So in light of the recent "G3 phone of the year" claims making headlines, i decided i wanted to make this post in the G3 forums only, to give insight on people who were in a similar boat as me.
THIS IS NOT A POSITIVE REVIEW. Just a disclosure. The G3 is a great phone, BUT WHEN COMPARING to the note 4 it wont be entirely positive. Im just warning people right now about that because ive actually owned both. This is for people who are THINKING ABOUT SWITCHING or SELLING. If you love our phone there is no need to read this.
So i bought my G3 almost 2 months ago. I sold it 3 weeks ago and have a note 4 ever since. Here is my honest to god review
Display: -Even at first sight the G3 is obviously not significantly better or worse than the top flagships. The G3's display is huge and that's great compared to certain models, but it's the only thing i'd say that makes the display uniquely or better relative to other flagships. The display just feems dimmer than others, especially the note 4. If you compare side by side, sometimes you cant notice it. In fact, some colors are better on the G3. The white maximum brightness (i.e. reddit) is amazingly bright compared to the note 4. Thats about it though. This isnt really fair as the Note 4 is hands down the best display on the market. Everytime i open it i can feel thats its one of if not the best display whereas i rarely got that feeling with the G3. End of story. How significant the disparity is obviously subjective. Ill say that i think it's around the third best after the iphone and note 4.
Note 4 - 9.8
G3 - 8
UI - If your using NOVA or other launchers, both are near washes The G3 just feels way more customizable in general with stock though. I guess the best analogy with the Note 4 UI Touchwiz is that it just feels like ur meant to use it do to how integrated and fleshed out it is. Some people will feel trapped, some people will like it. Overall i think the UI is slightly edged for the G3 but in the end this is just preference.
Battery: Note 4 is just universally better. G3 has a ridiculous standby time but when it actually matters (like web browsing) it drops in real time. There is about a 1 hour half difference in SoT for me. (4 vs 5:30)
Note 4 - 9.5 G3 - 7.5
Fit/Feel/Look: This is really what does this in for me. Again, a lot of this is subjective. IF YOU WERE LOOKING FOR A PHABLET SCREEN GO WITH THE NOTE 4. Regardless of how much smaller the G3 is and how much easier it is for one handed use etc. if you like phablets, the Note 4 is superior. The fit in the hand just feels much more premium and it doesnt look like a PSP gaming device. In addition, due to the extra size, it accomodates use of both hands without feeling like your fingers have no wiggle room/being clustered. Its hard to explain. Both are nearly identical in screen size, but the Note 4 feels so much better with 2 hands than the G3 ever did, at least for me (aerage man hands). Think about if you really want a one hand experience or if it was just a bonus to a 5.5 screen. even if it was, one handed use isnt perfectly functional or great on the G3. Its like in the middle where 2 hands isnt nearly as great as the Note and one hand isnt perfect. BONUS: If you dig flip cases, the S-VIEW blows the quick circle out o the water x10. Just feel it once. The Note 4 just feels like a phone bros (again if you're specifically tryng to avoid a phablet, the G3 is better hence the reason its still a 7.8)
G3 - 7.8 Note 4 - 9.8
Lag/Heat: Note 4 is like 30 percent less heat. Note 4 has no noticeable lag aftr one month in standard browsing etc. I would say the G3 has 20 percent more. IF YOUR USING NOVA the G3 only lags SLIGHTLY more than the Note, but it still has a huge problem where under 80 percent+ brightness it will throttle its fps to like 50 (from 60) and you will feel it. If you use Nova and under 80 percent brightness, it should be a similar experience to a Note 4 in many regards minus gaming.
-Note 4 - 8.5 G3 - 7.1
But the Price!: This is the reason why, i believe, many of you (including me a month ago) as well as the review site justify the G3 > the Note 4. The price disparity in Canada is 800 vs 600. Is it worth 200 dollars more? If you were looking for a phablet from the beggining it definitely is relative to how much phones are used. Still ,it's a harderish decision. The reason why the price arguement doesnt work for me is simply resale value. The Note 1-3 have depreciated the least of ANY flagship phone historically. I dont know why, but go on craigslist right now and compare Note 3 prices to G3 prices. There is only like a 100 dollar difference which is crazy since the Note 4 is already out. Regardless, you'll still lose money and if you damage your phone you can't resell so its a risk.
Either way though, in conclusion i dont regret my time with the G3 at all. What ultimately lead for it being bad for me was --> I wanted a phablet but the small size of the phone was just a plus (should be the other way around if you want the G3 vs Note 4) -------> My hands were not small enough for good 1 handed function and too big for the G3 to be as good as the Note 4 in terms of 2 hand ---------> THE FIT/BUILD/FEEL of the Note 4 is like a phone, it's premium and it doesnt look like one big ass screen (SUBJECTIVE) ------> LAG due to me being on higher brightnesses and auto throttling -------------> Display blows my mind every time.
Again, the G3 is third for me (albeit theres a lot in that 3rd category). Its definitely a good phone if u match what it offers etc.