r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jan 08 '26

No Spoilers Is it just me or is The Devils hard to read sometimes?

1 Upvotes

I picked up The Devils in New Year’s day, coming from reading King Sorrow and prior to that The Wisdom of Crowds. And noticed that this book for some reason is kicking my ass, don’t know if it is because of the punctuation, or the way it is structured or sometimes the old words, but it makes my head hurt a bit when reading it.

Don’t get me wrong, I’m loving every single bit of it and cannot put it down, but it seems that for some reason, it is just harder to read, did this happen to you guys?


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Mar 22 '26

No Spoilers May try First Law series,

1 Upvotes

At B&N yesterday looking at it, I am a fan of Pillers of the earth series

Does First Law have magic and dragons like King of thrones, I do not care for?


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jul 13 '26

No Spoilers Is Joe into Ayn Rand?

6 Upvotes

So, the first JA book I read was The Devils, and in that one there’s a passing reference to a “Sir John Galt.”

There’s also a location in TFL trilogy (which I just finished today) that has Galt in the name, but I’m drawing a blank on what exactly it is.

One reference, maybe that’s a coincidence. But two? I have to assume Joe is at least a fan of Atlas Shrugged, or was at some point.

Regardless of your thoughts on Rand, it’s interesting to think of his characters through an Objectivist lens. Thoughts?

EDIT: Y'all really downvoting me and my comments for simply asking about this? Seems kind of silly. In The Devils, "Sir John Galt" is referenced in a list. Here's the exact passage:

"Jakob of Thorn fought in the Second Crusade against the elves, as a Knight Templar alongside the following:

  • Szymon Bartos, old acquaintance from Jakob’s time in the Iron Order;

  • Elzbieta—another member of the Iron Order, which Jakob strangled and regrets killing, back when paranoia swept over the Order’s ranks;

  • King William the Red of Sicily and his butler, Biordo Ambra;

  • Sir John Galt, the Pillar of Faith."

The pillar of faith. I'm not saying "Is Joe Abercrombie a stone-cold Objectivist who loves capitalism?" but would he reference Ayn Rand's most famous character as a Knight Templar "pillar of faith" if he wasn't at some point into the ideas? I'm merely curious about it, and downvoting this/me because you vehemently hate Rand or her ideas is missing the point entirely.

EDIT 2: I clearly shouldn’t have phrased this as “into,” since my point was not to ask whether he was a fan of the ideas or philosophy. I’m more curious if some past encounter with her ideas (or with Atlas Shrugged more generally) had perhaps a notable impact on some of the themes in this author’s work, even if it was to explore the negativity or problematic nature of those ideas.


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jan 25 '26

No Spoilers Best character to play Logan 9 Fingers

6 Upvotes

I was just watching The Northman and I think Alexander Skarsgaard would be perfect for the character.


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Aug 29 '26

No Spoilers Is Gourav Mohanty Blatant Plagarism of Joe Abercrombie's First Law or Homage?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jul 28 '25

No Spoilers Next Novel

3 Upvotes

Greetings all. I'm finishing up The Devils and really enjoying it (even the ending isn't everything I wanted). I want to try something else by him, what else has he written that's the most similar in comedy-fantasy tone? Thanks!


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jan 29 '26

No Spoilers Just finished The Devils

7 Upvotes

Why was I under the impression that this book is a stand alone?


r/JoeAbercrombie • • 23d ago

No Spoilers The Devils: What happened to the prose?

0 Upvotes

While it is forgettable slop on every level, does anyone have a take on why the prose of The Devils is so noticeably worse than in any of his previous works? It is flat, repetitive, workmanlike, brimming with clichés and completely uninterested in conveying any states of mind beyond the most cartoonish self-descriptions ("She was not pure," "How dare they insult his genius"). The Jacob passages about the many wars he has fought appear as if they were copy-pasted throughout the book, without any noticeable development or even change. Even compared to Joe's young adult fiction (which I happen to be a fan of), it is so unspeakably dull, never even rising to the level of exciting pulp. So, basically: do people agree? And: what happened?


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jan 11 '26

Spoilers: The Devils Casting Call for The Devils Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Who should play the characters, and why?


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Dec 01 '25

No Spoilers Thank you

9 Upvotes

As gay fansty fan thanks for inculding us most fansty we dont exist so u made my year by having a main real gay reltionship


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jun 12 '26

Spoilers: The Devils Papal Binding (The Devils)

3 Upvotes

So I'm on my third read through on the book and caught something I hadn't noticed before. When the Pope is introduced she applies the binding to the Devils. The entire book emphasizes how strong the binding is and how it cant be broken. All the characters have been part of the Devil's for quite some time with the exception of Balthizar. So if this is the case.....why does the Pope need to apply the binding to everyone else? Sure, Balthizar needs to be bound. But everyone else should have been bound years ago? Does the binding need to be applied at the beginning of each mission? If so, does that leave a window for the Devil's to escape in-between missions? Wonder if that will become a factor later


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jul 24 '26

Spoilers: The Devils Read The Devils, curious about The Blade Itself

12 Upvotes

Just finished The Devils. Curious if The Blade Itself is for me.

What I liked: The world, the gothic horror creatures/monsters, the ‘Villains are Good Guys’, the magic, and ESPECIALLY the ending (not the surprises as some were pretty densely obvious, but the cataclysmic conclusion and devastating “oh this isn’t just fun and games” crash down to earth.)

What I did not enjoy: the humor. It felt thin and out of world. While there’s only one “con” to many “pro’s” this was such a significant dislike I put the book down for ~10 months and planned not to finish.

Thoughts? Thank you!


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Sep 04 '26

No Spoilers I've gone through the whole collection and here is what I think

0 Upvotes

He's brilliant. Has a way with words more than most. But every story is so predictable. Everyone sucks and everyone is bad. I get it. You're a nihilist. Can someone please just have a happy ending??


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jul 22 '25

No Spoilers To anyone that has read the Devils by Joe Abercrombie

0 Upvotes

So I’ve been looking forward to reading this book a lot, it’s my first Joe Abercrombie but I liked the premise. However I’m only 80ish pages in and there’s already been a hell of a lot of in depth action scenes. I’m very not into action fantasies and it’s quite putting me off. Is it like this through the whole book? I am enjoying the non action scenes but I just can’t be bothered reading everyone fighting and being killed all the time, I mostly just wanted fun adventure scenes. Should I continue?


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jul 19 '25

Spoilers: Best Served Cold Best Served Cold

5 Upvotes

After finishing the first trilogy I am now reading the stand alone novels. Best Served Cold comes along with a lot of fighting and killing and blood and splatters. I'm not sure I like it that much.

I wonder if The Heroes will be more of the same.

I might then postpone it and read some Sanderson first.


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Aug 29 '26

No Spoilers Finished Blade Itself

0 Upvotes

Honestly pretty peeved at how the book ended. I feel like there was no resolution. 500 pages of prologue only to end with our characters essentially "beginning" their journey. Moving onto the second book now and I hope it doesn't continue that trend.


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Oct 17 '26

No Spoilers Do you guys think I made a mistake reading the series in reverse? Spoiler

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jul 11 '26

Spoilers: The Devils Is The Devils...cozy?

18 Upvotes

Don't take this question / idle thought too seriously, but am I, a manly beer drinking lout of a man, accidentally reading cozy fantasy? It's good, but is The Devils...cozy?

Is the book a massive ruse to lure big boy readers like me in with swords and blood and then spring on us found family dynamics and cryptobestiality? A gateway drug to Rebecca Yarros and Sarah J Maas?

I feel the need for some Cormac McCarthy as a palate cleanser.

I'm enjoying it though and looking forward to the sequel.


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jun 03 '26

No Spoilers Half A King

6 Upvotes

So I tried to get into Half A King, but since it’s targeted more towards a YA audience, it doesn’t have quite the same feel. As I had just finished listening to The Heroes, I dropped it when The Devils became available. Is the Half series a good read/ listen? Return to it?


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Sep 09 '25

No Spoilers Who should play The Devils Characters in the movie if it were made today?

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

My picks: Natasha Lyonne as Vigga, Jenna Ortega as Alex, Jason Stratham as Jakob, Macie Williams as Sunny, Jamie Lee Curtis as Cardinal Zizka, Titus Burgess as Balthazar, Kate McKinnon as Baptiste, Luke Thompson as Baron Rikard


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Feb 27 '26

No Spoilers Best title in the series?

11 Upvotes

I think the unconventional titles in the series are hit or miss. When I'm reading at work and people ask what I'm reading, they often look puzzled, the same way I was slightly puzzled when my friend told me about The Blade Itself.

Personally, I think Last Argument of Kings goes hard as fuck as a title. It sounds like the name for a legendary battle axe. On the other hand, A Little Hatred is my least favorite. It sounds kinda vague. Or like it's part of a recipe.


r/JoeAbercrombie • • Dec 22 '25

Spoilers: The Devils I was just watching this interview with Wet Leg and it struck me that Hester Chambers IS Sunny

3 Upvotes

r/JoeAbercrombie • • Jul 14 '25

Spoilers: The Devils Just finished The Devils - Some thoughts.

13 Upvotes

Now, to be clear, I enjoyed The Devils. I just didn't enjoy it as much as I hoped I would.

I understand that Joe wanted to write a new series, a new world, however, it just felt a bit over trodden by works other authors have already explored. With the setting being 'different Europe,' this book felt way too similar to Mark Lawrence's Broken Empire series, especially the RQW books. It was also very 'Joe Abercrombie trope heavy'. The 'chosen one' turns out to be a fraud. The kindly uncle turns out turns out to be a villain, which, whilst acknowledging this is a trope in-book, doesn't invalidate it's trope-y-ness. Some incest thrown in at the end for no discernible reason. Killing the cousins one by one like bosses in a video game felt like lower quality Best Served Cold plotting.

To me, it also felt a bit 'paint by the numbers' fantasy book. 'Group of ragtag misfits go to a place to do a thing and encounters adventures on the way.' Don't get me wrong, I liked the humour how everyone only says clever things, but it felt a bit Discworld try hard, which is where I come to main point.

The book would have dramatically improved, if it was just a First Law standalone. Change a few names of a few people, of settings, and this would have been a very good First Law standalone. Joe already has a massive sprawling thought out world, with established characters and rules. He could have just set this book in some weird unseen continent in the Circle of The World and it would have made total sense. In fact, it reads exactly like a First Law book anyway, just without the depth as it's the first in a new series.

To conclude, I liked The Devils, but I suspect I would have liked it more if it was the first in the Second Great Leveller Trilogy.


r/JoeAbercrombie • • May 06 '22

is there something that’ll allow me to brush up on what’s going on before “A little Hatred” it’s been about 7 years.

4 Upvotes