r/Knight • • Mar 29 '24

Discussion What happened to the knights?

1 Upvotes

How come people think that medieval knights such as the Teutonic Knights are decent warriors when medieval knights such as the Teutonic Knights were actually very weak?

The Battle of Grunwald proves that medieval knights were weaklings who had weak stupid military training. The Battle of Grunwald was a battle in which the Teutonic Knights were decisively defeated by a Polish-Lithuanian alliance despite the Polish-Lithuanian alliance being extremely outnumbered by the Teutonic Knights.

Many people say that at the Battle of Grunwald, there were pro-Polish-Lithuanian alliance knights on the Polish-Lithuanian side but based on facts, reasoning, and common sense, there weren't any. Knights being on the Polish-Lithuanian side never played important roles in the Polish-Lithuanian victory of the battle because those pro-Polish-Lithuanian alliance knights never existed. In fact, there weren't even any type of heavy cavalry on the Polish-Lithuanian side. In fact, there weren't even any cavalry on the Polish-Lithuanian side. Yet the Teutonic Knights still lost which is embarrassing.

Another battle that proves that medieval knights were weaklings was the Battle of the Ice which took place in Russia between the Teutonic Knights and some Russians. The Russians just steamrolled the Teutonic Knights in the Battle of the Ice without any difficulty or losses whatsoever despite being extremely outnumbered by the Teutonic Knights. This proves that the Teutonic Knights are again just amateurs with no proper military training or even martial arts training.

And by the way, the Templar Knights never won battles against Mamluk slave warriors or even killed members of the Mamluk slave warrior class despite the Mamluk warrior class always being extremely outnumbered while the Mamluk slave warrior class always destroyed medieval knights.

So why do people think that medieval knights were decent fighters when they clearly aren't?


r/Knight • • Jan 15 '20

Idea for a quest

0 Upvotes

One quest could be to restart a subreddit like we did with this one from r/SubredditAdoption. How else are new subreddits going to be made? The criteria could be a certain amount of users/posts/etc.. Creating a new subreddit and bringing it to life could also count.

Edit: Nevermind, u/-Y_u_Read_this- is right.


r/Knight • • May 04 '24

Creation I decided to make a PFP with AI. Here are some of the tries :

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Sep 03 '24

Other Is there a princess who needs saving?

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Feb 13 '25

Question Design me a suit

2 Upvotes

Design me a suit of armor. I don't need measurements or anything, just the names of the pieces. I want as much coverage as possible while retaining mobility (it's heavy I know that's not what I mean)

I also want decoration. Not making the edges fancy or whatever, I mean colored cloth decor over the armor.

Don't leave out the underparts, gambesons, mail, etc.

Make it a bit feminine too, like the tapered cuirasses and stuff.

I'm broke so it'll take a long time and I might forget but you could get a pic of the full suit.

Also if you'd be so kind and find me a website to get it all from that'd be good

Danké, freunds


r/Knight • • May 25 '24

Other Is this helm worth or is it prolly a scam

2 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Oct 25 '24

Question Where do find decent armor from for an affordable price?

2 Upvotes

Everything that I find on Amazon that’s affordable ends up with like 1 or 2 stars or won’t arrive before Halloween. Time slipped by and completely forgot about this holiday that I love. So please give me a good site to buy some armor from.


r/Knight • • Dec 02 '20

Creation Set of Knights I made on Hero Forge

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Jul 10 '24

Question Fantasy fiction story and the proper use of a knighted character name

3 Upvotes

I'm writing a fantasy fiction story where one of my characters is a knight and I'm not sure how often I'm supposed to write, "Sir Dudley Do Right."

For example: Sir Dudley picks up his spoon and takes a bite. Mmm...so tasty!

Again: Sir Dudley yells, "Listen to me, for I'm of the Do Right family, you must hear me! Hey...where are ya'll going...?" Sir Dudley mopes.

Silliness aside, I want to avoid over using the title when I'm just talking about the character in my story. It seems...wrong to just refer to him as Dudley throughout the story unless someone addresses him in conversation.

Please let me know and thanks!


r/Knight • • Jul 17 '23

Creation Renly and The Rainbow Guard - Brady Paints

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Jul 06 '23

Creation Renly and The Rainbow Guard - Brady Paints

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Apr 25 '20

Trial Progress Trial of Gratitude

3 Upvotes

Originally completed 01262020.

  1. Physical health

  2. Parents alive and in good health

  3. Cat

  4. Fiscally ok / sound for now

  5. Friends

  6. Other half

There's more to each of these that I like to remember as it definitely helps especially given current world events. Knock on wood these stay true for a long time.


r/Knight • • Feb 27 '23

Trial Progress Trial 16, first book. Just a random knight incorporating different pieces of armor and equipment I've seen.

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Aug 30 '23

Question What do you think would be the perfect armor? What would you wear if you were a knight? What weapons would you use?

4 Upvotes

Preferably provide images or links, maybe sketches, but descriptions welcome!


r/Knight • • Jan 18 '20

Trial Progress Trial 25

15 Upvotes

25. Trial of the Servant

Do a chore for someone

This was not so much of a chore, as it was something that needed to be done. My brother recently was diagnosed with a prolactinoma. He is not tech savy, and does not have good vision because of the tumor. I spent the majority of my Friday night helping him create an email address, sign up for disability online, and creating accounts for him so he can view test results online.

So, it wasn't exactly a chore, but this trial was the closest I could find to what I helped him with.

edit: spelling

edit: I tried to add flair to this post, but nothing came up for it. Sorry. :/


r/Knight • • Apr 11 '25

Creation To Die Where She Loved

Thumbnail
gallery
87 Upvotes

After losing the woman he loved, the knight ventured into the snow covered peaks of the Forbidden Mountains, guided only by a fragile hope, that in a solitary tower hidden among the heights, there lived a man who could bring her back to life. He climbed treacherous paths, braved the ancient cold and silence of those forgotten lands. But when he reached the tower, he found nothing. No magic, no answers. Only stone and emptiness. Resigned, he descended back to the valley, to the lake his beloved once cherished. There he sat for days, lost in thought, drowning in sorrow and memory. Until finally, weary of searching for life where it no longer existed, he chose to let go of his own, walking into the waters that once mirrored her gaze, hoping to be reunited with her at last


r/Knight • • Sep 12 '20

Question Armor I saw for sale $400 6’2 adjustable leather on the inside for height, weight, etc. backward searched the image and their not selling a stock photo. It comes from Manhattan antiques

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Nov 30 '20

Trial Progress Kate and Carl are Knights while Jim and Matt are Knaves

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Knight • • May 12 '22

Discussion Have people who frequently criticized Hollywood tactics esp for Medieval era (in particular formations and organization) actually seen much cinema? I seems a lot of films esp older ones are far more accurate than what internet bashing gives credit for.

5 Upvotes

I watched Lancelot and Guinevere starring Cornel Wilde yesterday and i the first major battle show....... The armies of King Arthur led by Cornel Wilde as Lancelot hid their entire army in the forest behind trees and bushes covered in cut down leaves..... By the time they attacked they had fully placed their troops n strategic positions and the first few barrages of arrows had thron the enemy barbarians in panick.

By the 6th volley, it as over for the barbarians because cavalry suddenly came out of nowhere to attack the aggravated and impatient barbarians as they attempted to follow the direction of the arrows. Followed by infantry suddenly coming from concealments and holding of the barbarians eyeing for the lines of archers.

One more hidden formation of cavalry charged and hit the barbarians from the side. The barbarian army gets slaughtered in the first contact and a lot of the army flees in terror.

The final battle of the movie has Lancelot attack Morderd's army. The battle starts out with the cavalry attacking each other. Lancelot's troops win the cavalry skirmish due to being more armored and having lances over Morded's spears which were at the size for hunting........

What surprised me most was rather than chasing Morded's army in the manner people always criticize Medieval movies or showing chaotic combat, Lancelot instead orders his archers to shoot down a lot of Mordred's retreating cavalry. Mordred tries to react by sendig archers to counter attack. But Lancelot sends n heavy infantry with shields in front of the archers. They form a whole turtle from top too bottom out of shields and ere basically immune to the arrows of Mordred's archers. By sending the infantry in front, Lancelot blocked the locaton of his archers rom Mordred and Mordred could not accurately aim to hurt Lancelot's archers. IN addition Lancelot's archers had placed in stakes, some wooden blocks including a few palisades, etc prior to the battle and these seem to protect them from the arrows esp when combined with the turtle of sword and shield infantry in a phalanx.

Eventually Lancelot orders his infantry to advance like a turtle n the phalanx and they get unharmed while marching on from range attacks. They meet Mordred's infantry and clash while Lancelot sends in his cavalry to attack the archers and then hit the infantry from behind. He then chases the remnants o Mordred's army including the heavily battered cavalry unit with his still fresh knights and demolishes them killing Mordred in the process.

This is one example but I seen too many to list. From the opening battle of Lion In the Winter where a cavalry charge was done against a marching square block of troops with shields and long spears that results in a clash where the spear and shield troops thought victory was guaranteed........ Until suddenly out of nowhere they get hit by an unseen cavalry formation that suddenly comes from a hill at their unprotected backs and thus get slaughtered!!!!! Dragonheart's penultimate battle was won by luring knights into a forest where suddenly they found themselves surrounded by the newly trained spearmen by Bowen and most of them get squashed by a pincer movement while also getting shot by archers Bowen placed on top of trees prior to the battle with only the evil antagonist king escaping with a few bodyguards. The 1950s Ivanhoe basically showed the Normans shieldwalls trying to attack Robin Hood's archers but forced back into a retreat into their castle as nonstop barrage of arrows became overwhelming in a panick despite suffering no casualties. Because they were far too few in comparison to the troops Robin Hood had gathered. Some obscure movie about the Mongol invasion of Europe ith Anita Ekerg as top billing showed European armies attempting to fight in combined arms and square blocks with organization even though the Mongol army slaughtered them in a counter attack during the siege right after the Europeans breached the fortress walls by creating an opening with Siege equipment and were sending troops to enter in. The Europeans ultimately won by using Mongol overconfidence and luring them near a lake where they used scare tactics like burning the nearby woods to cause a panick that led to lots of the Mongol army to drown to death or get burned alive followed by a cavalry counterattack to finish of the remnants.

Not to mention Alexander Nevsky showed the Teutons fighting like the Romans with advance stuff like rotating worn troops with fresh ones and surprise ambushes at marching Russians, thrown javelin volleys, etc The Russians won because they themselves were using walls of pike blocks and after prolonged fighting they attacked from the sides with fresh reserve. The Teuton army wasn't even destroyed from the Russian flanking movement but because they were pushed back to a part of the frozen river that had thin ice surface (which was a calculated move by Lord Nevsky planned days before the battle).

So I really have to ask if all the criticism towards Hollywood in general about showing Medieval Warfare as chaotic melees and never showing organized battles like square formations on he march or more complex use of the environment is really unwarranted? Considering in Robin an Marian the Sherrif refused to enter the forest to fight Sean Connery as Robin Hood because he felt they'd be easy pickings for Robin's archers and in another Robin Hood move Errol Flynn had to sneak into the castle disguised as priests because the Men of Sherwood lacked the siege equipment needed to take the capitol (as well as to show King Richard who accompanied the attack was alive so most defenders wouldn't fight the Sherwood archers)............

Are the makers of cinema far more knowledgeable about accurate tactics like Pikemen combined with crossbowmen and archers internet circlejerk give them credit for? Not just Hollywood but it seems esp in European cinema like the Cornel Wilde Lancelot movie, they seem aware that Medieval Warfare was not primarily individualistic fighting despite all the criticism frequently posted online esp at reddit!

I mean the fact Alexander Nevsky shows the Teutons dong Roman era stuff like rotating fighting troops with fresh troops and Robin Hood Prince of Thieves (the Kevin Costner one) showed the Sheriff actually wiping out the Sherwood fortress in the only major battle shown onscreen by combining disorganized barbarian mercenaries with organized infantry tactics including appropriate use of fire to burn down the woods............

Why is there so much angry rants online always bashing cinema for portraying Medieval warfare as individual duels and chaotic? It seems the opposite esp when you see organized warfare and complex tactics in forgotten titles like Robin and Marian!


r/Knight • • Jul 31 '24

Meme Our biggest enemy

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Jan 18 '20

Trial Progress Working on Trial of the Chef tonight!

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Jul 15 '21

Announcement Update from the mods

9 Upvotes

Hello fellow villagers, pages, squires, and knights! I have been running this sub for a little over a month now and wanted to give an update on where I am. I have basically gotten everything figured out in regards to the trials and their quick books. Going forward I made some edits to the various tasks in each book and extended the requirement for completion of the trials to encapsulate the entire book. I have given the option for those who completed a book before I took over the option to be grandfathered into the next rank. If you feel I missed making you a page or squire please PM me as the modmail is tied to oldreddit still and I haven’t updated it yet.

I have also put the discord idea on hold until we have a more active community that would warrant it. The idea being each knightly order could have a channel and that it would be a place to help others work through their trials.

Further, I would like to create some sort of system to speed some people along to immediate knighthood in order to try and create the vision of knightly orders and expanding the community. My thought was people who have completed things like becoming an Eagle Scout have already done most of our requirements in the books through merit badges and community service. And we could award them knighthood right away. Any other ideas?

Please respond to this post with any ideas for the future of this page or things you would like to see. I would love for this page to become more active and see many people contributing to their communities and upholding our creed to the betterment of themselves and others. Questions, concerns or thoughts on life all welcome.

Excelsior!


r/Knight • • Aug 21 '24

Discussion Rate the fit

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/Knight • • Jan 24 '20

Question Just a quick question for the trial of the pilgrim, what is the time limit for it, or is there one?

10 Upvotes