r/KnowingBetter • • Jul 06 '19

Counterpoint Knowing Better’s Fall from Moderation

16 Upvotes

Now it may just be me, but in my opinion, the Knowing Better channel has had a steep decline in balanced and moderate perspectives and has slowly slid to the left side of the political spectrum. I have no problem with his channel having a political leaning and if he wants to post videos that support that political view. But he has built a reputation on how he is a political moderate and likes to take a balanced and unbiased approach towards many topics. A personal favorite video of mine from this channel is “Just Plain Racist.” https://youtu.be/cfs3SSNB6rI) As he mentioned once in a separate video, in the comments of the Just Plain Racist video, he got called a Nazi and leftie. I found this peculiarly interesting as I think it really displayed how unbiased and down to reality he was.

I’ve always appreciated his ability to truly be a political moderate. I treated his channel as a particularly trustworthy source in the sense that he would usually give a straightforward and balanced opinion and analysis. As someone who tries to be a centrist, his videos were a really great find. There’s not many channels or even videos that are able to pull that off and not many that even try. He truly established his position as a political moderate. It was rare to come across people that even have that title rather even attempt to have it. His videos were taken by me as very informational and unconcerned with shoving his beliefs down my throat. But, especially recently, his leaning has seemed to become ever apparent.

A few weeks ago, Knowing Better released a video on feminism. I, for one, was fairly excited. Feminism had always been hard topic for me without choosing a particular side. It is very much a yes or no belief. I was hoping that Knowing Better would a blatant and unapologetically factual analysis on feminism, one that I could pick up on and understand and possibly shape into my own outlook on the topic. But the video lacked any of my hopes and simply delivered a very biased and opinionated view on the topic. I finished the video disappointed. He very rarely criticized the movement or showed a negative side to the belief and it’s ideas. (I’m not saying I wanted a criticism of equality just one of the modern day feminist movement which has a much different implication.)

Anyways, it seems he is taking a trend towards bias, especially on political videos, which I find disappointing. He used to seem to have a very strong sense of independence from political leaning in his videos. I’m not saying he’s not allowed to have opinions. I’m not saying he suddenly needs to delete that video or any other videos with bias. It’s his channel and his videos. He can do with it what he wants. I just wanted to see if anyone else noticed this. For me it just confirms that I cannot watch his videos anymore without afterwards shaking off the biased opinions sprinkled throughout. It is for sure disappointing but I still very much love his channel and his videos that don’t have political issues discussed. I hope he continues to make great content and that his channel only grows. He does a lot of great work and has multiple informative and analytical videos that are great for education. Feel free to critique this or agree. Just wanted to throw my opinion out there.

Peace.


r/KnowingBetter • • Sep 08 '26

Suggestion Unpopular Opinion: KB's long form video style are ultimately a bad idea, however well-intentioned.

0 Upvotes

KB has been making videos on YouTube for the better part of the last 10 years. We've watched him go from 10-15 minute videos to 3 part 3 hour long video series that take years to make. Each progressive topic only seems to require a longer video, regardless of the topic. He argues this is because this is necessary to convey the information in the most honest way possible, but I disagree. In this post, I'm not only going to argue why I disagree, I am also going to make an argument for why it ultimately doesn't matter if I agree or not, because 3 hour long videos are never going to be a good idea.

Knowing Better likes to do his research. I think his videos are a way for him to learn about topics he cares about. This is a good thing. When you want to get things right, you take your time to do the work of learning as much as you can about a topic. Problem is you need to convince your audience why they should care. Which means also means they have to care enough to watch the entire thing. KB doesn't always do a good job of "knowing" what is really important for the audience to know. This is a hard thing to do, so I don't entirely blame him. The issue is this problem becomes more obvious the longer the video gets. The latest Hawaii video is a good case in point. There's just way too much in it. Too much for a video anyway. I know there are die-hards that would disagree. They would say the quality is still top notch and that's all that matters. I say, if you have to write a script the length of a book. You might as well just write a book.

KB's video essay style has improved over the years. Audio quality, video quality, improv characters, cameo characters, archival footage.... the list goes on. It's been quite impressive. Ultimately though, 95% of the videos are still just KB talking to a camera in his apartment. It gets a bit boring. It's really hard watching the same guy talk to a camera for 3 hours in the same space. Documentary style videos have a lot of set locations and guests for that reason. After an hour or so, it starts to feel like a ramble, people lose focus, pick a different video, and some never return. If a third of the people that watch your video leave because they're bored. That's not good.

These videos take a lot of time and effort to make. I'd like to see KB make a good amount of money from them. But asides the reasons I have already mentioned, time between videos, I don't see his channel generating a lot of buzz. Buzz is not the point, but it's still important.

IMHO, something between 50 to 90 minutes is the sweet spot for a long form video on YouTube. Anything longer, you might as well make a documentary or movie. Or write a book. Also, you hit diminishing returns on effort spent on making the video.


r/KnowingBetter • • Oct 23 '20

Joe Biden is quite possibly the best candidate for Vice President

0 Upvotes

He is

-smart

-compassionate

-honest

-funny

-caring

-has a sense of humility

-communicative

-can read a teleprompter

-enthusiastic

Don't know why KB hates him so much. Better than Gabbard!


r/KnowingBetter • • Mar 04 '21

Counterpoint I love Knowing Better's videos, and loved his latest video on libertarianism - but he lost me when he began talking about Neoliberalism. I would love to discuss with him some of the inaccuracies in this video regarding neoliberalism.

22 Upvotes

As a forward, I felt the need to make this post because the typical misinformed fringe left dogwhistle of "All politicians are just useless Neoliberals who agree on economics!!!" is not something I expected from KB, and immediately disheartened me. I find it incredibly difficult to believe that his line on "Both parties fundamentally agreeing on economics" is informed by any historical readings or research, as it is probably the easiest to disprove line of thinking currently popular in political discourse in the US.

While he got the fundamentals correct on Neoliberalism, he was incorrect on the foundation of the term, and what it initially meant - it was actually coined in the late 1800's to describe a moderate capitalist economic policy with a strong state and welfare net to intervene and prevent collapses a-la the great depression. This is why people, specifically those further on the left in the democratic party, tend to use this term interchangably to refer to completely different ideologies, such as Reaganomics and Pete Buttigieg. This kind of incorrect usage is dogwhistled by KB (knowingly or not, I don't want to make assumptions) during the tail end of his video.

Secondly, the idea that all American presidents past Reagan have been Neoliberals is incredibly suspect and downright misinformation. I would agree that Reagan, HW Bush, Clinton, and Bush Jr. were all neoliberals, but Obama nor Trump qualify as Neoliberals. The type of Neoliberalism KB discusses is the post-Pinochet usage, or the usage most commonly used to refer to Reagan/Thatcher.

This usage encompasses a wide variety of economic policies, so it's important to narrow things down - generally, it's best described as the assessment that laissez-faire economics helps the economy while government controls and barriers hinder it, lowered barriers to trade and immigration with other countries, and the prioritization of profit margins over social justice and social safety networks. This definition intentionally excludes things, which I will now point out as blatantly as I can -Neoliberalism has absolutely nothing to do with military intervention, nor does it have anything to do with most aspects of social issues. Military intervention doesn't make you more of a neoliberal, and being a dove doesn't make you any less.

With that out of the way, it's immediately evident that no, not all presidents have been Neoliberals, and no, both parties do not fundamentally agree on it. This is clear as day if you actually understand the definition and history of Neoliberalism.

Protectionist economic policies - i.g "Make it in America!" and "TPP is bad!" are both diametrically opposed to Neoliberalism. Tons of Donald Trump's economic policies are inherently opposed to it, and more fall under the categorization of populist conservative fiscal policy, not neoliberalism. Not only that, but Trump was majorly opposed to free movement - immigration - another major aspect of Neoliberalism. Him being a warhawk has no bearing on this status. Sure, he has things in common with Neoliberalism, but the idea that he is one is genuinely laughable.

Second, with Obama, he absolutely did not agree with Republicans on most economics. Obamacare was originally a public option - which no, is not a neoliberal "corporate democrat" plot to keep insurance companies wealthy. Bernie Sanders is wrong when he says most of the world has his plan - only three countries have eliminated private insurance, most first world countries have the Public OPption. Obama had to scrap this plan because he just didn't have enough control of the government. We live in a Democracy - even if plans are objectively better, which a public option is, we aren't a dictatorship.

Even outside of Healthcare, Obama was a major proponent of welfare programs and government intervention. The 2009 stimulus bill would make most actual neoliberals cringe - and again, I hate that I have to pre-emptively fend off misinformation, but Obama's bailing out of banks/industries were NOT neoliberal, neoliberalism would be to let them fail, and consequently let the US fall apart into economic anarchy, where actual Reagan Neoliberals would say "See??? Government screwed us, we must rebuild as Ayn Rand said!".

I could go into more detail, but no, neither Obama or Trump are Neoliberals.

Lastly, no, both parties don't "Generally agree on economics", there are just a lot of unfounded economic ideas among the Bernie Sanders wing of the party that make you think reforms are needed where they're not.

Firstly, Bernie's brand of protectionist economics (Leaving the TPP, stopping outsourcing, encouraging production in the US) are completely unsupported by any economist on the left or right side of the spectrum. Rent Control has been, throughout history, a major policy failure and has not worked, and again, no major economists anywhere on the spectrum back it. The 15$ minimum wage is generally not supported by economists anywhere on the spectrum, and most of the rosiest economic analyses have found that the amount of people it would help/hurt would be roughly the same, therefore leaving the minimum wage a wash - most economists agree somewhere around 12$ would be far better. And as I said before, Single Payer is a terrible idea in the US at the moment - it's not exactly unfounded economically, but making such a gigantic leap when so much of the country is not on board is insane. What Bernie/Berniecrats won't tell you is that the support for a Public Option approaches 70%, but with the stipulation that "It will eliminate private insurance" it falls to less than 30%.

Democrats have been proposing a major government reform to healthcare since [Hillarycare back in the early 90's](https://ballotpedia.org/%22Hillarycare%22_(The_proposed_Health_Security_Act_of_1993). They've been, since the mid 2000's, opposing tax cuts for the rich, and proposing increasing taxes for the rich. They have had, for decades now, a fundamentally opposing view with Republicans on social safety nets, welfare, and availability of higher education.

This is not hard to find, just read through presidential candidate policy proposals, policies that died during the Clinton/Obama administration, and it shows how completely different the parties are. The assertion that "all presidents past Reagan are Neoliberals" and that "The parties generally agree economically and have for decades" is misinformation foremost, and incredibly dangerous and only serves to push candidates who will fail in national elections because this type of thinking is incredibly niche and doesn't drive turnout with most of the country - independents.

Again, it's just disheartening to see KB repeat dogwhistles for misinformation that is so incredibly easy to disprove with just a surface amount of research. I'm not sure if he just has a blind spot for this specific area of politics or if he really is just agitating for Bernie-esque politics. I hope he responds to my post, because he has been my favorite politics YouTuber for his well researched and thought out videos, which have always been incredibly informative. It just doesn't seem reflected in the last section of this latest video.

Edit - To those downvoting my comments about dog whistling, I encourage you to do things like googling the definition of dog whistling, or reading things on its usage historically, not just in Twitter threads - /u/itwasbread is objectively wrong here and does not understand how to use the term.


r/KnowingBetter • • Oct 08 '24

Question Why is the Waco Siege portion of the SDA video so short and non-comprehensive?

0 Upvotes

I’ve been a fan since 2021 and have always appreciated the videos for being easy to digest, factual analyses of religion and other topics; so the Waco siege part of the SDA video threw me for a loop. It all feels dumbed down so much that it leaves out important facts. Some stuff I noticed was missing were:

  1. KB doesn’t mention how the Branch Dravidian’s never had a history of converting their weapons from semi to full auto

  2. No mention of how the ATF insider’s report (the one used to help justify the search warrant) had strange/misinformed details that made no sense

  3. No mention of how the raid didn’t even have to occur since the ATF could have just arrested David Koresh the next time he headed into town

  4. No mention of the FBI’s use of sleep deprivation on the cultists via blasting rabbit and dolphin sounds out of a loud speaker, leading to rash actions being made by the Branch Davidians due to a lack of sleep

  5. No mention of the feds taking pictures posing over dead Branch Davidians

And most importantly

6. Unlike 9/11 and “Jet fuel can’t melt steel beams”, “Who started the fire” has actual evidence pointing to the feds being responsible.

Without all of these details, it just looks like the ATF were just doing their job and it was all the Branch Davidians fault (David Koresh holds a portion of that blame, definitely, but this wasn’t a black and white case). He just brushes over all of it, jump cuts to the original Koresh, and then to the point about it being 9/11 before 9/11. I’m just a bit disappointed that he teased Waco in the beginning of the video only to build up to what amounts to surface level notes about their downfall. I still thought the rest of the video was really good, but I can’t wrap my head around why something that important wasn’t explained more.

Edit: After seeing the replies to this comment, I thought I should cover what everyone is saying because I think some people aren't getting the point.

Original Question: Why wasn't the Waco Siege part of the video longer?

"This isn't a video about the Waco Siege"

Yeah, I know that. The video doesn't need to be all about the siege. My problem is that nobody can properly summarize the Branch Davidians without the siege. The siege showed that there was no "good" side and that the case was even more botched than Ruby Ridge. Without all of the details or the court trials following the siege, people create an uninformed conclusion about this topic. A summary of Heaven's Gate isn't complete without their suicide ritual just as a summary of the Branch Davidians isn't complete without the siege. My question is: Why didn't KB paint a clear picture of the whole ordeal beginning-to-end if he was set on talking about it in the SDA video? Why not just save it for another video?

"Because it would stir up the anti-government people, like you"

Well, I'm not anti-government. I don't think the government is controlled by evil blood-sucking-lizard-demons or whatever. I still pay my taxes, go to jury duty, vote, follow laws, yada yada. Without the government doing its job we wouldn't have much of anything, so I'm pretty grateful that good-ole Uncle Sam exists. Your first point doesn't have any weight to it either. Talking about anything will rile up some fringe community somewhere. KB has criticized schools favoring white students and the militarization/growing power of police. Should he have just "stayed quiet" about these topics because they would make someone somewhere feel vindicated in hating schools, police, or the government in general?: No. The point of an informative video is to give facts and let the viewer come to their own conclusion. People like Alex Jones (anti-gov conspiracy theorists) already have their mind set on an answer and aren't the target audience of this video. I'd be surprised if anyone with political views similar to Alex Jones would even be able to get 2+ hours into the video.

"Stop staning the child molester, just believe the government."

This is probably the most confusing comment I saw. First: "child molester" is too broad of a term, he is a STATUTORY RAPIST, lets get that straight. Never once did I justify or defend anything he did because he was an evil person; that should be obvious. Your fault is thinking this is an issue where you have to take either the side of either the ATF/FBI or the Branch Davidians when it is not. The Branch Davidians are obviously not the "good guys", but the feds fumbled the case so badly and with so little regard for the lives they were supposed to save that they aren't "good" either. There is no side to root for. "Just believe the government" is the most uninformed thing i've seen about this topic. The ATF's search warrant for Mount Carmel falsifies that Koresh never left the compound, giving them a "reason" for why they had to meet him at the compound. Why they couldn't have just arrested him for statutory rape when he was outside of the compound is beyond me; they could have prevented the entire siege by doing that. Why would I trust them when they lied in the search warrent? Why would you trust them? (Before anyone tries to gotcha me, no, this doesn't contradict my last argument about not being anti-government. You can be skeptical of someone's ability to perform properly without being anti-gov. The only way we can change things like schools and policing for the better is to not blindly believe what they tell us, but rather to find the truth and use it to judge how these institutions can improve).

My problem with these responses are that they either brushed over my question or created caricatures of what they percieve I am and attacked that instead of the question I am presenting.

This all leads back to my question: why not add more details about the Waco Siege to the summary of Waco? That's THE thing people know Waco for. If it couldn't be fit into the video, then why even include Waco if people couldn't get all of the details about it? Why not have this be an SDA video and make Waco completely seperate? This isn't me praising Koresh nor is it me wanting to spread anti-government beliefs, this is me asking why not give viewers all of the facts about the topic.

TL;DR: Branch Davidians weren't good, the fed's response and siege weren't good, no justice was served to those David Koresh harmed. All I asked was: Why didn't KB cover the Waco Siege, the event Branch Davidians are most well known for, in his section on Branch Davidians? If he's making a stand alone video for them, then why include an incomplete picture of the story in the SDA video?


r/KnowingBetter • • May 04 '20

Tier list of modern KB videos, I really only take issue with the F tier

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/KnowingBetter • • Feb 11 '26 Popcorn

Question Have the parties swapped again?

0 Upvotes

With the craziness of maga at least half or more of the Republican party seems to be for laws they would have claimed treasonous not 15 years ago. While many of the more gentile progressive people I know are hardliners now. Pro gun and states rights.

I was a lifelong conservative until maga showed up I thought I was a Republican. I guess I'm not any more. I like Dwight Eisenhower and John McCains politics. Now Maga is in control and I don't even recognize the Republican party. As Reagan said the pretty left me. Although I never liked Reagan. I didn't vote for Trump as this is exactly what I foresaw happening.

What say you internet brain trust? Am I crazy or did maga break Conservatism? Did things switch again?


r/KnowingBetter • • Jun 12 '20

Please take down, or archive at least, the Columbus Video

0 Upvotes

Sorry to make a scene, but this has to he done.

Your past videos are good, but it has come to my attention that your "In Defense of Columbus" needs to go. It's been speculated that your video is being used to help revisionists justify his "innocence."

This is unrelated, but I have had an abusive ex girlfriend in the past that I never thought I would use a domestic hotline to help me. You're a great pal, but I believe you can't kick the can at the end of the trail.

Columbus did have good qualities, but the same could be said of Hitler.


r/KnowingBetter • • Aug 08 '24

In the News Curriculum/Homeschooling mom

3 Upvotes

Hi knowing better! I'm homeschooling my children and ran into your video on neoslavery. Have you thought about curating a curriculum of true history for those of us who doesn't know where to start or what to trust? I want to teach them true history and fully done.


r/KnowingBetter • • May 27 '23

Question Is there any way to talk to knowing better himself?

23 Upvotes

Ive been watching him religiously for about 5 years and id love to smoke a blunt and hop on a call for an hour with him. Even if we dont agree on a lot of political issues hes so fucking smart and such a critical thinker i think that conversation would be highly beneficial.

Im willing to pay whatever it takes. Does anybody know if hes active on his discord server voice chats? Or is there some other way I can pay to talk to the dude?


r/KnowingBetter • • Jul 16 '20

Counterpoint Actual Justice Warrior debunks KB's police militarization video

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/KnowingBetter • • Mar 21 '19

Watched like 3 videos from Knowing Better ...

2 Upvotes

I kind of like his videos, but in some of his videos his bold face proclamations and la-di-da-da attitude make him look foolish, especially when he is obviously reaching. It makes it look like he's trying to slip something by everyone who is watching his videos by just saying what he's saying forcefully and with an "and I'm obviously right here ..." kind of attitude, which is a way of being disingenuous.

Frankly he's just not nearly as bright as he thinks he is, but he could be if he was just more honest about what he's saying.

For example .. that bit about Jordan Peterson. I'm not a big Jordon Peterson fan, I think he's reaching a lot too ... but dog whistling to Nazi's ... REALLY ? I mean f'ing come on, that's reaching REALLY far and KnowingBetter was saying it just like it was fact.

The other way KnowingBetter is obviously disingenuous is that he has a strong political point of view underlying what he's saying ... he may not think he does, but he does, he's not being nearly as objective as he thinks he is. And I'll hand it to him, on some things he totally nails it, but I think he still needs more life experience outside of whatever circumstances he's grown up in to really see the world from enough different perspectives to make an honest argument for some of the things he's saying. He just hasn't walked in other people's shoes enough to try to pull off being the worldly objective person who has a reality based view of history that he thinks he is, maybe in another 10 or 20 years if he travels a lot and lives in a lot of different circumstances, in different parts of the country, etc ... for example, he's never spent a lot of time in rural areas or the south, it's obvious because he has a lot of urban stereotypes in his head when he's expressing himself, it's incredibly cringe worthy when he's talking because he has no real life experience with people from those places.

So my impression in general is that he's clever, and I basically like him, except that he's just not nearly as objective as he seems to think he is. It makes him come off like a 13 year old kid who thinks he knows everything. A lot of the things he's saying to debunk agendas are, in fact, ground in agendas .. but it's like he doesn't realize he himself has bought into some of these narratives.

TL;DR when you say something that your viewer knows for a fact is wrong, and you say it with a smug look on your face and a "can't fail" attitude that what you are saying is beyond question ... you look foolish and it's kind of cringy.


r/KnowingBetter • • Oct 01 '24

Question Is this a religious apologia channel?

0 Upvotes

This came up in my YouTube recommendations, specifically the SDA video.

I'm pretty much against the apocalyptic religions in their entirety, and don't want to give a view to anything to something that supports, justifies, propogates or encourages them. It wasn't clear from the YouTube description.

Thanks in advance.


r/KnowingBetter • • Aug 25 '26

Counterpoint what is the real intention in the first video?

8 Upvotes

the first video has so many red flags for me, I can't even begin to list them all. I know his narrative is that he wants to attack the sovereignty movement, but this video didn't address the sovereignty movement. it addressed a general understanding of hawaiian history.

there were so many small points which were clearly meant to be small offensives or attacks on hawaiian history. I also noticed a lot of in depth research on points that support his narrative, the or "colonial side" if that's what you want to call it, but what appears to be a lack of depth for the "other side" of the argument.

for example, one point that I am very familiar with is the ranking system. went over ali'i, maka'ainana, and kauwa, but did not adress that ali'i had more ranks then kaukau, Ali'i nui, and "mo'i". Mo'i as a term means King, but traditionally, it was ali'i aimoku which was the synonym. aimoku means to hold or feast on land (you control it's resources pretty much) and was the title for ali'i who controlled entire islands. ali'i nui is more general for the high chiefs. high chiefs had many ranks depending on their genealogy. Niaupi'o, wohi, pi'o, naha, ect ect. these ranks had their own Kapu which governed the lives of chiefs themselves. niaupi'o, pi'o, and wohi ali'i were the highest ranks, and most have the potential to become the ali'i aimoku, because they are usually the children of such. these ali'i held the mo'e kapu, meaning to prostrate (aka, bow down) before a higher ali'i. others had to bow before them, but not the wohi ali'is who's rank allowed themselves to be exempt. these titles among ali'i nui were reflective of responsibility rather then religious (as kapu are viewed as religious). Lili'uokalani was very christian, as was her siblings and most of the ali'i in the late 1800s. in the mele and oli written about her between the 1800s and until her death, she is referred to as a wohi ali'i. remember the beginning of the lilo and stitch song "e mahalo nui ia i ke ali'i wahine, ka wohi ku i ka moku". that part of the song comes from an oli which was titled Ka Wohi Ku I Ka Moku and appears after the overthrow. mark ho'omalu who helped develop mele no lilo for lilo and stitch recorded the full song in a modern style: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9V-4yDpoKo0 and can be found in the ulukau data base, pages 37-3

another thing: no need disrespect ka hae kanaka maoli. first off, if you come to hawai'i...no one serious is gonna tell you the kanaka maoli flag was made first. it doesn't need a basis in history to exist. it represents the Native Hawaiian people.
could have simply said in 2001 a flag was created to represent the Native Hawaiian and was called the Kanaka Maoli flag. false claims were created to say that this was the original hae hawai'i but this is untrue and not supported by historical text

personal opinion: reminds me of the royal standard of kalakaua a bit:

and remember, these are just two things that maybe were only a few minutes each. there was a pattern of times where...I just had to give eye and wonder...huuuui!, what you really want????


r/KnowingBetter • • Dec 15 '25

Suggestion Suggestion: Shorter videos?

2 Upvotes

I really enjoy how much time and effort KB puts into his videos, but the longer they get the more difficult it is to find time to watch them.

I know he’s already split his Hawaii video into three parts, and I’d love to see him do more shorter videos by splitting them into a series.

Maybe I’m the only one who feels this way, in which case please don’t change on my account; but I’m curious what others who Know Better think!


r/KnowingBetter • • Aug 24 '25

Question Is KB's first name a secret?

9 Upvotes

I've watched hours of KB; his videos are top shelf when it comes to things that silence my thoughts before bed. Brain food ASMR at its finest, but I'm now wondering what his name is. It could be anything from Steven to Carlos. I have no idea and honestly don't know if I want to.


r/KnowingBetter • • Jun 20 '26

Counterpoint Ricky Martin / Bad Bunny Songtext Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Hey,

I just wachted the part in your new Video (on Nebula) regarding the song text of Bad Bunny.

I'm german but understand some spanish.

I think it's not quite comparing anything to the native americans. It's more of fear of americanisation and capitalsm and replacement of people and culture.

I lived on a german island. Way smaller.

They are having fear of losing culture and people are being displaced because renting housing for tourist is bringing in more money. People have to leave the island because auf the tourist or mainland people who want to live there.

Thats a totally different fear then the comparison to the native americans. Espacially you know that this is not really whats happening.

Hawaii is really american now and he wants that Puerto Rico stays the way it is (or a least can keep the spirit or something).

You are a good example for that. You lived there but you are not really upholding the local culture. (No reproach) the local culture is getting displaced by the american one and as a german I can understand that that is not something you want.

Hope you can change that for the youtube upload! You yourself said that changing the narrative can be quite bad for a argument even if in good faith.

Add from my first upload:

I know that change can be good and most puerto ricans want more change. The questions is who is really peofiting of this? Rich people? How can this change be good for everyone and "fair"? How can the local people still control ghe local politoc if they have way less federal politic power and money?

Apart from this small counterpoint:

Loved this video!


r/KnowingBetter • • Jul 01 '19

TIL a genetic mutation can cause some people to have 4 cones that perceive color as opposed to the standard 3, which means they would be able to see 100 million colors while a normal person sees just 1 million.

Thumbnail
popsci.com
2 Upvotes

r/KnowingBetter • • Sep 01 '26

Counterpoint I made a video summarizing the evidence against Knowing Better's claims of widespread infanticide in Hawaii

Thumbnail
youtube.com
75 Upvotes

Around a month ago, I started a discussion here surrounding KB's claims of infanticide in Hawaii. I made a video responding and summarizing my argument: That KB's evidence is flawed, and his claims could contribute to white supremacist views.

I stay respectful and focus solely on KB's statements and citations. I don't say anything personal about him.

Long story short: Modern historians seriously question (some outright refute) that infanticide was widespread in Hawaii. My video summarizes and explains the evidence against widespread infanticide. The most damning piece of evidence against Knowing Better's claims is that his main source for infanticide, William Ellis would later testify to a House of Commons committee on Indigenous peoples that:

“Infanticide… did not prevail to any extent in the Sandwich Islands.” (Stannard, David E. “Recounting the Fables of Savagery: Native Infanticide and the Functions of Political Myth.” Journal of American Studies 25, no. 3 (1991): PAGE 397.)

There is also extensive evidence against widespread infanticide, such as other 19th century primary sources and modern osteological analyses.

Remember: KB's claim is that infanticide was widespread and very common in Hawaii and also existed prior to European contact. Infanticide existed in many cultures, the claim I am responding to here is that infanticide was more common than usual in Hawaii.


r/KnowingBetter • • Sep 24 '20

Question Thoughts on whether or not KB should remove/archive for patrons the first Columbus video

38 Upvotes

With protests starting back up again last night in response to Breonna Taylor’s murderers basically getting away with it last night, I remembered back to the beginning of the protests where, at that time, a lot of Columbus statues were being removed, whether by direct action or through government action. I also remember at that time seeing a lot of right wingers passing his first Columbus video around, especially on Facebook, using it to try to pass off that Columbus wasn’t “that bad”.

In my opinion, I honestly think the Columbus video should either be archived for patrons and/or removed in response to it being used by right wingers who show it, trying to get people to believe that Columbus wasn’t that bad.

I just wanted to hear y’all’s thoughts on the matter and what y’all think about whether or not the video should stay up. Also I apologize in advance if this has been brought up recently and/or a lot!


r/KnowingBetter • • Jun 23 '22

Suggestion KB there is news about NFT Bored Ape Yacht Club being a neo Nazi dog whistle and racist undertones. Could you investigate?

20 Upvotes

r/KnowingBetter • • Mar 02 '21

Small peeve about the length of Knowing Better's videos

1 Upvotes

I have noticed a trend in knowing better's most recent videos. They seem to be getting longer. The most recent one clocks in at almost 50 minutes. The one before that is just a few minutes shy of a full hour. I'm not sure this is necessary a good thing.

I suspect KB is doing this as a response to some of the criticisms against his videos, and general delivery style. A few YouTubers have made response videos to some of KB's most controversial videos, leveling all sorts of criticisms against him. Some valid, some not. I think KB is now trying to counter these criticisms by making his videos more robust and comprehensive. Try and make sure he covers all his bases, so to say. While I don't think there is anything wrong with this aim by itself, I don't think making longer videos is the best way to go about it.

Anything longer 30 mins is leaving educational video territory, and slipping into documentary territory. The problem is, if you're going to do a documentary, you need to up your production value some more. I'd expect to see more of the actual evidence on your videos (not you talking about the evidence for 50 minutes). I'd probably like to see some interviews from experts, witnesses.... that kind of thing. Making an hour long video with you speaking to the camera is very hard on the average viewer's attention span. I'm sorry, I really like KB, but I don't think spending the first 10 minutes of your video given us a history lesson on Ayan Rand is very useful.

TL;DR - KB's videos are always fun to watch, and a breath of fresh air when plowing through the dredge of YouTube, but if his videos are going to keep getting longer, I fear he may start to lose some of his casual viewers.


r/KnowingBetter • • Jul 27 '20

Is this for real? I don’t think so...

Thumbnail
latimes.com
1 Upvotes

r/KnowingBetter • • Oct 01 '23

Related Video I would like to read opinions on a dissenting video

0 Upvotes

Armoured Skeptic (AS), another youtuber I watch, posted a video specially rebutting a non-listed KB video on Columbus. The Skeptic video is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wjNmdHVGSvk
I posted the video previously and the mods took it down saying I wasn't being careful. AS certainly was not being careful, as per his brand. Here's me trying to being careful.

This topic is huge and fraught with problems. KB's original take, while maybe not perfect, was an interesting and less common viewpoint. It required a bit of bravery, because of the moral questions it raises. There seems to be agreement that Columbus Day should be replaced with something else and it is universally accepted that Columbus was not a moral role model.

I'm assuming AS's main thesis is that this land (the Americas) should be owned by the descendants of indigenous people and that colonialism is a European bias that many people today can't see past. I think he's ignoring what happens when living creatures on this planet scale when they are prosperous. I believe the problem of scale requires moving up the "tech tree". With technology comes power; with power comes responsibility.

If we agree that Columbus is an example of abuse of the aforementioned power, and we assume that scale will inevitably cause populations to being to overlap, is this an argument against cultures scaling up?


r/KnowingBetter • • Nov 26 '22

Related Video Paused whilst one video, Caught this masterpiece.

Post image
53 Upvotes