I love the world of Kenshi.
It was vast, detailed, and vibrant; it had everything I needed to immerse myself in this beautiful yet dangerous land.
But the actual gameplay and progression left me feeling tired and bored.
â How to make money?
â âDonât mine ores, sell drugs.â
â Why am I so squishy?
â âDonât fight normal enemies â go to some hidden area, find a hidden vendor, use your drug money to buy top-tier armor, then head to a specific spot, get beaten up by a large group of bandits, and keep getting up over and over again from faking death to grind Toughness fast.â
Letâs be real â Kenshi has some serious design problems when it comes to progression. If the only answer to any âhow do I progress?â question is basically âyou need to find the RIGHT WAY,â and that âright wayâ means exploiting the living hell out of a broken mechanics, then itâs fundamentally messed up. A newcomer would never figure out that kind of meta knowledge on their own without watching guides or reading wikis. Like, how the hell is a new player supposed to know you can buy and sell illegal stuff, let alone know the trade routes? and those trainning methods? once you know these kinds of exploits, you canât just pretend you donât. You just canât create a new character and be content with your natural progression (if the game has any) anymore. It becomes the right way â if not the only way â to play the game.
And donât even get me started on the Strength and Stealth training. Those are literally the last things I want to be doing when Iâm fully immersed in the world â yet if I donât do them, the game punishes me for it. When a game practically forces you to exploit its systems just to play "NORMALLY", thatâs not âdeepâ or âhardcoreâ â thatâs bad design, plain and simple.
I hope Kenshi 2 would walk out of this pile of mess and really make progression natural and meaningful.
========EDIT THE 2ND DAY==============================================
Iâve read almost all of your comments â thank you, and I love you, even if you think Iâm a worthless idiot beyond saving (maybe I am). But I noticed something interesting while reading:
Most of you believe you have to restrict yourselves voluntarily to enjoy the game â whether itâs avoiding F5/F9, following strict self-imposed rules like never stealing, or only selling your own loot, etc.
Most of you think itâs my problem because I apparently dared to âoptimize the fun out of my gameâ and had the audacity to complain about it.
so basically this:
"Players should take responsibility for their own fun in a sandbox."
âFreedom and self-imposed challenge are part of the experience.â
Alright, I get it. Kenshiâs a sandbox. You do what you want, make your own rules, and if you end up miserable, well, thatâs on you for not playing âthe right way.â Fair enough.
But hereâs the thing:Â freedom doesnât excuse janky design.
A game can be open-ended and still have a progression loop that feels good without needing a PhD in wiki-science or a vow of self-restraint to enjoy it. Otherwise, it stops feeling like a sandbox and starts feeling like a survival test against the game design itself.
Yeah, I could ignore the meta, roleplay as a barefoot monk, and train my strength by just heavy-loaded myself in travel. or follow some code, never touch F5... But at that point Iâm not âimmersed,â Iâm basically doing QA work for free. why? When a player has to manually avoid certain mechanics, self-impose artificial rules, or find creative workarounds instead of using the game exploits, just to make the game enjoyable, theyâre no longer engaging with the gameâs design â theyâre patching it themselves.
Thatâs exactly what QA testers do: they push the system to find where it breaks or where it stops being fun, so designers can fix it later.
And the second point, whether it's me finding those "exploits" on youtube or it's all by myself, the question is the same: How am I gonna start a new playthrough pretending I know nothing? now when I curl up in fetal position, get beaten up by holy templars or crazy robots, do I supposed to forget that 10 minutes ago I just got crazy rich from a drug run, and be happy and content about my current "story"? I have to lie on the ground slowly bled to death and not think about making better choices to make my life easier? no, I'm very serious, do you all think that's fun? I sure don't, I'm sorry. I'm a simple man, I'm having fun when I got positive feedback, like, if this time my drug sells better or smth like that, and ofc I will get bored selling drugs at some point, then I turns to other ways of profit if it has any. like if there's organ market or smth in the game, but anything like that just doesn't exist. and that's my problem, if you give a easy way in the game, you have to also set some quirks to it, or you provide alternatives to balance that out, to make it feel like less of an "exploit".
And that "players will opt the fun out of the game" quote? Idk the context of this quote but I thought that was a cop-out. Of course players optimize â thatâs literally what humans do. We find patterns, solve problems, and get efficient. Thatâs not a flaw in the player; thatâs something good design should anticipate and make it fun.
So no, I donât hate Kenshiâs freedom. I love the world and the chaos of it.
What I hate is that the natural way to play â the way a new player would play before looking anything up â feels like punishment. there's too little positive feedback, yes you got stronger and tougher after you've beaten to death again and again, but waiting 5 min just to have my character waking up, that's not fun at all, maybe some of you find that's interesting but not me.
I just want Kenshi 2 to make progression feel as natural and satisfying as the world itself.
Freedom and design shouldnât be enemies. They should make each other shine.
But now I got to download some Overhaul mods tho, cheers!