r/LineageOS • • Feb 01 '19

Lineage OS bad maintainer

0 Upvotes

We have a lineage OS maintainer of X00TD who makes official builds having slow charging (<500mA) and doesn't pass safety net. He broke away from core devs due to some issues and now he doesn't ask help from anybody. How can you take maintainership from devs like those so more interested people can work on it. Also he started releasing los 16 for other devices rather than the device he officially maintains. I am a lineage OS fan so I really want good and stable lineage os. any suggestions would be appreciated


r/LineageOS • • Mar 31 '19

April 1st, 2019 Joke Reminder & Features Request

0 Upvotes

Hi all LineageOS enthusiasts :)

Summary

What this post is about

  • Asking for help about how to deactivate all future LineageOS April 1st fool joke per device. Using a graphical user interface (GUI). For beginners end-users. Not for advanced end-users.

  • For those not interested in tomorrow LineageOS potential April 1st, 2019 joke, this is your reminder about it

What this post is not about

  • Not about a new feature request. I tried to edit the title of this post. But found no option to do this with Reddit. Do you know how to do this?

Details about the challenge below

The Challenge

For those not familiar with the past yearly LineageOS April fool jokes. It could be, but not limited to, bad taste "joke", unfunny persistent notification that may cause panic and security concerns, potential business income lost, fake update ROM, fake website, fake logo. All of the above risk to further degrade the trust with contributors, users, and maintainers.

Related announcement at https://lineageos.org/An-April-Apology/

https://archive.fo/7FpwL

Some developers and some contributors said that they enjoy the yearly April 1st fool joke. To each their own. I know that most LineageOS contributors are volunteers. If a yearly April fool joke motivate them to further contribute, then go for it. Whatever floats your boat. As long as it's not sinking my boat for an extended period though ;) Speaking for myself I use LineageOS both as my personal device and for business. Some people and some clients enjoyed the April fool joke, some really did not. In other words, the risk with the April fool joke is to further degrade the trust with some contributors, users, and maintainers.

Details and context about the challenge at https://www.reddit.com/r/LineageOS/comments/89f76y/can_we_have_a_serious_talk_about_april_fools/dx31niz/

Suggested Resolution

To clarify what help I need, find the User Story below. Do you have any suggestion to resolve this challenge?

As a end-user I need to be able to opt-out of the yearly April fool joke, so that my clients do not panic due to fake security concerns, and my business income is not negatively affected

Assumptions

  • Assumes using a graphical user interface (GUI). Within LineageOS. For beginner end-users. Not for advanced users.

  • Assumes the number 1 in this mockup shows the suggested location of this new opt-out feature inside LineageOS at https://i.postimg.cc/y6kpr0tj/mockup-configuration-april-fool-v1.jpg

  • Assumes by default the April fool joke would be activated. Because according to some developers it is a tradition. While at the same time users would be able to easily and quickly opt-out from all future April fool jokes. Per device.

  • Assumes a toggle switch

  • Assumes using setprop persist.lineage.nofool true

Any other suggestion to resolve this challenge? Is there already a patch for this? If not, any volunteer interested to contribute this new feature and patch? If needed, I would be happy to contribute testing and documentation.

F.A.Q.

Cheers,

Francewhoa


r/LineageOS • • Apr 13 '25

Mike Kuketz "LineageOS is closely linked to Google services" ....has this changed over the years ?

0 Upvotes

Hi

I just read an article about LOS from an IT security firm perspective and I have posted the conclusion underneath

My question is this.

Have LOS team done anything to minimize the ties to google and the "phone home" and "constantly sharing data" aspect of the services used... or is it just as the conclusion describes ?

thanks

PS.. I can already see that people are getting defencice... this is not an attack, but simply a question from a worried user

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

7. Conclusion

We remember the opening quote:

I can't agree with that. Yes, LineageOS supports many devices. Yes, you can continue using LineageOS, especially older devices. But: If you really want to do without Google or want to receive timely security updates for your device, you should look for a different custom ROM. LineageOS itself isn't making any special efforts to distance itself from Google. But to be fair, they never claimed to be. Not using Google apps or Google Play services doesn't automatically mean that a custom ROM is Google-free. That requires additional steps, which LineageOS doesn't take.

Overall, LineageOS leaves a neither privacy-friendly nor truly secure impression. This is mainly due to the following points:

  • Despite not using Google Play Services, LineageOS is closely linked to Google services

  • Delayed delivery of (security) updates

  • Older devices do not receive full security updates of proprietary components such as bootloaders or firmware

  • No Verified Boot support

  • The quality of LineageOS on a particular device is significantly influenced by the skills and commitment of the maintainer

Ultimately, LineageOS is primarily aimed at users who want to continue using their older devices, as they may no longer be receiving the latest Android versions and security updates from the manufacturer. From an ecological perspective, this also makes sense, as most devices still function perfectly on the hardware side, but often have to make way for the consumer-oriented nature of capitalism. Ultimately, this means even more electronic waste – something we can all do without.

https://www-kuketz--blog-de.translate.goog/lineageos-weder-sicher-noch-datenschutzfreundlich-custom-roms-teil4/?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en-US


r/LineageOS • • Jan 01 '24

When is LineageOS 21 gonna be availiable?

1 Upvotes

Anyone have any idea when the Lineage os 21 is going to roll out for devices. It has been months since Android 14 launched.


r/LineageOS • • Sep 21 '24

Info im sick of the toxicity from lineageos's developers

0 Upvotes

this is a reply i posted in a response to a year old comment, since that was a year old most likely the lineage developer i responded to is the only person whos going to see it, and i want everyone to be aware of the bullshit lineage's devs are pulling, so i'm posting it here too so other people can see

in response to npjohnson1's comment

We can't support randos builds

Here's a correction: "we dont want to support ROMs made by people who dont want to deal with our toxicity"

LineageOS developers are by far the most toxic people I've ever had to deal with, one of my favourites was when a Lineage dev banned someone in the Lineage Discord server because someone gave advice to someone who was planning on switching from LineageOS to crDroid. It's damn near impossible to get help with Lineage because of the developers extreme toxicity. I've also heard that switchroot (which is related to LineageOS and a team npjohnson is a part of) in the past got mad at people for porting ROMs that aren't LineageOS to the Switch, despite it being a fully open source project, however it seems like they're no longer doing this as no one said anything to me when I ported crDroid to the Switch.

Speaking of the Switch, why do LineageOS developers get an exception to the guidelines for maintainership? The Nintendo Switch (which npjohnson1 maintains) is violating 4 of them (All devices must support software encryption -- switch doesnt have encryption, all devices with a USB port must support file access via MTP -- wasnt true for the first few builds, all other sensors supported by a device's stock os should be supported -- ir sensor on the right joycon isn't supported, and all devices with nfc supported in their stock os must support nfc -- switch has nfc but is unsupported in android), and theres no notes at the bottom of device-support-requirements.md giving any valid reasons for the Switch to have any exceptions. It seems like developers of LineageOS get a free pass to violate the guidelines because they develop the ROM. Most other ROMs won't allow you to violate their guidelines no matter what. I'm sure there's a few UL ports made by Lineage developers that are official because they're a Lineage developer, yet the one made by thefantum isn't allowed because he's not a Lineage developer.

Lineage devs need to get over themselves.


r/LineageOS • • Mar 03 '24

Whatsapp is NOT working anymore in Custom roms

2 Upvotes

So after i reinstall WhatsApp on my op5t running lineageos i got a message saying that i have to use official WhatsApp to log in. i did everything but the problem not fixed so i upgrade to lineage 21 (android14) the same problem again.

after that i went back to stock rom and voila whatsapp get back to work again. then i install again lineageos and the error is back again.

i heard that some banks doesn't allow open bootloader devices to login and you you have to flash safetynet module ? could this fix the issue ? is anyone experiencing the same issue.

the error i got : https://imgur.com/a/OUzKMLv


r/LineageOS • • Sep 03 '26

Question Why doesn't Lineage accept feature requests?

2 Upvotes

Edit- why is everyone so emotional about this?


r/LineageOS • • Apr 02 '24

Samsung

0 Upvotes

Why you only support mid class Samsung phones? No s21 no s22 no s23 no s24? Samsung pay you extra money to not support their flagship phones?!


r/LineageOS • • Oct 01 '24

I'm leaving LineageOS and here is why (Poco x3 Pro)

0 Upvotes

Poco x3 Pro (or some of them) has a problem - ghost touch. And xiaomi solved this problem somehow on software level. I never experienced ghost touch on MIUI. But, when I flashed LineageOS 20, I started having it immediately, which makes LineageOS ususable ROM for this phone. Maintainer, SebaUbuntu, must know about this problem, because people complain about it on XDA forum under his post, where he is active sometimes. He even commented my post in this sub, where I mentioned this problem. But he doesn't seem to plan solving it. Maybe it doesn't depend on him, I don't know.

Now I moved to CrDroid and don't have ghost touch anymore. Plus, now I have android 14, while the latest LineageOS version for Poco X3 Pro is android 13.

LineageOS is a cool ROM, much better than MIUI for sure, but seems to be unusable on Poco x3 Pro.


r/LineageOS • • Aug 21 '25

DO NOT UPDATE (21 AUG UPDATE)

0 Upvotes

Hi all! Just updated my Pixel 4a, I can't gess pass the unlock pattern, and the phone constantly reboots. STAY AWAY from the update (as for me I am staying away from custom roms as well starting today)! Also any advice appreciated!


r/LineageOS • • Jul 07 '22

Question You seriously telling me that I can't switch the recent and back buttons on Android 12?

0 Upvotes

r/LineageOS • • Dec 24 '22

[Rant] Some LOS apps are total sh*t. Don't use them for anything important.

0 Upvotes

I'm just so frustrated that I decide to post a rant here. It is also my warning for those planning to use LOS apps for their daily tasks.

Today I had an important talk, which I need to record it. I've used LOS Recorder for a long time so I hadn't had any doubt with it then. To my total disappointment, when I finished the recording (30+ minutes or so), Recorder didn't save it. On the notification it showed Audio length: 00:00. I waited for 3 hours and still nothing happened. What strange is, I'm able to record other tracks, however the audio line is flat (wtf). I have searched for the record in record directory, /data/local/tmp and /data/data. It was nowhere to be found.

This also makes me remember a year ago or two, when LOS Snap (the gallery app) deleted ALL of my photo when I was just selecting one photo to delete.

AND this also reminds me of KDE: they do their main product very good (Plasma desktop), but all other apps of theirs are total piece of shit. Some don't even function at all. Relevant enough?


r/LineageOS • • May 06 '21

Question Did LineageOS really sign the open letter to "remove RMS", and if so, why did LineageOS sign that?

0 Upvotes

LineageOS is listed as one of the organizations that have signed the open letter to "remove RMS", here (note: linking this to explain the context of what LineageOS signed, this letter is a harsh personal attack and it is not necessarily a good source of information, it's far from objective): https://rms-open-letter.github.io/

There seem to be some problems with that open letter, see for example the comment here: https://eliasrudberg.se/rms/

See also: https://people.gnome.org/~michael/blog/2021-04-12-excommunicating.html

The latter blog post calls the open letter "one of the most divisive initiatives I've seen in free-software", and it does provide convincing grounds for that.

Is it correct that LineageOS as an organization has signed that open letter, or is there some mistake like someone adding the name without LineageOS leadership people knowing about it?

If LineageOS did really sign it, how is that justified, how does LineageOS answer the criticism against the open letter?

Edited: added disclaimer before first link. For more about the problems with that open letter, see: https://stallmansupport.org/


r/LineageOS • • Apr 29 '23

Question What is the purpose of LineageOS. ? Why was it created, and for whom.?.

0 Upvotes

r/LineageOS • • Apr 13 '20

I have a Samsung Galaxy S7. What exactly does this mean: "The Samsung Galaxy S7 is no longer maintained."

6 Upvotes

Do they mean "no longer maintained" by Samsung? Because, yes, I know that. Do they mean "no longer maintained" by them (LineageOS)? If so, that kind of goes against their statement of "LineageOS extends the functionality and lifespan of mobile devices".


r/LineageOS • • Nov 15 '18

This is how you get people to not update.

3 Upvotes

So OTA now hammers us with update notifications daily. 300+ meg download + install is not a light operation. Even phone reboot once a day is very atypical. What will happen now is one of following:

  • Many people will ignore notification for the most part, updating once in a while

  • Many people will disable notification and update whenever they remember (likely less often than in the past)

  • Many people will disable update checks and update whenever they remember (likely less often than in the past)

Decision to push heavy updates daily is very unfortunate. This could be mitigated very easily by adding an option to configure how often phone would check for available updates, it is not there.

In the meantime i am disabling update check.


r/LineageOS • • Jun 09 '25

Anyone know how to update lineage 21 to 22?

0 Upvotes

I have oneplus 8 pro and it's says update is blocked, anyone knows how to go around this?

https://imgur.com/a/eQJxQQi


r/LineageOS • • Feb 20 '20

lineageos.org website uses google trackers! Why?

2 Upvotes

I do not know if this is some sort of a sick joke, but can please someone explain why lineageos.org from all the websites has to use google's spyware services (google analytics, google fonts)?

I really cannot understand this. Lineage OS team, the one I would suggest that has some brains and would stand against all google trash....


r/LineageOS • • Mar 22 '17

Android O not for 32-bit devices? Hoe about Lineage 15 plans?

2 Upvotes

Well, bad news. Most devices widely used currently won't be supported, because Play Services and gapps, including play store won't be available for 32-bit arm devices. Goodbye bacon and others.

Just curiousity. How do you think, will Lineage support be continued for 32-bit hardware? Will we get Lineage 15.0 builds? Or stay on Nougat forever?


r/LineageOS • • Nov 23 '18

Question What is going on for the last week with the updates?

0 Upvotes

I love this OS and still rocking it on my phone (OnePlus One) but for some reason but for the past week (or even more) I keep getting update notifications every day. What gives?


r/LineageOS • • Oct 15 '17

LineageOS is the best distribution of android Open Source Project

1 Upvotes

r/LineageOS • • Aug 25 '26

Question, Why is LineageOS running so slow?

0 Upvotes

Ok so Currently im on LineageOS 20, using an older SM-T580, and it is running Slower then My Stock firmware, do you have any tips to Speed it up?


r/LineageOS • • Jul 05 '18

Once again... burned by the supported devices list being wrong

0 Upvotes

I spent a few hours looking for an affordable recent supported device at the device list and decided to go for the Axon 7 Mini... only to find out TWRP for this device is gone and the phone I got is a Canadian variant (Bell carrier, B2017G / P852A15 / verdandi) which can't be unlocked and doesn't even have an OTA update available, keeping it stuck at Marshmallow.

Why is this so hard ?

Is there a similar list that shows release date and month? Or is there any way I could contribute this information to the current list?

Edit:


r/LineageOS • • Jan 07 '24

Is there an idiot's install guide to lineage os?

1 Upvotes

Video, text, anything designed to be followed step by step?