Hear me out: It's one of the most touching works of art I've ever encountered on the subject of grief. I was always fascinated by the lyric's meaning and searched for years.
I know literal interpretations of his work and ascribing direct meaning is usually pointless, it's intentionally vague and open, but here it's just too deeply personal for me.
But I kept seeing "it's about the death of his psychiatrist, Dr. Kramer". Sure, the album is dedicated to him and the dates line up but the correlation never sat right with me.
I wish that we could talk about it
You mean consulting his therapist about the death of... his own therapist?
Then I learned that that interpretation was never really confirmed, when asked about someone great, Murphy says: “I just think it’s unnecessary because it’s personal. Songs are songs and to reduce them is to waste them.”
So my theory is:
The "someone" in "someone great" is his premature/still-born child, a baby that didn't make it and the rift it caused with his partner.
You're smaller than my wife imagined,
Surprised you were human.
Verse 1: he's speaking to his partner, his inability to comfort her after a premature childbirth/miscarriage, how they've changed. It's probably her/their basement since what kind of psychiatrist "argues" and who's office has no sunlight or windows?
Verse 2: the day he got the news
The way you were breathing refers to his baby, his condition is why he expected the worst, while the call, the voice on the other end, is from the hospital staff or his partner.
Verse 3: being in shock, not dealing with the loss and using work to escape
The bridge: it keeps coming is the recurring stabbing realization of grief
Verse 4: Once again, speaking to his partner about this rift and loss, the radio silence could be a heart monitor but probably the lack of communication between them.
Finally: we're safe for the moment, saved for the moment
Who's we? Him and his therapist?
No, it's him and his partner, surviving and dealing with the loss.
Someone great is his child and all these potential hopes and dreams.
Any thoughts?
EDIT:
Ryan Leas wrote in Dazed (13 July 2016):
“…always made me think it was about a miscarriage, or losing a child, or having to give away a child. Either way, it’s heartbreaking.”