Note: I in no way support Russia's invasion of Ukraine, most of my friends were Ukrainians and I am saddened by the post I am about to write.
The reception from my previous post is that people on this sub really really want Ukraine to win. I do too, but Sun Tzu once said War is a matter of vital importance to the State; the province of life or death; the road to survival or ruin. It is mandatory that it be thoroughly studied. And to thoroughly study anything is to let go of our biases, our emotions and how we want things to be and examine why things are the way that it is today.
Artillery still is King on the Battlefield. The recent loss of Sereodonetsk is the proof of this, it is what we saw in Syria, what we saw in Grozny Chechnya and what we continue to witness today: the sheer overwhelming scale of Russia's artillery power over Ukraine. Despite all of Ukraine's support from America's lend lease and military aid from NATO countries, there is no point in having 100 NLAWS, or 1000 Javelins or 10,000 rifles, vehicles or helmets...if your positions are continuously bombed by artillery till you have nothing left...then you are going to lose. According to Ukraine's deputy defence minister:
“Russia is firing more than 60,000 shells/day, Ukraine’s deputy defense minister told us. That’s 10 times more than Ukraine, she said. Production of the 152mm shells is so limited that even if everyone gave Ukraine all of their stocks of the rounds, it still wouldn’t be enough.” Isabelle Khurshudyan
https://twitter.com/ikhurshudyan/status/1540292368552890369?s=20&t=f-NhEqc1kZ3V_N2k_clKZg
10 times more, 10 times more! How can you possibly hold a position when the enemy is firing ten time more shells than you? Take a look at the list of engagements of the war from Feb 2022 to March to June 2022. In Feb Ukraine according to Wikipedia have won 12 out of the 22 of its engagements with Russia. Since then it has barely won 3 out of 14 engagement whilst Russia have won 9 with 1 being a tactical victory with a strategic withdraw. The big difference came from the shift in Russian doctrine from not using artillery enough to using overwhelming artillery power to destroy an enemy before advancing. And guess what it works!
Ukraine's issue with its artillery can be traced to 3 reasons:
Firstly, Russian sabotage before war have destroyed large quantities of Ukrainian shell stockpiles.
Ukraine is running out of shells for the majority of its artillery in part because of a clandestine Russian campaign of bullying and sabotage over the past eight years, including bombings of key munitions depots across Eastern Europe that officials have linked to Moscow, according to Ukrainian government officials and military analysts.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/06/24/ukraine-ammunition-russian-sabotage-artillery/
Secondly, most of Ukraine's artillery is of Soviet origin and most of those shells for those guns are made in Russia.
Most of Ukraine’s artillery pieces date back to the Soviet Union, meaning they rely on the same 122mm- and 152mm-caliber rounds that Russia uses. But outside of Russia, very little supply exists — in large part because Russia spent years targeting Ukrainian and other Eastern European ammunition storage facilities and suppliers before launching its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in late February. Russia has also taken other steps to acquire the ammunition or otherwise prevent its sale to Ukraine.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/06/24/ukraine-ammunition-russian-sabotage-artillery/
Thirdly, despite the US/NATO finally waking up and begun supplying Ukraine essential artillery pieces. Their Howitzers for example uses vastly different shells and it take quiet some time before Ukraine's artillery corps could transition to Western made Artillery shells.
Howitzers used by NATO and the United States fire 105mm and 155mm shells. Western countries supplied Ukraine with plenty of those shells but only a limited number of systems to fire them. Despite U.S. and European pledges to send more artillery, Ukraine still does not have enough to replace its old Soviet-era equipment entirely with NATO-standard weaponry.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/06/24/ukraine-ammunition-russian-sabotage-artillery/
Germany lost WW1 as quiet simply it run out of shells to fire! We are now seeing a similar situation in Ukraine, with it losing city after city due to Russia well simply just bombing them out of oblivion. Unless this is rectified soon, it is clear that Russia's victory in Ukraine is Inevitable.
Secondly, lets just assume for the sake of the argument that Russia and Ukraine reached parity today and are forced into a unwinnable stalemate with the current status quo. This would mean Ukraine have lost more than 25% of its land, almost entirety of its coast, almost a sizable amount of its industrial/port cities and will in essence be reduced to a landlocked country should the war finish today. The recent Russian grain blockade of Ukraine and the West's inept response towards it shows the new reality of the battlefield, that Russia in essence is already in control of Ukraine's major exports and therefore control of its economy and politics in the long run.
So even if the war ends today Russia has won! For a comparison Ukraine surrendering today will the same as the US surrendering all of its West Coasts and East Coasts to Russia but still keeping Florida for some reason. How is that a victory for America?
Sun Tzu once said that the best way to conquer a city is via diplomacy, second via strategy, third via battle outside the city but the worst thing to do is to besiege the city. Well I will say to Sun Tzu, your armies clearly aren't firing 60,000 shells a day!
But to sum up like I said before, it doesn't matter if Ukraine wins 10 battles or 20 battles or even 100. Russia simply has more, it has more industrial output, it has more people, it has more tanks and artillery and even if the Nazis destroyed all of them it simply just produced more. Its hard to produce something like a YJ-12 supersonic cruise missiles without Western computer ships, but industrial war machines like artillery and its shells is not that hard to produce. Against the US/NATO/China of course that is not acceptable, but against a minor power like Ukraine it will be enough, like the facts have suggested and will continuously suggest.
Sadly unless Ukraine can change the situation of its industrial output when it comes to artillery shells dramatically and soon. It is likely that Russia's Victory in Ukraine is Inevitable.