r/KotakuInAction • • Feb 07 '15

META I'm a moderator at /r/GamerGhazi. AMA.

0 Upvotes

As announced here.

Only two rules are the following:

  • I will not answer questions which I feel would lead to disclosure of excessive information on my personal life. Asking what's my favorite color is OK, asking where I live isn't.

  • If you insult me (by which I mean general name-calling), I will respond to you with chillout music.

Otherwise, feel free to ask whatever you want.

EDIT: Due to the large volume of questions, I might take a while to answer. Please be patient!

EDIT2: OK guys, it's been 4 hours already and I'm tired. I think I'm done here. If you'd like me to answer your question in specific, please PM me the link to the comment and I'll get to it tomorrow. Thanks to all.


r/KotakuInAction • • Nov 25 '24

No, Arcane is NOT a good show.

28 Upvotes

Tired of this show being pushed around like it is the greatest animation ever. They did the same with the Spiderman movie, which was also bad. Not only do I hate the artstyle, I hate that it has nothing to do with League of Legends. And most of all, I hate the dyed hair politics that infest it. Imagine being a kid who plays League, then trying to watching this show. I'm pretty sure they are wondering wtf is going on, too.

I have a major bone to pick with this IP cause I was there during beta and played all the way to 2019 before the game just got too tiresome in many ways. Not only due to Tencent fully changing the game into a skinnerbox skin game with rigged matches like a casino to retain engagement through psychological manipulation, removing old characters despite players already purchasing them (or reworking them), and a bunch of other small things...

But then the wrong people invaded Riot and changed it into a game that not only doesn't appeal to me as a target audience, but shifted the identity of it entirely to people who don't even play pc games, at least seriously. And thus, this show was born. Full of melodrama that appeals only to a specific group of people that do not understand what made the game what it is, and Riot encouraging it with their rampant infestation of the political correct virus and lgbt moniker.

And to prove that this show is nothing but an non genuine cultural phenomenon, the only clips and discussion I hear about it is around emotional and lesbian drama. And the finale being praised cause two women finally start carpet munching on screen. Even though I do not touch this game anymore, I expected a show about League of Legends to be far more...fun and entertaining. More in-universe characters, more adventures, spreading out the cast to multiple settings and characters like other animated shows. But for some reason, the writers just once again -- a prevalent phenomenon in the media industry -- use the ip to tell what they WANT to to tell while just ignoring most to all of the IP lore. We seen this constantly across the industry and Arcane is currently one of the worst aspects of it.

And what bothers me the most is that I do not see a lot of criticism against this show as others, just because the artstyle looks unique. The same thing happened with the Spiderman animation movie with Miles, and it seems almost NPC like to just be amused by the visuals and suddenly forgetting what they did to the ip as a whole.

And no, I and others who think like me are not crazy. Arcane is another problem in our modern culture.

EDIT:

See how strange the praise of the show is in the comments (though I can tell some of you are simply showing sarcasm, which I applaud). I've never seen such a spell like it take over people. Obviously, there's some tourists here who will shill their cult show no matter what. In addition, how the users who say it is a good show also claim they don't play the game -- proving the point.


r/KotakuInAction • • Nov 16 '14

False Youtube-Musician Jonathan Mann made songs making fun of Gamergate. Lost a third of his abonnements, half of his Patreon, videos now all 50% negative ratings. Now makes a backpedalling song: "Hey I just made a joke, we have to work together" - Gets panned in the comments.

Thumbnail
archive.today
0 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • Aug 04 '23

What happened with Baldur's Gate 3 ?

0 Upvotes

I did not play the early access, I just downloaded the game yesterday.

So... I go to create my character and wtf ?

Can't choose the gender but I can choose the pronous ? What ? Larian Studios has fallen too ?

I remember the two first Baldur's Gate said to us there are no differences if you play a man or a woman (not like Fallout or Arcanum lol) but still... ?


r/KotakuInAction • • Jan 21 '19

SOCJUS [socjus] Streamer Hbomberguy Raises Over $230,000 for Trans Charity to spite Graham Linehan

42 Upvotes

http://archive.is/2xswK

A trans charity was supposed to get a bunch of money from the national lottery in the UK. This was successfully blocked by a campaign led by former IT Crowd and Father Ted writer (as well as occasional KiA punching bag, feel free to search the sub) Graham Linehan. This led Leftist youtuber Hbomberguy to announce a Donkey Kong 64 100 percent charity stream. It’s blowing up and people like Cher and Neil Gaiman have donated.

He’s over 50 hours in, and is breaking down. It’s a fun watch.

https://www.twitch.tv/hbomberguy

Here’s a description of the charity, Mermaids UK:

Mermaids UK is a group that aims to raise awareness of gender nonconformity and gender dysphoria in children and young people. The group lobbies for improvements in professional services for transgendered children and has won numerous awards over the years for their work, including the European Diversity Awards Charity of the Year 2016 and the British LGBT Awards 2018 for Outstanding Contribution to LGBT+ Life for Mermaids CEO, Susie Green.


r/KotakuInAction • • May 30 '15

META [META] Updates to moderation policy, flairs and self-posts

0 Upvotes

Hello all,

A few weeks ago, we asked for community input regarding the increasing numbers of Off-Topic posts in KiA, and what we should do about them. We've heard many opinions on the matter and if one thing is clear, it's that the community is considerably divided on the issue. That's hardly unexpected for GamerGate, but I will stress that as mods, our priority is catering for the whole community, not just the loudest subunit.

KiA as a subreddit was founded for discussion of issues surrounding ethics in games journalism. This, of course, evolved over time, as the sub quickly became the hub for GamerGate activities on Reddit. We eventually added the tagging system to help people better identify and filter content. However, that system isn't a free pass for people to post absolutely anything. Since off-topic posts are often tangentially related to GamerGate to varying degrees, this became very difficult to moderate.

From the earliest days, KiA's policy has been this: "If it's related to gaming, or directly mentions GamerGate, it's fair game." The introduction of the Off-Topic flair was meant to aid this, as it would still cover topics that were of interest to GamerGate, but weren't directly related to gaming. However, this has led to KiA gaining a reputation more as an anti-SJW sub instead of Reddit's GamerGate hub. We can't deny that most of the community is vehemently opposed to SJW ideology, but it was never the intention of KiA to prioritize opposition to SJWs.

One thing that is clear is that there is a need for a space to discuss the influence of SJWs outside of gaming. While this is not KiA's mission, KiA is the only sub that can really fill that role at the moment. However, there are many outside of GamerGate that feel this is important, too. As such, alongside /r/TumblrInAction, we're going to see if we can launch another subreddit, /r/SocialJusticeInAction, for more serious anti-SJW content. If this new sub does well we may come back to the issue of SJW content in KiA at a later time, but for now we're looking to encourage crossposting to satisfy both subreddits.

Let's clarify something first: The changes below will make very little difference towards what content is removed. The intention is to more clearly define where the boundaries for content types lie.

Now this is the only major change we're making to the sub, effective immediately:

POSTS THAT ARE LIMITED TO TEXT-POSTS ONLY

  • Posts with the OFF-TOPIC and SOCJUS tags must be text posts, only.

  • Link to the main content within the post.

  • Explain why it's of interest to GamerGate and/or KiA.

Submitted content still needs to have a tangible relevance to GamerGate, but it'll allow for OPs to better make the case for why their post deserves our attention, and to keep content that's relevant, if off-topic, such as Protein World, Joss Whedon, ShirtStorm, etc. Anyway, here is a summary of what kinds of content belongs here and what doesn't:

ETHICAL ISSUES IN GAMES JOURNALISM

  • Submitted under the ETHICS tag.

  • Includes evidence of ethics violations and agenda-pushing in games media.

  • Examples: GameJournoPros, Undisclosed affiliations.

GAMERGATE IN POPULAR CULTURE

  • Drama over GamerGate, public figures' opinions on the subject, etc.

  • Belongs in the relevant tags such as DRAMA, PEOPLE, etc.

  • The one exception being Ghazi posts, which go to /r/shitghazisays, as their goal is to distract our attention.

  • Examples: Media smearing, TotalBiscuit's posts.

WIDER ISSUES IN GAMING

  • Can be posted under the INDUSTRY tag, provided it's of significant interest (try /r/neogaming for general chat about games).

  • Examples: Steam mods controversy. Unethical practices by developers.

ETHICAL ISSUES IN WIDER JOURNALISM

  • Can be submitted as OFF-TOPIC, particularly if it's a related publication, such as Gawker or The Guardian.

  • Needs to be of interest to GamerGate. "Journalist lies about a shovel in this month's Gardener's World" is not the sort of thing we want to see.

  • Examples: Newspapers lying to further a political narrative, journalists taking money for positive film reviews.

SJWs IN GAMING CULTURE

  • Stays in KiA under relevant tags such as CENSORSHIP.

  • Examples: Censoring GTA. Declaring gamers to be misogynists.

SJWs IN WIDER NERD CULTURE

  • Stays in KiA under the SOCJUS tag.

  • Major controversies may be rolled into megathreads if the need arises.

  • Can also be crossposted to /r/SocialJusticeInAction

  • Examples: Shirtstorm, comics, Sad Puppies.

COMPLETELY UNRELATED SJW SHENANIGANS

  • Until now have been removed or downvoted to oblivion.

  • Will now be redirected to /r/SocialJusticeInAction

  • Examples: "Video - Feminist punches someone", "Why SJWs are evil", "Political party has SJW policies"

SPAM

  • Gets removed.

Our hope is that this strategy from here on out will keep KiA strong while developing a sub on the side for all people that wish to run a broader 'culture war', rather than just those in GamerGate. Since there's a lot more people and content on the wider front against SJWs, this will allow us to maintain a focus on content at least tangentially related to GamerGate over here in KiA while growing both subs at the same time. Consider it as our answer to /gamergatehq/'s Rule 10.

Also, just as a casual reminder: TAG YOUR POSTS. Just make sure it includes the tag you want in the title (e.g., [Ethics], [Off-Topic], etc.), and ONLY that tag, and Automod will take care of the rest. Oh, and make sure your tags are spelled correctly, too. This helps KiA's tagging system to work to maximum efficiency.

We've made a few minor changes to the tagging system to reduce overlap between tags, and we're also introducing the [Summary] and [Bias] tags. Full descriptions of each are now available on the rules page.


FAQ:

What is /r/SocialJusticeInAction?

A subreddit with minimal moderation intended for more serious news and discussion about the broader culture war against SJW ideology. Consider it like /r/TumblrInAction, but serious. For example, you can post YouTube videos and political content, and nothing will be under a moratorium—things you can't normally do in TiA.

But isn't this censorship?

Censorship would be to deny conversation on a specific topic. We're making a dedicated space for content we've noticed is getting heavily downvoted or removed from here anyway. There is quite clearly a need for it which KiA does not properly fulfill.

Divide and conquer?

People assume this is somehow an effort to divide the community, whereas in reality it's more of an effort to split the content. People can be subscribed to both subreddits quite happily if they want GamerGate as well as wider anti-SJW news on their feeds. We're still going to be looking out for better ethics in gaming after all.

But lots of people want generic SJW content.

When asked to define GamerGate, everyone can agree that ethics in games journalism is central. Our sub and mission statement reflects that. SOCJUS content is still off-topic, but we recognize that there is no better place for it right now. Content being popular with a specific subpopulation of those in GamerGate doesn't mean that it truly belongs here.

I disagree with this, resign now.

Not today.

This is proof that Reddit admins are taking control over KiA and the site is lost to Chairman Pao and there are no heroes left in man.

Literally the last time we heard from the admins was during the Modtalk Leaks. This has nothing to do with them or with Reddit's new "safe space" bullshit.

We quite clearly can't please everyone, so our solution here is to make something that fulfils the needs of as many people as possible. Under this new system, content that was previously being removed now has a proper space and can be discussed as you see fit.


So this is how things are going to work. We'll run with this for a while and see how it works out.

Thanks for reading.


tl;dr: We're going to redirect some content that usually gets removed anyway to /r/SocialJusticeInAction. Also, posts tagged with OFF-TOPIC and SOCJUS need to be text-posts, now, so OPs can explain why they're relevant and the community can up/downvote it how they see fit. We've also added a few new category tags.


r/KotakuInAction • • Mar 17 '15

This is KotakuInAction, not DCInAction. Focus on videogames not the Joker/Batgirl issue.

30 Upvotes

There are currently 10 topics on the issue on the hot page of KotakuInAction. This is ridiculous. We are about videogames ethics and problems yet all I see lately is sjw drama and now the problem with this comic cover varient. We need to focus on why we are here, otherwise we might as well become TumblrInAction and just make fun of all sjw overreactions with no results for change. Video games.


r/KotakuInAction • • Nov 20 '15

KiA Mod PSA [KiA MODS] Proposed KiA Rule & Guideline Changes

11 Upvotes

LOOKING FOR FEEDBACK AND CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICISM!

Hello fellow shitlords,

Over the past few weeks the mod team has been working toward a consensus on a few changes and clarifications with regards to our subreddit rules, flairs, and mod practices. We believe we’re ready to present them to you so that we can request and address any feedback you may have and make any necessary modifications before those changes go live.

A couple of months back the mod team (under the guidance of IAmSupernova) drafted and implemented an updated mission statement which attempted to capture the ethos of KiA and bring some clarity to the purpose of the subreddit as a whole.

In order to help improve consistency within the mod team when it comes to removals and what we consider off-topic, we would now like to align our rules and flairs to better match that mission statement, our ethos, and address how KotakuInAction has grown over the past year.

These changes should help users and mods come to a common understanding of the rules and the when, how, and why of off-topic moderation. We aren’t going to make everyone happy, but we believe this is a step in the right direction.

 

Without further ado, I’d like to present the main changes we are proposing:

 

Posting Guidelines & the KotakuInAction Pillars

Described in our mission statement are the four keys we believe are the foundations of discussion on KotakuInAction: Gaming, Entertainment, Media and the Internet.

We have come up with a well rounded list of topics that we believe are the staple of discussion of each pillar, as follows:

 

 GamingEntertainment (Nerd Culture)MediaInternet
GGamesFandom & SubculturesTruthfulnessInternet Culture & Social Media Platforms
AGaming IndustryConventionsHarm MinimizationInternet Technology
MCreative VisionCosplayCorruption, Collusion, and Conflicts of InterestInternet Law
EPeople in GamingOffline EntertainmentAccountability & TransparencyFree Speech & Censorship

 

The above table would help both the community and the mod team determine what is in fact on- or off-topic, and submissions guidelines would be updated or kept as follows:

Any submission that touches on at least two pillars is considered on-topic. The self post requirement currently in place is removed for all on-topic submissions. Self posts are of course still allowed, but no longer mandatory. Submissions that only touch on two pillars must be accompanied by a comment elaborating on the situation and relevance in order to give a better picture to the community. Submissions that only touch on only one pillar will be considered off-topic and removed. Any direct mention of GamerGate is considered on-topic (Gamedropping).

While this generally covers what we consider off-topic, keep in mind submissions must still adhere to other subreddit rules, in particular R2 (No Personal Info) and R5 (No witch hunting).


 

There are a number of additional proposals we have:

 


Additional rule updates

  • R1 - to be merged with R3 (Exact wording to follow) This has been a point of repeated contention due to the admitted vagueness of R3

  • R3 - to be removed or revamped with the new version of R12 The old R12 gets removed and will be replaced by the new system of Pillars

  • R7 - to include deliberately misleading editorializing. Misleading titles/topics have been on the rise of late, and since ethical concerns are of importance here, we should be setting a good example.

  • R8 - to include the removal of endless discussion posts around a hot topic that don't add anything new. This would only impact situations where a myriad of threads spring up without any new information being added. It’s a counterpoint to megathreads, in the sense that we will allow new posts on a hot topic that does add new information, but we might limit the number of active discussion posts on a hot topic that don’t add anything new.

  • Additionally, we want to make it official that we will no longer remove R1/(R3) comments any more. Official warnings will still be given, but for transparency’s sake all comments will be left intact, barring any reddit wide violations.

 


Preliminary flair changes

We really do mean preliminary here, since the whole set of flairs is a completely different discussion. The flair proposed here are partially obvious and partially already tacitly allowed/used already and it’s more a care of making it official.

 

  • [Twitter bullshit] - This one should be obvious. Some drama can be entertaining in its own way, but often there are semi-pointless twitter slapfights going on which technically qualify as valid within the other rules as they stand now, but don't actually provide any content of substance. This flair will be set to be filtered when choosing the On Topic KiA button near the top of the page.

  • [Community] - Some threads aren't really focused on meetups and such, but still serve as a bit of community building, or morale type posts. Things like the "so what are you playing?" kind of thread. They don't cause any harm to keep around, and can provide a nice break from the steady flow of drama, happenings, and such.

  • [History] - The use of this should be obvious. We are more than a year into GamerGate, with new faces popping up all the time who aren't aware of what has gone on, what approaches have been taken to various issues, and why certain specific people always manage to put themselves in the forefront of various shitstorms. Previously we had been using a custom-tagged version of the Discussion flair, but this easily deserves its own separate flair.

 


Politics in KiA

In addition, and based on previous feedback we’ve collected, we will institute an official moratorium on posts dealing with politicians and their misadventures with the media. This means we will not consider random hit pieces, commentary or announcements on or by political candidates to be on-topic except where a direct link to Gaming, GamerGate or an issue of Free Speech is present.

 


Commentary

In practice, this means…

that generally KiA will open up just a little more, the self-post requirement will be a thing of the past, but needing to justify posts of dubious merit won’t. Also, these proposed changes are intended to make actions on the part of the modteam even more transparent and hopefully also a great deal more consistent.

The basis of this scheme is our mission statement specified in a little bit more detail. In the end this table is supposed to be a tool both for mods as well as for users. It should help users understand what it is they need to do to have their posts accepted on KiA and moreover it is supposed to be a tool for mods to work with and to help achieve a better consistency in their modding actions. The requirement to related a borderline topic to GG by means of a line or two of commentary will remain, but instead of forcing this into a link-post, this can be done as a comment in the post itself. Therefore, instead of forcing users to use link-posts, they now have the option to do it the way they want. This revamped Rule 12 (moving to Rule 3) should not affect the types of posts removed, but instead open up topics that are currently limited to self-post to being link posts as well. It is intended to be less restrictive than the current system and to provide more transparency on mod actions and work as a guideline for both users and mods to work together to determine what is on- and off-topic.

 


Finally

We think we've accounted for most of the typical posts/cases, but if you see something we've forgotten, please let us know. Notably, it’s hard to imagine how the recent “SJW Attacks: College Campus Edition” fracas would fit into the columns as they are defined, however we recognize the community has an interest in these topics and we’re interested in hearing about how we might update the system to be more accommodating for these kind of events. Also, if you have any questions, comments or if there are any additional bullet points, items, name changes etc. etc. you think bear mentioning, please don't hesitate to comment.


r/KotakuInAction • • May 23 '19

META [Meta] We are removing One Angry Gamer from the whitelist

0 Upvotes

Keeping this brief for everyone. Due to the recent influx of outrage baiting and the praise of censorship of the Arthur episode with Mr. Ratburn getting married to another male, we the mods on KiA have decided to remove One Angry Gamer from our whitelist.

As well, it is up for discussion on whether or not OAG should be tiered on the blacklist.


r/KotakuInAction • • Oct 28 '14

VERIFIED I am Jesse Singal, a journalist who has been critical of GamerGate. I am on a train and we will see how long the wifi lasts. AMA.

5 Upvotes

One of your mods reached out to me on Twitter a few days ago and asked me to do one of these things. I wasn't going to have time until later in the week, but, miracle of miracles, the Amtrak train I am on appears to have functioning wifi -- for now, at least. So let's see how this goes... Ask me about journalism stuff. At the risk of sounding condescending, I think a lot of GG folk misunderstand and misinterpret certain things about my profession.

(If the wifi goes out I blame Adam Baldwin.)

EDIT: Just like I did in my Gamerghazi AMA, I'll be fixing typos throughout. Screenshot to your heart's desire; won't be changing substance of answers.

EDIT 2: Realized I should provide some basic info. I'm a senior editor at New York Magazine's website, where I edit Science of Us, a blog about the science of human behavior. I also write a weekly column on video games for The Boston Globe, and that's where I first started covering some of this stuff.

EDIT 3: Holy shit half hour into the ride and the wifi is still working this is unprecedented.

EDIT 4: Because it comes up again and again and again, I should just state up here that I don't buy the idea that a dozen articles came out at the same time as a result of collusion and coordinated messaging. I don't buy it because 1) that isn't how journalism works in reality; and 2) this rundown strikes me as a good debunking of the idea that all these articles were saying the same thing in the same way.

EDIT 5 (12:07 am ET): Just got kicked off for a bit but am back on. If it happens again I might call it a night, but in a meantime will try to answer as many questions as possible.

EDIT 6 (12:21 am ET): Outta steam, guys. Sorry. You'll see I tried my best to jump around and answer a lot. I think there are a lot of basic premises on which we simply disagree. I appreciate the folks who were civil, and thanks to everyone for taking the time to leave questions and/or read this.


r/KotakuInAction • • Oct 23 '14

VERIFIED I am Mike Cernovich's Raging Bile Erection. AMA!

0 Upvotes

Hey everybody, I wrote this a couple days ago. AMA!


r/KotakuInAction • • Jul 15 '19

TWITTER BS [twitter bullshit] Accessibility specialist Ian Hamilton argues that GamerGate supporters are wrong about journalists using disabled gamers as shields

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • Jan 17 '23

CENSORSHIP [Censorship] Sankaku Complex - "Fire Emblem Engage’s Western Release Allegedly Gutting All Romance With Minors" NSFW

Thumbnail
archive.is
0 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • Sep 03 '26

When certain players get offended that developers add mechanics that create difficulty, tension, or consequence, it’s hardly surprising that studios keep dumbing their games down.

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • Jun 08 '15

KIA is supposed to be a rational arbiter of truth, not ideology. Trust but verify. There is CONTEXT behind the /r/Planetside fiasco

8 Upvotes

http://i.imgur.com/xmydAZp.png

A female posted a thread a few days ago with a photo of her in a red skirt with the logo of her in-game faction embroidered onto it. It was a nice photo, and she did a good job on the skirt - she was proud and wanted to show it off to the community. Within a few hours, the banned user (along with a few others who were banned) began to hurl some extremely disgusting comments at nothing, debating her sexual orientation and preferences (something that is very private, I'm sure you don't need to be told this). For some reason, the discussion turned heated and was soon directed specifically at her. She read all of these comments, and an hour later she deleted her entire Reddit account and deleted her photo. After that, the moderators who are now being trashed (unfortunately), handed out bans to everyone who was involved in the abuse. It was honestly disgusting to read and watch these banned users talk how they were talking. One of the banned users decided he was just in such abuse, and disagreed with his ban. He then spread to 20 other subreddits to get this vote brigading started. All in all, this mod team should have acted sooner and banned these users sooner. If anything this was not a case of censorship - in fact they should have acted faster and banned them quicker. Someone was genuinely harassed to the point of emotional damage. Now this Mod Team is receiving an extreme amount of abuse because no one is bothering to check their facts.


r/KotakuInAction • • Sep 09 '23

BG3 released over a month ago and STILL has more concurrent players than Starfield, which just released

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • Aug 08 '23

am i one of the few people who find BG"3" a very overhyped game?

13 Upvotes

I am in act 3, mid way i would say. I will put turn based side of the game aside since i am completely against turn based CRPGs, BUT, turn based isnt even the main issue i have with the game. Honestly? I feel like Act 1 was kinda bait for hyped players as it was well put together and the start of the plot was pretty damn good (except the prologue part, cuz ngl Illithids i dont find compelling as one of big bads). The characters that join your party are amazing as well, especially Karlach and Shadowheart; cant judge Minthara yet as im hesitant to replay the game from 0 simply because of random bugs from act 1 and onwards when it comes to flags and romance stuff.

I hit act 2 and it starts well, but then I feel like the flow is off the more i progress, and companions suddenly say and interact way less than previously. The plot also feels very 2 sided. For all the openness of how you could solve quests as they claimed, or whatever the hell its called, not only you only can do things in 2 ways only, but if you try to do it your own way it breaks the quest. I had this issue after i tried to just go ham on the act 2 zone. I won, but the quests and most npcs broke. then in act 3, i mostly tried to pursue romance first and sought a solution to Karlach's big ticking issue. There is dialogue for it but it literally just ends her questline. Datamining shows there is no perma solution which, if you know lore and 5e ruleset, at bare minimum, true resurrection would solve easily at a Baldurian temple (not really spoilers since Larian made it obvious act 3 is in Baldurs Gate). What the issue is, lies in companions quests.

then we have non lethal damage, or knocking npcs out. This is utterly useless garbage. Knocking out an npc literally is just killing them. They are removed from the game after long rest and are flagged as dead. Honestly, what the actual fuck? I am baffled that for all these claims, the devs didnt bother implementing actual knocking out. It is just a cop out non lethal kills. Then we get the big bait of kinky scenes and polyamory which both got debunked and known to be a lie now and not actually that big or super expansive, in fact polyamory instantly is disabled when you get intimate despite companions being open to it previously (and no I did not get the game for those).

I dunno, all these hours while enjoyable at start started getting tedious in act 2. I ignored the fact that the game is turn based, which worked in act 1, but in act 2 it started just seeping in with the rather mid story. Now i know people are fans of Dos1 and 2, but neither those or BG"3" have great writing, companions? sure, i like them a lot. Plot? hell no. It is weird saying it but even Skyrim had a more compelling plot than BG"3" long term than this game. I honestly am not surprised that WotC lore based rpg has a mid plot since WotC lore itself is currently mid with all the woke bullshit. Now, I am NOT saying BG"3" is woke, but the plot is just at best mid like WotC's lore in general is. This game i honestly feel like doesnt deserve to be called a Baldur's Gate "3". A sequel in name only and not deserved.

If you seek good CRPGs, I would recommend WotR and Kingmaker as they are more enticing. Yes, the kingdom and crusader mechanics can be unfun with all the loading screens, but honestly? I found both games way more fun than BG"3", and if you seek to play this game because its a "sequel", dont, its not. That is a lie as well. There is very if not anything to do with the previous games. I would go further into that but the rest would be spoilers. Just know that Jaheira and Minsc while in the game, dont actually make this a sequel in any way, which tbh im glad for.

Due to the whole disappointment, I now am hungering for starfield. I need something to chill... there just has been too much frustration with BG"3" ngl... also if you see any weird grammar or stuff, apologies, not my first language so the more i write the more screw ups get in :D

Edit: Also if mods deem this a spoiler post then feel free to tag it. Some things while already known, the other stuff I purposely kept vague as to not spoil anything that shouldnt be

Edit 2: I am very glad ppl are civil here about my opinion. I have yet to see a nutjob reply so that says something about this sub :D lets keep it on!


r/KotakuInAction • • Jun 07 '26

META [Meta] What the fuck is up with idiots on this sub posting screenshots as sources without any context?

0 Upvotes

Okay, I get it. Western devs like to make their female characters look ugly, while eastern devs like to make their female characters look pretty. This has been a known factor in the AAA gaming industry for several years.

What I don’t get is how people here have gotten so prone to posting low-effort shit on this sub to such an extent that they think that having a screenshot with no context or explanation is somehow a valid excuse to post here.

I’m talking about shit like this:

These aren't just obscure-ass posts that just appeared in the “New” section, the first two posts are on the top of the front page of the sub as of this writing. Both posts have hundreds of upvotes.

How is it that we’ve gotten to the point where posting an image with no further context or explanation is somehow an acceptable practice on this sub? I have no clue as to how we’ve dropped our standards on what makes a good source for making a post.

Mods, I’ve already raised this issue earlier with idiots posting screenshots to articles without any archive links, but now our community has stooped to the point where idiots here are now posting screenshots without any CONTEXT.

It’s as if though we’ve convinced themselves that a picture without ANY explanation is somehow worth a thousand words. Can we please clamp down on dumbasses posting with “i.redd.it" links for once?


r/KotakuInAction • • May 16 '26

Clearing Up Misinformation Surrouding the Production of Mixtape

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: I'm not defending this game in any capacity. I haven't played it and never will. I think it's very cringe and fake nostalgia bait. My only issue is with people parroting false arguments just to support their dislike for the game. I recommend only reading the claims you actually thought were real and ignoring the rest. This post isn't intended to strawman any other argument, but to address those exact specific claims; my goal here is to inform.

1. "The Studio is Owned by a Nepobaby"

This is false, and the true version of this claim is kind of a nothingburger.

Megan Ellison is the daughter of Larry Ellison, Oracle co-founder and once the richest person in the world, according to the Financial Times. In 2016, Megan founded the game publisher Annapurna Interactive.

Since then, the company has published many successful indie games, such as Stray, Outer Wilds, and What Remains of Edith Finch, developed respectively by BlueTwelve, Mobius Digital, and Giant Sparrow. Annapurna doesn't own any of those studios. In fact, the publisher doesn't own any game studios as subsidiaries.

Mixtape was developed by Beethoven & Dinosaur, founded by musician Johny Galvatron, and published by Annapurna. So the studio isn't owned by a nepobaby. However, it's true that the game was funded by one. But so were all the other games published by Annapurna Interactive, and if you enjoy indie games, chances are you have enjoyed a game that was published by them.

2. "All of the Devs Fired Themselves"

This is, again, a confusion between the publisher and the game studios that I often find in recent discussions. The fact they are referencing is that in 2024, the entire staff of Annapurna Interactive quit after a breakdown in negotiations with their parent company.

Many gamers were arguing that if the game was published by a nepobaby, then the game is bad and is being forced by the industry. That's why, to rationalize enjoying other Annapurna-published games while still shitting on Mixtape for that same reason, people try to differentiate those games, highlighting the fact that today's Annapurna is a totally different team.

However, that doesn't change the fact that those games were funded by Annapurna, which was a nepobaby company from the beginning. You could argue that the new staff is more woke and that this led them to choose to fund woke games more frequently. That argument is more defensible, but it is also a totally different argument that has nothing to do with the company's nepobaby status.

Conclusion

At the end of the day, game studios and their publishers are totally different things, and a publisher being good or bad doesn't say much about the game studio. One famous example is the Subnautica 2 drama, where you have a shitty publisher, Krafton, and a beloved game studio, Unknown Worlds. In that particular case, the publisher even owns the game studio, and even then, there are differences in alignment.

Mixtape gives people lots of reasons for criticism, but I think the main source of difference in opinions comes from millennials being cringe and the fact that this game targets a very niche audience that might love the game while everyone else hates it.

TL;DR: Mixtape wasn’t made by a nepobaby-owned studio; it was funded/published by one, just like many Annapurna games people might already enjoy. Also, the people who “fired themselves” were Annapurna staff, not the studio devs.


r/KotakuInAction • • Mar 13 '26

FATAL FRAME II: Crimson Butterfly Remake is a flop.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • Jun 27 '15

Tauriq Moosa, the SJW clique's latest cause célèbre wrote an article in support of banning gay marriage

Thumbnail
archive.is
0 Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • Jul 08 '23

Final fantasy 16 is proof that you cannot please the wokeists. Spoiler

11 Upvotes

Even with Square Enix promise to move from a Japanese audience to a "broader market" aka leftist ideology, even with their "ethics department" aka leftist council, the game has come under fire for not being feminist enough.

However, playing and beating this game, I'm seeing that it's a lot like Star wars Jedi Surivior... it is actually laced with woke themes.

Outside of the MC's, the best NPC leaders, the smartest characters, and the most noble are the women. They are, indeed, flawless. The men are only there to fight.

The one white male npc leader leads his ppl to slaughter for his own selfishness.

The game shies away from letting the mc kiss his love but the gay love scenes were dealt with slowly and with utmost care - because that's what their majority straight male customers want to see!

One of the most OP and badass characters is the gay prince.

The town of "sex workers" aka prostitutes were treated with the honor of virgin nuns and looked to for guidance. In fact the dame was the hero.

Even with the glorification of these sex workers, they somehow made sure that none of them were overtly attractive to the "male gaze" because, you know, can't objectify sex workers.... . . .

Hell they even toned down Shiva from being attractive goddess to a non-binary looking ice thing.

Obligatory, Disney-esque, dumb father needs to learn from his daughter messaging.

We get introduced to Odins dominant who brings the obligatory Christianity is evil messaging with all his lord God rhetoric and splitting of the red sea.

Like, why are they hating this game?

The game itself is basic af. No real strategy, story doesn't really make sense, clive and whatever his gf name, have no chemistry and look like "customize your player" models.

The most fun you'll have in this game are the eikon fights and the few glances they give you of jote ;)

All in all, the game is as good as one can expect during the times we live in. But it just goes to show that group should never be pandered to because they'll never be happy and they just limit what game developers can do.


r/KotakuInAction • • Oct 22 '16

/r/all John Oliver's hypocrisy on internet harassment.

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

r/KotakuInAction • • Jun 23 '15

UNVERIFIED Voat forced to shut down /v/'s because of SJW's spamming CP

7 Upvotes

https://voat.co/v/announcements/comments/163288

There's no definite proof, but when you've got a new platform for free speech, and people start making boards saying "post CP here this board is for CP we love it and Voat, Voat loves CP!", you know it's SJW's again. Just like they did with 8ch. And again, it seems they've won.

It's a sad day.


r/KotakuInAction • • Aug 22 '16

What it feels like to be in Gamergate

Post image
46 Upvotes