r/KnivesOutMovie • • 3d ago

Question A question about Prentice and the "lie" (Wake Up Dead Man) Spoiler

8 Upvotes

I rewatched "Wake Up Dead Man" today and I'm wondering about something. (TONS OF SPOILERS AHEAD!)

Basically, the whole story is based on the "lie" told by Martha, right? In my perception, it's just an omission, but she treats it as if she lied, because she knew where the jewel was and during all this time never told anyone (only Grace before she died, as is revealed later).

Otherwise, Wicks would already have the money and wouldn't even be a priest in the first place; then Martha wouldn't need to kill him to turn him into a kind of "legend," which would prevent Samson's death and later her having to kill Nat as well.

But for all this to work, we have to believe that nobody ever knew that Prentice died from swallowing the jewel. But the autopsy would probably catch that, wouldn't it? And Jefferson would certainly have access to the information. He was a child at the time, and Martha was taking care of church matters, but, well, eventually he would discover the whole story of how both his mother and grandfather passed away. In fact, he's the one who mentions the story first, so he did know. And he wasn't even a little curious about how it happened? That doesn't seem to fit the character who becomes so ambitious as soon as he discovers that Martha knows. This proves to me that, then, there was something inside him that was always interested in that wealth.

Anyway. For the story to make sense, no one could have discovered how he died. But surely that would come up in the autopsy, so... Do you have any explanation for this?

I don't like the film any less because of this, I'm just "nitpicking" because I find it so fantastic that I like to discuss every detail!


r/KnivesOutMovie • • 3d ago

I feel like I’m going crazy

0 Upvotes

So I’ve watched glass onion about 10-20 times since it came out. And up until about a year or so ago I thought I knew the movie. But in the past year I rewatched it and it was a completely different movie. I can’t tell if I’m going crazy or if it was the alcohol, but I swear on everything that the movie was simply about them going to the glass onion island and playing a murder game and someone getting murdered . But the movie shows different interaction in the case and why the detective got there. If anyone is experiencing the same thing lmk because istg the movie has been edited or something. It is not the original movie I have been watching since it came out.


r/KnivesOutMovie • • 3d ago

Meme Can you imagine how frustrating it would be to play games with Marta?

55 Upvotes

I would be unbelievably tilted if every time someone beat me at a game they were like “I was simply putting beauty into the world, you lost because you were actually trying”

Marta would three stock someone at Smash every damn game and say she was attempting to create a ballet with Pichu’s movement is all

The audacity, smdh


r/KnivesOutMovie • • 27d ago

Knives out movie observation - Joanie and the Will

23 Upvotes

I just realized something. The timeframe between the will change and Harlin’s death is about a week. And Harlin had conversations with his family to clean house the day of his death. What if the changes to his will caused a thorough due diligence uncovering Joanie’s double dipping of Meg’s tuition? Are these 2 things connected or am I grasping at straws?


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Oct 16 '26

Knives Out wood burning on poplar

Thumbnail gallery
100 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie • • Oct 16 '26

Glass onion - clue game

47 Upvotes

I was rewatching the glass onion and during Blanc’s rant about the game clue I realized something. He talks about how it’s a stupid game, running from room to room, checking boxes, etc. That’s exactly what Andi does to collect the evidence. Made me chuckle.

Anyone else notice comments like this in the glass onion or other knives out movies?


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Oct 15 '26

Question Just finished watching Glass Onion

33 Upvotes

I just finished watching Glass Onion, and I have never been more confused in my life. So we get to the ending where we find out that Miles was the one who killed Andi, and from my understanding, nobody but Miles, Helen, and Blanc know of her death. So how did Miles not question who was standing right in front of him? He knows what happened to Andi because he killed her, then Andi reappears on his island (after he just killed her, btw, like, is that not supposed to be suspicious), and he DOESN'T question who is standing right in front of him 😭???? Can somebody explain if I missed or confused something because I seriously did not get the whole point of putting Helen in place of Andi or the whole plan Blanc comes up with. Thanks a lot :)))


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Oct 14 '26

Discussion James Bond Goldeneye Game Reference

11 Upvotes

Did anyone notice the no smoke alarm when Blanc is smoking in the garden is the same alarm used in the Bunker mission in Goldeneye for Nintendo 64? It happens at about the 38 minute mark.

This game was like a good few years of my childhood and what are the chances they used that same alarm from the 1997 game.


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Oct 13 '26

Characters like Father Jud

61 Upvotes

I love Father Jud so much and I would love to watch more movies that feature genuinely good guys like him.

Are there any movies with a similar character?? I would love to hear your movie recommendations!!


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Oct 11 '26

Discussion Do you think Benoit Blanc will one day be remembered the same way as Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot?

Thumbnail
gallery
183 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie • • Oct 03 '26

You are a good nurse.

84 Upvotes

Finally watched the knives out movies this week and was really enjoying the first one but came to a hard stop when the detective said the nurse knew the differences between meds based on viscosity because she is a good nurse. I am wondering if anyone else (probably American) has to take medical errors and near misses every single year screamed the same scream I scrumpt.


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Oct 03 '26

Discussion Knives Out 4: Lambs to the Slaughter OR The Sheep Detective 2: Sheep in Wolves Clothing

39 Upvotes

This crossover has to happen


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Sep 21 '26

Am I the only one that found this line funny?

Post image
284 Upvotes

Honestly, the line itself isn't crazy funny, but it's funny to me that he's trying to appear serious and this sounds so out of character for Blanc/Daniel Craig


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Sep 20 '26

Meme trooper wagner conspiracy theory

19 Upvotes

trooper wagner following the events of the first knives out, has been hired as an undercover agent. he infiltrates miles bron's circle, and then the town monsignor wick's church is at.

this is a joke, but it's funny to think about blanc seeing trooper wagner occasionally during his cases


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Sep 05 '26

I like both

Post image
339 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 30 '26

Discussion In hindsight... the police in Wake Up Dead Man do such a sloppy job

49 Upvotes

So they have the body of Wicks, right?

On the body are no bruises or scratches. He went down without a fight, from a single stab, in the back room of a church, meaning either he died instantly when someone brandished a knife (which could happen but normally there's a bit of a scuffle at least, right?) or he was in some way impaired or unable to fight.

You'd reasonably run some blood tests to see what's going on there, right?

Doing so would incriminate Dr. Nat, and ultimately probably save his life and Samson's. Blanc was involved in the search and he found nothing untoward despite looking for evidence of something that went unusual IN THE ROOM.


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 30 '26

Discussion Earliest point Benoit Blanc could have solved each case

50 Upvotes

As in... reasonable proof that it couldn't be anyone else but the killer.

Knives Out

Three main things to solve:

  1. Maria was there when Harlem killed himself (gets that on a glance at her shoes, though I think a red splotch on her shoes doesn't guarantee blood- not like it would be impossible for her to eat food with red sauce and spill some on her shoes- literally had reddish baked beans that day too, and Tobasco is quite common in restaurants)

  2. The grandma saw Ransom arrive twice, instead of once.

  3. Tox reports were clean.

I don't think Blanc could have figured it out completely until the end.

Glass Onion

Main point is that Miles has no alibi at Andi's house and almost flattened Duke. Duke knocked, and Andi didn't open, and others collaborated on knocking when there was no answer- reasonably, Andi was already dead by that point.

Earliest possible moment was at the pool.

Wake Up Dead Man

Not concrete evidence but he could have arrested Maria after the autopsy, confirming that the top of the lamp from the bar was sewn into the clothes, but Nat wouldn’t be anything more than a suspect until Jud finished writing his paper, confirming that Wicks had a bottle that could have been tampered with inside the room when he collapsed.


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 29 '26

Question Knives out/glass onion themed birthday ideas for my best friend?

20 Upvotes

So my best friend’s birthday is in November and we both love the knives out movies. I prefer the first one but she loves glass onion. We do have a trip planned together for her birthday but I want to do something glass onion or generally knives out themed for her as well and I’m not really sure what.

I was thinking maybe doing breakfast in bed for her while we watch the movies but I don’t know what to actually make. So any suggestions for birthday breakfast meals that could fit the theme would be nice.

Also open to any other birthday ideas. It doesn’t necessarily have to be food related, I just want to do something cute and themed around the movies for her.


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 28 '26

Discussion unpopular opinion but,,

92 Upvotes

i love knives out 2. it is my favorite in the current line-up and oh my god it’s so good. i have no idea why it’s so widely disliked in official critic reviews & by everybody else but i love it. that’s all x


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 25 '26

Notice how stupidity isn't even an option.

Post image
69 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 24 '26

Discussion Between those two, who is the most pathetic?

Thumbnail
gallery
138 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 23 '26

Question Wake Up Dead Man question

7 Upvotes

I just watched it for the first time and I’m confused as to why Father Jud was going to confess to killing Wicks and why he thought he killed him? What am I missing?


r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 22 '26

Discussion How do you feel about Helen ?

Post image
125 Upvotes

r/KnivesOutMovie • • Aug 21 '26

The Origin of Knives Out in Breaking Bad

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes