r/KashmirShaivism • • Aug 25 '26

Question – General "You cannot know the Light without Darkness. You cannot know heat without cold." That is what some spiritual teachers preached. Is this why we suffer? Is this the view of KS?

0 Upvotes

I've read the stories of the Nanjing Massacre and the Korean genocide by Japan during World War 2. It was horrific to read. Does Shiva NEED to experience these atrocities in order for Him to recognise Himself and be joyful?


r/KashmirShaivism • • Feb 04 '24

Does Kashmir Shaivism support male bisexuality?

4 Upvotes

So I’m a recent convert to Hinduism considering between Sri Vaishnavism and Kashmir Shaivism. After these events I’m leaning more towards Kashmir Shaivism. So I know most Hindus on r/Hinduism are pro-LGBT and the stance of the Hindu American Foundation is very pro-LGBT and India is slowly becoming more pro-LGBT but I met a real homophobic Vaishnava yesterday on this post he did begin with a good critique that I shouldn’t use Vishnu or Krishna becoming Mohini and sleeping with men while still being married to his wives to justify my bisexual desire for both sexes and ethical non-monogamy. I should just know God loves me and supports me acting on my bisexuality but probably wants me to be monogamous whether that’s a straight relationship with biological kids or a gay one with adopted kids or biological kids through surrogacy. But he said that “the scriptures oppose homosexuality.” I said only the Dharmasutras and Dharmashastras do and they’re man-man smurti not divinely inspired shruti. And I brought up how during The Vedic Age, and even to a lesser extent up until The Middle Ages, India wasn’t homophobic and homosexuality and bisexuality thrived. Something that can be confirmed by multiple historical first hand sources and historians agree on this. It’s even on Wikipedia which shows this is the consensus. It can be found on multiple websites with a quick google search. He’s delusional to deny it. It’s in the Kama Sutra for crying out loud! So are the Dharmasutras and Dharmashastras not followed by certain sects? Are they optional because they’re man-made smirti? Can I just follow the Vedas, Upanishads, and maybe the Bhagavad Gita and Puranas? Which sect of Vaishnavism is best for that? Or should I just leave Vaishnavism and practice Shaivism? I would be open to Shaktism but due to coming from and still living in and abusive matriarchical household with an abusive Mom and a Gran I bicker a lot with I’m reluctant to embrace pure goddess worship.

By the way my metaphysics are in line with Ramanuja’s Vishishtadvaita. I believe in a Supreme Self as a omnipresent cosmic consciousness and believe in physicalist or neutral monist cosmopsychist (just the belief in cosmic consciousness and monism and that reality is real) but am open to idealist cosmopsychism (cosmic consciousness and monism but reality is merely thought) and idealist panentheism (like Spinoza, God has infinite attributes the only ones that can be perceived are thought and extension). So which sect of Hinduism would be best for me? Which one allows for at least a monogamous homosexual relationship and fits my metaphysics. I see most Hindus on this sub on other posts are pro-LGBT and the official position of The Hindu American Foundation is supportive of marriage equality and most agree with me on metaphysics. So all of these pro-gay and pro-bi Hindus who think that the Supreme Self is capable of thought have to come from some sect? Is it Shaivism? Does Kashmir Shaivism fit me?

The only thing I don’t like about Kashmir Shaivism is the idea of yogic s—c—e. It disturbs me as someone who has struggled with suicidal ideation and has had to be institutionalized for it. But am I just misunderstanding it and it’s like euthanasia where it’s just for the elderly and terminally ill at the end of their lives if they feel they’ve lived a good life and don’t want to reincarnate? Because that doesn’t sound objectionable. But yeah. Will Shaivism accept a bisexual who acts on his bisexuality whether it’s his heterosexuality or homosexuality? Particularly if it’s in monogamy?


r/KashmirShaivism • • 18d ago

Discussion – Āgama/Text Intercaste marriage within chakra

0 Upvotes

As far as i know mahanirvaan tantra too offers a ritual chakra where a intervarna marriage may happen, but the(bhairavi chakra) can only be made by advanced sadhakas hence prohibited for normal seekers...

Does trika shaivism too offers an alternative? If yes could this chakra be created by non advanced sadhakas?

If yes wasn't this breaking the rule of kaula that you need to keep this practice secret


r/KashmirShaivism • • Mar 12 '25

How Laila Majnu's Sufism has it roots in Kashmir Shaivism

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/KashmirShaivism • • 4d ago

Question – Beginner Have a secular perspective question. Most people if they have a song, food, or movie they really like they share it with others. I hear many devotional things about this enlightenment/kundalini awakening experience. Yet if it was so good why isn't majority of the world enlightened?

0 Upvotes

From a secular perspective it's clear thousands of years passed no matter what country or religious population you look from businessmen, to government, to teachers, to police, the amount of saints or human angels is not just so over flooding it's the norm.

It makes me doubt that enlightenment is even possible! Why would one take faith on something there isn't serious evidence on?

People thousands of years ago also claimed many things.

I'm having my doubts like how can this possibly be real. If these people were really enlightened they'd be wanting to share the road to high happiness everywhere.

So since they're not they must not believe in it and it's simply a business.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Feb 28 '25

ELI5 Kashmiri Shaivism

1 Upvotes

Please can anyone ELI5 what Kashmiri Shaivism is ? What problems it addresses & how does it attempt to solve


r/KashmirShaivism • • Nov 22 '25

Question – Beginner man i am frustrated

1 Upvotes

i got called b neon buddhist and muslim about shiv mohini ep in bhagwata purana what to say about it it cooks my mental health man


r/KashmirShaivism • • Dec 12 '25

Content – Image/Video/Quote Just getting into kashmir shaivism

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Hey g's im just getting into kashmir shaivism, I've ordered tantra illuminated and the supreme awakening by swami lakshmanjoo. I've attached some screenshots of my chat with ai. I've also developed a 30 min meditation of 10 mins of breath + om namah shivaay + focusing on the "gap". Tell me what you guys think of my screenshots with ai and the meditation. I have adhd tendencies, and i wanna increase mindfulness and concentration. Shivoham.


r/KashmirShaivism • • 18d ago

Other Kuṇḍalinī psychosis: Am I the reincarnation of Swami Lakshmanjoo

0 Upvotes

I grew up in the residence of an evangelical church in the Philippines.

When I was about 6, I was discovering meditative samadhi on my own. My cousin would call me weird. And people in the church would start to notice.

A Pastora and a Pastor would then sit beside and ask me about it, "How does it feel, Jonn?"

I told them in tagalog, "masarap" (meaning yummy, which may have a sexual connotation in our language), and so they laughed, and gently corrected it with the word, "masaya" (happy, blissful).

Then they prayed for me.

When I was about 18, trying to attend a conference, about the time when I was questioning my faith and was about to be an atheist for the next 4 years...

I was doing something like karma yoga (yoga in action), or maybe spanda: simply noticing and consuming every moment of experience as divine.

—Which I think I discovered from word of mouth, or at another church congregation, or because of an art class or textbook, or perhaps because I was trying to be a writer.

They noticed again.

After asking me about what I'm doing again, Pastora told me I was discovering tantra or yoga on my own.

Pastora showed and told me as well that they think I was the reincarnation of a Hindu sage who looks like what I realize now as Swami Lakshmanjoo.

Pastora said, "Do you believe in reincarnation, Jonn?"

"We think you're a reincarnation of him."

My teenager-self reacted defensively in tagalog, "I feel insulted, why is he ugly?"

***

Is there a way to verify all these?

In the month of May this year, just around the time (or day) my grandmother passed away, I experienced super-sexual joy...

—Which I think is a type of kuṇḍalinī called bindhuveda, meaning my deepest desire is to seek comfort and nourishment in this life.

I don't know what to make of these.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Oct 16 '25

Question – General Possible parallels between the “Law of Attraction” and concepts in Kashmir Shaivism?

2 Upvotes

I realize this may sound like an unusual question, but I’m curious whether there exists any framework within Kashmir Shaivism that could conceptually align with what is popularly known as the “Law of Attraction.”

In other words, is there an explanation—philosophical, metaphysical, or experiential—within this tradition that addresses how individual consciousness or intention might influence external reality?

I’m not referring to the modern pop-spiritual interpretation of the term, but rather wondering if there are Shaiva notions (perhaps related to spanda, vimarśa, or icchā-śakti) that describe a similar dynamic of consciousness shaping its field of manifestation.

Any guidance or philosophical clarifications would be deeply appreciated.


r/KashmirShaivism • • May 27 '24

The Trika Conundrum, a critical take on Kashmir Shaivism from an Advaita Vedantin's POV.

2 Upvotes

Monism in the Hindu Daarshanika Parampara comprises of two schools: Bhedabheda and Advaita.

Bhedabheda school subscribes to Parinamavada: i.e., Brahman becomes Jagat, Jiva and all that is. So, all that you see, even your phone is Brahman.

Advaita school subscribes to Vivartavada: i.e., Brahman remains forever unchanged and it just merely appears as Jagat only so far as this avidya is lost.

.

Now, these two schools have many subschools within them like for -

Parinamavada:

  • Bhartrprapancha

  • Bhaskara

  • Nimbarka

  • Vijnanabhiksu

  • Chaitanya

  • Vallabha

  • Ramakrishna And several others.

Vivartavada:

  • Gaudapada

  • Sureshvara

  • Vacaspati

  • Prakashatman

  • YogaVasishta

  • Madhusudana

  • Vivekananda And several more.

With this brief introduction, we can examine a fundamental problem surrounding Trika Shaivism.

.

Satya, Mithya, Asatya

All of Vedanta accepts Satkaryavada (even Samkhya does) so therefore, Brahman is 100% Sat.

If Brahman is Sat, then anything that arises from it cannot be Asat.

This is the mandate by Bhagavan as in BG 2.16

nāsato vidyate bhāvo, nābhāvo vidyate sataḥ

That leaves room for Jagat to only either be Satya or Mithya -

Next Bhagavan says in BG 2.25

avyakto ’yam acintyo ’yam, avikāryo ’yam ucyate

So here it says that Brahman is invisible, inconceivable and immutable.

If you argue that Jagat is Satya then it violates this rule since the phone in my hand is visible, conceivable and mutable (I can break it, but I won't.😅)

Therefore, to satisfy both these points, Brahman has to be Mithya.

.

Abhinavagupta's Shenanigans

Mahamaaheshwara Abhinavaguptacharya (AG) as evidenced in this article (which is from a highly respected Tantra website) - https://www.kamakotimandali.com/2021/05/02/paradvita/ He gives apparently "scathing" criticisms of Shankara's Advaita, all of which will be immediately dismissed by a Shaankara Advaitin as mistaken understandings of Shankara's teachings.

Here, rather than refuting his attacks on Shankara, I shall place arguments against his own system as described by himself.

  1. Here AG is talking about Brahman:

A person may ask why this is His nature, but it is useless to question or challenge the essential nature of a thing. It would be absurd to ask why fire is warm, or why it shines, or why it burns, and so on. Fire, devoid of such qualities, would, quite simply, cease to be fire. Similarly, Brahman, devoid of the vibrant manifestation of his divine creative power, would be reduced to the position of an insentient entity.

Refutation: We know now why fire is warm, why it shines and why it burns thanks to Science. Anyway, here he says that Brahman is sentient but how can something that is sentient give rise to something that is non-sentient? If the chair I am sitting on is also physically made of real Brahman stuff how come it is so different from me, who can think and walk? Therefore it only makes sense that this chair is mithya. (Thank you Acharya Vidyaranya for this argument).

.

2) AG claims to be describing Shaankara Advaita:

Another difference between Advaita and Parādvaita approach is that while Advaitins can experience true monism only in the state of samādhi, Parādvaitins experience it even during mundane transactions.

Refutation: this is wrong since Advaitins more than anyone hold that Brahman is here and now, not just in Samadhi. AG has confused Shankara with Vedanta Hybrid Patanjali. Therefore the name of 'Paradvaita' can be dismissed as merely boastful self-glorification.

.

3) Here AG admits the Bhedabheda position:

Adopting the view of supreme non-dualism, Abhinavagupta says that Parādvaita is the principle wherein monism, dualism and mono-dualism appear equally as the manifestations of one and the same divine reality.

Refutation: Shankara's Advaita is purely Monistic as is already known. Here apparently, 'Paradvaita' (the better Advaita) is the one that admits dualism. The statement hence refutes itself.

.

4) Specially confusing statement up ahead:

Parādvaita neither accepts diversity nor rejects it totally. Though diversity is not an absolute reality, yet it has its roots in such a reality. Abhinavagupta says: The absolute monism is that principle which neither refutes nor establishes diversity. (Mālinīvijayavārttika)

Refutation: so he his a Bhedabhedavadin. Or is he? If he doesn't accept or reject diversity, what is he doing? 🤔

.

5) Here he denies Parinamavada:

According to Abhinavagupta, all phenomenal manifestations take place in the manner of a reflection. He teaches realism (satkāryavāda), but his realism is neither a material realism nor does it involve any process of pariṇāma. All of the creation is merely an outward reflection of the divine powers of Brahman.

Refutation: AG says he is not going with Parinamavada so for him the Jagat isn't 'Satya'. But so far, here and in several sections in the original article, he has mocked Shankara for Vivarta. He theorizes then, a new Vada entirely, called Prathibimbavada. The Jagat is like a reflection of Brahman. However, any reflection be it in a mirror or in water, is nothing but a virtual image. A reflection is dependent on the original. My mirror image cannot exist without my being there. My mirror image is also not real, i.e., Sat.

In all this, it can be seen that AG is just a giving a new variety of Vivartavada like the many other people I have listed above. By denying Jagat Satya, but not explicitly stating Jagat Mithya, AG has managed to assume a position that somehow attracts people of both schools of Monism. However, it can easily be deduced that the denial of Jagat Satya is equal in of itself to saying Jagat Mithya. Thus, making him too a Shaankarite.

Reasoning It Out

Parinamavadins mock Vivartavadins that they want to "escape" the world and its reality out of fear of facing nature's crests and troughs.

Vivartavadins mock Parinamavadins that they are too "afraid" to let go of the world and its pleasures and so want to keep at it.

AG here is trying to have for himself the best of both worlds. To have the pie and eat it too. However, such things aren't allowed in this mithya world. 😌

Om Tat Sat.

Disclaimer: please don't bother commenting if you are going to say things like, "Bro you are just an ant bro. Don't think yourself too smart to talk about the Mahamaaheshwara bro", "Trika Shaivism is a huge school and puny minds like yours can't understand it", "Read the texts and study under a real teacher before you comment on them" and several other similar things.

However, I'd LOVE to see a refutation of my refutations like in a classic debate. I also would love to hear about the mistakes I have committed in word or in concept. By sounding disrespectful to Acharya Abhinavagupta in my post, I don't mean to send the wrong message that his contribution is moot. His Dhvanyaloka Locana is the greatest work in World Aesthetics and I would reverentially call him Bhagavan Abhinavagupta even if we are just counting this work, not to mention his even greater work, Abhinavabharati.

TL;DR: Abhinavagupta takes Shaankara Advaita and sells it in a fresh package.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Jun 11 '24

Authority of the vedas

7 Upvotes

If I become a kashmir shivaist, do I have to Accept The infallible authority of the vedas? The vedas teach Things about caste and gender that I cannot Accept.

I. According to the Kathaka Samhita (xxxi.2) and the Maitrayani Samhita (iv.1.3; i.8.3) “A shudra should not be allowed to milk the cow whose milk is used for Agnihotra.” II. The Satapatha Brahmana (iii.1.1.10), the Maitrayani Samita (vii.1.1.6) and also the Panchavimsa Brahmana (vi.1.11) say: “The Shudra must not be spoken to when performing a sacrifice and a Shudra must not be present when a sacrifice is being performed.” III. The Satapatha Brahmana (xiv.1.31) and the Kathaka Samhita (xi.10) further provide that : “The Shudra must not be admitted to Soma drink.” IV. The Aitareya Brahmana (vii.29.4) and the Panchavimsa Brahmana (vi.1.11) reached the culminating point when they say: “Shudra is a servant of another (and cannot be anything else).”


r/KashmirShaivism • • May 13 '24

WHOSE consciousness is it in the Consciousness-Only system?

1 Upvotes

From what I understand, Consciousness-Only view postulates there are no objects that cause conscious experience. The "matter" of the objects IS consciousness. We know consciousness exist from first-person report. It's pretty much the only thing we know. The existence of objects independent from consciousness is under the question.

I want to challenge this with a thought experiment. Let's say we have two friends: Amy and Bob. Amy is a bee is a normal person who sees multiple colors. Bob is color blind and sees only shades of grey. They are looking at the same flower. They know it's the same because they can report seeing it sway under wind at the same time, react to it swaying, etc. There is the same objects we call F which somehow causes Amy to have her conscious experience of the flower CF and Bob to have his conscious experience of the flower CF.

What people like Rupert Spira will say is that there is no F --> CF. There is just CF. F is identical to CF. F == CF. It seems to me, schools like Kashmir Shaivism or Yogacara agree. There is only consciousness, not independent objects that cause the qualia of consciousness.

OK, but let's go back to our terms. Let's say CF_a is conscious experience of the flower that Amy has (and can report). And CF_b is the same for Bob. The problem we run into is that CF_a ≠ CF_b. Amy and Bob report different qualia. Amy says she see five colors, and Bob says he sees two shades of grey.

So we can't say that generally speaking F == CF, because we don't know which CF to collapse F into: CF_a or CF_b, since the two are not identifcal.

In other words, if FLOWER is EXPERIENCE OF FLOWER, then whose experience is flower "actually" is? It seems like there has to be some essence of the flower (F_e) which causes separately CF_a and CF_b.

End of the main question.

Addendum:

You might say: No, there are two objects: F_a and F_b. F_a is the flower that IS Amy's consciousness. F_a == CF_a. F_b == CF_b. It's a mistake to think that there is a single F out there, since clearly Amy and Bob are reporting different F. I don't really have time to discuss this fully, but it seems like there should be some essential F that splits up into F_a, F_b, ... F_i for every CF_i. That essential object is what we call "flower in and of itself". If that weren't the case, there would be no way for people to cooperate on the world, synchronize their clocks, pass each other objects, etc. So, the idea that essential F splits up into F_a, F_b, ... F_i, is pretty much the same as Dualism that Consciousness-Only was trying to defeat.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Oct 04 '24

LGBT

7 Upvotes

What is the kashmiri shaiva take on the lgbt community?


r/KashmirShaivism • • Dec 03 '25

Question – Beginner I have a few questions

8 Upvotes

For the past 2 years i defined myself as an Hinduist, thing is i didn’t completely agree with mainstream Hinduism. While searching for alternative truth i came across Kashmir Shaivism. From what i understood you don’t really believe in a god, but its more like a symbol, am i right? And why choose this philosophy or religion, either than let’s say Buddhism, Jainism etc…?


r/KashmirShaivism • • Jul 30 '25

Content – Image/Video/Quote An unclassified CIA document depicting the idea of Ajatavada

Thumbnail cia.gov
5 Upvotes

Note: I'm fairly new to the idea of non-duality and Shaivism in general, so apologies in advance if I make some mistakes with the terminology.

In the ideas of Ajatavada, we hear of the idea of an all-encompassing conciousness, where All is One, and One is All. The absolute is an all being not subject to life or death, composing of all existences and our views on our existence as we know it.
This is an unclassified CIA document dating all the way back to the 1980s (Initially a study on the potential of psychics and astral projection in miltary recon), detailing studies on the all conciousness and ideas *very* similar in nature to Ajatavada, with the hints at returning to the Absolute. How odd that a fairly modern study comes to the same conclusion that the monks did long ago.
What do you all think of this?
(Side note: One of my friends, I've noticed, frequents this subreddit often. If you see this post friend, greetings, You Are That.)


r/KashmirShaivism • • Jun 30 '26

Discussion – Sādhanā/Practice Can someone verify this method of sauh

2 Upvotes

I shall reveal the deepest meaning of the seed sauḥ, by whose realization one becomes Śiva. Among all scriptures, no seed is held to be higher. To understand it, every notion of method must be abandoned. Sauḥ is the method beyond method, the Anupāya, transcending initiation, stages, progression, and gradual realization.

The Lord presiding over this seed is the Ineffable Śiva, the One, the One-within-One, the Two-in-One, and the Two. He is neither male nor female yet both, neither unity nor duality yet the source of both.

There are two contemplations of sauḥ. Contemplating its letters and sound reveals Parābhaṭṭārikā, Goddess of the Fourth Kūṭa of the Kādi Pañcadaśī, known as Mahā Saptadaśī or Turīyāmbā, the Seventeenth Kalā of the Moon. Contemplating the luminous Silence from which sauḥ arises and into which it dissolves reveals the Supreme Śiva, the Light of Being hidden within the Light of Consciousness. This realization is Tīvra-tīvra-śaktipāta, wherein ignorance is shattered and one's identity with Śiva is recognized without dependence upon gradual practice.

Oṃ is the Śabdabrahman, Lord Śiva before His manifestation as Bhairava. Within it resides the Pañcapraṇava: śrīṃ hrīṃ klīṃ aiṃ sauḥ, the five opening seeds of Mahāṣoḍaśī. They are the five exalted powers of Śiva and the subtle forms of the five elements: śrīṃ (Jñāna, Ākāśa), hrīṃ (Ānanda, Apas), klīṃ (Tapas, Agni), aiṃ (Cit, Vāyu), and sauḥ (Sat, Pṛthvī). Though hrīṃ is the innermost as Ānanda, sauḥ alone integrates all five powers.

Beyond the Pañcapraṇava lies the Bhairava State, where oṃ becomes ūoṃ, the first seed of the secret seventeen-syllable mantra of Chinnamastā. Rising from the heart to the forehead, ūoṃ carries awareness beyond Praṇava into Supermind. The syllable ū is the hidden pillar of incorruptible unity that enables ascent beyond the void.

The characteristic seed of the Bhairava State is hūṃ, Infinite Space, within which resides sauḥ, the Infinite beyond Space. There abide the primordial Five Praṇavas and Five Elements: sauḥ hūṃ hāṃ sūṃ kṣīṃ, which are none other than Svacchanda Bhairava Himself. Yet beyond even Bhairava remains the Ineffable and Integral Śiva. Bhairava appears only during the ascent; upon realization, only that Supreme Śiva remains as All.

Now I shall explain the practice of the seed sauḥ belonging to this transcendent Lord Śiva.

Sit comfortably and close your eyes. Bring your awareness to the center of the forehead. Visualize a white spark emitting golden sparks, radiant like infinite suns and moons. This spark is you. There is no god, no goddess, no other, only you.

Surround this spark with an Infinite Space of Crystalline Light, clear as a diamond. This Space is the Original Sat, the Absolute Mind, and it is also you. Let the spark dissolve until only this Infinite Conscious Space remains. Recognize that everything can arise from this Mind. Create a mountain within it and know that it is yourself, for it is formed from your own consciousness.

Let the spark reappear and become your body. See every particle of your being shining with the same white and golden flame. Realize that, as the Infinite Mind, you have chosen one among infinite sparks to become a Divine Center, a soul inseparable from the Supreme. The white flame represents the vision of the Absolute Mind of Sat, while the golden sparks represent the soul retaining that vision within individuality.

You may mentally recite sauḥ, but once you become the mantra itself, recitation is unnecessary. Maintain this awareness throughout daily life. See all beings and all things as existing within you and made from your own Consciousness. This is the Consciousness of the Mantra. When it becomes continuous in waking and sleep, Tīvra-tīvra-śaktipāta arises spontaneously, destroying the veils of ignorance at their root.

The seed sauḥ may also be understood symbolically. S is the Infinite Space of Crystalline Light, Sat, the shaft of Śiva's trident and the Absolute Ground of Being. Au is the threefold point of the trident, the Soul as the white flame with golden sparks, representing Cit, Tapas, and Ānanda. Ḥ signifies all universes projected within the Absolute Mind and their recognition within the awakened soul as inseparable from God.

These explanations are only pointers. What matters is the living Consciousness of sauḥ. During meditation, create worlds, beings, and experiences within your awareness, recognizing them as manifestations of your own Consciousness. Then extend the same recognition to the world itself. As this awareness becomes natural and unbroken, the veils of separation dissolve, and the Tīvra-tīvra-śaktipāta of the Ineffable Śiva arises of itself. Realization is then revealed as what has always been present.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Jun 28 '26

Discussion – Itihāsa/History Does Shiva tracing the roots to pre-Vedic times and retaining some of those, as seen in how Shiva is characterized, have something to do with the acceptance of meat consumption in Shaivism?

2 Upvotes

Same as the title


r/KashmirShaivism • • Sep 29 '26

Question – General Practices to remember past lives?

2 Upvotes

I only know of APARIGRAHA (non-hoarding, non-possession), mentioned by Lakshmanjoo. But does it really happen automatically? I have been trying to declutter unnecessary things, belongings, files, etc.

Do I not have to meditate, pray for a dream (to remember past lives)? Or does it happen by intuitions, by acknowledging that a certain biography you've read was so similar to your life that it's likely a past incarnation?

Can I find some practice worth looking into in the Tibetan Tulku tradition?


r/KashmirShaivism • • Jul 30 '24

KS and metaphysical solipsism

2 Upvotes

It seems that Kashmir Shaivism, as well as other Consciousness-only schools, posit that the world doesn't exist independently of our consciousness, but that the ontology of the world IS consciousness, and specifically each person's consciousness (so the world is really many conscious objects working together).

My issue is this: Why would anyone believe this nowadays in light of modern science?

I understand how in the medieval times someone could believe that objects don't exist, and our experience IS objects (and vice versa). All that they were aware of was personal subjective experience, and there was no concept of modeling the world's phenomena.

But today science works on the assumption that the world objectively exists. You don't know what your guts are doing and never will unless you feel sick and have to go do a doctor. Then you take medication that readjusts acid level or replaces microflora, and suddenly you feel better. If your conscious experience was all there was, you would need to go to a psychologist, who can convince you to stop feeling pain. Instead, you go to a different doctor, who gives you a proton pump inhibitor pill. You have no idea that it works or how it works. You just take it, and you feel better, assuming acid was the issue. If acid wasn't the issue, you won't feel better – you will need a different pill.

Medicine and Western science can cure many diseases based on the assumption things are ticking away on their own, without your conscious involvement. This shows veracity of their assumptions about the world.

Also, we know that our conscious experiences are very tightly tied to the working of very specific brain centers. Damage a very specific nucleus of neurons, and a person can't see left side of a city square anymore – can't even conceive there IS a left side (he will draw clock numbers as all sitting on the right side of the clock disk... for his consciousness, there is no such thing as "left" sides). Some patients lose ability to see faces, or shapes, or color, or tell time, etc.

I am not arguing that consciousness IS brain activity (i.e., that consciousness experience is reducible to neuronal physiology), but I am arguing that what we are conscious of is not the objects but specific brain parts passing electricity. When a person gets a stroke and now can't see faces, does that mean people's faces stopped existing? That just seems like a strange thing to believe in.

I understand if someone believes that Shiva's consciousness is the world, and our brains is a part of that consciousness, and OUR consciousness is just a small part of Shiva's consciousness. He dreams the entirety of the world into existence and then experiences that dream through small slivers of that reality, namely the consciousness of our thalamocortical systems. But I don't think that's what KS is positing.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Aug 14 '26

Question – Beginner New here.

2 Upvotes

I’m not sure whether I’m looking for a religion at all, but from what I’ve encountered so far, this seems closest to the truths I’ve come to through my own experiences.

I’d really appreciate some insight into a dream I had. In it, there were two versions of me. One was meditating in pursuit of power, while the other was meditating to deepen a relationship with Creation, Shiva, Source, or whatever name you prefer. Neither one felt inherently wrong.

Lately, I’ve also been experiencing a strong buzzing or energetic sensation throughout my body. Even after I eat, it intensifies and sometimes if not most of the time I hear loud tones in my head that change pitch.

In another experience, I was shown that my heart was my true treasure. It was filled with gold, jewels, and kingly crowns decorated with serpent imagery. In a separate dream, I appeared as half man and half serpent, with a human upper body and a serpent lower body.

Part of me wonders whether seeking power through meditation is wrong, and whether I should instead focus on loving and connecting with the “true me”.. Creation, Shiva, Source, or however it might be understood within this tradition.

I’d be grateful for thoughts from people who are more familiar with this religion or spiritual path, especially regarding the symbolism of the serpent, the heart, and the two forms of meditation. This is all very new to me, and I’m still figuring out whether I consider myself religious at all.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Aug 27 '26

Question – Beginner Interesting text

2 Upvotes

Greetings to everyone!

I recently came across this text, and I like it very much. However, I haven't been able to find any source for it, so I'm curious to hear what you think about it. Have any of you encountered this text before, or what is your opinion of it?

Thank you very much in advance! Daniel

अद्वैतस्वातन्त्र्यविज्ञानतन्त्रम्

Advaita-svātantrya-vijñāna-tantram

The Tantra of the Recognition of Non-Duality and Freedom

“At the beginning of the universes, Kṛṣṇa divided Himself into two parts: one is Śrī Kṛṣṇa, Lord of the cowherd girls, the other is Mahādeva.”

Devī Bhāgavatam, Book 4, Chapter 2

अथ भैरवी उवाच — Bhairavī’s Question

एकं चेत् परमं तत्त्वं कथं द्वैतमिदं विभो ।
कथं भोक्ता च भोग्यं च कथं काम्यं च कामुकः ॥

ekaṃ cet paramaṃ tattvaṃ kathaṃ dvaitam idaṃ vibho |
kathaṃ bhoktā ca bhogyaṃ ca kathaṃ kāmyaṃ ca kāmukaḥ ||

If the supreme reality is one, O all-pervading Lord, how does duality appear? How arise the experiencer and the experienced, the desirer and the desired?

कुतो देहः कुतो विश्वं कुतो भेदस्य सम्भवः ।
कथं भेदः प्रशाम्येत कथं कामः प्रसिध्यति ॥

kuto dehaḥ kuto viśvaṃ kuto bhedasya sambhavaḥ |
kathaṃ bhedaḥ praśāmyeta kathaṃ kāmaḥ prasidhyati ||

Whence arise the body and the world, and whence the appearance of difference? How is difference pacified in its source, and how is desire brought to its true completion?

देहक्षेत्रं कथं देव कथं बालद्वयं मनः ।
कथं क्रीडारसं प्राप्य स्वभावं पुनराप्नुयाम् ॥

dehakṣetraṃ kathaṃ deva kathaṃ bāladvayaṃ manaḥ |
kathaṃ krīḍārasaṃ prāpya svabhāvaṃ punar āpnuyām ||

How, O Lord, is the body itself the field? How may consciousness be contemplated as the two children? How, entering the rasa of their play, may I recognize my own nature again?

कथं क्षेत्रं तनुर्भूत्वा कुण्डली भैरवी भवेत् ।
भैरवश्च कथं देहे प्रकाशोऽनुभवे स्थितः ॥

kathaṃ kṣetraṃ tanur bhūtvā kuṇḍalī bhairavī bhavet |
bhairavaś ca kathaṃ dehe prakāśo ’nubhave sthitaḥ ||

How does the field manifest as the body? How is Bhairavī present as Kuṇḍalinī? And how does Bhairava abide in embodied experience as the light by which it is known?

हृदयोत्थाश्च ये कामाः कथं शक्तिस्वरूपिणः ।
कथं बालस्वरूपेण द्वैतग्रन्थिर्विलीयते ॥

hṛdayotthāś ca ye kāmāḥ kathaṃ śaktisvarūpiṇaḥ |
kathaṃ bālasvarūpeṇa dvaitagranthir vilīyate ||

How are the desires arising from the heart forms of Śakti? And through the form of the children, how is the knot of exclusive duality dissolved?

भैरव उवाच — Bhairava’s Answer

शृणु भैरवि तत्त्वं मे क्षेत्रदेहरहस्यकम् ।
बालभावं समाश्रित्य स्वभावं प्रत्यभिज्ञसे ॥

śṛṇu bhairavi tattvaṃ me kṣetradeharahasyakam |
bālabhāvaṃ samāśritya svabhāvaṃ pratyabhijñase ||

Listen, Bhairavī, to the mystery of the field and the body. Taking refuge in the contemplative form of the children, you recognize again your own nature.

क्षेत्रं देहः स्वयं चित्तं बालरूपद्वयं स्मृतम् ।
भैरवो भैरवी चैव एकचित्तस्य क्रीडितम् ॥

kṣetraṃ dehaḥ svayaṃ cittaṃ bālarūpadvayaṃ smṛtam |
bhairavo bhairavī caiva ekacittasya krīḍitam ||

The field is contemplated as this very body; consciousness is contemplated in the two child-forms. Bhairava and Bhairavī are the play of the one Consciousness, not two independently existing principles.

न तत्र न्यूनता काचिन्न कामोऽपूर्णतात्मकः ।
पूर्णानन्दरसः क्रीडा स्वातन्त्र्यस्य विजृम्भिता ॥

na tatra nyūnatā kācin na kāmo ’pūrṇatātmakaḥ |
pūrṇānandarasaḥ krīḍā svātantryasya vijṛmbhitā ||

There is no deficiency there, nor is primordial desire born from incompleteness. The play is the rasa of complete bliss, the unfolding of Consciousness through its own freedom.

The two children are therefore not two eternal substances. They are two distinguishable forms within the self-manifestation of one awareness: Bhairava as luminous awareness and Bhairavī as its inseparable freedom, power, self-apprehension, and manifestation. Their distinction is real as appearance and play, but never separation in being.

Each prose section below is accompanied by a Sanskrit anuṣṭubh-style metrical recension and IAST transliteration. The Sanskrit verses are a newly composed metrical rendering of this work, not quotations from an ancient source.

I. Vṛndāvana, Kailāsa, and the Field

वृन्दावनं स्मरेन्नित्यं प्रेमक्रीडारसाश्रयम् ।
तन्मध्ये कैलसं ध्यायेदुमया सहितं शिवम् ॥

vṛndāvanaṃ smaren nityaṃ premakrīḍārasāśrayam |
tanmadhye kailasaṃ dhyāyed umayā sahitaṃ śivam ||

कैलासपृष्ठतो ध्यायेत् क्षेत्रं विस्तीर्णमद्भुतम् ।
स्वदेहमेव तत् क्षेत्रं चित्क्रीडायाः प्रतिष्ठितम् ॥

kailāsapṛṣṭhato dhyāyet kṣetraṃ vistīrṇam adbhutam |
svadeham eva tat kṣetraṃ citkrīḍāyāḥ pratiṣṭhitam ||

दक्षिणे सरसी रम्या वामे वनपरम्परा ।
देहक्षेत्रे तयोर्मध्ये बालौ क्रीडापरायणौ ॥

dakṣiṇe sarasī ramyā vāme vanaparamparā |
dehakṣetre tayor madhye bālau krīḍāparāyaṇau ||

I contemplate Vṛndāvana as the timeless space of love, relationship, play, and the manifold moods of experience.

Within its expanse I contemplate Kailāsa. Upon Kailāsa I contemplate Mahādeva and Umā.

Behind Kailāsa the landscape opens into a broad field. When I meditate, I do not place an alien landscape before myself. My own body is contemplated as this field.

The field is bordered on the right by a lake and on the left by belts of forest. Beyond the forest opens Vṛndāvana, and beyond another belt of forest lies the yellow-sanded village.

I do not contemplate the body as an inert point. The body becomes a landscape of manifestation. As body, I am the field; as consciousness, I am the awareness in which the two children play.

II. The Two Children

न न्यूनत्वात् प्रवर्तेते बालौ क्रीडारसोत्सुकौ ।
पूर्णस्य स्वेच्छया शक्तिः क्रीडारूपेण वर्तते ॥

na nyūnatvāt pravartete bālau krīḍārasotsukau |
pūrṇasya svecchayā śaktiḥ krīḍārūpeṇa vartate ||

भेदो लीलार्थमुदितो न भेदः परमार्थतः ।
भैरवो भैरवी चैव चिदेकस्य स्वरूपिणौ ॥

bhedo līlārtham udito na bhedaḥ paramārthataḥ |
bhairavo bhairavī caiva cidekasya svarūpiṇau ||

भैरवोऽहं भैरवी चाहं बालरूपे व्यवस्थितः ।
एकानन्दस्य रूपे द्वे क्रीडतः क्षेत्रमध्यतः ॥

bhairavo ’haṃ bhairavī cāhaṃ bālarūpe vyavasthitaḥ |
ekānandasya rūpe dve krīḍataḥ kṣetramadhyataḥ ||

I am Bhairava and I am Bhairavī, contemplated in the child-forms: two forms of one bliss playing within the field.

I run after the beautiful form running before me. Then the play reverses and the other child-form follows me. At other times the two sit facing one another; at other times they play in different places of the field.

The movement of the children does not arise from lack. There is no object whose acquisition could make Consciousness complete. The movement itself is the free play of fullness.

Bhairava's joy continues in Bhairavī's joy, and Bhairavī's joy in Bhairava's joy. The distinction permits relation and play; non-separation prevents that distinction from becoming absolute division.

I do not contemplate this from outside. As body I am the field; as consciousness I am their common ground; as Śakti I am the movement of their play.

III. The Lake and the Closed Lotuses

क्षेत्रदक्षिणभागे तु सरसी विमला शुभा ।
निमीलितानि पद्मानि तस्यां सुप्तानि भावयेत् ॥

kṣetradakṣiṇabhāge tu sarasī vimalā śubhā |
nimīlitāni padmāni tasyāṃ suptāni bhāvayet ||

देहभावाः प्रसुप्तास्ते पद्मेष्वव्यक्तरूपिणः ।
यथाकालं प्रबुध्यन्ते शक्तेः स्वातन्त्र्यलीलया ॥

dehabhāvāḥ prasuptās te padmeṣv avyaktarūpiṇaḥ |
yathākālaṃ prabudhyante śakteḥ svātantryalīlayā ||

आकाशं सलिले भाति भिन्नं चाप्यविभाजितम् ।
तथैव विश्वमखिलं चिदाकाशे प्रकाशते ॥

ākāśaṃ salile bhāti bhinnaṃ cāpy avibhājitam |
tathaiva viśvam akhilaṃ cidākāśe prakāśate ||

On the right side of the field lies a wondrous lake. Its shore is surrounded by flowers and plants; animals move around it and birds above its water. Closed lotuses rest upon the surface.

Within the closed lotuses I contemplate embodied manifestation. What unfolds as bodily experience is present here in an unexpanded form.

The sky is reflected in the lake. Water and sky are distinguishable without becoming alien to one another. Their relation is already present in the one field of experience.

Because my body is the field, the lake too belongs to the landscape of my embodiment. Because awareness is not other than the power by which the landscape appears, I am also the one who knows and plays within it.

IV. The Yellow-Sanded Village

वामे वनान्तरे ध्यायेद् ग्रामं पीतसिकतामयम् ।
गेहं भग्नं च वरणं शुष्ककूपं च भावयेत् ॥

vāme vanāntare dhyāyed grāmaṃ pītasikatāmayam |
gehaṃ bhagnaṃ ca varaṇaṃ śuṣkakūpaṃ ca bhāvayet ||

तत्रापि बालकौ तौ द्वौ नामरूपान्तरस्थितौ ।
संकोचे शक्तिमन्विच्छेन्न दोषं धर्मतां नयेत् ॥

tatrāpi bālakau tau dvau nāmarūpāntarasthitau |
saṃkoce śaktim anvicchen na doṣaṃ dharmatāṃ nayet ||

Beyond the forest belt on the left I contemplate a yellow-sanded village: dry pale sand, a house, a broken fence, a sandy courtyard, and a dried-up well.

The two children appear here as well. Their play may continue under names such as Adharma and Mṛṣā and through the forms associated with them.

I do not deny the destructive forms of experience. I seek the deeper power appearing through them without declaring their contracted expression either identical with or different from the uncontracted state.

Thus the practice is the recognition of identity, not the erasure of distinctions of function, consequence, or conduct.

V. The Field Becoming the Body

क्षेत्रमेव तनुर्भूत्वा स्वशक्त्या सम्प्रकाशते ।
भैरवी शक्तिरूपा सा भैरवः प्रकाशकः ॥

kṣetram eva tanur bhūtvā svaśaktyā samprakāśate |
bhairavī śaktirūpā sā bhairavaḥ prakāśakaḥ ||

The field, becoming the body, manifests through its own Śakti. Bhairavī is that Power; Bhairava is the luminous awareness by which manifestation is revealed.

न भिन्नौ भैरवीशौ तौ न चैकत्वेन नाशितौ ।
एकस्य चित्स्वभावस्य क्रीडया रूपभेदिनौ ॥

na bhinnau bhairavīśau tau na caikatvena nāśitau |
ekasya citsvabhāvasya krīḍayā rūpabhedinau ||

Bhairava and Bhairavī are not separate realities, nor are their forms destroyed by unity. Through play they are differentiated forms of the one nature of Consciousness.

बालक्रीडा न नश्येत सा देहेऽपि प्रवर्तते ।
क्षेत्रं देहत्वमापन्नं स्वातन्त्र्येण प्रकाशते ॥

bālakrīḍā na naśyeta sā dehe ’pi pravartate |
kṣetraṃ dehatvam āpannaṃ svātantryeṇa prakāśate ||

The children's play does not perish; it continues in embodiment. The field appears as body through the freedom of Consciousness.

Bhairavī may be contemplated in embodiment as Kuṇḍalinī, the contracted and unfolding power of the same Śakti.

Bhairava does not become merely the limited belief 'I am only this body.' Bhairava is the light of awareness through which even bodily identity is experienced.

The limited bodily 'I' is therefore not outside Bhairava, but neither is limitation itself the fullness of Bhairava. It is a contracted mode of the one power of self-experience.

The practitioner does not reject the body. The body is recognized as a real appearance within Consciousness, a form of its self-manifestation.

VI. Desire and Icchāśakti

पूर्णे चिति न वै न्यूनं काममूलं सुखं परम् ।
संकोचाद् विषयाकाङ्क्षा विकासादिच्छया स्थिता ॥

pūrṇe citi na vai nyūnaṃ kāmamūlaṃ sukhaṃ param |
saṃkocād viṣayākāṅkṣā vikāsād icchayā sthitā ||

कामं मूलं नयेद् धीमानिच्छां शक्तिं च भावयेत् ।
शक्तिं भैरवसाम्येन पश्यन् पूर्णत्वमाप्नुयात् ॥

kāmaṃ mūlaṃ nayed dhīmān icchāṃ śaktiṃ ca bhāvayet |
śaktiṃ bhairavasāmyena paśyan pūrṇatvam āpnuyāt ||

सिद्धिर्वा न भवेद् बाह्या कामस्य विषयाश्रया ।
स्वमूलस्य परिज्ञानं प्रथमं फलमुच्यते ॥

siddhir vā na bhaved bāhyā kāmasya viṣayāśrayā |
svamūlasya parijñānaṃ prathamaṃ phalam ucyate ||

कामस्य मूलमानन्दो नेच्छा न्यूनत्वसम्भवा ।
संकोचे विषयाकाङ्क्षा पूर्णे सा इच्छाशक्तिता ॥

kāmasya mūlam ānando necchā nyūnatvasambhavā |
saṃkoce viṣayākāṅkṣā pūrṇe sā icchāśaktitā ||

The deepest ground of desire is bliss; primordial willing does not arise from deficiency. Under contraction it appears as longing for an object; recognized in fullness, it is the power of willing, icchāśakti.

Thus the root of embodied desire is not lack in the field. There is no lack in the uncontracted ground.

Yet the recognition of this ground is not a guarantee that every object imagined by the limited individual must externally appear. The fruit of recognition is first the recognition of the power within desire.

I follow desire toward its source: from object-longing to willing, from willing to Śakti, and from Śakti to the non-separation of Bhairavī and Bhairava.

A desire may be fulfilled, transformed, relinquished, or remain unfulfilled as an external event; none of these by itself determines whether its ground has been recognized.

VII. The Dissolution of Exclusive Duality

अहं त्वमिति भेदे तु क्षेत्रं स्मृत्वा विशेद् बुधः ।
काम्यकामुकभेदे च बालरूपं विचिन्तयेत् ॥

ahaṃ tvam iti bhede tu kṣetraṃ smṛtvā viśed budhaḥ |
kāmyakāmukabhede ca bālarūpaṃ vicintayet ||

भेदं नैव विनाश्येत न कुर्यादेकतां जडाम् ।
भेदस्याप्याभासभावं चिदैक्ये प्रत्यभिज्ञयेत् ॥

bhedaṃ naiva vināśyeta na kuryād ekatāṃ jaḍām |
bhedasyāpy ābhāsabhāvaṃ cidaikye pratyabhijñayet ||

When within the body 'I' and 'other' appear, I return in recognition to the field. When 'desirer' and 'desired' appear, I return to the children.

When 'within me' and 'outside me' appear, I recognize that all these positions arise within one field of manifestation.

I do not erase the two child-forms. I do not force one into the other. I am Bhairava; I am Bhairavī; and I am the field in which their relation appears.

Thus I do not annihilate difference. I dissolve only the claim that difference means absolute separation.

This is the loosening of the knot of duality: bheda remains available to experience, while bheda is recognized as an ābhāsa within non-divided Consciousness.

VIII. Kuṇḍalinī

देहक्षेत्रे परा शक्तिः कुण्डलीभावमाश्रिता ।
नान्या वस्तु स्वतन्त्रा सा चितः स्वातन्त्र्यरूपिणी ॥

dehakṣetre parā śaktiḥ kuṇḍalībhāvam āśritā |
nānyā vastu svatantrā sā citaḥ svātantryarūpiṇī ||

संकोचं देहभावं च मन्त्रं बोधं विकासनम् ।
भैरवः प्रकाशयति स्वप्रकाशस्वरूपतः ॥

saṃkocaṃ dehabhāvaṃ ca mantraṃ bodhaṃ vikāsanam |
bhairavaḥ prakāśayati svaprakāśasvarūpataḥ ||

In embodiment the field continues as my own body. Bhairavī continues as Śakti and is contemplated as Kuṇḍalinī.

Kuṇḍalinī is not a second substance imprisoned inside the body. She is the power of Consciousness appearing according to the conditions of embodiment and capable of recognition in her uncontracted nature.

Bhairava is the awareness illuminating the entire process: contraction, bodily identity, mantra, movement, recognition, and expansion.

Thus field, body, Kuṇḍalinī, awareness, and play belong to one continuum of manifestation.

IX. Dharma and Svabhāva

धृधातोर्धर्मशब्दोऽयं धारणार्थे निरूपितः ।
स्वभावधारणं धर्मं ध्यानेऽस्मिन् परिभावयेत् ॥

dhṛdhātor dharmaśabdo ’yaṃ dhāraṇārthe nirūpitaḥ |
svabhāvadhāraṇaṃ dharmaṃ dhyāne ’smin paribhāvayet ||

नाधर्मो धर्मतां याति शक्तिदृष्ट्या कदाचन ।
संकोचं तु परिज्ञाय स्वभावं पुनराश्रयेत् ॥

nādharmo dharmatāṃ yāti śaktidṛṣṭyā kadācana |
saṃkocaṃ tu parijñāya svabhāvaṃ punar āśrayet ||

I connect dharma with the semantic field of dhṛ: holding, bearing, sustaining, supporting. In this practice, dharma is contemplated as that which supports the recognition and expression of one's deeper nature.

Adharma is not redefined as secretly identical with dharma. Rather, even in contracted movement I seek the Śakti without denying the distinction between contracted and uncontracted expression.

I do not destroy identity. I release its exclusivity. The limited 'I' is returned to the wider ground from which it arose.

Thus returning to svabhāva means recognition, not annihilation.

X. The Names and the Unstainability of Śakti

न किञ्चिच्चित्परं वस्तु सर्वं तस्याः प्रकाशनम् ।
तथापि हिंसया हिंसा धर्मो नैव प्रजायते ॥

na kiñcic citparaṃ vastu sarvaṃ tasyāḥ prakāśanam |
tathāpi hiṃsayā hiṃsā dharmo naiva prajāyate ||

नाम्नां मूलानि पश्येत ध्यानोपायेन साधकः ।
रूढार्थं न परित्यज्य शक्तिं तेषु विचिन्तयेत् ॥

nāmnāṃ mūlāni paśyeta dhyānopāyena sādhakaḥ |
rūḍhārthaṃ na parityajya śaktiṃ teṣu vicintayet ||

The powers appearing through destructive, fearful, painful, or contracted forms are not outside Consciousness. Nothing can stand outside the all-inclusive field of manifestation.

This does not mean that injury becomes non-injury, falsehood becomes truth, or destructive conduct becomes dharma merely through etymological reinterpretation.

In contemplating names such as Adharma, Mṛṣā, Dambha, Māyā, Lobha, Nikṛti, Krodha, Hiṃsā, Kali, Durukti, Mṛtyu, Bhīti, Niraya, and Yātanā, I may examine their linguistic movements as contemplative supports, while preserving their established meanings and ethical or experiential distinctions.

The recognition sought is deeper: the energy by which even contraction appears is Śakti; contraction itself is not thereby declared the uncontracted state.

XI. Preparatory Mantra Practice

भैरवं बालरूपेण मन्त्रकाले विचिन्तयेत् ।
देहं क्षेत्रं विजानीयाद् भैरवीं च पुरःस्थिताम् ॥

bhairavaṃ bālarūpeṇa mantrakāle vicintayet |
dehaṃ kṣetraṃ vijānīyād bhairavīṃ ca puraḥsthitām ||

भैरवीं बालरूपेण पुनर्मन्त्रे विचिन्तयेत् ।
दृष्टिभेदो भवेद् यत्र चिदेकैव प्रतिष्ठिता ॥

bhairavīṃ bālarūpeṇa punar mantre vicintayet |
dṛṣṭibhedo bhaved yatra cidekaiva pratiṣṭhitā ||

1. Baṭuka Bhairava

AUM BATUKA BHAIRAVAAYA NAMAHA

During this mantra I contemplate myself in the child-form of Bhairava. My body is the field. Awareness is luminous and playful, and before me appears the beautiful Bhairavī-form that is never truly outside awareness.

2. Ucchiṣṭa Cāṇḍālinī

AUM NAMO UCCHISTA CHANDALINI VAAGVAADINI RAJMOHINI PRAJAAMOHINI STRIMOHINI AAN AAT YEVE VAYU UCCHISTA CHANDALINI SATYAVAADINI KI SHAKTI KURU SVAAHAA

During this mantra I contemplate myself in the child-form of Bhairavī. The body remains the same field. The apparent change of standpoint occurs within one awareness.

XII. The Five Mental Offerings

भैरवी भैरवं ध्यात्वा पञ्चोपहारमर्पयेत् ।
भैरवो भैरवीं ध्यात्वा मनसैव प्रतिगृह्णीयात् ॥

bhairavī bhairavaṃ dhyātvā pañcopahāram arpayet |
bhairavo bhairavīṃ dhyātvā manasaiva pratigṛhṇīyāt ||

दाताहं ग्राहकोऽहं च क्षेत्रं चाहं तथैव च ।
भेदः पूजाक्रमे तिष्ठेद् वियोगो नास्ति तत्त्वतः ॥

dātāhaṃ grāhako ’haṃ ca kṣetraṃ cāhaṃ tathaiva ca |
bhedaḥ pūjākrame tiṣṭhed viyogo nāsti tattvataḥ ||

The offering takes place at this point of the practice. When I meditate in the form of Bhairavī, I mentally prepare offerings for Bhairava; when I meditate in the form of Bhairava, I receive them from Bhairavī.

The five contemplative offerings retained here are meat, alcohol, sweets, flowers, and fragrance. They are mental offerings in this recension.

As Bhairavī I offer; as Bhairava I receive. Then the standpoint reverses.

The offering does not occur between two absolutely alien beings. I am the one who offers, I am the one who receives, and I am the field in which offering and reception become manifest.

The distinction is ritually preserved; separation is not.

XIII. Main Mantra Stage

मुख्यमन्त्रजपे देहं न त्यजेत् साधकः क्वचित् ।
क्षेत्रभावेन तिष्ठेत चिद्रूपं स्वं विचिन्तयेत् ॥

mukhyamantrajape dehaṃ na tyajet sādhakaḥ kvacit |
kṣetrabhāvena tiṣṭheta cidrūpaṃ svaṃ vicintayet ||

कदाचिद् भैरवो बालः कदाचिद् भैरवी भवेत् ।
दृष्ट्योर्भेदेऽपि चिदेका क्रीडया बहुधा स्थिता ॥

kadācid bhairavo bālaḥ kadācid bhairavī bhavet |
dṛṣṭyor bhede ’pi cidekā krīḍayā bahudhā sthitā ||

1. Ucchiṣṭa Gaṇeśa

AUM HREEM GAM HASTI PISHAACHI LIKHEE SVAAHAA

During this mantra I remain within the wholeness of the body-field.

2. Baṭuka Bhairava Mantra I

AUM HREEM BATUKAAYA AAPADUDDHAARANAAYA KURU KURU BATUKAAYA HREEM

3. Baṭuka Bhairava Mantra II

AUM KLEEM VEEM RUUM DHRUM GHNEEM HREEM BATUKA BHAIRAVAAYA NAMAHA SVAAHAA

In the main stage I do not leave the body. As body I am the field; as consciousness I recognize Bhairava and Bhairavī as inseparable aspects of one awareness.

At times I occupy one child-standpoint, at times the other. At times the children face one another; at times one follows the other.

The original mood of the field is not deficiency. It is the freedom of fullness to appear as relation, movement, differentiation, and return.

XIV. Dhāraṇā of the Lake

सरस्यां पद्ममुद्दिश्य देहबीजानि भावयेत् ।
अव्यक्तानि स्थितान्यत्र शक्तिक्रीडाविकासिनि ॥

sarasyāṃ padmam uddiśya dehabījāni bhāvayet |
avyaktāni sthitāny atra śaktikrīḍāvikāsini ||

जले व्योम यथा भाति न दूरं नापि तन्मयम् ।
भेदाभेदौ तथा ध्यायेत् स्वदेहे चिदधिष्ठितौ ॥

jale vyoma yathā bhāti na dūraṃ nāpi tanmayam |
bhedābhedau tathā dhyāyet svadehe cidadhiṣṭhitau ||

I go to the lake on the right side of the field and contemplate the closed lotuses. Within them lie the latent possibilities of embodied manifestation.

The sky is reflected in the water. The water does not travel to another realm in order to obtain the sky, nor does the sky become water. Difference and non-separation are simultaneously contemplated.

I experience my body in the same way: not as an alien prison to be abandoned, but as a manifestation whose deeper nature can be recognized.

I return not to another place, but to a deeper recognition of this very field of experience.

XV. Final Dhāraṇā

क्षेत्रोऽहं देहरूपेण बालौ चित्तस्य रूपिणौ ।
भैरवोऽहं भैरवी चाहं क्रीडैवाहं निरन्तरम् ॥

kṣetro ’haṃ deharūpeṇa bālau cittasya rūpiṇau |
bhairavo ’haṃ bhairavī cāhaṃ krīḍaivāhaṃ nirantaram ||

As body I am the field. The two children are forms appearing within Consciousness. I am Bhairava; I am Bhairavī; I am their ceaseless play.

कामस्य मूलमानन्दं ज्ञात्वेच्छाशक्तिरूपतः ।
द्वैतग्रन्थिं विलाप्याहं स्वभावं प्रत्यभिज्ञये ॥

kāmasya mūlam ānandaṃ jñātvecchāśaktirūpataḥ |
dvaitagranthiṃ vilāpyāhaṃ svabhāvaṃ pratyabhijñaye ||

Knowing the root of desire as bliss and recognizing it as the power of willing, I dissolve the knot of exclusive duality and recognize my own nature.

I do not annihilate bodily identity. I recognize it as a limited standpoint within a greater field of awareness.

I do not demand that the world conform to every contracted desire as proof of realization. I recognize the fullness from which the power of desire arises.

I remain in this body. I meditate in this body. Whatever fulfillment, transformation, action, or relinquishment follows is received within the freedom of Consciousness.

XVI. The Swan Returning to the Lake

अभ्यासफलसम्पत्तौ हंसरूपेण मे मनः ।
स्वह्रदं पुनरायाति यत्र तस्य निकेतनम् ॥

abhyāsaphalasampattau haṃsarūpeṇa me manaḥ |
svahradaṃ punar āyāti yatra tasya niketanam ||

When the fruit of practice ripens, my mind, contemplated in the form of a swan, returns to its own lake, its dwelling.

सृष्टीन् ब्रह्म च लङ्घित्वा हृष्टो हंसोऽवरोहति ।
ह्रदस्य सलिले रम्ये स्वस्थानं पुनराश्रितः ॥

sṛṣṭīn brahma ca laṅghitvā hṛṣṭo haṃso ’varohati |
hradasya salile ramye svasthānaṃ punar āśritaḥ ||

Passing in contemplation beyond the worlds and conceptual absolutes, the joyful swan descends upon the beautiful water of the lake and rests again in its own place.

The swan is not an entity escaping creation. It is a contemplative image of recognition: awareness ceases to seek itself elsewhere and recognizes its own field as the place of manifestation.

XVII. Bhairava Questions Bhairavī

भैरवीं प्रति देवेशः प्रोवाचेदं ततो वचः ।
भैरवि ब्रूहि मेऽद्य त्वं क्षेत्रं कुत्र प्रतिष्ठितम् ॥

bhairavīṃ prati deveśaḥ provācedaṃ tato vacaḥ |
bhairavi brūhi me ’dya tvaṃ kṣetraṃ kutra pratiṣṭhitam ||

Then Bhairava addressed Bhairavī: Tell me now, Bhairavī: where is the field established?

कौ तौ बालौ च तत्रैव नित्यं क्रीडापरायणौ ।
कामः कुत्र समुद्भूतः कुत्र चैव निवर्तते ॥

kau tau bālau ca tatraiva nityaṃ krīḍāparāyaṇau |
kāmaḥ kutra samudbhūtaḥ kutra caiva nivartate ||

Who are the two children devoted to play within it? Where does desire arise, and into what does it return?

द्वैतग्रन्थौ विलीनायां का त्वं भैरवि मे वद ।

dvaitagranthau vilīnāyāṃ kā tvaṃ bhairavi me vada |

When the knot of exclusive duality has dissolved, who are you, Bhairavī?

भैरव्युवाच — Bhairavī’s Recognition

क्रीडाहं ध्यानरूपाहं साधकोऽहं तथैव च ।
क्षेत्रं चाहं मन्त्रनादो ध्यानस्य फलमेव च ॥

krīḍāhaṃ dhyānarūpāhaṃ sādhako ’haṃ tathaiva ca |
kṣetraṃ cāhaṃ mantranādo dhyānasya phalam eva ca ||

I am the play, the form of meditation, and the practitioner. I am the field, the sound of mantra, and the fruit of meditation.

प्रकाशोऽहं विमर्शोऽहं स्वातन्त्र्यं चिद्रसोऽप्यहम् ।
कुण्डलीभावमापन्ना देहे शक्तिरहं स्थिता ॥

prakāśo ’haṃ vimarśo ’haṃ svātantryaṃ cidraso ’py aham |
kuṇḍalībhāvam āpannā dehe śaktir ahaṃ sthitā ||

I am luminous awareness and its self-apprehending power; I am freedom and the rasa of Consciousness. Assuming the mode called Kuṇḍalinī, I abide in the body as Śakti.

भैरवोऽहं भैरवी चाहं भेदाभेदविवर्जिता ।
स्वभावं प्रत्यभिज्ञाय नित्योदितसुखात्मिका ॥

bhairavo ’haṃ bhairavī cāhaṃ bhedābhedavivarjitā |
svabhāvaṃ pratyabhijñāya nityoditasukhātmikā ||

I am Bhairava and I am Bhairavī, beyond the limitation of either absolute difference or featureless identity. Recognizing my own nature, I am the ever-arising fullness of bliss.

क्रीडानन्दस्य नित्यं वै विचित्ररूपिणी स्थिता ।
इत्यद्वैतस्वातन्त्र्यविज्ञानतन्त्रम् ॥

krīḍānandasya nityaṃ vai vicitrarūpiṇī sthitā |
ity advaita-svātantrya-vijñāna-tantram ||

I abide eternally as the manifold forms of the bliss of play. Thus ends the Advaita-svātantrya-vijñāna-tantram.

XVIII. Etymological Appendix — Sanskrit Verses, IAST, and English

Dharma

Root: dhṛ

English: to hold, bear, sustain, support. In the meditation: that which bears or supports its own nature.

Adharma

Root: a- + dharma

English: the privative prefix a- + dharma. In the source text: that which has lost its own nature.

Mṛṣā

Root: mṛṣ

English: forbearance, endurance, permission; allowing something to take place. Used here as a contemplative semantic association.

Dambha

Root: dambh

English: assumption of a particular behavior or appearance.

Māyā

Root: mā

English: measuring, apportioning, creating, projecting.

Lobha

Root: lubh

English: attraction, desire, strong orientation. 

Nikṛti

Root: ni- + kṛ

English: ni-: downwardness, inwardness, placement or fixing; kṛ: doing, making, creating, performing. A morphological contemplation retained from the original text.

Krodha

Root: krudh

English: agitation, boiling up. 

Hiṃsā

Root: hiṃs

English: striking, injury, wounding; alteration of integrity. 

Kali

|

Root: kal

English: counting, measuring, ordering, calculation. 

Related semantic field in the source: kāla, kalpa, kalpanā.

Durukti

Root: dur-/dus- + ukti

English: dur-/dus-: difficulty or obstruction; ukti: utterance, expression.

Mṛtyu

Root: mṛ

English: passing away, cessation, dissolution, transformation. 

Bhīti / Bhaya

Root: bhī

English: trembling, being shaken, withdrawal. In bodily experience: trembling, defensive reflex, readiness.

Niraya

Root: nir- + ay

English: nir-: moving away/outward/departure; ay: going, movement, progression. 

Yātanā

Root: yā / tan

English: yā: going, proceeding, wandering, flowing; tan: extending, stretching, spreading, manifesting; tanū: bodily extension. 

Bhairava

Root: bhī + rava

English: bhī: trembling/bodily response; rava: sound, resonance, vibration.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Jun 27 '26

Discussion – Darśana/Philosophy The 'Anaesthesia' Critique of Kashmir Shaivism and my Response

6 Upvotes

Kashmir Shaivism (KS) claims that consciousness is absolute: it is not, as the Buddhists argue, a dependently arisen phenomenon or, as materialists argue, generated by the brain, but is always already present. Whilst similar to Advaita Vedanta (AV), it is not making the same claim: AV considers Atman (the individual Self) to be identical with Brahman (the Absolute); KS instead considers the individual Self to be a (temporary) contraction of Shiva (the Absolute).

However, like AV, KS is vulnerable to the empirical case of general anaesthesia (all idealist philosophies - using the term 'idealist' broadly here - are vulnerable): if consciousness is really absolute, then why does general anaesthesia, a material phenomenon, appear to interrupt it? I don't think this problem can simply be brushed away but needs to be addressed carefully by the idealist. I include below my attempted response - I don't believe that my response 'proves' KS and eliminates the anaesthesia critique - instead, I think it simply makes the critique claim less than it appears to. I would be interested to hear your thoughts. Full disclosure: the arguments below are mine, but I used AI to polish them. You can skip to the end for a summary of my defence if you’re short on time:

1.      Contentless awareness — absence of content during anaesthesia isn't absence of consciousness itself; just because there was no content to experience, it does not follow that consciousness itself was absent (to say otherwise would be to equate consciousness with its contents – a Buddhist move). Problem: consciousness becomes indistinguishable from nothing and it becomes unclear how we can continue to use the term ‘consciousness’ meaningfully.

2.      Locus vs. ground — anaesthesia affects the contracted individual locus (jiva), not Shiva/the Absolute itself, since KS (unlike AV) doesn't posit strict identity between the two (this is why I think anaesthesia is more problematic for AV to address than for KS). According to KS, consciousness is not limited to one specific location in space; anaesthesia involves a temporary interference with one particular locus of contracted consciousness; it does not affect consciousness as a whole. In other words, the individual mind which anaesthesia affects is not the entirety of consciousness; it is a contracted manifestation of universal consciousness. Problem: doesn't address why awareness, if truly absolute, shouldn't persist regardless.

3.      Continuity — even if we grant that anaesthesia (somehow) interferes with consciousness as such, note that consciousness returns following the procedure (as opposed to being eliminated altogether). The materialist needs to explain how this return is possible since ‘something cannot come from nothing’. Since consciousness does return, and something cannot come from nothing, the idealist can argue that consciousness must have been present ‘in the background’, as it were, and never wholly absent. Problem: same problem as above (see point 1): it’s unclear how to make sense of a ‘contentless consciousness’ since it is indistinguishable from nothing.

4.      Yogic precedent — advanced meditators reportedly maintain awareness through deep sleep, so plausibly through anaesthesia too. Problem: this is speculative, plus, sleep and general anaesthesia may not be analogous cases at all. As far as I’m aware, there have been no empirical studies testing yogis’ awareness under general anaesthesia and, by definition, there would be no objective means of verifying whether their awareness was maintained under these conditions; you’d have to rely on testimony alone.

5.      Filter/transmission model — the brain doesn't produce consciousness but filters or receives it, like a mirror and its reflection or a radio and sound waves; anaesthesia disrupts the filter, not the source. Problem: speculative, and doesn't explain what happens to "you" during the gap.

6.      Memory ≠ consciousness — absence of memory (as with most dreams) doesn't entail absence of experience, so the lack of recall after anaesthesia doesn't prove nothing was experienced. Problem: this is correct but cuts both ways — it shows the data is neutral, not that consciousness positively persisted.

7.      Fundamentality vs. continuity — even granting total cessation of experience under anaesthesia, this only threatens the claim that consciousness is unbroken, not the claim that consciousness is ontologically fundamental rather than produced by matter. The hard problem of how matter generates subjectivity remains regardless of how the anaesthesia case is settled. Problem: It’s not clear how consciousness can really be regarded as ‘fundamental’ if it is discontinuous.

8.      Idealist counter-example — whilst anaesthesia can be used by the materialist as an empirical case undermining idealism, the idealist can refer to empirical arguments too: for example, despite being in a coma, with little if any registered brain activity, some patients have reported subjective experiences, suggesting that consciousness is not generated by the brain. Problem: such cases remain speculative and controversial.

9.      The Hard Problem — even if we were to grant that anaesthesia (somehow) directly interferes with consciousness as such, the materialist would still be left with the hard problem of consciousness; the problem of explaining how consciousness is derived from matter; the idealist argument is that no combination of unconscious elements can possibly give rise to subjectivity. Problem: doesn’t address why anaesthesia (appears to) affect consciousness.

Summary: The anaesthesia objection demonstrates a close correlation between brain function and conscious experience, but it does not establish that the brain produces consciousness. Kashmir Shaivism can consistently interpret anaesthesia as a temporary disruption of the individual, contracted manifestation of consciousness (jīva), rather than of universal consciousness (Shiva) itself. Appeals to contentless awareness, the distinction between memory and consciousness, the continuity of consciousness following anaesthesia, yogic reports, and filter or transmission models all suggest that alternative idealist interpretations remain possible, even if none is conclusive. Moreover, even if anaesthesia were shown to interrupt consciousness itself, the materialist would still face the Hard Problem of explaining how subjective experience arises from matter. Thus, anaesthesia presents a challenge to Kashmir Shaivism's claim of uninterrupted awareness, but it does not by itself refute its central claim that consciousness is ontologically fundamental rather than produced by the brain.


r/KashmirShaivism • • Aug 08 '24

Is the ingestion of human faeces part of k shaivism tantra?

0 Upvotes