r/KnivesOutMovie • u/otaviogondin • 3d ago
Question A question about Prentice and the "lie" (Wake Up Dead Man) Spoiler
I rewatched "Wake Up Dead Man" today and I'm wondering about something. (TONS OF SPOILERS AHEAD!)
Basically, the whole story is based on the "lie" told by Martha, right? In my perception, it's just an omission, but she treats it as if she lied, because she knew where the jewel was and during all this time never told anyone (only Grace before she died, as is revealed later).
Otherwise, Wicks would already have the money and wouldn't even be a priest in the first place; then Martha wouldn't need to kill him to turn him into a kind of "legend," which would prevent Samson's death and later her having to kill Nat as well.
But for all this to work, we have to believe that nobody ever knew that Prentice died from swallowing the jewel. But the autopsy would probably catch that, wouldn't it? And Jefferson would certainly have access to the information. He was a child at the time, and Martha was taking care of church matters, but, well, eventually he would discover the whole story of how both his mother and grandfather passed away. In fact, he's the one who mentions the story first, so he did know. And he wasn't even a little curious about how it happened? That doesn't seem to fit the character who becomes so ambitious as soon as he discovers that Martha knows. This proves to me that, then, there was something inside him that was always interested in that wealth.
Anyway. For the story to make sense, no one could have discovered how he died. But surely that would come up in the autopsy, so... Do you have any explanation for this?
I don't like the film any less because of this, I'm just "nitpicking" because I find it so fantastic that I like to discuss every detail!