything come out and then form an opinion before being so reactionary.
firstly regardless of proof, selling a small businesses prototype is negligent and wrong and shits fucked
but y’all acting like GN looks pristine in this? literally the first few mins in the video goes like this: Steve got butthurt about a snide comment, paints himself as someone that practices “ethical” journalism, doesn’t reach out to the accused party, then verbally white knights about not monetizing when obviously bashing LTT is going to make him so much money on other vids.
this whole shit is just youtubers not knowing how to run a business and trying to catch clout by bashing each other. grow tf up, stop idolizing these dudes, enjoy the content you want to see without taking them so seriously, and do your own research on shit.
→ More replies (1)
3.1k
u/mxforest Aug 14 '23
This will go down in LTT history as the biggest single f up.