r/JewishDNA • • May 28 '22

r/JewishDNA Lounge

8 Upvotes

A place for members of r/JewishDNA to chat with each other


r/JewishDNA • • 1h ago

Irish Jews Genotypes

Post image
5 Upvotes

Are there ancient Jewish families with no Ashkenazi or Sephardic genes? The genealogy of my family line shows we were traditionally doctors to Irish royalty in the early Middle Ages. Per 23andme, my genetics show my ancestors were almost entirely from southern Ireland, with a tiny percent from England, northern Europe and possibly North Africa. I have zero Ashkenazi or Sephardic genes. Recent family history suggests that my father may have been a crypto Jew. Mom was a staunch Irish Catholic (in the US), but Dad would only say that he believed in God and prayed every day. His future in laws had opposed the marriage because "he wasn't Irish enough". Possibly a compromise was reached in which the children would be raised Catholic.

I always felt different, like an outsider. I have a vague memory of a small narrow wooden object with little drawings at eye height on the wall beside my bedroom door. This was later removed and the spot was painted over. When I was little, Dad walked me to church every Sunday but never went in himself. I had never heard of Bar Mitzvahs, but when I was thirteen I stopped going to Mass. I pretended I was going but would walk past the church to a bookstall and browse books until Mass was over, then walk home. We had many books at home on WWII and the Holocaust. In Catholic high school I became friends with a boy with a Jewish sounding last name. I didn't actually know he was secretly Jewish until later. He then invited me to his home for dinner. On the way to his house I asked if there was anything I should know. "Just no meat with dairy", he said, "so since we're having meat, there won't be any butter on the table with the bread". At our high school's fiftieth reunion I learned he had desperately called one of our other high school friends to beg for a job. The friend said he couldn't afford to hire him. Our mutual friend died a premature and pretty bad death. I asked the "friend" if there were any other Jews at our high school. He became angry and retorted "There were no Jews!" at our high school. He said K. and his family were "German! Catholic German!"

As an adult I drew and painted pictures about the Holocaust, and read about Moshe Dayan. I dated a sabra who had moved to the US. Eventually after studying for two years under Conservative and Reform rabbis while living through two Jewish annual cycles as a Jew, I formally converted. My father died and I found a very old olivewood mezuzah in his desk. My mother was evasive about it. I traveled alone to Jerusalem and showed my father's mezuzah (in the shadowbox photo above) to a dealer of Judaica. He told me that many years prior he used to sell the exact same kind, depicting the same Old City gate. In Israel I also learned there is an opinion among some rabbis that converts are people who in a past life were not able to live as Jews.

Are there ancient family lines of Jews that are neither Ashkenazi nor Sephardic? What are your honest impressions on my complicated history and speculations?


r/JewishDNA • • 21h ago

Possible Welsh Jewish ancestry but nothing showing

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/JewishDNA • • 1d ago

My family tree connected me to famous 16th-century rabbis. Then one Y-DNA haplogroup landed on 2,000 men with 535 different surnames.

Post image
0 Upvotes

I grew up without my parents. Everything I know about my family I pieced together myself, from archives and from the DNA of cousins I had never met.

Like a lot of Ashkenazi trees, mine had grown some impressive branches over the years. Follow one line far enough and it reached the Rema, the Horowitz dynasty, and other famous rabbis from the 1500s. I never fully believed it, but I never checked it either.

This week I checked it, with one simple idea.

A Y-DNA haplogroup passes from father to son almost unchanged. So if one tested man in your tree has a haplogroup, every man on his paternal line should carry the same one: his father, his brothers, his paternal uncles, their sons. I took one tested man and let his haplogroup flow along the male line exactly as my tree drew it.

It reached 2,000 men. With 535 different surnames.

No paternal line on earth has 535 surnames. Kohanim and Leviim were sitting on the same “father to son” chain, which is impossible by definition.

So I asked the opposite question: where exactly does the tree break? The answer was 33 men who were each recorded with two different fathers. Every one of them was a seam where someone’s tree had been copied onto another. One of those seams I had made myself years ago, as a guess I forgot to mark as a guess.

After cutting that one invented link, the same haplogroup sat on 8 men. All with one surname. That is what a real paternal line looks like.

You can run this check on your own tree without any tool:

Pick one man with a known Y haplogroup.

Walk his paternal line up and down: fathers, sons, brothers.

Count the surnames. More than a handful is a warning.

Look for anyone with two fathers. That is where to dig.

The same works for mtDNA on the maternal line.

Full disclosure: I did this with a platform I built myself, AutoTreeGen. I am a solo developer in Melbourne and I made it first for my own Jewish cousins, with endogamy in mind from day one. It checks the tree against DNA line by line and shows where they disagree. AI never touches the raw DNA; the check above is plain counting. It has a free tier if you want to try it on your own tree.

But the method matters more than the tool. Has anyone else found a “famous ancestor” branch that fell apart when they tested it against DNA?


r/JewishDNA • • 2d ago

Mtdna H1aj1a

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/JewishDNA • • 2d ago

Surprised

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/JewishDNA • • 2d ago

Ashkenazi Jewish DNA

7 Upvotes

Hi 👋 So, I'm of partial Ashkenazi Jewish ancestry, scoring around 20% on AncestryDNA and 23andme. I have always been curious about the European DNA that constitutes 50% give or take to the AJ DNA, which I understand to be mostly southern European, esp south italian.

I was just wondering if someone could clarify something. Can it be claimed that all Ashkenazi Jews have Southern European autosomal dna? Or can there be variations? For example, rather than Southern Italian, they may have predominantly French, or German DNA, in addition to their Levantine?

The reason I'm asking is because of my results on the sites IllustrativeDNA and MyTrueAncestry. They consistently show Gaul, Frank and other continental Celtic type results, in addition to the expected insular celtic and Germanic from my British side... Now, I'm aware that my AJ % isn't extremely high, so I'm not sure if that's a reason why I show very little if any Southern European or Greek result on these sites. I have however received Southern Italian and Greek on AncestryDNA, 23andme, myheritage and livingDNA, so I'm confused 😕

Any help is greatly appreciated and apologies for the long bloody read.


r/JewishDNA • • 2d ago

Greco-Roman/East Med ancestry in Ashkenazi jews

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/JewishDNA • • 3d ago

Closest cousin yet for the biggest AJ Y haplogroup

Thumbnail
jewishgeneticdiscovery.substack.com
10 Upvotes

20 years ago, researchers knew that many Ashkenazi Jews shared common paternal-line ancestors with folks from Russians to Indian Brahmins within what became known as haplogroup R1a.

10 years ago, further research showed Ashkenazi-specific R1a was mainly specific to Levites--whose tradition is inherited along paternal lines--and had its closest cousins among Persians, Armenians, and Kurds, sharing ancestors who lived at the end of the Bronze Age, not the beginning of it.

Today, we share news of an even closer connection: a Tajik man is closer to the AJ lineage than anyone else known, sharing a common ancestor around the 6th century BCE. Read our Substack article to learn more!

What I love about this result is how it complicates neat narratives about population history, thereby helping us frame better questions. We don't know the path R-M12205's ancestors took before participating in the founding of the Ashkenazi community--but we're closer now knowing that this connection exists.

Special thank you's go out to the group effort that made this possible: FamilyTreeDNA, the Tajik DNA Project, the Afghan-Pakistani DNA Project, the Circassian DNA Project, and Jeff Wexler’s LeviteDNA.org.


r/JewishDNA • • 4d ago

My dna say im jewish?

3 Upvotes

Just yesterday, I saw my MyHeritage results and discovered that I have approximately 17% Mizrahi Jewish ancestry. As far as I know, my family has no Jewish roots whatsoever, and there are no family stories to that effect. Do I count as Jewish? I was considering immigrating to Israel as a Jew, but it strikes me as both ridiculous and irrational.. please help.


r/JewishDNA • • 5d ago

Mediveal Rheinland jews the begining of Ashkenazi Jews

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/JewishDNA • • 7d ago

Did Ashkenazis ever migrate from Ukraine, Moldova, or Poland, to Belarus?

Post image
7 Upvotes

I am confused. As far as I can trace my ancestors in paper documents (I can get to about the mid 1800’s), my family seems to have lived in Belarus.

I do not have any certainty but my last name has strong links to Ukraine, but idk if maybe Belarusian Jews adopted it, so maybe it is possible that my family was actually from Ukraine?

The test did not see any Belarusian or Lithuanian signatures, so it looks quite confident.

I didn’t think this would happen because I thought the trend of Ashkenazi Jewish migration was more commonly East/South, and not North or West.

What do you guys think?


r/JewishDNA • • 9d ago

50/50 Sephardic Asheknazi

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Both my grandparents from both sides are 50/50 ashkenazi & Sephardic. Why do I get different results from my heritage and ancestry? Which one is correct?


r/JewishDNA • • 9d ago

Unexpected DNA-results

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I'm half Ashkenazi Jewish. My mom was Jewish. My grandmother came from Podolia in Ukraine, and my grandfather came from a town near the border between Belarus and Russia. Both were born in the USSR.

For some reason, 23andMe suggests that most of my Jewish ancestry is associated with Poland and Ukraine. MyHeritage even shows the majority of my Jewish ancestry as Central European rather than Eastern European.

Has anyone else here taken ancestry tests and gotten similarly weird or unexpected results? Was one of my biological grandparents likely not who I thought it was?


r/JewishDNA • • 9d ago

Infographic on mtdna U5b2a1a10

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/JewishDNA • • 11d ago

Are Jews, genetically one people in terms of autosomal DNA?

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

To answer this question, I composed a proximity list of all the samples of available Jewish groups in Casperhub (Vahaduo G25 based platform), relative to Jews who never left the levant for 3000 years (Syrian Jews).

Background: the 34 sample average of Syrian Jews sample is from the Mariopulous collection of G25 samples. This sample is closest to Lebanese Christians from Zgharta. Meaning, this average represent a very endogamous ethno-religious minority. I guess that this is what the average Jewish profile would have looked like, if all the Jews would have stayed in the Levant.

In the list I included also some non Jewish groups for reference.

The average samples:

  1. Israeli_Jew - See my previous post about national averages.

  2. North african Jew - average of 7 populations: Egyptian, Libyan, Tunisian, Djerban, Algerian and Moroccan Jews.

  3. Mizrahi Jew - Iraqi, Iranian and Kurdish Jews average.

  4. Mountain Jew - Azerbaijani, Chechen, Balkarian and Dagestani Mountain Jews average.

  5. Ashkenazi East - Lithuanian, Polish, Belorussian, Russian, Ukrainian and Romanian Jews average.

  6. Ashkenazi West - German, French and Austrian Jews.

  7. Sephardic - Turkey, Greece and Bulgarian Jews average.

  8. Indian Jew - Cochin and Mumbai average.

  9. Palestinian_Muslim - see my previous post. It is the average of all profiles available in the mariopulous collectiin on Casperhub.

Results: 95% of the world Jewish groups fall under 0.066 fst distance to Syrian Jews. If we exclude Bukharian Jews as well, 94% are below 0.056 fst distance. The outliers being: Yemenite, Indian and Ethiopian Jews.

Finally, to compare it to other nations, I included additional 2 proximity lists of Greeks and Palestinians. I picked a greek from the mainland, as it is historically the greek heartland. For Palestinians, I picked Palestinian Christian as the unmixed endogamous reference point. The Greek results were of a range of 0.093 fst distance. This is due 3 main subgroups: mainland greeks, greek islanders and anatolian and black sea greeks. Most of the greeks were below 0.056 fst distance (mainland and islands).

For Palestinians, the range is 0.073 fst. It is mainly due to ssa admixture in muslim palestinians.

So I can conclude by saying: The Jewish genetic autosomal range is typical for a people with a rich history of thousends of years that included occupation, expulsion and diaspora. Most certainally, jews are not a random collection of converts. The origin of the majority of Jews is from Judea.


r/JewishDNA • • 11d ago

Substack on jewish mtdna

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I'm starting a Substack on Jewish mtDNA. If anyone is interested in this kind of stuff, here is the link https://tijmo.substack.com/


r/JewishDNA • • 10d ago

What is the chance that the average Ashke would have a venesian Jewish ancestor within the 1400-1700's?

2 Upvotes

Ik this is more of a historical question but I was not sure where to ask this question.


r/JewishDNA • • 12d ago

Medieval Britain and North African Jews

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Akbari has thousands of unpublished samples. But that has not stopped some from guessing the origin of some of the samples. This one in particular with Burial Id: I35349 is labelled as "Britain MA SouthEuro?" suggesting South European ancestry. It is from a medieval burial from Britain. Running through kinplot.com
calculator, I found the following: Its closest people today are Algerian and Moroccan Jews (0.025, 0.027); English rank 518th. England had Jews until 1290. I guess we have to wait for the publication of the findings to learn more about the individuals in these burials. Attached is the breakdown of the sample owner's ancestry across various time periods. I have included a heatmap for the medieval period.


r/JewishDNA • • 13d ago Bravo

PSA: Ashkenazi Jews have Levantine Ancestry

72 Upvotes

I'm tired of arguing this point, so here's the academic research showing this point from every angle. AJs are probably the most studied population on earth, so there's a surfeit of evidence. Whenever someone wants to make a claim otherwise, please send them this.

  1. Paternal Lineages (Y-DNA): Y-chromosome analyses demonstrate that most Ashkenazi Jewish paternal lineages belong to Middle Eastern haplogroups (such as J1, J2, E3b, and Q) shared directly with non-Jewish Middle Eastern populations like Palestinians and Syrians (Hammer et al., 2000; Atzmon et al., 2010). Specific sub-lineages like the Ashkenazi Levite marker (R1a-M582) have been proven via whole Y-chromosome sequencing to originate in the Near East rather than Eastern Europe (Rootsi et al., 2013).
    2) Autosomal Whole-Genome Clustering: Large-scale genomic studies consistently place Ashkenazi Jews in an intermediate genetic cluster bridging Middle Eastern and European populations, displaying extensive Identical-by-Descent (IBD) sharing with other Jewish Diaspora groups (Sephardic, North African, and Mizrahi) and Levantine groups (Kopelman et al., 2009; Behar et al., 2010; Atzmon et al., 2010). Local ancestry inference confirms a substantial, foundational Levantine genome core (Xue et al., 2017).
    3) Ancient DNA Evidence: Archaeogenetic sequencing of Bronze Age and Iron Age human remains from the Southern Levant (Canaanite sites) demonstrates that modern Jewish populations, including Ashkenazi Jews, derive 50% or more of their ancestry from populations related to the ancient Bronze Age Levant (Agranat-Tamir et al., 2020).
    4) Not associated with Caucus Region: Comprehensive genome-wide sampling across 15 populations from the Caucasus and Volga regions found no evidence of a significant Khazar or Caucasus contribution, reinforcing that Ashkenazi roots are firmly anchored in the Levant and Mediterranean Europe (Behar et al., 2013).


r/JewishDNA • • 12d ago

The known haplogroups of my Moroccan Jewish ancestry

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/JewishDNA • • 14d ago

Updated Ancestrydna Journeys for my Ashkenazi side

Post image
14 Upvotes

Just noticed today that most of Europe got new genetic journeys on AncestryDNA so I thought I would share my new Journeys for my Ashkenazi family.

These journeys are essentially spot on considering my Ashkenazi family is 3/4 Lomza and 1/4 Astrakhan (with recent migration from Kaunas in Lithuania).

I also appreciate that they group Northeast Poland and Northwestern Belarus, as a lot of my Lomza Ashkenazi ancestors migrated from what would be modern day Northwest Belarus within the last 250 years.


r/JewishDNA • • 15d ago

Resultados de Judeus Sefarditas (Sírios e Egípcios)

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes