r/LifeInsurance • • 1d ago

Questionable agent practice

Okay, I’m going to try to be brief

I have an agent will call him Andy he is with life insurance company. I know him his phone is in my address book and he took care of my whole life policy many years ago and a really hardly over here from him since

A few months ago, he contacted me from the telephone number. I know introducing him to me as being my representative from the company. I know with the policy number of the company I know him!

He simply explained to me that my policy has earned enough equity that the payout would increase by about $3000, and the payment could decrease by about $15 a month

I didn’t need to give him any authorisation for this. I didn’t need to sign anything I didn’t receive any email. The payment amount would just change by $15 and it will be charged on the same day of the month to the same existing account.

Okay well thanks for letting me know Andy and sure enough about a month later I received the new charge for exactly $15 less from an insurance company. I have never heard of

My regular insurance payment was still there $15 more at the same day of the month

Now Andy doesn’t answer his direct line, so I call the company I know of Andy to work for

Because I never even received this new policy, and I have nothing confirming what we did, and this charge is from a different life insurance company

While Andy doesn’t work there anymore

They believe Andy left with all their contact information and they weren’t too concerned about it

So I tracked down the company that did make the charge, the different life insurance company

They do have a policy in my name, it’s for considerably less than I thought it is for but the monthly fee is the right dollar amount

I asked specifically how this was authorised, but they didn’t know the answer to that. And said I must’ve done something, but they don’t have any record of it.

The only option I had was if I chose to cancel the the contract for using one of their links, and by doing so admitting that I asked for the policy, and I’m now cancelling the policy

I never asked for a policy they would never confirm or deny if Andy was an agent with their company

They simply said agents worked directly with the consumers, and they don’t go through them, struck me as a little weird

So I love trying to figure out how to stop this rabbit hole

And another interesting fact is my initial whole life policy is paid for by my daughter who is the beneficiary. I would not have any authorisation to put it on AUTO pay to her account. I don’t even know the account number nor did I give it to anybody she had set it up with Andy initially years ago I was there in the room but I didn’t see any account numbers.

So I’m completely bewildered, and I’m getting no assistance from other company

Funds are being withdrawn from a well known insurance company even my daughter tried to get involved and stop it. The bank says the insurance policy just has to be cancelled. The insurance policy says to cancel it, You have to admit that you asked for it

But we didn’t ask for it, and we’ve tried to find attorney. None of them are interested.

I’m very doubtful that I’m the first 70 years old woman has happened to

4 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

6

u/skyydog 1d ago

He churned your policy to earn another commission. He lied on your health questions on the app by answering them for you and by forging your signature. If you have a claim within the first 2 years it could be denied if any of those questions were answered incorrectly. He probably canceled your other policy which you likely did not want. Do not talk to him or his agency. Confirm with your original company that your policy is still in force. If not file a fraud report with them and ask that it be reinstated. Notify the new comp that the agent signed you up without your authorization. And file a complaint against the agent with the state department of insurance.

1

u/Current-Factor-4044 1d ago

Thank you so much for your response and yes, I did all the things that you mentioned

My original insurance is still active with that original company.

I have absolutely no copy of any kind on the New, additional secondary, whatever you wanna call it fraudulent policy to know what lies regarding my health have been entered.

In contacting The original company they were able to confirm he was at one time an agent for them. But I knew that I had my original policy. They seem to have no interest or concern in him, having my information from that company and using it at another company.

The secondary company would not confirm or deny this agent has any affiliation and only wanted me to cancel something that I never originated, nor that they have any documentation that I originated.

The really bother some part, here is that the secondary company has absolutely nothing no recording, no computer click no IP address regarding this policy. The person who is being ACH for the policy is the same person being ACH for the original policy which is not me it is the beneficiary my daughter I do not know that account number and order to provide it nor do, I have permission to allow it to be charged. The secondary company didn’t care about that either.

The most they would do was send me a link to cancel it, which would have to include my acknowledging that I requested it and I did not.

What I have not done is reported to the department of insurance. I don’t know what that is but I’m going to try to find out.

I am very troubled by this, and I cannot possibly be the only person that this is happened to .

Thanks so much for the response

1

u/zzzorba Financial Representative 1d ago

The old policy may have enough cash value and/or dividends to be withdrawn (or loaned) to cover the premiums, but that amount is still being withdrawn from somewhere even if it isn't your bank account. Ask the first company how premiums are being paid and who authorized that change. Also ask for an inforce illustration so you can see the current values (he may have withdraw a chunk of cash value to put into the new policy) and where they are headed.

Sounds like Agent then opened the new policy which costs $15 less than the old bill so you'd simply think you got a benefit. Ask the new company for a copy of the application with your signature.

Your daughter needs to contact her bank and dispute the unauthorized payments and pursue fraud charges.

1

u/Current-Factor-4044 1d ago

Thank you so much could you elaborate on what enforce illustration means

Because I was very direct and went up the food chain regarding where this documentation might be that I entered into this new policy with this new company that I never heard of

They told me they have no documentation, but they won’t cancel it until I clicked the cancel button which acknowledges that I requested the policy and now I have decided to cancel it and I don’t wanna press that button because I didn’t acknowledge anything

Good point about my daughter’s account. I really haven’t thought about it because I thought exactly what you mentioned in the beginning what would the agent mentioned that my originally policy about 15 years old has enough equity or growth in it to reduce the premium cost a little bit and increase the benefit that made sense to me and I knew the agent it was his phone number that called me it was already in my phone

I have called both insurance companies, but I think I need to have a little more conversation based on what you mentioned with the original company to make sure nothing to various as going on there. I know it’s still an active policy still being paid for
But that doesn’t mean something else hasn’t been altered that I’m unaware of

I had about an hour worth of conversations this morning of the food chain that included all the right questions I think such as where is the documentation is there or recording is tax is there an IP address is there a document sign? Is there an email is there something?

And they didn’t need the banking information because it was already allegedly in the system, because it was allegedly the original insurance company and one thing is factual the agent who called Andy said the payments would come out the same day, but I never got the policy the updated policy I was expecting from the original company, that’s what led to the phone calls he did say that I would have to be the one to cancel the original policy and I remember saying why would I have to cancel it if we’re just modifying it what is it you need me for because you’re not asking me to affirm anything or anything those were probably my red flags

My daughter is not too happy for obviously reasons she’s like Mom. I said this policy up for you. If you wanted to make a change in it, you should’ve come to me and I understand that she did this and she is the beneficiary and she pays it but I figured since they called me and it’s my policy I could and should do this and she would be happy

I’m usually very on top of little detail, so I’m really surprised this happened

1

u/Current-Factor-4044 1d ago

I’m sorry to respond to you again, but he turned the policy that is exactly what this felt like as it’s come together with the pieces

The thing here is obviously I’ve concerned about myself of course I am, but this cannot be a one time thing

And I’m also very concerned that neither insurance company has any concern over this not the insurance company that, and they once worked for and obviously has taken my information with him from

And even less concerned from the insurance company, he went to where he is using this information where they have no kind of documentation that a policy was ever put in effect how could they not have that documentation? How could they be okay with not having that documentation?

But yet they want very specific documentation to cancel something that was never documented as going into effect

This seems so confusing

1

u/skyydog 1d ago

Let the DOI deal with it. Seems the insurance company would be concerned. They are probably investigating internally and to protect themselves they don’t want to tell you that their contracted agent did this. The agent has access to your daughter’s bank account info so she should monitor her account closely and probably open a new account.

1

u/Current-Factor-4044 1d ago

Very good point, I haven’t even thought of that because I completely believe what he said it made perfect sense he was my agent they would have this information encrypted in our system. He didn’t need me to confirm anything on banking I could not have confirmed it

But when you say that, I realise you’re correct because the second company would not have had the banking information the agent would have personally had to possess it, which I I guess I knew that, but I didn’t put the dots together until you mention it

Thank you so much for your response

I’ve been looking this over thinking for a couple months that the secondary company was parent company of the first company and didn’t really think anything of it because I knew the agent personally or at least this person as you could know your life insurance agent

4

u/turbo332 1d ago

This is a blunt force tactic, but file a complaint with the insurance commissioner in your state. Tell them the exact things going on and keep your file updated as you go along. Insurance commsioners don't talk to cusstomer service. They talk to ceo's and the chairman of the board. You should have things straightened out within a week.

1

u/Current-Factor-4044 1d ago

Oh wow, thank you I’m just stunned

I am one of those people that knows exactly who I work with I confirm everything if I did not personally know him and have his phone number in my phone and his name attached to my original policy because he was the guy we wouldn’t have even had a conversation and I really wish we had not

1

u/Adorable_Bus_989 1d ago

Tell both companies to send you a copy of the policy. You can’t really do anything until you know what you have. 

1

u/Current-Factor-4044 1d ago

I completely agree !

I have the original policy with the original company and it’s perfectly intact

It’s the second company that I did not put a policy in place for and they have nothing to confirm. I did no phone call no recording no email. No IP address no text. Nothing at all it took me three weeks to get a policy number from them and a face value of the policy which was considerably less than the alleged modification of the original policy, not to mention it what a accompany I’ve never heard of that has no relationship with the original policy

It’s so annoying the only thing that they have offered to do for me to send me a link to cancel a policy. I have never activated and then cancelling it. I must click that I initiated it and now I would like to cancel it.

The thing is I never initiated it

Thank you very much and you hundred percent incredibly difficult to reach this kind of company and move up the food chain to various alleged departments that allegedly can help you, but I really don’t think that they were anything different than different customer service reps I’m gonna try the insurance commissioner

1

u/Adorable_Bus_989 23h ago

Then stop the payment at the bank. The company will contact you then,

1

u/strikecat18 1d ago

I don’t understand why you think canceling the policy means admitting you wanted it. I’ve never seen a cancelation request form that causes the insured to admit they purchased the policy.

1

u/Current-Factor-4044 16h ago

It’s the first mystery click tab to continue on the application

1

u/Hot_Watercress6672 16h ago

This is terrible. I had a client going through something similar with another agent, lets call him Tom. Well Tom stopped answering her calls, and stopped responding, and modified her policy, put her in another policy, it was a mess. I had to work with her and the second insurance company to get it sorted out. But when you submit to the department of insurance and the insurance commissioner of your state, be clear, concise, and state the violations. Try not to inundate them with emotions. Wish you had a reputable agent who could talk to the insurance carrier and doi on your behalf. I hope this helps.

1

u/Current-Factor-4044 15h ago

That’s the thing, I thought Andy was a reputable agent I mean he had come to the house gone over everything 15 years ago I had his phone number. I could call him when I had an issue

1

u/Hot_Watercress6672 15h ago

Well, you certainly need one now. They'll be able to communicate with the insurance company etc, with you and for you. They know the language so to speak. There was another reddit thread that mentioned something like this, and I drafted the entire email for them to send to the insurance carrier to get his situation fixed. I'm waiting to hear the good news.

3

u/PleasureMissile 1d ago

Report to your state’s insurance commissioner.