r/LessWrong • • Oct 20 '25

Peter Thiel now comparing Yudkowsky to the anti-christ

191 Upvotes

https://futurism.com/future-society/peter-thiel-antichrist-lectures

"It Kind of Seems Like Peter Thiel Is Losing It"

“Some people think of [the Antichrist] as a type of very bad person,” Thiel clarified during his remarks. “Sometimes it’s used more generally as a spiritual descriptor of the forces of evil. What I will focus on is the most common and most dramatic interpretation of Antichrist: an evil king or tyrant or anti-messiah who appears in the end times.”

In fact, Thiel said during the leaked lecture that he’s suspicious the Antichrist is already among us. He even mentioned some possible suspects: it could be someone like climate activist Greta Thunberg, he suggested, or AI critic Eliezer Yudkowsky — both of whom just happen to be his ideological opponents.

It's of course well known that Thiel funded Yudkowsky and MIRI years ago, so I am surprised to see this.

Has Thiel lost the plot?


r/LessWrong • • Jun 19 '26

Proposal: shut down /r/LessWrong

130 Upvotes

I've been browsing /r/LessWrong for many years, due to having toggled on 'subscribe' and never quite getting around to leaving. I will be leaving shortly (and /r/ControlProblem and /r/cogsci as well), but before I do:

I think this subreddit has gotten so bad over the years it should be shut down or rebooted with a new set of moderators.

I look at the front page right now. There's at least 3 AI slop/spam links (there's engagement bait self-posts daily), including NoLabelJustMe who appears to have dedicated his life to submitting LLM psychosis spam every day here forever no matter how clearly downvotes tell him to 'go away'. Half the links are low-effort memes. Most of them are generic AI-related hot takes or news, which have little to do with LW. There are no LW submisions - zero! None! In 100 items! Skimming through https://www.reddit.com/r/LessWrong/comments/ I see little of value, and no commenters I know or respect. Checking my bookmarks, the only valuable conversation or link I have ever bookmarked from this subreddit was 16 years ago, when the subreddit was new and still had a chance.

All of the discussion which might happen here happens on LW2 proper, or ACX, or /r/slatestarcodex, or maybe Twitter. ("But I want a place I can submit links and have informal discussions about LW topics!" Yeah, we have that already - it's called LessWrong. Short Form, if you want to be informal. "OK, but I think it's ugly compared to Old Reddit." Fair enough, no arguing taste, but then you can configure any UI you want in GreaterWrong including Old Reddit-style graphics - and now you aren't dependent on the Reddit Powers That Be deciding that AI monetization demands disabling old.reddit.com... "They banned me for posting my 99%-LLM-written essay / the commenters there didn't just upvote me but criticized me!" Good. You'll thank them someday.)

The moderators don't exist. Sole moderator Oliver Habryka hasn't commented on Reddit in 3 years, and is extremely busy with vastly more important things like AI safety, Lighthaven, and the actual LessWrong. Spammers continue indefinitely for months until, presumably, they earn a site-wide ban.

Rebooting is infeasible because there are not high-quality mods on tap, especially with short timelines (I and everyone else who would do a good job have better, or at least more fun, things to do); and there is simply no need for this subreddit to continue to exist and besmirching the good name of LessWrong as an attractive nuisance. It does not fill any niche and if it hasn't in 16 years, it's not about to start. It was maybe possibly justifiable 10 years ago, but in mid-2026, with the blasted wasteland it is now...? No. Let's just shut it down.

Given the economics of AI & online trends, communities should be proactive about cleaning up and reducing vulnerability surfaces, and trying to engage in a flight to quality. So I appeal to /u/Habryka to pull the plug on this stillbirth of a subreddit, and lock all submissions/comments forever. (/u/Bakkot can help explain the mechanics.)


r/LessWrong • • Apr 16 '25

God hates rationalists

Post image
123 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Oct 13 '26

Are we supposed to pretend this just didn't happen?

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Nov 16 '25

The new Pluribus TV show is a great and unusual analogy for AI.

96 Upvotes

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/cKuPsenbX9cL68CgG

Pluribus (or "PLUR1BUS") shows how the world radically changes after everyone on the planet merges their thoughts and knowledge to become a single entity. Everyone except, of course, the main character and 11 others. The sci-fi magic that causes this is an alien message received by SETI and decoded as an RNA sequence that then spreads to everyone. Importantly, as of the third episode, there's no direct involvement of the aliens apart from sending the sequence, apparently eons ago. This means that everything happening, everything the new "Pluribus" entity does, is the result of human knowledge and abilities.

This is really interesting to me as it fits a "minimalist" definition of AGI that does not include any super intelligence. We see Pluribus struggle with the biology research needed to solve the mystery of why 12 humans are immune to the change. Every body that is part of Pluribus can now access all the knowledge of all top scientists, but some things are still hard. This capability is somewhat similar to a giant AI model able to imitate (predict) anyone, but nothing more.

Of course Pluribus is actually way worse as a threat model since it replaced everyone instead of just duplicating their abilities. And Pluribus also has all of the physical access and physical abilities of everyone; it's not going to die because it couldn't deploy robots quickly enough to maintain the power grid for example.

In fact, this is one of the bleakest scenarios imaginable for the survival of humanity as we know it. This contrasts sharply with the overall tone of the show, where everything is surprisingly normal, and actually quite comfortable for the immune humans (at least for now). So much so that they don't seem to see any problem with the way things are going. This adds to the deep despair of the main character, who can't even convince the 11 people still on her team to try to win.

And that's the other amazing parallel between Pluribus and current AI: they are both just so nice and helpful. There's a few things that will probably be soon outdated as references to the 2025 LLM's personality traits, but the way Pluribus never pushes back against the humans, and just agrees to any dumb request with a stupid smile on its face, desperate to make them happy in any way, is very funny. The rub is that there is one request it can't agree to: stopping the search for a "fix" to their immunity. Because, you see, it has a "biological imperative".

In the end, it's a great show to let people visualize the profoundly alien nature of something made of human level intelligence only, and the creepiness of an entity whose goals are completely different from ours. To me the most fascinating aspect is how the unity of purpose of Pluribus, the fact that it is a single individual with the abilities of billions, is almost enough to make it more powerful than humanity as a whole. I'm sure there will be more sci-fi elements introduced later in the show, but I hope they keep exploring this side of the problem in more details.


r/LessWrong • • Sep 12 '25

No matter how capable AI becomes, it will never be really reasoning.

Post image
83 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Mar 03 '22

I just did my first Bayes Theorem equation and I wanted to brag

77 Upvotes

First off, I'm not particularly well educated. I don't have much in the way of "higher learning". I'm a gardener. I mow lawns for a living. Today I scrubbed leaf scum off walls in rain so heavy, it caused mass flooding in nearby towns. Most of my days are spent picking up leaves.

Even my basic learning was more basic than usual. I was homeschooled - my mum was a religious, anti-vax nutter who thought keeping me at home was the way to go. Consequently, I taught myself maths. Mum was no help - we read the maths textbook together, but her "explanations" involved variations on the words "Eurgh?" and "What?". I ended up explaining it to her most of the time.

I got as far as learning basic algebra before throwing in the towel. I'm not a naturally gifted mathematician.

I went to a real school for my final year - I got put in the "dumb class" for maths. My fellow students cultivated ingenious techniques to derail the lessons, including asking our Bangladeshi teacher about their War for Independance. He was quite happy to forego explaining how percentages worked in favour of reminiscing about the times he cut people's heads off. Today's maths lesson is: don't cut people's heads off, you'll regret it.

Today, after a lifetime of getting things wrong and not really knowing why, I finally sat down to learn Bayes Theorem. I spent about an hour on Less Wrong before following a series of links to arbital.com, where I got presented with my first equation.

It took me nearly half an hour to complete and I had to google "percentage calculator" to help me because I only have 32% trust in my percentage calculating skills. That's a joke that's only 58% funny.

The real joke is I had to google "what is 80% of 20".

But guys... I GOT IT RIGHT. First time.

I know there's so much more to learn, I shouldn't be complacent, yadda yadda yadda.

But I admit... I skipped with joy, and I'm still buzzing.


r/LessWrong • • Mar 11 '26

What specific policies, values, or social changes associated with the left are so unacceptable to MAGA supporters that they regard Trump’s corruption and self-enrichment as an acceptable tradeoff?

63 Upvotes

In another thread, one defence of MAGA was that many supporters recognize Trump’s demagoguery and corruption but tolerate it because they find the left’s policies and values even worse.

I want to understand that tradeoff at the object level. What specific left-wing policies, institutional changes, or value commitments are so unacceptable that they make Trump’s self-enrichment, corruption, and demagoguery seem worth tolerating?

Please give concrete examples and explain the tradeoff explicitly. Please avoid general vibes/impressions like “wokeness,” “globalism,” or “moral decay,” unless you unpack what those mean in practice. I want to focus on specifics. i.e. What woke policies, specifically? What aspects of globalism (e.g. low trade barriers leading to off-shoring markets with lower labour costs)? Etc.

In the spirit of honest engagement, I should be specific too about instances of corruption. Thankfully, I keep a long list I can pull some examples from:

  1. Hush-money falsification case: a New York jury convicted Trump on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records in a scheme tied to concealing a hush-money payment before the 2016 election.

  2. Foreign and private business entanglements while president: in January 2025, the Trump Organization adopted an ethics policy that allowed deals with private foreign companies, a looser restriction than the one used in his first term. Associated Press noted that this could create channels for outsiders to try to buy influence with the administration. Specific examples of this include: accepting a $400 million plane from Qatar’s ruling family, the $75 million Amazon-backed Melania documentary deal, million-dollar inaugural donations from corporations seeking influence, and the Trump Organization’s willingness to pursue deals with private foreign companies while Trump is in office.

  3. Payments and business conflicts tied to Trump properties: ethics watchdog CREW reported that during his first presidency Trump likely benefited from millions in foreign-government-linked spending, and has not only continued but massively expanded business arrangements that create conflict-of-interest concerns.

  4. Pressuring Georgia officials to overturn the 2020 result: Trump was recorded pressing Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger to “find” enough votes to reverse Biden’s win in the state, while repeating false fraud claims and hinting at legal consequences.

  5. Federal indictment over the 2020 election / fake electors / Jan. 6: the DOJ indictment alleged a multi-part effort to overturn the election, including knowingly false fraud claims, pressure on officials, attempts to use fake electors, and efforts to obstruct certification on January 6. Even leaving aside debates about prosecution, this is a concrete example of alleged conduct aimed at subverting a lawful transfer of power.

  6. Sweeping Jan. 6 pardons, including people convicted of assaulting police: upon returning to office, Trump pardoned or commuted the sentences of 1,500+ Jan. 6 defendants, including people convicted of assaulting officers. This signals impunity for political violence (but only when undertaken on Trump's behalf).

  7. Firing inspectors general and top watchdog officials: in early 2025, Trump fired about 17 inspectors general, and also moved against the heads of the Office of Special Counsel and Office of Government Ethics. Courts temporarily reinstated at least one watchdog while the legality of the firing was litigated. Even defenders of strong presidential power should recognize this as weakening independent oversight over executive misconduct.

  8. Insecure private messaging channels for sensitive material: Trump and his allies made Hillary Clinton’s private email practices a years-long scandal, but Ivanka Trump was later reported to have sent hundreds of government-related emails through a personal account, and Jared Kushner and others were also scrutinized for using private email and messaging apps for official business. Pete Hegseth has been notorious for discussing sensitive operations and classified intelligence over apps like Signal, where breaches have occurred (like inviting random journalists to conversation threads).

  9. Granting politically aligned, outside-linked actors unusual access to sensitive state data systems.: DOGE obtained access, or sought access, to highly sensitive IRS, Treasury payment systems, and Social Security federal databases, prompting lawsuits and oversight scrutiny. Treasury said DOGE had “read-only access” to payment system codes, while courts and watchdogs treated the arrangement as serious enough to warrant injunctions, audits, and ongoing litigation over who should be allowed near these systems. The same pattern extended to other databases, with numerous injunctions (many of which appear to have been ignored).


r/LessWrong • • Oct 03 '25

Artificial intelligence will grip your psyche, steering your thoughts in ways you won't be able to resist. Next generations are cooked.

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Jul 11 '25

This future will be about billionaires and their ressouce accumulation

Thumbnail
reddit.com
56 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Feb 05 '13

LW uncensored thread

51 Upvotes

This is meant to be an uncensored thread for LessWrong, someplace where regular LW inhabitants will not have to run across any comments or replies by accident. Discussion may include information hazards, egregious trolling, etcetera, and I would frankly advise all LW regulars not to read this. That said, local moderators are requested not to interfere with what goes on in here (I wouldn't suggest looking at it, period).

My understanding is that this should not be showing up in anyone's comment feed unless they specifically choose to look at this post, which is why I'm putting it here (instead of LW where there are sitewide comment feeds).

EDIT: There are some deleted comments below - these are presumably the results of users deleting their own comments, I have no ability to delete anything on this subreddit and the local mod has said they won't either.

EDIT 2: Any visitors from outside, this is a dumping thread full of crap that the moderators didn't want on the main lesswrong.com website. It is not representative of typical thinking, beliefs, or conversation on LW. If you want to see what a typical day on LW looks like, please visit lesswrong.com. Thank you!


r/LessWrong • • May 06 '26

Eliezer Yudkowsky Faces Entrapment Attempt in $10,000 Debate. Psuedonomyous AI Lab Director Warns Him to Tone Down Anti-AI Remarks or Face Legal Repercussions.

47 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Feb 03 '26

at long last, we have built the Vibecoded Self Replication Endpoint from the Lesswrong post "Do Not Under Any Circumstances Let The Models Self Replicate"

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Jun 17 '15

LessWrong without pseudo-science

47 Upvotes

I long thought that comparing LessWrong to a cult was exaggeration, and that singularity wasn't a religion. But now I'm not so sure.

After spending several months on #lesswrong, I've come to realize that LessWrong is absolutely doused in absolute nonsense. I've had people tell me that destroying the solar system for computers is plausible, guaranteed to happen, and preferable -- and then have them insult me for being interested in science fiction.

I've asked people how nanotechnology and AI will achieve all that they're purported to, and all I've received as an answer is "AIs will discover a way". Sorry, that is religion, not science. LW is filled with other gibberish, like "timeless physics", which only indicates that EY has never studied actual theoretical physics in his life.

Ideology is prioritized over reality, where taking "logical" principles to their ultimate conclusion is more important than doing things that are useful in real life. See shit like "utilitarianism".

But, nonetheless, the rationality techniques are good. They work. I compare it with meditation -- it's possible to use meditation without subscribing to Buddhism. And I'd like to read a LessWrong minus the religious AI-ism and other bullshit -- only real rationality. Maybe have some plain English, for once.


r/LessWrong • • Oct 03 '26

How to change your identity. A guide to the highest leverage behavior change technique.

Thumbnail
lesswrong.com
45 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Jan 12 '22

It's about the mental paradigm

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Jun 03 '26

[meme] Yud screenshot on a shitposting sub

Post image
43 Upvotes

The comments say that the text transliterates as “translate w no added commentary: elon musk is made of cheese”


r/LessWrong • • Nov 20 '25

What is the shortest example that demonstrates just how alien, and difficult to interface with, aliens can be.

43 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Dec 19 '21

LessWrong got me interested in reasoning years ago, so I hope what became of that interest is interesting to LessWrong: a fallacy debating game

Thumbnail
kickstarter.com
43 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Mar 30 '23

Eliezer Yudkowsky: Dangers of AI and the End of Human Civilization | Lex Fridman Podcast #368

Thumbnail
youtube.com
40 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Aug 16 '21

Why Is It So Hard to Be Rational? - The New Yorker

Thumbnail
newyorker.com
39 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • May 12 '26

Holy fuck, people hate you guys

38 Upvotes

Casual here, I’ve visited lesswrong now and then over the years, always liked what I saw.

Now that Yudkowski’s coming into prominence some more, (for bring up all sorts of stuff goddamn years before pretty much everyone, like deception in ai)—I find that people still goddamn hate him!

For fucking what?

I guess one might have disagreements with the standard views of LessWrong, but shit, almost goddamn everybody comes in with the most uncharitable interpretations.

I fucking swear-when ai kills us all, its a guarantee people will still scumfuck their way out of paying Yudkowski his due.


r/LessWrong • • Dec 09 '25

Why do people who get paid the most do the least?

Thumbnail reddit.com
36 Upvotes

r/LessWrong • • Oct 05 '26

How much should we worry about the pneumonic plague lableak in Siberia?

Thumbnail
lesswrong.com
35 Upvotes