r/JonBenetRamsey • • Apr 02 '24

Images A rare photo of JonBenét with Patsy when she had stage 4 ovarian cancer

Post image
4.6k Upvotes

r/JonBenetRamsey • • Aug 10 '21 Bless Up Popcorn Bravo Take My Silver

Theories Why ‘Burke Did It All’ Scenario Makes A Lot of Sense: Part 1

2.0k Upvotes

I believe that BDIA (Burke Did It All) theory as outlined by Chief Investigator Kolar makes most sense in JonBenet’s case. In this post, I’m going to explain why. I’ll try to cover every piece of evidence that makes me think BDI: some of my points will be factual, others will be purely subjective. So, for the most part, this is just my view on things.

  1. Circumstantial evidence and speculations

a) Pineapple: Burke’s fingerprints are connected to the last action of JonBenet that we know of

On the table in the breakfast room, investigators found a bowl with unfinished pineapple and milk as well as an empty glass with a tea bag. During the autopsy, the pineapple was also found in JonBenet’s stomach. According to Thomas, it was “consistent down to the rind with what had been found in the bowl”. The bowl itself “bore the fingerprints of Patsy and Burke.” In turn, “latent fingerprints on the drinking glass on the dining room table … belonged to Burke” (Kolar).

According to Schiller, "Based on the condition of the pineapple in her intestine, the experts estimated that JonBenet had eaten it an hour and a half or two hours before she died." So, she ate it shortly before being hit in the head, considering that she lived for 45-120 minutes after that. It could happen right away or a bit later. As a side fact, a medical imaging technologist conducted an experiment and concluded that she was hit within 30-minute timeframe. The original post is gone now, but you can find the details about the experiment copied here.

There are two likeliest scenarios here based on available evidence: either Patsy served a snack of pineapple and tea to Burke after they came home from the Whites or Burke made it himself, and Patsy’s prints on the bowl are explained by the fact that she handled the dishes earlier (their housekeeper was not there). I believe in the latter version of events for a simple reason: the way this snack is prepared screams of a child, not an adult to me. There is a big amount of pineapple inside: it’s highly unlikely that whoever was eating it would finish it. There is just too much of it. A huge inappropriate spoon was chosen. Kids don’t care about such things and they often overestimate how much they’ll be able to eat.

Patsy says this much in her interview: “Somebody else did this, because I would never put a spoon that big in a bowl like that … I would think I would put two or three pieces on their plate with the rest of their food or something, because, I mean, it looks weird to set out a bowl like that.” She is a liar, but in this case, I believe her because the meal does look childish to me.

So, it is likely that Burke and JonBenet were eating pineapple together shortly before JonBenet was attacked. But apart from this theory, we also have Burke’s testimony where he indeed places himself in the vicinity of the attack. In his Dr. Phil interview, he says: “I had some toy that I wanted to put together. I remember being downstairs after everyone was kinda in bed and wanting to get this thing out.” Due to the location of his room and the fact that it was nighttime, it would be easy for Burke to hear where everyone was. So he went downstairs after everyone was in bed, and it’s very possible that this was the moment when he decided to eat pineapple, too. It was his favorite fruit. His admission just reinforces the idea that he was downstairs when he wasn’t supposed to, and the pineapple links him and JonBenet together shortly before the blow to her head.

b) Chronic sexual abuse of JonBenet

It was proven that JonBenet had a prior hymenal injury that indicates previous/ongoing sexual abuse: it was thought to be digital. She was also assaulted with a paintbrush very shortly before her death. Since no sperm was found and penile penetration wasn’t confirmed, we cannot determine the age or even the gender of the attacker. However, obviously, it had to be someone with access to JonBenet. And I think Burke fits this profile not just because he was a member of that household, but also because he and JonBenet were known to often sleep in one room.

From Bonita papers: “[After bedwetting,] JonBenet would usually get up and change her own clothes. Sometimes she would go into her brother’s bedroom and crawl into the extra bed to avoid going back to her own cold, wet one.”

From Burke’s interview:

BR: “I would sometimes sleep on - I forget which bed. But I would sometimes sleep in there ‘cause mine got cold.

DS: “Cause your room got cold. So whose bed was this?”

BR: “Um, JonBenet.”

Furthermore, while we have no way of confirming it, there was an account that likely came from the housekeeper about Burke and JonBenet playing “doctor” together. Here’s a detailed one: “I walked in on them two or three times when they were clearly playing some game like doctor. They were in Burke’s bedroom and had made a “fort” of the sheets from his bed. They were under the sheets and Burke was really embarrassed when I asked what was going on. He was red in the face and yelled at me to get out. It happened about three times in the months leading up to the Christmas when JonBenet died.” Coincidentally, this was around the time when her bedwetting issues reemerged. Also, take a look at Specifics of assault thread, it has more playing doctor accounts.

Also, from Bonita papers: “Dr. Bernhard felt there needed to be more follow-up with Burke in the discussion of sexual contact. The only show of emotion by Burke, other than the irritation with the questions about the actual crime, was when Dr. Bernhard began to ask about uncomfortable touching. Burke picked up a board game and put it on his head an action indicating anxiety or discomfort with these types of questions and that there was more that he was not telling her.”

Here are some statistics on sexual abuse among children from Kolar's book: "The statistics for forcible rape were even more discouraging. Sixty-one (61) boys under the age of ten had been arrested for this offense in 1996. An additional three-hundred and thirty-five (335) boys had been arrested who were aged 10 to 12 years."

Sibling molestation is more common than molestation by an adult family member and it's the most underreported type of sexual abuse.

Data from a recent US Department of Health and Human Services Child Maltreatment Report (2014) states that at least 2.3% of children were sexually victimized by a sibling. By comparison, during this same period 0.12% were sexually abused by an adult family member. [Sibling sexual abuse] may also be the longest-lasting type of intrafamilial sexual abuse and the type of abuse most likely to remain undisclosed in families and unreported to authorities." Link to research where this is mentioned.

More:

"As many as 40% of children who are sexually abused are abused by older, or more powerful children. The younger the child victim, the more likely it is that the perpetrator is a juvenile. Juveniles are the offenders in 43% of assaults on children under age six. Of these offenders, 14% are under age 12." Link.

Note: this report includes studying sexual abuse committed by other children, adult family members, strangers, and people who the family trusts. Of them, 40% of cases are done by kids.

From older and more specific sources:

"In-depth research indicates that brother-sister incest occurs most often, as much as five times as often as father-daughter incest (Nakashima and Zakus, 1977).

c) Location

JonBenet was found in the basement. The basement, with its Train Room, was viewed as Burke’s domain. He played there a lot, alone and with his friends.

d) Scatolia

Many people heard about Burke’s smearing his feces on JonBenet’s things, but there are a lot of misconceptions here. This is what actually took place:

The Ramseys’ previous housekeeper, Geraldine Vodicka, reported that Burke smeared feces on a bathroom wall. We don’t know which bathroom it was; it happened 3 years before the murder.

LHP reported finding grapefruit-sized fecal matter in JonBenet’s bed.

Kolar about the crime scene: "CSIs had written about finding a pair of pajama bottoms in JonBenet’s bedroom that contained fecal material. They were too big for her and were thought to belong to Burke. Additionally, a box of candy located in her bedroom had also been observed to be smeared with feces."

We don’t know who actually did this. However, personally, I find it hard to believe that JonBenet would reach out for her candy box with her fingers stained in feces. Burke did have one reported incident of smearing, so it’s logical to assume that he indeed was the one to smear JonBenet’s candy box. He could use pajama bottoms to do that. This would speak of his negative feelings to her on that specific night.

2) The crime

Whenever I consider what happened to JonBenet, I see an illogical, chaotic crime that no sane adult would commit. Let’s review it in the chronological order. I’ll cite Spitz, the forensic pathologist involved in this case:

This first injury sustained by JonBenét was believed to have been the constriction marks on the sides and front of her throat. … [H]er assailant had grabbed her shirt from the front and twisted the collar in their fist. The cloth from the edge of the collar had created the discolored, striated bruising and abrasions on the sides of her neck, and the knuckles of the perpetrator had caused the triangular shaped bruise located on the front side of her throat.

(You can see an experiment with the size of this abrasion here. Imo, it supports the idea of BDI.)

Then:

JonBenét reached up to her neck with her hands to attempt to pull away the collar causing some nail gouges / abrasions with her fingernails on the side of her throat. Released from the grasp of the perpetrator, JonBenét turned and was struck in the upper right side of her head with a blunt object … The blow would have rendered JonBenét unconscious and accounted for the absence of any additional defensive wounds on her body. Inflicted perimortem with her death, was the insertion of the paintbrush handle into JonBenét’s vaginal orifice. The last injury sustained was the tightening of the garrote around JonBenét’s throat that resulted in her death by strangulation /asphyxiation.

It is believed that 45-120 minutes passed between the blow and the strangulation. So, we have someone strike JonBenet in the head with a heavy object and then go quiet. Some time passes. As she’s unconscious, several abrasions appear on her body. People tried to match these marks to stun guns, but nothing fit. Kolar, in turn, compared the marks to the train tracks lying in the Train Room and found a perfect match. Kolar: “The pins on the outside rails of that piece of “O” type train track matched up exactly to the twin abrasions on the back of JonBenét. This was a toy readily accessible in the home and located only feet from where her body had been found. Crime scene photos / video had captured images of loose train track on the floor of Burke’s bedroom as well.”

u/AdequateSizeAttache performed her own experiment. You can read about the results here.

Personally, after seeing all this, I’m certain that JonBenet was poked with train tracks. This is very childlike behavior, not to mention that train tracks belong to Burke in particular. It looks like he tried to wake her up and gauge whether she shows any signs of life. Assault with a paintbrush is once again pretty juvenile in nature. The injury was acute but the harm was pretty limited for someone who’d do it for sexual gratification. The paintbrush was jammed inside once and that’s it. Then JonBenet was strangled. Again, why would an adult spend time constructing a crude device that looks like a boy scout toggle rope or a tightening stick? It’d be easy to strangle her with a belt, some rope, manually, or even smother her. Spending time to make this device is a strange decision. However, it’s not so strange if we consider that it was done by a boy with an engineering mindset who enjoyed building things — and Burke did enjoy it, it was his hobby. There are misconceptions about the ‘garrote’ or the knots being intricate — in reality, they were not. The ‘garrote’ was a nylon cord with a knot tied to a paintbrush. As for the knots:

Kolar: "Investigators would also enlist the aid of a knot expert, John Van Tassel of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. He would eventually determine that the slip knots used in the wrist and neck ligatures were of standard fare. The end of the cord wrapped around the remains of the paintbrush were observed to be concentric loops and ended in a simple hitch that secured the knot in place. Again, there was nothing particularly fancy about the knots suggesting that a skilled perpetrator had been responsible for tying them."

Michael Kane, the prosecutor: "I don’t know where this came from that these were sophisticated knots. I don’t know that anybody had the opportunity to untie those knots who was an expert in knots, but the police department had somebody who fit that category and that was not the opinion of that person. These were very simple knots."

In my opinion, out of Burke, Patsy, and John, Burke is the likeliest candidate to kill JonBenet in this strange manner. There are other reasons that make me this so: if interested, check Specifics of strangulation thread. Also, JonBenet’s body was found with her feet pointing toward the door and her arms being raised. It’s not a proven fact, but it looks like someone dragged her by her arms at some point. Adults could just pick her up, a child couldn't.

There is another BDI theory that Burke simply hit JonBenet in the head and the parents staged the rest. I don’t believe this to be true for several reasons.

First, I’m certain that John and Patsy would call the ambulance. JonBenet’s head wound didn’t even bleed. She was still alive. Patsy never shied away from calling the doctor, so it’s difficult for me to imagine that she would suddenly change her patterns and choose to do terrible things to her daughter’s body. In addition, I don’t think they’d go to such lengths to hide this kind of attack. Kids fight. One kid hitting another in rage is common. On the other hand, if they found JonBenet strangled and assaulted with a paintbrush… this could push them into covering the crime up because they’d never be able to explain it away.

Another reason why I think the attacker inflicted all major injuries is the paintbrush assault. Why stage sexual attack, then hide the evidence and try to deny it happened? It doesn’t make sense. If they wanted to make it look like JonBenet was raped, it’s one thing, but the Ramseys were never willing to discuss it. Also, the bindings on her wrists were very loose and didn’t even leave marks — they were believed to be staged by most investigators. This is a stark difference from the strangulation. The person who tied her wrists coudn't bear harming her more than she already was. If we imagine that one parent strangled her as staging and another one tied her wrists, then still, I’m sure that the strangler would correct the sloppy work after taking a look. So, I have no doubts that the same person hit, assaulted, and strangled JonBenet; the duct tape and the wrist bindings were staging.

3) Behavioral evidence and speculations

a) 911 call

Patsy’s 911 call was officially enhanced because there were voices heard after the conversation ended. Everyone interested in the phone call can try this recording. The enhanced conversation starts with 1:45.

It is an official part of investigation. You can find information about who worked on it in this post. The phone call is described by Thomas, Kolar, Schiller, Miller, etc. in their books. It was deemed credible enough to be used during Grand Jury hearing, and Burke admitted it sounded like his voice on it. You can see some quotes from it in these screens from a documentary.

This is what has been officially reported (taken from Kolar's book:)

Male (angry): “We’re not speaking to you!”

Female: “Help me Jesus. Help me Jesus.”

Young male: “What did you find?”

Years later, experts from CBS documentary who tried enhancing it with newer technology deciphered Patsy's words as "What did you do? Help me, Jesus." This bit is not the official version, but it is exactly what I personally always heard.

Some sources (including Schiller) report additional bits that came earlier. In them, Burke asks, "Please, what do I do?” This explains why John tells him "We are not speaking to you."

Both reactions from John and Patsy are telling to me. If John or Patsy murdered JonBenet, I don't think John would snap at Burke like this. If Patsy killed her, he would feel extra protective. If he killed her, Patsy would be protective, and I think she would snap at him for daring to snap at Burke after what he did. "What did you do?" definitely sounds like a follow-up from John's words, and I believe both are applied to Burke.

And of course, there is the fact that both parents deny Burke was ever there in the kitchen with them, but I’ll cover it later.

b) Psychological profiles

Many experts believe that the attack on JonBenet started as a rage attack. And that’s where the psychological profiles of John, Patsy, and Burke come into play.

John was described as calm, cold, and collected even in very stressful situations. Some gave him a name “Ice Man”. He never shouted, he never showed physical aggression. I struggle to think what his 6 yo daughter could do to make him not just lash out at her, but to grab an object and hit her in the head. If we imagine that he was the one to sexually abuse her and she screamed, then I think his first instinct would be to cover her mouth with his hand. It’s very easy to subdue a small child, you really don’t need to grab something heavy to do it. I don’t believe he was sexually abusing JonBenet, too. His other children not just love him, they adore him. They are his fiercest defenders. Melinda lets him near her own children. When he lost Beth, his first daughter, due to a car accident, he was a wreck. According to what others said, he was wailing in pain in the attic every night; he named his plane after his daughter; he started reading about afterlife daily. In terms of JonBenet’s pageants, he visited talent parts in particular, not the whole thing. Pretty strange for someone who’s sexually interested in his daughter — you would think he’d take a chance to stare at her in alluring outfits.

Patsy was also not known to be strict or aggressive, although some people commented on her possible mood swings. There are no accounts of her punishing her children physically and Burke confirmed in the interview that when he and JonBenet did something bad, they were just talked to. Patsy lived through cancer and was known as a very passionate mother. For her to grab something and bludgeon her daughter in the head with it? I find it more believable than with John, but not nearly as believable as Burke doing it.

Burke is the only person the family who is known for having hit JonBenet in the head before. It happened several days before JonBenet’s birthday in 1994. Burke hit her in the face with a golf club, got her in eye, and Patsy had to take her to emergency room. Later, Patsy claimed it was an accident. However, we also have an account from Judith Phillips, the photographer of the family, voiced in the CBS documentary: “I think Burke had a bad temper. It’s like he had a chip on his shoulder. He had hit JonBenét. Before the murder, I would have to say, it was probably a year and a half. They were playing in the yard and apparently he hit her with the golf club, right here(points to area under eye). She (Patsy)says the kids were playing, Burke lost his temper and hit her with a golf club.”

Kolar muses about the dates (the blow to the face shortly before birthday + the blow to the head on Christmas): “One can only wonder whether sibling jealousy or envy may have played any part in that instance, and whether these feelings spilled over into the events of the Christmas holidays in 1996.”

An interesting account from Thomas: “In 1995 [JonBenet] tripped in a grocery store, landed on her nose, and the doctor treated her with ice and Popsicles. Six months later she fell again, bonking herself over the left eye. In the twenty-four months before her death, she visited the doctor eighteen times.”

Was JonBenet really that clumsy? Or maybe Burke did hit/push her and Patsy came up with excuses? But please note that only some of these visits were due to physical injuries. JonBenet had other issues, too.

c) Reactions to murder

John and Patsy were described as devastated by JonBenet’s murder by multiple people. Several examples.

Thomas: "[Patsy] looked vacant and dazed, repeatedly asking in a soft, empty voice, “Why didn’t I hear my baby?”

Schiller: “While Patsy slept, Pam found John in the living room holding Burke. To Pam, Ramsey seemed to be in a trance. His face was blank. His eyes were red. “I don’t get it,” he said over and over. Then he got up, walked outside, shook his head, and asked aloud, “Why?”

Thomas: “Patsy was in a stupor on the living room floor after taking a Valium issued by Dr. Francesco Beuf, her children’s pediatrician and a family friend. John Ramsey also took a couple of Valium and walked through the house drinking scotch, occasionally stumbling. Once, a police officer overheard him cry softly, “I’m sorry … I’m so very sorry.” John Fernie and Dr. Beuf took him for a short walk outside."

Shapiro's account: “The next Sunday I attended church, and as I sat down, to my left, in the row right in front of me, were Patsy and John. Burke was sitting with the Stines, near me. I had to look away fast, not wanting to draw attention to myself. Patsy looked like she was in tears and scared. John was just calm. Burke was happy as a clam, hopping around with a friend.”

Kolar sums it up further: “Trujillo … informed me that he had taken the photographs on the afternoon of Saturday, December 28, 1996, when he was collecting non-testimonial evidence from members of the family. I took a few moments to silently study each of the photographs. John Ramsey looked tired, haggard, and despondent. Patsy Ramsey was hard to recognize. Her hair was pulled back tightly against her head; she was pale and without makeup and looked as though she had aged a hundred years. The beautiful woman I had seen in many other photographs was barely recognizable, and there was no doubt in my mind that she was consumed by anguish. Like his parents, Burke was seated in a chair and he leaned back slightly, with his right arm slung casually over a nearby table. Burke looked directly into the lens and smiled for the camera.”

Now on to Burke in particular. Out of all members of his family, Burke was the only one consistently described as having flat affect.

Pam Archuleta about memorial service for JonBenet: “During the service, Burke was playing with a model airplane and not paying attention to what was going on around him. His parents were grieving as were every adult in the room, but Burke was ignoring everything and just flying his plane lost within his own thoughts. I wondered what he was thinking and feeling.”

Thomas’ description of Burke’s interview with a child psychologist Suzanne Bernhard: “The boy remembered his sister as being “nice” but added, “Sometimes she bugged me.” JonBenet would tickle him and rummage through his desk to find candy and baseball cards. Bernhard asked how he was dealing with his sister’s death, and Burke replied, “I kind of forget about it. I just kind of go …” and he lapsed into sounds similar to Nintendo beeps. His descriptions were flat and indifferent. Bernhard detected no fear that the killer might come back for him or that Burke thought the family was in danger. The psychologist said it was very unusual for a child to feel safe when a sibling had been violently killed.”

Bonita papers: “Burke displayed an enormous amount of lack of emotion, almost to the point of indifference, which Dr. Bernard explained may be attributed to shock, but could also have been a lack of attachment to his family … Even in response to questions which should have elicited strong emotions, he remained non-expressive. When asked “How have things been since your only sister died?”, Burke responded, “It’s been okay.” When asked to draw a picture of his family ... JonBenet was not in the picture at all. Dr. Bernhard thought it extremely abnormal that JonBenet was not in the family picture at all, since her heath had occurred only 13 days prior. Most children continue to include deceased siblings in family drawings years after the death because it is too devastating for them to think about the loss. Burke also told Dr. Bernhard that he was “getting on with his life”, another very abnormal reaction for a child who had so recently lost his sibling.”

Kolar: “Anthony [Burke’s friend] told investigators that he never saw Burke cry during their stay in Atlanta. Kaempfer advised that the only time she had seen him display some emotion and sadness was at the cemetery after the graveside services. He had left a group of people and went to the side of JonBenet’s casket, patting it gently. After that brief display of caring, Burke and Anthony went exploring, skipping through the headstones in the cemetery.”

Kolar: “Stine appeared to Kaempfer to have been disturbed by the conversation and had listened to Burke and Doug talk about how JonBenet had been strangled. Based upon Kaempfer’s statement, it appeared that Stine had over overheard the boys discussing whether or not manual strangulation had been involved in JonBenet’s death. Stine described the conversation as being “very impersonal,” and it struck her that the discussion about the details of JonBenét’s death was like the boys were “talking about a TV show.” This discourse between Burke and Doug had taken place no more than two days following JonBenét’s murder and apparently had such an impact upon Stine that she brought it up in conversation with Mary Kaempfer at the first opportunity.”

Schiller: “On the third day [of interview about JonBenet’s death], Schuler asked Burke if he had any questions, anything he wanted to know. By the way, that Rolex watch you have on, Burke asked, how much did it cost?”

So, what does it mean? Burke showing little emotion for JonBenet doesn’t make him a killer. Maybe he didn’t love her; maybe he is just emotionally superficial. On the other hand, I would argue that this is exactly what makes it likelier for him to kill JonBenet like she was killed rather than for his parents, who were described as loving and doting by practically everyone.

d) According to Kolar, “I had also found it interesting that the Paughs had reportedly purchased several books on childhood behavior for the Ramsey family. The titles of the books were intriguing: The Hurried Child – Growing Up Too Fast, by David Elkind; Children at Risk, Dobson / Bruer; Why Johnny Can’t Tell Right From Wrong, Kilpatrick.” Note that these books aren’t focused on problematic children in particular. They are pretty general in nature. However, they are all behavior books, and all three address the issue of early development of sexuality and crossing boundaries that children often don't recognize as wrong (among other things). The fact that Nedra chose to gift books about parenting to the Ramseys can imply that she either heard about some problem or observed it herself during her stay at the house. It does look like a strange gift for someone who's had kids for a while — and three books at that from one person! — unless there were some issues.

e) People around the Ramseys provided interesting observations about their behavior

Schiller: “Howard, who had known [John] for years, felt he knew something about JonBenet’s death but couldn’t talk about it. She thought it was something he didn’t have anything to do with, but she also saw a man who didn’t know how to help his wife deal with their daughter’s death.”

Schiller: “On 12-27-1996 at Fernie house, Patsy said, "they've killed my baby" to Pam Griffin and then asked, "Couldn't you fix this for me?" and then "We didn't mean for that to happen." Pam couldn't say why, but she remembered feeling as if Patsy knew who killed JonBenet but was afraid to say.”

Kolar: "While attending the memorial services in Boulder, and while playing with Anthony in Atlanta, Burke was described by Anthony as acting like “he kind of knew what happened and trusted that people would find out.” Anthony indicated that Burke may have appeared “confused” at times, but was not acting upset and indicated that he was not scared. When asked how he was doing, Burke said he was “fine.”

From these reactions, people felt like John and Patsy didn’t kill JonBenet but knew what happened; Burke’s friend commented that he felt like Burke believed people would find out the truth and appeared confused but not scared. My interpretation: Burke wasn’t scared that his parents would be arrested and he likely knew he himself wouldn’t be arrested due to his age. He was confused by the amount of efforts his parents invested to create panic and mislead everyone, and he believed it might not last long.

4) Protecting Burke

While this is largely a behavioral analysis part, it’s so significant that I feel like it should be placed in a separate section. I’ll start with a quote that I feel describes the situation well.

Account of Brian Cabell: "Distraught, seeming uncomfortable and a little frightened, the Ramseys nonetheless seemed ready. They sat there not as two individuals but as a couple."

John and Patsy not simply covered up this crime — they engaged into an actual war to keep the truth hidden. They worked as a team and they both lied, accused, and obfuscated. The preface to their book Death of Innocence states: "Wherever we go... whatever we do..." The meaning of these words is disclosed in chapter 6. It's a song from Gypsy that JonBenet apparently loved. The complete line is "Wherever we go, whatever we do, we're gonna go through it together." My subjective interpretation is, these words outline their actions well — whatever they have to do, even if it’s ugly, they are in this together.

Patsy when asked if John did it: “If John Ramsey were involved, honey, we wouldn’t be sitting here. I’d have knocked his block off. Read my lips! This was not done by a family member. Didn’t happen. Period. End of statement.”

John when asked if Patsy did it: “"If that was what happened, I would not protect her from or protect that fact ... Absolutely not.”

Yes, sure, both are liars. But I do believe they wouldn’t cover for each other. Patsy would have benefited from giving John up in numerous ways. She'd be a heroic woman who suffered at the hands of a monster and fought for justice — she had cancer before that and was fighting for her life, so I'd say people who like to blame the victims for "not seeing anything" would be few in number. She'd get endless attention and sympathy, she'd still have a lot of money even after the divorce since at least a part of everything belonged to her, too, and she could sue John for the rest (plus the money from the interviews); she's do right by JonBenet, protect her son from a monster, and stay true to her religious convictions.

Kolar: “Patsy stated that she would have nothing left to live for if she lost Burke.”

Patsy in DOI: “The thought that the Department of Social Sservices might have considered removing Burke from our custody still horrifies me … Maybe Burke has been in an accident, and if we lost him, too, I couldn't live."

John's career is trickier, but it could have taken off, too, if he span the tale right. He’d also do right by JonBenet and protect Burke. He’d get a chance to find a new lovely partner and cultivate the image of a brokenhearted father. I think he and Patsy were a strong couple, but I don’t believe they were so in love that they’d pick one another over their children.

I do think they protected Burke. Here’s why - and here's more info on why they might have covered for Burke.

a) Not letting Burke be questioned

The Ramseys did everything to stop people from interacting with Burke. Burke is an early riser who didn't leave his room that morning even despite all the commotion; it was Fleet who finally asked about him, which forced John to go 'check' on him. When people tried to talk to Burke, John stopped it. He stopped the police from doing it, too. From Thomas' book: "So when Officer Rick French saw [Burke] being taken away, he went over to talk to the boy. But John Ramsey intervened. The father told the policeman that Burke didn’t know anything and had slept through it all, and he hustled the boy to a waiting vehicle."

They resisted the questioning. Shortly after the body was found, when Dr. Beuf determined that Patsy couldn’t be interviewed because she felt too badly, he also “determined that Burke Ramsey could not be interviewed by police” (Thomas). Now this is very strange, considering that we know that Burke’s emotional state fully allowed him to be interviewed. In fact, without the knowledge of his parents, he spoke to detective in the afternoon of 26th, although the questions centered on JonBenet’s disappearance only, not murder. I’ll address this interview later.

Later, when the officers were doing routine stuff like taking the fingertips, "[John] was shepherding Burke, a month shy of turning ten years old and apparently oblivious to the gravity of the situation. Gosage and I went gently about our business while Ramsey held and hugged the boy, almost smothering him and speaking quietly in his ear."

Later: "We got very little from an interview with nine-year-old Burke Ramsey, for whom Team Ramsey had dictated stringent terms to an agreeable district attorney’s office: No police could be in the room, the questioning would be by child psychologist Suzanne Bernhard, and the session would not be held in a police building. Any possible police leverage was bargained away before the session began … Detectives Jane Harmer and Ron Gosage, a group of social workers, and Burke’s lawyer, Patrick Burke, watched from behind a two-way mirror. The detectives were able to make suggestions to Bernhard, but the psychologist asked shrink questions, and the interview became an entirely different sort than one to solicit evidentiary information … More than a year and a half would pass before Burke was allowed to be interviewed again."

Thomas about the second interview: “Now eleven years old, Burke would be interviewed alone by Schuller while Hofstrom and Ramsey lawyer Jim Jenkins watched from another room. The arrangement seemed designed more to make the boy comfortable than to elicit information.”

In 2010, Boulder Police tried to speak with Burke at his home, but he declined. His attorney Wood called BPD later with an objection. He informed that Burke has no interest in answering questions.

Beckner confirmed it in his AMA: “Yes, we had two detectives fly out to meet with him at his residence to see if he would sit down and talk to us. He refused and later his lawyer told us not to contact him again.”

b) Sealing Burke’s medical/psychiatric records

This was something the investigators couldn’t access because Ramseys’ attorneys fought against it with particular vehemence. Apparently, the family was entitled to an “island of privacy” after their ordeal. Beckner confirms this in his AMA: to the question of whether BPD ever successfully obtained the medical records for Burke, he says “No.”

c) Infantilizing and distancing Burke from the crime

There are numerous accounts of the Ramseys lying to distance Burke from the crime, from major to minor ones.

  1. 911 call. The Ramseys are adamant that Burke slept through the night and heard nothing. Even when the information about the enhanced call became public, they still insisted that Burke wasn’t there. According to them, Burke slept through the shouting and running up and down the stairs, through John/Patsy entering his room, through the policeman entering with a flashlight, through all the visitors arriving, etc. They were forced to alter their testimony later when Burke admitted he wasn’t asleep, but they still never admitted he was with them in the kitchen and just pretending to sleep upon the arrival of the first officer.

  2. The gifts. Kolar: “There had been another discrepancy in one of Patsy Ramsey’s law enforcement interviews that caught my attention. Investigators had noted that the wrapping paper on a pair of Christmas presents observed in the Wine Cellar at the time of the discovery of JonBenet’s body had been torn. She told the detectives that she couldn’t remember what was contained in the presents, and hence the need to tear back part of the paper. I learned, over the course of my inquiry, that it was Burke who had actually been responsible for tearing back the paper of the presents while playing in the basement on Christmas Day, and I wondered why Patsy would claim responsibility for doing this.”

Indeed, why would Patsy lie that she did this when it was Burke who did this? And when did he do this, exactly? It’s possible that he and JonBenet sneaked downstairs together to take a look at whatever gifts were still left (LEGOS parking garage for Burke stands out in particular), and something about it led to their conflict.

3) Burke’s age when he hit JonBenet. During the incident where Burke hit JonBenet with a golf club, he was 7 year old. It happened in 1994. Patsy claims it happened in 1993 and then tries to make Burke even younger in a ridiculous way. Patsy: “He was taking a practice swing, he was just a little guy, he was two or three, or two and a half, and he was -- it was our first summer there, how young they were there.” Obviously, JonBenet wouldn’t even be born if Burke was 2.5.

Continued in Part 2


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Nov 25 '24

Rant The saxophone? What??

1.9k Upvotes

How in the world did that woman manage to determine that JonBenet was “masturbating” with it? Like she was just being a 6 yr old girl and imitating how she had seen people play that particular instrument, right? She never put it “between her legs” and I can’t believe no one called that woman out for saying that. Insane.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Sep 27 '24 Hooray

Images She was murdered less than 24 hours after this picture was taken. She looked so happy🥺

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

Someone out there knows what happened.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jan 03 '24

Discussion John brings JB upstairs holding her like this and asks if she’s dead

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

It’s ironic in the TV movie that came out in 2000 the actor playing John holds her close to his body. In reality, her body stiff from rigor mortis. This is a college educated man with a billion dollar business. You can’t tell me he didn’t know she was dead and had been dead for a long time.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jul 21 '24

Images To those who say BDI isn’t possible because of his age…

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

It absolutely is not impossible or even unlikely.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Sep 26 '20 Bless Up

Research Setting the Record Straight on the Evidence of Prior Sexual Abuse - Part 1

1.4k Upvotes

[This post has been split into two parts because of selfpost character limits.]

Introduction

It surprises me how often I see discussions involving speculation on whether JonBenet's UTIs, vaginitis, bedwetting, and history of frequent doctor visits indicate sexual abuse or not. These discussions invariably include people chiming in to share how they or someone they know had similar issues but were never abused. From these discussions, one could get the impression that itchy pageant costumes or Mr. Bubble useage are perfectly reasonable explanations for the evidence of sexual abuse.

The fact is, there's no need to speculate based on these things. There is physical evidence that is a significant indicator of prior sexual abuse. This is the evidence that should be at the forefront of discussions on the question of sexual abuse, not bubble baths or bedwetting. Issues such as vaginitis, UTIs, and bedwetting are not specific to sexual abuse; there are other possible explanations for them. There is no other possible explanation for the physical evidence besides trauma from physical penetration.

In reading discussions on the case over the years, it's always puzzled me how often the evidence of prior sexual abuse gets downplayed or dismissed. In considering why, I believe it is due primarily to these two common misconceptions:

Common Misconception 1 (as demonstrated above): The evidence of sexual abuse = vaginal irritation, UTIs, rashes, bedwetting, soiling, frequent doctor visits

Common Misconception 2: There is a medical debate on the issue and there's evidence to support both sides

Common Misconception 1 is a straw man argument — the actual evidence (the physical findings) is not being addressed or refuted.

Common Misconception 2 is an argument from false equivalence. An equal, rather than accurate, amount of weight is given to both sides of the issue. People see the mountain of conflicting information and contradicting opinions and think "It looks like expert opinion on this issue is divided; I guess a case can be made for either side." The enormous difference in expertise and experience between the various experts is ignored, as is the level of access they had to the evidence. This misconception gives the impression that all these expert opinions cancel each other out, rendering the issue debatable and open to interpretation. Consequently, the probative value of the evidence is undermined, making it easier for people to feel they can dismiss.

I think several factors have contributed to these two misconceptions:

  • Media speculation in reaction to the redacted autopsy report.

A partial autopsy report was released on February 14, 1997, with certain sections having been removed by the coroner. Most of the information detailing the vaginal trauma, for example, was purposefully held back. What did remain was a section that said there was chronic inflammation and epithelial erosion found in the vaginal mucosa. This detail sparked a lot of attention and debate in the media, with various experts weighing in with their opinions on what it could mean. In reaction to speculation from some doctors that the released autopsy report portions indicated chronic sexual abuse, the Ramsey's media consultant Pat Korten made [statements] (http://web.dailycamera.com/extra/ramsey/1997/02/15-3.html) such as:

"It is my understanding that this (vaginal inflammation) is not uncommon among children of that age," Korten said.

Child abuse experts were asked to join the fray with their own reactions. In a February 20 article, the Daily Camera reported this quote from Dr. Joan Slook, pediatrician with the Baylor College of Medicine in Houston:

"Poor hygiene can cause chronic inflammation," Slook said. "Some little girls don't wash themselves properly." Improper wiping or washing in the vaginal area can introduce bacteria and produce inflammation, she said.

"Some little girls can have asymptomatic bladder infections that can cause irritation in the vagina," Slook said. "Chronic inflammation is a pretty non-specific thing to say," she said, adding that epithelial erosion also is vague.

In all this media commentary and premature speculation based on incomplete information, chronic inflammation became conflated with evidence of sexual abuse. Even after the full autopsy report was released and information about the evidence of prior abuse came out, Ramsey defense campaign representatives continued to respond to questions about prior sexual abuse with explanations involving poor wiping, bedwetting, and bubble baths. These sneaky answers did the trick — it convinced people who didn't know otherwise that the evidence was something it wasn't.

  • The Ramseys' PR defense campaign efforts. It's not by accident or happenstance that there's a lot of confusion and conflicting information out there on this topic. It's what defense campaigns do — manufacture reasonable doubt and disseminate it in the media. Most of the misinformation in this case can be traced back to Ramseys, their attorneys, their private investigators, Lou Smit, and other defense campaign advocates. They have put out a lot of misleading information which has shaped and controlled the public narrative about this case.

We know the Ramseys were not happy the police had evidence of prior sexual abuse and it was something they wanted to go away — this is mentioned in Steve Thomas's book. Clearly, this evidence is not in their best interest and is something they have actively tried to counter.

  • The PBworks wiki page on the evidence of sexual assault. The 'JonBenet Ramsey Case Encyclopedia' is a popular resource online for those searching for information about the case. I've even see some mainstream media outlets use information from it in their articles. Its 'Evidence of Sexual Assault' entry gets referenced and linked online all the time. However, it is very misleading in the way it portrays the evidence and is a good example of false balance/bothsidesism.

  • Lawrence Schiller's book. Perfect Murder, Perfect Town is another popular resource on this case. It is regarded as the 'bible' as far as books on this case go. In it, Schiller downplays the evidence of prior sexual abuse, presenting it as something that is wholly uncertain and over which expert opinion evenly divided. On whether JonBenet had been abused prior to her murder, Schiller says: "It was likely that the truth would never be known." That is not an accurate reflection of the value of this evidence in this criminal investigation. Law enforcement accepted that the balance of medical opinion did show JonBenet had been abused prior to her death and considered it a fact of the case. To portray the issue as if there was an equal lack of supporting evidence on both sides to where no conclusions could be drawn is disingenuous.

  • Paula Woodward's book. In her book We Have Your Daughter, Woodward misportrays the evidence of prior sexual abuse as well as the opinions of the experts. I have written about this previously in this post.

  • Forum discussions. There's a tendency for online discussion on this case to be filled with recycled rumors, misconceptions, opinions, and beliefs which become repeated so often they eventually turn into forum cliches and factoids. I don't know how many times I have seen inaccurate statements like "For every expert that says there was prior sexual abuse, there's another that says there wasn't" get declared as if it were a fact.

However, if one takes a closer look at the evidence, it becomes apparent that it is not weighted equally on both sides. There is no medical debate, but a medical consensus. Every child sexual abuse expert who examined the genital findings from JonBenet's autopsy recognized physical signs of sexual abuse that predated her murder. Despite some objections to their conclusion, no one has disputed the physical findings of these experts. Their findings are compelling and should be seriously considered. In order to do that, though, one must first understand what the findings are and get acquainted with the doctors who testified to them.

The purpose of this post is to lay out everything that is known about the evidence of prior sexual abuse, but also to put it into a larger context so that hopefully it will be better understood. This will involve delving a bit into the history of child sexual abuse evaluations (it will become relevant later), as well as some background information of the experts involved. I will also go over dissenting opinions and address some common counterarguments and myths.

The evolution of modern pediatric sexual abuse evaluations: A brief historical timeline

1857 - One of the first known forensic medical studies on child sexual abuse, Étude médico-légale sur les attentats aux mœurs (Forensic study on offenses against morals) by French medical doctor and pathologist Auguste Ambroise Tardieu, is published. This treatise describes various forms of child abuse and maltreatment and includes anatomical drawings of genital findings which by modern standards are considered surprisingly accurate and ahead of its time. For some reason these efforts are largely ignored and it will be over a century before interest in sexual abuse evaluations from a medical perspective is resurrected.

1940s-50s - Child sexual abuse remains an unacknowledged taboo. Medical textbooks of this era tell doctors that children can contract STIs like gonorrhea from non-sexual means, such as from toilet seats, sharing towels, or sleeping in the same bed as an infected adult. Such myths will pervade for decades.

1962 - "The Battered Child Syndrome" by pediatrician C. Henry Kempe is published and physical child abuse is recognized. A watershed moment in pediatrics and child abuse protection. This article is about detecting hidden signs of physical abuse using modern radiological technology and newly proposed evaluation guidelines. Detecting chronic or hidden sexual abuse, however, will prove to be a more enduring challenge.

Late 1960s - By now all 50 states have child abuse protection laws in place.

1970s - Feminist campaigners and policymakers take up the cause of child sexual abuse. Most child protection workers during this period are social workers and therapists. The field of child abuse protection and evaluation is in its nascency.

1974 - Congress enacts the Federal Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act (CAPTA, P.L. 93-247). CAPTA creates a nationwide focus on establishing standardized protocols for dealing with all forms of child abuse and neglect. Mandatory reporting is one component of CAPTA. Before, only doctors were required to report cases of suspected child abuse; now, it is anyone in a position of authority — teachers, camp counselors, etc. Consequently, there is a significant increase in the reporting of child abuse cases and an increase in the demand of evaluations for suspected sexual abuse. Most of the physicians doing these medical evaluations are not researchers or academics but work with prosecutor's offices and law enforcement.

1975 - Suzanne M. Sgroi, physician pioneer in the field, publishes an article calling child sexual abuse "the last frontier in child abuse" which "remains a taboo topic in many areas."

1977 - C. Henry Kempe brings awareness to the issue of child sexual abuse by following up "The Battered Child Syndrome" with a landmark lecture at the Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Pediatrics in New York City. The talk, titled "Sexual Abuse, Another Hidden Pediatric Problem" is published in the journal Pediatrics the following year.

1980s - Doctors start examining children's genitals, documenting, cataloging and trying to interpret their findings. Some use a colposcope, a binocular-like instrument originally used to detect cervical cancer, which magnifies the vaginal canal and tissues up to 4-30x. Some take anatomical measurements which they use to develop criteria for suspected abuse. They know what findings they see in abused children, but there is an acute lack of understanding of what "normal" or nonabused genital findings look like.

1981 - The article "Sexual Misuse: Rape, Molestation, and Incest" by Dr. Bruce Woodling is published in the journal Pediatric Clinics of North America.

Dr. Woodling is a California physician whose area of specialty is in sexual abuse forensics. The paper presents his research on what he has dubbed the "wink response test", a concept borrowed from Tardieu's 19th-century forensic manual. This test involves stroking the area near the anus with a cotton swab and gauging the response — contraction of the sphincter indicates no abuse, while an involuntary opening or 'winking' response indicates prior penetration. It was a test Tardieu developed to diagnose pederasty and Woodling has applied it to children as a way to detect anal abuse.

1982 - The wave of daycare sexual abuse hysteria of the 80s begins with the Kern County abuse allegations. The investigation and trial will culminate in the conviction of two couples (the McCuans and Kniffens) for sexually abusing several children. Dr. Woodling's wink response test and testimony play a part in their conviction. Several other similar cases in the same area at the time result in convictions of several others.

1984 - Daycare abuse hysteria continues with the Fells Acres and McMartin Preschool accusations. In the Fells Acre case, day care teacher Gerald Amirault will be put on trial and convicted of sexually assaulting and raping nine children. Questionable interview methods of the children and unproven genital evaluation criteria form the basis for the conviction.

The McMartin preschool case is the first to receive major media attention in the United States. Pediatrician Astrid Heger, under the tutelage of Dr. Bruce Woodling, conducts many of the evaluations of the McMartin children and diagnoses the majority of them as having been sexually abused. The criteria used for the evaluations are based primarily on Woodling's research as well as other published papers at the time (e.g., Cantwell's 1983 study on hymenal diameter measurements). Many of the children are found to have suspect genital findings such as notches, clefts, bands, tissue tags, ruffled or rolled hymenal edges, 'microtraumas' seen only with magnification, hymenal openings which measure over four millimeters, as well as positive reactions to Woodling's wink response test.

mid to late 80s - More abuse allegations and convictions including Country Walk, Wee Nursery, Bronx Five, Little Rascals day care, Glendale Montessori cases.

1988 - Dr. John McCann, a pediatrics professor and researcher from UCSF School of Medicine, drops a bombshell at the 18th annual child abuse convention in San Diego. He presents the results of a study he and his colleagues have worked on the past four years. They had gathered a control group of about 300 nonabused/"normal" children and meticulously documented and photographed their anuses and genitals, the first such study to do so. What they learned shocked McCann and everyone else in the field. Many of the anatomic findings which some specialists were claiming to be signs of abuse were commonly found in the nonabused children. The study showed that the large variation of anatomical features of childrens' genitals were, in fact, just that — variations of normal. This meant that parents and caretakers were being reported and convicted based on erroneous unscientific criteria. This presentation, titled "Anatomical Standardization of Normal Prepubertal Children," is a watershed moment in the field.

1989 - The first paper based on McCann's study ("Perianal findings in prepubertal children selected for nonabuse: a descriptive study") is published in the journal Child Abuse & Neglect. Among its conclusions, it shows that Dr. Woodling's wink response test has no scientific basis.

The impact of McCann's study influences leaders in the field to call for an overhaul in the way sexual abuse evaluation criteria are approached:

Medical Examination for Sexual Abuse: Have We Been Misled?

The more we learn, the less we know "with reasonable medical certainty"?

1990s - This decade sees an explosion of research and progress. The second paper based on McCanns' landmark study ("Genital findings in prepubertal girls selected for nonabuse: a descriptive study") is published in the journal Pediatrics in 1990. The dropping of charges in the McMartin preschool trial, also in 1990, marks the beginning of the winding down of the nation's abuse hysteria. McCann's research is presented as evidence by the defense in some abuse trials, such as the McMartin and Little Rascals daycare cases.

1992 - A classification system for evaluating children for suspected sexual abuse is proposed by Dr. Joyce Adams, Katherine Harper and Sandra Knudson. This later becomes known as the Adams classification system (keep this system in mind as we will be referring back to it) and will be periodically revised with updated criteria throughout the following decades. It will be adopted and used in the field of child abuse pediatrics and gynecology worldwide. John McCann's research help form a basis for this system.

mid to late 90s - More research based on cross-sectional, case-control, and longitudinal studies of abused and nonabused children are published which improves understanding and accuracy of evaluation criteria: Berenson, Heger, Adams, Emans, Kellogg, Kerns, McCann, Muram, Finkel, etc. Due to the errors of the previous decade, specialists in the field are highly conscientious and prudent about differentiating nonabuse from abuse criteria.

The evidence of prior sexual abuse in the JonBenet Ramsey case: What we know

When Boulder County Coroner Dr. John Meyer performed JonBenet's autopsy, he identified signs of acute vaginal trauma which he believed was consistent with digital penetration. What we didn't find out until the publication of James Kolar's book Foreign Faction in 2012 is that Dr. Meyer also saw indications of prior sexual contact. Concerned about this possibility, he sought a specialist opinion and brought Dr. Andrew Sirotnak to the morgue to examine JonBenet's genital injuries. Dr. Sirotnak was a child abuse pediatrician who headed the Child Protection Team at Children's Hospital Colorado. He confirmed Meyer's opinion that there were signs of prior sexual contact.

Here are the relevant passages from Kolar's book:

  • Dr. Meyer also observed signs of chronic inflammation around the vaginal orifice and believed that these injuries had been inflicted in the days or weeks before the acute injury that was responsible for causing the bleeding at the time of her death. This irritation appeared consistent with prior sexual contact.

[Foreign Faction: Who Really Kidnapped JonBenet?, A. James Kolar, p. 58]

  • Following the meeting, Dr. Meyer returned to the morgue with Dr. Andy Sirontak, Chief of Denver Children's Hospital Child Protection Team, so that a second opinion could be rendered on the injuries observed to the vaginal area of JonBenet. He would observe the same injuries that Dr. Meyer had noted during the autopsy protocol and concurred that a foreign object had been inserted into the opening of JonBenet's vaginal orifice and was responsible for the acute injury witnessed at the 7:00 o'clock position. Further inspection revealed that the hymen was shriveled and retracted, a sign that JonBenet had been subjected to some type of sexual contact prior to the date of her death. Dr. Sirontak could not provide an opinion as to how old those injuries were or how many times JonBenet may have been assaulted and would defer to the expert opinions of other medical examiners.

[Kolar, p. 61]

  • Dr. Meyer was concerned about JonBenet's vaginal injuries, and he, along with Boulder investigators, sought the opinions of a variety of other physicians in the days following her autopsy. Dr. Sirontak, a pediatrician with Denver Children's Hospital, had recognized signs of prior sexual trauma but neither he nor Dr. Meyer were able to say with any degree of certainty what period of time may have been involved in the abuse.

[Kolar, p. 63]

Boulder Police would later ask several child sexual abuse experts to review the autopsy findings* in order to help them determine if there was evidence of prior sexual abuse. In addition to Andrew Sirotnak, these are the experts whom we know were consulted:

Richard Krugman

James Monteleone

Valerie Rao

John McCann

That's right — that John McCann. The same John McCann who was responsible for putting child sexual abuse evaluations onto scientific footing and who happened to establish the standards for what is considered normal and abnormal in pediatric genital exams was consulted on the JonBenet Ramsey case.

In Steve Thomas's 2001 deposition for the Wolf v Ramsey civil trial, Thomas says that McCann came recommended by the FBI. There's a reason for that, which is that McCann was regarded as one of the the foremost authorities on interpreting pediatric anogenital findings in cases of suspected abuse. Thomas also refers to McCann, Monteleone, and Rao as the "blue ribbon pediatric panel." Based on various sources, we know that there was at least one meeting in Boulder in September 1997 involving McCann, Rao, Monteleone, and Krugman.

Here is the relevant passage from Thomas's book:

In mid-September, a panel of pediatric experts from around the country reached one of the major conclusions of the investigation - that JonBenet had suffered vaginal trauma prior to the day she was killed.

There were no dissenting opinions among them on the issue, and they firmly rejected any possibility that the trauma to the hymen and chronic vaginal inflammation were caused by urination issues or masturbation. We gathered affidavits stating in clear language that there were injuries "consistent with prior trauma and sexual abuse"...."There was chronic abuse"..."Past violation of the vagina"...."Evidence of both acute injury and chronic sexual abuse." In other words, the doctors were saying it had happened before.

...

The results, however, were not what is known in the legal world as "conclusive" - which means that there can be no other interpretation - and I would fully expect defense lawyers to argue something different. Nevertheless, our highly qualified doctors had brought in a remarkable finding.

[JonBenet: Inside the Ramsey Murder Investigation, Steve Thomas & Don Davis, p. 253]

The experts expected to testify in court had the case gone to trial. As we know, there was no criminal trial, but we know the experts were called to testify before the grand jury.

*During JonBenet's autopsy, an instrument called a colposcope was used to examine and document her genital injuries. This is standard procedure in forensic pathology in cases of suspected child abuse or sexual assault. Colposcopy illuminates and magnifies the vaginal cavity and is used to identify abnormal changes to tissue and the internal genital structures. The experts would have relied on these colposcopic photos as well as histologic samples of JonBenet's vaginal mucosa in addition to the autopsy report, coroner's notes, and lab results.

The physical findings explained

These are the genital findings we know were discovered at JonBenet's autopsy:

Ref. no.FindingSource
1Chronic inflammation around vaginal orificeFF
2Small amount of dried blood on perineumAR
3Small amount of dried and semifluid blood on skin of fourchette and in vestibuleAR
4Hyperemia of vestibule and vaginal wallAR
5Abrasion on hymenal orifice at 7 o'clock position, involving the hymen and vaginal wallAR
6Epithelial erosion with underlying capillary congestion of tissue from 7'oclockAR
7Hymenal orifice measuring 1cm x 1cmAR
8A lack of hymenal tissue between the 10 and 2 o'clock positionsAR
9Vascular congestion and focal interstitial chronic inflammation of vaginal mucosa in all sectionsAR
10Bruise on hymenBP
11Three dimensional thickening from inside to outside of inferior hymenal rimBP
12Narrowing of inferior hymenal rim to base of hymenBP
13Exposure of vaginal rugaeBP

AR = Autopsy Report

BP = Bonita Papers

FF = Foreign Faction


What do these physical findings mean?

Here is a quick break down:

  • 5, 6, and 10, with corresponding bleeding 2 and 3, are signs of acute trauma from the time of the murder.

  • 7 is something that gets brought up as evidence of prior abuse ("enlarged hymenal opening"). However, criteria based on hymenal opening measurements were removed from the Adams classification guidelines in 1996. McCann did not include it in his criteria for abuse, but said it supported the findings for abuse. Since the late 90s/early 2000s, specialists have tried to move away from using measurement-based criteria as it is difficult to do precisely. Research data has shown that measurements can vary with the examination position, technique, age of the child, state of relaxation of the child, and the skill of the examiner.

  • 8 describes a crescentic hymen, a common variation of hymen types. This is a normal finding. Generally, discrepancies of the anterior half of the hymen (above the 3 and 9 o'clock positions) are not considered concerning and missing segments, notches, clefts can be normal findings. It is the inferior half of the hymen (below the 3 and 9 o'clock positions) where experts look for indicators of abuse.

  • 11-13 are findings observed by John McCann that describe structural changes of the hymen from a prior penetration. 12 describes a transection (a healed laceration) of the inferior portion of the hymen.

  • 1, 4, 9 can be caused by a variety of other conditions and on their own are not classified as indicators for abuse. In the case where findings indicating abuse are also present, they need to be considered in context.

McCann's findings

The most important of these findings to understand is 12, which is one of McCann's observations outlined in the Bonita Papers.

There was a three dimensional thickening from inside to outside on the inferior hymeneal rim with a bruise apparent on the external surface of the hymen and a narrowing of the hymeneal rim from the edge of the hymen to where it attaches to the muscular portion of the vaginal openings. At the narrowing area, there appeared to be very little if any hymen present.

To understand what this means, take a look at the white line segment labeled "Hymenal width" in this colposcopic photo (warning: image of vagina/hymen). It demarcates the length of the hymenal membrane from the rim/edge to the base where it attaches to the vaginal wall.

A narrowing of the hymenal rim means the hymenal membrane is reduced in dimension from the rim/edge toward the base. When the rim is narrowed all the way to the base, that is called a complete cleft or a transection. A transection is a discontinuity of the inferior hymenal rim that extends to or through the base of the hymen. Basically, it is a telltale residual absence of tissue from a healed complete laceration.

If this is difficult to visualize, here is a figure which shows what transections look like:

Figure 3: Hymenal Membrane Characteristics

[source]

The Adams classification system

In the fields of child abuse pediatrics and pediatric gynecology, the set of guidelines most widely used in interpreting genital findings is the Adams classification system.

If we were to look at the most recently revised version (2023), we would see that it identifies certain "Findings Caused by Trauma":

These findings are highly suggestive of abuse, even in the absence of a disclosure from the child, unless the child and/or caretaker provides a timely and plausible description of accidental anogenital straddle, crush or impalement injury, or past surgical interventions that are confirmed from review of medical records.

Among those findings that are "highly suggestive of abuse" includes point 38, listed in the subsection titled "Residual (healing) injuries to genital/anal tissues" under section E:

Healed hymenal transection/complete hymen cleft- a defect in the hymen below the 3 to 9 o’clock location that extends to or through the base of the hymen, with no hymenal tissue discernible at that location

This is precisely what Dr. McCann described having observed in JonBenet.

A transection in the inferior half of the hymen of a prepubertal child is a significant finding because it is considered a clear indication of a prior penetrating injury:

  • Multiple studies have noted the presence of hymenal transections only in prepubertal girls with a history of disclosed sexual abuse.

[ Sara T. Stewart, MD. Hymenal Characteristics in Girls with and without a History of Sexual Abuse, p. 533]

  • Hymenal transections are very rarely seen in prepubertal girls who have not been sexually abused. However, a demonstrated transection, based on multiple studies, is commonly viewed as “a clear but uncommon indicator of past trauma.”

[Mishori, R., Ferdowsian, H., Naimer, K. et al. The little tissue that couldn’t – dispelling myths about the Hymen’s role in determining sexual history and assault.]

  • Thus a deep notch, transection, or perforation on the inferior portion of the hymen may be considered as a definitive sign of sexual abuse or other trauma.

[Berenson, et al. A case-control study of anatomic changes resulting from sexual abuse, p. 829]

  • A transection of the posterior hymen between 4 and 8 o’clock in prepubertal girls suggests genital penetrating trauma; however, the presence of this finding is not confirmatory of sexual abuse. Posterior hymenal findings including transections between 4 and 8 o’clock, deep notches, and perforations were not seen in studies of prepubertal girls without a history of genital trauma from sexual abuse included in this systematic review. Therefore, one can conclude that the posterior hymenal findings of transections, deep notches, and perforations are extremely infrequent findings among children without a history of genital trauma from sexual abuse or other means. [...]

However, because the prevalence of posterior hymenal findings (between 4 and 8 o’clock) such as transections, deep notches, and perforations are near zero in nonabused prepubertal girls, the presence of these examination findings suggests genital trauma from sexual abuse. In the absence of known genital trauma from accidental means, the possibility for sexual abuse must be strongly considered. In a prepubertal girl with a posterior hymenal finding of a transection (between 4 and 8 o’clock), a deep notch (between 4 and 8 o’clock), or a perforation, a report to child protective services should be strongly considered. At a minimum, an examination by a child abuse specialist should occur to confirm these findings and to help provide a careful interpretation regarding the likelihood of sexual abuse.

[Molly Curtin Berkoff, MD, MPH; Adam J. Zolotor, MD, MPH; Kathi L. Makoroff, MD; et al. Has This Prepubertal Girl Been Sexually Abused?, p. 2790]

If any doctor or medical provider today observed a transection on the inferior half of the hymen of a prepubertal female patient, he/she would be required to make a report for suspected sexual abuse and an explanation would be required for how that healed injury got there. In forty years of research, this finding has not been seen in any other instance besides from penetrating trauma. In prepubertal girls, it is indicative of sexual abuse unless it can be shown otherwise.

What the evidence says

The evidence says JonBenet had been subjected to at least one penetration of the vagina through the hymenal membrane prior to her murder. The penetration caused a complete laceration of the inferior hymenal membrane. After the laceration healed, a transection and other structural changes of the hymen remained.

The age of the prior injury could not be determined, but based on his research on the healing of hymenal lacerations of prepubertal girls, it was McCann's opinion that it was more than ten days old. His research has shown that "most signs of an acute [hymenal laceration] injury were gone within 7 to 10 days." Some of the experts thought the prior injury could have been weeks or months old.

While the evidence could conclusively prove only one prior penetration, the experts believed there had been more than one instance of penetration/sexual contact and that JonBenet's genital findings indicated abuse that had been repeated or ongoing. They were unable to determine how many incidents over what period of time.

Four of the five experts (Sirotnak, Monteleone, Rao, McCann) were confident in their opinion that JonBenet's genital findings were diagnostic of sexual abuse. One (Krugman) could not disagree with that assessment, but lacking certain forensic evidence (i.e., the victim's testimony, the confirmed presence of sperm, or an STI), was unwilling to assume a sexual motive for the abuse. He felt there was evidence only of physical abuse of the genitals.

What else could explain the prior penetration/ hymenal trauma besides sexual abuse?

There are three known causes of transections in the inferior hymenal rim in prepubertal girls — penetrative sexual abuse, accidental penetrating trauma, and surgical intervention.

Most accidental genital injuries sustained by children are straddle-type injuries that involve a fall onto the horizontal bar of a bicycle, jungle gym, or picket fence. This type of accident involves compression of the soft tissues against the bony margins of the pelvic outlet. Trauma is usually limited to the external structures of the genital area (e.g., labia, clitoral hood, fourchette, perineum).

Accidental penetrating or impalement injuries that involve trauma to the hymen are relatively rare:

Of 161 accidental genital injuries reported in the literature, 3.7% involved the hymen.

[Child Abuse: Medical Diagnosis and Management, 4th ed. Antoinette Laskey and Andrew Sirotnak (eds.), p. 359]

However, they do occur and the resulting injuries can mimic those of sexual abuse. In such cases, it is important that the cause of the injury be confirmed.

Whether an acute or healed genital or anal injury is identified, it is incumbent on the medical professional to obtain a complete history of the nature of the injury. [...]

Key differences in the history of accidental trauma, such as a straddle injury, are that accidental injuries are more commonly observed by a third party, medical attention is sought immediately after the injury, a scene-of-injury visit confirms the plausibility of the injuries and the accompanying history, and the pattern of injury is consistent with the history.

[Child Abuse: Medical Diagnosis and Management, 4th ed. Antoinette Laskey and Andrew Sirotnak (eds.), p. 359]

If JonBenet's prior hymenal injury was the result of an accident or a past surgical procedure, it should be reflected in her medical records and easy to prove. An accidental penetrating injury that results in a complete laceration of the hymen is considered severe, one that would be painful and cause bleeding. It would be expected that most parents or caretakers would seek medical attention for their child's injury.

We know the Ramseys were not timid or frugal when it came to getting medical attention for JonBenet's injuries and ailments. We have records of her being seen by the doctor for various bumps, falls, and injuries, such as a bent fingernail from a fall, a bruised nose from faceplanting at a grocery store, a bump on the brow from a tripping fall, and a small cut to the cheek from a golf club swing. If JonBenet had sustained an accidental genital injury that resulted in a severe laceration, I find it very hard to believe she would not have been taken to the doctor for such an injury when she was taken for lesser injuries and ailments.

Clearly, there was nothing in her medical records that could account for such an injury or the Ramseys would have provided it to police.

 

(Continue to Part 2: The experts, responses to dissenting opinions and common myths, etc.)


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jan 12 '25

Questions Anyone else find this photo disturbing?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

I scoured the Reddit search bar prior to posting this, but couldn’t find any posts that matched my keywords. I’ve only seen this particular picture a couple of times. It took me a while to find it on Google, but I kept looking because I remembered feeling disturbed by it.

Could it be a completely innocent photo? Sure.

Is it something I would consider normal? No.

It looks like an advertisement to me. If I was a father, I’d never feel comfortable with my child posing on my belt this way.

If I was a photographer, I’d suggest another pose, or at least a fatherly hand on her shoulder, along with her smiling, as opposed to what could be construed as… well… a more “adult” expression.

If I was the mother, I’d reconsider having it printed.

This photo seems to be part of a family photo shoot done on the same day. But all of the photos in this set make the children appear serious and sexualized. I can understand that this may have been the photographer’s “vision”. Maybe the parents weren’t necessarily onboard with it.

However, as a parent, I think I would’ve redirected the shoot to something more kid-friendly. I think most of us can agree that neither Patsy nor John were timid people.

Is it evidence of some egregious act? No. But it does raise eyebrows for me.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • May 14 '21

Images I don't know if anyone else cares, but I've always found the thought of John and Patsy possibly sitting on those stools that night arguing about what to do next, to be fascinating.

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/JonBenetRamsey • • Apr 22 '20 Bless Up Bravo

Theories Profoundly Patsy

1.3k Upvotes

Pageantry, Performing, Pineapples, Proper Possession, and the Prime of Miss Jean Brodie.

Here’s the thing. Patsy Ramsey wrote the ransom note. She did so in her own hand, at the very least. However, this isn’t an exposé on Patsy’s handwriting. Numerous highly-qualified forensic document examiners have concluded that she wrote the note via handwriting analysis. Enough said.

This post is about another piece of evidence, found inside the ransom note, that points directly to Patsy Ramsey. When someone stages a crime scene, the personality of the stager is reflected in how the crime scene was staged. If you take a deep dive into the staging of any crime scene, and pair it with a completely thorough examination of known suspects, you should see the eyes of the stager looking right back at you. I see Patsy.

Patsy and Pageantry. Bread and Butter. Patsy was involved in pageantry and performing for a good number of her formative high school and college years. For the Talent portion of all of the pageants she performed in, she prided herself on doing something different. It was the “bread and butter” of her performances. While ninety-percent of contestants did some sort of of singing, dancing, or musical instrument routine, Patsy stuck out as an actor, playing and providing the voices for all characters in a scene she had picked out from her favorite book/play/movie. That play was The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie.

For at least five years straight, Patsy read, memorized, and crafted a performance from a scene in The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie. This play/book/movie was Patsy’s greatest influence growing up. Much like a certain band, song, or movie, may have influenced your life, this is what inspired Patsy in numerous ways in her young performing life.

From Linda McLean’s, 1998 book, JonBenét’s Mother: The Tragedy and The Truth! We gain this information and introspect:

“Patsy won the Miss West Virginia pageant held in June 1977. She had just finished her last final exam of the semester and had to hurry home just in time for the event. For her talent presentation, she used a scene from the play called “The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie.” This was the same scene she had performed to win national honors on our high school forensics team. In oral interpretation, as student takes a scene from a story or play and interprets it for the audience. There are no costumes, props or theatrical makeup and the speaker talks in a different voice for each character.”

This piece is from the Charleston Daily Mail on July 12, 1977, when Patsy Ann Paugh said:

“My talent is a dramatic interpretation that I wrote based on a portion of The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie. I play two characters Miss Mackay, the stern head mistress, and Jean Brodie, the eccentric, vivacious school teacher. When I won second place in the National Forensic Tournament in Philadelphia the interpretation was 10 minutes long. For the talent competition it had to be cut to two minutes and 50 seconds. It's very difficult to establish character and build to a dramatic climax in less than three minutes.”

It is important to establish how influential TPOMJB was to Patsy. The main character-Miss Jean Brodie, was an independent, vivacious character whose favorite expression was “Crème de la crème”, which is a French term meaning, "the best of the best". Can you say “Jacqués, JonBenét, and Attaché?

Patsy took four months after the death of her daughter to finally sit down for an official interview. Her journalism and pageant background wasn’t lost on them either. Look what pops up almost right out of the gate, while asking about her education.

TRUJILLO: I’ve got to ask which talent.

PATSY: (Laughter) “The Kiss of Death” dramatic dialog.

THOMAS: (Inaudible) Miss Jean Brody.

PATSY: Your right.

TRUJILLO: Was that, was that earlier?

PR: “The Pride of Miss Jean Brody.” Well actual. . . no it wasn’t, actually what happened, uh, I did the Miss Jean Brody, I competed in high school with that and uh, placed nationally with it and then I had done that for Miss West Virginia and won with that and then when you go to Miss America you have to do through this business of um, in the event you make the top ten and your on television there are all these rights and royalties or whatever they call it and uh, I have, they have to give you clearance, okay, and to make a long story short, I was unable to get clearance for this. Uh, I can’t remember exactly the details, but uh, I ended up writing a dialog that I used and I don’t even remember, but it had a lot of the same characterizations and that kind of thing. It was all, I was definitely thrilled when I won the talent, you know, because it was a real chore getting there.

The following are quotes from the book/play, The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie:

“Sandy screamed. Monica, whose face was becoming very red, swung the attaché case which held her books, so that it hit the girls who stood in its path and made them stand back from her.”

The speciality of the feast was pineapple cubes with cream, and the speciality of the day was that they were left to themselves. Both girls saved the cream to the last, then ate it in spoonfuls.

Coincidence? Perhaps. However, the next reference found inside the book, connects Patsy directly to the ransom note. This is from the same book/play that had inspired and influenced Patsy so profoundly, that she spent hours, days, years even- memorizing, rehearsing, and performing a full ten-minute skit from it.

“Oh dear,” said Rose out loud one day when they were settled to essay writing, “I can’t remember how you spell ‘possession.’ Are there two s’s or—?”

Everyone knows that the ransom note writer incorrectly spelled the word “possession”, using only one s, instead of two. Do you know how astronomical the odds are that anyone other than Patsy, is the ransom note writer?

Although not exactly the same, this connection is akin to a line Ted Kaczynski wrote in his published manifesto, “You can’t eat your cake and have it too.” The FBI BAU spotted this rather odd turn of phraseology, in a historical written document by Ted Kaczynski many years before. His influence was his mother, who taught him the “correct” way to say the proverb. Most of us today say “You can’t have your cake and eat it too.” This piece of forensic linguistics evidence, became known as the “smoking proverb”. This case was solved almost entirely by forensic linguistics analysis, which determined that Ted Kacyznski, was indeed, the UNABOMBER.

Patsy said that her dramatic interpretation in her pageants was from a scene in TPOMJB, that involved her playing both, Miss MacKay and Jean Brodie. There is an explosive scene in the story that revolves around a fake letter that was written by two of Jean Brodie’s students pretending to be Jean Brodie. Familiar? The scene has Jean Brodie providing her own amateur handwriting and linguistic analysis. The following quotes are from the scene.

From the film, The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie (1969):

“It is in fact a letter. It was found by Ms. McKenzie in a library book. She glanced at it, but, after the first sentence she dare not actually read it, she brought it instantly to me.”

Patsy claimed in her interview with police that when she found the ransom note, she read a few lines and didn’t bother reading the rest. Ironically, the one line she did say she read was the one that ended with the word possession.

“At this time we have your daughter in our posession”

After Ms. McKay reads the letter out loud to Ms. Brodie, she hands the letter over to her and asks for her response. This is when the coy and calm, Ms. Brodie, confidently offers up her own handwriting analysis:

“It is a literary collaboration, two separate hands are involved. One of the authors slants her tail consonants in an unorthodox manner and the other does not. Also, the paper seems somewhat aged.”

Ms. MacKay becomes further perturbed by Ms. Brodie’s words and when she attempts to force her to resign her teaching post, Ms. Brodie delivers this statement from high on her soap box:

“I will not resign, and you will not dismiss me, Miss MacKay. You will not use that excuse of that pathetic, that humorous document to blackmail me. Mr. Louder, you are witness to this. Miss MacKay has made totally unsupported accusations against my name and yours. If she has one authentic thread of evidence. Just one. Let her bring it forth. Otherwise, if one more word of this outrageous calumny reaches my ears, I shall sue. I shall take Miss MacKay to the public courts and I shall sue the trustees of Marcia Blain, if they support her. I will not stand quietly by and allow myself to be crucified by a woman whose fit of frustration has overcome her judgement. If scandal is to your taste Miss MacKay, I shall give you a feast!

Pure Patsy.

JOHN RAMSEY: Patsy writes very neatly. She’s a feminine writer. There is misspellings in the note. She graduated at the top of her class. She doesn’t misspell words like business and possession.

Clearly, Patsy was influenced greatly by, The Prime of Miss Jean Brodie. She embedded the story into her everyday life, especially into her pageant performances. Another discovery from a Redditor, made some months ago, clearly provides proof that Patsy had a history of embedding movie line references in her historical writings and letters.

In the 1980 movie, "The Shining", there is a scene that shows the author, Jack, had obsessively typed out the phrase, "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy", over and over and over, on his typewriter. In Patsy's 1995 Christmas newsletter to friends and family, she wrote, "All work and no play makes John a dull boy". This is clear evidence of Patsy using a line from a movie in her historical writings.

The author of the ransom note did the same thing.

/preview/pre/9fvsdkeaceu41.jpg?width=912&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e4b395a039bbaac347e98cdf1586cdfb91e9fa68


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Aug 10 '21

Theories Why ‘Burke Did It All’ Scenario Makes A Lot of Sense: Part 2

1.3k Upvotes

Part 1 is here

4) ‘Average at sports & Only an adult man could hit JonBenet with such strength.’ During the interview, John discusses how “Burke was a normal child: average at sports, has lots of friends”, etc. He’s describing positive attributes of Burke and yet inserts that he's average at sports in there. It's an implication that Burke wasn't strong enough to hit JonBenet.

This isn't the first time it happens. In his books, John is very adamant about only a man being strong enough to inflict such a blow. It's not true according to medical experts; the CBS experiment proved that a child Burke's age could indeed inflict this kind of damage. Interesting that John says it: he basically draws attention to himself by removing his son from equation. Also, from Patsy's Christmas letter: "This winter [Burke] is the tallest guy on his basketball team." From another letter: "'He played flag football this fall and is currently on a basketball binge! His little league team was #1."

5) The shoes. In her interview, Patsy considered it important to imply that Burke cannot tie his own shoes: "Now I get up usually a little before seven and uh, get Burke rallied and get him ready for school and get his breakfast and pack his backpack and make sure he has his homework done and tie his shoes and . . ." I think it’s an awkward attempt to distance Burke from the fact that he could tie knots on the garrote, which the Ramseys insisted were very complex when in fact they were anything but. You can find the refutation of their claims in Part 1.

6) Wine cellar and Hi-Tec. In 1998 interview, Patsy goes out of her way to avoid saying that Burke often played there. When asked who goes there, she lists different people like LHP but not Burke. She and John also kept claiming that no one in their family had Hi-Tec boots. The footprint was found in the basement and intruder theorists strongly believed it was left by a killer. John and Patsy point it out in their book, too. But it turned out to belong to Burke. Brennan: "A mysterious Hi-Tec boot print in the mold on the floor of the Ramseys' wine cellar near JonBenet's body has been linked by investigators to Burke, her brother, who was 9 at the time.” When confronted about it in her 2000 interview, Patsy denies remembering buying this pair of shoes for Burke even though they are very distinctive and he loved them.

Levin: I'll say this as a fact to you, that, and maybe this will help refresh your recollection, [Burke] thought that -- the shoes were special because they had a compass on them, his only exposure for the most part to compasses had been in the plane and he kind of liked the idea of being able to point them different directions. Do you remember him doing that with the shoes?

Patsy: I can't remember the shoes ... I mean, I just, I can't remember shoes with compasses, and I don't know all of the brand names of all the shoes that I buy for my children ... I don't remember compasses on any shoes.

7) Broken window. We know that the basement window was broken and that John claimed to have broken it in the summer when he was locked out. He told a truly fascinating long story about it. John and Patsy claimed Burke was in Charlevoix, but when asked about it, Burke inserted himself into this story, claiming that he was there when it happened. Here’s what he says: “Yeah I was with him, but I didn't actually go in that way. I just waited.”

When this happened, John suddenly claimed he broke the window several times to fit Burke's words into their story.

In any case, it’s a strange tale because pieces of glass, including large ones, were still lying around. Basement was Burke’s playground, so how come his parents didn’t fix the window or even clean up properly on time? Patsy claimed she did, but there is an account from LHP (The Star, 2000): ""I used to clean their house three times a week. If something was broken, Patsy had me clean it up. On the morning of the murder, police found a broken window in the basement, just a few feet from the room where JonBenet's body was found. John Ramsey told the police that he had broken the window to get into the house months before when he was accidentally locked out. But I think that is a lie. If there had been broken glass in the basement, Patsy would have told me to clean it up. Another thing didn't make sense. John claimed he was locked out on that day when he supposedly broke the window. But he never used a key to come in the front or side door of the house. He always opened the garage door from his car with his remote and came in through the garage entrance."

So maybe the window was broken very recently, perhaps even on the night of murder? Or earlier than that but during Burke’s temper tantrum? Burke’s bat was found outside, another thing that Patsy was very reluctant to admit. I don’t have a strong theory about this, but the story is strange all around and it does look like parents are trying to remove Burke from the picture.

8) Denying Burke and JonBenet often slept together

TT: Okay. Do you have an idea if JonBenet moved over towards Burke’s room at all that night. Slept in his room?

PR: Um, I can’t remember, can’t remember.

TT: Okay. Is that something that she would normally do?

PR: No.

TT: Sleep in Burke’s room. I know everybody’s got, you got, they both have two beds in their rooms.

PR: Yeah, right um, I don’t think so. I just can’t remember.

ST: How about on the, uh, night of the 25th when you and John put her to bed, would it have been unlikely for her to have then moved to another location in the house to have slept, your bed or Burke’s room?

PR: Yeah, it would have been unlikely.

ST: Okay.

I already provided quotes proving that Burke and JonBenet did sleep in one room often above. But also, from Burke’s 1998 interview, about the night before JonBenet’s murder: "Yeah, I think she actually slept in my room. So that I would wake her up when I woke up, 'cause I would always wake up before her."

9) Patsy avoiding saying that Burke reacted negatively to seeing a newspaper where he was accused of killing JonBenet.

John describes it in his book The Other Side of Suffering: “They stopped at the supermarket to do a little shopping and at the checkout counter our boy saw the headlines of one of the tabloids: JONBENET’S BROTHER DID IT! Burke’s face fell, his eyes watering. “Mom?” Patsy knelt with her arms around him, the afternoon ruined. “Son, don’t you pay any attention to what they’re saying. They are not very nice people.” Still, how was he to forget the picture of his little sister on the cover of the tabloid with such a devastating headline?”

Patsy’s account in the interview:

Patsy: We were at Target in Atlanta and buying pencils and all that stuff, and there it was at the check-out, his eye level. And he said something horrible, and he kind of glanced -- I saw him glance at it and glance away. And, you know, put my arm around him, said, honey, they just make up lies and stories about -- we just can't pay any attention.

Haney: Do you remember –

Patsy: He didn't say anything.

Haney: Okay. Still –

Patsy: (Shaking head.)

Haney: -- do you remember what that photo or headline was?

Patsy: Not -- I can't -- not specifically.

10) John claiming he put Burke to bed after they worked on some toy. The problem is, this toy undergoes some transformation with time.

In DOI: "I went downstairs to try to get Burke to come up to bed, but he was deeply involved in assembling the miniature parking garage he had received that morning."

John's interview: “Some kind of little square car elevator, you know, I don't know, it was a -- something only a child would appreciate, but it was like a car, garage repair thing, elevators run up and down and stuff, little micro cars.”

In The Other Side of Suffering: “Burke plays downstairs in the living room by the Christmas tree. He’s trying to assemble a mechanical robot made of the Legos he got for Christmas, so I sit down on the floor to help him put it together, but it’s way too complicated for tonight. I help get [Burke] ready for bed, tuck him under the covers, and give him a kiss on the forehead. "You're a good son, Burke. I love you."

All in all, I feel like John also presents Burke as younger than he was in his book. As one of the examples, Burke allegedly asked:

"Will she come back?"

"Of course. Yes. We'll find her."

"And then we'll go on the plane?"

"Yes, then we'll go on the plane."

Sounds pretty childish and generic, considering how much Burke adored planes and knew about their specific types + that he and his family took such trips very often. It’s very subjective, but I personally don’t see an almost 10-year old Burke speaking like this. And this:

"How come you're sleeping on the floor?" he asks, eyes wide, clear, innocent ... "Dad?" His gentle face, trembling mouth. "Will we be okay?"

d) Overselling Burke’s relationship with JonBenet

  1. In Death of Innocence, there are several instances where John and Patsy try to create brother-sister bonding moments. Unfortunately, they feel forced as hell. One example: apparently, when kids were opening presents, “JonBenet asked for Burke's assistance with the name tags, since he could read and she couldn't."

Woodward: "During a parental interview for kindergarten, Patsy wrote in some paperwork that “activities [JonBenet] liked were artwork, coloring, ceramics, reading."

Here’s JonBenet’s drawing where she signed her name. If she could write it, she could definitely read her own name tag, and she wouldn’t need Burke’s help with it.

There are several more examples. Another one: according to the Ramseys, Burke brought his friend to play with to the memorial service because otherwise, he’d feel “lost without his sister.” We already saw the account of Burke’s behavior during this period.

2) According to John, Burke and JonBenet were "best buddies" and he would have protected her with his life. Whether Burke is a killer or not, it is very clear from his reactions that he and JonBenet didn’t share some deep emotional bond.

e) Self-righteousness and acceptance

Both John and Patsy act extremely self-righteously. Oddly, John even compares himself to a Biblical hero who was forced to do something bad in TOSOS. When he learned that some people didn’t want to let him into their church, he wondered: "What would you tell these pastors regarding Moses or Kind David? They were murderers. Would a church today refuse entry of two of the greatest heroes of the Bible and two of the most significant servants of God?"

It’s difficult for me to imagine that John would compare himself to Moses or King David if he himself murdered his daughter because it’s wild even for someone like him. But if he felt like he was protecting his son, then yes, I can see why he’d think of a comparison like this, imagining himself a hero of a sort, even though it’s still over-the-top.

Shortly after JonBenet’s murder, in CNN interview, John and Patsy showed a remarkable absence of anger at the killer.

John: But the other -- the other reason is that -- for our grief to resolve itself we now have to find out why this happened.

Patsy: And if anyone knows anything, please, please help us. For the safety of all of the children, we have to find out who did this.

John: Not because we're angry, but because we have got to go on.

They changed their approach later, but I always wondered if they were so mild the first time because Burke might have been watching.

In 2006, when asked what should happen to the killer of JonBenet, John said: "Well, I think I'd have to know more about the person. Because I think they need to recognize the consequence of their action and... that's a tough question."

Sounds like a father speaking of a guilty child who doesn’t fully understand the consequences of his actions.

f) Other possible efforts

It’s interesting to me that after JonBenet was found, John was described blurting out several times, “I don’t think he meant to kill her, because she was wrapped in a blanket,” or “she was warm, she was wrapped in a blanket.” On the one hand, he could be talking about himself, but all things considered, I think he was trying to soften the impression people would get if they found out Burke did it. It’s important to remember that the Ramseys were careful with their lies on that first day — it’s possible that they were ready to be caught and were preparing solutions.

5) Motivations

Find a motive, find a killer. Overall, the Ramseys were described by most people, including their closest friends who later severed contact with them, as a wonderful and loving couple. No one ever mentioned that Burke and JonBenet disliked each other. There doesn’t seem to be a visible motive here, and this is what brings me to Burke once again. Because kids can be explosive. They can fight in the morning and play together in the afternoon. Even little annoyances can push them into anger. Burke's interview:

Police: How about your sister, does she ever argue with anybody?

Burke: Um… sometimes me.

From Debbie's letter: “Burke was aggravated when JonBenet would get in front of the television and she would pester him like siblings do” (McLean, p. 103). She adds that he never got mad and he really cared for her, but again, we’re talking about kids. The behavior can be unpredictable and disproportionate to the perceived offense. Some possible ideas:

a) Pineapple. Burke’s fingerprints are on the bowl and the glass, JonBenet’s are not. She was attacked shortly after eating a bit. Perhaps she grabbed a bit from Burke’s bowl and it pissed him off (especially if they were having an argument prior to that).

b) Nintendo. Interesting that John would say how he and Burke worked on some toy that changed forms and Burke wasn’t playing Nintendo, the great new toy he got and was obsessed with. Maybe he was playing and this is just some more distancing by the Ramseys? Maybe Nintendo factored into what happened, especially if JonBenet ruined his game.

c) Gifts. Some people believed JonBenet was attacked in the basement. Remembering the torn gifts, maybe she threatened to tell on Burke.

d) Lego. Quoting John: “JonBenet was a typical little sister to her big brother, Burke. Often an annoyance as he built his Lego projects.” Thomas: “Savage had only complimentary things to say about the Ramseys and the kids. You could make Burke behave by telling him no, she said, but sometimes JonBenet had to be given a “time-out” for doing things such as stomping on Burke’s Lego creations.”

e) Sexual abuse/fight. If JonBenet threatened to tell someone about what’s being done to her, I find it difficult to imagine a smart adult man like John freaking out and attacking her. He could manipulate her and keep her quiet easily. But a kid could freak out and want to keep her quiet.

6) How Burke could keep what he did a secret for so many years

Many people are skeptical about BDI because they don’t think a 10-year-old boy could keep a secret like this. In reality, children keep secrets all the time, be it something like being sexually abused, engaging in inappropriate behavior, etc. With Burke in particular, chances of him speaking were minimal, and his parents had to know it because he was their kid and they knew his habits.

Dr. Bernhard asked Burke if he had any secrets, and he said, “I probably do... But I don’t really remember them. And if I did remember them, I don’t think I’d tell you … Because they are secrets.”

Absolutely everyone described Burke as a quiet, non-talkative kid who rarely engaged in social interactions and elaborated on anything. I’m going to mention some major examples.

a) Brian Scott, the Ramseys’ landscaper: “JonBenét seemed to socialize with them just fine. Her brother, Burke, was three years older. He almost never said a word to me. Just played by himself in the backyard, completely occupied with his own projects. Next to the sandbox and swing, in the pea gravel area, he dug a system of canals. Then he put a hose on top of the slide. The water poured down and spread perfectly throughout the elaborate waterway. “Someday you’re going to be an engineer?” I asked him. “No,” he said. Just a single word—no. He always seemed to play alone.”

b) Archuleta: “JonBenet flirted with Michael, asked him questions and laughed and winked at him. Burke remained engrossed in his Game Boy computer and was not a bit social.”

c) Burke was interviewed on the 26th without his parents knowing. The Ramseys claim to learn that this happened only after getting subpoena from GJ: "As we reviewed the documents, we wondered, what interview occurred on the 26th?" If they are telling the truth, then Burke didn’t bother to even tell them about having an hour-long interview on the day his sister’s body was found. So yeah, not talkative at all.

d) During the interview, here’s how John and his lawyer describe Burke’s behavior once he came back from the GJ proceedings:

John: All we could get out of him was you know, what did they ask you? Nothing. Was it fun? It was the most boring thing I have done in my life. End of statement.

Morgan: Where did you go? Out. What did you do? Nothing.

John: So that was a lot of fuss about I guess we all thought about 12 year-old boys, they don't really talk much.

e) Dr. Bernhard “had a difficult time drawing information out of [Burke]. He seemed reticent to talk about his family, and she thought him very protective of them. It was her experience that kids usually talked more about their family relationships, and Burke was not displaying attachment to either his sister or parents” (Kolar).

I don’t have any troubles seeing this child keep his secrets to himself.

7) Burke’s interviews

According to Officer French’s report, when John led Burke downstairs and into Fleet’s car, Burke was confused and crying. This is the only instance of strong emotions from him that was reported. However, the moment he was in the safety of Fleet's car, he asked no questions about his sister or parents and showed no worry about what's happening. He played his game, ate a sandwich in the middle of an interview about her disappearance, and managed to lie in the process. This makes it pretty clear to me that he was crying not because he was stressed about his sister going missing & everyone being upset — he was likely confused about why he’s being taken away and scared for himself.

a) Interview with Detective Patterson

The first interview with Burke happened on the 26th. The Ramseys didn’t know about it happening. Burke was asked just about JonBenet’s disappearance, not murder. He “stated that the family went directly home after the party. This conflicted with statements offered by the parents who reported that they had made two stops on the way home to deliver Christmas presents to family friends … The only noise he reported hearing after going to bed was the “squeaking water heater.” He did not hear any “scream, cry, yell or any raised voices” during the night” (Kolar).

These specific details intrigue me. I wonder if Burke said this or if this was Detective Patterson’s phrasing. Because “scream, cry, yell” describe the likely reactions of Patsy and John; “raised voices” describes the way they were likely arguing about what to do.

Kolar: “A red flag fluttered when I noted that Burke concluded the interview, not with a question about the welfare of his missing sister, but with a comment about his excitement about going to Charlevoix. The anticipation of being able to build a fire at the family’s second home apparently held some appeal to him … How could Burke not be inquiring about the status or welfare of his missing sister? Was it conceivable that he was already aware of her fate?”

b) Interview with Dr. Susanne Bernhard

The next interview happened on January 8, 1997, and as Kolar believes, “the Ramseys capitulated to this second interview because they didn’t want to give up temporary custody of their son to the Department of Social Services.”

I already described the conditions the Ramseys dictated and some of Bernhard’s conclusions about Burke’s lack of emotions and the way he didn’t include JonBenet in his drawing. From other interesting moments: it’s strange that Burke stated he feels safe. If JonBenet was killed by an intruder or his parents, it’s likely that he would worry about his own fate. He didn’t. Then:

Bernhard: So, what do you think happened?

Burke: I know what happened!

Bernhard: You mean when she got killed? How do you think that happened?

Burke: I think… Well, I asked my dad, Where did you find her body? He said, I found it in the basement. And so, I think that someone took her very quietly and tiptoed down in the basement … and then maybe took a knife out [made a slashing gesture].

Bernhard: Do you think that’s how she died?

Burke: Or maybe a hammer. Hit her in the head, maybe. (illustrates how it could have happened)

According to Burke and his parents, they didn’t discuss any details of what happened to JonBenet, so maybe it’s a lucky guess about the blow to the head — or maybe he knows about it personally. The stuff with the knife is also interesting. Again, maybe he’s just guessing. Maybe he’s replaced the train tracks/the paintbrush in his mind with a knife to avoid saying the truth directly — because in a way, JonBenet was stabbed with them. But Burke’s knife seems to have been found not far from JonBenet’s body, although the accounts about the exact locations differ.

From Bonita Papers: “A red Swiss army knife was also found lying in the corner of the room away from the blanket.”

From DOI: “I wondered if, as they walked through the basement, any of the jurors brought up the issue of Burke’s red Swiss army knife, which according to the media had been found on the countertop near a sink, just a short distance from where JonBenet’s body was found. The implication was that the killer could have used the knife to cut the nylon cord used to tie … JonBenet’s wrists together.”

Schiller: “Next was a picture of Burke’s red pocketknife that the police found in the basement several yards from JonBenet’s body. It might have been used to cut the cord that was found binding the child.”

What’s strange is that Burke says nothing about strangulation. Kolar: “Why would Burke tell Dr. Bernhard that he knew what had happened to JonBenet and not mention her strangulation? He clearly was aware that strangulation had been involved due to the conversations he was overheard having with Doug Stine not more than two days after the murder of his sister.”

Kolar mentioned something else that I consider eerie but interesting: “I was taken aback at another comment offered during the playing of a board game. The nature of the game involved guessing the features of faces hidden on the opponent’s side of the game board. Burke had mistakenly flipped down a face on his side of the board and then returned it to an upright position, commenting: “Oops, you’re not dead yet.” This off-hand comment seemed extremely callous and suggested little care or concern for the circumstances at hand. I would later think that this comment might have its source in the events surrounding the death of JonBenet.”

I can see where Kolar is coming from, considering that someone seemed to poke JonBenet with train tracks.

c) Interview with Detective Dan Schuller

This interview happened in June 1998. It is believed that the Ramseys hoped agreeing to it would stop Burke from being called in for GJ proceedings, but it didn’t happen. From notable moments: when Burkeis asked whether he played in the basement much, he takes a very long pause and then carefully replies, “Sort of.” Also:

BR: I don’t remember hearing anything. Because I was sleeping, you know ... I always sleep real deeply and I can never hear anything.

He sounds like he’s overselling it, especially since we know he was awake at some point for his voice to be in the tape. He actually admits to being awake himself later.

When shown a photo of pineapple snack, Burke has an interesting reaction.

BR: It’s a bowl of … (pause) … oh. (laughs) Something. (laughs)

It looks like he recognized what it is, figured out the implications, and changed the subject — next, he’s describing the glass.

When talking about hearing his parents panic in the morning before the 911 call, Burke describes his mother’s and his father’s behaviors like this:

BR: [She was like], like overreacting, cause I heard her downstairs, like oh my gosh, oh my gosh, oh my gosh, you know, so my dad was like okay, calm down. She was just like overreacting … He was sounding like, yeah, he wasn't going to like freak out. He was just gonna do what needed to be done.

Purely subjective interpretation: at this point, Burke knows JonBenet died, so it’s strange to refer to his mother’s panic as overreaction. His words about his father “knowing what needed to be done”, to me, come across as the description of their decision to stage everything. Because what else “needed to be done” that John specifically knew of? Patsy was the one to call 911 and that’s it. They didn’t do anything beyond that for Burke to feel respect for his father — and it sounds like he admires his ability not to “freak out” like his Mom did. For it to stay in his memory a year later, it had to be something significant and lengthier than a brief conversation about calling 911.

d) Dr. Phil

Like I said before, Burke refused to be interviewed by detectives in 2010, but he went on Dr. Phil’s show. I already mentioned some important things from it, like Burke admitting to being downstairs after everyone went to bed, but there are several other concerning parts.

Burke: “I mean I remember, like, at one of the pageant things or something, she just like go out and, just like, you know, like, flaunt or whatever on stage and… she wasn't shy, I guess.”

This usage of the word “flaunt” is disturbing to me. It shows a degree of resentment Burke still feels even though years have passed. He also mimics Patsy's anguish over not being able to find “her baby” with a laugh. Yeah, some people smile when they are nervous. I used to do it myself as a kid. But a smile alone doesn't define your reaction. Burke looks excited. His eyes are sparkling at the memories when he's describing them.

Burke: I remember the casket was small and her eyes were closed. I think one of her eyes was a little bit, like, droopy or something. I thought that was weird.

Dr. Phil: Was it traumatizing to see her?

Burke: That was weird. That was traumatizing. A little bit. I don't, like...had I ever been to a funeral before, period? I'm not sure.

Burke does say he felt a lot of sadness, but his comments about her eye being droopy and this “a little bit” show emotional disconnection, in my opinion.

Dr. Phil: When death was imminent, did [Patsy] have this case and JonBenet on her mind?

Burke: Maybe? Probably? I think she just more had family on her mind and I think she was kind of sad that she wouldn't get to see me go through college and finish growing up.

I would think Burke would agree that his religious mother was thinking about JonBenet in her final days instead of making it a point to state that she was rather thinking about "family" and being sad she'd miss his graduation. Does JonBenet not mean “family” to him? It’s like that picture he drew without her. When asked about it, he said: “She was gone so I didn't draw her.”

8) Other details and statistics

a) People who suspected Burke

  1. Kolar was the first person to present such a specific theory, but he wasn’t the first to think BDI, and some people agreed with him/supported him. Governor Owens was interested in him pushing his theory forward. Kolar admitted in his AMA that he talked to “a number of law enforcement officials, some of whom who participated in the original investigation, who voiced support for [his] hypothesis.” From his other AMA: “I believe investigators theorized two points of view on this topic: 1, that Patsy had initially engaged in the cover-up by writing the note and keeping John out of the initial fabrication of the kidnapping. He later became aware of some of the events after they had taken refuge at the Fernie home. 2: that John and Patsy had been involved together in the cover-up from the very beginning after the discovery of their daughter’s body that morning before calling police.”

The second variant sounds like BDI to me, so it seems original investigators were aware of this possibility.

2) Thomas’ account: “A friend who was an FBI agent tipped me that a Michigan State professor was working on the Ramsey case at the request of the DA’s office. The professor had talked to the FBI about crime scene photos and the ligature [and] had wondered if Burke Ramsey might be the killer.”

“Hunter himself was all over the map. He propped his chin on his fist and asked aloud, “I wonder if Burke [Ramsey] is involved in this?”

3) Hunter was asked to sign an affidavit declaring that all questions about Burke's possible involvement in JonBenet’s murder were addressed and that he was never viewed as a suspect. He refused to sign it in the presented form. Hunter revised it to: “From December 26, 1996, to the date of this affidavit, no evidence has ever been developed in the investigation to justify elevating Burke Ramsey’s status from that of witness to Suspect.”

4) Thomas' letter: "We were told by one person in the district attorney’s office, months before we had even completed our investigation, that this case “is not prosecutable.””

Why? Surely more evidence could be developed to support the idea that John or Patsy molested and killed JonBenet, especially at an early stage. But 9 year old boy wouldn’t be charged with any crime, so perhaps this is what someone in the DA office meant?

5) Miller: “The New York Post also published a Burke Did It headline and spent an unreported sum defending itself against the Ramseys ... Lawyers tried to mine the case for discovery, digging into police, DA and corresponding evidence in the Boulder Grand Jury's files. Every person in that home, adult and child must have been investigated. The police did look at Burke as a possible suspect. Documents related to Burke, lawyers for him, Post believed, held information that supported their headline, either in Hunter's office or within the grand jury files … A New York judge approved discovery requests and ordered the Ramseys to respond. But, the Post folded its hand and settled under undisclosed terms ... Altruism is never a tabloid goal. If The New York Post had been vindicated on the basis of information that Burke was a seriously considered suspect by Hunter's office or the grand jury, would this have reopened the possibility of indictment against the parents who presumably knew of their son's involvement? Has Burke ever taken a lie detector test? The beauty of Burke had something to do with it is that it helps explain the parents' post-homicidal behavior.”

b) Indictments

Patsy and John were both indicted as accessories to a crime. Some people believe the jurors couldn’t decide who did what, so they decided on accessories charges. Others felt like it meant John and Patsy conspired to cover for someone else. Stan Garnett, DA, voiced this specific opinion:

CNN Host: "With the charges that the grand jury had voted to indict, are they referring to a third person?"

Garnett: "It does appear that the theory they were looking at assumed that maybe someone other than the two Ramsey parents had been involved in what happened."

c) The Whites

It’s a commonly known fact that the Whites seem to know something. Fleet White was with John during crucial moments, and his family later severed contact with them. He and his wife Priscilla fought for justice for JonBenet, but their behavior is odd if they think PDI or JDI.

Schiller: “White had recently told one of the detectives that he would go to jail before he would testify before the grand jury. His attitude was puzzling … A local lawyer ... found their attitude illogical—they wanted closure in the case but refused to cooperate. Eventually, she concluded that the Whites, having lost confidence in the process and thinking there would never be an indictment, had reasoned that their noncooperation couldn’t hurt the case. It was like stabbing a corpse: it’s already dead, so you can’t hurt it anymore.”

If the Whites believed JonBenet was killed by one of her parents who also molested her, I think they would fight much harder to ensure Burke’s safety and get him out. They would use every tactic and tell the world. Them thinking BDI explains their decision to be quiet despite their clear wish for justice.

d) John’s, Patsy’s, and Burke’s behavior when Burke was testifying during GJ

Pam Archuleta described everyone’s reactions when Burke was testifying. There is nothing particularly incriminating there, but I consider her observations fascinating. Here are some descriptions: don’t be confused since some of them span across different days: “We waited all day for Burke to return from his day before the grand jury. Patsy and John became quite anxious and I knew the waiting and waiting was getting to them. ... Patsy and John had quietly suffered on their own by talking, taking walks, and turning to God. They had Melissa and John Andrew, but Burke was now the youngest and had been in the home the night of JonBenet’s murder. What had he heard or seen? Were there things he wasn’t saying to protect himself or was he trying to push the sounds of that night out of his mind. Was he still in shock?”

“Burke finally was delivered to our home by Ellis Armistead and he seemed very tired. John and Patsy hugged him and did not ask him any questions regarding the grand jury. Burke asked to be excused so he could go to his room downstairs and play his computer game. Patsy went down there to make sure he was comfortable and then she returned upstairs to the table to eat something ...”

“John and Patsy did not say much during the day except to express things like “How long is it going to take for Burke to be questioned?” or “I thought he would be done way before now.”

“The night was quiet and Patsy was especially quiet and tearful. Burke picked at his food and asked to be excused to just be by himself. John went downstairs with him and must have told him good night. Later Patsy did the same, but she came back upstairs and tears were in her eyes. I noticed that Burke’s light was out so he must have gone to sleep.”

“Even though Burke was in questioning for hours and hours, Patsy grew more anxious as the day wore on, but John kept an optimistic attitude.”

My impression is, their behavior seems pretty secretive (they didn’t even ask Burke anything when he arrived because Pam was nearby), with the drama happening strictly behind the closed doors.

e) Burke’s drawings

You can see the picture of Burke’s drawings here with an interpretation by Dr. Glass. I don’t consider her observations reliable or insightful, but I do think the drawings are interesting.

f) Statistics

Here are some statistics from Kolar's research on crimes, including sexual assaults, done by children:

The average onset of preadolescent sexual behavior problems (SBP) are between the ages of 6-9 years. Although the term “sexual” is used, the children’s intentions and motivations for these behaviors may be unrelated to sexual gratification. FBI UCR reports in 1979 revealed 249 rape arrests for children less than 12 years of age. Sixty-six of those children were under the age of 10.

1990 FBI and media reports in this time period indicate that among adults convicted of sex crimes, approximately 30% said they began offending before they were 9 years old. A 1993 nationwide survey of SBP therapists identified preadolescent behaviors in 222 children that ranged from voyeurism to coercion: The more serious offenses involved digital penetration, penile intercourse, anal intercourse, bestiality, and ritualistic or sadistic sexual abuse.

I conducted further research into crime statistics involving juvenile offenders and learned that two-hundred and fifty-seven (257) children, who were fourteen (14) years of age and younger, had been arrested for murder and non-negligent manslaughter in the United States in 1996. Sixteen (16) of those arrests had been for boys under the age of 10. Another fourteen (14) arrests involved boys aged 10 to 12 years. The statistics for forcible rape were even more discouraging. Sixty-one (61) boys under the age of ten had been arrested for this offense in 1996. An additional three-hundred and thirty-five (335) boys had been arrested who were aged 10 to 12 years.

Kolar claims that if a child gets professional help, the risk of them reoffending becomes insignificant. Burke “was still being treated professionally nearly a year and a half after the event.”

Summing it all up, these are the reasons why I think Burke killed JonBenet. I might be wrong, but to me, BDIA is a theory that makes most sense.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jul 06 '25 Regret

Images Am I the only one who finds this photo disturbing?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

Maybe I'm overthinking this, but doesn't this seem like an inappropriate photo for children to pose for, especially siblings? I've noticed that this photo session, in general, is a solemn one, but in this picture, JonBenet and Burke do not appear happy. I'm sure they were told to pose like this, but still. There's something . . . . off about it.

I'm going to express some opinions here, and I know it has been discussed before that the Ramseys were possibly an "incest family," meaning that family members (such as JR) may have been molesting the children. It was stated that JonBenet had been chronically sexually abused before the night of her murder. I'm wondering if Burke was abused as well (which could account for some of his behavior), and /or if he may have witnessed his sister's abuse. There has also been talk about JR being emotionally distant, and it's been stated in various studies and by experts in the field that families where incestuous abuse is taking place tend to be emotionally stifled, and the abuse, and the contact surrounding it, is often the only affection that the children know. It has also been said that an incestuous father may foster other incestuous relationships, such as between siblings, and the children often think that the behavior and abuse they see and are subjected to is normal. It's also very common for this abuse to be generational, and for both parents to have been abused in childhood as well. The mother may turn a blind eye to her children's abuse or even subtly promote it, therefore re-enacting her mother's role in her childhood abuse. Of course, this is speculation on my part, but it's been stated that both children exhibited troubling behavior that was indicative of abuse. I suspect that Burke was emotionally neglected as well, and his parents' shielding him and isolating him in the years following his sister's death hindered more than helped him. His interview with Dr. Phil said so much - he's socially awkward/dysfunctional, emotionally stunted, likely traumatized, and could have Dissociative Identity Disorder. He's clearly on the spectrum as well. I know some suspect Burke; I do not. I have a lot of sympathy for him. People talk about how weird he is, but he was never going to be normal under those circumstances. Losing his sister in such a horrible way and his mother dying when he was still quite young must have affected him deeply. I think it's safe to say that his parents failed him in many ways.

JonBenet's bedwetting was happening more frequently in the weeks leading up to her murder, and it was noted that her behavior changed - she was acting clingy and unsure of herself. It's heartbreaking what this poor little girl endured in her short life, what a terrible death, and still, no justice! The way she was paraded around, treated like a circus animal, and sexualized is just disgusting. I think there is no question PR was living vicariously through her daughter, and I think that her death from ovarian cancer was a manifestation of her guilt for allowing her children to be abused and for her involvement in the cover-up of JonBenet's death. As for JR, he's harder to read, but we know he's wealthy, powerful, and has the connections to hire the best legal and PR team. Maybe we will have to wait until he dies before the truth comes out.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Sep 14 '26

Media First look at ‘THE MURDER OF JONBENÉT RAMSEY’, starring Melissa McCarthy and Clive Owen.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

"The series follows the unsolved murder case of JonBenét Ramsey and the devastating personal & public reckoning the family faced. Releasing December 10 on Netflix."

How am I only finding out about this now?


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jun 11 '25

Discussion I saw it today

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

Finally saw it today

I was worried about looking like a weirdo taking pictures of a murder house. Nope.. just me and several other car loads of folks , with license plates from all over, standing around discussing our theories. It’s so interesting to get a feel for exactly how tight those houses are situated together. And Baseline Rd is very close, and busy with people walking along. Everything looks so much further apart in pictures. Really hard to imagine someone breaking in and going unnoticed. But at the same time, easy to imagine. I was hoping to get some kind of “vibe” But, given the layout.. every proposed version of events truly seems somewhat possible. It’s really a beautiful house


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jul 07 '25

Images left flowers for sweet jonbenet today

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

if you plan on visiting, use the st james episcopal cemetery address, not the polk st address on google. her grave, along with patsy’s and elizabeth’s, is near the parking lot.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Dec 13 '24

Ransom Note Patsy's handwriting samples compared to ransom note

Thumbnail
gallery
1.2k Upvotes

Often when experts use terms like "can't exclude" it belies how compelling the evidence can be.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Nov 30 '24

Rant The way JR grabbed JB's body will haunt me forever

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

The way he came up from the cellar holding JB's body as a mannequin is SO shocking and disturbing.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Sep 06 '25 Mindblown

Discussion BURKE RAMSEY is at CrimeCon 2025, with John

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

OMG, it's Burke!


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Dec 25 '23

Discussion Taking a moment to remember the little girl behind the pageants and the case

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

Here are some adorable little JonBenet stories I remember off the top of my head to remember the child that she was.

Teachers at her school don’t remember JonBenet in any fancy clothes and were only vaguely aware that she even was in pageants. She liked to wear t-shirts, jeans and sweatpants. Her hair was often in pigtails. They said JonBenet was a humble, compassionate and popular student who was a positive role-model for the other kids.

At Boulder’s recreational center she could climb the wall like a little spider. Patsy had her signed up for upcoming rock climbing lessons in January 1997.

She was fearless and would always be the first person to jump in a pool and do somersaults.

When she was in preschool, JonBenet and John would walk hand-in-hand to her school. Sometimes she was so excited to see her friends that she would forget to say goodbye to her dad!

She liked ice-skating, and just a month before her murder she even went ice-skating in NYC at Rockefeller Center. JonBenet told her mom she wanted to be a professional figure skater when she was older.

She could climb trees just as fast as any boy in the neighborhood.

She liked to make cardboard boxes and slide down hills with her friends.

She liked to build snowmen outside with Burke and Melinda. One year when there was not a lot of snow, Melinda told JonBenet they probably wouldn’t be able to build one, but JonBenet was determined and told her they could do it. She was right, with her determination they build a big snowman!

She liked to make lemonade with John Andrew.

She was named Camp of the Week at Camp McSauba in Charlevoix (Burke was Camper of the month)

She liked to do this game she called "Presenting" where she and her little friends would sing and dance to a song, and adults had to be quiet during the presentation or JonBenet and her friend would tell them to shush and start over again if they missed any parts.

When she was alone, JonBenet would present her songs and dances to her stuffed animals.

Patsy and JonBenet’s favorite duet to sing together was “Together, Wherever We Go” from the Gypsy musical.

I think she deserve to be remembered for those things. Rest in Peace sweet girl.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jan 08 '22

Discussion Can we talk about how weird the name "JonBenét" is for a second?

1.1k Upvotes

When I was a kid and this case was all over the news, I assumed "JonBenét" was some French name I'd never heard of. It wasn't until I started looking into the case recently that I realized it's actually just a bastardization of "John Bennet (Ramsey)" that they threw an accent on to make it sound fancy.

I don't have an exact point or theory here, but ... this is super weird, right? I mean, I get that it's not particularly unusual to name a child after yourself, but he already had John Andrew from his previous marriage, and it seems like a stretch too far to change a boy's name to a (made up) girl's name just to feed your narcissism.

I feel like this is indicative of the overall weirdness of the family, and their obsession with self-aggrandizement.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Dec 23 '24

Discussion Exactly 28 years ago today, the Ramsey’s hosted their Xmas party on 12/23/1996

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

I’ve known about this case since I was 10. I am 27 today. I was born March 1997. I have a special place in my heart for JonBenet because her murder will always be the exact same age as me.

Posting these pictures here to remember JonBenet’s last Xmas and one of her last happy days! Merry Xmas & RIP, Jonnie B <3


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Sep 03 '24 Diamonds are Forever Sipping Tea Bless Up Heart of Silver

Discussion BR interviews... from a child interviewer

1.0k Upvotes

I commented on one of the posts about BR seeming guilty based on his response to being presented with the pineapple picture, and someone suggested I make my own post.

My entire career has been spent doing these exact interviews that BR received at 9 and 11. I've done thousands in the last 15 years and testify as an expert witness regularly. I'm a licensed therapist and I've done nearly 1000 hours of training, 300 specifically in interviewing protocols.

As I said in my other post, you cannot infer much of anything from demeanor in these interviews. They're specifically structured to support kids and keep them calm. I've interviewed kids who have witnessed murders (drive-bys, parents being killed in DV, sibling deaths) who come in the next day and seem like totally normal, silly kids. They're eating snacks, playing video games in our waiting room, and when we meet, they talk about what they've seen like we're discussing the weather. In all my time interviewing, I'd guess that 5-10% of kids cry or show any strong emotions. It's something I get asked about on the witness stand frequently because people like to use lack of emotion as a sign that kids are lying. (That's not how trauma works.)

Did they coach him on specifics? Maybe. I've found it's much more common that adults don't realize how often they have conversations that kids overhear. When kids don't have all the info, their brains naturally try to fill in the rest to try to make sense of the world. BR's description of what probably happened to JBR sounded like that to me. He knew general details from overhearing his parents and other adults and his kid brain filled in the rest. I saw YT comments of people saying that BR saying "whoops" was a red flag when he discussed what happened to her. I think it makes sense to describe it that way because it's hard for kids to wrap their heads around the idea that humans kill each other intentionally, so it must have been an accident somehow.

As neutral and casual as these interviews are designed to be, kids know when adults want something (even just the correct answer) and when the stakes are high. Kids naturally want to please adults. I'm not the end all be all on child development and behavior, but I read BR's reaction to the pineapple picture more as wanting to give the "right" answer and probably weighing what the interviewer was looking for vs. ensuring he wouldn't give an answer that could inadvertently get his parents in trouble. He seemed confused as to why someone would be pulling out a picture of his bedtime snack when his sister had just been murdered, and trying to figure out in his 9-year-old brain what that meant. Even if his parents said, "We didn't do anything wrong. Go in there and tell them the absolute truth and answer all of their questions," a kid is still going to be fearful that his parents are in trouble or might go to jail.

I also wish the public would chill on body language analysis in general. It's junk science, generally only applies to adults anyway, and doesn't take neurodivergence, trauma, or cultural differences into account. When I'm thinking through my next question in an interview, I almost always look up and to the left. It's not a sign of deception. It seems like there's a lot of confirmation bias that goes on with BR's interview clips (both as a kid and as an adult), and almost every YT clip I found had creepy music laid under his interviews, which is going to add to the sinister way they're interpreted. There's nothing sinister about his behavior or answers.

Did BR do it? Hell if I know, but statistically, probably not. I didn't dig long enough to find out when this took effect, but you can't be charged with a crime under the age of 10 in Colorado anyway. If he or his family were involved, the onus isn't on a 9-year-old to be a whistleblower for a bunch of (rich) adults. Let this man live. No matter what, he was a child, and the trauma of his childhood continues to follow him today when he seemingly just wants to live a normal life out of the spotlight.

ETA: People are commenting “What about this fact?” and “You’re ignoring the other evidence.”

I never claimed to be doing an in-depth case analysis. I was simply responding to posts/comments that said things like “Why is BR laughing in this interview?” “Why is he pretending he doesn’t know what the picture is?” “Clearly this kid is a psycho, his body language says it all.” Claims about how his interview can be “read” just aren’t based in reality.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jan 07 '24 Take My Silver

Media This interview seals the deal for me

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1.0k Upvotes

Its easy to get lost in all the details, but Linda Ardnt was the first one on the site and these are her straight up observations without being muddled by any other details that emerged later. This interview leaves no doubt in my mind who did it.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Dec 17 '24

Media Found Patsy in childhood board game

Thumbnail
gallery
1.0k Upvotes

My mom found this board game at a thrift store back in the early/mid 90’s. Years later we realized Patsy Ramsey was in it so she kept it all these years. I just found it while going through stuff in her basement.


r/JonBenetRamsey • • Jul 17 '21

Images Jonbenet jumping into a pool. This photo humanises her for me…not the pageant ones. She was just a little girl living her life. Rest in peace angel.

Post image
1.0k Upvotes