r/KDRAMA • • Dec 25 '21

On-Air: JTBC Snowdrop [Episode 4]

25 Upvotes

Episode 1 | Episode 2 | Episode 3

  • Plot Synopsis:

Set in 1987, when South Korea was governed by a dictatorial government.

Graduate student Im Soo-Ho (Jung Hae-In) is covered in blood and he jumps into the female dormitory at Hosoo Women’s University. Eun Young-Ro (Kim Ji-Soo) finds him and helps to hide him. They develop a romantic relationship.

Im Soo-Ho is graduate student at a prestigious university. He is Korean-German. He has charisma and he is also mysterious.

Eun Young-Ro is in the first grade of Hosoo Women’s University. She is a major in English literature. She first met Im Soo-Ho on a blind date and fell in love with him at first sight.

Kye Boon-Ok (Kim Hye-Yoon) gave up entering university due to her poor family background. She now works as a telephone operator at a women’s dormitory. Pretending to be a university student, she attends a blind date with Eun Young-Ro. Kye Boon-Ok later gets involved in a case.

Lee Kang-Moo (Jang Seung-Jo) is the leader of team 1 at NSP (National Security Planning). He is a man of principle, who doesn't compromise in any situation. (Source: AsianWiki)

  • Conduct Reminder:

We encourage our users to read the following before participating in any discussions on /r/KDRAMA: (1) Reddiquette, (2) our Conduct Rules (3) our Policies, and (4) the When Discussions Get Personal Post. Any users who are displaying negative conduct (including but not limited to bullying, harassment, or personal attacks) will be given a warning, repeated behaviour will lead to increasing exclusions from our community. Any extreme cases of misconduct (such as racism or hate speech) will result in an immediate permanent ban from our community and a report to Reddit admin. Additionally, mentions of down-voting, unpopular opinions, and the use of profanity may see your comments locked or removed without notice.

  • Spoiler Tag Reminder:

Be mindful of others who may not have yet seen this drama, and use spoiler tags when discussing key plot developments or other important information. You can create a spoiler tag by writing > ! this! < without the spaces in between to get this spoiler. For more information about when and how to use spoiler tags see our Spoiler Tag Wiki

This on-air discussion requires a flair passport to participate. Sign up here ◡̈


r/KDRAMA • • Jan 20 '22

Discussion My problems with most Kdrama male leads

6 Upvotes

I'm not saying Kdrama is bad, I just can't stand seeing the common ML tropes.

(1) Why do they have to be rich all the time?

CEO here CEO that. Always a CEO. If not he could be a rich man with fancy life because of his parents. The problem here is that most FL see this as a win/win situation due to poverty. But what if the guy is poor tho? Can the FL still love him? It would be more romantic if the FL loves the guy simply because she really loves him and not because he can provide for her dreams and able to spend money for expensive flowers and surprises.

(2) Arrogant

Can't they just make a cool ML who is really cool without being arrogant? I know the reason behind this is to show that the FL can change him. That he is an a-hole to other people except to her. This shouldn't be an ideal love story. If I saw a man yelling at the old man, mocking other girls, disrespecting his parents, and being rude to children I'm not going to say "Oh he's my ideal man I wanna marry him!" It doesn't matter if he will treat me special, if he finds out that I'm just a human with flaws that is same with other people then he will dump me for sure.

(3) Spoiled

And because they are rich, they are spoiled also. I watched a makjang once (the title was "Secret Daughter" I think) and I didn't like it. The ML was spoiled and useless af. He can't do chores and he can't eat cheap food. He is not perfect for the hardworking FL. If the FL get sick then he might not be able to take care of her. How can he wipe her puke if he can't even eat cheap food? Not even mentioning the fact that he can't do chores so the FL still have to do it and endure the sickness.

(4) It would be better if they are not just "male leads"

I don't like how most writers focus so much on writing an interesting FL but they can't do the same to the ML. The FL had a dream, a family that she loves, sense of humor, and friends that she loves hanging out with. But the ML? He's just rich and handsome. He usually don't have anything to do aside from being a love interest. He should have a personality that had something to do outside the FL's life. He could be an animal-lover, an artist who loves drawing strangers and giving it to them, or anything that has nothing to do with the FL. And this is the reason why I love the ML in Goblin. He is not just a love interest, he interacts kindly to other people and he even had a younger sister that he loves so much.

This is just my opinion. Feel free to share what you think.


r/KDRAMA • • Dec 28 '21

Discussion Question about historical distortion controversies

3 Upvotes

So, with the recent media around historical distortion in Snowdrop (which I have not watched), I am reminded of similar issues being reported with Mr Queen and Joseon Exorcist about their portrayal of historical figures, amongst other things.

Can someone with more experience with Kdramas and maybe Korean culture as a whole provide any more insight on why (I assume) Korean fans were so angered by these distortions in clearly fictional and fantasy works that involved time travel and body swapping (in the case of Mr Queen) and literal evil spirits/zombies (in Exorcist)?

I mean - is it an unwillingness to accept to poetic licence/creativity or an inability to separate between the fictional character depiction of a historical figure and the actual historical figure?


r/KDRAMA • • Jan 14 '20

Discussion Anyone else worried about Netflix ruining K-drama?

0 Upvotes

Well not ruining per say, but I feel like K-dramas on Netflix are taking over and becoming more popular than the ones aired on Korean channels. I am worried that this could negatively affect K-drama as we know it.

Netflix dramas are usually 45-minutes long, containing 8 episodes per drama and that same drama can get a second season. This is the typical television format you'd see on Netflix shows which was created to save the service at much money as possible while being able to produce as much content as possible (meaning they release more shows with the same format).

That is different than the traditional format of k-drama, which is 1-hour long episodes, 16 episodes per show and there normally isn't another season. Not to mention Netflix dramas are very westernised and encourage themes that are not typically present in traditional k-dramas.

The more Netflix shows become popular, I feel like traditional dramas could be affected and korean channels will be less encouraged to produce more shows because Netflix is taking over with their money-efficient television show format.

I try to stay away from Netflix K-productions as much as possible because they just don't have the same feel to it as traditional ones. They also feel more polished and yet not well written as the latter. I was wondering if anyone was thinking the same?


r/KDRAMA • • Dec 24 '21

On-Air: JTBC Snowdrop [Episode 3]

54 Upvotes

Episode 1 | Episode 2

  • Plot Synopsis:

Set in 1987, when South Korea was governed by a dictatorial government.

Graduate student Im Soo-Ho (Jung Hae-In) is covered in blood and he jumps into the female dormitory at Hosoo Women’s University. Eun Young-Ro (Kim Ji-Soo) finds him and helps to hide him. They develop a romantic relationship.

Im Soo-Ho is graduate student at a prestigious university. He is Korean-German. He has charisma and he is also mysterious.

Eun Young-Ro is in the first grade of Hosoo Women’s University. She is a major in English literature. She first met Im Soo-Ho on a blind date and fell in love with him at first sight.

Kye Boon-Ok (Kim Hye-Yoon) gave up entering university due to her poor family background. She now works as a telephone operator at a women’s dormitory. Pretending to be a university student, she attends a blind date with Eun Young-Ro. Kye Boon-Ok later gets involved in a case.

Lee Kang-Moo (Jang Seung-Jo) is the leader of team 1 at NSP (National Security Planning). He is a man of principle, who doesn't compromise in any situation. (Source: AsianWiki)

  • Conduct Reminder:

We encourage our users to read the following before participating in any discussions on /r/KDRAMA: (1) Reddiquette, (2) our Conduct Rules (3) our Policies, and (4) the When Discussions Get Personal Post. Any users who are displaying negative conduct (including but not limited to bullying, harassment, or personal attacks) will be given a warning, repeated behaviour will lead to increasing exclusions from our community. Any extreme cases of misconduct (such as racism or hate speech) will result in an immediate permanent ban from our community and a report to Reddit admin. Additionally, mentions of down-voting, unpopular opinions, and the use of profanity may see your comments locked or removed without notice.

  • Spoiler Tag Reminder:

Be mindful of others who may not have yet seen this drama, and use spoiler tags when discussing key plot developments or other important information. You can create a spoiler tag by writing > ! this! < without the spaces in between to get this spoiler. For more information about when and how to use spoiler tags see our Spoiler Tag Wiki

This on-air discussion requires a flair passport to participate. Sign up here ◡̈


r/KDRAMA • • Oct 27 '25

The r/KDRAMA Approach Moderation Approach of This Community

8 Upvotes

Our Guiding Moderation Approach

As the global popularity of kdramas have grown, membership in our community has also skyrocketed. The bigger our community has grown, the more diversity there is in the interests, wants, and habits of our community. While our rules, policies, and moderation practices are continuously evolving with the growth of our community, our 'bottom line' approach and philosophy towards moderation in this community remains unchanged.

Essentially we view r/KDRAMA as a subreddit dedicated to the kdramas -- that is to say the universal common factor for all members of this community is that we all watch kdramas. Beyond watching kdramas and discussing them though, it is apparent that the interests and wants of the community members differ from each other. While all of us are united in watching kdramas and discussing them, some will go beyond just watching and discussing kdramas to being fans of actors and actresses, with an interest in their personal lives beyond their acting work. Similarly, some of our community also go beyond Kdramas and consume other K-entertainment such as Kpop, variety shows or movies. However all these are in the realm personal preferences beyond the universal common factor of watching and discussing kdramas.

As a mod team, we have chosen to steer our community based on the most universal common factor uniting us all -- the watching and discussing of kdramas. And even within this most universal commonality, we differ from each other in which dramas we watch as we do not all watch the same dramas. Thus, based on this aspect of differences between us as viewers, we have to seek a compromise and a balance of interests where no posts about a single drama or issue dominate our subreddit feed because it is a fact that there is no single drama or issue that is of interest for every single member of the community. As a result, our rules and policies strictly limit what types of content may be shared as posts within our community, especially with regards to news items.

We know this approach does not cater to everyone's preferences but it does satisfy the most universal common factor that brought all of us to this community. This approach is a compromise that balances various interests of our large and diverse community, we ask that users who are not satisfied by this compromise to also think about other users that hold different opinions and are partaking in this compromise too -- a bit of kindness, tolerance, and understanding goes a long way.

Our Rules and Policies

Our moderation of the subreddit is done according to our Rules and Policies, which the mod team reviews and revises regularly in accordance to the growth and state of the community.

While we maintain an abbreviated version of our rules in our sidebar widget on New Reddit, it is the full rules and policies contained within our wiki, as linked above, that ultimately governs and guides moderation in our subreddit.

There Are Too Many Rules

Aside from conduct rules, the bulk of our rules are on what content may be posted as posts in our community, such as which specific types of news articles are allowed. If you do not want to take the time and energy to review our content rules, then you can choose to just engage with the community via commenting only. For comments, as long as you remain respectful and on-topic to the post at hand, you will be fine. There is no need to make posts if you find navigating our content rules to be too challenging.

We especially encourage new members of our community to refrain from immediately making post submissions when they first join our community and instead engage with our community through commenting and observing the type of discussion and review posts that are posted within our community. By observation and engagement via commenting, many new users and new watchers of kdramas will better understand kdramas and our community, which often helps ensure that when users do end up making posts, these posts are a good fit for our community. This is especially the case as our community tends to receive many submissions of content that is rehashed in our community or has information already available within our community's subreddit wiki resources.

Censorship! or But My Freedom of Speech

The Reddit User Agreement does not guarantee freedom of speech rights and in fact clearly state that content posted to Reddit is subject to deletion and removal at Reddit's sole discretion. If your content is deleted by Reddit, please reach out to them to argue your case.

For content removed from the subreddit by the moderators -- please note that removal of content from a subreddit only means that other members of the community can no longer view the content within the subreddit, it does not mean that the moderators have deleted your content.

Importantly, subreddits are not obligated to permit all kinds of content to be posted within the community. In fact, moderators are expected to create and enforce rules for their subreddits1 while removing posts and comments that violate their community-specific rules2. As moderators, we have a duty to moderate what types of content is permitted in our community in order to preserve the culture, health, and engagement of our community. If the culture of our community is not acceptable for you, please seek alternate subreddits.

If you strongly believe that our moderation is in violation of your rights, legal or otherwise, in relation to the use of Reddit or that our moderation actions are in violation of Reddit's Moderator Guidelines, please contact Reddit directly as they have the ultimate authority over moderators. Here is Reddit Help's information about Reporting that may be assist you in making a report.

Responding to Moderation Actions in General

DO'S

  • Read anything from the mod team carefully. The mod team leaves comments and messages to inform users, please take the time to read these comments and messages to be better able to participate in our community. Failing to read and comprehend messages and comments from the mod team is never an acceptable excuse for rule breaking behavior.

  • Remember the human. Be civil when responding and engaging with members of the mod team. Incivility and hostility when responding to moderation actions will likely lead to more negative consequences, not less.

  • Get some distance and perspective before responding. Responding emotionally in the heat of the moment is generally not a good thing. We suggest that you take a break before responding.

  • Have patience. Moderators are volunteers and we are not online 24/7, please have some patience when engaging with the mod team when you do not receive an immediate answer.

DONT'S

  • Do not be hostile. Hostility and incivility will get you no where other than banned from our community. Incivility is not limited to profanity or hate speech and includes things like personal attacks and insults made directly or indirectly.

  • Do not assume you are the only one receiving moderation action. In situations where multiple users are involved in problematic behavior, the mod team will take varying levels of moderation action on all users involved. However, the mod team is under no obligation to disclose their moderation actions to other users. Hounding the mod team to take action on others users will not help your case so do not do it.

  • Do not engage in Rules Lawyering. Rules lawyering will not help your case and wastes everyone's time. Ultimately the mod team has the final say on the interpretation and application of our Rules and Policies.

  • Do not dictate how the mod team should moderate. We will not moderate based on the whims of any one specific user so telling us that we should moderate a certain way because you think that is the better/best approach will not change our moderation.

Moderator Role Explained

Moderators are users that help manage a subreddit community by moderating the content that is allowed in the community, establishing and communicating relevant rules and policies, and engaging with other community members.

Moderating a subreddit is an unofficial, voluntary position.

Moderators are not employees of Reddit and are limited in what they can do, with many things they cannot do.

For example, moderators CANNOT do the following:

  • move posts or threads

  • edit other users' submissions or comments

  • delete other users' submissions or comments (only remove in communities they mod)

Please keep the above information in mind when engaging with the moderation team in general and especially when responding to moderation actions. The active members of the r/KDRAMA team are also active users in this community and we love to see our kdrama community thrive. We volunteer our time and energy to the community because we treasure the community and kdramas, so please treat us with respect as you would other members of the community.


Note: This post is part of our recurring post series 'The r/KDRAMA Approach' which highlights different aspects of our subreddit moderation approach and policies. Comment replies to this post are not regularly monitored by the mod team. If you need attention from the mod team, please either start your comment with "Mods" or send a Modmail.


r/KDRAMA • • Dec 26 '21

On-Air: JTBC Snowdrop [Episode 5]

64 Upvotes

Episode 1 | Episode 2 | Episode 3 | Episode 4

  • Plot Synopsis:

Set in 1987, when South Korea was governed by a dictatorial government.

Graduate student Im Soo-Ho (Jung Hae-In) is covered in blood and he jumps into the female dormitory at Hosoo Women’s University. Eun Young-Ro (Kim Ji-Soo) finds him and helps to hide him. They develop a romantic relationship.

Im Soo-Ho is graduate student at a prestigious university. He is Korean-German. He has charisma and he is also mysterious.

Eun Young-Ro is in the first grade of Hosoo Women’s University. She is a major in English literature. She first met Im Soo-Ho on a blind date and fell in love with him at first sight.

Kye Boon-Ok (Kim Hye-Yoon) gave up entering university due to her poor family background. She now works as a telephone operator at a women’s dormitory. Pretending to be a university student, she attends a blind date with Eun Young-Ro. Kye Boon-Ok later gets involved in a case.

Lee Kang-Moo (Jang Seung-Jo) is the leader of team 1 at NSP (National Security Planning). He is a man of principle, who doesn't compromise in any situation. (Source: AsianWiki)

  • Conduct Reminder:

We encourage our users to read the following before participating in any discussions on /r/KDRAMA: (1) Reddiquette, (2) our Conduct Rules (3) our Policies, and (4) the When Discussions Get Personal Post. Any users who are displaying negative conduct (including but not limited to bullying, harassment, or personal attacks) will be given a warning, repeated behaviour will lead to increasing exclusions from our community. Any extreme cases of misconduct (such as racism or hate speech) will result in an immediate permanent ban from our community and a report to Reddit admin. Additionally, mentions of down-voting, unpopular opinions, and the use of profanity may see your comments locked or removed without notice.

  • Spoiler Tag Reminder:

Be mindful of others who may not have yet seen this drama, and use spoiler tags when discussing key plot developments or other important information. You can create a spoiler tag by writing > ! this! < without the spaces in between to get this spoiler. For more information about when and how to use spoiler tags see our Spoiler Tag Wiki

This on-air discussion requires a flair passport to participate. Sign up here ◡̈


r/KDRAMA • • Jul 02 '20

Replace Kim Go Eun with Gong Hyo Jin in Goblin...

0 Upvotes

Don't get me wrong I LOVE LOVE LOVE Kim Go Eun, but when I watched Goblin the age difference really bothered me and the immaturity of the main character (since she's a high schooler) got really annoying at times. The concept of the whole show was very captivating and I can't help but wonder how much better it would have been if the main character was older and played by an older actress like Gong Hyo Jin- I think the connection between the characters would have felt stronger and heavier as well- given that the main female would be more mature, I would have liked those interactions better. I think it would have been an improvement.

Still loved the show either way, and I understand certain plot elements would have to change.

Anyone feel the same way?

EDIT: It's not a matter of being woke, and I never put the blame of KGE for the things I didn't like about the character. I think I asked the wrong question, perhaps I should have said if the characters were written differently it would have been better. If KGE character was written more maturely the whole show would have just been better.

I get that it's a fantasy- that's not something I can't wrap my head around- just because it's fantasy it doesn't mean that it's immune to any criticism in terms of plot and characters, just because it's a fantasy it doesn't necessarily mean that anything goes and you now can't find anything wrong with it since it's so far fetched to begin with.

I'm new to this sub and I didn't know there are often age gap questions- the fact that it's a common question I'm guessing stems from the fact that it's a common theme in Kdramas, and we all know it's usually an older man with a younger female- I think there's nothing wrong with constantly pointing it out (and I get that it's often two consenting adults).


r/KDRAMA • • Jul 17 '21

Discussion [DISCUSSION] Lee Eun O's character in Lovestruck in the city is a terrible person. Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Edit - apologies for the timeline mix-up, when i saw the drama I thought lee eun o had not broken up with her bf before going to yangyang. i was mistaken.

So I know this will bear me down with a lot of criticism. But hear me first and then go one with your respective moral reasonings.

Lee Eun O's character in Lovestruck in the City was a terrible person. She lied and cheated through and through and had zero explanations as to why she did it, nor was there a reason to explain. Her actions defined her identity not the other way round. When she came back from Yangyang to find her ex- boyfriend w another girl, whom he had impregnated. The first thing people felt was what an asshole Bf, the first thing i noticed was She had a bf when she went to Yangyang, where she met a man, kissed him, slept with him and even married him. That makes her no better than her ex - boyfriend. Both of them were exactly the same, and that's probably why they dated.

She misled her friends for so long. I understand their anger towards her ex - boyfriend because they didn't know of Park Jae Won's existence - what haunts me is that she never had the decency to tell them otherwise until much later which was introduced into the storyline as a redemption arch for forgiveness but imo was bullshit.

She stole, she lied, she ghosted, she cheated under the pretense of having two distinct identities. And when she finally accepts all her identifies are her - she should also accept her wrongs instead of making it a plot device for a characters "growth and moving on".

I'll blame it kn the writers obviously, they wrote Ji Chang Wook's character beautifully but took away any ground of moral sublimation Lee Eun O might have achieved.

If you say they were Lee Euno vs Yoon Seon Na and hence it's justified, please rethink.


r/KDRAMA • • Nov 27 '21

Review D.P: important topic but disappointing execution Spoiler

0 Upvotes

It sometimes happens that important and quite shocking topic covers flaws of production. And for me D.P. is example of that. It potrays pretty realistic and direct way pathology in Korean army before reform from 2014 and how traumatic experience was that for many young men (it is universal problem in armies with conscription). But beyond that it is good drama? I’ve doubts about it.

Firstly D.P. is very film like. In good and bad way .Cinematography is natural and on high level like we should expect from film director. Cast is top notch, all young rising film stars. Koo Gyo-Hwan as Ho-Yeol again steals the show (his breaktrough is the only positive of Peninsula) and Cho Hyun Chul like always shines in complicated techincally role of victim who becomes pertrator after mental breakdown. Jung Hae In as Jun-Ho (main lead) gives good but standard performance. Son Suk-Ku performs comedic break as jerk capitan with suprising depth. Not a fan of Kim Sung-Kyun’s role, he didn’t have much present.

D.P. is adaptation of webcomic and unfortunatelly I’ve impression that screnwriters: Kim Bo-Tong (author of original series) and Han Jun-Hee (film director) were defeated by series format. Drama is written like film and that’s exactly big flaw of it. If we take out cases of Jeong Hyeon-Min and Heo Chi-do, we would get pretty much film scenario after small edits. And that’s why there are parts which seems like forgotten (f.e. Ho-Yeol’s knive attacker) or unexplored (Jun-Ho’s complicated relationship with his family). Editing of episodes is also strange and inconsistent ( f.e. one episode ends up with dramatic information that father is in hospital but in next episode scenes with him takes like 30s). I think overall that it’d be much better if they focus less on cases (cut one or two) and more on developing main characters. And false ending really doesn’t work well with series format. It is more tiring than even in films.

This is already pretty serious issues. But the worst one for me is actually dramatic characterisation of Jun-Ho. He is messy written. I suspect that he was originaly planned as kind everyman (openining especially suggests that) but somehowe he ends more like hidden macho. And that’s made him really contradictory character from dramatic perspective. But let’s sum up his story:

Jun-Ho goes to the military and wants to finish military service without problems. So he just tries to endure and he ignores violence against him and others despite his fighting abilities. Fortunatelly he ends up in D.P. which let’s soldiers often leave base. In his first asignment he fucks up because of bad influence of partner from influential family and deserter kills himself pretty much because of them. He is sensitive guy as victim of domestic violence so he really regrets his mistake and beat up his partner. Thanks to his luck he still stays in D.P. without consequences and gets new partner. He really tries to make up his mistake in next missions. Meanwhile his friend**, Suk-Bong in the Unit is non stop violently bullied what Jun-Ho ignores** when he comes back to the base. Until he spots that Suk-Bong starts to bully new recruits and that’s when he decides first time to intervene. Then Suk-Bong almost kills his bully and becomes deserter. Jun-Ho is really desperated to catch him before bigger tragedy happens.

Suk-Bong calls Jun-Ho and Ho-Yeol hypocrites so at least this condradiction is planned by author but while I buy Ho-Yeol’s attitude I can’t say that about Jun-Ho. Why sometimes he cares so much and sometimes not? Is he has deserter-kink? It is not like it was hard to predict what can happen with Suk-Bong especially that he has expierience with similar cases. I could understand him if he played only hero outside the base but he is not really characterised this way. He can beat influential guy but can’t even try to intervene with small fries.

I think it’d be much more logical if case of suicide was in middle part. Whaterver if screenwriters planned Jun-ho as real everyman coward who is afraid of bullies or macho who thinks that everyone is responsible for only yourself (what could be partially related to his mother), there should be moment when he clearly changes his attitude for dramatic characterisation. But it’d be too late because Suk-Bo would already desert. Meanwhile they starts with suicide and that’s one of reason which made Jun-ho’s behaviour towards Su-Bong really confusing.

Maybe I’m harsh with criticism but I really didn’t expect such amateurish mistakes from quite well known film director. And that’s why for me D.P. was big disappointment. I think that too often korean directors wants to write on their own scenario (especially for longer series) when not necessary have skills or patient to do that (Squid game is another example of that, just Hwang Dong Hyuk is much more talented). But still I think it is worth to see because of topic (it is only 6 episodes) and rare occasion for kdramas fans who don’t know korean cinematography to see more realistic portrait of young Korean men.


r/KDRAMA • • Oct 07 '19

Miscellaneous The Beauty Inside OST plagiarized Ed Sheeran

2 Upvotes

The drama "The Beauty Inside," that came out around this time last year.

It has an english OST called RUN by 2morro that sounds SO INCREDIBLY much to Ed Sheeran's Castle on the Hill. The comments section doesn't seem to mention it, even though it's so blatant whenever I hear it. I wonder if anyone feels the same.

2morro - RUN https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OK_rEPSP6EQ

Ed Sheeran - Castle on the Hill https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K0ibBPhiaG0


r/KDRAMA • • Apr 27 '26

The r/KDRAMA Approach Moderation Approach of This Community

0 Upvotes

Our Guiding Moderation Approach

As the global popularity of kdramas have grown, membership in our community has also skyrocketed. The bigger our community has grown, the more diversity there is in the interests, wants, and habits of our community. While our rules, policies, and moderation practices are continuously evolving with the growth of our community, our 'bottom line' approach and philosophy towards moderation in this community remains unchanged.

Essentially we view r/KDRAMA as a subreddit dedicated to the kdramas -- that is to say the universal common factor for all members of this community is that we all watch kdramas. Beyond watching kdramas and discussing them though, it is apparent that the interests and wants of the community members differ from each other. While all of us are united in watching kdramas and discussing them, some will go beyond just watching and discussing kdramas to being fans of actors and actresses, with an interest in their personal lives beyond their acting work. Similarly, some of our community also go beyond Kdramas and consume other K-entertainment such as Kpop, variety shows or movies. However all these are in the realm personal preferences beyond the universal common factor of watching and discussing kdramas.

As a mod team, we have chosen to steer our community based on the most universal common factor uniting us all -- the watching and discussing of kdramas. And even within this most universal commonality, we differ from each other in which dramas we watch as we do not all watch the same dramas. Thus, based on this aspect of differences between us as viewers, we have to seek a compromise and a balance of interests where no posts about a single drama or issue dominate our subreddit feed because it is a fact that there is no single drama or issue that is of interest for every single member of the community. As a result, our rules and policies strictly limit what types of content may be shared as posts within our community, especially with regards to news items.

We know this approach does not cater to everyone's preferences but it does satisfy the most universal common factor that brought all of us to this community. This approach is a compromise that balances various interests of our large and diverse community, we ask that users who are not satisfied by this compromise to also think about other users that hold different opinions and are partaking in this compromise too -- a bit of kindness, tolerance, and understanding goes a long way.

Our Rules and Policies

Our moderation of the subreddit is done according to our Rules and Policies, which the mod team reviews and revises regularly in accordance to the growth and state of the community.

While we maintain an abbreviated version of our rules in our sidebar widget on New Reddit, it is the full rules and policies contained within our wiki, as linked above, that ultimately governs and guides moderation in our subreddit.

There Are Too Many Rules

Aside from conduct rules, the bulk of our rules are on what content may be posted as posts in our community, such as which specific types of news articles are allowed. If you do not want to take the time and energy to review our content rules, then you can choose to just engage with the community via commenting only. For comments, as long as you remain respectful and on-topic to the post at hand, you will be fine. There is no need to make posts if you find navigating our content rules to be too challenging.

We especially encourage new members of our community to refrain from immediately making post submissions when they first join our community and instead engage with our community through commenting and observing the type of discussion and review posts that are posted within our community. By observation and engagement via commenting, many new users and new watchers of kdramas will better understand kdramas and our community, which often helps ensure that when users do end up making posts, these posts are a good fit for our community. This is especially the case as our community tends to receive many submissions of content that is rehashed in our community or has information already available within our community's subreddit wiki resources.

Censorship! or But My Freedom of Speech

The Reddit User Agreement does not guarantee freedom of speech rights and in fact clearly state that content posted to Reddit is subject to deletion and removal at Reddit's sole discretion. If your content is deleted by Reddit, please reach out to them to argue your case.

For content removed from the subreddit by the moderators -- please note that removal of content from a subreddit only means that other members of the community can no longer view the content within the subreddit, it does not mean that the moderators have deleted your content.

Importantly, subreddits are not obligated to permit all kinds of content to be posted within the community. In fact, moderators are expected to create and enforce rules for their subreddits1 while removing posts and comments that violate their community-specific rules2. As moderators, we have a duty to moderate what types of content is permitted in our community in order to preserve the culture, health, and engagement of our community. If the culture of our community is not acceptable for you, please seek alternate subreddits.

If you strongly believe that our moderation is in violation of your rights, legal or otherwise, in relation to the use of Reddit or that our moderation actions are in violation of Reddit's Moderator Guidelines, please contact Reddit directly as they have the ultimate authority over moderators. Here is Reddit Help's information about Reporting that may be assist you in making a report.

Responding to Moderation Actions in General

DO'S

  • Read anything from the mod team carefully. The mod team leaves comments and messages to inform users, please take the time to read these comments and messages to be better able to participate in our community. Failing to read and comprehend messages and comments from the mod team is never an acceptable excuse for rule breaking behavior.

  • Remember the human. Be civil when responding and engaging with members of the mod team. Incivility and hostility when responding to moderation actions will likely lead to more negative consequences, not less.

  • Get some distance and perspective before responding. Responding emotionally in the heat of the moment is generally not a good thing. We suggest that you take a break before responding.

  • Have patience. Moderators are volunteers and we are not online 24/7, please have some patience when engaging with the mod team when you do not receive an immediate answer.

DONT'S

  • Do not be hostile. Hostility and incivility will get you no where other than banned from our community. Incivility is not limited to profanity or hate speech and includes things like personal attacks and insults made directly or indirectly.

  • Do not assume you are the only one receiving moderation action. In situations where multiple users are involved in problematic behavior, the mod team will take varying levels of moderation action on all users involved. However, the mod team is under no obligation to disclose their moderation actions to other users. Hounding the mod team to take action on others users will not help your case so do not do it.

  • Do not engage in Rules Lawyering. Rules lawyering will not help your case and wastes everyone's time. Ultimately the mod team has the final say on the interpretation and application of our Rules and Policies.

  • Do not dictate how the mod team should moderate. We will not moderate based on the whims of any one specific user so telling us that we should moderate a certain way because you think that is the better/best approach will not change our moderation.

Moderator Role Explained

Moderators are users that help manage a subreddit community by moderating the content that is allowed in the community, establishing and communicating relevant rules and policies, and engaging with other community members.

Moderating a subreddit is an unofficial, voluntary position.

Moderators are not employees of Reddit and are limited in what they can do, with many things they cannot do.

For example, moderators CANNOT do the following:

  • move posts or threads

  • edit other users' submissions or comments

  • delete other users' submissions or comments (only remove in communities they mod)

Please keep the above information in mind when engaging with the moderation team in general and especially when responding to moderation actions. The active members of the r/KDRAMA team are also active users in this community and we love to see our kdrama community thrive. We volunteer our time and energy to the community because we treasure the community and kdramas, so please treat us with respect as you would other members of the community.


Note: This post is part of our recurring post series 'The r/KDRAMA Approach' which highlights different aspects of our subreddit moderation approach and policies. Comment replies to this post are not regularly monitored by the mod team. If you need attention from the mod team, please either start your comment with "Mods" or send a Modmail.


r/KDRAMA • • Jul 22 '20

Review Hospital Playlist or Hospital Playland? A Critical Review

7 Upvotes

Hospital Playlist is truly a glass of whole milk. Wherever this hospital is, I want to go there (even though i'm not sick) and have these doctors cry for my life.

For me, Hospital Playlist ultimately lands into the pass the time category for a number of reasons:

  1. The characters are vanilla supermans. They have no flaws, which in itself could be a character trait but not for all 5 characters. Superman is boring. He's practically invincible and stands for truth and justice. He's not even technically human. But Batman is interesting. Because Batman is a vigilante, and he wants revenge. He's a good guy that resorts to beating up criminals and working outside the law to enforce justice. He doesn't want to be Batman, but he feels that he has to be. Much more complex and interesting, right? These characters in Hospital Playlist, they are are all slightly different versions of the same 'perfect' character. Their differences are at the most superficial levels. Close your eyes and give one character's line to another and it won't seem out of place.

  2. The director-writer (after the success of Reply series and Prison Playbook) is being self indulgent in his flashbacks, band performances, and the perfect hospital. This is not a reflection of life, it's one man's naive hope of what he wishes life would be like. But people like this don't exist and for good reason. Real people have more depth than this. Real people are wonderfully and monstrously imperfect.

  3. Hospitals like this don't exist. And while I am always willing to suspend belief, this world they have built has no purpose in the storytelling. They don't address or explore any of the tough moral issues and questions that naturally arise in a building of life and death. Everything ultimately feels safe and the stakes don't feel real. Even death - tragic deaths have meaning in this show even though the ultimate tragedy of life is that there is sometimes no meaning and no reason for the unfortunate and especially untimely passing of our loved ones. The family members are always perfect. If they aren't perfect, they always eventually get there along with a few tears. There is always an answer. Indonesian man with insurance? No problem, there's an anonymous benefactor. Old man can't give his liver to his daughter because he's overweight? He'll lost 20 pounds and the doctors says, sure we'll take your liver.

  4. No true conflict exists in this world - as all of us know, true conflict sometimes sees no resolution, which means that in this world, there is no place for growth or change in our characters. No one goes on a journey. We get faux journeys through 15 minute vignettes of sick patients getting better through the heroics of the doctors.

If you want to watch a drama to feel happy and have a good cry, this drama is for you. This drama will give you the feels and make you want to call your friends and your parents. And that's ok! That's one way you could pass the time, watching things that are sweet and cuddly and make you feel that everything is going to be alright and the world ain't that bad.

Should you watch this? Sure, if you want to watch a 15 hour video of a puppy greeting a solider coming home (Though these are the most beautiful 40 years old i have ever seen, so I guess that's saying something). But don't mistake watching puppy videos for an exploration of various themes of the human condition.

Whoops, forgot to talk about the most important aspect of a DRAMA, which is story: there is none...


r/KDRAMA • • Jul 01 '20

Discussion What’s going on with female lead characters?

13 Upvotes

I’ve been watching a lot of K drama the past few years and really enjoyed it. Lately I noticed that I don’t like some of the shows that are really popular, and it seems to be a theme that it’s because the female lead character who is of course pretty, sexy, often rich or becomes so, is also selfish, manipulative and petty and yet still seems extremely desirable to the lead male character.

I experienced this with Hotel del Luna, Itaewon Class, and now in It’s Okay Not to be Okay. Even though some of my favorite actors are in them I just can’t relate to these mean women even when I know there will probably be some redemption cycle by the end. Maybe this is generational since I am pretty old, but just looking for some feedback or possible explanation of why these characters seem to be becoming so popular recently.


r/KDRAMA • • Aug 31 '17

Park Hyung Sik Admits He Was Actually In Love With Park Bo Young

Thumbnail
koreaboo.com
4 Upvotes

r/KDRAMA • • Feb 19 '22

Review Our Beloved Summer: toxicity and my schadenfreude Spoiler

84 Upvotes

Honestly, I have ambivalent thoughts about Our Beloved Summer, because I felt that Yeon-su got off too lightly. She was just lucky that Ung is an extremely forbearing person who truly loved her. I'm not quite fond of imbalanced relationships, and think that her inability to communicate in a long-term relationship is a massive red flag.

I would have, frankly, chosen NJ were I in Ung's position. The earlier episodes were more exciting for me seeing NJ come to terms, slowly and surely, with her affection for Ung. When they shafted her for the sake of the main couple, I felt a bit irritated because she didn't deserve the love she wantonly threw away five years ago. It came to the point that I wanted Ji-ung to see Chae-ran's effort and Ung to end up with NJ. It also vexed me that NJ was only used as a plot device with not as much development as Ji-ung, even though she was a bright character.

I felt schadenfreude for Yeon-su's desperation and anxiety during her friendship stage with Ung, especially because she saw what she should have had been doing with NJ. Despite her tight schedule, NJ would always make time for Ung and consistently gave the effort to boost him up.

It was a bit of a letdown for me to not see Yeon-su own up to her own misdeeds in the past (because her grandmother did it for her), although Episode 15 was refreshing because she vocalized and admitted her own fault. I guess I wished to see more effort from her, especially because NJ, in contrast, was more reciprocative of Ung's kindness.

The series's acting is excellent, and the time jumps were also well-done. It's just that hinging a series on a toxic lead left a sour taste in my mouth, because it was so imbalanced against Ung. Contrast this to recent, well-written romantic comedies like Mad for Each Other, where both leads, despite THEIR mental disorders, make huge efforts to go beyond themselves for each other.

Da-li and the Cocky Prince, on the other hand, is also something that I feel has a healthier dynamic. I particularly loved one scene late in the series where Da-li empathizes with Moo-hak's plight and does everything in her power to protect him, too.

I think that an important element in romantic love is to go all the way: this was manifested even in a series like My Mister, where both leads were willing to silently go the distance for each other even without the other's knowledge. So the final episode of OBS left a bit of a bitter taste in my mouth because Ung was willing to sacrifice for Yeon-su, but she wasn't willing to do the same for him.

She's very fortunate to have a man like Ung love him.

Does anyone else think the same? I just don't think this is a masterpiece like others have stated.

8.5/10


r/KDRAMA • • Mar 02 '19

Discussion Who I personally think should've been casted in "My ID is Gangnam Beauty"

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/KDRAMA • • Mar 27 '18

K-actresses that have it all?

0 Upvotes

And by “all” I mean - face, body, popularity, talent.

Have you noticed most of Korean actresses who are considered “goddesses” have really beautiful face but they’re usually short and stocky (Song Hye Kyo, Lee Min Jung, Kim Tae Hee, Ha Ji Min). On the other hand there are actresses who have killer figures but aren’t considered that goddess like beautiful (Gong Hyo Jin, UEE).

So which actresses have it all? Beautiful face, model like figures (taller than 170 cm or 5”6’)? On top of that they’re popular and are praised for their acting?


r/KDRAMA • • Dec 19 '19

Just watched My ID is Gangnam Beauty and just want to rant

2 Upvotes

Of course female characters aren't that better off in these dramas. There is always that one pretty girl who turns out to be a manipulative toxic person great the main characters are. Like the writers already make the characters already too perfect, but somehow its not enough so they make everyone worst just to show the contrast. I just hate how kdrama's always do this, especially for male characters who are not the first or second lead. Every male character is either a misogynistic asshole, a bumbling idiot or how they are just shallow. Like how the bar owner character is an asshole because he chooses the pretty girl over the girl with the accent, when she basically fell for him because of the way he looks too. Or how the drama makes it seem ridiculous that every guy is fawning over Soo Ah, but 50% of the drama is just girls going crazy over how looking Kyung Seok is.

Which leads me to another thing that really bugged me. How can a drama, that is addressing how we shouldn't just judge people based on looks, spend so much time on how looking the main character is? It's so hypocritical.

Of course female characters aren't that better off in these dramas. There is always that one pretty girl who turns out to be a manipulative toxic person. It just feels like these characters are written just for the sole purpose of being hated. Of course Soo Ah got a small redemption arc at the end, but in most cases these characters don't become more then hate magnets.


r/KDRAMA • • Jul 27 '19

Am I the only one who lost interest watching the succeding episodes of a romantic KD because the main characters are already in a relationship? Or they already did IT?

1 Upvotes

My recent victim is ONE SPRING NIGHT, others are SHE WAS PRETTY, FIGHT FOR MY WAY.

Can someone explain what could be the reason?


r/KDRAMA • • Sep 02 '19

Did Goblin ruin all the other k-dramas for anyone else?

5 Upvotes

Goblin ruined all the k-dramas out there for me. There is no way anything out there that can satisfy my drama needs like Goblin has. And it has just ruined my life. I can't watch any other drama. Nothing is ever as good as Goblin.

I'd watched plenty of dramas before Goblin and I've always found them pretty pleasing and I'd move on to others but after watching Goblin I just can't seem to move on. It's been 2 YEARS..

The story was just so well written. I've honestly loved every single minute of it. I know some people found the age gap thing weird where as I couldn't even notice it after I was involved in it. Everything just tied up so well at the end. Every episode made my heart pound with excitement. It's made me cry with both joy and sadness. Every single person on the show had a purpose..

Maybe its childish to be so hopeful but I love the feeling that our actions are accounted for and that someone is watching over us and that all of us mean something..

Goblin just hit so many notes with me that I don't think I can get enough of it. Some of the lines are so beautiful.. Like - You can live in nightmares even when you're not dreaming.. God!! Its just indescribable.. And the whole thing about the 4 lives.. Its like the writer has gone beyond and figured all of it out..

Is it just me who's stuck??? Its been 2 years but I still keep going back.. I've watched other dramas since then but I keeping thinking Goblin was way better or comparing it mentally...

Td;dr - Goblin is the most perfect drama out there and nothing can compare.. (No offense to other dramas out there.. Just my personal opinion.. Wondering if there are others out there like me..)


r/KDRAMA • • Jul 16 '14

My new favorite korean actress - Kang so ra

0 Upvotes

I am not korean , one of reason i watched korean drama is exploration. I always looking for something totally new face or acting that you do not see anywhere. its like when ever you find it first you feel good.

Han hyo joo is one of my favorite actress because her face , mannerism is completely new compared to all other korean actress.

Now i find Kang sora in UGLY alert by exploring mydramalist.com website. I have to say she is best actress in showing emotion in romantic role. None come half level to her. Now i am planning to see all of her drama. Thought people give a try all of her drama because she can act unlike 95% of korean plastic face actresses.

The funny thing is i found her only now after watching 100+ kdrama. I missed all of her drama because some reason title of her drama did not attract or its not popular.

As you all know i normally picky and never get impressed by korean actors and actress's acting. But I am very very impressed by kang so ra acting in UGLY alert should get OSCAR award if there is fair system.

You can skip watch ugly alert all kang so ra scenes ( around 60 episode and you can stop. after that not much romance) because that is where you see something refreshing in that someone can make u live in romance by just watching her do her thing.


r/KDRAMA • • May 08 '19

Whatever happened to Kim Soohyun?

0 Upvotes

He was quite a popular Hallyu actor from 2011-2015 (esp during his My Love from the Stars/Moon Embracing the Sun days) but I haven't seen him in any dramas lately. The last drama he was in was The Producers in 2015 and then the most recent film he did was Real in 2017.


r/KDRAMA • • Jan 26 '20

Are there K-Dramas dubbed in englisch?

0 Upvotes

It gets a tiring sometimes to always read subtitles, so i wonder if there are some shows at least with dub instead of sub.