r/Koryu • u/ekosfer147 • Jun 08 '21
r/Koryu • u/Spooderman_karateka • Sep 30 '25
Tengu and Kenjutsu?
I was looking into Shinkage ryu and it's offshoots (Yagyu Shinkage ryu, Taisha ryu, Jigen ryu) and I came across Tengu in Taisha and Yagyu. Apparently there is a story of Yagyu Munenori dueling a Tengu and when he beat it, he ended up cutting a rock in two (inspired demon slayer too). That rock is called Itto-seki located in Nara.
But this story is of Yagyu, so why does it appear reference in reference to Taisha ryu? The Tengu does look different in Taisha ryu (images 1 and 4) related images in comparison to Yagyu Shinkage ones (image 2 and 3).
My main question is, what is the significance of the Tengu in Shinkage ryu? Does it symbolize an idea shared by Murame and Yagyu? (They apparently almost fought too).
Thank you!
r/Koryu • u/[deleted] • Mar 07 '25
What style of kenjutsu would you say that Clint Barton uses?
r/Koryu • u/OwariHeron • Aug 16 '24
What It Means to Join a Koryu
I may just be spitting into the wind here, but since the subreddit's been getting a lot inquiries covering the same kind of ground, I thought I'd write something of an overview that would, ideally, catch some preconceptions early, before we have to rehash them for the umpteenth time. Maybe the mods will find it worthy enough to pin or include in a FAQ, but if not, hopefully interested people will find it in a search or something.
Let's start with what koryu is not.
Koryu is not historical re-enactment. If it were, it would be very bad at it: wrong clothes, wrong hair, wrong training spaces. Despite the best efforts of popular media to portray it as such, koryu has nothing to do with being a samurai, or acting like a samurai. Even in the days when they were practiced primarily by samurai, they weren't practiced exclusively by samurai.
Koryu is not about becoming a good fighter/swordsman/etc. This may sound paradoxical, but it's true, and is most easily shown by judo and BJJ. If these arts were all about being a good fighter, then Kyuzo Mifune and Helio Gracie could have stopped training when age and accumulated injuries took away their strength and speed. They continued training even when they were so old they would get thrown or submitted by 25 year-old students 10 out of 10 times. The value that old exponents find in their modern arts is the same value that exponents of koryu find in their classical arts.
Koryu is not about preserving tradition. Again, this sounds paradoxical. My point is that while preserving tradition is something we do, it's not what it's all about. The question is, what is worth preserving? If it was just about preserving tradition, koryu would look a lot different. Iai-only schools would have full curricula. There would be fewer to no lost kata. There would be a lot less variance across time. The fact is, the soke and shihan of various schools change things all the time. Sometimes it's to make things more combatively pragmatic, sometimes it's sacrificing combative pragmatism for some other factor. At this point in time, the surviving koryu have generally been pared down to the elements that each felt most important, and what those elements are vary from school to school, and from art to art. To be sure, modern kendo and judo also did this.
Okay, so what are koryu, then? Koryu are inherited disciplines for self-improvement that utilize the combative paradigm of pre-modern era Japan. Wait, wait, one may say, maybe that's what they are now, but weren't they originally training systems for the samurai? Actually, no! Even for the arts that actually date back to the Sengoku era, they revolved around a philosophical and ethical core of shugyou, originally the Buddhist pursuit of enlightenment.
The "inherited" part is important, and should be deeply considered by anyone thinking of joining a koryu. When you join a koryu, it's not just about your personal acquisition and attainment of skills. You make a commitment to pass it down to the next generation. Not the shape and sequence of the particular kata in that school, but the philosophical and ethical core, as well as the spirit that vivifies the kata, and turns them from a sequence of physical movements into a path to transcendental experience that can last a lifetime. If the generation after me only goes through the motions by rote, essentially becoming a kind of traditional dance or performance, then I will have failed not only them, but also all the many generations of forebears who worked to pass it down through history to me.
This is actually a fair bit of pressure, because if it were just the physical movements, it would be easy. But actually you're trying to pass down something intangible and fragile. It requires constant vigilance and effort to maintain. This is why veteran practitioners can sometimes get a bit snippy when people act like we're trying to become badass swordsmen and failing, or say that kata are just "ritualistic," "pre-choreographed" "drills" that don't teach you how to fight.
If that doesn't sound appealing, if all you want is to be technically proficient in swordsmanship, then koryu are not for you, and in fact, are not even necessary. These days you can watch videos and copy them in the privacy of your home. You can practice ZNKR kendo and ZNIR iaido. You can combine all that with HEMA. As long as you are upfront about it, and don't pretend that what you do is a koryu or a historical tradition, it's fine. But that's not what koryu are about, and not why they have survived through the centuries long Edo peace as well as the modernization of Japan.
None of which is to say one can't learn combat from koryu. It is, after all, shugyou based on the combative paradigm of pre-modern Japan. Many people have. I'm only saying that combative skill in and of itself is a by-product of that shugyou, not the point of it. Fingers and heavenly glory, and all that.
r/Koryu • u/Numerous_Creme_8988 • Apr 26 '26
Jojutsu practice at Kyokushinkan (Okazaki Kancho and Ishijima Shihan)
r/Koryu • u/OwariHeron • Sep 16 '24
Shiai and Koryu: The Case of Yagyu Shinkage Ryu
Part 1 - Introduction
With this series of articles, I would like to address a certain dissatisfaction with the common debates one sees online regarding koryū, kata training, and sparring or what is called “aliveness”. These are typically framed in very binary ways which I find incongruent with my own experience of practice, and my understanding of the history of koryū in general, and Yagyū Shinkage Ryū Heihō (YSR) in specific.
This first part will be an introduction to the argument I am addressing, the terms in which I will address it, a very general look at the history of shiai in classical Japanese martial traditions, and some of my own conclusions and speculations. Part 2 will be an examination of the appearance of shiai in the early historical record of YSR. Fortunately, the historical record is relatively well-preserved, and has been printed in a number of different modern sources. Part 3 will look at the modern (post-Meiji) history of shiai in YSR. Finally, in Part 4 I would like to present the YSR approach to kata and free training, specifically through the lens of what we call the “shiai-seihō,” or “shiai-gata.” I'll note that this material is adapted from private presentations I've made elsewhere.
I suspect that on the whole much of what I am talking about is present in other traditions, if not expressed or thought about in exactly the same terms. So I want to stress that the ultimate goal here is not to boast about the specialness of YSR, but rather to hopefully inspire further study of these ideas in other traditions, and encourage a re-examination of commonly held assumptions.
Let’s begin by defining our terms. I’ll be using the term shiai throughout the series, mostly because that is the term used in the Japanese sources I have. What do I mean by “shiai”? Let’s first define its ostensible counterpart, kata-geiko (form training), as two-person training utilizing certain pre-set parameters, the end result of which expresses one or a few predictable shapes. This would include very simple drills such as pad work, uchikomi-geiko in judo and kendo, and of course the more sophisticated kata of koryū.
Shiai, then, is an engagement between two people with non-lethal intent, typically with semi- or full-contact, for the purpose of training or testing of skill, utilizing spontaneous expression of technique within set parameters partly or wholly outside the parameters of kata-geiko. This includes point-matches, non-point matches, jigeiko and kakarigeiko in kendo, randori in judo, “free practice,” and “sparring.”
I believe these can be seen as a spectrum, rather than discrete items. Indeed, of the examples given above, kendo’s kakarigeiko in particular seems to straddle the line. I hope to provide another, more detailed example in Part 4.
Having defined our terms, let’s now look at the argument. The following represent ideas that I have often run into in discussions online, and even in printed material. The general argument can be summed up as this:
“Koryū didn’t spar. The masters of the old days didn’t have friendly matches; they had duels. The primary training method of koryū was kata-geiko. Later, in the mid-19th century, matches with bōgu became popular, which lead to the development of modern kendo, and Kanō developed his randori and shiai-system for modern judo.”
I have no desire to to rehash the old “jutsu vs. do” thing, but I think it is fair to say that, in general, classical schools are seen as kata-centric, conservative, and focused on either battlefield combat or dueling. Modern budo, then, is seen as shiai-centric, relatively innovative, and focused on physical and mental fitness. In terms of history, kendo and judo are seen as new innovations of the Meiji era, distinct from classical schools, many of which have died off. It is also generally assumed that the classical schools that remain are representative of their respective eras.
All of the above strikes me as perfectly reasonable given the information that we have. The problem, however, lies in that very last assumption, that extant classical schools are representative of their eras. It underpins everything else. But I would submit that we have a survivor bias issue. Extant classical schools, far from exemplars of Edo period and earlier ryūha, almost assuredly represent only the most conservative traditions.
It’s believed that there were some 1,400 martial arts ryūha existing by the time of the Meiji Restoration. Together, the Nihon Kobudō Kyōkai and Nihon Kobudō Shinkōkai account for less than 80. While not every extant ryūha belongs to those organizations, it’s unlikely that there also exist 60-some other traditions needed to get us to even 10% of the number that once existed. I suspect that many, probably even most pre-Meiji kenjutsu and jujutsu schools had a strong shiai tradition, perhaps even being shiai-centric, and that these schools eventually became subsumed into kendo and judo.
In my opinion, the real primary difference between classical and modern budo is not necessarily based on its approach to real combat, but rather that classical budo was proprietary, while modern budo is largely open source. And rather than a break at an inflection point in Meiji, I think there was simply a gradual shift from the classical paradigm into the modern one. Certainly, some events accelerated this shift, particularly the modernization of Japan in the Meiji era.
The thrust of this series will be kenjutsu, but let’s take a quick look at other schools.
And as far as jūjutsu you have the very obvious example of sumō as one way that the grappling arts engaged in shiai. And far as I’ve been able to determine, the randori of Kano’s judo was taken from Tenjin Shin’yo Ryū (founded in the 1830s).
In terms of sōjutsu, there’s the very obvious example of Owari Kan Ryū. It was founded in the late 17th century, before the invention of the kind of bōgu that it currently uses, so its shiai tradition may date back to the invention of bōgu as we now have it.
With naginata, at first glance this seems to actually fall very much in line with the general argument. Maniwa Nen Ryū, for example, has shiai for its kenjutsu practice, but not for its naginata practice, as noted in Ellis Amdur’s Old School. However, a researcher named Maehata Hiromi has noted that some woodblock prints show wooden naginata vs practice spears, as well as short shinai fixed to naginata hafts, so perhaps there actually were shiai at one time.
Even just taking a very broad view of kenjutsu history, we find the following:
The fukuro-shinai is invented sometime in the mid-16th century. Extant schools that use the fukuro-shinai today include Shinkage Ryū, Nen Ryū, Kashima Shintō Ryū, and Tatsumi Ryū. These are all very old schools.
Historically, we know that there were shiai in Shinkage Ryū and Nen Ryū. Might this not suggest a much more widespread use of shiai among bugeisha?
Bōgu dates back to the 18th century and Jikishinkage Ryū and Nakanishi Ittō Ryū.
The modern yotsuwari shinai dates back to the 19th century with Ōishi Shinkage Ryū.
And then you have the Three Great Dojo of the Bakumatsu period. Each represented a different koryū, while also being known for shiai. The All Japan Kendo Federation draws a straight line from them to modern kendo.
This is a very potted history of kendo, but I think we can already see the basic arc of kendo history stretching back centuries, interwoven with the history of koryū. I think I could go far enough to say that kendo as something distinct from koryū is, for all intents and purposes, actually a post-war thing!
Of course, it is no great revelation that the popularity of shiai at the end of the Edo period led to modern kendo. The case I want to make is that this interest in shiai goes back centuries further. We have shiai in schools dating back to the 16th century. Or, alternatively, older schools at least adapting to new fukuro-shinai technology. I would argue that where there are fukuro-shinai, there is almost certainly shiai. I personally think that they are a great tool for kata practice, but they are not a necessary one. Particularly in pre-bōgu days, they must have held a strong lure for those who wished to test their skills in relatively safe conditions.
Then we have bōgu development at turn of the 18th century. I think this indicates demand during at least the 17th century. And Maniwa Nen-ryū’s bōgu suggests alternative models that never caught on.
And of course, once these tools were first developed, development was rapid afterward. Therefore, rather than kata vs shiai being a distinction between classical and modern budo, I actually think that shiai should be part of the conceptual image of koryū. as much as two-man kata and battōjutsu. Not necessarily present in every extant school, but at one time pervasive enough to be the norm.
r/Koryu • u/kenkyuukai • Oct 03 '16
Kata in Classical Japanese Martial Arts
Kata (形) in Classical Japanese Martial Arts
Introduction
When most martial artists hear the word "kata" they usually think of the solo forms in karate, taekwondo, or kung fu. Most discussion on the internet, whether for or against kata, focuses on solo forms as well. The goal of this post is to offer a wider view of what kata are by exploring kata in classical Japanese martial arts, or koryū bujutsu.
Koryū bujutsu are the martial arts founded in mainland Japan prior to the Meiji Restoration (1868). While many were not actively training for war, it was still a feudal era with an armed warrior caste that was fundamentally different from modern life. What makes classical Japanese kata stand out from the kata in karate (Okinawan), taekwondo (Korean), or kung fu (Chinese) is the emphasis on weapons and paired kata. This post will explore these differences and provide examples.
Weapons in Classical Japanese Arts
Classical Japanese arts are primarily focused around weapons. The bushi (samurai) of feudal Japan were essentially armed to varying degrees at all times and their martial arts reflect this. While many schools use the katana as their focus, they often also incorporate kodachi (short sword), naginata (glaive), yari (spear), bō and jō (staffs of varying length), kusarigama (chain and sickle), jūjutsu (unarmed or lightly armed), and other weapons in their techniques and kata. Even those schools who focus on jūjutsu often either have armed or armored kata and/or include weapons in other parts of their curriculum.
A Focus on Paired Kata
Perhaps in contrast to traditions from Okinawa (i.e., karate) and other countries, the majority of traditional Japanese martial arts practice paired kata. The senior student leads, providing the stimulus to which the junior must respond. The senior's attacks vary in timing and speed to suit the level of the junior, as does the subtlety of the openings the senior presents. Only the art of iaijutsu (sword drawing) is primarily practiced alone due to the use of live, sharp blades. Even then, almost all traditional iaijutsu "waza" (technique) is either complemented by "kata" (meaning paired practice) or is a complement to paired kenjutsu.
Kata vs Real Fighting
A Thousand Changes, Ten Thousand Variations
Classical schools are more than a collection of techniques; they are a mindset, a strategy, and physical principles. The kata within are not the limit of technique but rather the start of it. Many historical treatises are adamant that the one must learn to move freely and that the techniques taught are just a way to get there.
The famous Heiho Kadensho (1632) by Yagyu Munenori, sword instructor to the shogun, states in the opening chapter:
One should learn the techniques enumerated above well and from them use one thousand and ten thousand techniques. [The technique sets above] are an outline. Once you have mastered the way, one does not count the number of techniques. (translation mine)
Hidden in Plain Sight
It is also important to realize that what you see is not always what you get. Not only are kata training devices, rather than simulated combat, in an era where you might stake your life on your martial arts ability not all techniques were taught openly. Ōtake Risuke, shihan of the Tenshin Shōden Katori Shintō Ryū - the oldest extant koryū bujutsu - explains it here from 2:05 to 3:03.
(Paraphrased into English)
2:05 (In response to why the kata are done so fast) If you smack real swords together like this they would get all beat up. The kata is done like this so the technique cannot be stolen. The real techniques are hidden.
2:23 These are techniques designed for fighting in armor. Raising the sword above the head, for example, is done this way because a helmet's crest would prevent raising the sword directly above the head.
2:45 First, he thrusts at the arm. In the kata, the opponent steps back. As he cuts towards the opponent's forehead, the opponent cuts towards the neck. In practice, the opponent blocks but the real technique is to the neck. The timing, however, is the same.
The same kata done at speed, from beginning to end, can be seen from 1:42.
The benefits of Kata in Classical Japanese Martial Arts
Weapons training cannot simulate a real fight to the degree unarmed arts can. Every form of training is a compromise, training certain aspects to a high degree at the expense of others. What are the benefits of kata training in paired weapons forms? Not all arts practice the same way, but here are some general thoughts:
kata allow training unarmored arts unarmored
kata allow more realistic weapon simulators or even real weapons
kata allow cutting full speed and strength
the above provide more danger and stress while still being somewhat safe
exposure to danger and stress develop mental and psychological fortitude
Of course, there are downsides as well. Oak is good but it does not handle or weigh exactly the same as sharp steel. Stopping a cut an inch from the target teaches distance but it's not the same as cutting through. The senior can change the timing, distance, or even order of kata to test whether his junior is truly reacting but it's not the same as sparring. That's why there are still some solo forms (1, 2), test cutting (1, 2), and sparring (1, 2, 3), in many arts.
Examples of Kata in Koryū Bujutsu
While many schools also spar or encourage their students to practice arts like kendō and jūdō, most still use kata as the primary vehicle of transmission. This list is only a selection designed to show a variety of practices; many other arts are out there. Kanji are provided to help interested parties search for more videos.
Kenjutsu (swordsmanship)
The majority of schools simply used wooden weapons and no protection. A rather dangerous practice, this adds a psychological element. The style of practice varies greatly as you can see from the below examples.
However, some schools made weapon simulators instead. Shinkage Ryū is credited with the invention of the fukuro shinai which is split bamboo covered in leather and many other schools adopted it as well. This also led to the bare shinai used in modern kendō.
Other schools make use of armor or padding to allow contact in weapons kata. Ittō Ryū is known for its characteristic oni-gote gloves and its large influence on modern kendo.
Some schools use a variety of tools, ranging from both shinai and padding to cloth wraps and thin, flexible branches.
Iaijutsu & Battōjutsu (sword drawing)
One of the few classical Japanese arts that focuses mainly on solo kata, most practitioners use real swords.
However, many schools still have paired practice.
Jūjutsu (grappling)
Schools like Kitō Ryū and Tenshin Shin'yō Ryū had major influences on jūdō which later influenced BJJ. Of course, there are many other schools as well.
However, many jujutsu schools use weapons or learn how to deal with them. Grappling with a knife or short sword is common, but full-blown weapons curriculums are also seen.
Bōjutsu & Jōjutsu (staff)
The training weapons used in staff arts are the real thing. With bludgeon weapons, especially longer heavier ones, even armor - traditional or modern - isn't much use.
Naginatajutsu (glaive) & Sōjutsu (spear)
While technically cutting and thrusting weapons, these polearms can still hit as hard as staffs. While naginata are generally bare, you can see spear tips are usually padded.
Esoteric Kata
Many schools have practices that are designed to develop strong fighters that aren't necessarily just techniques. There is a broad spectrum of breathing, core exercises, and spiritual practice.
Jigen ryū (示現流) (I list this as kata because there is a pattern to it)
Summary
There are as many different ways of doing kata as there are schools. Some are fast, some are slow. Some are obvious, some are subtle. Some are esoteric, some are brutal. What the koryū bujutsu of feudal Japan had in common, however, was the use of paired kata focused around weapons.
Classical Japanese martial arts demonstrations were traditionally either offerings to the gods or a presentation to a lord and many demonstrations remain the same today. Because all the videos above are from demonstrations the testing and changing of timing, speed, strength, and resistance that occurs during training isn't always present. Here's one example of practice vs. demonstration, both showing the same technique.
I hope even a public glance at the koryū bujutsu gives you a wider perspective on what kata is.
Additional reading:
Josh Reyer's E-Budo Post regarding his experience in Yagyu Shinkage Ryu. The insight is brilliant.
Diane Skoss's Kata and Aikido which talks about far more than just Aikido
Ellis Amdur's Public Presentations of Skill in Traditional Japanese Martial Arts
This is an updated and improved version of this 2014 thread.
r/Koryu • u/dumbpunk7777 • Feb 03 '24
Pilgrimage
Hitting the Katori Jingu was def a special experience 🙇🏼♂️
r/Koryu • u/OwariHeron • Oct 01 '24
Shiai and Koryu: the Case of Yagyu Shinkage Ryu, Part 2
Early Historical Record of Yagyū Shinkage Ryū
For this part, we’re going to look at mentions of shiai in the early historical record, stretching from the mid-1500s to the 1700s. One thing I didn’t want to do with this series was just appeal to my authority as a practitioner. So I have tried to as much as possible refer to primary sources. These are available in Japanese due to the work of the late Imamura Yoshio, professor emeritus at Tokyo University of Education. In particular, his mammoth two-volume work Shiryō Yagyū Shinkage Ryū (Historical Materials of Yagyū Shinkage Ryū), which provided transcriptions of a great number of historical documents related to Yagyū Shinkage Ryū.
Kamiizumi Hidetsuna
We begin with Kamiizumi Ise-no-kami Hidetsuna, founder of Shinkage Ryū. It is often claimed that he invented the fukuro-shinai. Though based in Kōzuke Province, he made a number of trips to Kyoto in the late 1550s and 1560s to demonstrate Shinkage Ryū and meet with those interested in heihō. Per a Owari Yagyū record[1], in 1563 Kamiizumi visited Kitabatake Tomonori, Governor of Ise, and asked if he knew anyone who would like to test their skills in a shiai (仕相). Kitabatake suggested Yagyū Munetoshi, a minor lord and heihō enthusiast in Yamato Province. A meeting was arranged at Kōfuku Temple in Nara, not far from Yagyū Village.
They decided to hold the shiai between Munetoshi and Kamiizumi’s student, Suzuki Ihaku. Their match had three rounds, all of which Munetoshi lost. We know that the shiai used fukuro-shinai, because it is recorded that Munetoshi thought something was up, asked to compare shinai length and was surprised to find that Ihaku’s shinai was three inches shorter than his. This clearly takes the encounter out of the category of “duel” and clearly into the realm of shiai – a match to test their skills. Accordingly impressed by Kamiizumi’s art, Munetoshi asked to be taken on as a student. Kamiizumi and his students stayed in Yagyū Village for the better part of a year, training with Munetoshi and his family and retainers. We’ll come back to them in a bit.
Around 1570, Kamiizumi sent a letter to Marume Kurando Nagayoshi. Marume became deshi of Kamiizumi in 1558; they demonstrated before Shōgun Ashikaga Toshiaki in 1564. Eventually Marume went to Kyushu, where he would initially teach Shinkage -ryū, and later founded Taisha ryū Hyōhō.
Kamiizumi’s letter contained the following lines mentioning shiai.
九州において、他流の兵法皆打払われた由を聞別し満足至り。“I am particularly pleased to hear that all other schools of heihō have been driven out of Kyushu.”
当月○○仕合停止せしむ可き旨、上意に候間、貴殿も仕合無用に候。“About shiai (仕合 ) being ceased on [unclear] of this month, as this is the desire of your lord, you have no need to do shiai .”[2]
Yagyū Munetoshi
Now let’s return to Yagyū Munetoshi. Munetoshi stayed involved in the various conflicts of the Sengoku Period for the next 10 years after meeting Kamiizumi., but eventually retired as general to devote himself to heihō. About 10 years after that, he wrote the Yagyū Kaken, or the Yagyū Family Constitution, in 1589. This document essentially laid out what he saw as the correct attitude to have one’s approach to his heihō.
Here Munetoshi writes of shiai in a negative fashion, but what is interesting is the implications those statements hold. Some selected lines (translated by me):
“What is most lamentable is being ignorant of inner teachings, vain for glory in shiai, and not only bringing shame to oneself, but being known for a certain Way, and thus bringing difficulties to a teacher of a ryū of heihō; this is truly, truly the greatest of faults.”
“First, in this ryū, there should be no need for shiai. To elaborate, the most important thing is to not abandon all other ryū, but to discipline oneself in the Way, attend to other ryū, and inquire into them.”
“A man with one letter is the teacher of the man with none; do not overcome other ryū. Determine to overcome today the self of yesterday.”
“The ways of my house must not be passed on to vain people, that do not diligently practice the Omotedachi*, but enjoy shiai, and deride the ways of other ryū.”[3]
*“Omotedachi” refers to first three kata one learned at the time, the quintessential, most representative kata of Shinkage Ryū.
So, obviously what Kamiizumi’s letter and the Yagyū Kaken are referring to is what is commonly called taryū-jiai, that is, shiai between practitioners of different schools. And what can see here is a certain ambivalence to them. On one hand, both Kamiizumi and Munetoshi engaged in shiai with other schools; that’s how Munetoshi joined the school, and Kamiizumi praises Marume for his success in the same. At the same time, when Marume’s lord puts a moratorium on such shiai, Kamiizumi is completely fine with that. Munetoshi, perhaps due to some incalcitrant student, has a very negative view of such shiai, at least when paired with a negative attitude towards other schools.
Munetoshi’s lament, along with Marume’s lord barring such shiai points to a culture, or perhaps a subculture of shiai among late Sengoku bugeisha. I would go further to suggest that if you have shiai between ryūha, then you likely have shiai within ryūha, as well. Particularly when have the technology to make those feasible, such as fukuro-shinai.
Munetoshi’s note about not practicing the Omotedachi is particularly notable. In a kata-only tradition, doing the kata is training in the school. If the kata were the only training in Shinkage Ryū, then not training the Omotedachi would mean you are not training in Shinkage Ryū. It seems clear to me that Munetoshi is lamenting a bias in training, focusing on getting better at shiai at the expense of diligent practice of the kata.
In 1593, Munetoshi took lay orders and began using the name Sekishūsai. The same year, he wrote a collection of heihōka, poems about heihō. These are in the tanka short verse form, which is 31 syllables, in 5-7-5-7-7 meter. Here are three that I think are relevant to this discussion:
仕相して打たれて恥の兵法と心にたへずくふうしてよし “Consider it shameful heihō to be struck in shiai; constantly innovate in your heart.”
Now this could simply be referring to the same kind of sentiment expressed earlier in the Yagyū Kaken, that it is shameful to be caught up in the glory of shiai. But another, and I think more likely, way to read it is as an admonition to reflect on why one might lose in a training shiai, and work to overcome that. I believe the latter half recommending constant innovation in the heart suggests this reading.
The next two refer to using a kodachi (short sword).
無刀とるつもり位を稽古して小太刀のこころがんみ(玩味)して知れ “Train the spirit and distance of mutō-dori by savoring and knowing the spirit of kodachi.”
兵法のあらそひくらいは、小太刀にてたがひの弟子ぜひしくらべよ “For spirit in a contest of heihō; measure with a kodachi the good and bad of each of your students.”[4]
The received understanding of this last one is that one should test one’s students’ “spirit” (kurai) using a kodachi. What is significant here is that, at this time, there were no official kata in Shinkage Ryū that used kodachi. The first kodachi kata was added to the school by Sekishūsai’s great-grandson, and then this was expanded on in the mid-Edo period. That suggests that what Sekishūsai is talking about is shiai using a kodachi. This is reinforced by a story about the 3rd soke, Sekishūsai’s grandson Hyōgonosuke.
Yagyū Hyōgonosuke
Yagyū Hyōgonosuke Toshitoshi was the third 3rd sōke of Shinkage-ryū, and is considered Kaiso, or founder, of the Owari Yagyū family. He was the son of Sekishūsai’s eldest son, and learned Shinkage Ryū at his grandfather’s knee. He became the heihō instructor to the Owari Tokugawa, in Nagoya, in 1615.
Hyōgonosuke was primarily the instructor of Tokugawa Yoshinao. Yoshinao was the 9th son of Ieyasu, and the first lord of Owari Domain. He received inka from Hyōgonosuke and so is considered the 4th sōke of Shinkage Ryū.
Kashima Dōen was a middle-aged doctor and student of Hyōgonosuke. He had trained in another ryūha in his youth, and so had some difficulty adjusting to the Shinkage Ryū way of doing things. As a result, he took copious notes about his training. As was the custom, he arranged for these notes, along with all documents related to his involvement in the ryū, to be collected and given to the Yagyū family after his death.
One of the entries in his training diary was as follows:
寛永五年戊辰六月十九日の朝、師小太刀にて、我道円中太刀にて、位を視るぞ。“The morning of July 20, 1628, my teacher (Hyōgonosuke) with a kodachi, and I, Dōen, with a regular tachi, (he said) “I’ll look at your kurai.”[5]
Kurai wo miru zo (I’ll look at your kurai) was Hyōgonosuke’s phrase for doing a shiai with his students. Again, we can be pretty sure this is a shiai because there were no kodachi kata in Hyōgonosuke’s day.
Another story of shiai in Hyōgonosuke’s day involves the grandson of Kamiizumi Hidetsuna, Kamiizumi Sonshirō Hideaki, who came to Nagoya serve the Owari Tokugawa. He asked Hyōgonosuke for a match, but first had to defeat Hyōgonosuke’s student Takada Sannojō. Sonshirō lost to Takada and became his student, also receiving training from Hyōgonosuke.[1]
Yagyū Renya
Finally, we have stories of Yagyū Renya Toshikane, Hyōgonosuke’s third son. In those days, a third son might be expected to marry into another family, or take orders to become a priest. But Hyōgonosuke’s oldest son, Kiyotoshi, was killed in the Shimabara Rebellion. Toshikata, his second son, and now heir, initially took over from Hyōgonosuke as heihō instructor, but Renya was so skilled at Shinkage Ryū that Toshikata stepped aside. Renya was the 5th sōke of Shinkage Ryū.
As Renya was famed in the Owari Yagyū family for his skill, there were a number of accounts about his skill that were told decades after his death. Not all of these are entirely reliable, but here are two that seem pretty solid.
It is related in Mukashibanashi (Stories of Old), a history of the Owari Domain, that at age 12 or 13, Renya would have shiai with the other children of Hyōgonosuke’s students, taking all of them at the same time. If any of other children struck him, he would give them money. He would come home with his arms swollen from welts, and when he struggled to tie his obi, his mother would turn away to hide her tears.[6]
Then, at age 18 (1643), Renya become heihō instructor to Lord Mitsutomo, the son and heir of Lord Yoshinao. Two different accounts relate that upon Renya’s arrival in Edo, Mitsutomo arranged a gauntlet of 30-some opponents who did Shinkage Ryū or Ittō Ryū. It is written that Renya went “2 or 3 rounds each” (二三本つゞ). This suggests something very much like the modern kendo scoring system. It should be noted, though, that the earliest of the two accounts of this gauntlet was written in 1739, nearly a hundred years after it supposedly took place. Though even that indicates that friendly shiai were considered normal and believable as far back as 1739.[6][7]
This concludes the review of the early history of Shinkage Ryū. I wanted to present these accounts as neutrally as possible, so people can make up their own minds, but I should note here that there is no question within the Owari Yagyū family that shiai was a part of training at this time. When there is commentary that Shinkage Ryū was banned from engaging in shiai because it was patronized by the Tokugawa family, it should be understood that this applied to inter-ryū contests, and not to intra-ryū training.
In the next part, we will look at the more explicit use of training shiai in Shinkage Ryū in the 19th and 20th centuries.
References
[1] 柳生新陰流縁起 Yagyū Shinkage Ryū Engi, “Origin of Yagyū Shinkage Ryū” (editor’s title), excerpted from the 後悔記 Kokaiki “Record of Regret,” 1718, by Yagyū Toshinobu, published in Shiryō Yagyū Shinkage Ryū, ed. Imamura Yoshio, revised edition 1995.
[2] 正伝新陰流 Shoden Shinkage Ryū, “True Transmission Shinkage Ryū,” 1957, by Yagyu Toshinaga, quoting 劍道の發達 Kendō no Hattatsu, “The Development of Kendo,” 1921, by Shimokawa Ushio.
[3] 柳生家憲 Yagyū Kaken, “Yagyū Family Constitution,” 1589, by Yagyū Tajima-no-Kami Munetoshi, reprinted in Yagyūkai lecture materials.
[4] 兵法百首 Heihō Hyakushu, “100 Poems of Heihō,” 1593, by Yagyū Sekishūsai Songon, published in Shiryō Yagyū Shinkage Ryū, ed. Imamura Yoshio, revised edition 1995.
[5] 道円集 Dōenshu, “Collection of Dōen,” 1628, by Kashima Dōen, reprinted in Yagyūkai lecture materials.
[6] 昔咄 Mukashibanashi, “Stories of Old,” 1739, by Chikamatsu Shigenori, published in Shiryō Yagyū Shinkage Ryū, ed. Imamura Yoshio, revised edition 1995.
[7] 連也翁一代記 Renya-ō Ichidaiki, “Life of the Venerable Renya,” 1847, Iinuma Moriyoshi, published in Shiryō Yagyū Shinkage Ryū, ed. Imamura Yoshio, revised edition 1995.
r/Koryu • u/nhkbdiakkk • Mar 03 '26
New school vs old school, a perspective from 1724
古今武芸得失論 (The Merits and Demerits of Martial Arts Past and Present) is a collection of notes on the teachings of 近松彦之進茂矩 (Chikamatsu Hiko-no-shin Shigenori) by his student 榊原新助政興 (Sakakibara Shinsuke Masaoki). The text was edited and published by a fellow student after Sakakibara's early death (age 35) in 1724 at the direction of Chikamatsu (1697-1778). Chikamatsu served Tokugawa Yoshimichi of Owari Domain and taught a multitude of arts under the name 一全流 (Ichizen Ryu).
Although not a long text in total, the passages below are only an excerpt of the original. Many of the sections continue on in more detail. My interest in this piece is not the details, per se, but the divide between 古流 (koryu) and 新流 (shinryu) presented within. While all the arts mentioned fit the modern definition of koryu, this text makes it clear that old and new are relative. While no definitions are given, one can surmise that Chikamatsu drew the line somewhere between war and peacetime.
The Merits and Demerits of Martial Arts Past and Present
For archery, learn the koryu but do not learn the shinryu. One can learn the history of koryu transmission from the lineages of the archery clans. Among them, Ishido Chikurin-ha1 is superior. [abridged]
For horsemanship, one should study the koryu and not prefer the shinryu. The koryu are the [arts of the] three clans Otsubo, Ogasawara, and Naito and Yamato Ryu, Korai Ryu, and Hachijo Ryu. Though the shinryu come from the aforementioned arts, they were created 100 years later by founders who had not been to war. They were created only for the convenience of wearing hakama and so include techniques that aren't usable in armor. The koryu transmit techniques that were found useful while riding in multiple battles when riding holding a bow and wearing a horo2. [abridged]
For firearms, shinryu are preferred. The reason is because firearms proliferated during the peak of unrest3 and those who used them had little time to train with them. They learned just a little then opened their schools and thus have no detailed teachings. During times of peace many schools had time to dive into specifics. What technique was done with 100 monme4 shot then is done with 30 monme shot now. What was done with 10 monme shot then is done with 3.5 monme shot now. The firearms themselves were in the past shot only 12 or 13 cho5 and did not light well. Now they are made with different materials, shoot 17 to 18 cho, and light well. This is why shinryu are superior to koryu. [abridged]
Spearmanship started with the Kusunoki clan6 and proliferated during the mid Ashikaga period. At that time only straight spears were used. There were no pronged spears7. Thus, koryu is only straight spears. Pronged spears were developed because it is difficult to defend oneself easily with a straight spear. Although one can achieve victory with a straight spear it is difficult to become skilled quickly. Pronged spears have an additional way to victory via the prong so even if one has not trained enough there is more chance of victory. [abridged]
For swordsmanship, there is no difference between koryu and shinryu. However, for battlefield fighting in armor, one should study koryu. The armored fighting taught in shinryu still comes from the framework of fencing barefoot on tatami and thus some of it isn't useful when actually wearing armor. [abridged]
For batto, there is also no difference between koryu and shinryu. Whether standing or sitting, all of them train drawing the sword well. My teacher said: knowing kenjutsu without knowing batto is like having a sword but no hands to hold it. He also said: one should not learn batto from a teacher who does not know kenjutsu. If kenjutsu is the body, batto is the limbs. The limbs cannot win without the body. Thus you must also learn kenjutsu.
The three arts of kempo, jujutsu, and kumiuchi are more similar than not but differ greatly in their intention8. [abridged] Because it is difficult to win [via kumiuchi] without strengthening the limbs, kumiuchi is considered the inner teachings by kempo and jujutsu practitioners. First kempo and jujutsu are taught to strengthen the body and limbs before training kumiuchi. In the old ways of fighting9 it was difficult to win with sword or spear when both sides were protected by armor so victory was decided by entering in close and doing kumiuchi. Therefore a bushi must know kumiuchi. Thus, like kenjutsu, regardless of new or old, one must not neglect training useful technique for when wearing armor.
Ishido Chikurin-ha (石堂竹林派): a branch of Heki Ryu founded by Chikurinbo Naoshige
Horo (母衣): a balloon like cloak used on horseback as protection
Unrest (乱世): aka the Sengoku Period, a period of constant warfare
Monme (匁, 目): a unit of weight, 1 monme = 3.75g
Cho (町): a unit of distance, 1 cho = 360 shaku = 109m
Kusonoki clan (楠家): Kusunoki Ryu was a school of martial strategy founded by Kusonoki Shigemasa, a warlord of the Namboku Period
Pronged spear (横手物): yokote-mono are spears with a prong on the spearhead or shaft
Intention defined here as: kempo relies on strength, jujutsu uses the opponent's strength, and kumiuchi is armored kempo
Old ways (古戦): aka the battlefield
r/Koryu • u/OwariHeron • Aug 19 '24
What Could Have Been: A Potential Pre-War Paradigm for (Koryu) Kendo
In July of 1935, 20th soke of Shinkage Ryu, Yagyu Toshinaga, gave a weeklong series of lectures at Kokushikan Academy (currently Kokushikan University) on the history, philosophy and training of "kendo," here meant in the broadest possible sense of Japanese swordsmanship. The notes for these lectures were later collected and published by the Yagyukai as Kendou Hachikou, or "Eight Lectures on Kendo."
Toshinaga was a lifelong critic of gendai kendo. Not because they did shiai; shiai was a part of Shinkage Ryu training from inception up to the war. Rather, he didn't like that they used long shinai, and he definitely did not like the footwork. He felt that these characteristics took kendo too far from its roots in classical swordsmanship. So as part of these lectures, he put forward an outline of what he considered the ideal paradigm for kendo training. Alas, Toshinaga was too independently minded to join with the major budo organizations of their time, and to navigate their politics and bureaucracy, so this paradigm never approached realization. But given the number of discussions we've had about kata and sparring, I thought it might provide some interesting perspective, from the point of view of someone who was very much for kata, and yet also was a strong proponent of shiai.
So, the whole paradigm is labeled "Kendo". And is broken down like this:
本源 hongen, the Essential Principles
Mental methods, mental attitude (心法, 心術)
Study of essential principles
History (剣道史)
Historical philosophy (剣道史哲学)
Philosophical principles (剣道哲理の学)
本体 hontai, the Essential Form
Sword methodology (剣法 kenpou)
Striking methods (撃刀法)
Test-cutting (試切り)
Individual practice of battoujutsu (抜刀術単独仕方)
Paired kata (丸太刀)
Sword Techniques (剣術 kenjutsu)
Shiai-seihou 試合勢法 (Keiko-jiai 稽古試合)
Seihou-shiai 勢法試合 (shiai)
Kiriai (截合)
Battoujutsu Kiriai
Okay, now to explain what these terms mean. The difference between "sword methodology" and "sword techniques" is that the former is focused on the individual student, either on their own or as the shidachi of paired practice, while the latter operates in the realm of mutual practice (no distinct uchidachi/shidachi).
Kata here is written with the kanji for "maru-dachi" 丸太刀. The significance of this is that these represent the "classical" forms, the ones that act as containers for the founders' insights. The exemplar of this would be Shinkage Ryu's Sangaku En-no-Tachi 三学円之太刀. It is contrasted with another term used later, seihou 勢法.
Higiri (lit. "cutting openings") is a level of paired practice wherein uchidachi bends or breaks the kata to strike shidachi when they leave an opening. Higiri-jiai is an advanced level where both uchidachi and shidachi do this.
Shiai-seihou references the Yagyu Shinkage Ryu sets of kata under the same name. The shiai-seihou of YSR were devised in the 1820s by Nagaoka Fusashige, an assistant instructor to the Owari Yagyu dojo. "Seihou" is another name for kata, I believe borrowed from Enmei Ryu, which Nagaoka also studied. These forms were devised as an adjunct to shiai practice, to prevent shiai practice from getting too unrealistic.
How, you may ask? In contrast to the classical forms, the shiai-seihou are faster paced, repetitive, and more physically intense. Their similar set-ups and parameters mean that the forms can be extemporaneously linked together in different configurations. As I understand it, Toshinaga here is suggesting a role for similar seihou created for general use.
But here Toshinaga shows how they can act as a bridge from the higiri-jiai of the kata to fully open shiai. Essentially, you would have two participants doing a shiai under the parameters of the shiai-seihou, both as part of intra-dojo practice, and then in a inter-dojo environment.
Kiriai, then, is how he classifies fully open shiai between two competing individuals, in both an intra- and inter-dojo setting.
Finally, you would have the same kind of progression with battou, though I must confess that I am less certain of how that would work. I'm not sure if we're talking shiai versions of the kumitachi, side-by-side competitions like you see today, or perhaps even actual free draw-and-strike against an opponent type situation.
So this is just one example of how a pre-war soke considered how koryu practice could fit into the greater kendo ecosystem, in a way that engaged with the interests of gendai kendo, but stayed true to the roots and considerations of the classical ryuha.
r/Koryu • u/tenkadaiichi • Jan 12 '22
Museum display of modern Koto-era style blades
r/Koryu • u/zealuk • Oct 11 '21
Certainly not a samurai, but here’s my experience joining Jigen-ryu and training in Japan for 15 years
r/Koryu • u/kenkyuukai • Feb 12 '16
Cool pic of Satsuma Heki Ryu battlefield group archery
r/Koryu • u/Greifus_OnE • Oct 14 '24
Kata demonstrations filmed in 1897
Very early film of a “Kendo” demonstration from 1897, although I am uncertain as to which Ryu is being represented here, or if it is an early kata from pre-standardized Kendo Kata.
r/Koryu • u/Toso-no-mono • Jan 20 '25
Documentary - Sugino Yukihiro
Hello, a couple of students have released a short documentary about our teacher, Sugino Yukihiro-sensei. If you have a moment to spare, please watch it!
r/Koryu • u/lets_chill_food • Mar 05 '24
Kuroda Tetsuzan has passed away
Sad to see one of the most impressive swordsmen of our era has passed 😔
r/Koryu • u/McKennaReeves • Oct 11 '26
Restored my father’s old bokken.
I’m not entirely sure what he used it for as I know he didn’t take it with him when training in Japan, but I intend to use it for solo kata.
r/Koryu • u/BerlinBoar65 • Jan 05 '25
I Tried Real Ju-Jutsu From Japan (Yagyu Shingan Ryu)
r/Koryu • u/Kusarigama12 • Nov 29 '20
Masaki-ryu Fukuhara-ha Kusarigamajutsu. Old video of Katsuse Yoshimitsu Kagehiro, 15th generation Headmaster of Suio-ryu Iai Kenpo and 12th generation Headmaster of Masaki-ryu Fukuhara-ha Kusarigamajutsu. Katsuse Soke is to the left.
r/Koryu • u/OwariHeron • Oct 15 '24
Shiai and Koryu: The Case of Yagyu Shinkage Ryu, Part 3
Later Historical Record of Yagyū Shinkage Ryū
There is little written about Yagyū Shinkage Ryū as it was in the 1700s. Renya’s nephew Toshinobu succeeded him as head of the family and instructor the Owari Tokugawa. He took the ryū into the 18th century and then passed it on to his son Toshitomo, who then passed it on to his son Toshiharu.
One of Toshiharu’s students was a man named Nagaoka Tōrei Fusashige. Nagaoka inherited from his father the position of shihan-hosa, assistant instructor to the sōke. Nagaoka’s official post in the Owari Domain was to train martial arts, particularly Shinkage Ryū, and to write about them. Toshiharu was succeeded by his son Toshiyuki, but Toshiyuki died at a relatively young age, and was succeeded by his teenage son, Toshihisa. But then Toshihisa also died at age 20, when his own son, Toshishige, was still a baby. Toshiharu’s younger brother, Toshimasa, together with Nagaoka, kept things together until Toshishige could come of age and grow into his role as sōke.
One thing Nagaoka noticed was that people were struggling in shiai. His solution was to devise more kata. He referred to these kata as seihō 勢法, to distinguish them from the original kata of the ryu, which are called tachi 太刀. The sei refers to ikioi, which means force and momentum, but also carries a nuance of the natural course of things. Hō refers to methods and principles. In the preface to his description of these seihō, Nagaoka wrote:
“There are many beginners who do not understand the way to achieve victory in shiai, and then go headlong down the wrong road. So I, Fusashige, have devised seihō in the broad outlines of shiai, with the teachings of the past masters, based on the forms of certain victory in the old [armored] style and new [unarmored] style, and give them to my fellows beginning their study.”[1]
Okay, so what are the shiai-seihō and what makes them different from the tachi so that they can aid the learner in shiai? Most of the tachi (Empi no Tachi being the notable exception) are split into distinct parts which are made up of one or two exchanges between the practitioners. The shiai-seihō typically feature 3 or 4 exchanges chained together, some even have 8 or 9, and some of them have effectively no upper limit, bound only by physical space and uchidachi’s wherewithal. They are also dynamic: within these multiple exchanges, attacks and responses come from high and low, from the left and the right, from far out and from close in, with both shidachi and uchidachi moving forward or moving back. After the new practitioner has learned the first three shiai-seihō, totalling 30 distinct sections, they have acquired the basic skill to respond to an attack from any angle, to any target on their body. Finally, they are highly permutable. Different seihō share similar parameters, so that one can flow into another, or the response in one might be used in a different, but similar seihō.
Nagaoka’s description of Gasshi, the very first part of the first shiai-seihō is also very interesting from the perspective of historic shiai. (Here is a description in case the link above should ever break; shidachi and uchidachi start standing roughly 30 feet apart, and with shinai held overhead, both approach the middle. They stop at a point with both just a little outside striking distance. Uchidachi takes a big step forward with their right foot, cutting straight. In response shidachi does the same, a big step forward with their right foot, cutting straight. The slight delay in shidachi’s response allows them cut over uchidachi’s cut, deflecting it to the side as shidachi’s shinai lands on uchidachi’s head. Both then step back, and do it again, this time cutting with the left foot.)
Nagaoka writes: “In the past, this was a type of higiri-jiai. Now we use the winning form of this shiai as a seihō.”[1]
I will talk about the meaning of higiri in the next part of this series, but there are three clear takeaways from these statements by Nagaoka. One is that shiai was a part of regular practice, and indeed that even beginners engaged in it. Two, we see issues with shiai being addressed with more kata. Third, with the statement “Gasshi is a type of shiai,” we can see that there are multiple parameters for shiai. It can be as open as a modern kendo shiai, or as limited as both practitioners in jōdan, both cutting straight against each other.
Moving on, young Toshishige eventually grew up and inherited the ryū and his hereditary position as heihō instructor. His son was Yagyū Sangorō Toshichika, the 19th sōke of Shinkage-ryū, and the last heihō instructor to the Owari Tokugawa. He oversaw the transition of the ryū from the Bakumatsu to the Meiji Era.
In 1868, Lord Yoshikatsu, the last lord of Owari and 18th sōke of Shinkage Ryū, opened the Meirindō, one of the early public schools of the Meiji era. As part of the school he also opened the Shidaibu Dojo, and invites practitioners of various ryūha to do uchikomi-jiai. Toshichika was appointed the dean of kenjutsu instruction for the dojo. According to Yagyū Toshinaga in his book Shōden Shinkage Ryū, the Shidaibu Dojo was devoted purely to shiai.[2]
The dojo project deteriorated after various edicts, such as the Haitorei, which ended the era of the bushi as warriors, and made the various ryūha ostensibly obsolete. In later years the Butokukai would be established to promote the training and transmission of classical and modern budo as a whole, but at that time Toshichika had decided to devote himself to purely passing down his family tradition of Shinkage Ryū.
I think what we have here is a major decision point for Shinkage Ryū. We can see the general trend towards shiai-centric practice, we can see the movement for involving multiple ryūha. Toshichika was intimately involved in that movement, at least as far as the Meirindō and Shidaibu Dojo were concerned. But either because of the experience, or in spite of it, Toshichika decided to step out of these movements, and focus on maintaining the essential character of Shinkage Ryū. We can imagine that had he chosen differently, Shinkage Ryū might have only survived in a few kata or pieces of kata in modern kendo.
On June 19th, 1885, Toshichika and his cousin Toshihiro traveled to Yagyū Village in Nara, and asked for a shiai with any of the former retainers of Yagyū Domain. I think it’s an interesting point that they did not offer to train or demonstrate kata, but that they wanted to see the vitality of the ryū in Yagyū Domain through a shiai.[2]
In 1913, Toshichika opened the Hekiyōkan Dōjō in Tokyo, and began teaching Shinkage-ryū to the Imperial Household Police. Toshichika’s son, Toshinaga, accompanied Toshichika to Tokyo, and was named sōke in 1922. He took over the Hekiyōkan after Toshichika retired back to Nagoya, and later opened the Kongōkan Dōjō, where he practiced until returning to Nagoya in 1935. While in Tokyo, he also taught kenjutsu to the Konoe Shidan (Imperial Guard).
In 1935, Yagyū Toshinaga gave a weeklong lecture series at Kokushikan University. These lectures were collected into a book called Kendō Hachikō, or “Eight Lectures on Kendo”. Kendo here is meant is the broadest possible sense as including modern kendo and classical schools. And here we can see Toshinaga’s image of ideal training, informed by his experience in Yagyū Shinkage Ryū.[3] I have already made a post about that lecture series, so in the interest of space, I will just provide a link to that.
Toshinaga shepherded Shinkage Ryū through the war and post-war years, eventually founding the Yagyūkai in 1955.
Toshinaga’s son, Nobuharu Toshimichi brought Shinkage-ryū to the 21st century, and accepted the first non-Japanese into the ryū that we know of. I want to wrap the historical examination by looking at his experience training during his teen years, as described in the book Dai-Sempai ni Kiku.
After practicing seihō they would don bōgu and try to actually strike each other with those techniques. About twenty primary school-age children would come to the dojo every Sunday, and [Toshimichi] was responsible for guiding them through basic practice.
He said, “There was a spirit of, ‘Let’s get some bōgu on and go at it freely, for real.’ Now I no longer have the old dojo, and time is limited, so we first work on the most important things.”[4]
The old Nagoya dojo, part of the Yagyū manor, burned down in the fire bombing of Nagoya in March of 1945, and the land was later appropriated by the city of Nagoya as part of the rezoning and reconstruction efforts. So it was at this point, after the war, roughly 400 years after the founding of the ryū, that Yagyū Shinkage Ryū moved to a kata-exclusive model.
Nevertheless, it maintains a path to shiai, both in the content of the shiai-seihō, and also in how all kata are practiced. I will explore this path in the next part.
[1] 新陰流兵法外伝 Shinkage Ryū Heihō Gaiden, “Shinkage Ryū Heihō Supplemental Teachings,” date unknown, by Nagaoka Fusashige, published in Shiryō Yagyū Shinkage Ryū, ed. Imamura Yoshio, revised edition 1995.
[2] 正伝新陰流 Shoden Shinkage Ryu, “True Transmission Shinkage Ryu,” 1957, by Yagyū Toshinaga.
[3] 剣道八講 Kendō Hachikō, “Eight Lectures of Kendo,” 1998, by Yagyū Toshinaga, ed. Yagyūkai.
[4] 大先輩に聞く Dai-sempai ni Kiku, “Listening to our Great Seniors,” 2005, by Taya Masatoshi.
r/Koryu • u/OwariHeron • Nov 01 '24
Shiai and Koryu: The Case of Yagyu Shinkage Ryu, Part Four
Now we’re going to look at how Yagyū Shinkage Ryū is practiced, particularly in relation to levels of “aliveness.” The Yagyū Shinkage Ryū curriculum is broadly divided into two groups: the honden (original teachings) and the gaiden (supplemental teachings). The honden are the tachi devised and passed down by Kamiizumi Hidetsuna and Yagyū Munetoshi (including beginner’s versions of two of these forms devised by 5th soke Yagyū Renya and 6th soke Lord Tokugawa Mitsutomo). The gaiden are made up of the shiai-seihō devised by assistant instructor Nagaoka Fusashige, plus some unique forms developed by Renya.
Let’s say that a young man named Tarō has joined Yagyū Shinkage Ryū. His first couple of training sessions he learns the reihō, he learns (more or less) how walk with his shinai held overhead, how to do a straight cut with both feet, how to do a diagonal cut with his right foot (right to left), and then his left foot (left to right). Then he learns how to do gasshi. It’s the most essential gokui of Yagyū Shinkage Ryū, and the hardest thing to do right, so naturally it is the very first thing he learns how to do. Very quickly, he’s taught the five parts of Sangaku En no Tachi. This is a beginner’s version, with all exchanges happening from that shinai overhead position. As soon as he knows the basic shape of this, he’s moved on to the first shiai-seihō. This is Airaitō Hasseihō: eight distinct seihō to teach fundamentals. These two kata are going to be pretty much all his training for the next sixth months. (Some other lines might include the beginner’s version of Kuka no Tachi at this stage, but the idea is still the same.) In the honden he will polish the mental/spiritual side (kurai) while practicing timing, and the subtle interaction of cutting lines. In the shiai-seihō, he will work on energetic, whole-body movement while honing his senses of timing and distance. Nagaoka wrote in his commentary of the shiai-seihō that, "I have included the rocks with the jewels, to encourage 博文約礼 hakubun-yakurei (correct behavior by broad learning)."
In this initial phase, Tarō’s practice is what we call torigai 鳥飼, which means “bird-handling.” Uchidachi’s shinai will never strike Tarō, but Tarō’s shinai will always strike the uchidachi. The idea here is to train a conditioned response. One might think that he is learning how to “do it right,” but “correctness” is less of a concern than doing it with whole body and spirit. Better to make a mistake doing it with all that you are than timidly and pedantically trying to “do it right.”
Eventually, as Tarō starts moving well, carrying himself with confidence and dignity, he learns the next shiai-seihō forms: fourteen with Tarō in seigan against an uchidachi with shinai overhead, and then another eight with Tarō in gedan against uchidachi with shinai overhead. In our line, this is where he learns the beginner’s form of Kuka no Tachi. At this point, his seniors start practicing with him in a way we call torigai higiri. Higiri can be written in two ways: 間斬り “cutting openings” or 非斬り “cutting what should not be.” Having gotten into the habit of doing things with all his body and mind, now Tarō starts working on getting the technical aspects right, because uchidachi’s shinai will strike him if the technique is not properly performed. The important distinction between this stage and later stages is that the uchidachi is not specifically trying to hit Tarō, other than in the sense of cutting to particular target. Rather, the hits could be considered “self-inflicted.” If Tarō did not do the technique wrong, he would not have been hit. His uchidachi is simply fully cutting to a particular target. Although Tarō begins to be struck on his hands or legs, it’s not especially painful and skin scrapes aside, it’s rarely injurious. Again, the goal is creating a further conditioned response: ignoring being struck, staying in the moment, and continuing the kata.
Tarō’s practice continues, and sometime after a year of regular training, he learns the standard version of Sangaku En no Tachi, with cuts starting from a chūdan or gedan position. He’s learned to make these kinds of cuts in the various shiai-seihō, so it is not a big jump to start doing the form in this way. Now his seniors start practicing in a way called higiri. Here Tarō’s uchidachi really start stress-testing him. Targets become variable. If his uchidachi see an opening, or they see Tarō starting to rely too much on the expected form of the kata, they may break the kata to strike where he has left himself open.
Tarō’s uchidachi begin altering timing and distance and making Tarō adjust. Particularly in the shiai-seihō, his uchidachi try to push Tarō out of his comfort zone, so that he can see where he needs to improve. And while being struck in earlier stages didn’t really hurt, being struck here hurts a lot. At this point, Tarō’s conditioned response has been trained enough so that even while his brain registers that a hit really smarts, he doesn’t even flinch.
The ability to properly watch his uchidachi and respond if they bend or even break the kata is important, because sometime 2 to 3 years after joining, Tarō starts learning how to do the uchidachi side. Initially, he will practice uchidachi with others of roughly the same level, and they are not as precise or controlled as the veterans he’s been practicing with until now. At the same time as he is learning uchidachi for the shiai-seihō he already knew, he’s also learning new shiai-seihō. These new shiai-seihō are especially helpful, as often they are set-up the opposite of the earlier shiai-seihō he learned: shidachi with shinai overhead against uchidachi in seigan or gedan. Essentially, he is learning, as shidachi, counters and responses to the techniques he’s receiving as uchidachi in the earlier shiai-seihō. But not in sense of “If A, then B,” but rather, “here are multiple possible ways of dealing with something A-like.”
Four to five years in, Tarō learns both the shidachi and uchidachi side of the standard version of Kuka no Tachi. This is significant because until now, his practice with his juniors has been under the watchful eye of a senior. But now he’s considered a shidōsha, someone who can be trusted to practice with a junior on his own. At the same time, his practice with other shidōsha now moves to the higiri-jiai stage. This means that both shidachi and uchidachi are on the look out for openings, and may break the kata if applicable. But in the case of the shiai-seihō, is it breaking the kata if one simply slips into another kata?
Let’s look at a practical example. In the 2nd seihō of Airaito Hasseihō, shidachi and uchidachi approach. Shortly before entering into cutting distance, shidachi surreptitiously slips their foot into range, and quickly strikes at uchidachi’s upraised forearm. Shidachi follows up by advancing a few steps, pushing uchidachi back. It is incumbent that shidachi stay in contact with uchidachi as uchidachi retreats and not get stuck in place or run out of steam. The reason why is demonstrated in a later shiai-seihō. In that later seihō, the set-up is exactly the same with shidachi striking first and driving uchidachi back. But in that seihō, uchidachi shoots back to create enough distance do a retreating cut at shidachi’s hands. Shidachi must now switch from driving uchidachi back, to cutting down this new attack. Between two veteran practitioners, familiar with these seihō, it is nothing for uchidachi to slip into the later seihō if he deems shidachi’s cut and advance is not sufficiently preventing him from doing so. Ideally, shidachi should be able to naturally respond to it, as trained. And that response may not necessarily be from the same seihō!
Practically, one may not see many such variations over the course of a practice. At that point, practitioners are so aware that it could happen that they practice so it doesn’t happen. Their practice is infused with the tension of this potentiality. The standard “shape” of the kata is not the goal of the practice, but simply the end result of both practitioners fulfilling the particular parameters of that kata. The infrequent, but not uncommon, variations are themselves entirely valid shapes.
It should also be noted that while these various stages have been clearly delineated through the example of Tarō’s practice above, in actuality the boundaries are not so distinct. From the beginning, Tarō’s been told to look out for openings in his uchidachi, and even to strike them if he sees them. Depending on his relationship and affinity with various seniors, as well as the particular thing being practiced, his torigai practice was leavened with torigai-higiri, or even straight higiri to illustrate a particular point, or to point out his own inattention/reliance on the expected shape of the kata.
And while it is ostensibly expected, and the ideal form of practice, higiri-jiai can be a fraught affair. Trust is needed, for both safety and for the maintenance of personal relationships, particularly among peers. There is a fine line between good-faith demonstration of an opening, and cheap-shotting someone. Some people, finding it a little too intense to do among their peers, or reluctant to do it with seniors, end up only doing a kind of torigai-higiri.
But with this framework, we can see how Yagyū Toshinaga saw another step to bridge higiri-jiai to full on shiai: you can set up shiai within particular shiai-seihō parameters—say, jodan vs chudan or jodan vs jodan—either open or with specified targets. And you can also see Nagaoka Fusashige’s goal: you can have entirely open shiai, where the strategies, targets, and techniques, are heavily informed by shapes vigorously trained in the shiai-seihō.
So, currently, entirely open shiai is not officially practiced in mainline Yagyū Shinkage Ryū. Should it be?
I don’t it think necessarily needs to be. For one, modern kendo is an outlet for people who really just want to engage is a kind of free practice, unbound by any parameters of kata-geiko.
I’ve also come to the conclusion that maintaining the integrity of the honden and gaiden requires intensive effort. I don’t know if it’s a manifestation of entropy, but even now, doing kata exclusively, in the manner described above, some people with the best of intentions have a tendency to do the kata in a mannered way, or, desiring to do the kata “right,” do not imbue it with the life it needs. I fear that, as Yagyū Toshimichi suggested, if we split our limited time between kata and shiai, that tendency would be increased, particularly if the shiai came to be seen as doing it “for real”. I go back to Nagaoka-sensei’s preface to the shiai-seihō, and note that even back then, shiai were enough of an issue that he actually created more kata.
In the meantime, higiri and higiri-jiai provide a degree of “aliveness” for feedback, particularly in the shiai-seihō. And finally, by diligently working to maintain the process described here, a framework exists to return to shiai if desired.
In conclusion, Yagyū Shinkage Ryū Heihō is a Sengoku era ryūha extant today with a focus exclusively on kata, but which has nevertheless been strongly associated with shiai in its practice since its beginning. Its dedicated use of the fukuroshinai allows it to create a spectrum of “aliveness” throughout the training process. It is probable that similar ryūha existed throughout the Edo period. Yagyū Shinkage Ryū can be seen as an exemplar of the type of ryū in the Meiji period that, when faced with the change of kendo from distinct “proprietary” styles to a more homogenized “open source” paradigm, chose to maintain a primary focus on its kata in order to preserve its particular character.