r/LessWrongLounge • • Jul 31 '14

The set of all possible fetishes is isomorpic to the singularity.

1 Upvotes

Look, just rejecting decision theory and the planning fallacy doesn't make someone causal Robin Hanson! Even a/an god is vulnerable to corrupted rationality.


r/LessWrongLounge • • Jun 28 '15

Are dolphins sapient?

1 Upvotes

http://www.radiolab.org/story/hello/

I just listened to a lot of this.

Are dolphins sapient? And if so, are they as sapient as humans? Based just on this podcast, it sounds like they are sapient but maybe less than humans, but I'm not sure. Thoughts?


r/LessWrongLounge • • Sep 27 '15

Apparently, cyber security right now is woefully inadequate. How would you solve this?

0 Upvotes

Just heard a radiolab podcast that talked about how cyber crime is ridiculously cheap and basically no one knows how to defend against it. Someone was cyber-held-hostage for ransom and apparently there are a lot of cases where police just pay the ransoms and stuff for the victims of such crimes and even have been cyber-held-hostage for ransom themselves.

How would you go about solving this?


r/LessWrongLounge • • Jan 30 '16

Good poly-romance novel recommendations?

0 Upvotes

Any recommendations for well-written, thoughtful original novels that aren't sexually explicit and whose protagonist is in a healthy polyamorous relationship and they don't break up in the end?


r/LessWrongLounge • • Oct 27 '15

How do you react in the face of a bomb threat?

2 Upvotes

I'm in class right now, and I just got a really weird and scary phone call from some stranger asking about someone named Brandy something. My second class today has been cancelled, apparently because of a bomb threat which Ohio State is trying to keep hushed up. I don't know what's going on, but I'm getting really worried. Shouldn't all the students and staff be evacuated or something?

Right now my goals are, in order of priority:

  1. Stay alive

  2. People I care about staying alive

  3. The campus population staying alive, as well as the wider city of Columbus if they're in any danger too.

What would be the best way to accomplish this? Whether that means just ignoring the situation and leaving it entirely to the campus police, or trying to get people to evacuate the city, or what?

I have zero expertise in dealing with terrorist threats. According to one of my classmates, the bomb will supposedly go off at 3pm today, but I have no idea how reliable that information is.

Please respond quickly.


r/LessWrongLounge • • May 17 '25

What can be dating strategy to get Rational Altruist/transhumanist boyfriend?

1 Upvotes

What can be dating strategy to get Rational Altruist/transhumanist boyfriend? I worry about my own cognitive biases, and overall wrong strategy. But I terrified that most of the people believe in god, or have evil ethic, or just can't accept me with a lot of my own problems (I don't think I have good value on the dating market). There are general guids how to date with men, but I not sure if they really follow evidence-based approach. They usually favour traits, which of course good, but probably not the most important for me. It makes things even more complicated.


r/LessWrongLounge • • Aug 27 '14

Don’t Want Me to Recline My Airline Seat? You Can Pay Me

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
1 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Feb 03 '16

Why the LessWrong community is a complete failure

0 Upvotes

Having participated and observed this community for some time, I feel confident enough to say that it has totally failed in it's stated goals and, worse than that, doesn't even try to adapt and learn from such failings.

The primary failing, and this is based upon reading LessWrong's blogs regarding time efficiency surveys that he's conducted, is that most people have been shown to become less driven, less motivated upon learning more. One might wonder how this could be but a look into the general atmosphere of the "LessWrong community culture" highlights this woeful failing. Critical thinking is advised... but politics isn't. This is a total self-contradiction, politics admittedly has much stupid content but the positive side is that politics are where beliefs are challenged. How can you properly be critical thinkers, if you avoid challenging your beliefs? Despite the "techniques" supposedly being taught, many members of this forum simply fall into reddit groupthink and don't try to correct their own behavior regarding ad hominem, black and white fallacy, and other assorted fallacious reasoning. In fact, some people don't even understand the full definition of ad hominem and don't even apply it correctly. This is the community of avid rationalists?

There is this bizarre idea that death is somehow a disease and not a natural process and that somehow making super-intelligent robots will somehow fix the issue of death or, at the very least, increase humanity's quality of life - despite no practical means of conducting such actions, no tangible way of actually accomplishing such a goal, and Eliezer Yudokowsky largely having no real means of funding except by ridiculous apocalyptic scenarios strewn around about how important his project supposedly is. A complete failure of rational - not to mention practical - marketing techniques.

Yudokowsky is intelligent enough to make a fanfiction that is so popular that it's being translated in several languages, yet he hasn't thought of simply making money by writing his own fictional work. Looking through topics that addressed this, he seems to be under the belief that only through traditional publishing can he make any real money, despite already having avid followers across several countries, and the advances in self-publishing which is so ridiculously easy to do nowadays.

Also, any effort to share actual rationality content, such as the talks by Julia Galef were deleted, evidently the fact that Yudokowsky attempted to get funding for an AI project to help support a rationality organization that they don't even bother sharing content with really makes me question his commitment to his own beliefs. What happened to spreading rationality? You know, the chief purpose of the entire project.

Anyway, this community has proven itself to be shallow and Eliezer Yudokowsky has shown himself to be so woefully inept. Atheism itself has taken a beating because TAM couldn't deal with the mildest cases of sexual assault upon atheist women at their conventions; some of which included instances of rape.

While that largely has nothing to do with Yudokowsky, my main points still stand. He's shown himself to be woefully inept, impractical, and frankly ridiculous with his "no death" ideas. This community has simply devolved into worshiping him like every other fan community that thinks their leader is perfect, they've failed to self-reflect on their own cognitive biases, and they've completely given up on doing anything before even trying to make changes in their own personal lives. It's become quite nihilistic to observe. So this is where I part ways.

Go ahead and downvote or go into ad hominem tangents, it's all you can do and it merely proves that I am right.


r/LessWrongLounge • • Apr 27 '24

A disturbing question about some disturbing matters

2 Upvotes

I'm really sorry if this breaks some kind of subredit rules (I could only find the normal reddit rules down right, so I'm assuming only those apply).

I'm new to this subreddit, but I'm an old fan of hpmor, I've read the Sequences (online, not the AI to Zombie one that was published as a book) and I'm more or less on the path to improve myself on the rationality side. When I have the time, I also enjoy some good old rational fanfiction or literature. I've just recently started and finished Friendship is Optimal (I know, I should have read that sooner, but really... Ponies?) and it was good. Not perfect, but good.

And then at the end, at the Author's Afterwords, I've found a denigration of MIRI and LessWrong community this website, and saying this was upsetting is an euphemismus.

Now I'm doing the wrong, irrational thing, and I'm coming here to have some confirmation bias, that all that stuff is wrong or there's some misunderstanding... I just couldn't find stuff online about this.

I don't think that even if it were true, it would invalidate anything about rationality and the lessons learned there, I know that people are people, I never thought of Eliezer Yudkowsky as a messiah, at most I've thought of him as the one who has opened my eyes about what rationality was, and for that I am extremely thankful. The bit about AI and trying to save the world were a positive plus, but nothing I considered impactful. Maybe in the next two or three generations. I thought it was all too optimistic, to be honest.

But still, I would like to know what the people here would say about this scandal.


r/LessWrongLounge • • Nov 16 '14

Petition: give NASA 1¢ out of every tax dollar

Thumbnail
petitions.whitehouse.gov
2 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Mar 18 '15

Objective Morality

Thumbnail
aciddc.wordpress.com
2 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Apr 01 '17

My First Time.

0 Upvotes

I had an interesting experience yesterday; I met this girl and we started chatting. It was quite smooth sailing; she opened the convo with "no I won't tell you my three sizes", and from there we hit it off; she said "she liked me", I was a little surprised, and replied with "I think you're a very friendly person". After getting to know each other a little better, she said: "I think we're quite compatible". It seemed a little off, and easier than I expected. However, fledgling that I am I wasn't one to refuse an easier journey. I just went with the flow; hey, if it's become easier, then who am I to complain? I'm not one of those masochists that likes a tough journey.  
 
She said she was a "bad girl" and enjoyed NSFW topics and role-playing. She offered me to try out RP. I agreed, and left her to the script; I was a neophyte, not yet introduced to the world of role playing. We started slowly, then eventually went to making out in the RP. It was quite the blissful experience.  
 
After the entire ordeal, I was happy and elated, while she dropped a bombshell; "my username and profile picture do not reflect my actual gender".  
 
My heart was a turmoil of emotions, as I let the implications of that sink in.  
 
Damn it! I should have noticed all the warning signs: "No I won't tell you my three sizes", "I like you", "I think we're quite compatible". What kind of girl goes to sexting within a few minutes of meeting each other. Alas, I failed as a rationalist; I wasn't able to beore confused by fiction than by reality. There was an unease in my heart — a slight sense of incongruity. To my own detriment, I ignored it. I shall forever live with this scar.  
 
Give me back my innocence.
Give me back my purity.
T_T


r/LessWrongLounge • • Aug 16 '14

Human maximizer

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Oct 12 '14

What do you think about postrationality?

Thumbnail
yearlycider.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Jul 26 '15

Reincarnation?

0 Upvotes

I'm not trying to say that I believe in reincarnation. I'm not sure what I believe, though I'm still leaning slightly against it. I'm bringing this topic up because I recently heard that there was some boy who claimed to remember having been in Barra or something, and many things that he claimed were later proven true. And when I looked it up, other similar stories occurred - and some of them described reincarnation in the same way, as a hole. People (apparently) independent of each other confirmed similar facts. I'm not trained in logic, and it's been too long since I've read a lesswrong post, but I'm pretty sure that peer confirmation is part of determining the truth?

I don't know if the sources are trustworthy. They seem like urban legends, and it's entirely possible and plausible that people lied about reincarnation, or there may be coincidences. Are there any sources in the lesswrong community or in other rationalist communities that have actually looked into this or something?

Because I THINK that the prevalent attitude is that God doesn't exist and reincarnation probably doesn't exist. I noticed I was starting to unconsciously ignore my mom (my source for the reincarnation thing) whenever she talked about the supernatural, and had to actively think about this, so I wouldn't be surprised if other people that considered themselves somewhat rational just tossed this sort of thing aside as well.

I don't have any actually trustworthy sources, but the source that I DO have is this: http://listverse.com/2013/10/21/10-interesting-cases-of-supposed-reincarnation/ It seems somewhat convincing, but I don't actually know any details and wouldn't actually be surprised if most or all of these were BS. The thing is that I don't think that many people in rational communities (that I know of, at least) actually bother to discuss the supernatural at all, or talk about them solely to decry them. I'm just curious if rational communities have tried to discuss this sort of thing in-depth, and what their conclusions were.

(Also, my actual research was largely cursory - I'm interested in this, but I'm not so interested that I'll spend more than a few google searches and a post on the internet asking people to figure out if reincarnation exists/why the evidence isn't good enough for me. I'm MORE interested in lesswrong discussions than in reincarnation, actually. I just figured I'd kill two birds with one stone by asking you what you think about the latter.)


r/LessWrongLounge • • Dec 26 '14

Experiments in Post-Rationalist Religion

Thumbnail
moreright.net
4 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Jul 04 '15

Why do so many people believe that .999...=1?

0 Upvotes

Is it just a really widespread case of conformity bias, combined with professional mathematicians not being willing to admit they're wrong? I mean, I know people believe a lot of crazy things, but this seems more extreme somehow. Once someone explains to you exactly how and why .999... does not equal 1, especially if they also explain how .333... does not actually equal 1/3, it becomes really REALLY obvious in retrospect.

It's explained in the links below on Physicsforums.com and in a video on Vihart's Youtube channel.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsOXvQn3JuE

https://www.physicsforums.com/threads/333-does-not-equal-1-3.229368/

So, why do people still believe that .999...=1, and why are professional mathematicians still teaching that nonsense?


r/LessWrongLounge • • Jul 02 '15

Immortality=Godwin's Law!?

1 Upvotes

So, if it was possible to live forever, what would the probability of someone eventually becoming a perfect clone of Adolf Hitler be? Also, what would the probability be of a particular historic event happening a second time exactly as it did the first time? I mean, I've heard about how if the universe is infinite, and if you travel far enough, eventually you would encounter repetitions, identical copies of ourselves down to the atomic level, etc. Although that would be really, REALLY far away.

About how long would you have to live for it to become more than 50% likely that you become Hitler at least once?

Also, how long would it take before it became more than 50% likely that the super mario bros games would get invented a second time at least once, and how likely is it that international copyright law will return to the way it is now by then?

Is it possible to calculate, or even estimate what the possible ranges of the order(s) of magnitude for the probabilities of these events would be?

I'm just a layperson, don't have any experience in quantum physics, so maybe my questions don't make any sense and should be unasked? Not sure. I'm kinda curious.

Thanks!


r/LessWrongLounge • • Oct 20 '14

Bad Ad-Hoc Hypotheses Festival 2014

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Aug 02 '15

Has anyone here ever watched "Accel World"?

0 Upvotes

It's a pretty cool anime. It's not very rational, but it does do a lot of subverting and playing with stereotypes, in particular gender stereotypes in a way that makes it quite refreshing.

It's basically about a virtual reality fighting game in a future where VR tech has become rather advanced and is a big part of everyday life. The players fight for "burst points", which can be spent to significantly increase the speed of your brain and body in real life.

Every burst linker has a character avatar for fighting in the game. And their username is basically determined by their utility function (or at least by some of the maximums and minimums of it).

If anyone on here has seen it, what do you think your username and special abilities would be?

I'd probably have the username "Purple Reader" or something like that, and I would have the ability to see the opponent's special abilities, weak points and stats, and I would also have limited shapeshifting ability, decent speed and better maneuverability.

What about you guys?

http://accelworld.wikia.com/wiki/Avatar_Color


r/LessWrongLounge • • Nov 12 '14

When will there be a Rational US President?

1 Upvotes

When will we develop fAI?... is a pretty common question - so let's ask a slightly different one.

When do you believe we will have a Rational President in the USA?

Naturally, I'm referring to the LW kind of rational.

Asking when we'll have a Rational President actually compounds several assumptions. A President is normally elected in a democratic process. It seems the sanity waterline is increasing over time; given long enough, it might reach a point where all Presidential candidates are LW-rational and all voters are LW-rational - which might lead us to have a Rational President.

I keep saying 'might', because it might never happen. It's possible that the United Earth Republic is formed first, rendering any notion of an American President irrelevant. Or all Americans might upload and have a shared consciousness, humanity might get wiped out, etc etc.

Or there might have been one already. I don't think so, but you might not agree.

If you think we'll develop fAI first and it becomes the trusted adviser of the nation with enough influence on all policies, I think that's good enough. When do you believe it will happen?

What is your probability distribution over time?


r/LessWrongLounge • • May 25 '21

Why would someone say that a fictional character killed his friends?

1 Upvotes

This question is based on a case that happened long ago that I read in a book of unexplained mysteries. It was a couple of years back, so I can't reliably remember any names. This is what I do remember;

a young man (in his late teens) went travelling with a group of 5 friends. He returned alone, when asked what happened he gave an extremely detailed, creepypasta-like story about how a 'monster' appeared and ate his friends one by one, and he saw and heard everything from up close, going as far as describing the exact length of each of his friend's screams of pain. When he was asked to describe this monster, he just described and drew pictures of the main cartoon character from a new family-orientated animated show at the time, introduced weeks before the incident, and airing in his State only. Interestingly, this character was also a dragon (a fictional species).

The show would air weekly, and on the day of the incident, from my research, it had aired three times.

The sole surviving witness described the height of the monster accurately to the character in the show. In the opening lyrics of the show, he is described as being ''ten feet tall''. The sole surviving witness described the height as ''about ten feet tall''.

He stuck to his story throughout his life until he was old and died, and had reportedly suffered long-lasting nervous breakdowns because people didn't believe him. He attempted to track down anyone claiming to have also seen this monster/character, contacting the administrators and members of forums and websites dedicated to paranormal phenomena (at the time of the incident, the internet was decades away, so he must have been in his 50's or 60's at the time of contacting people across the internet). He also reportedly became an alcoholic and drug addict after the incident because his life was changed due to his and his friend's experience with seeing a cartoon character appear in reality, and then have it chase and kill his friends one by one.

The drawing he had made and signed of what he saw strongly resembled the character, except that it looked less friendly and more evil.

From what I recall, only 1 body was found, despite a massive search by the military.

His story doesn't match the press stories. In the original press release, a day after the incident, he says he and his friends became separated and he didn't see them again. Later on, he published his story to paranormal magazines, explaining that the journalists at the time had told him to omit the part about the monster. Reportedly, he immediately told the monster story to the families of the missing boys, as well as to one of the search and rescue authorities, who believed him.

Questions

Why would he say / imply a fictional character was behind the deaths of his friends?

Why was he so obsessed throughout his life? I've known teenagers who lost friends in a car crash who are now in their forties, and they are not obsessed about what happened to the point of requesting the telephone numbers of anyone who had survived a car crash, for example.


r/LessWrongLounge • • Nov 18 '14

Conditional probability explained visually [Suggested by VorpalAuroch, Original post by bbrazil]

Thumbnail setosa.io
2 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Aug 09 '14

What would you do with a perpetual motion machine?

2 Upvotes

r/LessWrongLounge • • Sep 16 '14

SSC: [Ozy] A Response to Spandrell (Sexual Deviancy and Statistics)

Thumbnail
slatestarcodex.com
2 Upvotes