Posting from a burner account as I think I may get heckled for this.
I’ve been an F1 for almost a year now, I’ve been on this page for a similar amount of time. I work in a semi-rural 500ish bed DGH in the Midlands.
There is an obvious theme to the complaints in this sub, and they are all complaints that I can’t relate to at all.
Money wise, I save ~20% of my monthly wage and still live comfortably, I earn more than all but two of my friends from my Home Counties private school (all of whom did well at school and did sciences at Russell Group Unis). Although my investment banker/financial consultant friends earn around 20-40% more, they are literally slaves to their bosses, often have to cancel plans last minute etc whereas I can handover and fuck off home.
Training wise I don’t see how I could reasonably expect more opportunity, I was often invited to theatre by SpRs as I showed an interest in surgery, even during COVID where there was very limited theatre time. 80% of the consultants I’ve had are super keen to teach me stuff, sometimes annoyingly so when they spend 20mins talking about COPD management and I just want to do TTOs and go home, but they obviously care about their role in educating juniors. This is an attitude that simply doesn’t exist in other industries as far as I’m aware.
Apart from in ED, where ANPs/ENPs/ACPs/etc were exactly as portrayed in this sub (but our ED as a whole is a different kettle of fish), I have never had a problem with them. I have only ever found them to be helpful, and a useful baseline of consistency when all other juniors are pinged around the wards. I can’t think of an example of when they have encroached on training for juniors and seem to have well defined service provision roles. Granted, we don’t have them in our surgical depts so maybe I’ve not been exposed properly, but on my medical rotation i never had a problem with them.
Overall my opinion of this sub is that it must consist of people who have put medicine on a pedestal their whole lives, made the decision to forego fun at Uni to become a better doctor, and now realise that, just like every other profession in a big organisation, they are just a cog in a machine. Maybe you have all spent too long surrounded by doctors, have never done anything else and actually have no idea what working life is like in other industries, idk.
However unlike every other profession in a big organisation, we are effectively guaranteed a job for life in the top 10-20% of the countries earners. We have at least a proportion of bosses who genuinely care about our development. We have protected working time limits and a shared workload. We have a job that keeps us on our feet and constantly interacting with other people rather than staring at a screen in the corner of our bedroom. Most importantly for me, we play a role in a system that changes people’s lives for the better, and get to experience this every day. I have no evidence for this, but I reckon the rate of mid life existential crises amongst doctors is lower than other professions, as we spend our days doing tangibly Positive things.
I agree with the sentiment of the NHS being a broken system, and this is very frustrating and it definitely needs reform. I think a semi private system a la Canada or Germany is the way to go, but I think that’s a separate discussion.
As for all this “service provision” whinging. If you don’t want to do service provision, don’t sign up for a career in the National Health SERVICE...
Despite forming these vaguely positive opinions of being a doctor, I am consistently told how much better the other DGH in the area is by all the F2s and above. Which makes me refer back to the title - I don’t get it, what is so shit?
Is there a silent majority on this sub that agree with me?
Is this sub just an echo chamber of negative SHOs, and all the happy doctors have better things to do with their lives that sit on reddit?
Am I just too green and need a few more years of being a cog to open my eyes and take the red pill?
I’m open to my mind being changed, but atm my opinion is that we, as a collective, have the best job in the UK and all of your attitudes are poison to your own careers and morale amongst junior doctors who read your posts.
Fight me in the comments.