r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Aug 04 '22

Foundation New FY1s

19 Upvotes

I can’t take this anymore. Is it generational? Is it the way we live our lives on social media?

There is a whole host of new F1s postings on Twitter how their day was perfect or their day wasn’t perfect or - the worst - that they didn’t leave at 5. And other medics are telling them to exception report. They have completely unrealistic expectations not just about medicine but life it seems. It literally shows they have no idea how the world works and how out of touch we have become.

I needed to get this off my chest because it’s worrying.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Apr 21 '22

Pay & Conditions What about striking for more doctors rather than more pay?

22 Upvotes

By more doctors I mean more training posts and staffing budgets. Here's my reasons:

  1. More doctors would mean a chance to breathe in the working day, better job satisfaction from doing a better job, less irate patients & public to deal with (from delays in care), more opportunity to have coffee breaks with team members, more opportunity to learn/teach and actually take our contracted breaks.

  2. Easier sell to the general public, it's harder for politicians to spin this as 'greedy doctors' asking for a properly staffed service. Majority of the general public agree the NHS needs more staff in recent surveys.

  3. I don't think higher pay will actually change attrition rates, some people leave medicine because of money but I think not enjoying the job is a larger problem, evidenced by the number of people trying to go 80%. The people who come back from FY3s more commonly do it for personal reasons I think (ie location of friends and family), I doubt raising the salary will keep those people who can't tolerate the working conditions any longer.

  4. More doctors = working fewer nights, bank holidays and weekends potentially, which are not well renumerated under the current contract relative to baseline hours.

  5. Less moral injury at work/medical errors/tired doctors, obvs benefits those out there and us in here, but may long term save taxpayers/the NHS money with less litigation from errors, if doctors have more time to do invidiual jobs.

  6. Easier to gain buy in from consultants and juniors, who feel weird about striking. They can't deny the change in patient doctor ratios/ED attendances over time.

  7. From a political standpoint, if the gov are trying to gradually starve the NHS of cash, nothing raises attention to this louder than the people on the inside saying we need more staff, this is intolerable.

I would personally be in favour of striking for any reason that enhances healthcare workers conditions/pay etc but wonder if this would be a easier win in the meanwhile, any thoughts?


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Mar 23 '23

Career The recruitment pity party

5 Upvotes

I get that there are systematic issues with recruitment and certainly training, particularly around changing goalposts. However, I’m getting a bit fed up of other people, particularly IMGs,being scapegoated for this despite GMC surveys showing broadly the same proportion of home vs foreign grads getting into training as prior to RLMT. There are plenty of advantages to being a UK grad: you understand the system well, you excel at comms skills and traditionally do better at postgrad exams, plus things like audit/leadership/management are traditional domains IMGs struggle to score in.

I’m sorry but a sizeable proportion of people got assessed through the same criteria and made it into training. The whole atmosphere here reeks of bigotry or entitlement from people who frankly just weren’t good enough. It’s a competitive process… I’m sorry that someone interviews or prepared better than you.

Edit: to those who think IMGs have some sort of massive advantage, please read this. Proportion of UK grads getting training numbers I broadly the same or rising

https://www.reddit.com/r/JuniorDoctorsUK/comments/11sw3t0/taken_from_2022s_gmc_workforce_report_other_than/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=ioscss&utm_content=2&utm_term=1


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Jun 01 '23

Foundation Opinions: supporting the UKFPO changes

2 Upvotes

I support the UKFPO changes because I think that the culture in medicine needs a change.

I appreciate that this takes away from those who are in top deciles already but imo, there's more to being a successful doctor than simple regurgitation of facts/pattern recognition questions that make up 95% of med school exams. While it is important to build up a knowledge base, problem solving/critical thinking are a lot more important skills in life.

I see so many med students actually spreading false information to others about exams etc. Like why? People going out of their way to pull others down rather than improving themselves. I think removal of EPMs would be a net positive. Being able to work in a team and thinking about the collective rather than the individual. This rat race for portfolio points (EPMs by extension) is the root cause for cultural issues we see in the system. We are all here to learn and provide an overall better service, not to simply benefit our own portfolios.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Aug 08 '22

Clinical Apparently jobs are done for the benefit of seniors and not patients. Cluelessness.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Jan 10 '23

Career Do not increase medical school places

3 Upvotes

I'm not denying that there isn't a lack of doctors in the NHS, there is a huge gap in employment vs need but I increasing medical school will not necessary fix that.

The bottle neck gets tighter as you get more senior, the countless amounts of hard working people doing anything and everything to get a speciality job or consultant job. Increasing medical school will just exacerbate this problem.

Instead....why not increase training for Physicians Associates. Get more of them trained and get them on the ward. Let them help us do the Discharge Summaries, the bloods and cannulas. This will allow the JDs to train and learn why the standard jobs are done well by those who will stay on the wards and ensure continuity of care.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • May 15 '23

Serious Serious mental health struggles are not a stick to beat noctors with

4 Upvotes

Do any of the doctors on this subreddit claiming ADHD is an overmedicalised version of normal behaviour have any psychiatric training? As someone with ADHD it seems that a lot of people on this subreddit know more than psychiatrists. Interesting.

As someone with ADHD (privately diagnosed by a psychiatrist after multiple appointments and a collateral history) the response from some on here today is why I don't tell anybody.

You wouldn't say to a person with depression "oh well I get sad sometimes too" or "you don't need antidepressants you're overreacting".

So why is it ok to mock people with ADHD and say this is not a real disorder? ADHD ruins lives, it's not a case of just misplacing your keys sometimes. There is plenty of research about neurotransmitters and brain structural changes, this isn't a "fad" and the symptoms were first documented in the 18th century.

Remember that your peers who have sought a private diagnosis have thought long and hard about this before spending thousands of pounds for an assessment in desperation because NHS provision is woefully inadequate. It's not a "trendy" diagnosis it is life ruining and we deserve treatment for it the same was as someone with anxiety/depression/bipolar etc does.

Please have some compassion for each other, I doubt all of the negative disparaging comments have come from psychiatry trainees and most doctors have very limited training on mental health and some of the comments are woefully misinformed. I think if you spent a day inside my head you'd be very grateful for your neurotypical brain.

So to sum it up - please show empathy for your fellow doctors, if we can't be be kind to each other then what hope do we have? And next time you sit in the mess mocking people with ADHD as amphetamine seekers maybe look around you and think there could be someone sat next to you who is struggling.

So can we please not turn serious mental health struggles into a stick to beat noctors with.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Apr 07 '23

Career Reasons I will not be moving to US

5 Upvotes

While their salaries for doctors are VERY appealing, here’s my list of what’s keeping me from doing USMLE and trekking over there:

  1. School shootings

  2. Mall shootings

  3. 7-11/cinema/church shootings

  4. stray bullets; gang violence involving guns

  5. Overt & covert racism

  6. open carry states

  7. concealed carry states

  8. American cheese

  9. police carrying guns

  10. medical bills crippling the working class

  11. GM fruit & veg

Have I missed any out?

edit: thanks guys, lots to think about! I’ve come across many posts focussed on the positives and hardly any for some of the negatives and somewhat valid issues to consider

To those who’ve said, yes, I’ve never been and I’m sure it shows haha, nevertheless, gun control is my biggest reason and it’s social/societal impacts. While 9. is present elsewhere, adding on 5. 6. 7. , increases the likelihood of trigger happy officers


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Nov 05 '22

Specialty / Core Training I*Gs and Competition Ratios

2 Upvotes

Having seen the post about the recent competition ratios wanted to explore this subs thoughts on training itself getting harder with most specialities needing audits, QI, research, teaching, commitment to speciality in addition to the MSRA (Re new RADS portfolio criteria)

If an I*G can come from a completely different healthcare system never having worked in the UK and manage to demonstrate a better commitment to the speciality, carry out more research and audits (foreign grads usually aren't aware of these hoops while in med school) and pip a local grad then surely they deserve the job and the medical system here hasn't equipped its own grads to be competitive?

Re USA prioritising its own graduates - even IF it didn't the difference in quality of an application from a local grad vs an i*g is astronomical with local grads all having a previous 4y undergrad degree, most instances some research output, higher STEP scores, and sub-Is

Ya competition for spots is increasing and so getting a training number is harder but if having a head start of 5/6y plus a lifetime of living in the country (not even getting into how that helps) doesn't equip you to get a NTN then isn't the anger misdirected??

Not an i*g just curious


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Jul 08 '23

Pay & Conditions Why I’ll be voting for the Scottish Deal

121 Upvotes
  1. The headline figure of 12.4% is impressive. In a year when CPI is projected to be around 7-8%, this offer surpasses that by a significant margin, outperforming any other public sector worker deal in the UK. Even considering last year's CPI, this increase matches inflation, ensuring that our pay hasn't eroded over the past two years, which is more than can be said for any other public sector profession.

  2. The SG has committed to providing at least inflationary raises over the next three years, which is a major victory. While we all remember the 2016 deal in England that promised a minimum 2% increase annually, 1) we’re not dealing with the Tories, and 2) our union is stronger now. If we are dissatisfied with the SG's attempts to reverse pay erosion, we can ballot again.

3. We have seen a huge shift in Overton’s Window – Wales was the first country to acknowledge pay erosion, and Scotland is taking action. Just 18 months ago, pay erosion was scarcely mentioned, and those advocating for FPR were viewed as fringe or extreme. It is now however very firmly on the political and media agenda.

4. It helps our English colleagues. In order to come close to what we have been offered, England would need a pay uplift of nearly 20% this year. By showing what an acceptable offer looks like, without the need for the BMA leaders to back down from their 35% demand, it exposes how truly shocking the Westminster government's meagre 5% offer is and what can actually be achieved when two parties negotiate properly.

5. The SG appear to be negotiating in good faith. They have actively engaged with us, acknowledged the issue of pay erosion, and are making genuine efforts to address it. While I maintain some scepticism, it is encouraging to see their willingness to collaborate. As mentioned before, if future negotiations don't progress to our satisfaction, we have the option to strike

6. Humza Yousaf has been touting his ‘no strikes in Scotland’ for months - well before his campaign for FM started. I feel the threat of loosing that claim was just as strong, if not stronger, than IA itself. I honestly don’t think we would have got much more out of the SG without long and sustained IA.

This is a good deal. Not only does it put money in our pockets today, it lays out the path for FPR, gives us a mechanism to negotiate in the future, and still leaves us the option of calling a future ballot if we’re not happy. We’ve shown that Scottish doctors can no longer be stomped on, and our union and members are ready to fight if needs be.

There’s my two cents. I’ll await the downvotes.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Mar 06 '23

Career If you could go back and start over, what career would you choose and why

0 Upvotes

Considering the amount of dissatisfaction with medicine at the moment, If you could go back and start over, what career would you choose and why


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Jun 18 '21

Pay & Conditions I don’t get it

33 Upvotes

Posting from a burner account as I think I may get heckled for this.

I’ve been an F1 for almost a year now, I’ve been on this page for a similar amount of time. I work in a semi-rural 500ish bed DGH in the Midlands.

There is an obvious theme to the complaints in this sub, and they are all complaints that I can’t relate to at all.

Money wise, I save ~20% of my monthly wage and still live comfortably, I earn more than all but two of my friends from my Home Counties private school (all of whom did well at school and did sciences at Russell Group Unis). Although my investment banker/financial consultant friends earn around 20-40% more, they are literally slaves to their bosses, often have to cancel plans last minute etc whereas I can handover and fuck off home.

Training wise I don’t see how I could reasonably expect more opportunity, I was often invited to theatre by SpRs as I showed an interest in surgery, even during COVID where there was very limited theatre time. 80% of the consultants I’ve had are super keen to teach me stuff, sometimes annoyingly so when they spend 20mins talking about COPD management and I just want to do TTOs and go home, but they obviously care about their role in educating juniors. This is an attitude that simply doesn’t exist in other industries as far as I’m aware.

Apart from in ED, where ANPs/ENPs/ACPs/etc were exactly as portrayed in this sub (but our ED as a whole is a different kettle of fish), I have never had a problem with them. I have only ever found them to be helpful, and a useful baseline of consistency when all other juniors are pinged around the wards. I can’t think of an example of when they have encroached on training for juniors and seem to have well defined service provision roles. Granted, we don’t have them in our surgical depts so maybe I’ve not been exposed properly, but on my medical rotation i never had a problem with them.

Overall my opinion of this sub is that it must consist of people who have put medicine on a pedestal their whole lives, made the decision to forego fun at Uni to become a better doctor, and now realise that, just like every other profession in a big organisation, they are just a cog in a machine. Maybe you have all spent too long surrounded by doctors, have never done anything else and actually have no idea what working life is like in other industries, idk.

However unlike every other profession in a big organisation, we are effectively guaranteed a job for life in the top 10-20% of the countries earners. We have at least a proportion of bosses who genuinely care about our development. We have protected working time limits and a shared workload. We have a job that keeps us on our feet and constantly interacting with other people rather than staring at a screen in the corner of our bedroom. Most importantly for me, we play a role in a system that changes people’s lives for the better, and get to experience this every day. I have no evidence for this, but I reckon the rate of mid life existential crises amongst doctors is lower than other professions, as we spend our days doing tangibly Positive things.

I agree with the sentiment of the NHS being a broken system, and this is very frustrating and it definitely needs reform. I think a semi private system a la Canada or Germany is the way to go, but I think that’s a separate discussion.

As for all this “service provision” whinging. If you don’t want to do service provision, don’t sign up for a career in the National Health SERVICE...

Despite forming these vaguely positive opinions of being a doctor, I am consistently told how much better the other DGH in the area is by all the F2s and above. Which makes me refer back to the title - I don’t get it, what is so shit?

Is there a silent majority on this sub that agree with me?

Is this sub just an echo chamber of negative SHOs, and all the happy doctors have better things to do with their lives that sit on reddit?

Am I just too green and need a few more years of being a cog to open my eyes and take the red pill?

I’m open to my mind being changed, but atm my opinion is that we, as a collective, have the best job in the UK and all of your attitudes are poison to your own careers and morale amongst junior doctors who read your posts.

Fight me in the comments.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Jul 15 '23

Career The attitude of people on this sub is going to be the reason we don't get FPR

0 Upvotes

Before anyone shouts me down as being an infiltrator and derailer, I am starting FY1 in a few weeks so I am as entitled to my opinion on these matters as you and I also fully support FPR in principle.

I'm also not saying it is everyone on this sub as I have seen some very kind and rational people on here, nor that what I'm going to say is limited to this sub as I assume those bullying on here are doing the same in real life but this sub is the easiest place to post as it is largely viewed as the coordination hub so industrial action. Last disclamer, I know we're migrating to the doctorsUK sub soon but given I assume most of the same people will switch over I guess the problem shall remain.

I truly do appreciate what this sub has done for the FPR movement but more recently the attitude of people here has become, quite frankly, vile and is starting to turn your allies (other doctors) against the movement.

I get you're angry, and rightly so, and that directing your anger towards those responsible (the government) has done nothing but now turning that hatred on your own people is going to tear the movement apart. You need doctors to support you if you want to succeed but at the moment all you're doing is turning those who are on the fence or mildly in support against you and pushing those already opposed further away.

The top things that have stood out to me about this sub are:

  1. Openly bullying or encouraging it of those who disagree or who can't comply (those in the military, who financially can't afford to strike or IMGs etc). As soon as someone even suggests they might not be able to strike or are opposed to it, or for that matter suggests we could ask for anything less than FPR this year you get people piling on shouting 'Scab' and telling them they're worse than Satan himself. Then you have those on here who are actively telling users to pressure others into striking and to ostracise and insult them if they don't. That's not exactly good to winning them over.

  2. Then there is a complete unwillingness to acknowledge there are different viewpoints to yours. Some people can't save funds to allow striking due to family etc (I know you go on about having had plenty of time to plan but the financially situation for some means they just can't, and yes there is the argument that they need FPR the most but if they're in danger of losing their house before that happens then clearly they have to work) or feel that FPR doesn't have to come in one go (like a lot of Scottish doctors with the offer they have received with then the option to strike later) then you simply start screaming that they're scabs again or call them infiltrators and derailers rather than engaging to explain your side and find out if there's any merits to theirs or if you can help out (how about offering to financially help those who can't strike due to funds?) or find a middle ground.

  3. Linked to this unwillingness to accept different points of view, you instantly accuse anyone whose point of view even slightly differs from yours as not being a doctor and of being a journalist infiltrator and trying to derail the movement then demand they answer questions to prove they're a doctor. I get where you're coming from but the fact it's only ever asked when someone disagrees with you means it's just being used to silence discussion as nlt everyone likes being attacked when they speak up.

  4. Hypocrisy- A lot of you, rightly, complain about untrained people giving bad interviews which could hurt the movement but seem to forget, this is a public sub where you are spewing bile and hatred for all to see. You're not exactly setting a good example for the movement when you're showing yourself to be petty and abusive and, to be honest, no better than the government. This sub no longer has the moral high ground. You talk about how we need to be united but at the same time are actively pushing away anyone who isn't a diehard radical and you complain about the government's refusal to negotiate but then refuse to engage with anyone who believes even slightly differently to you.

I can clearly only speak for myself (though I know a few other final year med students and Scottish FYs feel the same) but this sub has started to make me feel unwelcomed (which makes it harder to keep track of what's going on as this is the best place to get news but I no longer wish to frequent it as it's a miserable place to be) but is also turning me against the movement as, for better or worse, this sub has become the face of the FPR movement and I don't wish to be associated and involved with such horrible people or to be attacked for not holding exactly the same beliefs. If you carry on they way you are going soon lose the support of the majority so I would ask you all to think before you speak or type whether what you're about to say is constructive or destructive and maybe don't voice it if it is the latter.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • May 29 '23

Pay & Conditions What makes you think that further strikes will lead to FPR?

13 Upvotes

Genuine question.

In your opinion, what so far, has convinced you that further strikes of whatever format (3 days/month, OOH pullout) will lead us to FPR? Considering that 7 days of “hugely disruptive” strikes and a month of negotiation has resulted in an offer of 5%.

Why will things eventually workout? Is there a critical waiting list threshold? Election pressure?


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Mar 24 '23

Serious Why do we want consultant support?

0 Upvotes

Serious question.

Why are we gushing over consultant support? In reality consultant support is them taking BMA rates and getting a load of time off in lieu- it’s not like they are making a noble sacrifice to support our movement. Or is it? I don’t know!?!?

Furthermore if consultants refuse to cover us (are they even allowed to do this?) surely that means our strike action is even more effective and the government much more likely to fold as there will be essentially no healthcare service for that period of time?

Can someone explain please?

Tldr: is consultant support good for us? Or are they essentially scabbing?

🦀🦀🦀


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Nov 16 '21

Specialty / Core Training Feeling very apprehensive for the future of UK Medicine

3 Upvotes

It feels like F1/2/3, CT1/2, ST3-8 aim to achieve what Americans achieve in 5 years. The quality of doctors across the pond is also unquestionably higher, to the point where I would refer to myself as a nurse if talking to American colleagues since the UK/US divide is so large.

The NHS and Royal Colleges deliberately graduate doctors without the purpose of them specialising. This makes sense - the NHS needs fodder to complete TTOs and pad out ED waiting times as opposed to producing world leading consultants.

I have an issue with the abuse of trainees as rota fodder instead of doctors who are there to learn. We produce worse doctors, over a longer period of time, with much lower pay. The pay scale of trainees is designed around “training” but the notion of such is laughable within the NHS. In the American system, you are worked like an absolute dog throughout residency, but there will be training, because your centre wants to produce great attendings. And the reward on the other side is unfathomable compared to the UK.

Over here, the lifestyle is chiller as a registrar, but it’s drawn out in terms of time, there’s very little priority given to training, and being a consultant seems underwhelming?

Personally, I like the idea that the NHS will give you a lot of money for doing very little (if you play your cards right), so I will stick to this country.

But what is the point of putting in all of this effort for portfolio points etc when you will lose the best years of your life being rota fodder and then end up on less than a GP?

If medicine was a side hustle then I could afford to pursue my interests, but at this moment I’ve pretty much consigned medicine to “just a job” and I’ll try to focus on 1) independence from admin and control of my life and 2) money.

It’s a shame that the NHS is largely incompatible with the notion that you can be very good at something to get ahead, but it is what it is.

This post is aimed at the current training requirements, which is very different to what Senior consultants went through


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Mar 26 '22

Quick Question Why is r/JuniorDoctorsUK so insufferable?

15 Upvotes

As above


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Dec 17 '22

Serious Should we really be surprised by HCAs and PAs taking over our responsibilities?

2 Upvotes

Okay. Hear me out first before you rip me to shreds.

The scope of medicine has increased tremendously in the last 20 to 30 years. The times of doctors treating every CAP with one of the two antibiotics and every stroke with physio and discharge to geriatrics are long gone. Every other profession in the world is moving towards highly specialized workers. You wouldn't expect an IT professional who handles web developement to be able to troubleshoot what a computer systems analyst would do.

Medicine has become so vast but we are still training as if it is the 2000s. You take a good 5 years to study for your basic degree. Then you spend two years learning to do the basics of patient management. Then, if you are lucky you get into training. You spend three more years getting a bit more experience. Fast forward 4 more years and now you are believed to be competent in a field. Now the problem is that specific field has become so vast that you still don't know all the intricacies of complex presentations and most of the subspecialties. So, once again, if you are lucky, you get to be a subspecialist in two or so years.

That is at least 16 years of training to be able to become a super-specialist. We are afraid that consultants and the hospital management prefer HCAs and PAs when that is what makes the most sense. They are specializing in just one department and one thing. They will get more and more experience while doctors keep rotating to wards that have nothing to do with them. I do not want to imply that what is happening at this point is right, but with a few tweaks and clear boundaries on responsibilities, HCAs and PAs are the future. If doctors are to stay relevant, they have to change the training pathways to be more specialized.

I would like your opinions on this matter as well, although, I don't think mine would be a very popular one.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Jul 14 '23

Serious Why is the BMA getting involved in non- healthcare related politics?

4 Upvotes

The JDC chairs sent an email update today correctly disputing the so-called ”independence“ of the DDRB & other pay review bodies, quoting a back bench Tory MP who said “we basically rig those anyway”.

Then the next section in the email states “it is unacceptable to increase taxes on migrant health workers to fund inadequate pay offer”.

I have two problems with this:

  1. migrant health workers do not actually end up paying the NHS health surcharge, they are able to claim a 100% reimbursement every 6 months provided they are still working in a health or social care role (https://www.gov.uk/government/news/health-and-care-staff-can-claim-immigration-health-surcharge-reimbursement)

  2. migrant workers outside health & social care may have to pay increased tax… but why is the BMA taking up a position on Government taxation or fiscal policy? Some BMA members may be pro-Tory, others anti-Tory. It isn’t for the BMA to tell the government how to run the economy. That is a job for political parties. Where they get the taxes from to fund healthcare service is completely outside the scope of the BMA as a doctor union.

TL;DR: it isn’t the BMAs job to tell the government to reduce taxes (unless specifically pertaining to taxes affecting doctors). That is the job of political parties & economists. The BMAs job is to be pro-doctor, nothing more than that.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Mar 09 '23

Pay & Conditions How do we professionally and respectfully hold scabs to account?

1 Upvotes

Obviously we need to remain professional with our colleagues who choose to work during the strikes. We don't know the circumstances that have led to them making their decision.

But we should be able to let them know we aren't happy with their decision.

Where does JDUK popular opinion think the line is between applying social pressure and bullying?


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Feb 28 '23

Pay & Conditions Politicians are united in envy against doctors, What if they call a General Election?

0 Upvotes

I wondered what the BMA/DV response would be if the politicians get together and call a snap general election. The current government has no interest in solving any of Britain's pressing issues, but rather want to grandstand on the global stage. Individual blowhard MPs of all parties are using external events as self-aggrandizing theatre, while the health service collapses, people can't afford their energy bills, and the shelves are empty.

The new updated Northern Ireland/Brexit deal has been brought here by unelected president Ursula, is being rammed through Parliament, and may set the stage for the out of steam Conservatives to claim the "completion" of Brexit and demand an election.

Due to what I firmly believe is a visceral envy of doctors' intelligence and respected position in society, most politicians hate doctors, and the best solution to nip our collective action on pay restoration in the bud would be to call an election (obviously this isn't the only reason). The Conservatives and Labour can use an election campaign to try and get doctors to postpone strike action with the faint promise of "negotiations with the new government", thereby destroying our momentum, demoralizing doctors, and causing huge difficulties with reorganizing new dates which could be several months into the future, further confusing the doctor population and reducing participation and engagement.

Furthermore, any new government or hung parliament could actually push through anti-strike legislation banning doctors from striking, as is already the case for police/army/prison officers.

So my plea to the BMA: if there is a general election called for 4-6 weeks' from now, DO NOT KNEE-JERK and stop the strikes.

Thank you.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Mar 16 '22

Career I for one, love and appreciate PAs and ANPs...

0 Upvotes

Hear me out first:
I have never had a bad interaction with any PA or ANP. Infact, they were always the most helpful bunch I have worked with. "Can you show me please how to do (put in any referral, ordering a test, etc...)?" "Of course Dr 7omos_Shawarma" - then proceeds to go over Steps A-to-Z with jokes in between. This, is unlike many of the so-called medics, who would rather see you fail or "I don't have time now" or whatever, that I dealt with (not all of them of course). How many unpleasant interactions have you had with consultants, registrars, and core-trainees have you had? I had plenty, and none with any ANPs or PAs. That is not to say that I didn't hear horror stories, I did, but there are plenty more medics that are worse than them.
Everyone is getting annoyed at how much they are getting paid/taking their jobs/FY1 not finding any placements because of them (or IMGs for that matter) - well guess what, they deserve their salaries, because just by working in the NHS, it is already difficult. Do I think we as medics (Fy1 to CT3) deserve to get paid less? Absolutely NOT. But who's fault is it? is it the ANPs or PAs? absolutely NOT. Are they taking your jobs? again, absolutely NOT. Why? because ANPs and PAs are permanent at their place, they don't need training in different placements for god knows how many years, and whenever there is a problem they cannot handle, they seek a consultant's advice. How many medics are willing to not get a place in a "fancy" place like London and work in an ED (or any department for that matter) in a deprived area (unless you are forced to)? not much, which is where ANPs come and fill the gap. Their salaries, their job offers, their training opportunities aren't their fault, and if I was an ANP or PA, I would want these conditions to work, which brings me to my last point.
Is it their fault? Absolutely NOT! It never was and never will be. It is the HEE's fault and all the brass up there sitting there and laughing at all of this. "Divide and Conquer" - anyone heard of that before? creating division between medics and other professionals is the way to go, and it is exactly what the government is trying to achieve. The government isn't our friend. It never was and never will be. In fact, ever since the new contract came into effect, we had a BIG BULLSEYE target sign on our backs. Do you think the government likes how we forced them to sign us into better conditions? Do you think they will ever let this go? No. In fact, they are slowly but surely making our lives worse by the day as pay back. They see us as a threat rather than anything else, simply because we forced their hands into better working conditions/hours. Soon enough, we may be back at the same point we were before and maybe worse.

I don't blame ANPs or PAs for any of this, but I do think our overlords are trying to create more division between healthcare staff, pushing in more ANPs and PAs instead of junior doctors for financial reasons, while trying to save as much money as possible to use on other things.

This was more of a rant than anything.


r/JuniorDoctorsUK • • Jun 18 '23

Just for Fun! “This isn’t meant to be patronising”

Post image
8 Upvotes