r/Jazz • u/TechnicalAnxiety9314 • 9h ago
Hot take: We should normalize bass players soloing first.
Before you ask, I’m a guitarist with some woodwind and piano experience—less so bass.
My reasons for this are as follows:
• Traditionally solos go top-down from the melody players, to the chordal instruments (usually), to the rhythm section ending with trades or a drum solo. I think bringing the band and dynamics down before the climax/shout chorus/drum solo/etc is often a mistake and can sabotage the build up when everybody else drops out.
• A well known phenomenon (I would argue is a result of the former) is people ignoring or tuning out, disrespectfully talking over the bass solo. I suppose you could argue that this creates an attention grabbing moment when the band reengages; but I would counter that it happens at the expense of probably the most important player in the band. So it’s about respect too.
• When executed properly à la some of Mingus’ arrangements especially, it creates a rare and interesting, almost mysterious opening that draws people in and subverts expectations.
——————————————————
I’m not saying we should always do this every time, but I do think it’s an oversight and I personally want to see more of it.