r/KnowledgeFight • u/oracleomniscient • Aug 30 '24
Telegram?
What the hell is Dan on about? I don't see how arresting someone who failed to regulate rampant crime on the utility they created and profit off of while also refusing to let anyone else regulate is a salient free speech discussion. Asking someone to murder your wife is speech, but there's no "having a point" in opposing it's criminalization. If anything, I think it's lenient to only arrest him after refusing to cooperate.
Idk, maybe I'm being too hard on him, but this feels like a particularly problematic manifestation of his compulsory "both sides"-ism. You not only have to ignore the world we do live in, you have to ignore that there even could be a world beyond this case.
Edit: All right, I'm sick of y'all upward hand-throwing cowards missing the forest for the same two trees over and over.
7
Aug 30 '24
I think calling a messaging app a utility is a bit of an overstatement
0
u/Kriegerian Space Weirdo Aug 30 '24
There are countries where Facebook and WhatsApp basically are the Internet. Russia isn’t one of them, but in some places that’s a true statement.
That reality raises a bunch of other questions, first of which being “why do we allow some fucking Silicon Valley creep to basically be the Internet for X millions of people in Y number of countries?”
3
Aug 30 '24
Right, but that's not the context of the statements op has been making. We are talking about the EU, where that's not the case, and they specifically said messenger apps, not apps that, amongst other things, allow messages. Telegram isn't a utility. OP also flat-out comments in the comment that they are bending the definition of that word to suit their whims.
-2
u/oracleomniscient Aug 30 '24
You're incorrect. In the world we live in now, even unencrypted messaging apps are effectively necessary.
16
u/CatJamarchist Doing some research with my mind Aug 30 '24
What you're ignoring is that a 'utility' generally refers to a public service
Telegram is a private service.
Public utilities and private services are regulated in different ways - it's fair to argue that platforms like telegram should be regulated like a public utility - but they currently are not.
6
-4
u/oracleomniscient Aug 30 '24
Yes, it's a utility that's not being properly provided. That said, I don't view governments and large-scale corporations to be distinct enough for that constructual distinction to be worth making.
9
u/CatJamarchist Doing some research with my mind Aug 30 '24
Yes, it's a utility that's not being properly provided.
No, it's not - it's a private service that could become a utility if laws are passed to make it so.
Your insistence that messaging services like Telegram are a utility does not make it a fact - utilities must be legislated.
I don't view governments and large-scale corporations to be distinct enough for that constructual distinction to be worth making
This makes no sense because utilities are literally legislated in to existence. A company just being 'big' has no bearing on whether it should be a utility or not. Eg: LVMH (Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton) is a 500+ billion dollar corporation - and it would make no sense to consider a fashion company a utility just because it's really big.
7
Aug 30 '24
I disagree, and I find it odd you keep stating your opinions like they are solid facts.
Also, even if they were necessary, that doesn't mean they were a utility. Not every necessity is a utility.
-9
u/oracleomniscient Aug 30 '24
Are you truly this unself-aware? I will admit that I'm using "utility" in a looser sense, including things like food and medicine.
8
u/CatJamarchist Doing some research with my mind Aug 30 '24
I will admit that I'm using "utility" in a looser sense, including things like food and medicine.
But why are you doing this? This is obviously going to confuse people in a situation like this because there are clear differences between actual public utilities and private services.
Public utilities and private services are regulated very differently - the difference between how food production is regulated VS the water utility is regulated is vast - you can't just treat them the same because it's convenient to your point.
7
9
u/Darkwing_Turducken Aug 30 '24
I’m not sure if what he articulated aligns with my feelings on this, but, while someone is ultimately responsible for the criming done by a company (or, in this case, the abetting of criming), determining who that is can be complicated, so just throwing it all on the CEO’s shoulders can seem questionable. There may be technical reasons why Telegram can’t release the requested data without compromising the data of uninvolved parties (it’s Telegram, so I’m not using “innocent”), and maybe that’s not being communicated or reported effectively. There are too many things we don’t know about Telegram, but we do know how capricious the Russian government can be against people it decides it doesn’t like, so there is room to give this guy the benefit of the doubt at this time.
0
u/oracleomniscient Aug 30 '24
The point still stands, though, that harms were deemed acceptable by Telegram until a government threatened their business, so they're still guilty of imprisonment-justifying crimes.
-1
u/oracleomniscient Aug 30 '24
I mean, I don't particularly trust the French government, but it feels silly to imagine that they would make this decision without confidence in their evidence of his guilt, and I don't see them helping out Russia. Maybe Israel, though.
24
Aug 30 '24
Edit: All right, I'm sick of y'all upward hand-throwing cowards
What does that even mean lol? Also, why are we cowards now for disagreeing with you? You are being so unnecessarily aggressive with people just trying to have a conversation about a podcast.
-16
Aug 30 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
11
Aug 30 '24
Holyshit who pissed in your cheerios?
I don't know if you notice but the subreddit has rules, first of which is about civility. So actually many people care if someone is being rude and aggressive to everyone else for no reason.
I'm not even going to touch the borderline racism of that english comment.
5
u/aragorn407 Literal Vampire Potbelly Goblin Aug 30 '24
“Who pissed in your cheerios” lmao I’m using that one
5
Aug 30 '24
I wish i could take credit for it lol, i heard someone else say it and it stuck in my brain
4
u/KnowledgeFight-ModTeam Aug 30 '24
This post is abusive or harassing. Please treat others with courtesy and respect while you are here.
11
39
u/CatJamarchist Doing some research with my mind Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24
I think you're missing some of the nuance of Dan's point - because he's right, it is a complicated situation.
Lets wind back the technological clock a little bit for a clearer example (because internet platforms are a whole lot more messy)
Imagine a Mob boss calls up a goon of theirs on an AT&T landline and says "Hey go whack a dude" - the fact that the evidence of a crime occurred on AT&T's landline does not automatically mean that AT&T themselves should be liable for that crime, just because it was facilitated on the landlines that they installed and maintain - especially if AT&T doesn't actually know the content of the call, just that the call occurred.
It's perfectly reasonable for someone to argue that AT&T should not be liable in that scenario - just like it's perfectly reasonable for someone else to argue 'Well AT&T should cooperate with an investigation and turn-over the record of who called who, and when that call occurred as part of an investigation" - and in fact (AFAIK) that's what the law decided - AT&T doesn't know the content of the call, so they can't be liable for it - but they can be subpoenaed for call records that can be used for an investigation, AT&T refusing to hand over such records would then make them liable for obstruction, etc.
The wrinkle with Telegram is that it's not always end-to-end encrypted (as Dan noted), so telegram does in some cases know the content of the messages and the who's and when's of the messages - hence why it's much easier to argue that the CEO of Telegram is liable in these cases when they refuse to cooperate at any level - nevertheless, the above example of phone-lines remains the central thrust of the defense, and is pretty understandable, up to a point.
5
u/VividBig6958 Aug 30 '24
Stonewalling the French Government while being a French citizen running a company with a French presence comes across to me as the crux of prosecutorial ire. Claiming a benefit from the state without meeting the obligations of the state is a non-nebulous claim unlike some of the others. Be interesting to see how this pans out.
3
u/DeepFriedCherry Aug 31 '24
Idk man I just listen to the funny Alex Jones podcast. I don't see any point in looking for tiny little cracks in their (Jordan and Dan's) ideology to tear them down, I listen to them bc I like what they do, and I'm not going to stop listening or liking the podcast over something so freaking minute lol.
-5
Aug 30 '24
Prior to early September 2001 no one thought there was a compelling case to let the government access broad communications information period.
2
u/hiiamtom85 Aug 30 '24
That’s not really true, it’s just more people took for granted free speech sophistry because it hadn’t blown up publicly yet. Why would people challenge the status quo in the US on speech even though it had been challenged repeatedly by voices squashed into silence by the fact that speech isn’t actually free? Who was going to question a bunch of lawyers pontificating about the value of the court system and the Skokie decision?
People like lawyers opinion on the legal tradition and value of things a lot less than they did a quarter century ago for good reason, trying to appeal to what was even at the time mythology for what is still a nebulous benefit deserves to be challenged.
0
Aug 30 '24
[deleted]
6
4
u/AssociationGold8749 Aug 30 '24
Or in Iran to get around government surveillance during their protests, or by journalists to give their sources anonymity etc.
58
u/AssociationGold8749 Aug 30 '24
Balancing individual freedom with the needs of the public will be a debate forever, and will likely intensify as we grow more and more interconnected.
In the real world people use services like Telegram to evade oppressive governments. The need for secure messaging is shared by both criminals and ordinary people. I could see taking down an encrypted messaging service to prosecute a crime in the US could mean a gay person in a Muslim country ends up dead. How do you prevent that from happening?