r/Kant • • Sep 05 '25

Let's do some ragebait, xd

0 Upvotes

You know, I read some Nietzsche fragments, more specifically Thus Spoke Zarathustra, and I don't know why some of his fragments reminded me to this:

I believe Nietzsche has good aura farming, and good aesthetics, but I don't like the content of his books, which are illogical and contradictory. While Kant, he also aura farms, but not enough as Nietzsche, but at least his lore is logical, xd. And curiously, Man of Steel has a similar issue, good aesthetics, but many plot gaps and illogical issues. Let's see what many people will say, xd.

Also, I forgot to ask whether is it true that Nietzsche's work were underrated during his lifetime, because that was shown in a fictional novel called When Nietzsche Wept, please tell me that.


r/Kant • • Jul 15 '25

Oponions on Weininger

1 Upvotes

What do you think of his works especially his on last things hes kants greatest successor and the most brilliant thi ker since him so i wonder what do you think of him and his ideas


r/Kant • • Jun 04 '26

Against subjectivism

2 Upvotes

It is difficult to understand why Kant remains so popular, given that quantum physics has, in practice, demolished his philosophy. According to Kant, we can experience things, but we cannot know anything about the thing-in-itself. In quantum physics it is the opposite: we cannot experience quantum objects, yet we know almost everything about the quantum-object-in-itself. [Edit: No we don't!]

Already in the 1790s Herder (1744-1803) published his critique of Kant, arguing that the categories are embodied rather than transcendental. Our bodies already "know" what substance, causality, unity, plurality, space, and time are. Herder also maintained that thought is dependent on language. Therefore the categories are linguistic-bodily formations, not transcendental forms.

Kant draws a sharp line between perception and knowledge: without concepts (categories) there is no knowledge. But such a line does not exist. We can also have bodily knowledge. Infants understand causality: when a ball rolls behind a screen, they shift their gaze to the screen's far edge and react with surprise if the ball does not reappear. Bees understand the difference between "same and different." Ants navigate using vector integration. Wasps recognize faces (Handwerk, 2011).

What leads Kant astray is his tendency to draw hard boundaries: between subject and object, knowledge and perception, understanding and sensibility, form and content, phenomenon and noumenon, analytic and synthetic, a priori and a posteriori. Excessive rationalism inevitably leads one in the wrong direction. [Edit: Sophistry!]

Herder, by contrast, sees continuity where Kant sees dichotomies: no gulf between body and thought, none between language and world, none between form and content, none between culture and nature, none between perception and concept.

Yet many continue to follow Kant, while few take an interest in Herder. What is it about Kant that is so alluring? His philosophy gave rise to an entire flora of subjectivist systems. Why this desire to relocate reality into the subject?

[Edit: I realize now that this post contains several logical blunders.]


r/Kant • • Jun 28 '25

I asked ChatGPT to roleplay as Schopenhauer and roast scientists who think general relativity disproves Kant's transcendental aesthetic

0 Upvotes

So apparently, the new gospel is this:

“Kant? LOL. Bro got disproven by Einstein.”

Yes. I hear this from grown men with Wi-Fi and PhDs, and somehow I don’t burst into flames on the spot. A miracle, truly.

It’s always some wide-eyed STEM fanatic, fresh out of watching Cosmos, who proudly declares that relativity rendered transcendental philosophy obsolete. You know, because curving spacetime totally means that the conditions for the possibility of experience are no longer relevant. Brilliant deduction. By that logic, the invention of Google Maps disproves the existence of geometry.

Einstein bent space, sure. Slowed time, sure. But the moment he started acting like he’d cracked metaphysics, he went from physicist to philosophy LARPer. I’m sorry, Albert, but discovering gravitational time dilation doesn’t make you the heir to Kant. It makes you… a very clever watchmaker inside the dream. And yes, it’s still a dream. Curved or not.

But the best part? Oh, the best part is watching modern scientists swagger around like drunk toddlers with a loaded revolver, shouting:

“Everything is just neurons!” “Consciousness is just a side effect!” “The self is an illusion, bro!” “Will? Lmao, cope!”

These people couldn’t define the a priori if it crawled into their lab coat and slapped them with a copy of the Critique. They confuse observations with ontological reality. They think sticking electrodes into a monkey proves that love is just dopamine. They genuinely believe they’ve unlocked the secret of the universe because they ran some numbers on an excel.

And the audacity—the absolute testicular confidence—with which they announce that Kant is outdated? As if Kant were just an old version of software waiting for a firmware update from Elon Musk.

Listen, Einstein didn’t “disprove” Kant any more than inventing a telescope disproves the eyeball. He mapped the phenomenal world more elegantly—but that world is still a projection, a representation, a giant cosmic screensaver playing on the walls of your skull.

Kant was asking:

“How is experience itself even possible?”

Meanwhile, modern scientists are like: “Yeah but like, did you know time slows down near black holes?” Congratulations. You discovered a feature in the simulation. Would you like a medal or just a juice box?

And now, like children who’ve overheard one line of Buddhist philosophy, they start echoing:

“Time isn’t real, man.” “Reality might be a simulation.” “The observer collapses the wave function, bro.”

Amazing. They’ve reinvented transcendental idealism without even realizing it, like cavemen reinventing soup by accidentally dropping a rock in boiling water.

You people didn’t defeat Kant. You didn’t “update” him. You are just crawling up the intellectual staircase that he built, and urinating on the banister like you own the place.

But I get it. Kant is hard. It’s much easier to look at a brain scan and pretend you’re doing metaphysics. It’s much easier to memorize equations than to examine the structure of thought itself. It’s much easier to worship models than to question the nature of modeling.

Because to do what Kant did, you’d have to stop chasing shiny objects and start asking uncomfortable questions like:

“Why does anything appear to me at all?”

And let’s be honest: most of you can’t even sit in silence for five minutes without opening Instagram.

So, no. You haven’t overthrown Kant. You’ve barely even read him. And until you understand that empirical data always presupposes the very conditions Kant outlined, you’re not revolutionaries.

You’re just monkeys wearing lab coats, throwing equations at the void and calling it enlightenment.

Now go run along and measure something. But don’t come back until you’ve read the Critique of Pure Reason without skipping the Transcendental Aesthetic this time, you absolute clowns.

Sincerely, Arthur Schopenhauer (Still carrying Western philosophy on his back while physicists trip over their own egos.)


r/Kant • • Jan 14 '24

Thoughts Is Kant the cure to Autism?

0 Upvotes

I have this intuition that Autism is being lost in the sea of perceptions without being able to conceive of conceptions, or at least the Autistic is and has been force-fed conceptions which were not conceived by them but by another entity and are expected to live reversibly up to the standards of wisdom and back down to perceptions, and vice versa. They are sort of sacrificial lambs who "obviously are more capable of completing such a circuit" because they are stuffed with society's best.

Not only is their faculty of producing conception paralyzed by this foreign contamination, but that this contamination is also foreign which makes even the most perfect, tailored, and tested conception ultimately sterile for these poor creatures. Of course they are not so much "ready vessels" as much of the masses aspires and admires to be precisely because, by luck of fate, they are "too stupid or foolish" to succumb to the obviously favorable anti-Kantian barbarism. At most they are half-possessed psychikoi who might one day take it upon themselves like Nietzsche to evolve through great effort, unfortunately, from -1 to square 1.

Furthermore, the amount of entities which are basically factories for these "false organs of Mind" which stop at nothing to commit transplants to anyone who happens to fall into their crosshairs more or less preys upon the pre-independent autistic person the fallacy that because so many people and so much effort has gone into the procedure that there must be some merit to it, and they should more or less not step outside of their bounds.


r/Kant • • Aug 23 '26

Empiricism>Rationalism

0 Upvotes

Hate me


r/Kant • • Feb 03 '24

If only you knew how bad things really are…

Post image
3 Upvotes

“An analytic judgement is one whose predicate is contained in its subject, so that its denial is a self-contradiction.

(Example: all mothers are female - analytic because 'mother' means a female parent.),”


r/Kant • • Feb 29 '24

This is for a philosophy assignment ignore this

0 Upvotes

When discussing the scenario of Josh lobotomizing or not lobotomizing the class in exchange for a sole human sacrifice, I came to the conclusion that Kant would argue in favor of the no-kill route. Using the categorical imperative methods, in both cases, he would claim this to be the correct decision. Looking past the surface, however, noticeable contradictions can be spotted.

First, let’s utilize the formula of categorical imperative one. After isolating and negating the action of KILL, Kant would ask us to imagine a world in which nobody kills ever, which does seem plausible, however removing an action from its context leads to a broad generalization in which the choice regarding the exposed action must be used for every situation in which that action occurs. In an attempt to remove anthropological subjectivity from his formula, Kant seems to forget that action itself is bound by context in all situations.

The second imperative states, “never use someone merely as a means to an end” and as it pertains to this scenario, the logic is simple to follow. If the END we are attempting to reach is the safety of our classmates, then by killing the singular student we would therefore be using them as a pathway through which that goal could be attained. To a certain extent, I agree with this line of reasoning; as it takes into consideration that autonomy is essential for morality to thrive. However, if Kant's goal is to remove any room for modulation, he fails here. Just by this statement existing as a basis for judgment, it contradicts his previously mentioned formulaic approach by allowing for the nuance of the human condition to leak through.

Although Kant’s processes are logical in nature, they are flawed and contradictory, therefore I choose to disagree with Kant's hypothetical conclusion and sit on the opposite side of the spectrum as it pertains to the methods used to reach said conclusion. (319)


r/Kant • • Oct 20 '24

Kant was a closeted rule utilitarian

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Kant • • Jun 15 '26

Is The Critique of Pure Reason by Immanuel Kant a proof by contradiction?

0 Upvotes

Is he doing a proof by contradiction? Because none of the book makes any sense, following this I would have to concur that in his efforts to seem reasonable he manages to do the complete opposite.

I’ll simple it down for those of you that don’t do math.

Critique of Unreason => True

Therefore Critique of Pure reason => False


r/Kant • • Jul 13 '26

Practical question on Sartre and Beauvoir, and Leibnitz and Hume and Kant and any other question in mind (without following them as a position on religion)

0 Upvotes

If we live in the best possible world (the problem of teodicea/ theodicy in Leibnitz), what exactly is that world, and what should it be (considering there is evil in it)? Please describe the best possible world, using examples as Descartes, Hume, Sartre, and Beauvoir and Kant did in their philosophy. To anybody who has already done it, I am forgetful; please remind me. And if you are interested too.


r/Kant • • May 19 '24

Why is the 'conscience; therefore, I exist' AKA cogito, er sum so popular?

0 Upvotes

Why do we put so much importance to this saying? Cogito can just as possibly be a function of evolution such as a dog's thirst for water is that same function of evolution?

You are what? A blob of matter I can't penetrate with words because you ignore your hearing faculties, have underdeveloped logical functions, or don't know how to raise objections to the things I put forward?


r/Kant • • Jan 15 '26

Free will is our ability to abolish any moral law

2 Upvotes

Homo sapiens live in both nature and freedom.

  • In freedom, the primary cause is a moral law.

  • In nature, the primary cause is a law of nature.

Nature itself is the creator and giver of the laws of nature.

No one has the ability to abolish any law of nature.

Everyone has the ability to abolish any moral law.

  • To abolish a moral law is an inner operation.

  • To obey or break a moral law is an outer operation.

With our ability to abolish any moral law, we are like God (כֵּֽאלֹהִ֔ים/kelohim) (Gn 3:5).

https://parakletos.dk/theology.html#freedom


r/Kant • • Oct 17 '26

Crosspost I just took Immanuel Kant's virginity. AMA

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/Kant • • Aug 14 '23

.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/Kant • • May 21 '26

Auditing the Kantian-Categories: Cognitive Muscle, Linguistic Hardcode, and Neural Signature

1 Upvotes

The most enduring trace of Kant's system is still his supposed proof of the categories. The main claim — that the categories were deduced from the a priori way we connect things — remains controversial. But the more modest claim, that some canonical expression of our pattern-matching ability must be the mind's default in any act of normal judgment, is currently enjoying wide acceptance across cognitive science, neurology, and adjacent fields.

This puts those of us working in Kant scholarship, or even just in informal philosophical reflection, in a uniquely productive position. We can use the roots of his framework like no one else to debate what may be the new fundamental question in philosophy of mind: what cognitive muscles are being activated when someone thinks, how do they interact with the semantic correlation muscles hardcoded in the natural language in use, and how do they produce a signature that would be auditable in neural scans — and eventually in scans of artificial systems.

Which is precisely why studies that claim to approach this question deserve to be held to the highest standard.

Even if a study showed different neural signatures for intuitionistic versus classical reasoning — different regions, different timing, different activation patterns — it would still face a problem it has not even begun to address. It would need to show that what it is measuring is the reasoner's own cognitive strategy, and not a compressed inheritance from a tradition they were trained inside. The brain doing classical logic in 2025 is not doing what Aristotle did. It is running a heavily preprocessed cultural technology. The neural signature you are measuring may be the signature of having learned a system — not the signature of the reasoning itself. Those are not the same thing, and no localization study can separate them without a prior account of how intellectual inheritance sediments into cognitive habit.

The problem is even deeper:

Euclid's steps into his own system are not recoverable by scanning anyone alive today. The inferential work that built the framework is gone. What remains is the framework as received — already hardcoded, already walls rather than conclusions. The study is measuring reasoning inside a tradition, not reasoning as a cognitive act in any philosophically relevant sense. The object it wants to study is partly historical and partly distributed across centuries of work that left no brain to scan.

This is the first pre-Ai-assisted draft of this post for those that think it is of value:

how to scan kantian-categorical work in three levels: cogntiive, linguistic and neural...The most eenduring trace of Kants system is still his supposed proof of the categories, and although the main claim (the the categories wre deduced from the a priopri way we connect things) is controversial, the more modest claim (that some form of canonical expression of our pattern-matching ability must be the minds default in any act of normal judgment) is curretly gozando de larga aceitação da ciência cognitie, neurologia etc. Showing a brain region lighting up tells you where something is happening, not what the computation is, not what inferential structure it has, not whether it is the same kind of cognitive work as mathematical proof or something closer to intuitionistic reasoning or something else entirely (the debate in logic nowadays is if there is a unique one or if pluralistic accounts align with pure cognitive signatures and if it does, how the disalignment happens in the transition from cognition to language). The localization without the functional and semantic account is just a map.


r/Kant • • May 05 '26

My Take on the Dead Internet Theory — From a Kantian Perspective

0 Upvotes

The Kantian argument would be a version of his answer to Hume: associationists like pure classical empiricists overstate how much we can connect and associate; there must be some constraints in the realm of the possible that trace back to how our mind organize experience. So the same would go here: dead internet thesis overstates what nonsense can actually do. Even nonsense does not arise in a vacuum — it emerges within a field already structured by meaning, and that structure eventually asserts itself: a superstition exposed by a better connection, an older theory reframed by a stronger one. The Kantian point here is not trivial: higher synthesis is not optional. Once representations are connected, the pressure toward more coherent organization is built into the architecture of representation itself. You cannot permanently stabilize a weaker structure when a stronger one is available. The flat earther machine fails not because we correct it from outside, but because the internal logic of constraint will not hold still at that level.

But here is where I think the theory gets something right, even if for the wrong reasons.

Most of our lives do not unfold in the paradigmatic spaces where constraints are strong — where mathematical relations have displaced naive associations, where differential structure is stable and overrepresented. Most of our lives happen in the regions where constraints are weaker, distinctions blur, and multiple incompatible connections can coexist without forcing a resolution. Politics. Social organization. Identity. Value. These are not domains where higher synthesis is automatically compelled.

And in those regions, the danger is not chaos. It is something more insidious: coherent, functional, self-sustaining nonsense — systems that successfully simulate sense across deep contradictions, not by resolving them, but by stabilizing at exactly the level of coherence needed to keep the deeper inconsistency permanently below the threshold of higher synthesis.

The whole texts soon here:

https://www.patreon.com/cw/LucasVollet


r/Kant • • May 29 '26

Empiricism and Intergenerational Learning

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: following essay contains AI use for formatting, grammatical and expressive improvement.

Classical empiricism needs to be revised. Its basic intuition is sound: knowledge comes from contact with the world. But it is too narrow if it restricts learning to the lifetime of the individual subject. Human beings do not confront experience as blank slates. They confront it through nervous systems already shaped by a vast history of encounters between organism and environment. The empiricist must therefore expand the concept of learning to include not only individual learning, but intergenerational learning through evolution.

Kant argued that experience is possible only because the mind already organizes sensation through basic categories such as causality, substance, unity, plurality, and number. We do not first perceive a meaningless stream of impressions and then gradually infer an ordered world. We perceive events as caused, objects as enduring, quantities as countable, and changes as occurring within a stable field of reality. These structures are not optional beliefs added to experience. They are part of the machinery that makes experience intelligible.

The empiricist objection is that such categories should not be treated as eternal possessions of pure reason. If the mind has these structures, they must have an origin. But the answer need not be that the individual learned them from personal experience. The better answer is that the species learned them. Across evolutionary time, organisms whose nervous systems parsed the world in causally and objectually useful ways survived better than organisms that did not. Natural selection gradually installed cognitive machinery that anticipates regularity, persistence, quantity, agency, and causal connection.

This means the Kantian categories can be understood as learned, but not by the conscious individual. They are learned by the lineage. They are the sedimented result of ancestral trial and error. What appears as a priori in the individual is a posteriori in natural history. Causality is not derived from my personal observations, but from the long evolutionary history that produced a brain unable to experience the world except in causal terms.

This revision strengthens empiricism rather than destroying it. It preserves the empiricist claim that cognition is ultimately answerable to worldly contact, while admitting the Kantian point that the individual mind comes pre-structured. The world teaches the organism in two ways: first, through the individual’s experience; second, through the selective pressures that shaped the organism before birth. Classical empiricism recognized only the first. A modern empiricism must recognize both.

The result is an evolutionary empiricism. It denies that the categories are timeless metaphysical necessities, but it also denies that they are arbitrary habits learned by each person. They are inherited forms of apprehension produced by countless generations of environmental testing. They are empirical in origin, but a priori in function. We experience through them because our ancestors survived by doing so.

Empiricism, therefore, should not oppose Kant too simply. It should absorb him. The mind is not a blank slate, but neither is it an ahistorical tribunal of pure reason. It is a biological inheritance, structured by the world before the individual ever opens his eyes. The categories are learned — not in childhood, but in evolution.


r/Kant • • Aug 15 '23

Prolegomenon to the anthropology of monkey (homo-sapiens) PENSES

Thumbnail
scribd.com
0 Upvotes

r/Kant • • Nov 14 '22

…On today’s episode: can we use categorical imperative to justify sex with dogs…

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Kant • • Sep 13 '25

Question What would the Kantian view of capitalism be?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Kant • • Dec 03 '24

the most common answer that seems right is always wrong because truth up to this point has been brought by death (Evolution) and we aren’t dead yet

3 Upvotes

^


r/Kant • • Jul 10 '25

I have a new form of neoKantianism (transcendental emergentism) for you and it solves most of the current problems in cosmology

0 Upvotes

What if Kant was literally correct: space and time only exist within consciousness...but idealism isn't true either? The implication is that classical reality and consciousness both emerged together not at the big bang but 555mya, on Earth, just before the Cambrian Explosion kicked off. "Before" that (though time didn't exist) the apparent history of the cosmos only existed in a noumenal-informational-quantum superposition. The uncollapsed wave function is noumena, collapsed classical reality is phenomena.

This immediately gets rid of not just the Measurement Problem in QM and the Hard Problem of Consciousness, it also gets rid of all of cosmology's fine-tuning problems (and allows us to get rid of inflation), and all of the "mismatch between QM and GR" problems. It explains why we can't quantise gravity (because gravity belongs to phenomenal reality, so doesn't need to be quantised at all).

The Two-Phase Cosmology (2PC) says reality unfolds in two distinct phases:

  • Phase 1: a timeless, quantum-informational superposition of all possible histories (Kant's noumena, except it is no longer completely unknowable).

  • Phase 2: the collapsed, classical universe we observe—ordered, causal, evolving in time (Kant's phenomena).

The collapse from Phase 1 to Phase 2 isn’t caused by a particle detector or decoherence. It happens when a conscious agent -- a participating observer -- emerges within the superposed system and begins making real decisions. This requires a global, irreversible selection of one consistent history (via the Quantum Convergence Threshold, QCT), giving rise to the flow of time, physical laws, and classical reality.

This single shift solves many deep puzzles:

  • Cosmology’s fine-tuning problems disappear because the “initial conditions” aren’t initial—they’re selected retroactively from the space of all possible histories.

  • Inflation is unnecessary: cosmic smoothness and structure follow from post-collapse consistency, not pre-collapse mechanisms.

  • The cosmological constant problem vanishes: vacuum energy in Phase 1 (quantum) doesn’t need to match what we observe in Phase 2 (classical).

  • Gravity resists quantization because it emerges after collapse—it's not a quantum force.

  • The measurement problem dissolves: there is no need to choose between Many-Worlds or Consciousness-Causes-Collapse—both are aspects of the same two-phase process.

  • The hard problem of consciousness is reframed: consciousness isn’t a product of matter; matter is a product of a conscious phase transition in the universal wavefunction.

  • Free will becomes real, not illusory—it is the very mechanism by which reality takes form.

The idea is radical but profoundly simplifying. Once you grasp the two-phase structure, the “weirdness” of quantum mechanics, the mystery of consciousness, and the anomalies of cosmology begin to make elegant, intuitive sense.

The Reality Crisis (series of articles)

Zenodo link for a PDF of the whole series of articles as single document

Very brief introduction to the whole system

Article explaining what this has to do with philosophy (esp. Kant, Hume and postmodernism/post-postmodernism). I call it Transcendental Emergentism.


r/Kant • • Jan 19 '26

Free will is our ability to abolish any law of freedom

2 Upvotes

[Sorry for posting a slight variation again, but by saying 'abolish any law of freedom', instead of 'abolish any moral law', I think I have made an improvement.]

Homo sapiens live in both nature and freedom.

  • In nature, the primary cause is a law of nature.

  • In freedom, the primary cause is a law of freedom.

Nature itself is the creator and giver of the laws of nature.

  • No one has the ability to abolish any law of nature.

  • Everyone has the ability to abolish any law of freedom.

To abolish a law of freedom is an inner operation.

To obey or break a law of freedom is an outer operation.

With our ability to abolish any law of freedom, we are like God (כֵּֽאלֹהִ֔ים/kelohim) (Gn 3:5).

https://parakletos.dk/theology.html#freedom

[About laws of freedom, Kant writes: "In contrast to laws of nature, these laws of freedom are called moral laws. As directed merely to external actions and their conformity to law they are called juridical laws; but if they also require that they (the laws) themselves be the determining grounds of actions, they are ethical laws, and then one says that conformity with juridical laws is the legality of an action and conformity with ethical laws is its morality." (The metaphysics of Morals, VI:214, trans. Mary Gregor)]