This might seem more ‘boring’ than a pocket universe or alternate dimension or whatever. But I think it would be a very cool subversion of our expectations for a sci-fi.
I’m not saying I believe it, but I like to keep an open mind. I’ve tried to look for evidence that would rule out this possibility, but I just keep noticing little things that seem to support the idea.
First, Clark’s map seems to show that he actively tried to see if the backrooms ‘overlaps’ or connects back to his basement from a different direction. But the halls just terminate at dead ends when they get close to the real basement. Clark noticed this and wrote ‘dead end!’ On his map. And the real basement is surrounded by dark shading and question marks. It looks like the complex cannot occupy the same area as the real basement, perhaps because they aren’t in separate ‘spacetimes’ or ‘dimensions’.
More details and discussion of the above can be found here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/KanePixelsBackrooms/s/qqKdiw38Yq
Also, I remember seeing some theories that, because California doesn’t have many basements, the store basement wasn’t ’real’ but actually part of the complex. But Californians debunked that, giving some examples of stores with basements. But if basements are relatively rare in that area, it would explain why the complex has lots of room to ‘stretch out’ at that level underground.
Third, the earthquake that happened when they opened the threshold could have been the initial rapid expansion underground. Instead of just the result of a subterranean nuclear blast.
Fourth, a subterranean pipeline map is seen on the cork board in Overflow. If the complex took information from that room, the map could have served as a ‘guide’ for expansion. Perhaps the pipelines serve as electrical conduits of some kind.
I could go on with lots more little clues, but I’m curious to see what others may have noticed.
Now obviously there is some very weird physical phenomena happening in the complex, so it feels like a different reality. But physics is showing more and more that our own universe is way weirder than most of us realize. Under certain extreme laboratory conditions, real world physicists have created some truly wild effects and processes that could easily get out of hand without the proper safety protocols enforced. The complex could just be an example of what unchecked scientific curiosity could do to our planet, right here at home.
No worries if you think it’s a crazy idea, but I think I t’s always good to question foundational assumptions once in a while. Even just to test them.