Hello! Self-proclaimed âelitistâ here.
My unpopular opinion is that itâs in our hobbyâs best interest to raise the bar towards higher-quality and more coherent costumes and that the fear of gate-keeping is mostly a myth that negatively impacts the diversity of the player base.
Let me preface this by saying that higher-quality â more expensive. I would also add that i consider âbuffer battle gamesâ as something else and I would rather focus on the immersive RP aspect.
My opinion, based on anecdotal evidence, is that low-effort costumes reinforce the common belief that LARP is, and has to be, a cringe fest of âsmelly unwashed nerdsâ who want to defeat imaginary dragons in the woods.
On the opposite, I see more and more players from diverse background with the accessibility of high-end costumes. Itâs becoming more about the unrehearsed/improv scenes, âpremiumâ camping , reenactment with less rigidity, HEMA/combat sports with a twist (weapons becoming more and more realistic) rather than âD&d but irlâ.
The argument that high-quality costumes = expensive, barrier entry, etc. is frankly regurgitated bullshit. You can build a base layer peasant for under $100 (honestly even under $20 through thrifting). The issue is unrealistic expectations people have that LARP = everyone and their dog has to be a bad ass lead character hero of the story saviour of worlds. No, you canât be a credible fully-armoured dragon-slaying knight for $100, $200, or $500 even. Thatâs life. You really want to play the part? Save up. Plan towards that goal, both in and out of game. Learn to maintain your gear, exercise, educate yourself on what it meant to be a knight. Your character will develop more depth and you will be proud of your journey.
Yes, I know some hobbyists choose LARP specifically to evade reality for a couple days and therefore donât want,or have time, to do all that. Thatâs fair, but donât come wearing a plastic maille shirt because the real thing is too heavy or too expensive (plus itâs really not).
I will be going off on a bit of a tangent here, but it has to be said. F*ck the over-usage of leather in LARP costuming. Why are we all hyped over something that is MORE expensive, LESS comfortable, heavier and ahistorical compared to natural textiles (cotton, linen, wool) or metal? It genuinely makes no sense if we look beyond fantasy media.
Here are my parting thoughts:
I encourage new players to start slow and to be modest with the goal of building from the ground-up rather than have unrealistic expectations or very specific plans right away. A quality linen/cotton pants and tunic combo (highly encourage thrifting) will allow you to be a blank canvas on which to develop your identity and figure out what you like and dislike. Donât be shy to borrow stuff. You canât be the central piece of a story as a new player and the best roles arenât reserved to the epic and very serious âparty of heroesâ anyway.
Setting the bar high and being proud of our hobby isnât elitism nor is it detrimental. Itâs about accountability, realistic expectations and a desire for better immersive events that will attract new crowds of players blinded by the stigma surrounding LARP.