My boyfriend and I recently moved out of our old apartment in California, and we're having a little disagreement about how far we should take a security deposit dispute with our former property management.
For context, our security deposit was $1,500. We officially moved out and physically handed over our keys on October 1st. We also provided management with our forwarding address, phone numbers, and emails.
California law (Civil Code §1950.5) requires landlords to return the security deposit or provide an itemized statement of deductions within 21 days of the tenant moving out. That deadline passed on October 22nd.
It's now November 19th, and we haven't received a single dollar. We also haven't received an itemized statement, receipts, or any communication explaining where our deposit is.
When we did our move-out walkthrough, the property manager told us that the apartment looked really good, that there was only normal wear and tear, and that the only thing they anticipated deducting was a small cleaning fee (around $100 or less).
Both my boyfriend and I were present for that conversation. but i unfortunately like an idiot forgot to take a picture of the actual paper itself. 🥲 (the wear and tear walkthrough)
I sent management a written message today explaining that the 21-day deadline had passed and requesting the return of our full $1,500. I gave them until November 27th to resolve the issue before we pursue small claims court.
Here's where my boyfriend and I disagree:
Under California law, tenants can potentially recover their original security deposit PLUS up to twice the deposit in additional statutory damages if the landlord acted in bad faith.
That would make our potential claim $4,500 total.
My boyfriend feels like we should just get back what we're owed and leave it at that. He doesn't really want to pursue additional money or feel like we're trying to make money off the situation.
I see it differently. I'm not trying to make money off anybody. I'm frustrated because we gave them our money, followed the move-out process, provided everything they needed, and they still haven't returned a squat in almost two months.
If the law provides additional damages for bad-faith withholding, why shouldn't we consider pursuing them?
I understand that the additional $3,000 isn't automatic and that a judge would have to determine whether bad faith occurred.
So, from an outside perspective:
Would you pursue the full $4,500 or just try to recover the original $1,500?
I'm genuinely interested in hearing both sides. Are we being unreasonable, or is this a situation where holding management accountable is justified?