r/JoyDivision • u/Beneficial_Track_939 • Feb 11 '26
r/JoyDivision • u/[deleted] • Dec 23 '22
Ian Curtis’ death
Watching New Order’s 1993 documentary (New Order Story), I’ve realized that the band didn’t care that much for his death… Neither the staff members.
Peter Hook makes a joke saying he’s the laziest member of the group because he “haven’t seen him doing much for years” on a public TV show!
The manager also says that they didn’t realize how he was feeling because “everybody was having a good time at that time and even Ian!” And then he says “oh maybe Ian wasn’t” and then laughed about it…
I feel like it’s very disrespectful to talk about someone who is dead like that. What are your thoughts?
Here is the video: New Order Story
r/JoyDivision • u/Doosdoosje • Jun 05 '25
Ah yes Stephen Morris was the only member of Joy Division? Huh what is this picture
r/JoyDivision • u/goggleblock • Sep 26 '24
Peter Hook and The Light Seattle Honest Review
1. I’m drunk
2. I was pretty drunk during the show
3. I got home safely – thank you Seattle Public Transportation
I can’t begin to tell you what an absolute privilege it was to see Peter Hook live, a mere 12 feet from my own drunk face,
I’ve been a New Order fan since 1987 when I heard ‘True Faith’ on my local alternative music radio station. In 1987, I was a lonely teenager, and I needed something to distinguish myself from the other teenage kids in my high school class. I chose “90s alternative” music, and I flipped on my local college radio station, KNHC – C89FM, and the first song I heard was True Faith by New order. I didn’t hate it, so I committed to it – I made it my teenager identity. From that point going forward, I was an alt-music teenager, and my cornerstone band was New Order. New Order was largely unknow in my area, and their style of music was not very popular among my peers. Nonetheless, I had committed to the songs and to the band for the sake of my unique identity among my peers, and I was a New Order fan, ride or die.
I bummed rides from my best friend who had a driver's license and a car. He had a 1968 Ford Mustang, and I paid him (maybe… probably not) to drive me to a nearby electronics store where I purchased my first CD player. My friend also drove me to a nearby record store that specialized in what was at the time obscure and alternative music. The first compact disc I purchased was New Order – Substance – a double CD set that I still own 38 years later. I made my friend drive me to that record store many more times so I could purchase bootlegs and import CDs from New Order and other alternative bands that I loved, including Joy Division, Nine Inch Nails, Nirvana, The Cure, Depeche Mode, David Bowie, and many more.
The point is (I’m drunk… remember… ) New Order (and Joy Division) was an integral part of my teenage development and identity as a young adult.
Fast forward to 2023 – I finally got to see New Order (and The Pet Shop Boys) for the first time in my life. I had not been able to purchase tickets to see New Order the couple of times thy visited my city since 1987 due to financial challenges. But when New Order announced they were playing Seattle, my wife bought tickets for me. Seeing New Order live for the first time in my life, even though it was an incomplete lineup, literally brought tears to my eyes.
A few months later, Peter Hook and The Light announced that they were coming to my area. I purchased tickets without delay.
My enthusiasm about New Order and Joy Division was based largely in the rhythms and melodies and synthesizers and dance tracks. It wasn’t until late in my life that I discovered the individual member’s contributions – in particular Peter Hook’s unique bass-as-lead guitar work. Going back through New Order and Joy Division’s catalog of music, I discovered Peter Hook’s unique contribution as a bass player and I grew to appreciate his massive contribution to not only New Order and Joy Division’s sound, but to the era’s music in general. Make no mistake, Peter Hook had defined a generation with his bass melodies and distinct style. The track that stood out for me, both as a centerpiece for my love for New Order and as an exhibit for Peter Hook’s exceptional bass stylings was 1985’s The Perfect Kiss from Low-Life. The 9-minute extended mix is bure bliss. It’ll be played at my funeral – period.
When I bought tickets to see Peter Hook and his backing band The Light, I expected him to rock those four thick strings like he did back in the 1980s. But upon seeing him last night, I was kinda disappointed. Here’s why:
1. 90% of the bass was played by Jack Bates, the bass player for The Light, and not by Peter Hook. Don’t get me wrong, Bates played Peter Hook’s iconic bass lines in a manner that was indistinguishable from Peter Hook himself, but I didn’t pay to see a New Order/Joy Division cover band… I paid to see Peter Hook. It was disappointing to see NOT Peter Hook play 90% of his iconic bass riffs. Hooky wore a bass guitar around his neck for the entire show, but only played his iconic riffs a small percentage of the time. His bass guitar was a costume.
2. 50% OF THE New Order tracks were played by sequencers, drum machines, and recorded tracks. OK – we can probably thank Bernard Sumner for this, but for a large part of the New Order segment of Peter Hook’s show, the band sat idle while a backing track played the music. Snore. Not Peter Hook’s fault… Not The Light’s fault, but it was weird to see a drummer and guitarist do NOTHING for 2 or 3 songs in a row.
3. As “unimpressive” as Bernard Sumner’s singing is, Peter Hook wasn’t much better. The singing was obviously intentionally buried in the mix for ALL of the New Order and Joy Division songs. New Order’s lyrics are, to be fair, crap… but they’re still fun to sing along with. Joy Division’s lyrics are depressing and morose, but they’re cathartic to sing along with. Peter Hook and The Light buried the vocals so deep in the mix that only the most devout fans knew and could sing along with the lyrics. The rest of the audience was resigned to mumble along with the melody.
4. The recreation of the songs was accurate and fair. Peter Hook and The Light recreated both New Order and Joy Division songs accurately in their sound, timbre, tone, pace, and feel. It’s as if Peter Hook had the original sequencer tracks to every synth-driven New Order hit and raw punk engineering sound mix for every bass-driven Joy Division track. PHaTL added nothing at all to the original tracks.
5. Paul Kehoe, the drummer, was AMAZING!!! When he was actually drumming (and not sitting around waiting to augment the pre-recorded drum track), he was able to replicate Stephen Morriss’s frenetic and tight drumming on all the New Order and Joy Division tracks.
6. David Potts was a great guitarist and singer for the New Order tracks that Peter Hook was unable to sing.
…This is where I’m going to piss some people of…
As iconic as Peter Hook’s bass playing is on both New Order and Joy Division tracks, it was apparent after watching tonight’s show that the real kinetic energy in NO and JD came from Barney’s guitar work – especially in the Joy Division tracks. To be honest, I have always underestimated Barney as a guitarist – giving most of the credit for Joy Division’s sound to Ian, Stephen, Hooky, and Martin Hannett. But seeing the Joy Division songs played live, I could see that most of the musical dynamics of their music came from Barney’s guitar work (recreated faithfully by David Potts). In the original Joy Division lineup, Hooky’s bass was solid… SM’s drums were tight, MH’s engineering was revolutionary, Ian’s vocals and lyrics were heart-wrenching, but Barney’s guitar was the subtle engine that moved the music up, down, left right, and into your heart. I never realized… after 40 years… that Barnard Sumner was the secret sauce that made Joy Division… and New Order, magical. And, based on what I saw tonight, Peter Hook and The Light knows (but fails to acknowledge for political reasons) Bernard Albrecht’s/Sumner’s/Dicken’s impact on Joy Division’s and New Order’s music. Sumner’s guitar was understated and underrepresented, and the show suffered as a result.
Peter Hook is NOT New Order and is NOT Joy Division. Peter Hook added a unique bass-as-lead guitar sound that influenced a decade of British dance and pop music, but he was only one part of the band and the music Peter Hook and The Light played painfully lacked Barney, Stephen, Gillian, and of course Ian. The show was impressive as a New Order/Joy Division cover band, but it was obvious from beginning to end that PHaTL a very good cover band but only part of the whole.
r/JoyDivision • u/Beneficial-Meet1617 • Aug 11 '23
bootleg t-shirt that makes me feel strange Spoiler
I've found it on a blog-like website few years ago and it's dated back to 2009. Anyone knows story behind... this?
r/JoyDivision • u/JakeNyg25 • Oct 25 '20
am i the only joy division that doesn't love disorder?
it's a good song, but not one of my favorite joy division songs like most joy division fans say
r/JoyDivision • u/FearlessInvite1461 • Aug 09 '24
How was ian so skinny
Just curious like did he have an eating disorder or anything on top of his other problems
r/JoyDivision • u/IotaVega316 • Nov 05 '19
Big fan of Joy division so i decided to make a mine craft parody lyrics of Love will tear us apart please rate my lyrics fellas
When your dogs bite hard
And your food bar is low
And skeletons ride high
But your torches won't glow
And were fighting the blaze
Taking different potions
Mines, Mines will Tear us Apart again
Mines. Mines will Tear us Apart again (thinking of replacing this with wither poison or something relating to killing you in mine craft y'all be the judge)
Why is the generator so cold
turned away from your pride
is my diamond sword that flawed
Our wheat farm runs so dry
Yet there's still this bonemeal
that we kept from our thrives
Mines, Mines will Tear us Apart again
Mines, Mines will Tear us Apart again
Do you cry out for your steve
all my redstone exposed
gets me being a souse
As our leads take hold
and it's something so golden
just can't be triumphant no more
Mines, Mines will Tear us Apart again
Mines, Mines will Tear us Apart again
Mines, Mines will Tear us Apart again
Mines, Mines will Tear us Apart again
any changes or critiques would be much appreciated
r/JoyDivision • u/numsens • Oct 05 '21
Honestly the only reason why Morrissey prolly hates joy division is cus ians of haircut
r/JoyDivision • u/Opening-Low-6832 • May 30 '23
Tattoo I had done today half zombie Ian and unknown pleasures tattoo from a couple years back that I had done
r/JoyDivision • u/[deleted] • Feb 06 '20
What is JoyDivision and why did it show up in my recommended?
r/JoyDivision • u/[deleted] • Jul 06 '23
Anyone wish that "Control" had the actor Cillian Murphy?
For context, he was supposed to play Ian. He looks like Ian, and probably would have done a great job as much as Sam Riley.
r/JoyDivision • u/Fred_Stickley • Apr 22 '26
Confederate Flag on Bernard Sumner's guitar
r/JoyDivision • u/Remote_Database7688 • May 11 '26
Is goth music just hacks ripping off Ian and the band?
Basically the title. I’ve listened to quite a bit of goth music from the original era and with very few exceptions it all just sounds like either straight ripping off of Joy Division or using elements so associated with them that it’s basically pastiche.
Edit: A lot of you seem to respect goth acts as being up there with the originals, but you also seem to know more about the timeline of punk/post punk than I do. I retract my statement.
r/JoyDivision • u/Drumchapel • Oct 01 '24
Division Order on twitter/X is having an argument with JK Rowling
Any reason a JD/NO fan would argue with her? Anyone know this band?
r/JoyDivision • u/Wanda_W1tch • Oct 04 '23
What is a Joy Division that you hate/don’t like?
Ok don’t come for me…but decades 😭
r/JoyDivision • u/Papazotian • Oct 31 '17
Love Will Tear Us Apart – Joy Division (Papazó cover)
r/JoyDivision • u/5ave_Ferris • Aug 13 '26
lots of love for joy division on this new community for human music curation
hello JD disciples... thought I'd show you all a cool thing which is that on my friend's new project Corus (a new social network for music lovers), some joy division tracks have been trending! The community is off to a great start - 34 ppl have already shared one of her tracks (maybe some of you are here?). We'd love for you all to join and share your favorite songs and hopefully find something new in the process. anyway - hope y'all are as excited as i am for their live recordings collection ✌️
r/JoyDivision • u/Dunjn_gio • Jan 25 '23
What’s the most skippable Joy Division song?
r/JoyDivision • u/C0baltBlu3 • May 23 '23
A clue to Ian's death?
Doing my usual rounds in trying to solve the mystery that is the lyrics of "In A Lonely Place" actually were, I came across a 1950 movie of the same name. Nothing was out of the ordinary until I looked at the release date. Given that his body was found on the morning of May 18th, it is likely that he officially hung himself on the night of May 17th, this film's 20th anniversary. Could these events be linked? Look at the film's synopsis, it involves a man getting romantically involved with another woman, just like Ian. Coincidence?