r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 9d ago

double standards Malèna (2000): A look at its production history, the treatment of its child lead actor, and the double standards in cinema NSFW

50 Upvotes

I recently watched Malèna (2000), looking into the actual production history behind the scenes raises seriously disturbing questions about how male child actors were treated in cinema.

What makes the premise profoundly unsettling from the outset is that the character Renato is explicitly written and established in the narrative as barely 12 and a half years old. This was not a story about an older adolescent on the verge of adulthood. The entire narrative framework deliberate centered on a literal pre-pubescent child.

To portray this 12-and-a-half-year-old boy, director Giuseppe Tornatore cast Giuseppe Sulfaro, who was only 14 during filming, opposite to 35-year-old Monica Bellucci. In a retrospective interview with movie outlet Kid In The Front Row in June 2010, Sulfaro stated that Bellucci would kiss him on the lips every single morning as a greeting, supposedly to make him comfortable and condition him for work on set. An adult repeatedly kissing a 14 year old boy on the lips as a routine workplace greeting is an egregious breach of professional and safeguarding boundaries that deserves serious scrutiny.

The casting process was just as alarming. In a interview with One Guy's Opinion during the US promotional tour in December 2000, Tornatore explained that during final auditions, teenage finalists were asked to improvise a scene with an adult actress and were told they could do whatever they liked. Sulfaro won the role because during the improv, he unbuttoned the adult actress's shirt to guess her bra size. Tornatore openly praised this in the interview, calling it "incredible" and highlighting his strong reaction capacity, rather than questioning the sheer recklessness and inappropriateness of putting a minor in that position in the first place.

The movie went even further across multiple explicit sequences:

In the brothel initiation scene, the 14 year old actor was stripped completely naked on camera by adult female sex worker- exposing his bare back, genital area, and body- while Monica Bellucci appeared in uncensored, full-frontal nudity as the worker in his projection scene

In a separate fantasy sequence, the minor was directed to undress Bellucci, caress her body, and was staged directly in front of her exposed, uncensored genitalia.

The fact that this explicit staging was conceptualized around a character explicitly defined as 12 and a half years old makes the adult misconduct even more severe. Both Tornatore and lead Bellucci bore a duty of care as the adults on that set. Framing these scenes as "harmless fantasy" or "pubescent awakening" obscures the workplace reality- adult authority figures placed an actual minor in direct physical handling and unshielded visual contact with adult genitalia, while exposing the child's own genitalia on camera. This completely crosses into clear child endangerment issues. Being a male child does not make this any less exploitative.

Looking at modern cinema, it is impossible to imagine any mainstream 21st-century film getting away with this level of on-screen exposure and behind-the-scenes treatment of a minor.

What makes this even more glaring is the double standard in how critics and film communities treat it. Malèna holds strong standing across mainstream platforms (two Oscar nominations, a 7.4 on IMDb, 3.6 on Letterboxd, and higher scores on Rotten Tomatoes) and continues to be framed as an untouchable arthouse classic. Compare that to modern films like Miller's Girl (2024), which was universally torn apart by mainstream critics- sitting at a dismal 30% on Rotten Tomatoes and a 1.8 on Letterboxd—with widespread outrage directed at its power dynamics. This severe backlash occurred even though Jenna Ortega was a consenting 21 year old adult and the production strictly utilized professional intimacy coordinators.

Why is an adult actress repeatedly kissing a 14 year old child on the lips every morning normalized in film history discussions ? Why is the exposure and sexualization of an 14 year boy depicting a 12-and-a-half-year-old still excused and not subjected to the level of scrutiny it deserves ? If the genders were reversed, I find it impossible to believe that the actress and director wouldn't have faced immediate boycott and legal scrutiny.

(The quotes and production details mentioned here are documented in the official 2000 Miramax press logs, the December 2000 One Guy's Opinion interview, and Sulfaro's June 2010 Kid In The Front Row interview.)

‎I want to open this up to the community to guide the discussion:

‎

  1. ‎Why do you think film culture and audience backlash still overwhelmingly focus on uncomfortable power dynamics when an older man is involved, yet frequently ignore or normalize instances where an older woman or female predator is the adult in power ?


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • Jul 05 '26

article How Gender Bias on the Battlefield Hinders the Protection of Civilian Men

Thumbnail
justsecurity.org
170 Upvotes

r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 10h ago

media & cultural analysis Misandrists want us to equate "less masculine" with "majorly feminine"!

58 Upvotes

Have you ever noticed that, in most Western media these days, the token "less-masculine" man usually has his lack of masculinity exaggerated? Sure, they'll include a man who isn't exaggeratedly masculine, but then they'll insist on making him act so effeminately that he acts more like a stereotypical traditional woman, and then, just to make it worse, they'll usually top it off by making him Gay.

Not that long ago, "soft" masculinity was something people actually accepted enough to give some representation to, but now it's basically a binary between "exaggeratedly traditionally-manly muscle-daddy" and "vaguely-queer-coded femboy-lite".

Why can't the media seem to put nuance into discussions of masculinity anymore? I think it's because mainstream feminists and conservatives alike want men to think that those are their only options. If men realised that masculinity is a spectrum and comes in many shades, they wouldn't feel compelled to conform to mainstream traditional gender roles; however, since most men, especially heterosexual men, don't want to be outright feminine, they absorb this depicted binary and subsequently assume that exaggerated traditional manliness is the "lesser evil".

Just to clarify, I'm not saying this whole situation was started as one big psy-op (although that wouldn't surprise me), but I am saying that conservatives and feminists alike are deliberately apathetic in creating nuance in this space precisely because it suits their agenda; conservatives want us to think that all less-masculine men are sissies, and radical feminists can't understand that toxic masculinity isn't innate to men in general. The belief that any man who doesn't display certain traits will automatically be markedly effeminate allows both conservative and feminist elites to press men into conformity with a single model of masculinity.

I'd be interested to hear other people's thoughts on this!


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 13h ago

other "I was there chilling with my son and I was like 'You better not grow up and rape nobody.' " Timestamp(12:07). The treating of boys/men as a pending doom.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
58 Upvotes

At the 12:07 mark in a reaction video titled "Nobody Wants A Baby Boy Anymore", Young Don treats his own young boy's future as a default moral risk before he has done anything wrong.

What stands out isn't just a single edgy joke it's how casually framing boys and men as potential predators gets passed off as normal parenting or progressive awareness. When empathy starts from suspicion, boys learn early that their default state is a threat to manage rather than a kid to guide.

Is this kind of "pre-emptive guilt" showing up more in mainstream commentary, or is it mostly amplified by social media clips?


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 22h ago Popcorn

media & cultural analysis So of course, GTA 6 has entered the center of the online gender wars - but for those LWMAs here who have played the game, what do you think?

52 Upvotes

GTA VI is the most widely anticipated piece of media of all time and has by far been the biggest, most profitable launch of any media ever. So it doesn’t surprise me one bit that it’s at the center of discourse.

But after far too many hours of Reddit and TwitterX scrolling, seeing the backlash (and the backlash to the backlash…) has kinda fucked up the hype for me. So my question for LWMA users is: Is it good? Do you feel like it girlbosses Lucia too much? Do you feel like there are feminist undertones in the game, or does it stick true to satirizing both sides in the same way that previous GTA games did? How do you feel about the devs changing to focus more on empathy - does it make it more immersive and feel cool as fuck, or does it make you moreso feel punished for wanting to enjoy GTA in the traditional GTA way?

I guess my main question is - with GTA 6 being at the center of attention right now, including the cultural gender wars, how do LWMAs feel about the entire thing?


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 19h ago

social issues So FVAMB Doesn't Exist?

19 Upvotes

FVAMB = Female violence against men and boys

Posted this recently on r/leftwingantifeminism and feel it fits here as well. Also not sure if social issues is the right flair for this? If the moderators feel different they can re-flair it.

It's bad enough when misandrists downplay and mitigate female on male crime to make it seem like it doesn't matter or isn't a big issue because in their warped minds it's always "Women and girls most affected, men and boys don't matter." They'll come up with asinine claims whether it's denying misandry is real or serious (false, it's very much both) or saying women being violent to men/boys isn't nearly on the same scale as it's counterpart (also false, it happens far more than many are aware of). I've even seen some claim women raping men/boys is impossible, which is also blatantly wrong. Rape is forcing someone into a sexual act against their own will, something both genders absolutely can and do do to each other.

But I've seen some have the absolute nerve and audacity to claim that FVAMB isn't even real because "women lack power and men have always had power over women." Just.. ugh. Just when you think they can't be more ignorant, stupid and hateful they'll make claims like this. And of course defending it saying it's rare for women to be violent on their own and when they are it's usually in self-defense. It never ceases to amaze and disgust me whenever there's an instance of female on male violence or crime the defenses and excuses misandrists always have at the ready. And even if the rates of FVAMB aren't as high, so what, that's supposed to negate the fact it does happen? And in numbers likely far higher than many are aware of? They of course forget how vastly underreported female on male violence is due to a number of factors. Between male victims being afraid of being disbelieved or ridiculed over being attacked by a female assailant, not being seen as manly for letting it happen, fear a female attacker can claim self-defense knowing law enforcement will side with her, how under the VAWA it's still counted as being against women and also how there's very few abuse shelters that even acknowledge or help male victims. And never distiquishing violence done out of self-defense versus that done out of genuine ill will. Which of course are all things misandrists always disregard.

One has the right to their own opinions but not their own facts, and it's an undeniable fact that even if not as common an occurance as it's counterpart, FVAMB definitely happens and likely far more than believed or documented. It's really mind-blowing that misandrists are so full of hate they'll go so far as to deny basic facts including that FVAMB exists and does happen. Is this what it's come down to, having to ask if someone like FVAMB happens?

I've said before many times how I'm mostly very left-wing and liberal with most of my views, and yet unfortunately people think this equates to hating men/boys and never wanting to bring attention to issues affecting them. Not acknowledging female on male violence as a serious and often overlooked issue has played a big role in recent times why the left has done so poorly with males and hopefully now the left has learned it's lesson and will try to shed more light on this. It shouldn't even be a matter of being left or right or something else, it's a fact both genders can be terribly violent to each other, and female on male violence needs just as much attention and condemnation as it's counterpart.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 1d ago

media & cultural analysis GTA 6 romance feature discourse is causing a lot of progressives to virgin shame men.

Thumbnail
gallery
148 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/77BWY4EmFL4?is=AtfqrKLYXwyDbaIe

This video game has created a lot of idiotic white knight takes. The first screenshot is from an actual video game Journalist.

There is a whole romance feature in the game some fans don't like. Because they want play the game to steal cars and shoot people. Any male gamer who doesn't like it automatically lable an incel who can't get a girlfriend in real-life. Saying that these men hate women so much, they can't even have empathy for them in a video game.

These fools don't even understand what an incel is. An incel is lonely man who struggles with relationships. So ironically incels would actually be the perfect demographic for this feature.

And also one thing here. IT'S A FUCKING VIDEO GAME. It's not real, the characters fake, I don't care about them. For fuck sakes the game is about criminals. You start off the game with the female main character robbing a bank, and threatening to shoot an old lady. But somehow men are the weirdos for not wanting to treat this female character like a real girlfriend.

So this take is just misandry brainrot or misandry slop. And it's also It's ironic and funny how the progressives or white knights are calling men losers for nlt wanting to buy flowers for a girlfriend in a video game. But yet these would be the same people that would find very odd if the same video game had a feature where the girlfriend has to buy flowers for her boyfriend too.

It's a fucking video game. GTA is a criminal sandbox, not a relationship simulator. Players shouldn't be obligated to emotionally invest in fictional characters, treat them like real romantic partners, or participate in every optional relationship mechanic. Some people just want to steal cars, rob banks, shoot people, and cause absolute chaos. That's the entire appeal of GTA for a lot of players.

Again here's the double standard: Would these same people defend a mechanic where the female protagonist has to buy flowers, purchase gifts, and perform romantic gestures for her boyfriend? Would they call female gamers lonely, bitter, or incapable of loving men if they didn't want to participate? Somehow I doubt it.

Shaming men for not wanting to perform fictional romantic gestures isn't demonstrating empathy toward women. It's just another example of misandry being disguised as progressivism. You're essentially calling men losers because they don't want to roleplay as someone's boyfriend in a fucking video game. There's nothing inherently misogynistic or incel or gay about not wanting to do romance in a game about professional criminals.

Edit:

Forgot this.

GTA 6 ~ PRAGMATA
What most commentators don't talk about is the stark difference between how the wokesters talk about GTA 6 vs how they talked about PRAGMATA.

To refresh your memory: Gamers liked PRAGMATA. It's a wholesome game, where masculine traits, such as strenght, sacrifice, protection are embraced and praised. You're taking care of a little android girl, you're essentially a father figure for her. Funny thing is, chuds were joking that it made them want kids.

What were the woke takes? Gamers were called losers, who will never experience something like that, they were called diddlers and creepts. Feminists called hated us, because the game showed a wholesome and strong masculinity.

Now, back to GTA 6... Jason is a doormat, entirely subservient to his selfish girlboss. Yet, the woke are imagining that the game "teaches men how to be in a relationship" and that it "teaches men how to treat women". WTF? It's as if they want to reduce men to be doormats with no say and no opinions.

Meanwhile, chuds are hating on the game. Not only because it's just another goy slop, but also because the game is heavily restricted in what you can do. But most importantly is the fact that the game seems very boring.

These two examples should shatter the mask the wokies dropped. They just mate normal heterosexual men. Nothing less.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 1d ago

misandry Cornwall coaching sessions aim to show what real men are like

Thumbnail
bbc.co.uk
93 Upvotes

First of all the use of the term “real men” is being used as a shaming tactic to get men to conform to their standards.
They make being a man and empowering men all about women. Protecting them, respecting them, being a “male ally” etc.
How is this supposed to make men feel better? Being constantly told that their lives should revolve around women and having coaching for men being about women rather than men themselves make men feel even more isolated.
We need to break down these gender roles, not reinforce them


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 1d ago

legal rights The "trans panic defence" is really just a defence for killing men

69 Upvotes

https://truthout.org/articles/tn-court-rules-killing-of-woman-may-have-been-justifiable-because-she-was-trans/

This case is a murder case, a man shot a trans woman and claimed self defence. He was convicted, and appealed on the grounds that the jury should have been told that the woman he shot was a transsexual, because they would give greater credence to a self defence claim against a man than a very large woman.

The appeals court ruled in his favour, that the jury might have accepted the victim being biologically male as exculpatory evidence.

This is the standard view on the left, here from Vaush:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M4rYr98rkRo

So he thinks it's the trans panic defence, that this is an anti-trans thing, but the facts are quite clear. The dead transwoman would be more acceptible to kill if people knew she was born a man. It's not really about trans, because this wouldn't apply to transmen, it applies to biological men.

So the coverage, which can't accept that and tries to limit it to a trans issue is one thing, and the ruling that a jury must know that a potential murder victim is a man is the other thing.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 1d ago

discussion The Left think their "devil may care, but I don’t" reaction to men's issues is special, when it's actually not.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
101 Upvotes

For starters, if you want to help lonely men. Maybe calling them losers isn't the best idea. The thing that pissed me off here. Is that some people on the left actually think they are being unique with their "pull yourself by your bootstraps" attitude towards men. This is the same attitude the right, the manosphere, and society general already have towards men. So a liberal think they are being cute by trying to give these men a reality check, when in reality most men are already aware that society don't have any empathy for them.

I could literally watch a Andrew Tate video about men and then watch a feminist video about men. And the talking points would be identical, im not even joking here. Both sides will tell men that women don't like them, because they are losers and have no drive. Again liberals aren't saying anything new or original here. You are basically just being the progessive version of a red-piller here.

So my question to Feminists. How is your side a alternative for men, when your side is still just regurgitating the same talking points the right use on men?

This is why we should avoid any conversation about the "male loneliness epidemic". Because bad faith Feminists only want to use this fake epidemic to demonize men or attack men. They don't really have any intentions of helping outside telling men their issues would go away if they were traditionally masculine in a progressive way (I.E. "positive masculinity".)


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 1d ago

media & cultural analysis David Corenswet/James Gunn's (DCU) Superman/Clark Kent being called a "Man Child"

24 Upvotes

For the most part, David Corenswet's Superman/Clark Kent under James Gunn's creative vision, has been near universally praised as being an adaptation that seems to have gotten the character pretty right, evoking the more optimistic/hopeful take of Donner/Christoper Reeve Superman,

That said, I've noticed a decent deal of folks critiquing how his portrayal of the character seems like someone who's "emotionally immature" and a "manchild",

I think it's due to how expressive and emotive he comes across throughout the movie, especially his moments of frustration/anger (that "mockup" interview with Lois that ended up getting intense, almost to the point both of them, Lois at least, was on the verge of breaking up with him),

I've seen this complaint fairly consistent across social media - stating how his display of anger seems like a bad precedent for who is meant to be the "ideal" mankind can strive towards and a symbol of hope, and they felt DCEU/Cavill's Superman's more reserved and stoic Superman was him being more emotionally mature/balanced (apparently, Supes can be an outright jerk or have genuine humane lapses, this is apparent in many of his comics, and even that 90s-00s DCAU adaptation, while depicted a more emotionally stoic Superman, even he had his moments)

Even Honest Trailers (Screen Junkies), who at times, "graze" towards left-leaning talking points in some of their videos/critique, mocked him as being a manchild, which tbh, I found was lazy and not well-thought out from their part - they tried to poke fun on how a lot of Gunn's usual tropes featured on this movie too, and in their attempts to make that parallel, they compare Clark/Supes with MCU's Star Lord/Peter Quill, telling how both are emotionally stunted manchildren. Really?

Personally, I took him being more emotional, especially compared to the previous live-action Superman (Henry Cavill/DCEU), as them emphasizing how beneath his superpowers and larger-than-life aura and symbol, he's at his core, a "human" raised by humble farmers in the middle of nowhere, it came across as an attempt to empathize and humanize such a larger-than-life character, especially how Cavill's Superman was critiqued as coming across as "God-like" and "alien" (writing a good Superman story is harder, I suppose, compared to say, Batman or even Spider-man),

This adaptation even went to the extent of demonizing/villanizing his birth/Kryptonian parents and their culture, to drive home the point how at his core, he's a human through and through born and bred in this very planet we inhabit (his ending monologue to Lex in the climax pretty much),

It felt resonant to me, as someone who's often told he's quite "emotional" and "attuned" with his emotions, as a guy, I never felt any of those humane reactions and moments he expressed as some inherent flaw or bad writing,

It seems like men expressing any emotions can be a potential doorway for them to be mocked/called as being emotionally stunted/immature or as a manchild. Which is doubly amusing, as anger is one of the few emotions, men are allowed to show, and nowadays, anger in turn, is also heavily stigmatized (understandbly so, in fariness, as anger can be corrosive and damaging), and now even (and maybe especially), an angry man is more ripe to be mocked/trolled as being immature.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 2d ago

discussion Feminists who claim feminism is solely a belief in gender equality are being disingenuous

117 Upvotes

Feminists who claim that feminism just means a belief in gender equality are being disingenuous.

I'm talking about "involved" feminists (those who can cite booktitles and theory, pursue discourse and activism, can tell you the figures they like, etc.), and not people who just casually identify as feminists, by the way.

The biggest reason for this is the feminist belief in patriarchy theory. In fact, feminists will tell you that you’re not a feminist if you don’t subscribe to patriarchy theory.

Feminists refuse to even consider any other model of gender inequality and sexism other than patriarchy theory, and treat it as irrefutable fact.

You could say we live in a patriarchy in a narrow definition of the word/concept. The significant majority of people in positions of power in politics, business, religious institutions, and so on are men. However, all of the other aspects of feminist patriarchy theory are far less clear.

A belief in patriarchy theory should be part of the definition of feminism, in my opinion.

Almost all feminists have other beliefs and theories, too, that are treated as irrefutable or almost irrefutable. There’s also stifling conformity within feminism. It’s often said that there are three major branches of feminism: liberal, radical, and socialist/Marxist. While there genuinely were multiple branches of feminism during second-wave feminism (1960s through 1980s) by the time third-wave feminism started in the early 1990s, liberal feminism was dead. Socialist/Marxist feminism died sometime around then, too.

During third and fourth-wave feminism, feminism has been virtually all radical feminism.

https://critiquingfeminism.substack.com/p/the-myth-of-feminist-division


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 2d ago

news In the spirit of International Mens Day, I'm happy to share some positive news with my fellow men in the United Kingdom

99 Upvotes

The UK government now appears to finally be taking a more serious stance on men's issues, building on the men's health strategy introduced last year. I see this as a change for the better because it seems like they're no longer just discussing men and boy's issues as a subtopic of women and girls issues, but as a policy in it's own right. One of the major criticisms I had of previous policies was that the government was approaching the topic of men and boys issues as a means to an end of improving the safety and wellbeing of women, rather than as an end in itself. This seems to be changing.

Another positive thing I see here is the proposal to reach out to men across the country, to find out which issues matter to them the most. I believe this to be a significant improvement from previous policy, where it was more the case that men and boys were simply being told what their issues were and how to solve them, instead of actually being listened to. So if they're serious about doing this, and it's not all just talk, then it's a great thing to see.

Yes, this should have happened years ago, and yes it's still not enough, but it is at least a step in the right direction and something to celebrate on International Mens Day. I believe we should celebrate small wins wherever we can find them.

Happy International Mens Day fellas! 💙

The link below if anyone in the UK is interested in becoming an ambassador:

https://www.gov.uk/government/news/new-mens-health-ambassador-to-help-improve-mens-health


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 2d ago

article Happy International Men’s Day, Brothers

212 Upvotes

The dads, the brothers, the sons, the grandads, the husbands, the mates, the workmates, the coaches, the neighbours and the bloke down the road who somehow owns every tool known to mankind and will happily lend you any one of them, provided you return it in the same condition. The men who turn up, get stuck in, make us laugh, carry their share of the load and often considerably more than their share. The men who work hard, love their families, look after their friends and quietly get on with things, even when life is giving them an almighty kicking.

Subscribe: https://sagesynclair.substack.com/

We know these men. We love these men. We are these men.

Yet, for a group of people who contribute so much to the lives of everybody, people have a habit of overlooking men when it comes to their wellbeing.

International Men’s Day is today, November 19. 

Let’s give the men a proper celebration. Not a grudging acknowledgement, not a day spent arguing about whether men deserve a day, and certainly not another opportunity to tell them everything they could be doing better. Let’s actually talk about men, what they contribute, what they experience, what they’re up against and why they deserve more support than they’re getting.

In 2024, for every 100 women who died at work in America, 1,128 men died. That’s more than eleven men for every woman. Think about the people behind that number: construction workers, tradesmen, transport workers, farmers, labourers and men in countless other occupations where going to work comes with risks most of us would rather not contemplate. They have families, mortgages, children, friends and people waiting for them to come home. 

This figure comes from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and is included in a document that has been quietly making an important case for fifteen years. It’s called For Every 100 Girls, and it brings together statistics on the lives of boys and men across education, health, employment, homelessness, incarceration and other areas of public life.

Tom Mortenson, a Senior Scholar at the Pell Institute, originally put the document together in 2011. His idea was to put a number of separate problems side by side, because looking at them individually made it too easy to miss the bigger picture. Mark Perry, emeritus economics professor at the University of Michigan-Flint, has continued updating the research, with the latest version published in August 2026. The project is promoted by The Boys Initiative, an organisation we’ll come back to, because it deserves to be much better known.

The mortality figures alone should have us paying attention. Among people aged 15 to 24, there were 267 male deaths for every 100 female deaths in 2022. In 2023, for every 100 females aged 15 to 24 who died by suicide, 385 males did. Among people aged 75 and older, the figure was 798 males for every 100 females.

These are enormous disparities. They represent young men who should have had decades ahead of them and older men who should have been enjoying the fruits of a lifetime of work, family and friendship. They represent parents who buried sons, children who lost fathers, partners who lost husbands and friends who still wonder whether there was something they could have done.

Male suicide deserves far more public attention, better research and properly funded support. Too many men reach a point of profound distress without the help they need. They are alienated, isolated, some are struggling financially, some have lost relationships or employment, and some have been carrying difficult circumstances for years. We cannot keep treating these deaths as though they are an unfortunate feature of being male. Men deserve lives that are supported, protected and valued.

According to the research, boys repeat kindergarten at 145 for every 100 girls, are suspended at 240 for every 100 girls and expelled at 267 for every 100 girls. By the time students reach their senior year, boys are considerably less likely to have top grades. In 2025, there were just 71 men enrolled in college for every 100 women. Men earned 73 bachelor’s degrees and 65 master’s degrees for every 100 women.

These numbers ought to prompt some serious questions about what is happening to boys in our education systems. Are we recognising their learning needs? Are we giving them enough support? Are we making sure the classroom works for children who may learn and develop differently? And are we doing enough to help boys see a future in education, skilled trades, professional careers and the many other paths to a fulfilling life? A little boy who struggles at school has an enormous amount of life ahead of him. We should be investing in that potential, not allowing him to become another statistic in a report about educational failure.

In 2023, state and federal prisons held 1,277 men for every 100 women. In 2024, HUD counted 220 unsheltered homeless men for every 100 unsheltered homeless women. In Operation Enduring Freedom, there were 5,098 men wounded in action for every 100 women.

Men are disproportionately represented in some of the most dangerous occupations, in the prison population and among people sleeping rough. These are complex issues, with many contributing factors, but complexity is no excuse for indifference. We need to understand what is happening, invest in solutions and make sure the men affected are not simply left to fend for themselves.

Veterinary schools enroll just 22 men for every 100 women. I mention it because the data is not always what you might expect, and because somewhere there is a veterinary faculty that appears to have an entirely different recruitment challenge. Even the blokes who want to work with kittens and puppies are becoming a minority.

These numbers deserve attention. They are not a competition between men and women. They are evidence of problems affecting boys and men that deserve to be recognised and addressed in their own right.

The Boys Initiative

Founded in 2008 by researchers, community leaders and others concerned about boys’ issues, The Boys Initiative is a US nonprofit with a clear mission: improve educational outcomes for boys, support the parents and teachers responsible for raising and educating them, and equip community leaders to advocate for policies that benefit boys. It moves beyond simply identifying problems. It’s trying to change the circumstances producing them.

The For Every 100 Girls project is a major part of that effort. Tom Mortenson’s original idea was to put the evidence in one place so that people could see the patterns. Mark Perry’s continued updates have kept the project alive, and the resulting document provides a useful resource for parents, educators, researchers, policymakers and anybody interested in understanding what is happening to boys and men.

The Initiative also runs and promotes a number of practical programmes.

Time 4 Recess is one of The Boys Initiative’s practical campaigns: making sure children actually get time to play during the school day. The campaign advocates for daily recess for all children, with particular attention to boys, and argues that schools should not be taking away playtime as punishment for classroom behaviour. Its work involves educating state legislators, promoting research on the physical, educational and social benefits of recess, and tracking legislation designed to protect children’s access to it.

The campaign had a significant win in California in 2023, when SB 291 was unanimously passed by the state Senate and Assembly. From the 2024–25 school year, the legislation guarantees pupils in California public and charter schools at least 30 minutes of recess on regular school days and 15 minutes on early-release days. Crucially, schools cannot withhold recess unless a pupil presents an immediate threat to the physical safety of themselves or another pupil. The legislation also provides for recess to take place outdoors whenever weather and air quality allow.

The Initiative’s case is backed by research on what happens when children are given time away from structured classroom instruction. Recess provides opportunities for physical activity, social interaction and self-directed play, and research cited by the campaign identifies benefits including improved attention, memory and classroom behaviour. The CDC also recognises recess as an important contributor to children’s physical, mental and emotional wellbeing.

Boys who spend much of their school day sitting still, following tightly structured lessons and trying to meet classroom expectations can benefit enormously from regular opportunities to move, explore, compete, socialise and simply be children. Recess isn’t a reward for finishing the work or behaving perfectly. It’s part of a healthy school day, and children shouldn’t have to earn the right to play by being the very children who need that break the least.

Time 4 Recess continues to promote legislation around the country, highlighting states that have adopted daily recess protections and encouraging other states to follow suit. It’s a good example of The Boys Initiative taking an issue affecting boys and children more broadly and doing the unglamorous but important work of trying to change actual education policy.

Helping Boys Thrive Summit brings together the people who have the greatest influence over boys’ lives: parents, teachers, counsellors, healthcare professionals, grandparents, mentors, faith leaders, youth workers and policymakers. Developed in collaboration with Dr Michael Gurian and the Gurian Institute, the Summit is a practical, science-informed professional development and networking event focused on understanding boys’ development and helping them succeed.

Rather than simply discussing the problems facing boys, the programme gets into the detail of what adults can actually do. Topics have included boys’ brain development, learning differences, school performance, the importance of fathers, the effects of absent father figures, bullying, male mental health, screen time, counselling and the emotional development of boys. Sessions have also explored how schools can better engage boys who struggle with conventional teaching methods, and how parents and mentors can provide the support and guidance boys need as they grow up.

The Summit is designed to give people practical ideas they can take back into their homes, classrooms, workplaces and communities. Its events have featured researchers, educators, authors and practitioners, including Dr Warren Farrell, Dr Michael Gurian and Mark Perry. A virtual summit hosted by The Boys Initiative and the Gurian Institute attracted more than 150 participants, including educators, parents and lawmakers. The broader ambition is to build a network of adults who understand boys’ needs and have the knowledge and confidence to do something useful about them.

Oh, Boy! launched in December 2024. It aims to bring boys’ educational, social and emotional challenges into wider public discussion, using research and shareable information to help people understand where boys are struggling and why they need support. Its material covers issues including educational disadvantage, mental health, the importance of fathers and positive male role models, and the need for learning environments that recognise boys’ developmental needs. The campaign also makes an important point: giving boys the attention and resources they need does not mean taking opportunities away from girls. We can want both to thrive. The Initiative invites people to add their voices to the campaign and help bring these issues to a wider audience.

Title IX Is For Boys addresses fairness in education. Title IX is the American federal law prohibiting sex discrimination in education programmes and activities receiving federal financial assistance. Although it is widely associated with expanding opportunities for women and girls, The Boys Initiative argues that its protections apply to males as well. Its campaign draws attention to educational programmes, facilities, scholarships and other opportunities where boys and men may face sex-based exclusion. Mark Perry has pursued this issue through formal complaints to the US Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights, challenging programmes he believes discriminate against male students. One example involved a women-only lounge at Michigan State University. Following the publicity surrounding the complaint, the university closed the lounge, remodelled it and reopened it to everyone.

The underlying argument is: fairness should work in both directions. Boys and men should be able to access educational opportunities, support services and facilities without being excluded simply because they are male. The campaign encourages people to understand their rights and draws attention to the importance of applying existing protections fairly. It is part of a wider effort to ensure that boys and men are not forgotten in conversations about educational equality.

The Initiative’s wider work includes early literacy, mentoring, mental health support, teacher training, positive role models and advocacy for better policies. It recognises that boys need adults who understand them, educational environments in which they can thrive and communities willing to invest in their futures.

Boys benefit enormously from having men in their lives: men who can teach them, encourage them, support them and show them what a decent, fulfilling adult life can look like. That might be a father, grandfather, uncle, teacher, coach, neighbour or family friend. The important thing is that the boy has somebody dependable in his corner.

Mortenson has spoken about taking this evidence to higher education institutions and being met, time and again, with silence. At 80, he is still looking for the ideas that might finally turn the numbers around. Fifteen years after he first began assembling the evidence, that's a sobering position to be in. Boys are still falling behind, men are still dying in disproportionate numbers, and the people and institutions with the power to make a difference have been far too slow to take notice. How many more years, and how many more lost lives, should it take before we intervene appropriately?

The organisation welcomes volunteers and supporters. You can find its work, research and opportunities to get involved at boysinitiative.org. Its volunteer contact details include [email protected] and 301-743-6094.

If you care about boys’ education, mentoring, mental health and the future of young men, this is an organisation worth knowing about. Give its work a look, share its research and consider supporting it. A few hours of somebody’s time can make a meaningful difference to a boy who needs a little encouragement.

Give Men and Boys a Voice at the United Nations

One way to help achieve this is by supporting the call for a dedicated United Nations Commission on the Status of Men and Boys. Such a commission could give international attention to issues including men’s mental health, male suicide, boys’ education, fatherhood, homelessness, workplace deaths, domestic violence against men, and equality under the law.

There is already a petition calling for the establishment of a United Nations Men’s Rights Commission. I encourage readers to consider signing and sharing it.

Add your voice. Sign the petition and help call for greater international recognition of the issues affecting men and boys.

Sign the petition for a United Nations Men’s Rights Commission

All our brothers belong

I want to get this right when we talk about men and brotherhood. 

I mean all men.

Our Black brothers, Latino brothers, Asian brothers, Indigenous brothers and men from immigrant communities. Our transgender brothers, gay and bisexual brothers, disabled brothers, working-class brothers, veterans, young men, older men, fathers, sons and men who are still finding their feet. Every one of them belongs in this conversation.

Men’s experiences are not all the same. A Black father raising his children in America will have a very different set of challenges from a young transgender man finding his place in the world, or an older immigrant man trying to build a life in a new country. We should be interested in those experiences, hear those voices and make sure that the support available to men actually reaches the communities that need it.

Trans men experiences, relationships, families and contributions are part of the story of men. They deserve to be recognised and celebrated alongside their brothers. 

Likewise, we should be making sure that the experiences of men of colour are not overlooked when discussing men’s health, education, employment and opportunity. There is enormous diversity among men, and any genuine commitment to men’s wellbeing must recognise it.

Brotherhood isn’t about everybody having the same background, the same politics or the same life story. It’s about belonging, mutual respect and knowing that there are people who have your back. 

There’s room for all of us.

We have become so accustomed to discussing men in terms of problems, statistics and social debates that we have forgotten to talk about how much we actually like them.

Where are the celebrations of fathers? The men who work hard, love their children and make sacrifices that their families may not even fully understand until years later? Where are the stories about the blokes who quietly support their communities, coach local teams, volunteer, care for elderly relatives and help their neighbours? What about the men who are wonderful husbands, loyal friends, patient teachers, brilliant colleagues, generous brothers and loving sons?

There are billions of them. They don’t need a medal for every decent thing they do, although I’m sure a few wouldn’t mind one. They do deserve to know that their contributions are seen and appreciated.

I think about the men who do physically demanding jobs, the ones who leave home before sunrise and come back covered in dust, grease, mud or whatever else the working day has thrown at them. I think about the men who spend their careers serving others, often in dangerous or stressful conditions. I think about fathers who have worked multiple jobs to give their children a better start, and men who have stepped into father figures’ shoes when a child needed someone dependable.

I think about the older men who have spent decades building businesses, raising families, serving their communities and accumulating the sort of practical wisdom that cannot be learned from a YouTube tutorial. I think about the young men with enormous potential who need opportunity and encouragement. And I think about the men whose contributions are less visible, whose lives haven’t followed the conventional script, but who are every bit as deserving of friendship, affection and respect.

We should be making sure that the men who are struggling receive the same recognition and care. A man’s worth is not measured by his salary, his job title, his physical strength or how much he can provide and sacrifice for other people. A man who has lost his job is still a valuable human being. A man who is ill is still deserving of respect. A man who is alienated is not somehow less of a man. A father who needs help is not a failure. A man who hasn’t figured everything out is not a lost cause.

A man has intrinsic value. 

We need to stop confusing a man’s ability to carry responsibility with an absence of needs of his own. The men deserve to be looked after, too.

That doesn’t mean giving them another list of things to improve about themselves. It means giving them support, opportunity, friendship, recognition and the kindness they have so often extended to others. 

Perhaps the best place to start is with the men we already know.

Call your dad. Take your brother for a beer or a coffee. Send your old mate a message. Invite the bloke who has been a bit quiet lately to join you for something. Spend time with your son. Tell your grandfather you appreciate him. If you know a young man who could benefit from a mentor, introduce yourself and take an interest in his future.

Don’t assume that because a man has a job, a family, a decent house and a functioning lawnmower, everything in his life must be wonderful. We all know men who are brilliant at making sure everybody else is alright while keeping their own difficulties firmly out of sight.

Make time for them. Listen to them. Let them know that they are appreciated.

If a friend is going through a difficult period, stay in touch. If a man is experiencing mental health problems, help him find the tools and support he needs. If an older man is becoming isolated, bring him into the fold. And if you’re in a position to help boys and young men through education, mentoring or community work, consider getting involved with organisations such as The Boys Initiative.

None of this needs to be complicated. Much of it is just friendship, family and community doing what they are supposed to do.

We should be a little more generous with the words we use. Men enjoy being told they’re appreciated, even if some of them respond to a compliment with an awkward cough and a sudden fascination with the contents of their pint glass. Tell your dad he’s a good father. Tell your brother he’s a good man. Tell your mate you’re glad he’s in your life. 

We spend an awful lot of time telling men we need something from them. Let’s get a little better at telling them how important they are simply because they’re here.

To the fathers, sons, brothers, grandfathers, husbands, partners, mates and men from every walk of life: 

I see you. I appreciate you. I am grateful for you. I want you around and happy for the longest time. 

I love you dearly. 


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 2d ago

discussion International Men's Day is not enough...

Thumbnail gallery
97 Upvotes

r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 2d ago

legal rights The uncomfortable truth about rape trials: Barristers are prevented from making a full defence

65 Upvotes

r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 2d ago

discussion How feminism has hurt men...

Thumbnail
reddit.com
96 Upvotes

"Accountability is one of the foundational cornerstones of feminism, and yet, when confronted with the nefarious acts or bigoted words of certain feminists, or feminist groups, these battle-hardened beliefs of personal responsibility often fall at the wayside.

“They’re not true feminists!” is the typical retort.

As the bitter pills of accountability, so often prescribed by feminist voices, are unceremoniously spat out when given to oneself.

Accountability for thee, and not for me, it seems.

And so, I have compiled an abridged list of unoffered apologies, that many of the world’s most iconic, and well known feminists duly owe men.

Things like –

Erasing men within domestic violence policy.

Or considering men who are raped by women to be “ambivalent” of their sexual desires.

For tracking down and shaming unenlisted men and boys during World War One, and publicly humiliating them into going to the war front.

Apologies for stating they want to “k*ll all men”

Or wishing that a virus that decimated male lives at unprecedented rates, was just “not killing men fast enough”

Perhaps an apology could be offered, for platforming a woman who helped torture and murder a gay man, when she was given a headline spot at the Million Women’s March?

What about those who spent their lives blocking shared custody laws, and fathers rights, or those who opposed gender neutral rape laws, or called services for male SA survivors a “frivolous” waste of money?

Yes, apologies are owed, from many of the biggest names around, and are long overdue.

The question is, will they ever be given?

What do you think?"


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 2d ago

media & cultural analysis Feminists don't actually hate femininity, they use it as a carrot and stick to dangle in front of men

53 Upvotes

As stated in the title, contrary to popular belief, feminists don't hate femininity, they use it as a carrot and stick to dangle in front of men. They love femininity, in fact they agree with anti-feminists that men are the protectors and and that women shouldn't need to do the protecting. Feminists shame men who don't automatically protect women, or they say, "What do women need protection from? Other men!" They also say this as a gotcha when a man says he doesn't benefit from the system, saying "Who set that system up? Other men!" This is clear as day misandry, and it's not new either, since feminists have used femininity to shame men, saying they are superior to men because they are divinely ordained by God to make humans and men are useless, only wanting sex, as stated in Charlotte Perkins Gilman's infamous December 10, 1916 article, "What is Feminism?"

This mentality is also evident in Breaking Down Patriarchy's video about the Cornell 7 case: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YEGFKPruzCQ

These are the same people who say women have a "natural maternal instinct" while defending Lindsay Clancy. I want to know your thoughts on all this, especially from women, because men tend to see masculinity as the social construct it is while woman tend to see femininity as biological, i.e. feminine rage/feminine urge.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 2d ago

social issues Double standard between women hating dresses and men hating suits.

83 Upvotes

For starters, I hate wearing suits. Suits make me feel so uncomfortable. My family were always nagging me to wear a suit. And they don't care about how uncomfortable it makes me feel.

It's so ironic that we live in a society where it's normalized for women to hate dresses, to the point it can be some type of feminist empowerment. But yet the samw society also says that men look better in suits though. The phrase "I love a man in a suit" is so popular, even in progessive women spaces.

That just shows how it's more acceptable for women to step outside their gender roles in society. And the thing is people will be more judgmental of men who don't wear suits too. Because in society men in suits are associated with status and respect. And it would be considered misogynistic to ever associate a woman value with a dress.

A man who hates suits can be viewed as unprofessional, immature, underdressed, or lacking ambition. Even outside the workplace, people frequently associate suits with masculinity, maturity, success, and respectability.

The romantic double standard: "I love a man in a suit" is socially acceptable, including in progressive spaces. However, imagine men routinely saying that women look more respectable, valuable, or attractive in dresses. That could quickly be interpreted as reinforcing traditional gender roles.

Again this double standard is a part of a bigger picture. Where society refuses to let men step outside their gender roles.

Women rejecting traditional femininity is often framed as empowerment, while men rejecting traditional masculinity can still be viewed as a deficiency.

Society has become more accepting of women stepping outside traditional femininity, but traditional masculine expectations remain remarkably persistent. Men are still expected to demonstrate status, authority, strength, financial success, and professionalism through their appearance and behavior.

There's nothing inherently wrong with someone loving a man in a suit or a woman loving dresses. The problem is when personal preferences become social expectations, and men are judged negatively for refusing to conform.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 3d ago

social issues Unattractive men are no more dangerous than attractive men, but they're often treated as if they are.

220 Upvotes

I've been thinking about this for a while, and I feel like it's something people don't really want to acknowledge.

Unattractive men are often perceived as creepy, intimidating, suspicious or even potentially dangerous simply because of how they look. And I don't think people realise just how much physical attractiveness influences the way they interpret a man's behaviour.

Think about it. An unattractive guy making eye contact might be seen as creepy. Approaching a woman might be interpreted as having ulterior motives. Being quiet or socially awkward might make him seem unsettling.

But when an attractive guy does the exact same things, suddenly he's confident, mysterious, charming or just a little awkward.

I know women will often point out that attractive men can be creepy too. And obviously, they're right. Attractive men can be predators, creeps and genuinely dangerous people. I'm not arguing otherwise.

But I feel like that misses the actual point.

Women might insist that it's not about looks and that creepiness is about behaviour, but honestly, my experience of watching how women react to different men suggests otherwise.

I've seen the same actions receive completely different reactions depending on how attractive the man is. What gets interpreted as harmless or even flattering from an attractive guy can be seen as threatening or suspicious when it comes from an unattractive one.

And that's the distinction I wish people would acknowledge.

An attractive man can certainly be creepy, but generally, his behaviour has to give people a reason to see him that way. An unattractive man, on the other hand, can sometimes be viewed with suspicion before he's even opened his mouth.

It's almost as if attractive men are judged by what they do, while unattractive men are judged by what people assume about them.

And to be clear, I'm not saying women should ignore their instincts or feel obligated to give anyone attention. Nobody owes anyone attraction, affection or interaction. Personal safety and boundaries are important.

But being unattractive doesn't make someone more dangerous. It doesn't make someone more likely to be a predator, a creep or a bad person.

Unattractive men are no more dangerous than attractive men, but they often have to overcome a level of suspicion that attractive men don't face in the first place.

I just wish people were a little more honest about how much looks influence their perceptions of others.

Has anyone else noticed this, or am I the only one who thinks there's a pretty obvious double standard here?


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 3d ago

article The Battered Husband Syndrome

Thumbnail papa-help.ch
65 Upvotes

This is a foundational academic article from 1977-78 that challenged the widespread idea in academia and the public that intimate partner violence was exclusively male-to-female. It also argues for gender symmetry in intimate partner violence.

The abstract of the article reads:

"This article examines the phenomenon of husband battering utilizing some historical data, comic strips as a reflection of popular values and the data derived from several empirical studies. Husband abuse is not uncommon, although many tend to ignore it, dismiss it or treat it with "selective inattention." The reasons why men do not report their victimization and why they stay in an abusive situation are examined in depth. Some of the myths commonly held about men's place in the family, their attachment to their offspring and their ability to easily move in and out of relationships are exploded. The article ends with a plea for a more comprehensive approach to study and treat family violence seeing it not as an isolated phenomenon but as another manifestation of a basically violent society."


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 3d ago

discussion Sexism against men meets the definition of prejudice plus power

48 Upvotes

There are some people who believe that for a form of prejudice to be an “ism”, so to speak, it must also be accompanied by social, institutional, or political power. For example, they believe you can’t be racist against white people (in the United States), you can’t be ableist against people without disabilities, and so on.

Very often, these same people try to extend this to sexism, saying you can only be sexist against women, or against women and non-binary people. However, this is not only demonstrably false, but goes against their own prejudice plus power definition without them realizing it, because men face institutional, societal, cultural, legal, social, systemic, systematic, economic, and judicial discrimination and oppression in a large number of ways. 

It also is based on a simplistic, black-and-white view of sexism, where it’s all one-way. It’s entirely possible for different groups of people to have a mixture of privileges and disadvantages.

For example, older people are marginalized in some ways, but also enjoy privileges in other ways. Older people also have disproportionate representation in government and institutions, and disproportionate economic wealth and power. You could say most countries are “gerontocracies” or “geriarchies.” At the same time, western societies are often argued to be overall youth-centric.

At the same time, younger people are marginalized in some ways, and enjoy some privileges.

I think few people would argue that prejudice, discrimination, marginalization, and privilege based on age is all one-way.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 4d ago

discussion Healthy Masculinty, is it a good approach?

48 Upvotes

With International Men's Day coming up I see a lot of workshops and presentations about healthy masculinity. About getting people together to talk about healthy masculinity.

I was wondering what peoples thoughts on this approach are? I personally see it as the same deficit model that toxic masculinity is. Just rebranded with a positive adjective.

It places masculinity into a approved model for men and boys to follow. While internalizing there problems within their relationship with masculinty.

It also presuposed that men and boys problem isn't systematic but their inability to ask for help or seek it. Yet I cant find robust studies showing that men aren't seeking help. But instead that men and boys learn that seeking help isn't affected and tend to work out there problems themsleves.

Or will seek help and be realistic about the effectiveness of the help.

I really dislike the term and find it a way to distract from men and boys real issue. While saying we are doing something. But instead of talking about men and boys issues and addressing them. We force a model that internalized the issue within men and boys themsleves. Abdicating societies duty to men and boys.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 4d ago

misandry “Feminine” Men and Women who Hate Them

Thumbnail
youtube.com
111 Upvotes

I want to know your thoughts on this video, because I have some for the comments. One said women hating on “feminine” men isn’t feminism when that has been a feature of feminism since its inception as a movement. Here’s my problem with the comments section: It just repeats the same mantra as the people it criticizes (Not real feminism, patriarchy, MRAs are anti-women, this is only “misogyny” when “femininity” is criticized in men despite the fact that “masculinity” is also criticized in men, etc). Women just despise men in general, regardless of political ideology and regardless of whether they believe men are biologically (traditionalist perspective, men are protectors) or sociologically (modernist perspective, men are protectors) inclined to do anything. We saw this with both MeToo movements in 2006/2016, Amber Heard supporters, and the performative women’s rights march in 2017 against Trump while ignoring that Hilary Clinton called women who voted for him a “basket of deplorables”. They did the same in 2024, insulting women by saying they couldn’t trust their husbands in the voting booth even though women choose men because they share the same values and that includes voting, also women vote more and have more reproductive rights and purchasing rights than men do: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FaCPck2qDhk Here’s an idea: Why don’t we just stop talking about masculinity/femininity as polar opposites or complementing each other, because both camps are wrong, just that one doesn’t hide what it is (these roles are “biological” and everyone should abide by them) and the other is feminism, which is and has always been conservative thinking dressed up as “progressive”. This was also true for the Progressive Era (1890s-1920s) overall, as they pushed maternalism (protective legislation) and smoking for working class women while shunning working men and their men’s rights advocates and temperance, screwing over both sexes in the process. Let’s talk about things innate to humans overall, because this “feminine rage/male tears” and “alpha male/beta male” nonsense helps no one. Here’s an example of a hopeful future feminists could take to heart, especially since they were the ones who brought it about in the first place, from the 70s, “Free to Be... You and Me”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFzMAApcW4U & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_to_Be..._You_and_Me.


r/LeftWingMaleAdvocates • • 4d ago

media & cultural analysis Pride and no prejudice: how Tough Guy Book Club taught 10,000 men to be unashamed of reading

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
64 Upvotes

This whole article is menslib talking points disguised as motivating men to read more books. Although Shay had good intentions setting up a bookclub for men, the article negates that with the usual feminist framing.

Just like how the male loneliness epidemic was co-opted by feminists, the same is happening with discussion about boys and men reading less often than girls and women. Overall, there is a decline in interest in reading books and literacy which was accelerated during and post pandemic. However, much of this can be attributed to how boys are falling behind in educational settings.

This whole article was dominated by this Bateman character, who is a book tok influencer. He fails to provide solutions and doesn't even address the root causes of the lack of interest in reading amongst boys and men. He makes wild claims that men shame other men for reading, when in fact it's feminists who are doing the shaming instead.

Like many feminists, Bateman never addresses the fact that the book industry is female dominated. Female dominated genres are what is promoted the most at bookstores. Male interests for at least a decade has taken the backseat. That's why you will see that most bestsellers are usually romantasy/ dark romance authors. On the other hand, hardcore speculative fiction, non fiction and shonen mangas are still pretty much male dominated.

Many online bookclubs and websites such as goodreads are quite antagonistic towards boys and men. That also aggravated the situation. These communities also tend to police boy's and men's reading preferences and outright shame them if they don't read feminist approved books. It won't surprise me that they might also these places off-putting and also think that reading books is for girls/ women.

It shouldn't matter if you are ghetto, tough, a nerd or a gay man to enjoy books. Books should be for everyone. And this guy completely misses the point.

If you are going to push for female centred genres, then naturally boys and men might find that off putting. Likewise, you would expect the same if male centred genres took the forefront, for it to be off putting towards girls and women.

The other elephant in the room is the lack of male representation in fiction. Most influencers like Bateman either ignore it or they think that the solution is to read books with non binary characters or female centred books. As a standalone concept it isn't an issue, but if the intention is to erase maleness or treat it as a sin, then I find it problematic. Which goes to my previous point about policing what boys and men read.

Male representation should be on equal standing as female representation in contemporary literature. The solution isn't to erase maleness and go tell boys / men to read books written by women. And later on arrogantly tell them that male representation is toxic masculinity or promoting right winged ideology. Theres a reason why male readers gravitate towards: mangas such as Berserk, Attack on Titan, or novels writteh by Camus, Kafka, Dostoevsky and so on. Because these authors write compelling stories with relatable male leads or male readers relate to the authors themselves.

If people really want boys and men to be motivated to read fiction then at least be a part of the solution and give attention to male centred fiction as much as you see female centred fiction (in contemporary literature).

Edit: corrections