Hello everyone!
I started reading this after some recommendations from my friends. I originally intended to read Re:Zero, but ended up picking this one first.
I initially read the manga, and after finishing it, decided to start the Web Novel again from Chapter 1.
I'm currently around Chapter 100, and I wanted to share my honest thoughts and hear from people who are further ahead: Is it worth continuing? Does the story get better in the aspects I'm about to discuss?
First of all, I don't think this is a bad story. Not at all. In fact, I genuinely enjoyed it, especially its starting phase when everyone supported the MC and he felt he was not alone. That is basically chicken soup for anyone who has read works dedicated to premise's beginning plot.
However, there's something that has been bothering me throughout my reading.
'Everything feels a little TOO perfect and convenient.'
Let me explain.
1. The world feels almost unrealistically accommodating.
We have:
A school administration that takes bullying seriously, handles the situation responsibly and actually holds itself accountable.
A teacher who is genuinely determined to get to the root of a bullying problem and is ALSO not hesitant to oppose an assemblyman to protect his student
An ex-mayor who genuinely cares about his people and is dedicated to doing what's right. In this era? LMAO.
Now, none of these things are inherently bad. Quite the opposite. These are things we SHOULD expect from institutions and people in positions of responsibility.
But when practically everyone in a position of authority behaves so ideally, the setting starts feeling a little too convenient.
I know it's fiction, but I sometimes feel like the entire world is solely dedicated for providing Eiji with the support and deliver the most satisfying possible outcome for Eiji (without him doing nothing).
For eg-
The former mayor happens to be his father's best friend. His father's past actions and relationships seem to have established connections that now work in Eiji's favour. He even managed to help someone affiliated with the same political party as Kondo's father, which basically helped his mother to face Kondo's dad when he came with his bs threatening. Now, what if Eiji and his mother didnt have the political support? How would a simple family deal with political pressure.
And when you look at the bigger picture, everything seems to be aligned in such a way that Eiji is almost guaranteed to receive help whenever he encounters an obstacle.
2. Eiji and Endo: Who is the ACTUAL protagonist here?
Eiji is a genuinely nice guy, and he absolutely didn't deserve the hell that Miyuki and Kondo put him through.
However, something about his development feels a little odd to me.
After being lifted out of his miserable situation through the support of his loved ones, Eiji suddenly starts shining. His talents become apparent, people recognize his worth, and his life gradually improves.
But when it comes to actually exposing the rumours, dealing with the situation and driving the revenge aspect forward, a lot of the work seems to be carried out by other people.
And this brings me to Endo.
ENDО IS THE GOAT.
Seriously, I sometimes feel like Endo is the actual protagonist of this story.
Eiji is the person we're emotionally invested in, but Endo is the one who actively drives so much of the plot. His involvement, initiative and role in the conflict make him incredibly compelling.
I sometimes find myself more interested in what Endo is going to do next than in Eiji's own development.
Does anyone else feel this way?
3. Is this essentially male wish fulfilment?
This is probably going to be a controversial observation, but I can't shake the feeling that Eiji is somewhat of a self-insert character.
The story has many elements of male wish fulfilment: a genuinely nice protagonist gets betrayed, he finds a supporting kouhai who believes him and develop crush on each other, his worth is eventually recognized, the people who wronged him face consequences, and he finds people who appreciate him.
Again, there's nothing inherently wrong with wish fulfilment. That's part of the appeal we all wished for after seeing him getting cheated on
I even have a completely ridiculous headcanon that this is basically the author's personal revenge fantasy, with Miyuki representing the girlfriend who cheated on him. LOL
4. Kondo's punishment
I also feel that Kondo's punishment is almost TOO perfectly aligned with his actions.
It's satisfying, certainly, but sometimes it feels as though the consequences were specifically calculated to deliver maximum reader satisfaction.
I don't necessarily dislike it, but it contributes to my overall feeling that everything in this story falls into place a little too neatly.
5. Miyuki's gradual redemption – Something I genuinely appreciate
Now, this is something I actually really like about the Web Novel.
Miyuki absolutely deserves criticism for what she did to Eiji. I have no intention of defending her actions. The bitch deserves hell
However, I find it interesting that the story actually explores her perspective and allows her to gradually acknowledge and regret her mistakes.
Rather than simply keeping her as an irredeemable antagonist (unlike ones we know from the genre) the story explores the consequences of her own actions and her gradual change.
I find this particularly interesting because there's a difference between a character deserving forgiveness and a character having a redemption arc.
Ik she should be punished but atleast everyone deserves a chance at redemption (not forgiveness)
The only W she has done so far by the part I have read is telling takayangi sensei about this and helping him further.
Final thoughts
I want to emphasize that I genuinely enjoyed the beginning of Jinsei Gyakuten. My criticisms don't mean I dislike the story.
I just feel that the narrative sometimes prioritizes satisfying outcomes over realism, and that Eiji's development occasionally takes a backseat to the characters who help him.
I'm currently at Chapter 100, so perhaps I'm judging things too early.
For those who are caught up with the Web Novel:
Does Eiji become more proactive in his own development, or does everything happen automatically for him?
Does Endo continue to have such a prominent role? Because honestly, I'm loving his character.
Does the story become more nuanced later on, or does it maintain this idealized, wish-fulfilment approach?
I'd genuinely like to know whether I should continue reading.