r/JewishDNA • u/Creative-Comb5593 • 1h ago
Irish Jews Genotypes
Are there ancient Jewish families with no Ashkenazi or Sephardic genes? The genealogy of my family line shows we were traditionally doctors to Irish royalty in the early Middle Ages. Per 23andme, my genetics show my ancestors were almost entirely from southern Ireland, with a tiny percent from England, northern Europe and possibly North Africa. I have zero Ashkenazi or Sephardic genes. Recent family history suggests that my father may have been a crypto Jew. Mom was a staunch Irish Catholic (in the US), but Dad would only say that he believed in God and prayed every day. His future in laws had opposed the marriage because "he wasn't Irish enough". Possibly a compromise was reached in which the children would be raised Catholic.
I always felt different, like an outsider. I have a vague memory of a small narrow wooden object with little drawings at eye height on the wall beside my bedroom door. This was later removed and the spot was painted over. When I was little, Dad walked me to church every Sunday but never went in himself. I had never heard of Bar Mitzvahs, but when I was thirteen I stopped going to Mass. I pretended I was going but would walk past the church to a bookstall and browse books until Mass was over, then walk home. We had many books at home on WWII and the Holocaust. In Catholic high school I became friends with a boy with a Jewish sounding last name. I didn't actually know he was secretly Jewish until later. He then invited me to his home for dinner. On the way to his house I asked if there was anything I should know. "Just no meat with dairy", he said, "so since we're having meat, there won't be any butter on the table with the bread". At our high school's fiftieth reunion I learned he had desperately called one of our other high school friends to beg for a job. The friend said he couldn't afford to hire him. Our mutual friend died a premature and pretty bad death. I asked the "friend" if there were any other Jews at our high school. He became angry and retorted "There were no Jews!" at our high school. He said K. and his family were "German! Catholic German!"
As an adult I drew and painted pictures about the Holocaust, and read about Moshe Dayan. I dated a sabra who had moved to the US. Eventually after studying for two years under Conservative and Reform rabbis while living through two Jewish annual cycles as a Jew, I formally converted. My father died and I found a very old olivewood mezuzah in his desk. My mother was evasive about it. I traveled alone to Jerusalem and showed my father's mezuzah (in the shadowbox photo above) to a dealer of Judaica. He told me that many years prior he used to sell the exact same kind, depicting the same Old City gate. In Israel I also learned there is an opinion among some rabbis that converts are people who in a past life were not able to live as Jews.
Are there ancient family lines of Jews that are neither Ashkenazi nor Sephardic? What are your honest impressions on my complicated history and speculations?