r/Klunatics • • Jun 25 '26

[Wolfsong] Seriously, why are we chill with Joe and Ox's relationship? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I would like to start this off by saying I do think Ox and Joe ended up being a good couple eventually, granted I still think Ox x Robbie would have been much healthier.

But anyway, one of my friends recently started reading Wolfsong and they've brought up how creepy things are between Ox and Joe during and after the "Low slung shorts' chapter, as well as repeatedly questioning why literally everyone in the book accepts or even encourages Ox being in a relationship with a codependent minor. Me and another friend have pointed out how weird and unhealthy the relationship is during multiple debates and kind of left it there, but now after reading some reddit I'm genuinely questioning why we as a community are just chill about this very unhealthy relationship?

Please give me some reasons as to why so many of us Klunatics have just accepted this relationship?

(Please don't pull the "they didn't do anything sexual until he was of age" cause that doesn't even remotely make a romantic and very corny relationship between a 17 year old and 23 year old okay)


r/Klunatics • • Mar 16 '25

Do all of Klune’s books have the same writing style?

4 Upvotes

I read and loved The House in the Cerulean Sea and Somewhere Beyond the Sea, but I couldn’t help but feel like it was targetted towards middle schoolers, the writing style just felt really juvenile and preachy to me. I was just wondering if the rest of his books will have that same vibe to it since I did really love the plot and characters.


r/Klunatics • • Sep 07 '24

Just finished reading Wolfsong for the first time

3 Upvotes

So I picked up Wolfsong mainly because of all the raving about it in this subreddit. I went in not knowing a single thing about it, just that I trusted TJ Klune lol. Now having finished it I can say that I didn’t care for it that much, and it mainly had to do with the writing. I understood and appreciated what I think TJ was going for, but I just couldn’t seem to connect/believe in Ox and Joe’s deep relationship. To me it felt vague/undercooked/ unexplored. It just was missing something and seeing as how the book is about them, it fell kinda flat for me.

This is true for me about most of the book’s writing. Another thing about the book was that I feel like I don’t know what any of the characters looked like? Now I know physical description in novels are a tough thing to balance because it can become too much very quickly, but I felt like in Wolfsong there was ….nothing. But overall I will say I enjoyed reading it. It was entertaining, dramatic and cute. And I think because I spent so much time reading it I’m attached to the world and characters, and was debating whether I wanted to continue the series. What do you think? LMK your thoughts!


r/Klunatics • • Aug 30 '25

I'm not liking Mark so far in Ravensong... Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Please don't hate me, I just want to share what I'm feeling towards Mark so far in Ravensong. So I'm currently reading Ravensong and I'm at chapter 'feral' where the Bennett pack had a call with Michelle after what happened with Pappas going feral. So they discovered that Mark and Carter are gonna be feral like Pappas because Mark got bitten by Pappas and Carter licked Mark's wound. After that Mark had a talk with Gordo and he said he's going to end things with Dale. What I don't like about Mark right now is that he's being all romantic with Gordo like sniffing him in the alley in the previous chapter when Gordo and his friends went to a bar to hangout. And Mark saying stuff to Gordo like "I'm not your first but I'm going to be your last." While he's in a relationship with Dale. I feel like he's being unfair to Gordo and especially to Dale.


r/Klunatics • • Nov 11 '25

Just started Somewhere Beyond the Sea. Arthur is, like, 20 years older but the kids are still kids. Can someone explain?

0 Upvotes

Also, as I’m just starting, I’m wondering if this book is any different than first. So far, it seems exactly the same.


r/Klunatics • • Dec 22 '25

My thoughts on Green Creek. Spoilers ahead. Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Exactly what it says on the tin, plus a little rant later.

So far I only read two books in the series: Wolfsong and Ravensong.

I actually did enjoy Wolfsong. TJ is a wonderful writer who can weave setting descriptions beautifully. His character work is really good too, he can make the characters feel real... Which is perhaps why I ended the book feeling rather put off by Joe. After finishing it, I just can't stand Joe anymore. I found his possessiveness of Ox off-putting. This kind of crossed over onto Ravensong; his entire "don't touch him or I'll rip your head off" got old really fast. Yeah, I don't like Joe. Maybe that'll change, maybe not.

I did like Ravensong, too. It broke my heart to learn the circumstances behind Gordo's disappearance. At first his constant insistence on ignoring/avoiding Mark was a little annoying and repetitive, even though I knew it was justified, but I got over it quickly.

Now here's my rant. I spent a few hours on this sub reading some spoilers (I don't mind them), and knowing what's in store is discouraging me from reading Heartsong.

And that's because Robbie is the closest I have of a favorite character, but he's been treated poorly since Wolfsong. First by Joe, for committing the crime of being attracted to a man who for all intents and purposes, was available because he, Joe, abandoned him for years in the name of a wild goose chase. And then, again, by Joe, and Carter, for being attracted to another man who is ACTUALLY available, but who happened to be Joe's brother. But fine, whatever. We are supposed to think that their possessiveness and co-dependency is cute. Whatever.

But what I learned through spoiling myself is much worse. Not only is Robbie going to be brainwashed and forced to attack his own packmates, but he's gonna be abandoned at the mercy of a maniac for a YEAR, while being mindraped, and when his "pack" "saves" him, they're gonna physically assault him? They're gonna beat him up for the crime of being brainwashed and having his memories erased, something they knew had happened, but they abused him anyway? And they won't even apologize? I get how traumatizing seeing their friends almost died must have been, but they knew at that point that it wasn't Robbie's fault.

Sorry, no. I don't think I'm gonna put myself through that. I have no doubt that this book will also be beautifully written and I would actually like to see Kelly and Robbie's relationship develop because they were so sweet in Ravensong, but I'm not going to put myself through such an upsetting read. I found it a little intriguing to learn why so many people loved the book and consider it their favorite, but knowing that these things will happen really make me uneasy with picking it up now :/

I know it's just a book. It's all fiction. But I get involved with the characters I read and get attached to them. I think I'll give Green Creek a looooong pause and read other works by TJ outside of the series. Also, be nice to me if you disagree with anything!


r/Klunatics • • Jun 01 '26

[Green creek] ox et jo ?

8 Upvotes

Je viens de commencer la saga green creek et j'ai une question avant de continuer à lire.. est ce que Ox et Joe vont être dans une relation romantique ?

Le truc c'est que je me suis lancé dans ma lecture en imaginant quelque chose de mignon et cosy (un peu comme la mer au milieu de la mer ceruleenne, seul autre livre que j'ai lu de l'auteur pour l'instant) et jo et ox sont a un âge où 5 ans d'écart ça compte... Et c'est un livre de romance et j'ai vu que Carter (celui avec qui le pensais que Ox aurait une romance) a son propre livre sans la saga et ne semble pas être avec ox.

J'ose pas trop lire les infos sur le livre sur internet parce que je veux pas être spoiler sur l'histoire...


r/Klunatics • • May 14 '24

Under the Whispering Door

2 Upvotes

I just started reading this book and it’s UTTERLY BORING. I’m on Chapter 9 and I’m wondering when something is going to happen. Does it ever get better?!?!


r/Klunatics • • Mar 11 '26

[Green Creek Series] Thoughts on Joe's Decision Spoiler

6 Upvotes

What did people think of Joe's decision to hunt down Richard? We see that it ended up pointless and caused near irrevocable harm to Ox, but does anyone understand Joe's reasoning?

Personally, I don't understand Joe's decision at all. He had no idea how to track Richard and no means of doing so. We see during the flashback chapters in Ravensong that Gordo and the Bennett boys spent most of those three years just driving around aimlessly. Like, what was their plan? And I get Joe is young but Gordo isn't and one would think he'd speak up about how they're just wasting time driving around with no idea of where Richard could be. It makes no sense and 3 years is a long time to literally be spinning your wheels.

Joe is also inconsistent when he explains his motivations to hunt Richard down. At one point he says he left Ox because he felt his involvement in his life resulted in Ox losing his mother and that it would be better for Ox to forget about him. Yet we know at no point was Joe willing to permanently leave Ox's life so this makes no sense. At another point he says he left to protect Ox from Richard and the hunt was supposed to distract Richard from Ox. And then on some other occasions he said he was motivated by revenge and rage. It just feels like without a clear motivation, justification, or need to leave spelled out, having Joe leave for three years was there for drama but did not feel like a realistic thing his character would do if that makes sense.

Did anyone feel like there was any logic in Joe's decision? The narrative makes it seem like yes, he made a mistake, but somehow it was the best decision at the time. We even have Gordo, Carter, and Kelly continuing to back Joe's decision despite the fact that he wasted three years of their lives. And what's worse is none of them ever actually said they were sorry to Ox, which they should've considering they put him through that only to return empty-handed.


r/Klunatics • • Mar 14 '25

Wolfsong series?

12 Upvotes

I recently found out about this book series and I really want to read it, the only problem is that I've heard people say it has spice in it, I'm not a big fan of reading stuff like that but if it's a tiny bit then that's alright but if it happens quite often then I'm not sure if would enjoy it, how much spice does it have in it? And is it still readable if I'm not a fan?


r/Klunatics • • Feb 13 '25

The House in the Cerulean Sea

6 Upvotes

I’m currently 60% through this book as my first TJ Klune read. And so far it’s good, but I just have one overarching question from fans of his work. Why does this book harp on Linus’ weight so much? Like, I know it’s helping to show how Linus feels about himself, but it feels kind of overkill..? Or am I missing something with what it helps to accomplish?


r/Klunatics • • Sep 14 '25

Somewhere Beyond the Sea. Thoughts?

1 Upvotes

I just finished this. I enjoyed learning more about Arthur and the plot with DICOMY, but I found David's personality annoying. Overall, I felt like I had to force myself to finish the book whereas I read Klune's books all within a few days. What did you think of the book?


r/Klunatics • • Mar 15 '25

Question about Somewhere Beyond the Sea Spoiler

1 Upvotes

So in like chapter 12 or so of the audio book, when Arthur falls in the water, he gets helped up to the surface by a fish named frank by Chauncey.

Did Chauncey mention Frank before? Where was it?

I was so confused, I figured Zoe would have helped him or something lol

I zone out when I listen to audio books sorry


r/Klunatics • • Jul 30 '25

Cerulean chronicles audiobook disappoint?

7 Upvotes

So I just finished reading Cerulean Sea and had to go on a 5-hour drive and decided to pick up Beyond the Sea on audible, as I wanted to keep the story rolling…

Aside from this narrator’s very…oddly paced…speech pattern….while reading…sentences - did anyone else who listened feel disappointed there’s no British accent/brit dryness(?) as (I) interpreted from the reading of book 1?

It seems pretty obvious that Linus & crew live in a vaguely/pseudo-British fictional place and then hearing an American accent use words like ‘petrol’ really just leads to letdown.

I have around 150 audiobooks and this may be the first I return and go back to reading. Feels like a shame on the part of the publishing/Klune team for not putting more thought into the narrative choice.


r/Klunatics • • Mar 12 '26

Wolfsong Hottake? Spoiler

17 Upvotes

Im just gonna clarify that this isnt a hate post on the Bennetts or Joe. This is just something I noticed in the book. At the beginning it kinda felt like the Bennetts treated Ox like a pet and used to help get Joe better. Which I understand why they did and why they didn’t just immediately tell Ox why they’re werewolves. To me it also felt like Ox was being groomed to be Joe’s mate and was kinda uncomfortable to read about when they found Ox had feelings for him. Like they all knew what Joe wanted from Ox, while he didn’t. And when Ox found out, he was understandably pissed. And when, Ox came out as bisexual to Carter, he was like “this makes things easier for the future“ which is such a weird thing to say and I don’t why Ox didn’t question him on that. Anyway, let me know what you think.


r/Klunatics • • Nov 19 '24

Juniper Books limited edition Green Creek series book set

Thumbnail
juniperbooks.com
9 Upvotes

Juniper Books just released their limited edition (80 sets only) book set of the Green Creek series. It’s so pretty - I wish I wasn’t broke!!


r/Klunatics • • Jan 25 '25

All the same?

9 Upvotes

I read The House in the Cerulean Sea and loved it. Then picked up Under the Whispering door and was a bit disappointed. I feel like I just read this story. Sure, the setting was different...but a cold, emotionally distant man gets his heart melted by a kind and loving person and the people living in a quirky house. And the interactions and dialogue were all extremely similar as well.

So I'm curious if I should pick up another one of his books. Are there any that are very different from the two that I've read?


r/Klunatics • • Dec 18 '25

Brothersong

11 Upvotes

Im on ch 18, but I feel the need to say this.

Im so tired of everyone (including Gavin) calling Carter stupid. I get that what he did wasnt the brightest thing, but it wasn't something Carter could ignore. I kinda feel like that part -acknowledgement of what Carter felt as- been fully disregarded. To the point Carter is disregarding what he did as well.

And yes, I understand the pack was looking for Gavin...but they were more looking for livingstone. I cant help but wonder if Carter hadn't done what he did would they have found Gavin that easily. Gavin needed someone to fight for him. Carter did.

Idk maybe I'm missing something, which is totally fine, but goodness theyre calling carter stupid pretty much every conversation they have with him.


r/Klunatics • • Dec 16 '25

[Green Creek] Robbie

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

I couldn't quite get the glasses as chunky as they should be without going overboard. This is my best attempt. Hope you like it!


r/Klunatics • • Sep 15 '25

How to be series - order

3 Upvotes

Audible has How to be a Movie Star free until 9/24, but I've never read How to be a Normal Person. Is the order imperative? I've seen where it's centralized around the same friend group but I'm out of credits and don't want to lose the opportunity to read the Movie Star one free.

What do you guys think?


r/Klunatics • • Jul 23 '25

Is Tales from Verania triggering?

3 Upvotes

Hi, I've already read a majority of Klune's books and was wanting to start on Tales from Verania, but I was a little worried by the first book's description. I was reading this particular description on Goodreads, which might not be super reliable, which is why I'm wanting to double check. This dragon character that captures the prince is described as "sexually aggressive," and as an SA survivor, it kind of threw me off. Is there anything really bad in the first book/series as a whole? Is it just played for laughs? Should I avoid this one?

Thank yall for your help.


r/Klunatics • • Dec 12 '24

Typo page 260

3 Upvotes

New here! I couldn’t help but notice the word “except” was used when it should have been “accept” in Beyond the Sea. Was this a misprint in only my copy? I can’t believe that wasn’t caught in editing!


r/Klunatics • • Oct 20 '24

My personal headcannon for Ox’s appearance

Post image
12 Upvotes

Not very accurate to the book I might change it , but I like the idea of him having longer hair


r/Klunatics • • 12d ago

my first book ever Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

🚨🚨SPOILERS!🚨🚨

Yo family what’s the word! okay context is..an acquaintance gifted me this whole series (like all 4 books) because I’m trying to get into fiction reading. I described to her that I can start with natural stories that have real lowkey fantasy…..not too much like lord of the rings or something. and I like nature and dark atmospheres. So this one has been rlly good so far in that way, cuz it’s really grounded. Also I wanted to read something that will help me feel more at peace with my sexuality, so she said TJ Klune was really well known for writing those type stories

Okay this where im on my knees begging for help. Bro this book Wolfsong by TJ Klune is so unusual I’m sorry I don’t mean to be a hater, if you like this book that’s cool. I just don’t GET IT mud WHY EVERYONE IN THIS BOOK ACT SO ODD. People who have read it please talk to me. It’s taken me three days to reach page 178 because I’m not exactly a genius. Tell me why this kid Joe’s whole mfing family wants him to suck dick so bad that they on the outside of the house listening at his indoor conversation with Ox ard. Bro I want to know if it’s just me or not because I don’t want to be the one freaking out about nothing but im genuinely losing my sanity. If I’m tweaking for no reason, let me know because I can change any biases that I might have like it’s cool gang you can let me know

But does the book change??????? Does it get better????? I got THREE OTHER BOOKS AFTER THIS ONE. The brother Carter is the best character in the book imo every time he shows up I’m like MY BOOOOYYYYYY🤝👊 I imagine Carter look like Bryn Chapman Parish. But it’s just so strange to me how everyone in the family wants Oxnard to bang Joe so bad I can’t help but feel like I’m going crazy. I started a thing where everytime the story made me uncomfortable I wrote “POLICE” next to the sentence. MFER NOW I NEED A NEW PEN!!!!! lmk ur thoughts. sorry if I said something wrong I don’t mean no harm 🙏

(okay so I originally posted this whole thing on a reading subreddit but someone reported it for suicide and self harm daferk. im so confused. so this is technialy a repost)


r/Klunatics • • Sep 18 '24

Question about Somewhere beyond the sea Spoiler

4 Upvotes

I’m almost half-way through the book so please NO SPOILERS on what’s going to happen next.

What I’m wondering is why do they have to hide David from the inspector?

What’s-her-name already knows about him from the bug in the hotel room? I get that he’s unregistered, but why does that even matter?

(Hiding him feels like a shallow plot device to try and raise the stakes about the inspection… It’s definitely set up for him being noticed and them getting in trouble because of it. I certainly hope it’s not that simple, but I don’t have high hopes. Trying to hide him just feels stupid/unnecessary and clearly set up for failure).