r/Japaneselanguage • • Feb 13 '24

Example

Post image

Are these examples correct?

27 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

73

u/ItsTokiTime Feb 13 '24

All of them should end with 勉強します

-61

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

If it would studied then the shared one would be correct because I am studying te form so I got this one from quora who shared this example

-38

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

Further more. How would I write in te for because te or de form used in continue action and equivalent to Ing form in english

43

u/Kubocho Feb 13 '24

私は毎月日本語を勉強しています

-56

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

How would you be write in te form?? I am studying Japanese every day???

60

u/Chinksta Feb 13 '24

You need help studying the basic grammar structure before jumping into making examples.

-19

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

Yes, but examples help to understand the pattern.

43

u/Chinksta Feb 13 '24

No. The example that you've given shows me that you don't understand the content and just jumped right in.

Take your time to build up the fundamentals then everything will set in perfectly without you breaking a sweat.

-8

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

Hope it will get fix soon. Any recommendations to better understanding te form??

28

u/Chinksta Feb 13 '24

Grab a textbook and read it? If not, you can always enroll on some course.

Googling also helps but you'll need to verify the results. Which puts you back to square one.

15

u/clitblimp Feb 13 '24

Tae Kim's "A Guide To Japanese Grammar" would be a good place to start.

5

u/Pokemon-fan96 Feb 13 '24

Tokini Andy on Youtube has videos that explain and breakdown the te form well, I'd recommend watching his videos

2

u/Butiamnotausername Feb 14 '24

What is your native language if you don’t mind sharing? It usually helps when you study grammar

1

u/Realistic-Writer1185 Feb 16 '24

https://jisho.org/

Would recommend using this if you really want to learn from example sentences. There's furigana too for the kanji used.

Also, can understand if you're frustrated, but all these people are correcting you for your sake, and not to put you down. They know what they're talking about. There's always a lot of folks who know better than we do.

8

u/chayashida Feb 13 '24

u/Kubucho wrote it in て-form. That's why it's していますand not します.

55

u/SaiyaJedi Feb 13 '24

No. You want “study” to be a verb, but right now it’s just a noun since it lacks する (roughly, “do”) at the end. Without context, it’s also impossible to tell who is studying, although if it were spoken aloud it would be natural to assume the speaker was referring to themselves.

1

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

Further more. How would I write in te for because te or de form used in continue action and equivalent to Ing form in english.

22

u/cyclicsummation Feb 13 '24

What you refer to is ~ている

So as the commenter above mentioned, you want to attach する after 勉強 to get 勉強 する. This becomes

勉強している for expressing continuous action.

5

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

That is what I really wanted to know. I will post more question. Keep doing your good wor.

4

u/Mormorar Feb 13 '24

〜ている is the real present tense, you use it with habits and with something you are currently doing, if you say 朝ご飯を食べます you are not saying "I eat breakfast" nor "I'm eating breakfast" you are saying that "you are going to eat your breakfast" or "I will eat my breakfast". There are exceptions but, mainly you just need to think that if you are currently (not when you are talking about a schedule etc.) doing something (like eating your dinner) or if you are talking about your habits the correct way to express it is using 〜ている. Your problem here is that you are translating that grammar to "present continuous", and that is correct but not always, as you can see.

1

u/cyclicsummation Feb 13 '24

Okay, let me know with further questions

14

u/Fabulous_Log_7030 Feb 13 '24

Because daily studying is a habit, you should use するorします as the above comments said.

The present continuous is better for an action happening right this moment, or if you are attending a university or working for a company as a major continuing phase of your life.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

[deleted]

4

u/HalfLeper Feb 13 '24

I dunno. Doesn’t sound natural in this context, though. Is that just me? 🤔

1

u/Tun710 Feb 14 '24

It’s natural. Using します will make it sound like you don’t have the habit of studying yet but will in the near future.

23

u/ttechnowaffle Feb 13 '24

語 is one character. It should be the same size as the others. The way way you wrote it looks like 言吾

-13

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

Ah! Thank you for the correction. How would you write in te form. Please correct example and share with us here

32

u/clitblimp Feb 13 '24

Why so focused on て form? Do you know what て form is or what it does? You're asking people to tell you how to do something that's completely irrelevant to the example you gave.

11

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

毎日日本語を勉強しています

Mainichi nihongo wo benkyou shiteimasu

This is te form.

1

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

Ah! Thank you for the correction. I frgot to put shitemasu. My bad.

Further more. Could you please kind enough and let me know on where we can use te form like present, past or future and share the reason why we use te or de form.

10

u/WaywardNihon Feb 13 '24

て (te) form is used in many different contexts. For example:

Imperative (commands): やめてください (yamete kudasai)ー please stop!

Sequential actions: 起きて、ご飯を食べて、学校に行きました (okite, gohan wo tabete, gakkou ni ikimashita)ー woke up, ate breakfast, went to school. (only the last verb needs to specify tense).

continuous actions: 勉強しています (benkyou shite imasu)ー am studying (can also be past 勉強していました benkyou shite imashita)

Like a lot of Japanese grammar, it doesnt correlate exactly to one form or tense in English. Its better to learn how to conjugate to te form (different stems use different conjugations (eg ∼ぶ verbs will become ∼んで, ~う verbs will become ∼って) and then learn its uses as you study different tense and grammar. It will pop up a lot.

1

u/Fris_ Feb 13 '24

Thank you. This is what I was looking for. Thank you for your help. Much appreciated.

21

u/Icy-Reindeer-2859 Feb 13 '24

Your 強 is missing the last stroke and your second 勉 is wrong. Also, your ゆ is unrecognizable without the context.

7

u/Odd-Citron-4151 Feb 13 '24

First of all, you need to turn 勉強 into a verb by using the Japanese to do form, which is する. But since it’s a continued action (your repeat everyday and so on), you need to bring it to present-participle, which means that you should use the for する+いる, which becomes している. As you progress, you’re going to see it, so don’t you worry about it right now.

Second, in a conversation when you already presented the subject of the sentence, it’s okay to omit it, but in this case, the usage of 私(わたし)は is necessary as we don’t know who study English everyday.

In this example, you just said “everyday Japanese study”. Using the first example, it should be something like 毎日、私は日本語を勉強している (まいにち、わたしはにほんごをべんきょうしている)。

Hope it helps, and keep going on, be proud of your efforts!

3

u/SinkingJapanese17 Feb 14 '24

I don't hear people say, "I study language every month.", but "I pay rent for parking every month." or "I study English every day." are okay. It gives me the same feeling as "I cook my dish every month.", or "I go walking every year."

5

u/iroha_times Feb 13 '24

私は毎日日本語を勉強しています。

私は毎週日本語を勉強しています。

私は毎月日本語を勉強しています。

Good luck with your Japanese studies! I'll also do my best in studying English.

2

u/GoodYoga Feb 14 '24

えらい言われようやな。。。

毎日、日本語勉強!

毎週、日本語勉強!

毎月、日本語勉強!

がんばってください。

3

u/SantiProGamer_ Feb 13 '24

A few notes here:

Benkyou (勉強) itself means studying, as with many Japanese words, you can attach the verb する (to do) to make it "to study" (勉強する, literally "to do study")

Also your Kanji do look a bit too narrow, but that only gets better with time and practice.

Everyone gets things wrong, take this as constructive criticism.

2

u/Comprehensive-Pea812 Feb 13 '24

second 勉 is incorrect

2

u/Ok-Love7473 Feb 13 '24

On the last line tsu almost looks like chisaii tsu

1

u/TheBottomPilot Feb 14 '24

する/します - one of the two has to be at the end of the sentence.

If you want the て it becomes the present tense form of しています。やってます is fine when speaking.

1

u/Piine7 Feb 14 '24

やればやるほど身につくから頑張ってねー

1

u/mitoro-3305 Feb 14 '24

日本人にも十分伝わる。 日本人も完璧に日本語を喋ることはできない。

Japanese people can understand it well enough.

They cannot speak Japanese perfectly either.

1

u/uglycaca123 Feb 13 '24

try to make each kanji like if it were to fit in a box and fill it (thicker 日, thicker 本, try to make the radicals in characters fit the same box in 語)

-4

u/CorporalAIDS Feb 13 '24

the kanji writing style also makes me want to throw up its so bad.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 13 '24

There’s no need to be mean to beginners

0

u/Eastern-Praline-5740 Feb 13 '24

良い感じです。全ての文章にしますをつけると完璧です!

-7

u/CorporalAIDS Feb 13 '24

try to learn english properly first before challenging japanese.

-6

u/Tokotoko8804 Feb 13 '24

Kanji jouzu ni kaketemasu ❤️

2

u/RedRedditor84 Feb 13 '24

The state of this sub when a wholesome comment like this is down voted...