r/Kidsonbikesrpg • u/FriendlyHairyBear • 12h ago
When can other players help my PC by spending their adversity tokens?
Today, I have a simple question: Under what situations, while playing Kids on Brooms, can other players help my PC by spending their adversity tokens to increase my die roll?
The rules as written do have some restrictions and guidelines about adversity tokens, but I've found a logical contradiction. If you're curious, the logical contradiction is fully spelled out in the postscript to this message.
First, I'd love an official ruling from one of the game designers.
Second, we all know that all GMs vary from each other in small details, in all TTRPGs. This is good. Otherwise, we'd all be photocopies of each other, and how boring would that be? I'd like to ask everyone to share when they allow one player to help a different player by spending an adversity token to increase the other player's roll. Since I've GMed precisely zero games of Kids on Brooms at this time, you all have infinitely more experience than I do. I'm all ears!
---Gregory
p.s. Here are the explicit quotes from the rule book that are logically contradictory.
Let's say that my PC is facing a fear, like a fear of snakes.
On Page 51 of the Kids on Brooms book, which is Page 56 of the PDF, we read this:
The first implication of being faced with your fear is that you must make all of your checks as Snap Decisions. When confronting what scares you, your fight-or-flight response is activated, which keeps you from being able to take Planned Actions.
Okay, since my PC is facing his fear of snakes, I will make only Snap Decisions, no Planned Actions. Got it.
On Page 47 of the Kids on Brooms book, which is Page 52 of the PDF, for all Snap Decisions, it says this:
Second, although you may spend Adversity Tokens to help yourself, other players cannot spend Adversity Tokens to help you. There’s no time for the kind of planning that collaboration requires.
Alright, since I'm making only Snap Decisions during this scene with the snakes, the other players cannot spend their Adversity Tokens to help me.
Yet, back on Page 51 of the Kids on Brooms book, which is Page 56 of the PDF, we read this:
As with all of your checks, you may still spend Adversity Tokens to improve your own rolls. Your friends, too, can still spend Adversity Tokens to help you--provided that you don’t all suffer from the same fear!
Cool, so I can receive Adversity Tokens from any of my fellow PCs who are there in the scene with my PC, and who do not fear snakes. That's handy. Yet, Page 47/52 said that "other players cannot spend Adversity Tokens to help you."

